<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<item xmlns="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5" itemId="2630" public="1" featured="0" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xsi:schemaLocation="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5 http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5/omeka-xml-5-0.xsd" uri="https://southernmusicresearch.org/items/show/2630?output=omeka-xml" accessDate="2026-11-21T02:10:35+00:00">
  <fileContainer>
    <file fileId="3569">
      <src>https://southernmusicresearch.org/files/original/b41e70522bbe878adfe7515a3d2948d5.pdf</src>
      <authentication>d7356afddb0d408d79004ae94b42384d</authentication>
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="4">
          <name>PDF Text</name>
          <description/>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="92">
              <name>Text</name>
              <description/>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12715">
                  <text>THE OLD-TIME

HERALD
A

MAGAZINE DEDICATED

VOLUME

12

NUMBER

OCTOBER

1

TRENDS

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

IN

CAMPBELL

OLD-TIME MUSIC

NOVEMBER

IN

MUSIC

OLD-TIME

MARK

TO

ALASKA:

THEN

BANJO

OLD-TIME
AND

2009

REMEMBERING

AND

7.50
Now
PART

MIKE

SEEGER

3

�BLUE RIDGE MUSIC

MOUNTAIN

&amp;

FARM MACHINERY

OLD-TIME CRAFTS

PIEDMONT

FOODS

STORYTELLING

LIVESTOCK AUCTION

MOONSHINE
ANTIQUE

CARS,

HORSE PULLS

SHEEP HERDING

STILL

RACERS,

FOLK GAMES
HOT

RODS,

COON DOG CONTESTS

AND DANCING AT...

BLUE RIDGE

THE

FOLKLIFE

Section with Illegible Text

SATURDAY

FESTIVAL

I

FERRUM COLLEGE

OCTOBER 24th

I

10AM

I

5PM

HI

FERRUM, VIRGINIA

I
HKj

I

3 Music
A

I

Stages

50+ Craftspeople

Full Day of Blue Ridge

Moonshine

&amp;

Folkways

Dance Hall Memories

Bootlegger and Early Rocker Storytelling

I
I
I

I

A

CROOKED ROAD
MUSIC TRAIL
"MAJOR VENUE"

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

I

Virginia Rockabilly!

Live

Performances

&amp;

Gallery Exhibition

I

Dancing, Dancing, Dancing
Flatfooting, Buck Dancing, and

ADULTS: $10

YOUNGSTERS

SENIOR CITIZENS

a

'50s Sock Hop

I

(6-15): $5

I

(60 and Up): $5

WWW.BLUERIDGEINST1TUTE.ORG

(540)365-4416
--Rain or

I

FREE PARKING

Shine-

f

�VOLUME 12,

NUMBER

1

OCTOBER-NOVEMBER 2009

FEATURES
Trends
By Ray

in

Old-Time Banjo Playing Part 3/10

Alden

Old-time Music
By

An

in

Alaska: Then and Now/20

Peter Bowers

Interview with Mark Campbell/32

By Laura

Chessin

COLUMNS
HERE &amp; THERE/4

REMEMBERANCES/6
Mike Seeger: An Appreciation
By Paul Brown

DEPARTMENTS
LETTERS/2

CLASSIFIEDS/40
REVIEWS/42

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Don

Leisters

Violins

Richmond, Virginia
Expert Violin
&amp; Bass Repair
Bow Rehairing

Section with Illegible Text

Section with Illegible Text

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�many aspects to old-time music, and
some people feel that trying to play like
the old-timers is not creative, or is un
interesting, and perhaps lackluster, and
that the form as a folk tradition should
change with the generations. As some

are

one put it, "Why copy somebody else"?
There is something to be said for this ap

proach. For instance, is the Western style
of fiddling a viable form? Of course it is.
It's a unique and wonderful style with
a whole world of adherents.
But it isn't
Appalachian by any means.
Likewise the music in the finals lacked cer
tain definite characteristics we think of as
Appalachian. The playing was clean, but
very modern sounding, and the tune ver
sions either lacked the spark, intonation,
or melodic structure of the originals, or if
played up-tempo were too smooth, and
in a modern "contest"
style. Old-time
Appalachian music must be connected
to the past or it wouldn't be "old-time".
The versions we play in a large part come
originally from musicians who were born
in the 1800s, and who in turn learned from
their elders. There is much power in this
system of learning, and in these early tune
versions and styles, and yet these musi
cians

of

old

were

individually

unique

personalities, and their music managed to
reflect both the tradition and themselves.
While one can try to play exactly like Melvin Wine, Ed Haley, or Edden Hammons,
for instance, one's personal touch will al
ways shine through, for better or worse.
This music has deep historical mean
ing. It's from and about people who lived

closer to the earth, who shared skills es
sential to their survival, and whose mu
sic echoed that culture in feeling, tempo,
and power, and

I

think the Clifftop festi

val should be reflecting that. Let's honor
the ancients, and revere the old versions,
as

there is something

essential

in them

that is still important and valuable to us.
Let's not be rewarding music at the Ap

palachian String Band Festival that dis
regards these values. Let's keep Clifftop

Appalachian and old-time.

Walt Koken

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�DARE TO BE SQUARE

WEST!

DEC 12-14 09
SEATTLE, WA
A WEEKEND

OF

SQUARE DANCE

MUSIC WORKSHOPS.

JAMMING AND TONS
With

and the

&amp;

DANCING,
OF FUN

dalseher. The Tallboys
Shall Wonder Strincband

Bob

WWW.BUBBACUITAR.COn/D2BS/

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

I

�ington,

NC;

Jared

Sweet,

Pounding

Mill, VA; Tony King, Galax, VA; Austin

Mikeal, Lansing, NC; Danny Casste
vens, Mocksville, NC. Junior guitar:
Jeffrey Roten, Ennice, NC; Chip Moyer,
Sparta, NC; Colby Holcomb, Thurmond,
NC. Harmonica: Glen Zuhlke, Galax,
VA; Daniel Moore, King, NC; Wayne
Childress, High Point, NC; Milton Scott,
Thurmond, NC; Paul Hiatt, High Point,
NC. Mandolin: Connor Lambert, Trout
man, NC; Terry Bullin, Elkin, NC; Ted
dy White, Carthage, NC; Ronald Davis,
Hillsville, VA; Jimmy Holder, Union
Grove, NC. Junior mandolin: Adam
McPeak, Max Meadows, VA; Connor
Hagwood, Durham, NC: Justin Willey,
Sparta, NC. Vocal: Shelby Mahaffey, Ri
ner, VA; Tommy Connor, Elliston, VA;
Jessie Lovell, Fries, VA; Tommy Nichols,
Mount Airy, NC; Jeanne Farlow, Trinity,
NC. Senior dance: Gladys Williams, Gal
ax, VA; Marsha Todd, Mount Airy, NC;
Barbara Bowman, Ararat, VA; Marty
Todd, Mount Airy, NC; Danny Easume,
Pehook VA; Junior dance: Brianna Dil
lon, Wirtz, VA; Samantha Wilhelmi, Ri
ner,

VA;

Makenzie Maitland,

Traphill,

Huysman, Sparta, NC; Hunter
Stewart, Bristol, TN. Children's dance
(participants, not scored): Kitty Amaral,
Elk Creek, VA; Matthew Bumgardner,
NC; Ben

