<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<item xmlns="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5" itemId="2648" public="1" featured="0" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xsi:schemaLocation="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5 http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5/omeka-xml-5-0.xsd" uri="https://southernmusicresearch.org/items/show/2648?output=omeka-xml" accessDate="2026-11-20T01:14:33+00:00">
  <fileContainer>
    <file fileId="3595">
      <src>https://southernmusicresearch.org/files/original/19c0c80906105755ab194b9084da4455.pdf</src>
      <authentication>60897535f72e0c8bb9257f8cf7205661</authentication>
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="4">
          <name>PDF Text</name>
          <description/>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="92">
              <name>Text</name>
              <description/>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12799">
                  <text>THE

OLD-TIME

HERALD

VOLUME

13, NUMBER

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

$5.00

7
THUS

QUICKSTEPS.

MASTERS

GRAND

MAKING A

COLLECTION

HOWARD JOINES
OLD-TIME FIDDLING IN MONTANA
TALES FROM THE 'WOODS

�Section with Illegible Text

New Releases from the Field Recorders' Collective

6

The

Hellbenders

(FRC700) featuring Bruce Molsky, James Leva, David

Mary Winston, and Dave Grant

&amp;

Sherman Hammons (FRC701) West Virginia's Sherman Hammons
was an accomplished singer in the traditional Appalachian style and a
fiddler in a fine, archaic style reminiscent of his Uncle Edden. Fie learned
banjo from a wide circle of West Virginia musicians.
Harold Hausenfluck, Volume

2:

Banjo Workshop (FRC702)

wide variety of banjo tunings and traditional styles
which he demonstrates on many classic and unusual tunes learned
from the masters.
Harold describes

a

Jerry Lundy with Hilary Dirlam (FRC703)

The grandson of the
great Galax, VA fiddler Emmett Lundy, Jerry Lundy (1942-2001) was a
skilled and driving fiddler who was well respected in bluegrass as well
as old-time music circles.

Calvin Cole, Fancy Gap Banjo (FRC704) Calvin Cole (Fancy Gap,
VA) played clawhammer-style banjo with tremendous precision and
drive. Though he was old enough to have been recorded in the 1930s
the Library of Congress, these recordings (made by Peter Hoover
Mr. Cole still at the top of his game.

by

in

1960) show

Parley Parsons, Old Galax Fiddling (FRC705) A member of
the last generation of fiddlers firmly rooted in the local style, Parley's
playing was immediately recognizable as having been influenced by
Emmett Lundy (b.1 864-d.1 953) and Charlie Higgins (b.1 878-d.1 967),
two iconic older Galax fiddlers.
FULL CATALOG LISTING
5

FRC108

Berkeley

FRC301

2

FRC302

the

960s FRC609

John

Sidna &amp; Fulton Meyers FRC504

Heywood Blevins FRC508

Albert Hash FRC411

Dock Boggs FRC305
Dock Boggs 1966 FRC312

Harold
The

Dewey Balfa FRC207

Uncle Charlie Higgins, Wade Ward &amp; Dale

Balfa

Brothers &amp; Nathan Abshire FRC111

Vol

1

The Horse Flies FRC602
The Hurricane Ridgerunners
Esker Hutchins

the Chicken Chokers FRC603
Fred

Cockerham

FRC101

Banjo Bill Cornett FRQ04
Cfyde Davenport Vol. 1 FRC103
Vol.

2

FRC104

Clyde Davenport
Reverend Gary Davis FRC1
Dixie Hummingbirds

1

6

FRC208

You can order via our

Dan Tate FRC506

Ramsey &amp; Byard Ray FRC1 13
Ola Belle Reed FRC203

Texas Fiddle Bands FRC409

The

WV

The Indian Creek Delta Boys FRC607

Tommy Jarrell Vol.

1

Round Peak Vol.1

Tommy Jarrell Vol.

2

Round Peak Vol.

FRC402

Lee Sexton

Kimble &amp; Wagoner Families FRC1 06

Shelor Blackard Family FRC112

credit cards.

payable to the Field Recorders' Collective to the address below.
1st Class Mail (Ohio residents please include applicable sales tax).

$1 5

To

each

order via
CD,

US

mail, send

$20 each DVD

Anderson FRC1005

Clyde Davenport FRC1004

a

PLUS

Field Recorders' Collective, 6206 Washington Street, Ravenna, OH 44266

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Aunt Jenny Wilson FRC408
Virgil

FRC105

Lonnie Seymour FRC403
Arnold Sharp FRC406

or

Jimmy Wheeler FRC401

Oi

FRC1 10

2

Musicians of Clay &amp; Calhoun

Counties FRC202

FRC109

Santford Kelly FRC503
Fiddling Van Kidwell FRC412

website and pay using PayPal

Wade Ward FRC507

Mountain Hilltoppers FRC201

Dink Roberts FRC209

FRC212

FRC303

Union Grove 1969 FRC114

Ross County Farmers FRC307
Band in Transition (Round Peak) FRC1

Ward Jarvis

Buddy Thomas

Renegades FRC605

Roan

FRC1 07

FRC310

Cecil Plum FRC404

Vernon Riddle FRC120
FRC604

FRC306

Corbett Stamper
John Summers

Obray

Poe FRC501

Gaither Carlton FRC118
FRC204

FRC119

Hellbenders FRC700

Jont Blevins FRC117

Ernie Carpenter

FRC505
Kilby Snow FRC205

The Nee Ningy Band FRC610
The Plank Road String Band FRC606

Hannah FRC405

Hausenfluck

Manco Sneed, Byard Ray &amp; Mike Rogers

Dennis McGee &amp; Sady Courville FRC30F
Marcus Martin FRC502

FRC601

Jeff Goehring
1

Chirps Smith FRC608

Addie Leffew &amp; Claude Wolfenbarger
FRC509

George FRC407

Frank

3

Bell FRC410
in

1

Norman Edmonds Vol,
Galax Gems FRC309

Walter Babson FRC31
P.T.

Norman Edmonds Vol.

r

1

dvds

Ray's Dream FRC1

i

Alden

Ray

John Ashby &amp; the Free State Ramblers

Roan

Mt Hilltoppers

FRC1002

Clyde &amp; Ralph Troxell FRC1003

check made
$5 for

i
m

The Field

Recorders'
Collective

�THE

OLD-TIME

HERALD
A

MAGAZINE

DEDICATED TO OLD-TIME

MUSIC

The Old-Time Music Group, Inc.
PO Box 61679

Durham, NC 27715
Phone and fax: (919) 286-2041
E-mail: info@oldtimeherald.org

www.oldtimeherald.org
EDITOR-IN-CHIEF
EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
Sarah Bryan

BUSINESS DIRECTOR
Peter Honig

SENIOR ADVISORY EDITOR
Gail Gillespie

CONTRIBUTING

EDITORS

Bill Hicks, Phil Jamison, Bob Smakula,
Clare Milliner, Walt Koken
ART DIRECTOR
Steve Terrill, 97 watt creative group

FOUNDING EDITOR
Alice Gerrard
ADVISORY BOARD
Mac Benford,

Hilary Dirlam, Bobby Fulcher,
Ramona Jones, Garrison Keillor,
Pete Kuykendall, Brad Leftwich,
Lee Smith, Pete Sutherland

OLD-TIME MUSIC GROUP, INC.
BOARD OF DIRECTORS
Art Aylsworth,

Gail Gillespie,

Sally Council,
Jim Watson

November 2013
No part of this magazine may be reproduced
without written permission from
the publisher. Not responsible for loss or non
return of unsolicited photos or manuscripts.
2013 the Old-Time Herald. The Old-Time Herald
in any form

(ISSN 1040358) (USPS 002672) is published
quarterly by the Old-Time Music Group, Inc.,
PO Box 61679, Durham, NC 27715. Subscrip
tion rates payable in advance. One year:
subscriptions--Canada $27US;
overseas $30US). Periodical postage rate paid
at Durham, NC 27715 and additional mailing
$20 (foreign

offices.

Postmaster: Send change

of address

to

the Old-Time Herald, PO Box 61679, Durham,
NC 27715. The Old-Time Music Group, Inc., is

not-for-profit, tax-exempt corporation under
section 501 (c) (3) of the Internal Revenue Code.
a

The Old-Time Music Group, Inc. celebrates the love

old-time music. Old-time music
grassroots or
home grown musicand dance
shares origins, influ
ences and musical characteristics with roots musics
throughout America. Our magazine, the Old-Time
Herald, casts a wide net, highlighting the Southeast
ern tradition while opening its pages to kindred
and comparable traditions and new directions. It
provides enlightening articles and in-depth reviews,
opportunities for musical learning and sharing, and
a forum for addressing the issues and questions that
bear upon the field.
of

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�The

Available

Enoch Dobson

in fretted &amp; fretless, at Enoch
Instruments and other fine dealers.

Call 301-595-0373 or visit www.enochbanjos.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�ment, for he believed the banjo was strictly
a black instrument before
minstrelsy.

described as a "moun
instrument in articles that have
influenced the popular view of banjo
history, when in fact, the folk banjo was
mostly a rural and Southern instrument.
It is unfortunate that the
banjo was per
ceived as a mountain instrument; this
ensured that its history would be cloud
ed with misinformation filtered through
mountain stereotypes.
Loyal Jones said in his foreword to the sec
The banjo is

tain"

ond edition of Appalachian Images in Folk and
Popular Culture, "The self-proclaimed 'ex
perts' on Appalachia, and there have been

many, are usually frauds or are deceived by
the appearances on which they happen to

focus at the moment." This book should be
required reading for anyone writing about
Appalachia. The "experts" who have writ
ten the banjo out of the Southern mountains
before tire Civil War did so without reading
mountain historians or folklorists. Read
ing a book about minstrelsy is considered
by some to be sufficient for understanding
Southern banjo history.
John Preston Arthur (1851-1916) said in
Iris

lristory, Western North Carolina, A History
1730-1913 "The banjo and fiddle have

From

been as constant companions of the pio
neers of the mountains of North Carolina as
the Bible and the Hymn Book." A contem
porary said of Arthur, "More so than any
other local historian, he went to the original
sources for his facts. He sought out old dia
ries, journals, letters, and even talked with

old citizens, who shared their recollections
with him." Arthur's lristory was apparently
not read by those who claim minstrels intro

duced the banjo

to

Anglo-American South

erners during and after the Civil War.
The banjoA of course, was an instrument
with African origins, and playing the
banjo and fiddle as a pair was pioneered
by black musicians. The first reference
I have
found to the banjo in the Carolinas is from the 1780s, when young folks

"would join in a regular old-fashioned
Virginia reel, and keep time with flying
feet to the delightful strains drawn from
a gourd banjo." The first reference to the

banjo in Kentucky is in 1781.
I have
evidence that rural Kentuckians
were dancing to the banjo and fiddle be
fore the Civil War in western, central and
eastern Kentucky; that Carolinians were
dancing to the banjo and fiddle before the
Civil War, and that pioneers on the Ar
kansas frontier were dancing to the gourd

and fiddle in Northwest Arkansas
between 1828 and 1838. (The majority of
banjo

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

settlers in Northwest Arkansas were from
the Southern mountains.)
That mountaineers played

songs popu
minstrelsy has often been cited as
evidence that minstrelsy is the source for
Southern banjo traditions; however, almost
all the early minstrel songs were taken
from the folk repertoire of the time. Dan
Emmett, who claimed authorship of such
lar

in

songs as "Old Dan Tucker" and "Dixie,"
learned to play banjo from mountaineer
Archibald Ferguson during a three-month
period in 1840. Emmett, a trained musician,
would have been in possession of much of

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Ferguson's repertoire, and no doubt knew
of Ferguson's death in New Orleans sev
eral months later. Emmett also had access to

Snowden family,

the repertoire of the black

who lived near him in Mount Vernon, Ohio.
Emmett likely learned "Old Dan Tuck
er" from

Ferguson, and

a

very good case

has been made for Emmett borrowing the
song "Dixie" from the Snowden family.

Josiah Combs was born in Knott Coun
ty, Kentucky, in 1886, and did his doctoral

dissertation at the University of Paris in
1925; his dissertation was edited by D. K.
Wilgus and published

as

Folk-Songs of the

Southern United States. This book is

a

valu
Af

able reference for those interested in

rican American contributions to Southern
music. Combs provides lists of African
American banjo songs introduced into
Kentucky by black musicians before and
after the Civil War.
Combs developed an intimate knowledge
of black folk music from his acquaintance
with black musicians in Knott County. He
collected songs from black banjoist Cullie Williams in 1902, and said, "He [Cullie]
was a great 'banjer' picker." Cullie worked
for Josiah's family in Hindman, Kentucky,
in the early 1900s and undoubtedly influ

enced the music of Banjo Bill Comett, an ex
traordinary banjo picker from Hindman.

Combs lists ten sources for Southern
mountain folk songs; the tenth was "Mis
cellaneous tunes, picked up here and there
by the Highlander outside the mountains,
or coming from circuses, vaudeville, etc.
." Combs
did not hold minstrel songs
in high regard. He said, "Genuine Negro
songs have often been confused with songs
of black-face comedians and vaudeville,
and have often been corrupted by them.
After the Civil War, Negro music and song
were seriously impaired by the composi
tions of cheap song-writers and publish
ers." Before the Civil War, of course, many
of the minstrel songs (some altered) were
from the folk repertoire of the era.
Finally, I can find no evidence that

any influence

min

folk
banjo in East Kentucky. Of the two ma
jor tunings used in minstrelsy, one (with
bass string lowered two frets) was not in
the folk repertoire in Knott County, Ken

strelsy had

on

the

tucky, circa 1950. My father, Mai Gibson
(1900-1996), used many tunings but did
not use this minstrel tuning. Reverend
Buell Kazee, who began learning to play
banjo circa 1905, said he learned this tun
ing later in life. This minstrel tuning was
not among the 16 Stuart Jamieson collect
ed from Blind Hobart Bailey of Hippo,

Kentucky, circa 1946.

�In conclusion, there needs to be a reex
amination of the contributions of African
Americans to Southern folk music and
dance. This needs to be done without
the obscuring minstrel myths. Then we

will truly know, as did Darley Fulks, that
much of Southern folk music and dance
is

African American in origin.
George Gibson

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Section with Illegible Text

Tupelo
Old-Time
Banjos
-k

Curly Maple,

Walnut or
Mahogany

k Maple Tone
Rim

ik

25.5" Scale
Wide Neck

-k

Aged Brass

Hardware

r

Sweetone
Tailpiece

k Wood

Armrest
ik S-

Scoop

k Dowel
Stick

k From

$1,795
with
case

Visit our Website
OME

BANJOS COM

Section with Illegible Text

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Congratulations
Recipients of this year's Brown Hudson
Folklore Award from the North Carolina
Folklore Society include two traditional
musicians, Surry County guitarist Chester

McMillian, and Carteret County folklormusician Barbara Garrity-Blake.

ist and

The awards were presented on September
28 at the 2013 North Carolina Folklife Fes

tival in Carrboro, North Carolina.
Winners

at

the

11"'

Annual

Tazewell

County Old Time and Bluegrass Fiddlers

Convention, held
dle:

Tazewell, Virginia,
follows. Old-Time Fid

in

14, are as

June 12

Steve Kruger, Betty Vornbrock, KilHelen White.

by Spencer, Jerry Correll,

Bluegrass Fiddle: Kilby Spencer, Stuart
Light, Dewey Long, Eddie Marrs.

Old-

Time Banjo: Ron Mullenex, Shawn Ter
rell, Steve Kruger, Gary Holmgren, Tina
Liza Jones. Bluegrass Banjo: Steve Lewis,

David Chrisley, Mike Mullins, Rita Hunt,
Steve Chrisley. Fiddle and Banjo Duet:

Ron Mullenex

and

and

Bill

Correll, Gary
Stuart Light
Kunz,
Holmgren
and Tina Liza Jones, Phil and Joe Bevins,
Robert Davis and Shawn Terrell. OldTime Band:

Crooked

Jerry

Jeffersonville Skirmish Band,

Road

Ramblers, Tower Street
Floyd, Reed Island
Rounders. Bluegrass Band: Bad Ridge,
Blue Rockin' Grass, Special Delivery,
Second Generation, Clinch River Gospel
Grass. Youth: Tatum Beck, Joe Bevins,
String

Band,

Blue

Madeline Jarrett, Ivy Joe Hart. Folk Song:

Phil Bevins, Eddie

Ogle, Dale Elswick,
Harold Dotson, Joe Bevins. Guitar: Steve
Lewis, Josh Raines, Rick Hall, Nathan
Sykes, Glenn Craver. Mandolin: Matt
Stacy, Hunter Walker, Jared Sweet, Rick
Hall, LeRoy Long. Dobro:

Eddie Marrs,

George Watkins, Adrian Sheets, Mike
Hankins. Harmonica: Tommy Taylor, Ed
die Ogle, Robie Castle. Dulcimer: Hunter
Mullins, David Parks, LeRoy Long. Bass:
David Chrisley, Jamie Stacy. Autoharp:
Judy Sipes, Kay Bevins. Dance, Male: Le
Roy Long, Robert Wilcox, Donald Hess,
Manuel Collins, Robie Castle. Dance, Fe
male: Kay Bevins, Thelma Powers, Kath
leen O'Connell, Susan Taylor. Dance,
Youth: Audrey Davis, Dana Pilkins, Kat

Bevins, Madeline Jarrett.
Contest winners

at the

Highland County

Old Time Fiddlers Convention, held June
13
16 in Monterey, Virginia, were as fol
lows. Fiddle: Jake Krack, Hannah John-

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

son, Jeff Shumate, Michael Gioudano,
Vigour. Youth Fiddle: Emma Harman, Alexis Small, David Musick. Banjo:
Steven Casto, Victor Furtado, Tyler May,
Miles Bonefaus, Tim Bing. Guitar: John
Hull, Mike Harrison, Tom Wright, Dennis
McKim, John Simmons. Dulcimer: Paige
Hedgecoth, John Donelson. Mandolin:
Taylor Baker, Leighton Scott Friend, Ellen
Pete

Fiddle: Kilby Spencer, Crumpler; Rich
ard Bowman, Mount Airy; Helen White,
Mouth of Wilson, Virginia; Jerry Correll,
Elk Creek, Virginia; Levi Funk, Fries, Vir
ginia. Bluegrass Fiddle: Crystal Shipley,

Tennessee; John Hofmann,
Thomasville; Nathan Aldridge, Graham;
Lauren Sheppard, Raleigh; Rex McGee,
Kingsport,

Dick Harrington. Open: Eddie Ogle, Bill,
Patrick McCauley, Rebecca Clayton, Tom

King. Junior Fiddle: Carson Peters, Piney Flats, Tennessee; Kitty Amaral, Elk
Creek, Virginia; Mary-Claire Hooper,
Elkin. Old-Time Banjo: Marsha Todd,
Mount Airy; Jared Boyd, Laurel Fork,
Virginia; Trish Fore, Galax, Virginia; Kel-

Wright. Band: Krack Brothers, Hoyt Street
Hotshots, Pride of Low Moor, Banana Ex
press, Cary Street Ramblers. Youth Folk
Song: John Gillan. Dance, Adult: Ellen
and Eugene Ratcliff, Lowell Terry, Victor

ley Breiding, Lewisville; Daniel Boyer,
Fries, Virginia. Bluegrass Banjo: Zachary Carter, Spartanburg, South Carolina;
Steve Lewis, Todd; Timothy Mills, Riner, Virginia; Brandy Miller, West Jef

Furtado.

ferson;

The 11"' Annual Henry Reed Memorial
Fiddlers Convention was held June 14

Junior Banjo: Miguel Villarruel, Glade
Valley; Madison Shepherd, Jefferson;
Brittany Osborne, West Jefferson. OldTime Band: Crooked Road Ramblers,

Vigour, Tripp Johnson, Dennis McKim.
Folk Song: Karin Magno, Joe Herrmann,
Lorie Lichtenwalner, Hannah Johnson,

Glen Lyn, Virginia, with the fol
winners. Old-Time Fiddle:
contest
lowing
15 in

Bill Blevins, Stuart Light, Carl Baron,
Ron Mullennex, Jim Costa. Bluegrass
Fiddle: Rebekah Bolt, Stuart Light, Paul
Herling. Old-Time Banjo: Ron Mullen
nex, Jim Costa, Jeff Norman, Teri Hayes,
Chip Arnold. Bluegrass Banjo: Barry
Collins, Tim York, Bill Moran. BanjoFiddle Duet: Bill Blevins and Tina Liza
Jones, Carl Baron and Kaye Somerville,
Lieselotte Heil and Teri Hayes, Paul
Herling and Ginger Wagner, Martila
Shirley. Old-Time Band: Katie and the
Pole Dancers, Blue Floyd, Indian Run

String Band, Allegheny Hellbenders
and Friends, Tower Street String Band.
Bluegrass Band: Gold Rush, Jason Har
ris Band. Old-Time Guitar: Clay Fergu
son. Mandolin: Nick Good, Clay Fergu
son, Eric Root. Bluegrass Guitar: Bran
don Hilton, Tyler Jones, Tim Thornton.
Bass: Clay Ferguson, BJ Compton, Keith
Thomas. Autoharp: Dianne Huffman.
Harmonica: Eddie Ogle. Dulcimer: Alan
Freeman, Tim Thornton, Matt Peyton,
Sue Santamaria. Folk Song: Harold Maurer, Pat

Willis, Tim Thornton, Phil Bev-

ins, Jason Harris. Dance: Cherie Comp
ton, Judy Atkinson, CJ Ferguson, Sierra

Hilton, Matthew Thornton. Youth: Joe
Bevins, Samuel Mikhail, Lukas Reed,
Christopher Maynard.
At

the

Alleghany

Convention,

held

County

July

19

Fiddlers

and

20

in

Sparta, North Carolina, winners were as
follows. (Hometowns are in North Caro
lina, unless otherwise noted.) Old-Time

Derek

Easter,

Cana,

Virginia.