Galax, VA; Ciara Pierce, Roaring River,
NC; Olivia Phipps, Independence, VA.
Winners at this year's Appalachian

String Band Festival (Clifftop, WV) were
follows. Fiddle: Tatiana Hargreaves,
Corvallis, OR; Eric Merrilll, New Ha
ven, CT; Emily Schaad, Rhinebeck, NY
as

Stephanie Coleman, Brooklyn,

NY;

Rafe

Stefanini, Elkins Park, PA. Youth Fiddle:
Tatiana Hargreaves, Corvallis, OR; Isaac
Akers, Chapel Hill, NC; Tessa Dillon, St.
Albans, WV. Senior Fiddle: Lester Mc

Cumbers, Nicut, WV; Henry the Fiddler,
Denver, CO; Walt Koken, Avondale, PA.
Banjo: Adam Hurt, Kernersville, NC;
Walt Koken, Avondale, PA; Rick Good,

Spring Valley, OH; Bob Smakula, Elkins,
Nancy Sluys, Westfield, NC. Youth
Banjo: Jesse Reist, Lancaster, PA; Brennen
Ernst, Lucketts, VA; Jared Boyd, Laurel
Fork, VA. Senior Banjo: Walt Koken,
Avondale, PA; Marvin Gaster, Sanford,
WV;

NC; Jimmy McCown, Hardy, KY. Tradi
tional Band: The Bailers, Greenville, WV;
The Yeah Buddies, Spring Valley, OH;

Orpheus Supertones, Avondale,

PA;

Un

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

cle

Henry's Favorites,

Free Union,

VA;

The Tights, Ithaca, NY. Neo-Traditional
Band: Nora Jane Struthers and Her
Band, Nashville, TN; The Boston Collec
tive, Boston, MA; The Old-Time Libera
tion Constituency, Lancaster, PA; Mando
Mafia, Charlottesville, VA; Green Willis,
Mountain View, AR. Best Original Song:
Nora Jane Struthers and Her Band,
Nashville, TN. Best Original Tune:

Mando Mafia, Charlottesville, VA. Old
Time Fiat-Foot Dance, 15 years of age
and under: Rebecca Molaro, Asheville,
NC; Lulu Furtado, Front Royal, VA;
Samantha Thomason, Hellam, PA. Old
Time Fiat-Foot Dance, 16 years of age
through 40: Josephine Stewart, Char

lottesville,

VA;
Ryan Clover-Owens,
Ithaca, NY; Joel O'Brien, Nashville, TN.

Old-Time Fiat-Foot Dance

41

years of

Bernstein, Asheville,
Kennesaw, GA; Jane
Henderson, Bloomington, IN. Old-Time
age through
NC;

Jay

59: Ira

Bland,

Fiat-Foot Dance
60 years of age and
older: Daniel Butner, Winston-Salem,
NC;

Mary Butner, Winston-Salem, NC;

Carole Bendick, Winfield, PA.
Winners at the Fries (VA) Fiddlers'
Convention were as follows. Old-Time
Band: Grim Sheepers; Pilot Mt. Bobcats;

Pinnacle Mt. Breakdown; Crooked Road
Ramblers; Virginia Creepers. Bluegrass

Creek Junction; Mountain Leg
end Express; Rakstraw Express; Kadzoo;
New Ridge Bluegrass. Old-Time Fiddle:
Brian Grim; Jake Krack; Richard Bow
man; Kilby Spencer; Jerry Correll. Bluegrass Fiddle: Jordan Blevins; Butch Bark
er; Kylie Hall. Old-Time Banjo: Michael
Band:

Fox; Ray Chatfield; Marsha Todd; Kevin
Fore; Patrick Hill. Bluegrass Banjo: Hous
ton Caldwell; Brian Cox; Henry Webb;

Steve Grissley; Gary Webb. Guitar: Matt
Osborne; Tony King; Asa Gravley; Gary
Dalton; Glen Skaggs. Mandolin: Ben Hill;
Tommy Sells; Nick King; Terry King;
Dalton Edwards. Autoharp: Joann Redd;
Gilbert Suitt; Glenna Anderson; Ross
Roberts; Virgil Adams. Folksong: Glen
Skaggs; Amber Compton; Jesse Lovell;
Gary Dalton; Erin Lunsford. Dulcimer:
Terry Lewis; Sharon Boyd; Lou Beasley;
Phyliss Gaskins; Dick Lamb. Dobro: Billy
Bourne; Jacob Joines; Marvin Farmer;
N.R. Taylor; Frank Lawson. Bass: Andy
Blevins; Brian Osborne; Loyd Richard
son; Mark Rose; Karen Carr. Henry Whitter
Award: Brian Grim

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Melnyk
Mike

�Rememberances

MIKE SEEGER: AN APPRECIATION
Seeger died at his home in Lexington,
Virginia, on the evening of August 7, 2009,
six days before his 76th birthday. He had
been living with cancer for more than a de
cade. Over the long course of his illness, he continued
his life's work as a performing musician, music collector,
advocate for old-time music, and documenter of South
ern traditional music and dance. He maintained an ac
tive solo performing career from his early twenties to the
end of his life. In 1958, he was a founding member of
the New Lost City Ramblers, a string band that fueled
an international revival of interest in old-time music that
continues today. Paul Brown offers this appreciation.

Mike

recordings on aluminum
home, he had a good leg up on
the task of learning instruments.
People
around him recall that before long, he
was a whiz on banjo, mandolin, and gui
tar. He took up the fiddle, the autoharp,
the jew's harp. With his parents and their
friends having modeled the behavior, he
started to record traditional musicians in
the Washington, DC, area where he lived
at around age twenty.
By this time he
was playing early-style bluegrass, and
swimming in the intense stew of oldther's
discs

field

at

time, country, gospel, and bluegrass mu
sic that was part of the DC soundscape.
The stew became ever stronger as people
continued pouring in from the mountain
South looking for work, and met urban
kids and young adults hooked on folk

music and its relatives.

It

would

be nearly

impossible

to list

ac

curately the total of Mike Seeger's con
tributions to the world of old-time music,
American cultural and social history, and
the lives of the people around him. It is
probably safe to say, however, that he did
more than any other single person in the
late twentieth and early twenty-first cen
turies to spread the word about old-time

music, to provide opportunities to the
traditional musicians who made it, and
to encourage new generations of players.
Those younger people whom he helped
show the way were profoundly important
to him. In his final weeks, he told reporter
and musician Keith Brand for an NPR ra
dio story that his real satisfaction was "for
all the people who are playing the music."
And when I visited him a week before his
death with my wife Terri McMurray and
friends Mary and David Winston, he was
moved to tears as he described what had
become his greatest joy at the annual Ap
palachian String Band Music Festival in
West Virginia: walking down the lane in
the wooded campsite area where he saw

people playing and heard music coming
from every direction.
Mike told me and others
including
filmmaker Yasha Aginsky in the new film
on the New Lost City Ramblers, Always
Been a Rambler, that he was fortunate in
his upbringing. Not only was he born
into a family of musicologists, folklorists, scholars, and performers, it was a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

family that affirmed taking action, had a
sense of mission, and surrounded itself
with interesting characters. His father,
the musicologist Charles Seeger, started
out as a proponent of so-called high cul
ture who came to value traditional mu
His mother,
Ruth Crawford Seeger, was a composer
who also cared deeply about old-time
songs and tunes. She transcribed many
of Charles' field recordings, and Mike re
called that there was frequently singing
at home. Mike's older half-brother Pete
had become addicted to the banjo as a
teenager and had embarked on a career
sic and its players strongly.