Crumpler; Fox Creek Ramblers, Galax,
Virginia; South Carolina Broadcasters,
Mount Airy; New Cabin Creek Boys,
Mount Airy; Slate Mountain Ramblers,
Mount Airy. Junior Band: Jones Sisters,
Linwood; Next Generation, Asheboro;
Pike City, Hillsville, Virginia; Elk Creek
Jam Band, Deep

Destination

Gap. Bluegrass

Bluegrass

Band,

Band:

Mocks-

ville; Cross Road, Cana, Virginia; D. J. R.
and G., King; Adam McPeak and Moun
tain Thunder, Max Meadows, Virginia;
Old Bills, Advance. Dobro: Pammy
Garden; Josh HazelVirginia; Marvin Farmer,
Hillsville, Virginia; Keith Aiken, Hen
derson; John Powell, Mocksville. Har
monica: Eddie Ogle, Roanoke, Virginia;
Dan Isaacs, Vilas; Glen Zuhlke, Galax,
Virginia; Paul Hiatt, High Point; Milton
Scott, Thurmond. Dulcimer: Dick Lamb,

Davis,
wood,

Pleasant

Cana,

Keezletown, Virginia; Wayne Seymour,
Reidsville; Lisa Smith, Advance. Auto
harp: JoAnn Redd, Galax, Virginia; Cur
tis Bond, Fries, Virginia; Penny Kilby,
Mouth of Wilson, Virginia; Vickie Boyd,

Fork, Virginia; Nellie Zuhlke,
Galax, Virginia. Bass: Jerry Steinberg,
Salem, Virginia; David Campbell, Fleet
wood; Barbara Bowman, Mount Airy;

Laurel

Durham; Donna Cor
rell, Traphill. Junior Bass: Kyser George,
Westfield; Katie Jones, Linwood; Karissa
Hayden, Hillsville, Virginia. Vocal: Alan
Teichman, Jamestown; Sarah Osborne,
Mount Airy; John Goad, Rogersville,
Tennessee; Susan Reeder, Galax, Vir
ginia; Kinsey Greene, Boone. MandoCaleb Hagwood,

�Catherine Conner, Stuart, Virginia;
Goad, Stuart, Virginia; Rodney
Hodges, Galax, Virginia; Adam McPeak,
Max Meadows, Virginia; Connor Lam
lin:

Nick

bert, Troutman. Junior Mandolin: Aus
tin Tate, Marion, Virginia; Liam Purcell,
Deep Gap; Tatum Holloway, North Wilkesboro. Guitar: Jeffrey Roten, Eunice;
Ben Watlington, Mocksville; Eric Har
din, West Jefferson; Steve Kilby, Mouth

of Wilson, Virginia; Austin Mikeal, West
Jefferson. Junior Guitar: Zack Arnold,
West Jefferson; Presley Barker, North
Wilkesboro; Mary Ellen Wingate, Inde
pendence, Virginia. Senior Dance: Samantha Wilhelmi, Marsha Todd, Cherie

Compton, JoAnn Call, Barbara Bowman.
Junior Dance: Mary-Claire Hooper, Leah

Madison Shepherd, Macy
Lillian
Cockerham. Children's
Henson,
Dance (noncompetitive, all get ribbons):
McGrady,

Myla George, Westfield; Kyser George,

Westfield; Addie Howell, Sparta; Kenyon
Purcell, Deep Gap.
At the Morehead Old Time Festival in
Morehead, Kentucky, held July 27 and
28, the following were the top-three win

ners in their contest categories.

towns

(Home

Kentucky unless otherwise
Fiddle:
Anna Roberts-Gevalt,
noted.)
Baltimore, Maryland; Nikos Pappas,
Tuscaloosa, Alabama; Matt Kinman,
Vilas, North Carolina. Youth Fiddle:
Meghan Bryant, Martin; Robert Miller,
are in

Catlettsburg; Emmaly Saliga, Pendleton.
Banjo: Brett Ratliff, Whitesburg; John

Haywood, Little Doubles Creek; Matt
Kinman, Vilas, North Carolina. Youth
Isaac May, Mount Eden; Chris
tina Saliga, Pendleton; Emily Bryant,
Martin. String Band: The Briar Ticklers;
Sponge Bob Square Dance; The Rail
Banjo:

Splitters. Singing:
Louisville; Sarah

Heather
Wood,

Summers,
Maysville;

Brett Ratliff,
Dulcimer:
Whitesburg.
Linda Stokley, Versailles; Sarah Wood,
Maysville; Ty Knipp, Olive Hill. Dance:
Julie Shepherd-Powell, Big Stone Gap,
Virginia; Sean Skafe, California; Anna
Roberts Gevalt, Baltimore, Maryland.
Youth Dance: Chloe Clevenger, Athens,
Ohio; Madison Welte, Morehead; Vin
cent Johnson, Woodsbend.

Contest winners at the Appalachian
String Band Festival, held July 31 Au
gust 4 at Clifftop, West Virginia, were
as follows. Fiddle: Clelia Stefanini, Elkins Park, Pennsylvania; Jake Krack,
Marlinton, West Virginia; Stephanie
Coleman, Brooklyn, New York; Leo

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Shannon, Seattle, Washington; Rhys
Jones, Warrenton, Virginia. Youth Fid
dle: Leo Shannon, Seattle, Washington;
Noel "Kitty" Amaral, Elk Creek, Vir
ginia;

William

Brauneis,

Washington,

DC. Senior Fiddle: Pete Vigour,

Crozet,
Polo
Burguiere, Ardeche,
France; Elmer Rich, Morgantown, West
Virginia. Banjo: Tim Bing, Huntington,
West Virginia; Andrew
FitzGibbon,
Montrose, West Virginia; Seth Swingle,
Earlysville, Virginia; John Morris, Ivy
dale, West Virginia; Mary Sue Joy, Hol
lywood, Maryland. Youth Banjo: Victor
Furtado, Front Royal, Virginia; Trevor
Hammons, Marlinton, West Virginia;
Rebecca Molaro, Asheville, North Caro
lina. Senior Banjo: John Morris, Ivydale,
West Virginia; Pete Peterson, Oxford,
Pennsylvania; Bill Schmidt, Baltimore,
Maryland. Traditional Band: We See It,
We Take It, Montrose, West Virginia;
Virginia;

Old

Greenfield, Massachusetts;
Bigfoot, Marshall, North Carolina; All
Day Breakfast String Band, Traphill,
Buck,

North Carolina; Wild Coyotes, Pocatel
lo, Idaho. Youth Traditional Band: Elm
Street Alley Cats, Elkins, West Virginia.

Neo-Traditional Band: No. 47, Elkins,
West Virginia; Jubal's Kin, Longwood,
Florida; Poor Taters, Athens, West Vir-

�Second Hand

Suits, Lancaster,
Jones Evidence
Pennsylvania;
Locker, Montrose, West Virginia. Youth
Band:
The
Mario
Neo-Traditional
Brothers Three, Fishersville, Virginia.
Best Original Song: Second Hand Suits,
Lancaster, Pennsylvania. Best Original
Tune: No. 47, Elkins, West Virginia. OldTime Fiat-Foot Dance, 15 and under:
Rebecca Molaro, Asheville, North Car
olina; Victor Furtado, Front Royal, Vir
ginia; Jeffrey Amundsen, Longwood,
Florida. Old-Time Fiat-Foot Dance, 16
40: Josephine
Stewart, Charlottes
ville, Virginia; Alice Cade, Ketton, Eng
land; Emolyn Liden, Asheville, North
Carolina. Old-Time Fiat-Foot Dance,
41
59: Jay Bland, Kennesaw, Georgia;
Jan Scopel, Annapolis, Maryland; Jane
Henderson, Bloomington, Indiana. OldTime Fiat-Foot Dance, 60 and over: Kim
ginia;

Davy

Marilyn

Annapolis, Maryland;
Branch, Kalamazoo, Michigan; Kriss
Sands, Mars Hill, North Carolina.
Forry,

August 5-10 the Old Fiddlers'
Convention was held in Galax, Virgin
On

ia, with the following contest winners.
Old-Time Fiddle: Jake Krack, Marlinton,
West Virginia; Eddie Bond, Fries, Virgin
ia; Jacob Bowen, State Road, North Car
olina; Adam Hurt, Kernersville, North
Carolina; Kilby Spencer, Galax, Vir
ginia; Erynn Marshall, Galax, Virginia;
Barbara Kuhns, Midway, Ohio; Richard
Bowman, Mount Airy, North Carolina;
Chris Prillaman, Ferrum, Virginia; Erika
Testerman, Mount Airy, North Carolina.
Youth Old-Time Fiddle: Ruth Shumway,
West Jefferson, North Carolina; Kitty Am
aral, Elk Creek, Virginia; Andrew Vogts,
Chadds Ford, Pennsylvania; Isabella
Gorman, Charlottesville, Virginia; Da
vid Jett, White Oak, Virginia. Bluegrass
Fiddle: Stephen Fraleigh, Raleigh, North
Carolina; Adam Larkey, Erwin, Tennes
see; Daniel Greeson, Jamestown, North
Carolina; Corrina Logston, Nashville,
Tennessee; Caleb McAllister, Fincastle,

Virginia; Danny Knicley, Taylorstown,
Virginia; T. J. Lundy, Newport, Dela
ware; Glen Alexander, Pfafftown, North
Carolina; Melody Berger, Waterford, Vir
ginia;

Spencer Strickland, Lambsburg,

Virginia. Youth Bluegrass Fiddle: Carson
Peters, Piney Flats, Tennessee; Savannah

Fraleigh, Raleigh, North Carolina; So
phia Fernandez, Durham, North Caro
lina; Tanner Henson, Asheboro, North
Carolina; Marissa Colter, Clemmons,
North Carolina. Clawhammer Banjo:
Tina Steffey, Jonesborough, Tennessee;

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Josh Ellis, Galax, Virginia; Peco Watson,
Galax, Virginia; Jared Boyd, Laurel Fork,
Virginia; Tim Bing, Huntington, West

Johnson City, Tennessee; Amber Collins
and Turning Point, Christiansburg, Vir
ginia. Youth Bands: Carolina Bluegrass
Express, Mount Airy, North Carolina;

Virginia; Marsha Todd, Mount Airy,
North Carolina; Kelley Breiding, Mount
Airy, North Carolina; Trish Fore, Galax,
Virginia; Victor Furtado, Front Royal,
Virginia; Marianne Kovatch, Fries, Vir
ginia. Youth Clawhammer Banjo: Victor
Furtado, Front Royal, Virginia; Madison
Shepherd, West Jefferson, North Caro

Salem, North Carolina; Gravel Road,
Pilot, Virginia; Next Generation, Ashe
boro, North Carolina. Dobro: Jordon
Roberson, Stoneville, North Carolina;
Quentin Frazier, Dapto, Australia; Gav

lina;

en Largent, Winchester,

Virginia;

Smith, Midway,
Pleasant Garden,
Marrs, Princeton,
Ellis, Mocksville,

Pammy

Robbie Anders, Galax, Virginia;
Luke Hall, Troutdale, Virginia; Miguel
Villarruel, Glade Valley, North Carolina.
Bluegrass Banjo: Lee Dunbar, Eagle Rock,
Virginia; Matthew Turman, Eden, North
Carolina; Andy Lowe, Winston-Salem,
North Carolina; Zachary Carter, Spartan

Exploding Orangutans, Front
Royal, Virginia; Unpredictable, WinstonPsycho

Ohio;

Doug
Davis,

North Carolina; Eddie
West Virginia; Robert
North Carolina; Mar

vin Farmer, Hillsville, Virginia; Maggie
Anderson, Woodlawn, Virginia; Wade
Fogleman, Snow Camp, North Carolina.
Mandolin: Nicholas Goad, Stuart, Vir

burg, South Carolina; Jeremy Stephens,
Danville, Virginia; Joey Cox, Pulaski, Vir
ginia; Rusty Breedlove, Salem, Virginia;
Jacob Wright, Blacksburg, Virginia; Ste
vie Barr, Galax, Virginia; Danny Bowers,
Winston-Salem, North Carolina. Youth

ginia; Ryan Blevins, Marion, Virginia;
Jonah Horton, Wilkesboro, North Caroli
na; Kevin McKinnon, Mocksville, North
Carolina; Tyler Tuttle, Wilkesboro, North

Bluegrass Banjo: Blake Lanning, Lexing
ton, North Carolina; Clay Russell, Trout

see; Matt Hiser, Camp Creek, West Vir

dale,

North

Virginia; Luke Smith, Robbins,
Carolina; Adam Bishop, Riner,

Virginia; Blake Hall, Radford, Virginia.
Old-Time Bands: New Ballards Branch

Bogtrotters, Galax, Virginia; Whoopin'
Hollar String Band, Marlinton, West Vir
ginia; Crooked Road Ramblers, Galax,
Virginia; Southern Pride, Galax, Vir
ginia; Dry Hill Draggers, Ferrum, Vir
ginia; Slate Mountain Ramblers, Mount
Airy, North Carolina; New River Bound,

Christiansburg, Virginia; The New Cab
in Creek Boys, Mount Airy, North Caro
lina; Back Step, Mount Airy, North Caro
lina; Virginia Creepers, Fries, Virginia;
Blue Ridge Mountain Ramblers, Galax

Virginia; Hard Cider, Independence, Vir
ginia; Fishers Gap String Band, Galax,
Virginia; West Bound 37, Rural Retreat,
Virginia;

Trativod,

Melink,

Czech

Re

public. Bluegrass Bands: High Voltage,
Pfafftown, North Carolina; Mike Bailiff
Bluegrass, Winston-Salem, North Caro
lina;

Esquire

J

and the Rejects,

Cana,

Virginia; Stoney's Jar, Mocksville, North
Carolina; The Country Boys, Mount
North Carolina; The Donkey
Airy,
Punch Brothers, Winston-Salem, North
Carolina;

Hawkins County Bluegrass,

Rogersville, Tennessee; Carolina Grass,
Mocksville, North Carolina; Grassless
Playground, Roaring Gap, North Caroli
na; Cox and Company, Pulaski, Virginia;
Second Wind, Fries, Virginia; South 79,
Mayville, New York; The Loose Strings,
Galax, Virginia; Tyler Williams Band,

Carolina; Cory Piatt, Springfield, Tennes

ginia; Ricky Ellis, Bedford, Virginia; Jer
emiah Gilmer, Bracey, Virginia; William
Jones, Cana, Virginia. Youth Mandolin:
Eli Smith,
Robbins, North Carolina;

Devin Huie, Wilkesboro, North
Austin Tate, Marion, Virginia;
Burdette, Winston-Salem, North
lina; Olivia Fernandez, Durham,

na;

Caroli
Fiona

Caro

North
Carolina. Guitar: Scott Fore, Radford,
Virginia; Wayne Henderson, Rugby, Vir
ginia; Austin Mikeal, Jefferson, North
Carolina; Eric Hardin, West Jefferson,
North Carolina; Buddy Dunlap, Wardensville, West Virginia; Gregg Wilson,
Fries, Virginia; Lucas White, Galax, Vir
ginia; Tony Collins, Bristol, Virginia; So

Knoxville, Tennessee;
Mount
Edmonds,
Andy
Airy, North Car
journer McClure,

olina. Youth Guitar: Jacob Greer, Jeffer
son, North Carolina; Tony Hicks, Laurel
Fork, Virginia; Pressley Barker, Traphill,
North Carolina; Jeffrey Roten, Ennice,
North Carolina; Zack Arnold, West Jef

ferson, North Carolina. Dulcimer: Hunt
er Walker, Beckley, West Virginia; Sharon
Boyd, Colonial Heights, Virginia; Tammy
Sawyer, Traphill, North Carolina; Holly

Hinshelwood, Abingdon, Virginia; Da
vid Parks, Dublin, Virginia; Tim Thorn
ton, Shawsville, Virginia; Dot Christen
son, Lexington, Kentucky; Frank Horn,
North Tazewell, Virginia; Jean Callison,
Mouth of Wilson, Virginia; Jimmy Watts,

Virgilina, Virginia. Autoharp: John Hol

landsworth,
Christiansburg, Virginia;
Ronnie Burroughs, Keysville, Virginia;

�Gerald

Anderson,

Troutdale, Virginia;
Penny Kilby, Mouth of Wilson, Virginia;
Libby Kahn, Independence, Virginia;
Glenna Anderson, Christiansburg, Vir
ginia; Lois Shumaker, Olin, North Caro
lina; Vicki Boyd, Laurel Fork, Virginia;
Bobbi Roberts, Galax, Virginia; Doug
Pratt, Cary, North Carolina. Folk Song:
Leslie Dunbar, Eagle Rock, Virginia;
Amy Ellis, Bedford, Virginia; Meagan
White, Greensboro, North Carolina; Eric
Marshall, Mount Airy, North Carolina;
Jamie Collins, Bristol, Tennessee; Ty
ler Williams, Johnson City, Tennessee;
Heather Mabe, Walnut Cove, North
Carolina;

Meagan Gregory, Johnson
Sheena Padgett, Hillsville, Virginia; Sierra Wilson, Fleetwood,
North Carolina. Dance: Glenn Wimmer,
City, Tennessee,

Rocky Mount,
han, Ivanhoe,

Virginia;
Virginia;

Kenny MonaMichael Mot

ley, Mount Airy,

North Carolina; Brett
Martin, Independence, Virginia; Angela
Hale, Elk Creek, Virginia; Delbert Dun-

ford, Wytheville, Virginia; Mitchell Rob
inson, Galax, Virginia; Dawson McKay,
Rural Retreat, Virginia; Nickie Hodges,
Stuart, Virginia; Christina Phipps, Inde
pendence, Virginia. Best All-Around Per
former: Nicholas Goad, Stuart, Virginia.
At the Fries

Volunteer Fire Department

Fiddlers Convention in Fries, Vir
ginia, winners were as follows. (Home
towns are in Virginia unless otherwise
noted.) Old-Time Fiddle: Kilby Spencer,
Crumpler, North Carolina; Eddie Bond,
Fries; David Bass, Durham, North Caroli
na; Richard Bowman, Mount Airy, North
Carolina; Erynn Marshall, Galax. Bluegrass Fiddle: Marlon Dean, Galax; Su
2013

san

Dabney, Easton, Maryland; Stephen
Gerni, Easton, Mary laird. Youth Old Time
Fiddle: Kitty Amaral, Elk Creek; Isabella
Gorman, Charlottesville; Allyson Bemis,
Fries; Josie Leonard, Woodlawn. Youth
Bluegrass Fiddle: Meagan King, Ivanhoe;

Kameron Nunn, Westfield, North Caro
lina; Jordan King, Wytheville. Old-Time
Banjo: Marsha Todd, Mount Airy, North
Carolina; Kelley Breiding, Lewisville,
North Carolina; Trish Fore, Galax; Josh
Ellis, Galax; Daniel Boyer, Fries. Bluegrass Banjo: Gary Webb, Max Meadows;