as

a

musician

in the

service of social ac

tivism
a career that
brought him both
fame and hardship as he found himself

with secure positions on blacklists dur
ing the McCarthy era and beyond. A sis
ter, Peggy, followed a path that was simi
lar in some respects. As for house guests,
Mike casually recalled to me people such
as the painter Thomas Hart Benton and
members of the renowned family of
pioneering folklorists, the Lomaxes. My
conversations with Mike over the years
clearly revealed his basic understanding
that he should pursue whatever interest
ed him, and that to do

anything less was

waste of the gift of life.
Pursue his interests he did. He started
seriously playing music relatively late,
at age eighteen.
But since he'd already
heard lots of music, including his fa

something

of

a

Then, as it emerged in several conversa
tions over our thirty-year friendship, he
came to recognize that he was in what
could be a lifelong love affair with the
older sounds. He said something similar
to journalist Keith Brand: "I realized oldtime Southern music was really what I

wanted

to play, because it had so much
history that went back into the old, old
To filmmaker Aginsky, he re
songs."
Mountaineers and
called, "Mainer's
Uncle Dave Macon, Carter Family. That's
what I loved."
Many of us love things, but tend to keep

them

for

ourselves,

perhaps

polishing

them, or putting them to use largely for
our own benefit. But Mike, as he pursued
a
performing career with great energy,
did much more than that. He lived the

family sense of mission by documenting

old-time musicians.
it

by bringing

He also expanded
them and their art before

new audiences.
This sort of thing had been done before
most notably perhaps by John and Alan
Lomax in the case of Leadbelly. But the

New Lost City Ramblers, and Mike on his
own, took it to a new level. In doing so,
they bridged chasms of culture and time,
helping urban audiences start to under
stand real country music and musicians
while groups such as the Kingston Trio
focused more on pure entertainment and
their own financial success. Mike and the
Ramblers affirmed the values, art, and

�lives of the rural musicians at a time when
their music was forgotten or dismissed,
often even in their local communities.

Affirmation can be a very powerful
thing. When I worked at mountain music
radio station WPAQ in the early 1980s,
the owner, Ralph Epperson, told me one
evening that one of his greatest satisfac
tions was being able to affirm publicly
music by putting

the value of old-time

local musicians on the air for thousands
of

to hear,

people
industry

radio

of the

while the mainstream

shunned them

favor

in

Nashville country music jukebox.
a number of older musicians
mentioned to him that perform

He said that
had

ing on his station had given them new

enthusiasm

for life, and

a

new sense of

worth in the world.
Mike Seeger practiced the same affirma
tion throughout his career. First with the

Ramblers, and on his own

as

the

Ram

blers performed less regularly, he went
to great effort to present older musicians
on stage and
a

communicate

sense of their value.

to

audiences

He sought

out

people who seemed to have disappeared,
such as the stunning banjoist and singer
Dock Boggs. He championed bluegrass
pioneers the Stanley Brothers and Bill
Monroe as they struggled to make a liv
ing against the onslaught of rock and roll
and commercial country music. He re

alized that the housekeeper in his own
home as a child, Elizabeth Cotten, was
of astounding interest who
a musician
needed to be heard. He helped her build
a career that took her around the world.
And as he appeared with these artists at

venues ranging from the Newport Folk
Festival

to

small house concerts and

lo

consistently celebrat
ed them and their achievements, rather
than pursuing adulation for himself. My
NPR colleague Corey Flintoff recalls that
cal radio

shows,

he

when he worked at a public radio sta
tion in Alaska many years ago, Mike and
Libba Cotten performed live one day on
his show. But Flintoff says he now real
izes he didn't pay anywhere near the at
tention he probably should have to Mike
because Mike, who could have tried
to steal the show or at least compete for
notice, was quietly, assiduously direct
ing the attention elsewhere. Flintoff re
calls,

"Mike stayed

in the

background,

except where he could interject to shine
some other light on Libba Cotten and her
music. I should add that she, in her quiet
way, seemed to be having a really good
time because Mike had made these tours

possible

for her."

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Older generations were not the only
ones to benefit from Mike's drive to share
and champion the art and lives of oth
ers. His contemporaries, such as the West

brilliance, and commitment often come
with extreme characteristics of all sorts. I
found accepting these aspects of Mike, as
his friend, was well worth it. His eccen
tricities were certainly no more challeng

younger musicians felt the same impact.

ing than many other people's, including,

Virginia-born singer Hazel Dickens, and

most common responses I
One
hear from these younger players when I
ask for their thoughts about Mike is, "He
of the

For example, banjo
changed my life."
Senders
Stefan
says meeting Mike
player
resulted in a sudden ninety-degree turn in
the direction of his life, sending him into a

joyous period of learning banjo, hanging
out with old-timers, and broadening his
view of music and the world. "He heard
me and

somehow conveyed

a

kind of re

spect and recognition and just picked me
up right there and supported me... Then
he said, 'You know, you

should go listen

said, 'Are you kid
He said,
was
dead.'
he
I
ding?
thought
'No no, you've got to do that.' And he
invited me to his house, and he took me
to

Tommy Jarrell.'

I

Tommy and introduced me
Senders also recalls Mike as
to people."
careful listener who would
a memorably
hear things in Senders' playing that were
unique and valuable, and tell him so.
down

to see

certainly experienced all of this my
met Mike quite by accident one
I
afternoon at Tommy's home in North
Carolina. We talked for a while, started
playing music with Tommy, and quickly
became musical companions and fast
friends. Somewhat to my surprise, he
soon invited me to join him on record
ings, to perform with him and with some
of the old-timers, and form a band with
the Bent Moun
him and Andy Cahan
Mike didn't have to do any
tain Band.
of this. But he chose to. Affirmation and
I

self.

example from Mike and Ralph Epperson,
not to mention my friend and fellow col

lector Ray Alden, helped me strengthen
commitments that still dominate my life

public service, documenting, interpret
presenting, and celebrating the work
of others.
Mike's mission-driven life didn't come
without costs. He recalled to filmmaker
ing,

for part of the first year of
the Ramblers, he and his young family
were homeless, staying with friends and

Aginsky that

relatives, as he forged ahead on what he
called a combination of ignorance and
hope. He had trouble sleeping. In the
earlier days of my friendship with him,
he could often be nervous, anxious, up
tight, tough to deal with, both socially
and when we were preparing music to
perform. But people of extreme focus,

I

would assume, my own.

As Mike aged, he became steadily more
mellow. He seemed to realize that he had
some significant accomplishments to his

name, and appeared more and more at
ease with himself and others. Photos and
early days, he
almost
earnest,
unsettlingly
displays
serious intensity. In later images and
film, he's equally intense, but frequently
smiling, laughing, and joking. He be
came yet more generous and even more
films bear this out.