Mike

Mullins,

Galax;

Steve

Chrisley,

Galax;
Wytheville;
Bradley Johnson,
Timothy Mills, Riner. Youth Old-Time
Banjo: Brittany Osborne, Jefferson, North
Carolina; Madison Shepherd, West Jef
ferson, North Carolina. Youth Bluegrass
Banjo: Clay Russell, Mouth of Wilson;
Blake Hall, Radford. Guitar: Steve Kilby,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Mouth of Wilson; Jacob Greer, Jefferson,
North Carolina; Garry Dalton, Draper;
Tony Hicks, Laurel Fork; Glen Craver,
Winston-Salem, North Carolina. Youth
Presley Barker, Traphill, North
Carolina. Mandolin: Adam McPeak, Max
Guitar:

Meadows; Rodney Hodges, Galax; Aus
tin Tate, Marion; Lewis Prichard, Beckley, West Virginia; Terry Keene, Barren
Springs. Youth Mandolin: Luke Morris,
Galax; Bailey Stoneman, Galax. Autoharp: Penny Kilby, Mouth of WilsonBobbie Roberts, Galax; Virgil Adams,
Fries; Vickie Boyd, Laurel Fork; Curtis
Bond, Fries. Dulcimer: Clarence Rob
erts, Galax; David Parks, Dublin; Fred
Reynolds, Eden, North Carolina; Tom
Gerni, Madison Heights. Dobro: Robert
Ellis, Mocksville, North Carolina; W. H.
Olivett, Galax; John Powell, Mocksville,
North Carolina; Marvin Farmer, Hillsville; Eddie Rowe, Galax. Bass: David
Chrisley, Wytheville; Jamie Stacy, Galax;
David Cline, Wytheville; Barbara Bow
man, Ararat; Adrian Johnson, Harmony,
North Carolina. Folk Songs: Ted Turner,
Gary Dalton, Honey Bressfield, Josh
Reins, Jack Hinshelwood. Dance, 17 and
Over: Samantha Wilhelmi, Riner; Barba
ra Bowman, Mount Airy, North Carolina;
Marsha Todd, Mount Airy, North Caroli
na; Marty Todd, Mount Airy, North Caro
lina; Dawson McKay, Crockett. Old-Time
Bands: Crooked Road Ramblers, Fries;
Fox Creek Ramblers, Mouth of WilsonSlate Mountain Ramblers, Mount Airy,
North Carolina; New Ballard's Branch
Bogtrotters, Galax; New Spring Val
ley Boys, Fries. Bluegrass Bands: Adam
McPeak and Mountain Thunder, Max
Meadows; Valley Grass, Saltville; Scaggs
and Company, Radford; 94 Bluegrass,
Roanoke; Laurel Ridge, Austinville. Hen
ry Whitter Memorial Award for Best AllAround Performer: David Bass, Durham,
North Carolina. Houston Caldwell Me
morial Award for Best All-Around Youth
Performer: Presley Barker, Traphill,
North Carolina.
On August 23
25 the Santa Fe Bluegrass and Old Time Music Festival took
place in Santa Fe, New Mexico, with the
following contest winners. Fiddle: John

Moulton. Banjo: Tony Holmquist.
pick

Guitar:

Kevin

Slick.

Flat-

Mandolin:

Steve Rosen. Vocal: Chrystal Copeland.
Songwriting: Blue Moon. Old-Time
Band: Fancy Minor. Bluegrass Band:
Higher Ground. Band Scramble: Rose
Tree
Ramblers. Entertainment
Duo:
Glenn &amp; Monica.

The Johnson County Fiddler's

Conven

tion was held on August 23 and 24 in Lau
rel Bloomery, Tennessee, with the follow
ing contest winners. Fiddle: Kilby Spencer,
Coleman Akin, Richard Bowman, Nokosee Fields, Steve Kruger. Twin Fiddle: Kil
by Spencer and Adrian Powell, Crystal

Blevins and Erika Testerman, Becky Co
hen and Dave Wood, Bill Birchfield and
Richard Bowman, Sally Anne Morgan
and Steve Kruger. Banjo: Kelley Breiding,
Debbie Yates, Tyler Hughes, Terry Tester,
Rick Ward. Guitar: Wayne Henderson,

Wayne Dye, Steve Kilby, Rick Huff
man, Tim Yates. Mandolin: Wayne Dye,
Rodney Hodges, Josh Bearman, Erving
Compton, Norman Wallin. Bass: Barbara

Bowman, Lula Meade, Hilary Dirlam,
Zack Pozebanchuk, Grey Nelson. Dulci
mer: Steve Kilby, James H. Garland, Dick
Lamb. Autoharp: James H. Garland, Pen
ny Kilby, Carmia Cornett, Richard Bow
man, Dexter Ramey. Harmonica: Paul Hiatt, Glen Zuhlke, Eddie Ogle, Art Lang,
Dan Isaacs. Folk Song: Steve Kruger, Alan
Teichman, Kay Justice, Matt Kinman, Ian
Snider. Vocal Duet: Coleman Akin and
Molly Yates and Sadie
Yates, Ed Norman and Tim Wells, Sarah
Gibson and Aaron Ratcliffe, Leon Blevins
and Tommy Blevins. Dance, Adult: Brett
Martin, Julie Shepherd Powell, John Per
Krist Truelsen,

Debbie Yates, Ersel Fletcher. Dance,
Madison Shepherd, Molly Yates,
Sadie Yates, Asa Nelson, Hazel Pasley.

ry,

Youth:

Crooked Road Ramblers, The
Maudlin Brothers, Jimmy Costa and the
Sunshine Boys, Slate Mountain Ramblers,
Roan Mountain Hilltoppers. Youth Perfor
mance: Madison Shepherd, Molly Yates,
Sarah Grace Larkey, Liam Purcell, Shooter
Band:

and Bud Brown.

Hoppin' John Old-Time and Bluegrass Fiddler's Convention was held
The

21 at Silk Hope, North
September 19
Carolina, with the following contest
winners. Old-Time Fiddle: Steve Kru

Jamie Rowan, Jon Newlin. BlueFiddle: Nathan Aldridge, Brian
English, Clay Sheiler. Old-Time Banjo:
Steve Kruger, Ben Reeser, Doug Shandger,

grass

Bluegrass Banjo: Courtney Clapp,
Nathan Aldridge, Grayson Laybourn.
Mandolin: Spencer Mobley; Leighton
Friend; Connor Hagwood. Bass: Caleb
Hagwood, Keith Sykes, Ellie Burdette.
Guitar: Dylan Shrader, Elise Fernandez,
Victor Lukas. Folk Song: Sarah Osborne,
Sarah Gibson, Macie Henson, Neshama
Littman. Youth Musicianship: Fiona
ley.

Burdette,

Olivia

Fernandez,

Jessica

�Lang, Sophia Fernandez. Adult Dance:
Schilling, Joan Levitt, Aaron
Ratcliffe. Youth Dance: Johanna Schil
ling, Macy Henson, Cage Bullard. OldTime Band: Epps Steppers, Okenichie

Jeremiah

Night Haws, Garbage Mountain Boys.
Bluegrass Band: Loose Gravel, Bethesda
Bluegrass, Fernandez Sisters. Non_Tra
ditional Band: Bawling Alley Sheiks,
Stray Locals, Porch Noise Complaints.
Cook-Off: Free Love and Bacon, AKA
Keithr Savary, M&amp;M, AKA Muriel Sink,
Bella Luna Farm, AKA Teresa Pruitt.
The 17lh Annual Ole Time Fiddlin' Con
vention and South Carolina State Fid

dling Championship was held Septem
Pickens County, South Caro
with
the following contest winners.
lina,

ber 21 in

Fiddle: Kirsten Harris, Peyton O'Kelley,
Marion Boatwright. Junior Fiddle: Beth

Hood, Mary Johnson. Banjo: Doug Rostick, Troy Harrison, Bailey George.
Guitar: Danielle Yother, Alex Alexan
der, Rowdy Hood. Wildcat Open: Alex

Alexander, Rowdy Hood, Jess Arnold

and Bailey George. Junior Open: Dan
ielle Yother, Mary Johnson, Keana Do
ver. Stringband:

Pinetop Revival (Dawn

Cantrell, Steve Cantrell, Josh Johnson,
Andrew Lathe, Dan Wood), Crooked
Pine (Craig Bannerman, Marion Boat

wright, Troy Harrison, Frank McCon
nell), Wyld Scallions (Robert Burns,
Marshall Goers, Doug Rostick).

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�notice

to

put

on anyway, as

it

a

tribute to

Gail and Bob. Performing and teaching
staff included the Mostly Mountain Boys,

Alice Gerrard, Dan Gellert, White Mule,
and Chirps Smith with Dot Kent. It was
a poignant mixture of fun, laughter, mu
sic and tears

a

bittersweet Gathering.

Even without Gail and Bob, who have
put so much concerted energy into creat
ing this gem, the event went on

without a
years, cer

hitch. That's because, over tire
tain volunteers have honed their skills,
setting up sound systems, selling CDs,
and doing kitchen duty and other tasks
we can't imagine. This year, they had to
add coordination, no small task, but at
least they knew the details.
A gathering to celebrate Gail's life,

mainly
Pop

organized

Wagner,

by

fellow

was held

in

musician
Paul

St.

on

July 21, 2013. Many of those of us who
loved her were there. At one point, an

impromptu orchestra

of about 30

people

got on stage and, led by Chirps Smith,
played "Ragtime Annie," the first fiddle

tune Gail learned.
Gail is no longer with us, but she leaves
behind an indelible legacy, in the form

of her students; those of us who learned
songs and tunes from her; her example

perform old-time music au
without
being pedantic; and,
thentically
every growing season, the seed beans
of

how

to

she shared with other gardeners.

In

ad

dition, volunteers are busy planning next
year's Gathering, and CDs of Bob and
Gail's performances are still available
at www.boveeheil.com. Bovee and Heil
have inspired so many of us by the ways,
as Jon Pankake wrote about them, "they
integrate their music with a vision of life
lived whole."
Lyle and Elizabeth Lofgren

Please join me in celebrating the life and
creative times of the amazing Curly Miller

(1954-2013), largely known

music circles

in

traditional

fiddler, classic rag banjoist, arranger, and leader of the old-time
string band The Old 78's. If you've at
tended old-time festivals in the last two
as

decades, you probably crossed
with
Curly the "ragmeister" and
paths
his distinctive music, as he was a regular
at music festivals such as Winfield, Cliffor

three

top, and Breaking Up Winter,
a

featured teacher

as

well as

music camps such
Mars Hill, and Ashokan
at

Swannanoa,
Southern Week.
Richard "Curly" Miller came from a
musical family and illuminated a rain
bow of musical passion throughout his
as

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

He was born in Baltimore, Mary
land, grew up in Penfield, New York,
married and moved down to Kingston,
Arkansas, in 1976, where he settled. He
played classical violin as a child, rockand-roll guitar as a teen, and three-fin
life.

ger

Leo

Kottke-style guitar

After moving
1970s,

in

college.

Arkansas to stay in the
he and wife Jeannie, their son
to

Kerry and daughter Sara enjoyed farm
life while he started raising Shiitake

mushrooms.
the festival

in

Curly regularly attended
Winfield, Kansas, where

Doc Watson and Norman Blake inspired
him into flat-picking guitar
that is,

until Frankie Gavin drew him headlong
In the early '80s,
into Irish fiddling.
his
found
Curly
way into old-time mu
first
bass
for the Skirtlifters,
sic,
bowing
and then fiddling and playing mando
lin with them. Through this association
with Clarke Buehling and the Skirtlift

Curly discovered his strong pas
sion for early old-time string bands, as
well as classic and minstrel banjo styles.
Many assumed music was Curly's pro
fession. It's just what he did for fun "af
ter hours" when work was done for the
ers,

day, and he wasn't fishing.
Curly was a creative powerhouse of
multiple dimensions, not just in music.
He loved to dream, and then work like
mad for however long it took to trans
form his challenging dreams into pristine

imaginative inven
tor and very mechanically talented. The
greater the challenge, the greater his zeal
and commitment for sticking with the
realities.

He was an

task until the job was well done.

He left

distinctive fingerprint everywhere.
Festival-goers can no doubt recall his
highly-refined home-made campsites,
that withstood even the worst rain and
this

wind storms. They were his own innova
tive designs constructed from materials
he had on the farm.

Curly was intensely passionate about
fishing. He made his own flies and lures
and knew exactly when, where, and how
to fish. He loved taking friends and fam
ily out, and frequently returned with
hundreds of keepers. Those were among
his most cherished times in life.
No mention of Curly Miller would ever
be complete without just recognition of
his radiant dynamo wife, Carole Anne
Rose. In 1985 she left her New Jersey life,
work as an AT&amp;T programmer /systems

analyst, and

a

former marriage, pursuing

the dream of raising organic herbs, veg
etables, and edible flowers in the South,

where the good climate, reasonably priced

land, and good water were abundant.
Turned out the farm she bought was nextdoor to Curly, who was fortuitously single

again. Shortly thereafter, they charmed
one another and their romance took off.
She's as dynamic and talented as Curly, in
her own unique ways. They made great
bookends, both in and out of music. She

very detail-oriented and he was very
imaginative. She is great at planning and
he was great at getting things done. They
both seemed always to have an endless
supply of energy, focus, patience with one
another, and good humor.
Curly and Carole Anne settled five miles
up a quiet dirt road and across a creek
or two near Kingston, Arkansas, in the
beautiful Ozark mountains of Madison
County, on the land she purchased adja
cent to Curly's. It had the best continu
ous water supply. They both loved living
in the Ozarks and happily shared duties
running their family business, Sweden
Creek Farm, raising organic Shiitake
is

mushrooms, herbs, vegetables, and edible

flowers. Carole Anne managed the office
side of the business. Curly controlled the

production process, and built and main
tained the equipment. They were might

ily assisted too. His sons Kerry and Silas,
and daughter Sara and her husband Ga
len, all shared responsibilities. They also
benefitted greatly from many dedicated

farm families, Adan and Hilda, children
Roberto/ Arcelia, their child, and many
other fine folks.
Curly applied the same kind of atten

inquisitive, tenacious problemsolving skills to his work as a mushroom

tive,

He
as he did with his music.
studied the weather relentlessly and di
rected controlled the mushroom process

farmer

so as to regulate the weekly
harvest. He developed and refined his
own process for raising Shiitake mush
rooms that enabled them to grow their

accordingly

family business, Sweden Creek Farms,
a major organic Shiitake mushroom
supplier. He determined how to control
the growth variables so he could manage

into

thousands and thousands

of

logs and de

liver the desired output each week, every

week of the year.
While Carole Anne and Curly were busy
looking after the farm and raising kids,
they still found time to develop their mu
sic. They sought out the oldest record
ings and sheet music of old fiddle tunes
that they could locate. They learned and
polished the tunes endlessly.
Early in their relationship, Carole Anne
suggested to Curly that she'd like to

�her guitar chops to the banjo.
Eventually with her idea and Curly's in

transfer

novative creativity, they came up with

a unique
solution that Carole Anne still
plays today. Basically, she clawhammers
an alternating bass pattern on a large-pot
skin-head six-string banjo, strung with
nylon strings and tuned similarly to a
guitar, but a step lower than standard.
The short thumb string, or "twanger" as

Curly called it, takes the highest-pitch
string and gets adjusted to suit whatever
key she plays in. The resulting big, bassy

banjo sound made an ideal rhythmic an
chor for Curly's challenging fiddle melo
dies, which wound their way through all
the usual fiddle keys, and all the flatted
keys

too.

That solid, sparse, and met
banjo accompaniment of Car

ronomic
ole Anne's applied to Curly's virtuostic
grasp of old raggy fiddle tunes evolved
into the very large and very recognizable

signature sound that would become The
Old 78's. (As they began to take this out
and share their music at dances, festivals,
and parties in the Northwest Arkansas
area,

people

frequently

commented

to

them that they sounded like old 78 RPM
records, hence their name.)

addition to the raggy repertory
Curly fiddled with Carole Anne's big
banjo style, they were both actively
learning the finger-picked classic banjo
In

style.

They fell in love with this style

largely through their association with
Clarke Buehling.
Curly arranged
many of these pieces from old sheet

music to play with Carole Anne. They
both laughed about the hours, hours,
and hours of practice time it took to
cultivate these pieces. If you're not ac
quainted with the classic banjo style,
you owe it to yourself to explore, find
it, and listen carefully.
Curly and Carole Anne managed always
to

steady stream of
festivals to come sit down

attract and inspire

musicians

at

a

with them, visit, and play. Although
the tunes were often very demanding
pieces pitched in flatted keys, or requir
ing great facility moving about high up
on the neck, or with highly unusual and
idiosyncratic chord progressions with
lots of parts, both Carole Anne and Curly

seemed

always

to

encourage

and

in

spire even the wariest of players to give
it a shot, even if they were out of their

comfort zone and sounding

somewhat

less than polished. Somehow, Curly and
Carole Anne both seemed to keep a very

positive, joyful, and playful attitude go
ing all the time. Curly was a dedicated

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

and patient teacher. He never seemed to
mind repetition and would happily play

troublesome parts over and over

for

peo

play them together with the folks
until they got it right.
Curly did a great job of using written
music and aural music skills in both
ple, or

learning and sharing his music.

Many

rags, Dixieland, and early
jazz pieces he played had more parts and
chord sequences that were too demand
of

the early

ing for most mortals to remember in a
casual festival jam setting. Curly was
always great about doing all he could to
help anyone who wanted to learn to play
those pieces. He taught lots of people to
He was
read and follow chord charts.
also patient about writing out new chord
charts if he didn't have them ready to

hand out.
I used
to think that written music had
little or no place in traditional music. If
we roll time back to the days before radio,
audio recorders, and mechanical record
ers such as player pianos, written music
takes on an entirely different meaning
than what I'd always considered. I've
also come to appreciate the value that
chord charts provide with some material
Thank you, Curly, for
in some settings.

opening my eyes

to all of

this.

and Ray bring to their sound,

especially

"Big Barry."
In the last several years, Curly became
increasingly interested in exploring the

of string band rags with
band,
early
jazz, and Dixieland. A
jug
number of us who shared his love for
that music, thanks to his patience, en

intersection

couragement, and leadership followed
into working out some of those
That group included
pieces together.

him

Curly and Carole Anne as the Old 78's,
with the Retro Ramblers, who are Brian
Schmiel, Edwin Wilson, Tolly Tollefson,
and me. We performed some of these
pieces at the Breaking Up Winter festi

val near Nashville, Tennessee. There are
some YouTube videos from that concert.
We also took some extra days after that
festival and recorded six of the pieces,
which will be released in the next few
months. We had hoped to share that

Festival of American Fiddle
of 2013 with Curly and
Carole Anne, but his health declined too

music

at the

Tunes

in July

quickly for that.

You can hear lots of great examples of
and Carole Anne playing their

Curly

fiddle /big banjo duets, classic and min
strel banjo pieces, as well as other col
laborations on YouTube. Simply search

Carole Anne and Curly were fixtures as
a dance band in their local dance scene.
They were always excited to learn your
new tunes, while also sharing the vir
tues of some new piece they'd figured
out and slipping it into their dances.
Curly was always happy to shave or add
enough beats to make a squirrely tune
fit the shape of a contra dance.
They

YouTube for "The Old 78's." You can
also read about them and their record
ings on their website at www.theold78s.
com.
Steve Greene wrote an excellent
feature article in 2007 for The Old-Time

ville Traditional Dance Society dance up
to May of this year, in spite of Curly's
rapidly declining: health.

overwhelming forward momentum. In
spite of the debilitating effects of the
unyielding colon cancer and treatment
programs he experienced, especially in

continued playing the monthly Fayette-

Since the late 1980s Curly and Carole
Anne have recorded three tapes and
five CDs. Their 2008 collaboration with
Clarke Buehling is entitled The Old 78's,
and among other things, features an im

pressive classic banjo rendering of "The
Russian Rag." In 2010 Carole Anne and
Curly teamed up with the fabulous tal
ents

and

friendships of Fayetteville,
musicians Ray and Melanie

Arkansas,
Palmer to explore more string band rags,
ragtime, and early jazz pieces predating
the 1930s, with Ray and Mel on banjo
mandolin and baritone sax, respective
ly. They captured some of this amazing
sound in their nationally acclaimed 2011
CD The Women
You really

need

Wear
to

No Clothes

At All.

check out what Mel

Herald (Vol. 10, No. 8) entitled, "The Old
78's and Shiitakes: Carole Anne Rose &amp;

Curly Miller."

Curly always maintained a serious
work ethic and upbeat attitude with

his last three and

a

half years, he never

really slowed down

or

stopped work

ing, fishing, playing challenging music,

learning new demanding music, play
ing for dances, teaching and perform
ing at music camps, and dreaming of

new possibilities. The last time I visit
ed Carole Anne and Curly at their farm
less than five weeks before he died, we
were up well after midnight. Long be
awoke the next day, Curly was
fore
already out on the tractor mowing the
pastures. He kept at his work duties all
I

day and we didn't begin to start up the
He
fun until his work was complete.
few
his
last
until
that
pattern
kept up
days here.

�Curly was
He always

a thoughtful and giving soul.
loved firing up the grill and

roasting veggies, fish from his expedi
tions, or some delectable hunk of meat.
It didn't seem to matter that his compro
mised digestive system was barely work
ing, he still was determined to cook ev

everyone else
could enjoy an incredible feast. It's easy

erything up so that at least

forget how challenging life can be for
some at times.
to

Curly

somehow

managed

always

to

His determination and

defy the odds.

I
don't at all
drive were unyielding.
mean to suggest that he was superhuman

without faults. It's just was always
dumbfounded by his ability to get more
or

I

done,

or to accomplish really challenging
feats with what seemed like relatively
little effort or trouble. He just didn't fuss
about the work required to get any job
done. Neither did Carole Anne. They

just chose to keep the love, smiles, music,
and good times flowing.
When I last spoke with Curly on the

eve of June 30, just a few days before
passed, he knew, and we all knew,
his time here was short. It was very im
portant to him that I relay his love and
gratitude to each of you, his family and
friends, for the lifetime of love and sup
port you all shared with him.
Curly is survived by his wife, Carole
Anne Rose, their son Silas Miller, his son
he

Kerry Miller, his daughter, Sara (Galen)
White, two grandsons, River Shane and
Rowan Benen White, his mother Roberta
Miller, two sisters, Sharon (Ted) Peters
and Barbara Miller; and scores of dear
pals everywhere.

to her new
She's
picked back up
reality admirably.
with Ray and Mel and they've already
played several of their old monthly
dances.
She's running the farm now
herself, along with the help of Sara,

Carole Anne

is

adjusting

their family, and farm families living
there. She's making the best of things,
isn't complaining, and still maintains
her joyously biting wit. It's not easy, but

she's never opted for easy.
Thank you Curly for sharing your
incredibly inspiring music, clever lan
guage, relentless determination, loving
spirit, and cheerful nature. They all ring
loudly and will always live on.

Rich Hartness

Charles Henry Faurot passed away Au
gust 25, 2013. Charlie was best known in
music circles for his classic recordings of

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

what

is

style of

now known as the Round Peak
old-time music.

Charlie was
grandfather,

devoted husband, father,

a

teacher,

and

coach. At

time of his retirement he was

a

the

Managing

Director of the American Stock Exchange.
In late 1950s, Charlie started recording ban
jo lessons from Yale classmate John Cohen.
to more than 50 years of recording
older musicians primarily from Southwest
Virginia, North Carolina, and Texas.

That led

His field recordings of Wade Ward, Kyle

Fred Cockerham, and George
Stoneman made up the first record devot

Creed,
ed to

clawhammer banjo. Two more vol

umes of clawhammer banjo followed. His
recordings of George Pegram made up
the first LP issued by Rounder Records.
Charlie's recordings (some made with
Richard Nevins) introduced many of us
Camp Creek Boys, Tommy Jarrell,
Fred Cockerham, and Oscar Jenkins, and
have become part of the canon of the mu
to the

sic of that area.

corded music by

Additionally,

Charlie re

Ball, Lena Hughes,
Earl Blair, Lewis Thomasson, Red Allen,
Ted Lundy, and Kenny Baker.
E. C.

A chance meeting with Texas fiddler
Bartow Riley at the Union Grove Fid
dler's Convention led Charlie to record
not only Bartow but many of the Solomon
and Thomasson families of Texas contest
fiddlers, as well as some small Texas con
tests in their entirety. Once retired, Charlie

Guy and his brother Pipp grew up in
Yonkers, New York, and spent their sum
mers on the ranch belonging to their
grandfather, V.H. "Hoyt" Porter, in Lovelady, Texas. In their teen years they put
together a band called The Roadrunners

young Diane Keaton as
singer. Diane Keaton eventu

that featured
the

lead

ally

left

cal

Hair,

a

the band

to

star in the

musi

when she was discovered by
Allen.
The brothers continued to
Woody
play the coffeehouse circuit up and down
the East Coast and

throughout the Mid

west from 1968 to 1983. They made two
albums and a few sineles.
In the early 1980s, Guy and Pipp, who
had inherited their grandparents' ranch
in Lovelady, decided to move to Texas
and refurbish the family homestead. Not
long after, Guy met and married Cathi
Stas from Wheeler and the couple was
blessed with a daughter, Dorcie.
The Gillette Brothers also refurbished
the historical Camp Street in Crockett
created a "listening room" out of
former pool hall and barbershop that
was built and owned by their grandfa
ther. Their new venue became known as
Camp Street Cafe &amp; Store. Together they
and
a

continued to entertain crowds at Camp
Street and across the nation with their
own brand of blues, cowboy ballads, and
folk songs. Their shows often included
vaudeville and old minstrel show com

fulfilled his promise to the Solomon fam
ily to issue some of their recordings. Thus
began Old Blue Records. Old Blue allowed

edy routines that featured the two play
ing anything from guitars, banjos, har

Sutphin and Riley Baugus, and The Stage
Hogs. It also allowed him to work with his

and were recipients of the Western Heri
tage Award for Best Traditional Western

him to issue recordings of old friends like
the Solomons as well as new friends like
the New North Carolina Ramblers, Kirk

sons, both banjo players, on the
production end of the music he
At the time of his death, Charlie
ing up a four-CD retrospective

recording/
loved.
was finish

for County
Records, including many of his classic re
cordings for that label as well as a number

previously unissued recordings.
Charlie Faurot's foresight to preserve
this music, and his generosity and pas
sion to share it, have had a major influ
ence on the old-time music revival.

of

Tom

Mylet

monicas, tambourines, and kazoos, to
which Guy Porter Gillette
the bones
was fantastic at.
The brothers continued to record as well,

CD of 2010 for their album Cowboy Minstrel
and Medicine Shoiv. The award was

among

many honors and praise for their preserva
tion of traditional cowboy music.
Guy Gillette had been battling a cancer
for the last year and

illness

succumbed

to that

at 5 am

on September 2. Camp
Street will never be the same without the

pure tenor voice of Guy, which blended

perfectly with Pipp's strong baritone.
Guy and Pipp's father Guy Gillette
passed away just two weeks earlier, on

August

19.

celebration of the life of Guy Porter
Gillette took place on September 10 at
Camp Street. It would have been Guy's
A

Guy Porter Gillette, son of Doris and
famed photographer Guy Gillette, and
brother of Pipp Gillette, with whom
he

performed and

Cafe

co-owned Camp Street

Store in Crockett, Texas, passed
on
Monday, Sept. 2, 2013.
away
&amp;

ti8th birthdav.

Penny Lynn Webb

(Excerpted with the author's permission
from County Life Magazine online)

�DITCH DVORAK, THEY WANT
"TURKEY IN THE STRAW":

A BRIEF HISTORY OF OLD-TIME FIDDLING IN MONTANA
By Aaron Parrett
they may have been preceded by some long-forgotten
French trader or trapper who happened to be musically in
clined, Pierre Cruzatte and George Gibson—
privates in Lew
is and Clark's Corps of Discovery in 1805— inaugurated the

Though

history of old-time fiddling in Montana. The one-eyed navigator and
translator Cruzatte is the better known of the two men, perhaps most
remembered for shooting Lewis in the rear on the return journey, myopically mistaking him for an elk. But the expedition's journals remind
us that the Corps enjoyed the performances of two fiddlers, and we
should remember that Gibson also played, though he is mentioned in
this capacity only once in the journals.
9, 1805, Corps member Ser
John
Ordway wrote that "in the
geant
evening the Capts. Revived the party
with a dram. They had a frolick fiddled
&amp; danced &amp; Sang untill late in the eve
ning." The same day, Captain Meriweth

On June

Lewis noted, "Cruzatte gave us some
music on the violin and the men passed

er

the evening dancing singing &amp;c and
were extremely cheerfull." On that day
the men of the Lewis and Clark expedi
tion were camped in the vicinity of the
Marias River, with a view of some moun

tains (probably

the

Highwoods)

to

the

south. These journal entries are the earli
est unequivocal references in the histori
cal record to

fiddling

in the

now the State of Montana.

region that

is

month previous, tire
had
camped on a point at the con
explorers
fluence of the Yellowstone and the Missouri
and enjoyed a similar celebration, as noted
by Lewis on April 26: "...we ordered a
dram to be issued to each person; this soon
A little more than

produced

a

the fiddle, and they spent the

eve

ning with much hilarity, singing &amp; dancing,
and seemed perfectly to forget their past
toils, as they appeared regardless of those to
come." Later, in the midst of their prepara
tions for the portage around tire Great Falls,
Ordway remarked on July 4, 1805, that "the
fiddle put in order and the party amused

themselves dancing

all

the

evening untill
jovil manner."

about 10 oClock in a Sivel &amp;
Musicologists have identified some 27 refer
ences in the journals to occasions on which
the fiddle was played, the majority of them
in Montana.
By and large, the men who made up the
Corps

were backwoods

folk, hardened

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

woodsmen drawn from

the periphery of
both socially and geo
graphically. Also important to remember
the United States

is

that

a

large percentage of the Corps of

Discovery were Metis people of mixed
European and American Indian or Cana
dian First Nations ancestry
including
Cruzatte, who was half French and half
Omaha Indian. As many were of French
heritage, they would also have been fa
miliar with tunes from a Gallic, rather
than primarily Scots-Irish, tradition.

Cruzatte's and Gibson's fiddling kept the
men of the Corps of Discovery in good
spirits as they struggled upriver through
terra incognita, but their music served an
additional, and perhaps more important,
ambassadorial purpose. The journals indi
cate that many of the occasions on which
the fiddle was played were encounters
with Indians, for whom music could have
medicine,

a spiritual power.
were eager to exchange their
the white travelers, and they
that lasted late into the night.
Unfortunately, none of the

The Indians

music with
held dances

journals en

mentions by name any of the tunes
they played, but as noted by Robert
tries

Flunt, who has written about the music
of the expedition, because of Cruzatte's
French heritage musicologists "assume
that many French Canadian folk tunes
of the era made up a considerable part
of his repertoire." Their repertoire might

therefore have included such tunes as
"Jolie Blonde" and "The Old French
Hornpipe," tunes that are still popular
today. Hunt also reconstructs a likely
repertoire based on the type of danc

ing the men were most likely to have

engaged

in.

Given that most of the re

from Kentucky and other
frontier regions, scholars have surmised
that when the journals mention dancing,
they most likely refer to a kind of buck
dancing. Quite likely the men would also
have performed more formal country
dancing, especially when called upon to
cruits hailed

share their medicine songs and demon
strate their dance forms to the Indians.

Howard Marshall,

an

old-time fiddler

and professor of archaeology and art his
tory at the University of Missouri, has
also investigated the likely repertoire of
Cruzatte and Gibson. As a result of his
research, he has recorded a CD called Fid
dle Tunes of the Lewis and Clark Era.

Many

identifies remain
the repertoires of old-time fid

of the tunes Marshall

active in

dlers today, such as "Fisher's Hornpipe,"
"Soldier's Joy," and "Leather Britches."

Because old-time fiddling was inaugu
rated in Montana at the relatively late
date of 1805, the development

of

a

dis

regional style in Montana has
lagged some decades perhaps as much
as a century
behind the development of
in
the
Eastern
regions from which
styles
the music arrived. It is still perhaps too
soon to speak of a distinctly Montana
style of fiddling, but we can identify
many of the strains that will be part of it.
Fiddler Mike Williams in Helena and
Bill Sevores in Missoula describe pres
ent-day old-time fiddling in Montana as
a fabric
a mish-mash of various
styles
of different strands contributed by differ
ent ethnic groups. Williams argues that,
unlike certain areas of the East, such as
North Carolina or New England, Mon
tinctive

distinctive fiddling style as
because
the
tunes and styles that are
yet
are
diverse and relatively
here
played
tana has no

recent imports from those older areas.
Sevores also speculates that the compar
atively small population of Montana has
inhibited the development of a distinct,
shared style.
That assessment is corroborated by the

memoirs of late-ninteenth-

and

early-

twentieth-century fiddlers. Bill Carlson,
for example, notes in Eighty Years of Rosin

�Floor Wax that he learned to play
from his father, who first learned Swed
ish tunes from his mother, but was then
influenced by the Texas cowboys with
whom he came into contact in the 1890s.

and

(Late-nineteenth-century cowboys found

that music had

a calming effect on their
herds: "Often," remembered one cowboy,
"have I taken my old fiddle at night when
on the trail, and while some of my com
panions would lead my horse around I
agitated the cat guts...") "Father learned
his dance fiddling from them," Carlson
writes, but expanded his repertoire from

playing with "Scotch, Irish, and English

settlers in the area." He writes that even

to

suit whatever crowd they

to be

for:

Germans

happened
performing
and Scandinavians wanted their waltzes
"fast

and

lively,"

Eastern

Europeans

wanted polkas, and Scandinavians were
also fond of schottisches. Canadians
preferred their tunes played at a faster
tempo, and the Irish and Scottish people

expected jigs and reels.
Unfortunately, the record of fiddling in
Montana between 1806, when the Lewis
and Clark

expedition left the region on
their return trip home, and the arrival of
the first gold seekers in the late 1850s and
early 1860s is lamentably scant. Never
theless, we can assume that the fur trad
ers heading upriver whom the Lewis and
Clark expedition encountered on the re
turn journey had men like Cruzatte and
Gibson among their ranks, who passed
their idle hours by playing the fiddle.

As the fur trade gave way to the gold
what passed for civilization

rushes,
gained

foothold, in the form of the small
villages
gulches whose dominant
features were taverns and dance halls.
Those who wrote about Virginia City
a

in the

and Bannack,

or

later Butte and Helena,

repeatedly described (perhaps somewhat

romantically) wild, unruly frontier towns
in which the incessant song of the fiddle
competed with whizzing bullets. Every
street was lined with saloons, and every
saloon had a dance band. Unfortunately,
the names of the people who provided
the music at such venues, and the tunes
they played, were facts the writers sel
dom considered worthy of note. The his
torical record shows that the early "dance
bands" were entirely ad hoc affairs two
fiddlers might be accompanied by only a
flute or a drum, for example. And while
we seldom find any mention of the spe-

Library

of

Congress,

Prints

and

Photographs

Division

tually "people from nearly every state in
the Union" settled in his native McCone
County, each group bringing with them
a particular
fiddling style. Carlson says
that the hallmark of good dance fiddlers
in the days before radio was that they

could play

1850s lithography by Britton &amp; Rey.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�cific tunes the early settlers danced to, we
encounter descriptions of the sorts of

do

dances they had. Similarly, though the
records seldom provide the names of
the fiddlers who graced the stages and
saloons at Bannack, Virginia City, Butte,
or Helena, we can get a clear sense of the
environments such musicians performed
in and the personalities of those with

whom they consorted.

Two of the early fortune hunters in the

mining camps of Montana were the Stu
Granville and James who
art brothers
their early

journal during
years
Montana. Both men were closely ac
quainted with two of the first fiddlers
to be mentioned by name after Cruzatte
and Gibson. The entry James wrote on
January 1, 1862, notes that even though
a blizzard was raging outside,
they held
a dance in John Grant's cabin at Grantsville, and that "the music for these dances
was two violins; and the dance most pop
ular was the old-fashioned quadrille."
Humble log cabins would have made for
cozy dance quarters. A similar account
described one of the earliest events to
kept

a

in

few years later in Butte: on
Christmas Day in 1866, "The first dance
take place

a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

was held in the cabin of Dr. Olman. Fifty
men, women and children attended and
two fiddlers furnished the music."
A month later, Stuart wrote that the
miners exhausted themselves in danc
ing again: "Danced last night. Oh! Joy. It
is not often that we have a fiddler, and
when we do have one, we try to keep
him in practice by having a dance ev
ery evening."

On July 23, 1862,

an

ap

parently new fiddler appeared, "a fine
violin player accompanied by his hand
some, seventeen year old wife. His name
is J.B. Caven." Stuart offers some hint
that Caven may have had some classical
training, since he writes that "we have
the Cavens over often and enjoy the so
ciety of an intellectual white woman and
good music." These entries are made by
James, but a few months later, Granville
takes up the pen again, and echoes his
brother on November 23: "There were
two good fiddlers in camp, "Buz" Caven
and Lou

P.

Smith..."

provides a picture of the sorts of dances
held in the taverns of Bannack and Vir
ginia City around the same time that the
Stuarts were in the Deer Lodge Valley.

"In every frequented street," Dimsdale
writes, "public gambling houses with
open doors and loud music are resorted
to." As quickly as the hopeful miners
could erect a few crude shacks, "dance-

houses sprung up as if by enchantment,"
echoed Nathaniel Pitt Langford, "and
the crack of the revolver was often heard

above the merry notes of the violin."
By all accounts, the mining camps were
raucous places lined with taverns, dance

and the
and gambling parlors
fiddle usually provided the soundtrack.

halls,
In

Vigilante Days and Ways, Nathaniel Pitt

Langford wrote:
The number of drinking

saloons

was greatly

ins gave way to

rough-and-tumble gold

rush villages such as Virginia City and
Bannack. A contemporary of the Stuarts

and gambling

excess of stores

and private dwellings, and to nearly all
of these was attached that most important

attraction of

a

mining town, the hurdy-

of the violin which
gurdy.
struck the ear upon entering the street,
was never lost while passing through it,
and at many of the saloons the evidence
The

Before long, isolated enclaves of log cab

in

sound

of the bacchanal

orgies

which were

in

�progress inside was often apparent in the
eagerness exhibited by the crowd which

surrounded the building without.

Dimsdale
taverns
havens:

as
a

described

all-purpose

these

frontier

entertainment

miner could drink, gamble,

choose a "hurdy-gurdy girl" with
whom to step through a dance called
by a "prompter" shouting, "promenade,
eight," or "all hands round." Dimsdale
does not identify the instruments in the
or

"orchestra," but since he is describing a
square or contra dance, the fiddle was
probably a key instrument. Moreover,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

added, "an Irish tune or
generally finishes the set."

he

a

horn-pipe

Albert D. Richardson's lively account of
traveling across the West, published a year
later in 1867, also gives a vivid description
of the musical environment of the "hurdygurdy" houses in Virginia City, complete

with an oft-reproduced lithograph depict
ing
and

dance band composed of two horns

a

fiddle. The festivities Richardson
describes commenced at nine in the eve
a

ning and continued until daylight, "in
terrupted only by two fights." The scene

depicted in the accompanying lithograph

matches

precisely

snapshot

of the interior

Richardson's

literary

of the bar:

"At

one end of the long hall, a well-stocked
bar, and a monte bank in full blast; at the
other, a platform occupied by three mu
sicians; between, many lookers-on, with

cigars and meerschaums."
A miner and resident of Bannack of the
same era, Robert Kirkpatrick, recalled in
his Reminiscences "hurdy gurdy houses
runing [sic] in full blast until nearly day
light Monday morning with their wide
doors on the ground floor wide open all a
day and night, with string band and clar-

�ionet [sic] that could be heard the whole
length of town." Kirkpatrick also alludes
to the typically inebriated state in which
the fiddlers performed: "a string band
of first and second violins and bass Viol
cost from forty to $60.00 a night, and the
musicians often got so drunk they could
hardly keep their seats."