In the

an

willing

to

fade into the background in

Many of us who saw
or parties,
even at his own home, took notice of the
fact that when he joined a jam session, he
was often as not on the edge, playing an
public situations.
him at fiddlers'

conventions

accompanying instrument.
He could easily have big-footed these
sessions. But banjo player David Win

ston of Lexington, Virginia, remembers
something quite different when Mike
showed up at local music gatherings after
he moved to the area in the early 1980s.
"He'd really focus on who was playing
and show his appreciation for the music

that was being produced by those people
he lived near." Winston says Mike might
look at the group of musicians and go out
to his car and get a banjo-ukulele.

"Here's a guy who had masterful com
mand of every instrument that's used in
the music, and had no interest at all in
showing anyone how proficient he might
He wanted to make the best music
be.
that could be made in that situation. So he
would go and get the appropriate instru
ment, find a comfortable chair, and start
playing. A smile would spread across his
His
face, and the music became better.
the
elevate
how
to
was
one
of
presence
how
to
show
not
how
situation,
people

proficient he was. And that's a gift, not
just a musical gift, but the gift of a lifetime,
to have that message conveyed."
As far back as the decade of his fifties,
Mike had a sense of the limited span of
life. At that time, he remarked to me that
there were certain things he wanted to

accomplish, and he would

be sacrificing
some other activities. I was a little sur
prised, because I did not normally hear
such talk from people his age.

Then he sailed into the list in an unstop
pable manner. He phoned one day, and

�Melnyk
Mike

asked what I thought of the idea of a music
festival in the South run by and for musi
cians, with no contests
something like a
as
he
called it. I told
South,
Brandywine
him I thought it was great. The next thing
I knew,
in 1986, he had founded the Rock
bridge Mountain Music and Dance Festi
val. He immediately started handing over
its

operation

to the

cians around him.
today,
living,
He decided
a

community of musi
The festival continues
gift from Mike.

evolving
traditional Southern flat-

dancing hadn't been adequately
documented, and set out to rectify that
foot

before the old dancers were gone
just
as he'd done with autoharp players de
cades before. The result was the video

documentary Talking Feet.
Largely in tire spacious, cluttered, and
fascinating work room at Iris home, he re
corded two impressive albums, life state
ments in a way, one each devoted to South
ern guitar and banjo styles. He archived
his field recordings. And finally, he started
an

ambitious

video

in the

banjo players
younger than he.

project,

recording

most of them
South
remains unfinished.

with amazement that he never stopped

performing

or

documenting.

tried to give him some space to accom
plish the tasks he felt were important, be
cause I'd spent so many priceless hours
with him already. But in 2006, when I was
I

pulling together

new album,

a

I

realized

that for three of the songs, no other
tar player could possibly do. I asked

would help me

if

I

promised not

gui
if he

to take

more than one day of his time. He agreed,
partly because two of the songs came from
old-timers we had known together, and
a third
from my own family's tradition,
which he never ceased to celebrate.
at his house. He looked a bit
I arrived
wan, but he was enthusiastic. We worked
through the morning and into the after
noon. He played magnificently. I ran into
momentary trouble with the singing of
one of the songs. As usual, he was encour
aging. By the end of the afternoon, we'd
nailed them all. When I listen back to the
album, the guitar work still sends shivers

up my spine. Mike said that on one of
the songs, from the Ward family, he was

he demonstrated that day was
what he had consistently encouraged in
all of us: respect for tradition, taking the
responsibility to be genuinely creative,
and a certain level of humility.
In our final visit with him a week before
he died, Mike was happy to talk about
music, but he didn't want to hear any
more of it. "I just want quiet," he said,
which was what he had in his big old
house on a wooded hillside surrounded
He was
by trees, shrubs, and flowers.

What

clearly grateful for his many friendships.
departed understanding that as his
life flickered away, he was leaving it up
those who happened to be
to all of us

We

close to him and thousands of people
he'd never met
to continue the music,
the collecting,

and the affirming.

Mike Seeger is survived by his wife,
Alexia Smith; three sons from his first
marriage, to Marge Marash: Kim, Chris,
and Jeremy; and four stepchildren: Cory,
lennv. [esse, and loel. whose mother is
Mike's second wife, Alice Gerrard.

trying

to recall the playing of our mutual
friend Fields Ward. He succeeded in that,
of course, but with his own striking yet

Paul Brown

Along the way, he became ill. Those of
us who were his friends watched him
handle his affliction with grace, and saw

unpretentious

He knew and worked with Mike Seeger
for thirty years. He is a newscaster, reporter,
and producer at NPR in Washington.

It

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

identity

clearly

audible.

tor.

is a

musician and music collec

�TRENDS IN OLD-TIME BANJO, PART III

THE SECOND CHOICE:
USE THE BANJO TO ACCOMPANY
THE VOICE OR THE FIDDLE?
Alden

By Ray

Pete Seeger and later the New Lost City
Ramblers always featured singing as a
main

in

ingredient

their

performances

and recordings. Pete's recordings, wheth
er from the political side (Folkways' 1941

LP Talking Union and Other Union Songs),
those for children (Folkways' 1951 LP

Songs

Grow On), or with a group (Van
LP The Weavers Songbag), focused

to

guard
on songs. Only rarely did solo instru
mental LPs appear, such as Folkways'

1954 LP The Goofing Off Suite. Continuing
with the singing tradition, from 1958 to
1961

Folkways issued several LPs

(The

New Lost City Ramblers The New Lost City
Ramblers Volume II, Songs from the Depres
sion, Old-Timey Songs for Children, The New
Lost City Ramblers Volume III), all of which

concentrated on songs with only the in
frequent instrumental ("Black Mountain

Rag," "Colored Aristocracy").

Thompson) from the Durham-Chapel

Hill area of North Carolina issued an LP
of old-time string band music instrumen
tals mostly

influenced by fiddler Henry

Reed. They featured tunes such as "Rich
mond Cotillion," "Betty Likens," "Mon
ey Musk," "Folding Down the Sheets,"
and "Over the Waterfall." The Fuzzy

Mountain String

Band,

another

string

band formed in the same area and influ
enced by the Hollow Rock String Band,
released its first LP on Rounder in 1971.
Their second LP soon followed, titled
Porch.

Numerous chang

Summer Oaks

&amp;

ing members

included Bill Hicks, Vicky

Malcolm Owen, Eric Olson, Blanton Owen, Tom Carter, Dave Crowder,
JoAnn Stokes, Dick Zaffron, and Sha
Instrumentals were
ron Sandomirsky.
again the prime focus, and members of
the band made visits to record old-time
fiddlers and banjoists so that that virtu
ally all their repertoire was learned first
and

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

turing fiddle and banjo veteran Walt
When these respective bands
and Dr. Humbead's New Tranquility
String Band dissolved at about the same
Koken.