Jean Davis reports that the early commu
nities such as Bannack established schools
and funded their teachers' salaries with
"benefit dances held in a home or in a sa
loon." As evidence, Davis cites a letter in
the Helena Weekly Herald from December
18th, 1874, which details the fundraising

case, for the community
of Clancy: "last but not least, on the list of
improvements of the burg is the 'School
House on the Hill' which is a credit to the
builders and an honor to the town. For
the furnishing of the same everybody and

method,

in this

his wife, the bachelor and the sweetheart,
and his or her friends, are going to have a
grand ball on the 22nd as you have already

had due notice. One of our fellow towns
men,

S. S.

Harvey, proposes to contribute

his share toward the ball by tendering the
use of his stable and sheds, to any of you
or any other man who comes
party with a team."

Helenaites,
to the

the open range gave way to rural
ranch towns and railroad hubs in east
ern Montana, those places, like the min
ing towns before them, relied on fiddle
music and dancing as their main source
of entertainment. One such event held at
Maiden in the Little Rockies in the 1880s
involved the infamous Western bad man
As

seems that the "Kid"
had a brother named Loney Curry who,
in addition to being a fiddler, had fallen
in love with the foster daughter of Pike
Landusky, who had forbidden the young
woman from seeing a man of "such un
"Kid"

Curry.

It

savory reputation." The feud came to a
a Christmas celebration in 1884, a
community dance that the Kalispell Times
later described as "a real old frontier jam
boree." Another of the Curry brothers,
Johnny, held the dance at his new barn,
with the music provided by Loney Curry,
"a fiddler of no mean ability." The danc
ing went on for two days and nights, at
the climax of which Kid Curry and Pike
Landusky had their famous showdown,
which left Landusky dead and Curry's
name inscribed in the pantheon of igno
minious Western outlaws.
head at

This was not the first time a fiddler had
been observed in the vicinity of typical Old
West violence: a year earlier in 1883, accord

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

ing to Davis, there was a fiddler named Pro
fessor Glab in the town of Junction "who

was employed in a saloon as an orchestra
leader." The bully of the town entered the
saloon with a rifle and a pistol and pressed
everyone in the room to share a drink with
him. Professor Glab declined, and "the town
terror shot a hole in his hat." The fiddler
took his drink, but then secreted himself in
a closet near the exit with a borrowed shot
gun. When the miscreant came past, "[the
fiddler] let him have both barrels at once,"
and a doctor later spent the evening remov
ing birdshot from the bully's back.

writers

in

the

Though early
mining
camps such as Stuart and Langford of
fered some description of the kinds of
steps that were danced at the dances

attended the quadrille, the Vir
ginia reel, waltzes, and so on it is not
until we encounter the narrative history
of Con Price in his 1945 memoir, Memo
they

ries of Old Montana,

that we get any in

dication of the specific tunes that were
played by fiddlers in nineteenth-century
Montana. Price was born in 1869 in Iowa,
and had come to Montana as a cowboy in
the 1880s. The camp cook for one of the
cowboy outfits he worked with in 1887
played the banjo and harmonica, Price
reports, "and had a kind of frame fixed
around his head so he could play both
at once." Price reveals that the cook only
knew "two or three tunes," but that was
enough to furnish the music at the danc
es.

According

"Turkey

in the

lings, and

a

to

Price, the cook played

Straw, Hell Among the Year

waltz

or

two."

On July 12, 1898, the Butte Miner ran an

article about a raucous party that had oc
curred at one of the taverns on the flat,

which inspired someone to write the
ballad "The Hopheads' Ball." The bal
lad describes how "Three fiddlers from
the red light
and some junkie with a
flute
Were hired to play such music
like ne'er before was played in Butte."
The ballad does not identify any of the
specific tunes played, nor the fiddlers,
but it does mention "Waltzes, mazurkas,
two-steps
They never passed one by;
There ne'er was dance invented
That
the hopheads didn't try.
The fiddlers
Like they didn't give a
kept on fiddling
When one of them was tiring,
dang;
He just took another 'bang.'"
John Barrows chronicled such events in

Musselshell Valley in the 1880s, and
was one of the few witnesses to notice
the toll such marathon sessions must
the

have exacted on the musicians: "the fid

grew very mellow
hours advanced, but a 'pleas
ant time was enjoyed by all.'" Another
writer recounts the burden imposed on
the fiddler: "These frolics began early
and lasted until the wee hours, and the
fiddler, growing weary, often fell asleep
and whittled away on the same tune
until someone woke him and started
him off on a new one." He adds that fre
quently more men were in attendance
at the dances than women, and that "it
was sometimes necessary to tie a white
kerchief around a gentleman's arm, thus
dler and his music
as

the

marking him as a 'lady' for that set." Bill
Carlson also describes this expedient in
his memoir and armchair history of oldtime fiddling, Eighty Years of Rosin Dust
At one particular dance
he recalls as having been held "in about
1905 or 1906," the men outnumbered the
women eighty to three. Carlson writes
that "some of the men 'Heifered' them
selves by tying handkerchiefs on their
arms, and took the part of ladies."
and Floor Wax.

Because

it is so

lightweight and portable,
instru

the fiddle tended to be the natural

ment of choice for the itinerant pioneer
and this would have been especially true
before the 1900s when other stringed in

struments including the guitar increased in
In her memoir Homestead on the
Kootenai, Jacoba Boothman Brad describes
an early-twentieth-century
tramp who
traveled through on his way to Kalispell,
and whose "passport was a violin from
which he drew the most lovely music....
popularity.

played for us as he sat on the porch, his
foot tapping time to the music."
Fiddling was often a key ingredient of
church functions and more genteel social
affairs as well. George A. Bruffey wrote
in his memoir of life in the Sun River Val
ley at Fort Shaw in the 1870s that "we
had a fine celebration on July Fourth,
he

1876. A general

invitation was extended.

All were there. A dance floor was laid.
Some of the 'good' ones objected to this.
Some held it would not do to allow any
fiddling. There were others who were
'in for it.'... some danced who had never
danced before or since."
The initial wave of immigrants to Mon
tana from the East was composed largely
of single men
many of them disgrun
tled soldiers or refugees from the failed
and so the early mining
camps were relatively free from moral re
formers. But the wagon trains that moved
westward on the Oregon Trail were fam
ily affairs, and as ranchers and cattlemen

Confederacy

�moved into the valleys of Montana, so did
strongly religious settlers, who sometimes
objected to dancing. Though the moralists
might have been vocally critical, they sel
dom succeeded in stamping out the devil's
music. Dances remained the most popu
lar version of frontier and rural entertain
ment in Montana for over half a century.
It may also be the case that unremarkable,

old-fashioned racial
part in the moralists'

prejudice played a
repugnance for such

entertainment forms. As Joseph Kinsey
Howard observes in Montana, High Wide
and Handsome, at dances in the nineteenth
century, "musicians frequently were the
half-breeds, famous fiddlers." The less of
fensive and historically more accurate term

for "half-breed" is Metis, and no history of
fiddling in Montana would be complete

without an account of the Metis.

Although the Metis

are

primarily associ

ated with the Red River region in Mani
toba, Canada, the Metis fiddle tradition

thrives in Saskatchewan and Alberta as
well. Though Canada officially recog
nized the Metis in 1982, the estimated
50,000 Metis in the US, many of whom
live in Montana and the Dakotas, have yet
to be granted official government recog
nition. During the 1920s and 1930s, hun
dreds of Metis lived on Hill 57 outside of
Great Falls, and on the outskirts of other
Montana towns. By the year 2000, there
were over four thousand Metis enrolled
as Chippewa-Cree. As a result, the Metis

fiddling tradition continues in Montana,
though its most well-known practitioners
(in the US) are associated with the Turtle
Mountain region of North Dakota.
As noted earlier, one of the first two
known fiddlers in Montana, Pierre Cruzatte, was Metis, and given the profound
significance of fiddling in Metis culture,
Howard is no doubt accurate in ascribing
much of the music provided in the early
days of Montana history to Metis fid
dlers. John Grant, with whom the Stuart
brothers wintered in the Deer Lodge Val
ley in 1862 was Metis, for example, and
in addition to Caven and Smith, the Stu
arts would likely have been acquainted
with Metis fiddlers in the early days in
the Montana territory.
The term "Metis" comes from French,
and means literally "mixed." The Metis

emerged sometime in the eighteenth cen
tury as a distinct people in the Red River
area of Manitoba,

Canada

the result of

intermarriage between the French settlers
moving westward across Canada and the
indigenous tribes they encountered. Af

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

ter

several doomed attempts

at

establish

ing an independent nation in the second
half of the nineteenth century, the Metis

endured through the twentieth century
as a landless people with a past of which
history has remained largely ignorant. In
the nineteenth century, some of the Metis
followed the dwindling bison herds from
the Red River Settlement into the Milk
River drainage, and then later into the
Judith Basin of Central Montana.

Metis fiddling has been described as "a
synthesis of Scottish, Irish, French, and
Indian origins." In her liner notes to the
CD Native and Metis Fiddling

in

Manitoba,

Anne Lederman explains that the vast
majority of Metis tunes deviate signifi

cantly from the typical 32- or 64-bar form
familiar in many other kinds of old-time
fiddling, either because they have phras

unusual length (3 or 7 beats), or be
cause the fiddlers choose to elaborate cer
tain phrases. In this respect, Metis tunes
resemble crooked Appalachian tunes.
Scholar Nicholas Vrooman explains that
the unusual phrase length in Metis fid
dling stems from its close alignment with
an Indian drumming and vocal tradition
wherein the fiddle duplicates a melody
that follows a vocal line and a rhythm
that follows the beat of a hand drum.
In any case, the Metis style of fiddling,
es of

like

its

is
counterparts,
dance tradition,
and the informal Metis anthem "The Red
River Jig" is both the name of a particu
lar tune as well as a style of dancing that
draws on "elements of Native dancing
as well as the jigs and reels of the French
and Scots." Metis fiddling also shares
affinities with its Appalachian or Mid
western old-time cousins with respect
to its use of a variety of tunings, such
as ADAE, or AEAC#, in addition to the
standard GDAE. Harrison remarks that
traditionally Metis fiddlers "were said
to tune their fiddles to the 'cry of the
loon and the bellow of a rutting moose.'"
As Whiddon notes, Metis fiddlers also
employ double-stops, slides and synco

Appalachian
closely connected to

a

pated accents, "practices adopted from
American fiddling." Metis fiddlers typi
cally hail from rural and impoverished
regions, and often play their music on

handmade instruments.

As in other kinds of old-time fiddling,
Metis tunes are passed from one fiddler to
next like messages, and tend to take on in
some small way the identity of each suc
cessive fiddler. One of the best known Me
tis

fiddlers, "Teddy Boy" Houle, learned

�watching his stepfather and uncles
Another one of the most famous
play.
Metis fiddlers in Montana history is Mary
Trotchie (1911-1982), who in 1969 won
first place in the women's division at the
National Fiddle Contest at Weiser, Idaho.
Like other fiddlers in the tradition, she
learned from older family members who
played her father and uncles. She also
cited Metis fiddlers Andy Dejarlis and
Ned Landry as important influences. At
present, members of the Fox family from
the Fort Belknap reservation (parents
by

James and Krystal, son Vince, and daugh
ter Jamie) are among the most active pro
ponents of Metis fiddling in Montana.
In the

definitive historical work written

on the Metis, Strange Empire, Joseph Kinsey Floward refers to the heritage of Me

describes the wedding
fiddling
of the charismatic
nineteenth-century
leader of the Metis, Louis Riel:
After some of the feast had been con
as he

tis

dancing began, with a Me
fiddler supplying the music-- the

sumed
tis

the

Red River jig, the "pair o' Fours," the
"Reel o' Cats," and traditional French

steps centuries

old.

Save for intervals

for more eating and drinking the danc
ing continued all night and sometimes

folloiving day. ...the youngest
and most enthusiastic leaped high into
the air and executed intricate figures;
all of the

Metis braves pounded their heels on
the floor and shouted "Ho! Ho!", signal
the

for the ride through
"Hiah! Hiahl", the

Plains Indians.

the buffalo herd, or
universal alert of the

Through all the clamor

the mad cry of the fiddle knifed,
up the tempo of the dance. The

stepping
solemn-

faced Metis babies, silent and unafraid,
gazed at the huge shifting shadows on
the walls which chased each other faster
and faster as the maniac fiddle sobbed
and shrieked.

The

tunes that Howard

tunes that continue

to be

mentions

are

played today

by contemporary Metis fiddlers, such as
Jimmie LaRocque in the Turtle Mountain

area of North Dakota, Johnny Arcand in
Saskatchewan, and Jamie and Vince Fox

whom studied with
LaRocque and Arcand.
Incidentally, Howard also relates an an
ecdote about a Metis fiddler in the late
nineteenth century accused of stealing
horses by Granville Stuart and his band
of vigilantes, known popularly as "Stu
of Montana, both of

art's Stranglers." Apparently the young
fiddler was "was forced to play all eve

ning

for the

entertainment of the Stran

glers and coolly hanged

the next day."

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Later one of the Stranglers defended
their actions by pointing out that "his be
ing

a

fiddler hadn't nothing
a horse thief."

to do

with

his being

of Metis fiddling culture
Montana literature as well.
The protagonist of Montana writer Peter
Bowen's Gabriel Du Pre novels, for ex
ample, is part Metis and plays the fiddle.
The main character in the Metis writer
D'Arcy McNickle's novel The Surrounded
(1936), Archilde Leon, is also of mixed

The celebration

thrives

in

(half Spanish, half Flathead)
and occasionally makes money playing
fiddle in a traveling band.
Through the nineteenth century and
up through the first part of the twenti
eth century, Metis fiddling, like other

ancestry

culturally distinct styles of old-time fid
dling, could have been identified by its
particular repertoire of tunes. But with
the advent of radio and cheap portable

phonographs in the 1920s and 1930s,
fiddlers in various traditions suddenly

gained access to other repertoires, which
resulted in a great deal of crossover.
Mary Trotchie, for example, claimed to

have learned her trademark tune "Fog
gy Valley" from listening to KOBB radio
(out of Great Falls) in the 1930s. Fiddlers

various traditions adopted contempo
rary popular songs from Tin Pan Alley

younger generations motion pictures,
fewer young
radio, and then television

people were adopting the pastime.
By the 1960s, concern had reached a
critical mass among the elder fiddlers,
many of whom had been born in the late

nineteenth century. In 1963, a group of
concerned fiddle aficionados started the
Montana Old-Time Fiddlers Association.
They were inspired by the foundation of

national organization in 1953, which
began sponsoring the Grand National
Oldtime Fiddle Championships at Weis
that same year. To coincide
er, Idaho,
with the 1964 Territorial Centennial cel
ebrations in Montana, the Old-Time Fid
a

dlers published a catalogue of over 100
fiddlers and accompanists in the state,
Fiddlers Book.
Comes

Broadway.

Today one is as likely to

hear "I'm Always Chasing Rainbows"
or "The Good Old Summertime" played

by an elder fiddler

at

an

old-time fid

dler's jamboree as "Arkansas Traveler"
or "Leather Britches."
The programming of Montana's earli
est radio stations reflected the popularity
of old-time fiddling. According to Mary
Murphy, author of Mining Cultures: Men,
Women, and Leisure in Butte, 1914-1941, tire
conventional wisdom at KGIR in Butte was
"Ditch Dvorak. They want 'Turkey in the

Unfortunately, old-time fiddling
enjoyed only a brief tenure on tire airwaves
before it was drowned out by kilowatt af
ter kilowatt of popular and country and
Western music. In the meantime, old-time
fiddling receded and began to disappear.
Straw.'"

Though

old-time

in the more rural

fiddling

lingered

areas of the state as

a

still-viable source of music for dances, it
dwindled so in general popularity that
at the midpoint of the twentieth century
it seemed in danger of dying out. Many
old-time fiddlers in the '40s and '50s ex
pressed concern for the vanishing style.

With more accessible forms of entertain

ment competing for the attention of the

Montana

dlers--representing

the

Old-Time Fid
fiddler of by

gone days. These older boys that came
with their parents in the covered wag
ons were the ones that brought the

fiddle, banjo, guitar and accordion to
this wide-open country. The "young
sprouts" that have grown up and were
never

quite able

to

close

their minds

only entertainment they knew
when the were young are the ones that
to

are

in

or

the

in

the

responsible for the fiddlers that are
existence today.

The centennial
for the

fiddlers

to

provided an occasion
align themselves. As

Johnson and many of the other fiddlers

quoted

in

the

booklet

attested,

their

direct ancestors had made the journey
cross country in the several decades af
ter Lewis and Clark, and like those first
Europeans to travel through Montana,
they carried their fiddles with them.

hundred years later there are sons,
grandsons and granddaughters who
had a desire to continue along the same
"A

road of family enjoyments," Johnson
writes, "to gather together and relive the
days of the dusty trails their forefathers
had traveled, and enjoy the clean funmaking entertainment that even brings
many friends and families together to
day." Like many fiddlers who helped
found the Old-Time Fiddlers Associa
tion in 1964, Johnson, born in 1893, was
the child of immigrants from the Mid
west
in his case, Lindberg, Kansas.
Other founding members of the OldTime Fiddlers Association included Jim
Ring, Dave Baylor, Alfred Olson, and
Hazel Bradley. Ring recalls that "in the
year before the centennial, or 1963, Mr.
L. T. Jolmson went to Weiser, Idaho to
the National Fiddlers' Contest and came

�Fiddler Jamie Fox

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

back with the idea of having a National
Contest here, and starting an organiza
tion. The first meeting was held at his
place." Ring, a fiddler himself, was born
in Tecumseh, Nebraska, in 1895 and had

picked up the fiddle

at age ten. To

coordi

nate their fledgling organization with the

approaching centennial celebrations, the
Veterans of Foreign Wars sponsored Ring
and Johnson "for a trip around the state
to organize the 'lavnut.'"
By 'layout/ Ring referred to the division
of the state into various regions, each of
which could sponsor local hoedowns
and jamborees, and then send represen
tatives to the annual contest held by the

state organization in Missoula (and later
Poison). For nearly two months Ring
and Johnson traveled around Montana,
talking to local fiddlers and describing
their vision of an organization that would
in

sponsor a national contest in 1964 under
the aegis of the Centennial Celebration.
"So began the Montana Fiddlers," writes
Maxine Ness in her informal history of
the

organization published

in 1976.

Though many locales around the state
had held fiddling contests prior to 1964,
none had been officially sanctioned by a
national organization. The state contest
that first year was divided into two cat
egories; Pat Colyer won the division for
fiddlers under 65 years of age, and Mark
Turnquist won in the over-65 category.
The National Contest sponsored in con
junction with the Territorial Centennial
was won by Byron Berline, who was al
ready making a name for himself in bluegrass and swing circles and was in high

demand

as

a

session musician.

Fiddlers organization
was thus off and running. In 1965, Jimmy
Widner won the under-65 division of the
state contest, and Jim Ring won the senior
division. Jimmy Widner had established
The

Montana

himself

as a legendary figure in the late
'50s and early '60s with the Snake River
Outlaws, a band that traveled extensive
ly around the West and played a smooth

blend

of

old-time with Western coun

try swing and a dash of bluegrass. Tom
Brown's biography, Fiddliri Around the
West, relates the adventures of Jim Wid
ner, covering his tenure in both the Snake
River Outlaws and the Western Gospel
Messengers. Widner was a great influ
ence on many of the present-day genera
tion of bluegrass and old-time fiddlers in
the Missoula area and in the Bitterroot
Valley, where he has made his home for

the last 30 years. He is cited in discographies as one of the definitive sources for

�such tunes as "East Tennessee Blues" and
"The Bitterroot Valley Waltz."
The Montana Old-Time Fiddlers Asso
ciation continued to grow in the 1970s,
and a decade after their inauguration,
representative fiddlers from the vari
ous regions of the state entertained the

crowd

at the

1974 World's Fair in

Spo

kane, Washington. A year later, a registry
of fiddlers called Montana Fiddlers listed

many younger members alongside the
of the older founding members;
the organization was succeeding in its
mission to ensure the preservation of the
tradition. By 1989 the Montana Fiddlers
registry (now called Montana Fiddlers
ranks

Hall of Fame) had grown from a 32-page
booklet in 1975 to almost 200 pages, di
vided into sections for each of the state's

eight regions.