"Sally Ann," "The 28th of January" and
"Green Willis" were learned from South
ern musicians such as Gaither Carlton,
Frank George, Burl Hammons, Tommy
Jarrell, Taylor Kimble, and Oscar Wright.

time, all three of them came together as
a
string band specializing in

Fat City,

tunes from the
repertoires of such early country record
ing artists as the Skillet Lickers and the

driving fiddle-and-banjo

perhaps the timing of the release of
these instrumental LPs, combined with
the influx of Northern musicians, some
what more unaccustomed to singing
than if they had grown up with song as
occurred in the South, that tilted the bal
ance of old-time banjo toward that of use
It is

the

fid

dle rather than the voice. One of the

no

primarily

as

accompaniment

to

table exceptions for using the banjo only

accompany the fiddle is that of New
Jersey native old-time banjo player Mac
Benford. As Mac wrote to me, "I moved
to

to

In 1968, just before large numbers of
musicians joined the old-time music re
vival, the Hollow Rock String Band (Alan
Jabbour, Bertram Levy, Tommy and Bob

bie

hand. Featured tunes such as "Shooting
"Double File," "Old Sledge,"

Creek,"

California's Bay Area

gan my professional

in 1967,

and

be

performing career

Dr. Humbead's
New Tranquility String Band and Medi
cine Show. This group specialized in the
recreation of the old-time music captured

with the much-beloved

on 78 rpm records from the 1920s, most
especially that of Charlie Poole and the

North Carolina Ramblers." Charlie Poole
and the North Carolina Ramblers were
a

singing band, and Mac sang many

of

their songs, some of which can be heard
from this exact era in California on the
Field Recorders' Collective's FRC609,
Berkeley

in the

fiddles
but

Hammers. Having two
unusual enough,

in the band was

the

ability

of Potts

and

Koken

to

play differing yet complementary styles
made Fat City one of the more distinc
tive outfits in the Bay Area

with the instrumental abilities of the ban
comes from combining efforts, such as
the teaming up of instrumentalist Adam
Hurt and singer-guitarist Beth Hartness.
Adam was mentioned in an earlier in
stallment of this article as an exponent
of the melodic clawhammer style. Adam
heard Beth, a guitarist and singer who

jo

grew up in the South, on an anthology
CD of the

Appalachian String Band Fes
called "Clifftop") and

tival (commonly

connected with her at a festival. As a
team, they go to festivals and give con
certs in which both instrumentals and
vocals can be featured.
The Third Choice:
To

clawhammer

or

finger-pick the banjo

'60s. For Mac, the primary

goal was not an academic exercise to rec
reate the music precisely, but, as he says,
"It was all about fun for us and fun for
our

Yellow

Georgia

audiences."

Mac became equally adept at using the

banjo to accompany fiddle tunes, as de
veloped in a later band. As John Lupton

writes of this development;

mentioned
if

at the

very beginning of

attending an old-time festi

clawhammer banjo
but
also
finger-picking styles. All
playing,
of the early urban pioneers had to deal
with this choice, and usually chose to be
able to play in both styles. This choice

val, one hears mainly

a while among early reviv
alists such as Mac Benford. Mac Benford
was born in 1940 in southern New Jersey,
where his grandfather had worked re
cording Enrico Caruso for RCA in Cam

continued for

Among the bands that eked out a liv
ing busking on the streets was the All
Skate, a band that performed on stilts,
and that included fiddler Bob Potts,
and the Busted Toe Mudthumpers,

As

this article,

fea

den. While attending

college in the late

�1950s to early '60s, Mac became caught up
music boom. At first he heard

in the folk

Weavers and the Kingston Trio. In the
summer of 1959, sailing camp counselor
Jack Grant of the Yale folk group exposed
Mac to more traditional styles through the
New Lost City Ramblers, Dave Macon,
tire

and

recordings.

Folkways

now-classic recordings such

Listening

to

as the

Harry
Smith anthology, Mac said, "when you lis
ten to old 78s, you hear more finger-pick
ing style than clawhammer." At the time,
Mac noticed that the then-current bluegrass style had "the old feeling." Moving
to Berkeley, California, in 1967, Mac was
thrown in with good players who had
started to make a living through music,
and started trying to play in a three-finger

bluegrass banjo style. Nonetheless, ev
eryone saw his technique as an old-time
finger-picking style. Although on many of
Mac's recordings you will hear him play
in the clawhammer style, recently he has
had a renewed interest in the finger-pick
ing style. Mac feels that while for years
Tommy Jarrell and Fred Cockerham cre
ated a "hot wave" for clawhammer, later
on, as people listened to Document CD
reissues of 78 rpm records, it may have
started a "finger-picking is cool" move
ment. Ironically, Mac also noticed that for

many in the bluegrass camp, promoted by
players such as Ralph Stanley and Tony
Trischka, a "clawhammer is cool" move
ment has gained ground.
Another urban banjo player who came to
play mostly in the old-time finger-picking
style was Tom Legenhausen, banjo player
with the Canebrake Rattlers. I asked Tom

how he learned and developed his style.
Playing with the Canebrake Rattlers,
influence on my playing was-

the main

not

surprisingly-records.

playing banjo
a

in

high school.

guitar, and was interested

started

I
I

wanted

in Bob

Dy

lan's early records. However, a distant
uncle had recently died, and there was
an

old

banjo

persuaded

in

his attic.

my aunt

banjo for Christmas.

My parents
give me the old
still remember my

to
I

profound disappointment when I opened
the old canvas case to find a tarnished
It was an old open-back
with 30 brackets, and plastic violin pegs,

old Sears banjo.

Never
to stay in tune.
thanked my aunt profusely, got
a
copy of Pete Seeger's book, and started
to learn. I knew nothing about the banjo,

guaranteed not
theless,

I

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Alden

taking records out of the New York Pub-

Ray

bluegrass, or old-time music. In keeping
with my family's frugal ways, I started

Mac Benford

�Lofgren
Elizabeth

Tom

Legenhausen

They had a lot of older Folkways records, so I was soon introduced to
Clarence Ashley and Doc Watson, Dock

lie Library.

and Wade

Boggs,
was

taken

totally

Ward.

However,

by Earl

Scruggs.

I
I

copy of Foggy Mountain Banjo.
remember putting the record on for the

found
I

a

first time-- "Ground Speed" came first,

the only person in our school who seemed

understand what

was trying to do.
Pat was playing blues, but was collect
ing everything. I'd go to his house and
listen to records-Muddy Waters, and
to

I

Walter-- and Pat would loan me

Little

Flatt and Scruggs records. We were also
listening to old-time music. Pat and I
Smokey Green Bluegrass Fes
Upstate New York. Although it

I
was totally captivated.
quit the
high school track team so 1 could spend
my afternoons working through the Earl

went

to the

tival

in

Scruggs' instruction book.

was in the air. Ralph Stanley was playing
some clawhammer in his sets. Stover and

and

I

The next record that made
to

me was

ference
Folk Festival
Keith.

albums

By now

what

Newport

that featured Bill

understood,

I

major dif

a

of the

one

was

in

but

general,
melodic

doing,
Scruggs
style seemed totally new, and was anoth
er mystery. I had saved my money from

summer job, and wanted to take some
I
found Roger Sprung
banjo lessons.
a

in

the

in

New

book-the

telephone
York

only teacher

top bill
took lessons for over a

that gave

banjo

ing over guitar.
and for a little while spent most of
time
playing fiddle tunes in Roger's
my
I

year,

melodic

banjo

school bluegrass

style.

this high
Pat Conte was

During

period,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

was

a

bluegrass festival, old-time music

Sprung held

a

banjo workshop. Although

the audience probably expected more

dis

of bluegrass technique, Pat and
I
peppered them with questions about
Don Stover was
clawhammer playing.

cussion

a

good clawhammer player-his "Things
still a new tune. Sprung is

in Life" was

good clawhammer player, and they
showed us the basics.
also

a

The

college

following
at

who played

September,

Cornell.
old

I

I

started

met Al Lubanes

time banjo,

and

Dan

ny Kornblum, an old-time fiddler, the
first week. I was really excited to meet
other players interested in playing

fiddle tunes. Ithaca was a good place
For bluegrass,
for music at the time.
there was Country Cooking and Tony
Trischka.