Today, the Montana Fiddlers continue

thrive, although two of the eight re
gions happen currently to be inactive
because of low membership. (Those
regions, five and seven, encompass the
extreme eastern quarter of the state and
are characterized by small populations
and extreme distances between fid
to

dlers.) The organization is otherwise vi
brant and active in sponsoring various
contests and the annual Fiddle Camp
Monarch, Montana, which each year
features world-class instruction from
such fiddlers as Brad Leftwich, Alice
Gerrard, Geoff Seitz, Bobby Hicks, Stu
art Williams, and Brendan Bulger.
in

Even in the nineteenth and early twenti
eth centuries,

when the old-time fiddling

Montana was
cal entertainment
of

a

main source of musi
it was neverthe

there,

a peripheral
phenomenon because
Montana itself was at the periphery of the
country. And though now old-time fid

less

dling has been again relegated to the mu
sical margins of the state neglected by
many in favor of bluegrass, or the flashier

contest style it endures as the original
"alternative country" music amid a pleth
ora of derivative or competing forms.
While many fiddlers in the old-time tradi
tion would agree that even two hundred
years of fiddling in Montana has not been
long enough to result in a definitive style
specific to the state, fiddlers such as Mike
Williams, the Fox Family, and Bill Sevores
are contributing to what may someday
be known to fiddlers nationwide as the
"Montana sound." (g
The text of this article with full citations
and notes can be found at oldtimeherald.org.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Howard Joines;

painting

by TJ

Worthington

�HOWARD JOINES:

MOUNTAIN FIDDLER IN CHANGING TIMES
By TJ Worthington

recently with Richard An
drews, an older man from these

Talking
mountains,

I

said, "Tell me some

Sparta,

some
Barbershop,

tence inspired this article, to share

NC

thing about Howard Joines." Howard,
who lived from 1908 to 1981, was the
master fiddler of his time in Alleghany
County, North Carolina. Richard looked
within for a few seconds and came back
saying, "When both his feet get to going,
you're going to hear some music."
This told me that when the music was
generating it took both his feet to beat time
it became a dance. Richard's one sen

Kermit

Pruitt,

Kermit's

thing about a fiddler who was known by
few non-fiddlers outside his home coun
ty and the surrounding area. I knew and
continue to know a lot of his kin, the Pine
Swamp Joineses and the Holbrooks of
Alleghany County, many of them musi
cians, but I've learned most about How

leghany County. There are pictures of
Junior's first bluegrass band, the Little
River Boys, and of country

singer Del

Reeves and fiddlers Joe Caudill and Art
Wooten. These are names everyone in
the county

above

a

certain age remem

bers with enthusiastic smiles.
a
web
Lucas
Pasley has created
site about the musicians of Alleghany

site.google.com site
It
includes
re
tradmusicalleghany/).
County

(http:

cordings and pictures of Howard Joines,
Junior Maxwell, Art Wooten, Clif Evans,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

courtesy

neighbor and distant cousin Junior Max
well (1922-2009) bluegrass musicians
whose beginnings were in old-time.
There is a small photo of Howard
Joines in Kevin Donleavy's book Strings
of Life. Another picture of him can be
found at Kermit's Barber Shop across
from the Courthouse on Main Street
in Sparta, North Carolina. The picture
shows Howard with Edd Atwood and
Clif Evans. Kermit Pruitt played bass
with Junior Maxwell's Green Mountain
Boys for a time. He has covered the walls
of his barbershop with photographs,
posters, and articles about music in Al

of

ard from his son Richard Joines, and his

Edd Atwood,

and others

Howard Joines, and Clifton Evans

mentioned

in this article.

Lu

fiddler and multi-in
strumentalist with deep musical roots in
cas is an old-time

the county. His great-uncle Guy Brooks
was the fiddler with the Red Fox Chasers,
the first band from Alleghany County to

make records. One of the Red Fox Chas
ers' 78s is a skit of 1920s slapstick comedy
in which the band members pretend to
be drunk on moonsfiine whiskey. Guy
Brooks was a Regular Baptist preacher as
fiddler, and when the members
moved over
the line into Wilkes County.

well

as a

of his church put him out he

write, I'm listening to music Lucas
Pasley transferred from reel-to-reel tapes
given to him to by Clif Evans' daugh
ter three or four years ago. Clif's tapes
opened a treasure chest. He knew all the
As

I

musicians

in

Alleghany County, and

all

through the '50s and '60s he went around
recording them, often backing them up
on rhythm guitar.

Clif

Evans

picked

rhythm

guitar

in

Howard's band. (Howard's other gui

tarist was Roy Martin. I've heard over
the years what a good picker Roy Mar
tin was. He was especially liked by mu
sicians for his flawless rhythm.) Until
these reels of Clif's surfaced, very few

recordings of Howard were known.
Among the previously-available record
ings are a couple of tunes he played
with old-time pianist Haywood Blevins,
which can be heard on the CD issued by
the Field Recorders' Collective.
The reels include a recording of How
ard playing "Sally Goodin," with Clif
Evans keeping rhythm for him on gui
tar, old-time style. It sets me in motion
sitting down. Howard's son Richard
said of Howard playing "Sally Goo
din," "He played

it as

good

as

anybody

ever heard play it." Richard was not
bragging; it was dispassionate observa
tion. He does talk about Howard some
times in a proud tone of voice, though
I

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

far from

haughty, because he respected

him so much as a fiddler and as a man.
Howard's kids loved their daddy, ap
preciated him for who he was. Rich
ard's sister Carol Holcomb is also a
and played guitar in 1988
with Alice Gerrard (fiddle), Enoch Ru
therford (banjo), and Dale Morris (bass)
as the Gold Hill Band on their Heritage
Records album Old Cap'n Rabbit. It has
been out of print for several years, and
may yet return to print.

musician,

When Howard Joines was eighteen years
old, he took a job helping to dig Roaring
Gap Lake "at 25 or 50 cents an hour." With
money from that job he bought himself a
fifty-dollar fiddle from the Montgomery
Ward catalog. The Nicola Amati copy was
the same

his first "real" fiddle. Around

age, according to Richard, Howard went
to Florida, where he played fiddle with
Red Gay's Brown Jug Fiddling band. (He
named one of his own bands at home the
Little Brown Jug Fiddlers.)

a fiddler
who liked to
new sounds. The dance band
experience in Florida likely opened his
young musical mind to new ways of
playing the old songs, even before the

Howard was

explore

advent

of

bluegrass.

In his

fiddling

I

can

hear him searching for new ways to hear
notes. When he played "Cluck Old Hen"
and "Chicken Reel," Howard made the

chicken notes sound like the hen was in
the room.
a

(In my

small hen on

a

portrait of him, I put
roost singing her note

into his left ear.) He played some country
songs as fiddle tunes. Like other moun
tain musicians of his generation,
wanted to play every kind of song.
In
is

he

this part of the mountains, bluegrass

often dance music, different from the

bluegrass that would be played for a sitdown audience in Nashville. Many mu
sicians of Howard's, Art's, and Junior's
generation preferred to play for dancers.
Howard's band was a square-dance band,
and played for dances on weekends.
He also won fiddler's convention tro
phies and ribbons galore. In the record

ings, he plays "Buffalo Gals Won't You
Come Out Tonight" solo, wide open. He
kept very strong rhythm with his fid
dling, while at the same time using long

strokes of the bow to bring the fullness of
the notes' beauty to the front. Howard's
fiddle was direct, no flourishes, like a

mountain singer. Richard Joines, remem
bering his father's fiddling, described it
in spontaneous poetry.

�Art Wooten; painting by TJ Worthington

He bears down on

Gets

Doesn't just tickle

the time that

it.

Doesn't take short strokes.
Keeps the bow going.

Howard and Art Wooten (1906-1986)
were lifelong friends. In the early and
mid-1 930s they were rising young fid
dlers

to

be

reckoned

in early middle age around
bluegrass fired up the moun
tains. In the '40s and early '50s, bluegrass
bands played all up and down the South
in
ern mountains, at town movie theaters

Howard was

it.

it out of it.

with, learning

as

fast as they could and playing every eve
ning that they could get together. They

lived almost within sight of each other's
homes. Richard says, "Daddy learnt Art
how to play the fiddle." Art later went to
Kingsport, Tennessee, to do cabinet mak
ing work, and played with a band there.

came through town, heard
Art, and took him aside. Recruiting him to
join the Blue Grass Boys, Monroe showed
Art on his mandolin how he wanted him to
play bluegrass on a fiddle. Art played with
Monroe for a few years and made nine re
cordings with him, beginning with "Mule
Skinner Blues," recorded live at the Grand
Ole Opry on November 25, 1939. Monroe
is noted to have said of Art, "The old-time
fiddle numbers, he was hard to beat." (After
the War, Art would also play with the Stan
ley Brothers, recording eight titles, and with
Bill Monroe

making four recordings.)
Richard Joines says that Bill Monroe also
talked seriously to Howard about playing
with his band, but Howard did not want
to leave home, wife, kids, mother and dad,
his farm, his life. He'd already learned that
a musician on the road didn't earn enough
to support any one of the above.
Flatt and Scruggs,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

cluding the Spartan Theater on Main Street
in school auditoriums, some
in Sparta
times in tents and at courthouses. Bill and
Charlie Monroe, the Blue Grass Boys, the
Stanley Brothers, Flatt and Scruggs, Reno
and Smiley, Jimmy Martin, Mac Wiseman,
the Louvin Brothers, the Osborne Brothers,
and Jim and Jesse McReynolds all played
in Sparta. The initial audience for bluegrass
was strongest in the mountains. Younger

musicians like Howard Joines and Junior
Maxwell took to bluegrass pedal-to-themedal; no seatbelts, no problem.
Junior Maxwell started to play

blue-

grass banjo when he was in his late twen
ties, having tired of old-time music. "Too
draggy." He wanted to make music like
he drove a car, fast as the road allowed.

played at square dances on week
ends with his older brother, Welter, play
ing fiddle. Junior's wife Maggie played
guitar, and they all sang. When Welter
died on Christmas Eve in 1945, his death
knocked the fire out of Junior. He quit
picking for some years. Later, when he
began to play music again, he figured out
bluegrass banjo and started bluegrassing
old-time tunes. "Plain" was the word Ju
nior used to describe how he believed a
banjo ought to be played. He liked clarity
in the notes, and respect for the tunes.
He

Junior said that he could always hear

a

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

hint of the old-time sound in the playing of

bluegrass musicians

of his generation. For
was like hearing the native accent
of someone speaking a second language.
Galax fiddler Otis Burris played bluegrass
with old-time in it, he said, as did Cleve An
drews, Junior's Little River Boys bandmate.
Art Wooten came home to Alleghany
County in his later years, and made mu

him,

it

weekends with Junior Maxwell's
bluegrass band, the Green Mountain
sic on

L. W. Lambert's band from be
low the mountain, the Blue River Boys.
Art played fiddle with these bands un
til he couldn't play anymore. The Green
Mountain Boys played dances at High
Meadows Restaurant on Saturday nights.
It was half tables and half dance floor on
weekends. Art made two LPs with L. W.
Lambert's band, one bluegrass, the other

Boys, and

old-time.

By the time of the

recordings in

his later years, Art's style had become
of

weaving-together
grass, flowing freely

a

old-time and blue-

in and out of each
other, what we call fusion today.

Willard Gayheart of the Galax-based bluegrass bands the Highlanders and Skeeter

and the Skidmarks is another example of
the area's musical fusion. Now 80 years
old, Willard plays Western swing, country,
and '20s pop music all mixed into an old-

time and bluegrass style. Willard doesn't

seem

to

distinguish between old-time and

bluegrass anymore. Though there is a dif
ference, they both flow the same for him.
Howard also used to play with banjo
picker Edd Atwood. Edd lived across
the road from some friends of mine,
who would invite Grandma's musician
friends over to play in the living room
from time to time. Grandma was Faye
Wagoner, who played guitar and sang.
She had jammed with banjo player Bertie
Dickens and Bertie's brother, fiddler Joe
Caudill, just about all of their music-mak
ing lives. Faye's husband Jimmy played
banjo, fiddle, and harp (harmonica). At
one particular jam that I attended, she
was playing with Fred McBride (fiddle),
George Eller (banjo), Edd, and a couple
of guitarists I didn't know.
Edd Atwood was in his seventies then,
very respectable two-finger old-time
banjo player. He smoked unfiltered Cam
els, which made his breathing a little del
icate, but it didn't slow down his picking.
Edd lived by himself for several years af
ter his wife died. He and Junior Maxwell
lived in sight of each other's farms. The
one time I was in Edd's house, I'd never
seen anyplace like it. Not one adornment
a

�on the walls. Not one more piece of

fur

than essential for one man who
wanted little. It was plum Zen. It told me
Edd's resources were within.
Howard made music with banjo player
Fred Roupe as well. Fred and Junior were
the county's elder banjo pickers in their lat
er years, their bands the hottest bluegrass
bands around here. A longtime friend and
niture

neighbor of Howard's from the Pine
Swamp community, Fred too started out
playing old-time music. In his later years,
Howard played with Fred's band, Swamp
Grass. (Richard Joines played rhythm gui
tar in both men's bands.) Fred's daughter
Joy Patton plays clawhammer banjo and
a

fiddle with the Tune Town Old-Time String
Band out of Marion, Virginia. She grew up
playing bluegrass at least as much as she

played old-time, and

it

informs her play
younger old-

ing in the way rock informs
time musicians now.

Fiddler

Tim

Smith

played fiddle

with

Swamp Grass while he was in junior high
and high school. (Fred told me he would
drive Tim to the gigs when he was too

a driver's license.) Tim's
grand
father was Kilby Reeves, a well-known el
der old-time fiddler from Alleghany Coun
ty's Twin Oaks township.
According to

Richard, Tim went to Howard weekly for
a time to learn
bluegrass fiddle. Tim later
became the Bluegrass Cardinals' fiddler.
Howard Joines' musical friends came
from across the spectrum of traditional

TJ

Worthington

young for

Faye Wagoner

music. While some musicians are only
comfortable in one style or the other, old
er regional bluegrass bands today often
play old-time tunes as freely as they play
bluegrass. Bluegrass wasn't something
separate, in his way of seeing. It was an
other wav of making the same music.
The '40s and the '50s were a time of
searching for new directions in every art
form, most visibly in abstract expression
ism that was happening in New York. In
the traditional music of the mountains,
bluegrass inspired a new spirit that took
instantly, a spark setting off a fire.
grass was laying rubber shifting
second gear to third. There was
that was new in the region in those
For many people, electricity was
and so was all that goes with it,

Bluefrom

much
days.
new,
radio

refrigerators and television. Seri
ously fast cars were new too, and paved
highways. A new energy had crept in
almost unnoticed. The people changed,
and their culture changed. Bluegrass was
a new
way to play old tunes, and to au
diences, a new way to hear the old tunes
they'd danced to all their lives,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Dean

Richardson

and

Wiley

"Junior"

Maxwell

�TALES FROM THE 'WOODS
PART 7: ITHACA
By Walt Koken

were heading north on
Interstate 81, which parallels US Route 11,
also known as the Lee Highway. Our des
tination was Ithaca, New York, and a gig
arranged for us there by our friend Ricky
Jay. It was at the Salty Dog, a new water
ing hole on the old Cayuga Lake inlet.
Mac, Bob,

and

I

Ricky, a prestidigitator of superb tal
ent, had traveled across Canada with the
Busted Toe Mudthumpers in the summer
of '68. A bit of

background information

will help set the stage for this part of our

wandering minstrelsy that summer.

'Thumpers' original lineup com
prised George Dorian on fiddle, Jeff
Thorn on guitar, and Larry Marschall on
banjo, all students at Cornell University
in Ithaca. When Larry graduated around
'65, 1 inherited the banjo chair, and Marty
Lebenson, one of George's housemates,
joined in on mouth harp. Our destina
tion in '68 was Alaska, but we veered
southward for various reasons when we
hit Alberta, and we ended up in Berke
ley, California, where we met Mac, Bob,
The

and

many
George's old
guitar player
stormed our

other old-time musicians.
friend John Coster was the
on that trip, and as we barn

way along, Ricky would
play multiple roles as agent, emcee, and
magician/ entertainer.
That band met its demise the following
year when George and Bob Pine, an excel
lent old-time guitar player from Pasadena
who had become an integral part of the
'Thumpers, died together in a tragic auto
mobile accident returning from a musiccollecting trip to Cape Breton Island. After
that, I moved to the Bay Area to play mu
sic with folks we had met there.
Later,

gigs

in

when Mac and Bob and
places such

as

played
Davis, California,
I

and Portland, Oregon, Ricky again trav
elled with us and was part of the act.

What could compliment old-time music
performance better than magic? How
ever, Ricky's best performance art was
meant to be viewed close-up rather than
on stage,

work in
bartender, where he

and he began getting

various places as a
could entertain and baffle customers

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

at

the bar. This was how he became briefly
connected with the Salty Dog. Ricky has

since gone on to more majestic heights,
performing magic on television, and gar
nering acting roles in major films.
So it was, that we were heading for
Ithaca and friends whom I hadn't seen
couple years, and for our only gig
We rolled into town
that fine summer day in time for happy
hour at Morrie's bar in Collegetown on
East Hill. The joint was jumpin'! Every
one was preparing for a block party right
for

a

on the East Coast.

there on Eddy Street that evening, and as
dusk descended, the three of us backed
into a store-front entrance and played for
the crowd. A local filmmaker who was

documenting the "happenings" caught

a

jamming, and the film was pre

bit of our

sented the following night on campus.

Ricky told us that he had heard from
my friend Doug Dorschug that we could
stay at his house. Doug had been a friend
of George Dorian's, and had come to
music parties in Ithaca and met us at

Union Grove, North Carolina, fid
dlers' convention in previous years. He
had served his time in Saigon and was in
the

school

at

Cornell on the

GI Bill. He

could

play banjo, guitar, mandolin, and piano,
so we were looking forward to a visit

His girlfriend, Jennifer Cleland, also played guitar and piano, and
was on leave from Cornell at that time.

with him.

They lived at the head of Hulbert Hol
low Road in the beautiful and rustic hills
of Spencer, a few miles south of Ithaca.
We availed ourselves of their place, and
for the few days we were in town we had
fun playing with them.
The Salty Dog gig was not memorable.
We were informed that we would have

provide our own sound system, in the
manner of the rock-and-roll bands that
to

usually played there. We managed to bor
row a sound system from a friend of a
friend who had a rock band, but unfortu
nately we ended up being our own sound

men, usually a recipe for disaster. The
buzz from Eddy Street seemed to flow
down the hill and into the Salty Dog. It

tough, noisy gig, reminding us once
we could use more oomph and
that
again
bottom end to power a crowd like that.
was

a

Some folks wanted

it louder, some quiet
was a bit of a struggle to convey
any musical subtleties. A far cry from the
Marion fiddlers' convention! They were a
happy crowd, though, and they seemed
to enjoy the show as best they could. A
fellow we met there talked us into playing
the following night at the "Christmas in
er,

and

it

at the Seneca Lodge resort in
nearby Watkins Glen.
Now, that gig was more fun. John Coster
had come for a visit with Doug and Jen

July" party

ny, and they all showed up at the
We got them to sit in with us some.

lodge.
It was
in a basement rec room, and there was a
small "stage" area lined with straw bales
where we played. The stage was crowd
ed, and I have a vivid memory of Bob,
rocking away on his fiddle, in the middle
tune, suddenly tripping and rolling
gracefully backwards over a bale. First
he was there, and then he wasn't!
Our East Coast sojourn was nearing
its end. We had had fun and success all
across the country, from Colorado to
Washington, DC, from North Carolina to
New York state, and we had associated
with plenty of fine musicians and friends
along the way. We had had lots of good
times together, but there was one trouble
spot we hadn't anticipated. The three of
us had spent perhaps a few too many
of

a

weeks playing, eating, sleeping, riding in
the tobacco-stained truck, and doing ev
ery other mundane thing possible togeth
er without relief. Besides, we'd given up
cigarettes for the trip, which contributed
to the stress level amongst us. In short,
we'd had our fill of one another.
Mac wanted to camp one night on a small
piece of land that he owned near Benning

ton, Vermont, before we made the long trek
back to California. So we made our way
to visit a friend of mine near Putney, Ver
mont, and the next day Mac and Bob drove
to Mac's property. We agreed that I would
meet them the following day by a certain
hour, or they would head west without

�me. Then Doug and Jenny showed up, and
the three of us played music and spoke of
alternatives to the Fat City String Band.

Doug's parents' place in Connecticut was
in need of painting, and I was flat broke de
spite our prizes and earnings in the prior
few weeks. And so it was that tire Fat City

String Band broke up, and Bob and Mac
drove off by themselves.
Doug and Jenny and I painted that house
and then went back to the Ithaca area.
Some friends who had a commune up
on Dawes Hill Road near their house in
Spencer had a string bass, which we bor
rowed for Jenny to play, and the three of
us entered the talent show at the Spencer
Picnic on Labor Day weekend and won
the fifty-dollar first prize

playing "Wheel

Hoss!" We needed a name for the trio so
we called ourselves the Mudthumpers,
in memory of our old friend George. We

played several times that fall and winter
at a Trumansburg eatery called the Kosmos, a natural food restaurant that was

communally. They would push the
tables out of the way and folks would
dance, and we would try to get some
one to collect money at the door. Doug
run

would play banjo,
Jenny would play
would play fiddle
City, we were still

mandolin,
guitar

or

or guitar,
bass, and I

or banjo. As with Fat
fishing for the proper
instrumental combination. We built up a
substantial local following over the win

also performed on Phil Shapiro's
radio show Bound For Glory on WVBR,
his live broadcast from a coffee house on
ter, and

the Cornell campus.
Mac and Bob played our last gig without
me at a coffee house in San Diego when

they arrived back on the West Coast. Mac
later moved to a friend's farm near West

minster, Maryland, where he spent the
winter. Bob remained in Berkeley, living

self-made "penthouse" on the roof
brother's art studio/ warehouse.
Towards the end of that winter, around
March of '72, Mac drove up from Mary
in his
of his

land for

a

weekend visit. There was

a

late blizzard and we got about three feet
of snow.

We were snowbound, so we sat
around and played music the whole time.
It sounded
great, and we were happy to
see each other again. We devised a scheme
to lure Bob to come east at Eastertime. We
would meet at the farm in Maryland, and
travel to Union Grove. There at the farm,
the five of us would play together for the
first time in the configuration that would

later become the

Highwoods Stringband,

sort of like the Skillet Lickers with

a

bass.

The prospect seemed exciting.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Attic
"NOT ENOUGH TO HURT MY PLAYING"
By Paul F.Wells

someone asks the traditional
We've
(or jazz or bluegrass...) musician if he or she can read
music. "Not enough to hurt my playing," comes the response.
Ha, ha, ha, very funny. This exchange is, of course, meant to
set up the person asking the question as a pompous fool, and
the musician as the hero who takes the snob down a notch or
all heard the old joke:

two via a bit of reverse snobbery of his or her own. Arguments
for and against learning fiddle tunes from print have long con
sumed extensive bandwidth in Internet discussion groups and
now on social media.

collection
of Paul

Wells

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Wells
Paul
of
collection

The fact is, there have always been
some fiddlers who are musically literate
and who can, and do, learn tunes from
printed music, and others who aren't,
and can't, and don't. Printed and manu
script collections of fiddle tunes have
been around since the first half of the 18th
century
essentially for as long as tunes
and tune types that would be familiar
to modern fiddlers have been around.
However, standards of musical literacy
among fiddlers, and attitudes towards
it, seem to fall broadly along regional
and cultural lines. Scotland, which is

regarded
a

as the

birthplace of the reel

as

enormous number

of

form, was the center not only of the

composition
fiddle tunes

of an

in the late 18th and

early

19"1

centuries, but of the publication of them
as well. No parallel tradition of tune pub
lication occurred in Ireland, though, and
the

situation

in the US is

divided; virtual

extant manuscript collections
of American fiddle tunes, and most of the
printed ones, come from the North.
This leads to some interesting questions
ly all of the

and speculation about the relationship of
learning process to musical style. That

given that Southern and Northern
fiddle styles in the US are markedly dif
ferent, what role might musical literacy,
or absence of it, have played in shaping
is,

regional

playing styles? That's

a

topic

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

another time and another place. For
now, let's just amuse ourselves by taking
a look at a
couple of fiddlers in the past
who not only played from printed music
for

but were proud

photographed

enough

of this skill to be

in the act of

exercising

it.

Our first image comes from a studio in
the rather unlikely spot of Carbon, Wyo

ming. No community by this name exists
today but, according to the website WyoHistory.org, Carbon was Wyoming's first
coal town. It was founded in 1868, flour
ished from then through the 1880s, and
ceased to exist in 1902. There is still a Car
bon County, an entity that also came into

existence

in 1868 and

presently occupies

nearly
square miles in the southcentral part of the state, along the border
with Colorado. This area has apparently
always been sparsely populated in the
2010 census only 15,885 residents were re
ported in all of Carbon County but dur
ing the heyday of the town of Carbon it
7,900

apparently supported a photography stu
dio and was home to at least one fiddler.
The short span of years during which
Carbon existed as a town helps us deter
mine at least an approximate date for our
photo. The book for which the fiddler's
female companion is acting as a human
music stand helps narrow the window
even further. It is Howe's Original Violin
School, part of the vast output of Boston

�music publisher Elias Howe. Howe was
also the publisher of Ryan's Mammoth
Collection, compiled by William Brad
bury Ryan and issued in 1883. This is
better known to today's fiddlers in its
guise as One Thousand Fiddle Tunes, pub
lished by M. M. Cole (1940). The Original
Violin School is undated/ as was the case
with many of Howe's publications, but
through internal and external evidence
we can give it a date of c. 1886. Therefore,
our photo probably was taken sometime

between the years 1886 and 1902.
How might
mining town

a

in

in small
coal
West in the 1880s or

fiddler
tire

1890s have obtained a copy of a
music book published in Boston? Quite
likely via that pioneer of American big
retail: Chicago-based Sears, Roebuck &amp;
Co. By 1894 Sears was publishing large
mail order catalogs. Included among the
musical wares on offer were many publi
cations from Elias Howe, Howe's Original
early

here)

it

included "the 135 pieces of music
in Howe's first violin school

contained

[one of his earliest works, published in
1843], over 200,000 of which have been
sold." It also contains quite a few tunes
that Howe had not published until they
were collected by W. B. Ryan for inclusion
in the Mammoth Collection, and a good
deal of music other than fiddle tunes.
The material is described on the cover:

"...quadrilles, waltzes, jigs, reels, horn
pipes, contra and fancy dances, songs,
polkas, gallops, schottisches, marches,
quicksteps, etc."
Then there are those "New Rules and
Exercises" that are also touted on the
cover. The book contains eleven pages

pedagogical material that ranges from
such basic topics as stringing the violin, to
advanced material such as position shift
ma
ing. There are 40 bowing exercises
of

terial that was first published in Ryan's
and "Chords for Second Violin Playing."

illustrations show
how
to
hold
the
violin
ing
(reproduced
here), advice to which our Wyoming fid

among them. A copy would
have set our Wyoming fiddler back a
mere 40$. Plus shipping. Sears may also
have been the source of his violin and

There is also

bow, fancy ivory frog and all.

cannot, of course, know what part
book's varied musical and instruc
tional contents was of primary interest to
our mustachioed fiddler and his prover
bial "lovely assistant," but it seems un
likely that we're dealing with an aspiring
classical violinist. We can speculate that
he perhaps cared more about the tunes
than about the pedagogical material. Af
ter all, one did not need to master all the
bowing exercises included in the Howe
book, or delve into the difficult realm of

Violin School

Howe began his publishing career

early 1840s and many of his tunebooks
self-instructing instrumental tutors

contained varying numbers of reels, jigs,
and hornpipes. Ryan's Mammoth Collec
tion was the only one of Howe's publica
tions to consist entirely of fiddle tunes.)

These sat alongside marches, melodies of
popular songs, and other types of dance
music. Such was the case with his Origi

owned by our Wyoming

does contain a healthy number
of fiddle tunes, many of which had been
staples of Howe's earlier collections. As
noted on the cover (which is reproduced
fiddler.

It

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

page of

dler apparently paid little attention!
We

in the

and

nal Violin School,

a

of the

position shifting,

in

order to play the rel

atively simple pieces gathered there.
In any event, our fiddler was proud
enough of his music book to want to

feature

his photo session. The

it in

grav

ity that he and his lady friend invested
in this occasion is obvious from the way

they decked themselves out in their finest
attire, complete with showy boutonniere.
He was ready to let the world know that

was he

musician

a

to be

reckoned with

and, by God, that he knew how to read

music, too!
Our other image this time around gives
work with, in that we cannot
the
music on the stand. On the
identify
we
are given a bit of informa
side,
plus
tion about the man. The hand-written
caption below the image reads: "Taken
at Prentice, Wisconsin
at the time our
dad was scaler in the lumber Camp and
Played for dances, then married Lulu."
We are again dealing with someone from
a small town. Prentice, in Price
County
in North-Central Wisconsin, had a popu
lation of only 660 in the 2010 census. As
us less to

suggested by the caption on our photo
this was, historically, logging country.

often the case with the images
at in this series, the picture
raises a number of questions that we can
not answer. Speaking for myself, I have
a hard time
getting my head around the
idea that this fellow with his lacy col
As

is

we've looked

matching display handkerchief, and

lar,

pinky ring on his left hand ever worked
in a lumber camp! However, timber scal

ing involves measuring logs, rather than
cutting or hauling them, and thus is not
as

rough

or

hazardous

an

occupation

as

we might imagine.
In terms of his music, although we are
told that he "played for dances," we
might ask what kind of dances or, more
to the point, what kind of dance music?
We

assume fiddle tunes of course but,

as

can tell, that's not a collection of
fiddle tunes sitting on his music stand.

best

I

And what's up with the music sheets
strewn all over the floor? This sort of ran
dom placement of objects is very much
out of the norm for studio photographs. I
have no good explanation.
Perhaps all we can say about this image
is that it is

a photo of a
musically-literate
dance musician who played the fiddle.
Or violin. Again, as was the case with the
Wyoming fiddler, this was a person who
was proud enough of his ability not only
to play music but to read it off the print
ed page to have lugged music and, in
this instance, a music stand, with him to
the photographer's studio. We trust that
although he could read music, it wasn't

enough

to

hurt his playing,

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Wells
Paul
of
collection

�MAY

2006 No. 29#

lilL

iSisr.1 ial woblowiue

boots music guide

£&lt;,
20

FROOTS

time out of time timeless
the essential worldwide roots music guide: the best of
local music from out there, for over 30 years, find and
subscribe (new! our very economic digital edition!) at
old time

I

new time

no

www.frootsmag.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Reviews

time orchestra"). So as to evade atten
tion from Walker and Columbia, Poole
and his band recorded as The Highland

Charlie Poole with the Highlanders

The Complete Paramount

ers (for Paramount)

&amp;

and The Allegheny
Highlanders (for Brunswick).
Only three of the aforementioned 12

Brunswick Recordings, 1929

recordings ("Lynchburg Town," "Flop
Eared Mule," and "A Trip to New York,
Part I") were included on Sony's ac
claimed three-CD set You Ain't Talkin' to
Me: Charlie Poole and the Roots of Country
Music. For that reason alone this Tomp

kins Square release is long overdue.

Paramount and
be characterized

Tompkins Square TSQ2875

San Antonio
Rich
Lynchburg Town
mond Square
May I Sleep in Your Barn

New York Part I
Trip to New York Part II
Trip to New
York Part III
Trip to New York Part IV
Tonight Mister

Trip to

Tennessee Blues
Flop Eared Mule
Under the Double Eagle
What is Home
Without Babies
For the commercial genre of "hillbilly"
music, 1929 was a year of significant
change (though perhaps not cataclysmic
change; that came shortly thereafter).
The Wall Street crash during the fall of
that year was the beginning of the end
for the recording careers of most "hillbil

Nevertheless, many mu
sicians, including Charlie Poole, made
ly"

musicians.

remarkable records that year.
A new CD from Tompkins Square com
piles 12 lesser-known sides from Poole's
short yet brilliant, and otherwise well-

documented, career.

The recordings

on

this CD all date, not coincidentally, from
1929, the year when Poole had grown so

disgruntled with the approach to mak
ing records of his longtime company
(Columbia Records) that he decided to
record for competitor labels, albeit with

pseudonyms because

he

remained under

contract to Columbia.
The North Carolina Ramblers had long
been a trio
with Poole on banjo and
vocals alongside a fiddler and a guitar
ist. As the decade drew to a close, Poole
was eager to expand his band's sound by

adding other instruments (specifically,
an additional fiddler and a pianist). Pro
ducer Frank B. Walker, who had overseen
Poole's

recordings for Columbia, was
adamantly against such musical experi
mentation during Columbia sessions.
In defiance,
Poole arranged recording
sessions with the Paramount and Bruns
wick labels for his newly expanded band
(which Kinney Rorrer, the album notes
writer for this CD, calls Poole's "old-

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Brunswick

sides

by an emphatic,

The
can

even

aggressive rhythm (punctuated by the
pounding of a piano). The pianist on
these recordings, Lucy Terry, was the sis

guitarist Roy Harvey, and ac
cording to Rorrer Harvey grew disgrun
tled with the band's inclusion of a piano
because his sister's playing overpowered
his own acoustic guitar.
Several of the recordings on this release
betray the comparatively poor sound of
the original 78s. (Paramount was notori
ous for the inferior quality of its releases;
not surprisingly,
the Brunswick sides
ter of band

on this CD are

sonically more dynamic
than those from Paramount.) Chris King,
the sound

engineer

for the project and

a

Grammy Award-winning producer of
historical releases, did a remarkable job
rendering quite listenable some rough-

sounding
that

the

78

RPM recordings. (The fact
78s did not sell well

original

meant that King and fellow producer
Josh Rosenthal had comparatively few
surviving records from which to choose

when selecting copies
Arguably
on

The

for

remastering.)
interesting recordings

the most

Complete Paramount &amp; Brunswick
1929 are four sides Poole and

Recordings,

the band recorded
to

New York, Parts

for

Brunswick, "A Trip
On these record

I-IV."

narrative composed by Roy Harvey
a fictional
band's trip by train
from the South to New York City in order
to make records. The "acting" throughout
this narrative is spirited, perfectly timed,
ings,

a

describes

For instance, when
New York-based record producer asks

and frequently funny.
the

the band "have you ever made any records
before," one bandmember replies "only jail
records." Over the four sides, Poole and

his bandmates

regularly (and spontane
ously) break into playing short renditions

old-time selections.
Poole made additional record
ings for Columbia as part of a trio, and
of

In 1930

died

in

May

1931.

Poole's doomed efforts

In
to

documenting

realize his con-

�cept of an "old-time orchestra," Tompkins

Square's release of Poole's Paramount
and Brunswick recordings on a single

completes and complicates our
understanding of this legendary, and
consistently innovative, musician.
CD both

TED OLSON
To order:

tompkinssquare.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Huber points out, we know less
about Howard Dixon's life because he
died young in 1961 at the age of 57 he
suffered a heart attack during his shift at
Rockingham, North Carolina's Aleo mill,
and died soon after arriving at the hospi
tal
and did not have the chance either
to write an account of his life or to work
with a folklorist to document his experi
ence, both of which Dorsey lived to do.
Howard's untimely death was a tragedy
not only for his family but for lovers of
old-time music, as we are thus deprived
of a chance to hear him play with Dorsey
again on the 1960s recordings.
Howard Dixon, playing a National steel
guitar, had a cinematic instinct for tones of
suspense, tension, and resolution. Dorsey
usually sang lead, but Howard's sing
ist. As

ing was equally special. I've long thought
that the brothers' 1936 recording of "Dark
Eyes" is one of the greatest recordings of
the 78 rpm era. Howard sings lead on this
one, at a brisk clip that contrasts with the
wistfulness of the song's story of lost love.
Each verse begins with a couple of picked
notes that sound like the beginning of an

instrumental break, quickly interrupted as
Howard commences again to sing. His ju
diciously-deployed falsetto makes the dif
ference between a great performance and

masterpiece. (The flip side, "Rambling
Gambler," also led by Howard, is almost as
a

good

as "Dark

Eyes.") That same sparing

use of falsetto is used to haunting effect on
the otherwise rather maudlin "Two Little

Boys." Another signature of Howard's was
the ascending slide chord that he often
used to end songs, sounding like a flying
saucer lifting off for its voyage home.
Another spellbinding but under-ap

preciated recording found on this set is
Dorsey's 1937 duet with wife Beatrice
on "Beautiful Stars." To my ear, the great
beauty of this eerie gospel performance
lies in the tension between Howard's

am

biguous peppering of mournful tones on
the National and the celebratory evangel
ical ardor of Beatrice's singing.

Dorsey's
somewhat gruff, mid-range singing lays
the song's foundation, projecting, as he
always did, resolute, if assailed, faith in
ultimate reward.
Unless you already

an

really

fellows, chronologically

is

love these
perhaps

not

the best way to listen to their recordings.
Your attention may wander when you

reach, say, the fourth or fifth song answer
ing "What Would You Give in Exchange
For Your Soul?" Try playing the tracks
on a random setting instead, to mix up
the eras, band lineups, and themes of the

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

songs; that way you'll have a richer expe
rience of the brothers' music.
And for those listeners who do already
love the Dixons, what a treasure this set is.
To have gathered together all these record
ings is well worth the high price ($125 or
so, depending on where you buy it). In ad
dition to the wealth of recordings we have
the very beautiful and extensive hardback
book. The first 140 pages of this gorgeous

publication are devoted to an excellent,
poignant biographical essay by Patrick
Huber (adapted from his book Linthead

transcriptions of the autobio
graphical writings left by Dorsey Dixon,
and extensive and informative song notes
Stomp),

by Huber. This is followed by a discography of the brothers' recordings compiled
by Tony Russell and Richard Weize,

derfully

won

polka-dotted with label scans.

The entire book is lavishly produced with
high-quality paper and printing, and

hundreds of illustrations

family photos,
record and radio promo materials, sheet
music covers, early picture-postcards of
the Carolinas, and other gems. Even the
box that it all comes in is beautiful.
Thank you to everyone who made pos
sible this fine tribute to Dorsey and How
ard
To

Dixon.

A

Blessing

order: bear-family.com

to

People is just that.
Sarah Bryan

�Section with Illegible Text

Prat

Section with Illegible Text

cam.

instruments

Section with Illegible Text

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�you not like a tune by a guy named "Lit
tle Hat" Jones and which has the refrain
"Leave so clean, just like a submarine?"
As he does throughout this entire album,

panache that is captivat
ing, showing why he ranks among the
Molsky brings

a

best in the old-time community.

BILL WAGNER
To

order: www.brucemolsky.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�when we combine the impulse to root
in older sounds with the im
to
create
a sound that is our own."
pulse
If these have remained his goals, Decosi-

ourselves

mo has not only succeeded, but inspired

his fellow

musicians on this recording

to

nlav with those enals in mind.

PETE PETERSON
To order:

www.cdbaby.com/cd/josephdecosimo

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�on

several of that band's signature pieces,

"Buck Eyed Rabbit," "Wild Hoss," "Crip
ple Creek," "East Tennessee Blues," "Silly
"
Bill, and "Texas Gals." All of these pieces
are led by Kirk's

smooth and articulate

underpinned by Eddie's bouncy
piano backup and vocals, and Tom's bub
fiddle,

bling ukulele, which looms in and out of
focus, almost but not quite taking a lead.

Also notable

is

Eddie's singing on "Wild

Hoss" and "Blue Ridge Mountain Blues"
on which he really nails the Hill Billies'
amusing declamatory vocal style. One
place where the Stage Hogs have really
put their own stamp is the banjo playing.
Tom's banjo ukulele playing kicks up the
rhythm on the majority of cuts and Kev
in's popping Kyle Creed clawhammerstyle banjo, occasionally fretless, perco
lates nicely on the breakdown-style tunes.
However, on snappy 2/4 pieces such as
"East Tennessee Blues," "Cacklin' Hen,"
and "Flop Eared Mule," the Hogs give a
more direct tip of the hat to the Hill Billies,

whose players mostly finger-picked banjo
(two- or old-time three-finger style), with
Kevin, Kirk, and Tom taking turns adding
some frisky picking. "Cacklin' Hen," an
other of my favorites, manages to capture
the humor and excitement of the Hill Bil
lies' version, with Kirk and Kevin's wild
dual banjos joining the fray, finger-picked
and clawhammer.

The Stage Hogs have done a fine job of
paying tribute to one of the great old-

time bands of yore,

imagine

anyone

a

job that's hard to

else

accomplishing.