For

old-time, there was

the

Highwoods String Band, up the road
in Trumansburg, and the Swamproot
String Band visited often. John Speck
er soon came to town-- he and Danny
started the Correctone String Band.
Bruce Molsky came to town as an
amazing guitarist, and quickly became
an amazing clawhammer banjo player,
I was in
and then an amazing fiddler.
transition from bluegrass to old-time
music.
and

I

liked

soon decided

playing fiddle tunes,
it

made

more

sense

play them in old-time styles, rather
than melodic bluegrass. I went to Gal
ax with Al Lubanes, Danny Kornblum,
and the Correctones. The most influen
to

tial records for me at the time were Vol
ume Two of the County Clawhammer

[Banjo] records, Wade Ward's Uncle
Wade album, the Tommy Jarrell, Fred
Cockerham, and Oscar Jenkins records.
was also starting to learn old-time fin

I

to Snuffy
I was listening
Jenkins' Rounder album, but the single

ger picking.

�most influential

tune for me was Wade

version

Ward's

Annie."

of "Ragtime

tune-the bass runs, and simple

That

rolls-- was

great

a

introduction

to

Poole-style banjo. At first, my Poolestyle playing sounded like bluegrass-it
was much too smooth.

After

year

a

or

exclusively claw
hammer style, my Poole-style playing
two of playing almost

started

sound more old-time, with

to

more rhythmic accents.
While I was getting deeper into old-time

music

in Ithaca, Pat Conte was
playing
more old-time music in New York. After
I

graduated,

moved back

I

and Pat and

to

New

York,

more.

began playing
Farrell started playing with us, and
ing the

I

Mark

dur

we played in
Central Park almost every Sunday. We
had our cases open for change, with in

following summer,

consistent results.

was the

dog cart, who took
gave
free hot dogs
We
were
day's playing.
playing all

proprietor

hot

a

of

on us and

pity
a

for

Sun

remember one

I

day when the only contributor
us some

old-time music

then-tunes from Clar

by

ence Ashley, Tommy Jarrell, and 78s. Pat
the entire

had

County Records reissue

series.

Later that summer, we met Bill
Dillofat the South Street Seaport String
Band Contest.

We were fairly compul
We picked out

sive about the new band.

few of our favorite old-time recordings,
and started to work on them. We prac
a

ticed as much
week.

two or three nights

as

We'd play, listening

to the

a

original

78 versions

again.
ence

to

of the songs, and play them
Any dispute was settled by refer
the 78 recording. It was fun, and

great way to learn the older styles. We
tried to pay close attention, not only to

a

the fiddle parts, but also to the guitar and
banjo parts. We did not want to simply

back up the fiddle, we were hying to con
vey the band sound that attracted us to a

particular recording. Rather than develop
one style of playing, I've tried

whatever style fit
Bill, and

a

learn

to

Pat,

particular song.

lot of time trying to
decipher the mysteries of the various old
styles. We spent a lot of time listening
to

I

all

spent

a

Uncle Dave Macon, Frank and Os
Marion Underwood, Wade

car Jenkins,

Ward, and Charlie Poole, trying to figure
oid what they were doing. Because so

many of the early band recordings
ture

finger-picked banjo, I've spent

of time trying
I heard.
That
and

a

to

fea
a

lot

learn the various styles

is a

never-ending struggle,
never-ending pleasure, since there

were so many different styles and
tions used by the players.

varia

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Music
Traditional
of
Council

Piedmont
PineCone
of

courtesy

Gail Gillespie and daughter Nora Rogers.

you attend an old-time festival, one
person you likely will hear playing ban
is Gail
jo in the old-time picking style
the
Old-Time
editor
of
former
Gillespie,
Herald. I asked Gail how she came to play
If

in that style, and she wrote:
My first banjo ivas a no-name

loaner

Bernard Michelle, an Airman
Eglin AFB, where my family lived
the '60s. In 1963, Bernard, who was

from

at
in
a

machinist and was building aluminumrim banjos in the style of Ode, loaned
I had
me a ramshackle "attic" banjo.
first heard a lot of non-bluegrass banjo
playing on New Lost City Ramblers
LPs. Based on the sounds I was hearing
(mostly Charlie Poole and two-finger
styles) combined with hints from the
Pete Seeger book, and some finger rolls I
knew from guitar,

I

came up ivith

a

basic

thumb-lead two-finger style. In the late
'60s I learned a generic non-Round Peak
style offrailing (from Marty Schuman,
who had recorded Florida fiddler Cush
Holston). By the '70s, when I first met
my husband Dwight [Rogers], we real
ized my style was too brushy

to

sound

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Dwight, who was developing a really
cool brushless band style, was the obvi

began to listen to record
ings he had discovered of the Cooper
Boys, and also to Charlie Poole as well
as other less-known local musicians who

ous choice for a banjo player.
Flash forward many years later: in the

Carolina Banjo Collection.

right with

band and at that time

a

unthinkable not

to

it

play clawhammer.

was
So

early '90s carpal tunnel froze the fingers
me from

left hand, sidelining
fiddling. At that time I was playing a
lot with Alice Gerrard, who was doing
on

my

lot

a

of Luther Davis/Emmett Lundy-

inspired fiddling.

That

style-- done

at

a

stately pace and with lots of "breathing
room"-- simply didn't work with my

frailing banjo style. My old two-finger
style seemed to work much better.
A class from
ta in

1994,

a

Kinney Rorrer

at

Augus

workshop from Tom Sauber

a
few years later, and many helpful tips
from Kirk Sutphin inspired me work on

developing

it

more.

Beginning

in

the

late '80s and early '90s, 1 had begun to
pay attention to the local finger-style

players of central North Carolina, play
ers such as A. C. Overton. Bob Carlin
invited me to tag along on several visits
to

Piedmont banjo players who finger-

picked, and

I

appeared on his compilation, the North
In

'90s, Alice and

the early

visited

I

spare twoand
she re
visited
and
we
finger style,
Bert

had

who

Dickens,

a

corded three-finger banjo player Martin
Marshall, who lived near Laurel Fork,
Virginia. Martin Marshall combined
Charlie Poole-style runs with rolls

in

a

very
very cool way. My banjo picking
much a work in progress, but Martin's
is

playing

is

always hold in my
play: basically a hybrid of

the goal

head when

1

I

what Marvin Gaster called "flat chording" and the roll style
ton favored.

thumb-lead,

I

he and A. C.

use three fingers,

mostly

Poole) tuning, and

I

drop-C

Over
mostly

(Charlie

try to keep it

roll

then
ing steadily and every now and
punctuate with bass runs on the fourth
and third strings. And of course 1 had to
learn the neck above the seventh

whole exciting new instrument

fret-I"

a

�The South Shall Rise Again

to

There was a time in which old-time
banjo styles became more or less dor
mant among young people in the South.
This began when Earl Scruggs' dynamic
style reverberated
South, soon after he

three-finger

picking

throughout

the

Bill Monroe's

joined

Bluegrass

Boys

in

the 1940s. As with banjo player Snuffy
Jenkins, Earl perfected his own three-

finger style after exposure to rural mu
sicians such as Smith Hammett and Rex
Brooks. Virtually every young Southern
musician who heard Earl Scruggs and
became interested in learning banjo af
ter that date

wanted

Earl's

Although

play in this style.

to

three-finger

style was

not radically different from some exist
ing Southern styles, his sense of timing
and the chords played up the banjo neck

added great excitement to the modifica
tion of old-time music into what became
known as bluegrass music.