They have the musical fluency and the
joyful spirit of the original band, yet have
taken advantage of their own prodigious
skills and personal tastes. Even if you
have the Hill Billies' original recordings
in your collection, you'll still find this CD

must-have.

a

GAIL GILLESPIE
To

order: oldbluerecords.com

Note to Artists and Record Companies
Please send all material for review to
the OTH (PO Box 61679, Durham, NC
27715). Please do not send to individu
al

reviewers. What gets reviewed is de
at the discretion of the OTH

termined

according

to

space available,

balance

of old and new, and compatibility with
our mission. We cannot review every

thing that comes in nor guarantee that
it we will review
it. We do not return materials to the
sender. Thanks!

because we received

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

H

�Way back in 1982, Kinney Rorrer wrote a
wonderful book, Rambling Blues: The Life

The New North Carolina Ramblers
A Tribute to Charlie Poole

and Songs of Charlie Poole. It
of the ideal biography of an

was

a

model

old-time mu
sician: detailed description of the cultur
al milieu; numerous photographs; and a
life story that perhaps made more sense
than the actual life described. The book
gave the words to most of the songs that

Charlie recorded— which is important,
because he often swallowed some of the
words, making them unintelligible, at
least to Northern ears.

Old Blue CD OB-71 2

being a good writer, Ror
unique position to write the
his
great uncle was Posey Rorer,
story:
fiddler with Poole's band, the North Car
olina Ramblers, for most of its existence;
and Poole was married to Posey's sister.
So family stories were available about
In

Kinney Rorrer: banjo, vocal; Jeremy Stephens
fiddle; Darren Moore: guitar; Corrina Logston:
fiddle (on 4 tracks)

rer

Hash House
The Man from Ten
There'll Come a Time
nessee Goodbye Mary Dear The High
Goodbye Booze Take a Drink
way Man
One Moonlight
Budded Rose
on Me
I Don't
Care
If
I Lose,
Leaving
Night
Dear Old Ireland
My Wife Went Away

Honeysuckle

and Left Me

Hungry

Bill

Mason

May

I

Sleep

The Only Girl
Your Barn Tonight
A
Old and Only in the Way
Ever Loved
is
Home
What
Mother's Plea for Her Son
in

I

Once Loved a Sailor
Without Babies
I'm the Man Who Rode That Mule Around
Forks of
the World
Flying Clouds
1

Sandy

Too Young to Marry

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

addition

was in

to

a

one of the key groups in the history of
recorded Southern string band music.
Kinney also formed the New North
Carolina Ramblers, with the aim of re
producing music, mainly recorded in the
1920s, from the North Carolina cotton
mill area. On this, their fourth CD, they
finally get around to Charlie Poole and
the North Carolina Ramblers. This is a
tribute album, not a greatest hits album.
Charlie recorded over 70 sides during a
relatively brief musical career (he died of

alcoholism

age 39), but the 24
here
do not duplicate
pieces presented
those, such as "White House Blues" or
in 1931 at

"The Baltimore Fire," that have been

cov

ered by other revival bands. So you can
buy this album without duplicating your
New Lost City Ramblers collection.
The instrumentation

(banjo,

fiddle, gui

arrangements (solo voice by Kin
and
length of the songs (about three
ney),
minutes) closely follow the original record
ings. And this is definitely a vocal album.
Only the first piece, "Honeysuckle," and
the last, a medley of three tunes that were
originally released as individual records,
are instrumentals. The rest use the original
tar), vocal

North Carolina Ramblers arrangements of
solo vocal interspersed with instrumental

repetition of the melody.
If you're familiar with Charlie Poole's
recordings (and there are numerous reis
sue sets available), you'll readily identify
your favorites from the song list. Mine
are: "Goodbye Mary Dear," "The High
way Man," "Goodbye Booze," "My Wife
Went Away and Left Me," "Bill Mason,"
and "I Once Loved a Sailor."
Corrina Logston adds a second fiddle
to three of the numbers. I don't recall
harmony fiddling in any of the original
North Carolina Ramblers songs, but the
technique here adds a very nice touch,

�particularly to the early 20,h-century Tin
Pan Alley tunes that Charlie loved to sing.
I could
listen to more of that sound.
LYLE LOFGREN
To Order:

oldbluerecords.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Midnight

Special

Instruments
btj

Hugh hunter

j

Resonator Banjos in 4, 5 and 6 string models
Open-backs
Banjo-Lute Hybrid 5 String Neck on a Lute Body
Banjoleles in Soprano and Tenor Scales
Travel-Light Collapsible Travel Banjo
Custom Pot and Neck Construction
and

Rockwood, Ontario, Canada

[dedicated

to

519-856-9266

www.midnightspecial.ca

hand building stringed instruments for generations of pleasure

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Contrasting Osborne's softer style is Ivy
Sheppard's slightly lower-pitched, twangier
voice, grittier and more biting in approach.
She sings lead on three and lets fly on them
all. "Write Me Sweetheart" is forceful and
anguished, "Let Me Fall" almost frantic,
"Blue Eyed Boy" pleading. All three stand
among the best tracks on the recording.
An even greater contrast is David Shep
pard's baritone voice, which not only

adds a welcome change of pace, but is
very good in its own right. He's equally
at home on the Hank Williams gospel
song "Sing,

weariness

to

Sing, Sing" or bringing a
"Short Life of Trouble." He

may be at his best, however, on his origi
nal "Waiting For My Darlin'," his story
of a woman waiting for the return of her
William from the First World War, which
captures the feel of songs such as "The
Boys in Blue." There is also a nice Irish
feel to Sheppard's voice on that one.
Having three distinct voices creates the

opportunity for some intriguing harmony
settings, and it is on these that the Broad
casters' vocals truly shine. Be it the duet of
Ivy and Sarah on "Little Birdie," or the way
Ivy and David snap off the lines on "East

Virginia Blues," or the resonant trio stack
ing of voices on "Sing, Sing, Sing," "I'll

Have A New Life," and their a cappella
version of "Where the Soul Never Dies,"
the results impress with forcefulness and
emotion, highlighting what is a very good
and highly entertaining recording.

BILL WAGNER
To

order: scbroadcaster.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Minnesota Fiddle Tunes Project

of the railroad, travel from the East Coast

became easier, and the early arrivals sent
mail back to relatives describing the won

Upper Midwest Old-Time CD UMOT-001
Cntie

Jo

Pidel and Friends: Kettlescrubber

Betsy Neil and Friends: Selmer Ramsey's

Eelpout Stringers: Flop Eared Mule
Temporary Stringband: Minnesota Waltz

Waltz

Swedish Schottische
Dick
Halverson's Waltz
Haybirds:

Roe Family Singers:
The

Minnesota

Pickers: Stoltman's

Polka

Temporary Stringband: Sherburne's Polka
Bob
Adam Hurt: Edwin's First Polska
Bill
Gary's Polka
Matthews and Friends: Saint Paul Waltz
Selmer Ramsey's Polka
Tjarnbloms
Minnesota Pickers: Ringnessen Reinlander
Brian Miller and Friends: Iva Dingwall
Bovee

and

Gail

Heil:

Tjarnbloms: Henry Grondahl's
Medley
Schottische
Minnesota Pickers: Ranger's

Waltz

Stringband:

Temporary

Running's Tune
Little Red Barn

Anabel

Sanford

Elmer
Wirt:

Steamboat Quickstep
The Gritpickers: Albert's Schottische
Pam, John, and the Dixons: Knute's Waltz
Phil Nusbaum: Bill Sherburne Medley
O'Neil Family: Fred Nelson's Jig
Minnesota Pickers: Oh, So Many Berries
The

Roe Family

Singers: The Girl

I

Left Behind

Sara// Panjunen: Jalasjarven Polka
Freak Creek Revival: Buckwheat Batter
Me

Tjarnbloms: Stoltman's Dad's Waltz

Minnesota

became

a state in 1856,
but
did
not
fast
at
first.
population
grow
The easiest way to get there from the East
Coast involved a steamboat trip down
the Ohio River to Cairo, Illinois, and from

the

another trip up the Mississippi to
or Minneapolis, at which point
further travel was blocked by a water
there

St.

Paul

was not appealing
northern and eastern
parts were impenetrable forest, while the
western part was tallgrass prairie. But the
land, most of which had been heavily gla
ciated, was fertile, and farmers who were
used to the landscape (Scandinavians)
began arriving in large numbers, with the
At first glance,
farming country: the
fall

it

main emigration being from about 1870
to 1910. Those who arrived were mainly
peasants with minimal education, coming
from countries where the population had
exceeded land resources. With the advent

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

derful opportunities. The emigrants did
not get free land, though— it had already
been bought up by speculators. There
fore, the would-be farmers had to work as
lumbermen, railroad laborers, or miners
(the northern Minnesota iron mines were
fabulously rich, with ore close to the sur
face) until they could save enough money
to buy a farm. It was not just Swedes,
Norwegians, and Finns who emigrated to
the new land— there were considerable

numbers of Germans, Czechs (Bohemi
ans), and Irish as well.
The mines and lumber mills (and, later,
the flour mills) were owned by Anglo-

from the East Coast who al
when they moved
had
resources
ready
in. They became wealthy, and, since they
were cultured in the Central European

Americans

sense, founded art museums, symphony
orchestras, theaters, and the sophisticat
ed attractions of the Twin Cities area. The
peasant farmers, though, brought their
fiddles and accordions with them, and
home music was the only source of en
tertainment through the infamously long
Minnesota winters. This CD samples
some of that music, weighted towards
Scandinavian instrumental music (more
specifically, music from southern Swe
den). About two-thirds of the tunes are
polkas, waltzes,
The

or

schottisches.

immigrants were not isolated from

American

same extent as
Appalachian settlers, but when
they played music from the Old Country,
they naturally played it the way they first
learned it. Each generation learned from
the previous one, and so these tunes and
playing styles have evidently remained
relatively unchanged compared with
music in the source countries. However,
these were farmers who had little time to
practice, so the tunes that survived tend
to be easy tunes with strong rhythms,
compared to the more exotic Swedish
dances, such as the polska (one example
here, learned from Edwin Johnson, who
society

to the

the earlier

emigrated from Sweden

in the

1920s), the

mazurka.
hambo,
The original sources for the music are
no longer around, but they were recorded
by collectors, and these tunes are played
by several talented Minnesota musicians.
or the

I'm pleased to report that all of them
get the Minnesota musical accent just

right —

a wonderfully
familiar sound
remember from fiddling relatives in my

pre-TV rural childhood.

I

Many of us who are interested in tradi
tional music tend to concentrate on Ap
palachian tunes and songs, while not no
ticing that other areas have their own tra
ditional music. Congratulations to Mike

Sawyer, who recognized that oversight
and obtained a grant from the Minnesota
State Arts Board to document some of it.
highly recommend this all-instrumental
recording as an introduction to some Up
per Midwest traditions.
The Scandinavian tunes all seem fa
miliar, and I have a hard time picking
favorites, since I grew up with them. To
make matters more confusing, Swedish
fiddlers normally name a tune after the
person they learned it from. But, in the
next town, Dick Halvorson's Waltz might
become John Peterson's Waltz, so tune
scholarship must be very difficult.
I

non-Scandinavian pieces, three
American breakdowns ("Flop Eared
Mule," "The Girl Left Behind Me," and
the medley played by Anabel Sanford
Wirt); one is German ("Saint Paul Waltz,"
from Whoopee John's New Ulm dance
Of the

are

1

band); and one sounds Irish to me ("Iva

Dingwall Medley").

Not covered by this CD are the vital Ger
and Czech traditions of southern
Minnesota; Finnish tunes, many in a mi
man

nor key, from the iron range; and singing
traditions from all the sub-cultures. Min

nesota has recently had an influx of newer
immigrants who must have brought their
music with them, too: Mexicans, Hmong,
Ethiopians, Somalis, and many others. I
hope someone will continue the task of
collecting (and learning) these traditions.
LYLE LOFGREN
To order:

minnesotafiddle.blogspot.com

�death, lost love, hard work, and fam
These are topics with which rural
mountain folk of the early 20th century

ily.

would be well acquainted, and the red

brick sternness in their voices, declaim
ing

from

atop

guitar

and

autoharp

grooves as delicate as they were driv
ing, show that the original Carter Fam

Sara, and A. P. —lived
what they sang. That they managed to
remain popular for the better part of
ily— Maybelle,

two decades, during

a

time when what

we now know as country music went

through a series of jarring transitions
changes the Carters helped to launch
only goes to show how deeply their
music resonated with their audience,
be it border radio listeners, concert hall
crowds, or record buyers.
It makes sense that such a story would

find its way into a graphic novel. The
text also allows a particularly full pic
ture to be

painted

of A. P.,

doubt the least understood

who was no
member of

the group. On recordings, this is largely
Maybelle and Sara's band, as they typi
cal split the lead and harmony singing,
and Maybelle added lead and slide gui
tar parts, mesmerizing in their perfect
simplicity, over Sara's rhythm guitar

autoharp. A. P appeared mainly as
vocalist, and usually as harmony ac
companiment. So what did he do be
or
a

sides put his name on tunes he clearly
didn't write? There's nothing like read
ing dialogue, and staring at the Carters

as graphic characters, to find out. A. P.
was possessed by music, and he was as
determined to preserve it as he was un

able to keep truly focused on anything
else, never mind his wife and growing
family. Like the Lomaxes, he was able

to recognize the importance of the older
music, and the fact that it was in dan
ger of extinction. He found a wealth of
songs in his own backyard and figured
the best way to preserve them was to
keep playing them. He simply needed
a band. The visuals give dimension
to

A. P.'s

planting of

a

dying apple seed

ling, his daughter's picking apples from
the same tree years later, the constant
lack of cash, as well as a demand for
their music that both baffled and drove

them on despite weather, failing autos,

and bickering between an increasingly
troubled A. P. and Sara, all laid out in
a

way as effortlessly straightforward as

their music.
In

these

ration

information such as
copping slide guitar inspi

pages,

Maybelle's
from

Frank

Ferera

records

or

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

torment over realizing Sara has
remarried is allowed to linger on the
page, and unlike in a biography, which
relies on interviews and other factual
A. P.'s

accounts for support, this simply devel
ops a narrative, largely through artwork
and sparse prose, that allows a reader
to

imagine what might've

happened.

No one has a record of most of what the
Carters said or did in their daily lives;
the role of this book is to bring out the

dilemmas

of

a

group of people who just
famous playing music

to get

happened
borrowed from a rich tradition they all
knew by heart but never took for grant

ed. It's also apparent that traveling all
over the US, doing radio and making

records, was something they finally got
weary of music-making, but they never
grew weary of making music itself. So
they walked away in the early 1940s
from a career that had never lagged. The
last few frames, of A. P. sneaking out of
a

performance by the second-generation

Carters, out into the night past his apple
tree, may have never happened, but it
brings out the essence of what this fam
ily left us with better than any other
phrase written about them.
Accompanying the book is a frustratingly

brief

18

minutes

of

the

Carters

�blasting out of border radio in San An
tonio, Texas, in 1939 for broadcast on sta
tion XET in Monterrey, Mexico. However,
it's as varied a set of music as you might
ever hear from them. Maybelle cranks
through short instrumental versions of
"Chinese Breakdown" and "Cumberland
Gap," but then there's A. P.'s solo, waltztime "One Little Word," which is likely a
rare recording of his own guitar playing.

a 16-year-old
Janette Carter gives
solo autoharp-backed reading of "O
Death." But overall, this is Maybelle and
Sara's show, and they play with a drive
harder than many of their commercial re
cordings ever seemed to capture.

Later,

a

BRUCE MILLER
To order:

carterfamilycomix.blogspot.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�DOWN HOME RADIO SHOW
Vernacular Music of the Americas

www.DownHomeRadioShow.com
Old-time, Blues, Pre-Blues, Gospel &amp; Spirituals,
Latin American Folk Music, Field Recordings,
Interviews, and more

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Hosted by Eli Smith

�CLASSIC BANJO
from

the acclaimed Classic Series from

u

Smithsonian Folkways a 30-track compilation capturing
the great versatility of the banjo and how it shapes
American musical identity.

1

The latest installment

H
H

Smithsonian Folkways

Smithsonian Folkways Recordings

Copyright
© 2021
ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.
Section with Illegible
Text

in

Enter code ClassicBanjoHerald at folhways.si.edu
to save 20% off retail price on this CD or

album download through 12/31/13.

f
f

Sm

p*
ft,?

�</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </file>
  </fileContainer>
  <collection collectionId="65">
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12031">
                <text>Old-Time Herald</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12032">
                <text>Presented in partnership with the nonprofit &lt;a href="https://www.wholesouth.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"&gt;Whole South Heritage Works&lt;/a&gt;, &lt;em&gt;The&amp;nbsp;Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;collection includes digital copies of every issue of&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald Magazine&lt;/em&gt;, 1987-2023.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Founded in 1987 by legendary musician Alice Gerrard,&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/em&gt;served for more than 35 years as a leading voice of the old-time music community worldwide&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;. Its&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="wixui-rich-text__text" style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt; 130-plus issues, all accessible here, contain a vast wealth of information that can’t be found elsewhere. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Issues include:&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent" data-testid="inline-content" class=""&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent-gridContainer" data-testid="mesh-container-content"&gt;&#13;
&lt;div id="comp-mf5sjgaq" class="ku3DBC zQ9jDz qvSjx3 Vq6kJx comp-mf5sjgaq wixui-rich-text" data-testid="richTextElement"&gt;&#13;
&lt;ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;deeply researched explorations into the history of old-time string-band music and related traditions&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;in-depth articles from respected historians, musicians, and writers&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;historic photographs, many of them previously unpublished&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;detailed discussion of the contemporary culture of old-time music and dance&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;field reports from regional scenes&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;interviews and oral histories&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;extensive album reviews, spotlighting both new releases and reissues of historic material&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;remembrances of departed musicians, including local community players typically overlooked in the national press&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;/ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Also included are robust community discussions and long-running, often fiery controversies waged in readers' letters to the editor.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Originally based in Galax, Virginia, the magazine was published for most of its run in Durham, North Carolina. Founding editor Alice Gerrard was succeeded in that position by Gail Gillespie, then by Sarah Bryan.&amp;nbsp;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;The Southern Music Research Center and Whole South Heritage Works are grateful to our community of donors, whose contributions made possible this significant digitization and archiving project — and to Alice Gerrard, who paved the way and made this whole thing possible.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;em&gt;A logistical note: Click on any issue's title or thumbnail image to access that entire magazine. On some screens, the PDF reader may initially display only a portion of the page. To view the issue more easily, click the "Presentation Mode" icon in the toolbar above the issue — four small arrows pointing outward in all directions. Then you can use your finger or your computer's arrow keys to scroll through the pages. Happy exploring.&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
  </collection>
  <elementSetContainer>
    <elementSet elementSetId="1">
      <name>Dublin Core</name>
      <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
      <elementContainer>
        <element elementId="50">
          <name>Title</name>
          <description>A name given to the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12800">
              <text>&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;, Volume 13, Number 7 (November 2013)&lt;/span&gt;</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="49">
          <name>Subject</name>
          <description>The topic of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12801">
              <text>Old-time music</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="41">
          <name>Description</name>
          <description>An account of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12802">
              <text>&lt;p&gt;&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;, Volume 13, Number 7 (November 2013)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Contents include:&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Ditch Dvorák, They Want ‘Turkey in the Straw’: A Brief History of Old-Time Fiddling in Montana,” by Aaron Parrett&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Howard Joines: Mountain Fiddler in Changing Times,” by TJ Worthington&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Tales from the ‘Woods, Part 7: Ithaca,” by Walt Koken&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Final Notes” include obituaries for Gail Heil; Curly Miller; Charles Henry Faurot; and Guy Porter Gillette&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="40">
          <name>Date</name>
          <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12804">
              <text>2013</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
      </elementContainer>
    </elementSet>
  </elementSetContainer>
  <tagContainer>
    <tag tagId="1632">
      <name>2010s</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="2411">
      <name>2013</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6457">
      <name>Aaron Parrett</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6460">
      <name>Charles Henry Faurot</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6209">
      <name>Curly Miller</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6456">
      <name>Ditch Dvorák</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6455">
      <name>Gail Heil</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6461">
      <name>Guy Porter Gillette</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6458">
      <name>Howard Joines</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5413">
      <name>Old-Time Herald</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="1417">
      <name>Old-Time Music</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6459">
      <name>TJ Worthington</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5460">
      <name>Walt Koken</name>
    </tag>
  </tagContainer>
</item>