Nonetheless

the

powerful pull of the
was
not ubiquitous. One
Scruggs style
is
example
George Gibson, who was
born in Knott County, Kentucky, near the
headwaters of the Big Sandy and Cum
berland River systems. George learned
an

older East Kentucky

my dad buying me

Maybelle banjo

a

for $10. My younger brother Doug had
taken

the

up

guitar and

also had

he

a

talent for the banjo. He would listen
to the Charlie Poole records and show
me how

he

Charlie Poole was

thought

particular tune. I would of
ten sit in front of my dad's victrola with
my banjo tuned to one of Charlie's re

playing

a

cords.

would then play along with the

I

record, again and again, trying to learn
Charlie's style. My brother and I also

watched Don Reno and Red Smiley and
Flatt and Scruggs on television on a
regular basis.

I

then sought out people

who had played with Charlie Poole. A
major influence was Ernest Branch of
Marion, Virginia, who had learned in

person from Charlie Poole.
Branch had recorded with Poole's guitar
player, Roy Harvey, in 1931. Another
major influence was Ted Prillaman, who
had played for Charlie Poole to dance
and could pretty much duplicate Charlie
Poole's style. Lonnie Austin, who died
in

1997, had recorded with Charlie Poole
to show me

and Lonnie would take time

chords on the banjo. Norman Woodlieff, Poole's first guitar player, explained
to me how Charlie played without fin
ger picks. My dad also encouraged my
brother and me to play old-time music

Kinney is also a prime example of
a Southerner for whom the
banjo is an im
portant accompaniment to the voice. When
I asked
Kinney how Iris interest in the banjo

times because

his

father

and

few

a

Section with Illegible Text

style of banjo
neighbors.
George's grandfather, George W. Gibson,
was playing banjo in Knott County in the
1890s. This older East Kentucky style of
banjo features different tunings, singing
with the banjo, and the use of the left
hand to add fill notes.
Another Southern banjo player who de
veloped an old-time three-finger picking
style based on family influences rather than
tire influence of Earl Scruggs was Kinney
from

Rorrer.

and his style developed, he wrote:
When I was a child, back in the 1950s,
my dad brought home a stack of 78 rpm
records
Rorer

recorded

by

uncles

his

and Charlie Poole.

vated

by the sound

those

records.

I

I

1

was

ten

sit on

the couch

iel, Grey Craig, and Buster Carter were

major influences. My style of playing is
probably more like Buster Carter's than

Charlie Poole's,
buy

in

Buster's

fact.

even tried

I

Orpheum
wanted

banjo

continue his

to

I

style on the same banjo.

to

several

Though

I

never

met Reid Rakes, I listened to his style
via tapes, as I knew he played with Poole
and in fact loaned Poole his banjo for
what turned out to be Poole's final re

cording session

in

1930.

I

am honored

now own Raid's banin.

Though the old-time finger style that
Poole played in has not survived in

addition,

my

would of

playing tunes

he

learned from Posey. He would also tell
me stories of the ten years that he had
lived at Charlie Poole's house as a young
boy. In the early

the D

in

capti

would often lie on the

and

play "White House Blues"

to

floor doing my schoolwork as I listened
to Charlie Poole's 78s spinning on my
In

to

position on my Maybelle banjo. Other
local musicians such as Lewis McDan-

Posey

heard coming from

sister's record player.
dad played the fiddle

by taking us to the home of Bascom La
mar Lunsford. Lunsford showed me how

1960s, my interest led

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

popularity

to

the degree that

clawham

mer style has, it does have its fans.
1
met Kirk Sutphin at the Galax Fiddlers

Contest

in

1984 and

I

was of course of
with his tal

course greatly impressed

ent on both fiddle and banjo. He could
absolutely duplicate the Poole style bet
ter than anyone that I had ever met. We
began playing together out of a love for
the same music and have been friends

H

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Stephens
Jeremy
of

courtesy

The New North Carolina Ramblers.

r,

I

Kinney Rorrer, Kirk Sutphin, Bailey Moore, Jeremy Stephens,

and Darren Moore.

ever

since.

In

early 1990s

the

nine-year-old Jeremy Stephens
Kirk Sutphin,

was

took an interest

met

master musician.

a

Though Jeremy was

I

who, like

a

in the

Don Reno fan,

he

old-time music of

Charlie Poole, Tommy Jarrell, and oth
Jeremy also learned Roy Harvey's

ers.

style, which meshed perfectly
with the Poole style of banjo.
Jeremy
had taken an interest in the music by lis

guitar

78s played on his babysit
tening
ter's victrola. Jeremy had contacted me
to old

through

radio show that featured blueI was then

a

grass and old-time music that

Danville, Virginia.
I continue
to play the Poole/Carter
style with an old-time band that includes
a lot
of the Piedmont North Carolina oldtime music. Our band, the New North
doing

in

Carolina

Ramblers,

released

a

CD last

year that includes the styles and songs
of such North Carolina artists as Charlie
Poole, Buster Carter, and Wilmer Watts.
also feature old-time music quite often

I

1 do
from WVTFRoanoke, Virginia.
Jeremy Stephens is currently one of the
youngest Southern banjo players who can

on

a

radio show that

FM (NPR)

in

play both bluegrass and old-time banjo
styles. At age four and a half, Jeremy began

fiddle lessons, and bluegrass banjo lessons
at age five. This interest in music began at
age four when Jeremy's parents took Jiim
to the Ferrum Folk Festival, where they
bought him a cassette of country blues
with tunes by artists such as Josh Thomas
("Heavy Water Blues") and Dock Boggs.
Much later, Jeremy was influenced by re
cords such as Raymond FaircJiild's bluegrass banjo LR Beginning in 1989, Jeremy
heard Kinney Rorrer's radio show, and
continued to listen to the many old-time
records played on the show until 1999,

when

went off air. Shortly afterwards,
called
Jeremy
Kinney and made personal
contact. In the interim of 1998-1999, at age
fifteen, Jeremy began to understand claw
hammer banjo and realized the continuity
it

old-time and bluegrass styles.
Riley Baugus is a Southern old-time
banjo player, also younger than Kinney
Rorrer, who became interested in oldtime banjo through a different route.
When I asked Riley to trace his path to
in the

the

old-time banjo,

he

wrote;

loved old-time and bluegrass
My
music and was always buying records.
dad

He loved
ers

and

there was

to

listen

to

the

Stanley Broth
Whenever

Flatt and Scruggs.
live

music happening

at

an

�Seymour
Abigail

Riley Baugus

outdoor festival,

my dad would

remember listening

I

to

try

to

the music.

get us there to hear and see

wanted

per

play music,
but I didn't have any idea how to start.
When I was ten the school system began

forming magic.

offering
wanted

I

strings class

a

school.

in our

I

play the fiddle and
I
thought that was what they were go
ing to teach me, but I soon discovered
to

learn

to

to

that they had other plans which includ
Dvorak and Bach. Growing up in a
home which held closely to most of the

ed

Blue

mountain

Ridge

traditions

had no real

ways of life,
love for orchestral
I

and

knowledge

music.

or

did stay in
the program for five years and I can say
that most of what I learned has been very

helpful

I

musician.

in my life as a

following summer

did odd jobs
and saved my money until I had enough
to go to Sears Roebuck and order a gui
The

tar from

I

The day it arrived

the catalog.

banjo as well. We didn't have
much
money and my parents

learn

very

music with him

and feeling like the musicians were

to

couldn't afford

to

buy

me

a

so

banjo,

got together some scrap
wood that we had around the house and
and

my dad

made

a

I

banjo. We went

to a

local music

store and bought an Elton tailpiece and
some precut guitar fret wire. We carved
the tuning pegs by hand from a stick of
split maple firewood. We laid them on
the windowsill behind the wood stove to

cure them out

a

bit more.

We made the

head from a thin piece of plywood and
the back as well. My dad rolled a piece
of 2'/2-inch molding into a circle for the
rim. For stability he put a piece of ply
on the back too, but we didn't real

wood

ize the need for a sound hole. It sounded
bit like an electric guitar without an

a

amplifier, but a bit louder. I learned to
play enough on it that my dad saiv I had
enough determination to learn more. We
went down to a pawnshop in downtown

Winston-Salem,

North

and

Carolina,

it

used Kay banjo for about $80.
bought
still have both of those banios.

again and played

ten and he was eight. We rode the same
school bus. His grandfather played the

I

tuned

it as

well

as

I

could and played

most of the night. 1 actually played
until my fingers bled. After a few hours
of sleep, 1 woke up and started playing
of the day.

I

on

and off for most

really wanted

it.

I

wanted

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a

Kirk Sutphin and

fiddle

and

knew

I

met when

Tommy

I

Jarrell.

1

was

He

�Alden
Ray

Mac Traynham

started teaching Kirk

to

play the fiddle

was carrying my violin
to school for the strings class and Kirk
was taking his fiddle to school for Show-

around then.

and-Tell.

I

I

he had one and he

saw

saw

I

immediately became friends
and started going to each other's house
to hang out and play. Not necessarily
had one. We

music, but just to play. We would talk
about music and try to play some. We
long time. In fact we
get together to play music some
thirty-two years later.
I started
getting really serious about

kept this up for

a

still

playing Round Peak-style banjo in about
1982 when I started going up to Tommy's
with Kirk. I loved the way the Round
Peak style sounded and I knew that that
was the style I wanted to play. I had been

listening

to

Holcomb

and

Dock

Boggs

Ralph

and

Stanley,

Roscoe

learning

play finger-style banjo. Clawhammer
fascinated me but was difficult to learn
until I actually got to see and hear it up
to

close.

When

sometimes

he

we

were

up

ivould play

at

Tommy's,

the banjo.

It

was truly magical. I tried to pay atten
tion very closely. We would sometimes
go over to visit Dix Freeman, who was
a

great man in his seventies who played
Round Peak banjo as well. Dix

fretless

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

was

a

big influence on my

playing,

time when the Hee-Haw television show
was popular and "Rocky Top" was a bluegrass hit, Mac heard the Will Circle be Un

as was

a

of record
Tommy.
Creed
and
Fred
Cockerham
Kyle
ings of
too. Paid Brown was a great banjo player
I

was listening

to a lot

All these

who also lived

in the area.

ers influenced

me and still do.

Kirk

and

his

dad,

backed up
Sutphin,

Wayne

for us. At

were

must-attend

these conventions

hammer.

events

meet musicians from all over."

Thomas Mac Traynam was born in Vir
ginia in 1954. His father was a minister
who, when young, had learned tongueblocking technique harmonica from Afri
can-American kids and, as a result, grew
up racially aware. This was something,
Mac mentioned, he would pay a price for
later on in his career. Mac's mother came
from old English lineage from the old south
Petersburg area below Richmond, an area
near the Dismal Swamp. From this heri
tage, Mac grew up with church music har
mony singing but simultaneously watched

sion shows.

friend with guitar and banjo

Mac got Pete Parish's The Wade Ward Way
LP, and then heard more and more claw

we would

the Flatt and Scruggs Martha White

a

who had gone to Scotland and brought
back Shetland Island tunes. Also at Galax,

and Terri McMurray, and I started the
Old Hollow String Band. Mount Airy,
Galax, and Fiddler's Grove Fiddler's

Conventions

decided to get a foundation
bluegrass. At the Galax Festival, Mac

broken LP and

in

play

televi

high school, wanting to be
different, the television influence of guitar

friend, Luke

An old roommate

Ward, showed Mac the clawhammer hand
motion and rhythm and, as Mac said, "I

was shown the road to Damascus." At
Giles County College, Mac took a folklore
class that led to visits with Maggie Rader,
a fireball two-finger
picking banjo player
with the flamboyance of Matokie Slaugh
ter of Pulaski, Virginia, who played tunes
for him such as
Ray Alden is
past 38 years,

a

Cumberland Gap.
banjo player
has

collected

who,

over

the

old-time music

from the South. Currently he has been, along
with other collectors, issuing field recordings
as part of the Field Recorders' Collective. See
their website at www.fieldrecorder.com.

In

and harmonica from Bob Dylan and the

Beatles was evident. While in college,

at

To be

continued: Part IV of "Trends

Time Banjo" will appear
the

Old-Time Herald.

in the

in

Old-

next issue of

�Section with Illegible Text

Old Time Music for the Holiday

Season

Great old time gifts from the Field Recorders' Collective: Below is just a sampling of our CDs and DVDs, please come
visit www.fieldrecorder.com to hear sound samples and see all of our offerings. See our website for special sets and
discounts. We are now in our seventh year of producing quality rare old time music!

The 2009 Releases: Shelor-Blackard Family (FRC112), Obray Ramsey &amp; Byard Ray (FRC113), Union Grovel 969 (FRC114), Dink Roberts
&amp; 2 (FRC211 &amp; 212), Dock Boggs 1966 (FRC312),
African American Banjo (FRC209), Ola Belle Reed Radio Shows (FRC210), Tommy Jarrell, Vol.
Walter Raleigh Babson (FRC31 3), Albert Flash (FRC411), Fiddling Van Kidwell (FRC41 2), Tennessee Banjo Addie Leffew &amp; Claude Wofenbarger
(FRC509), Nee Ningy Band (FRC61 0); DVDs: Troxell Brothers (FRC1 003), Clyde Davenport (FRC1 004), Virgil Anderson (FRC1 005)
1

ALSO: Round

Peak Vol.

1,

The Balfa

Brothers with Nathan Abshire, John
Summers, Texas Fiddle Bands P.T.
Bell, The Hurricane Ridgerunners, The
2008

Renegades,

ALSO:

The Indian

Chirps Smith, Berkeley

Creek Delta Boys,
in

the

1

960s

Esker Hutchins, The Ross County
Dennis McGee and Sady

Farmers,

2007

Courville, Aunt Jenny Wilson, Heywood
Blevins, Jeff Goehring.
DVDs: Hiram Stamper and the Roan

Mountain Hilltoppers.

ALSO: The Kimble and

Wagoner

Families, Simon St. Pierre, Corbett
Stamper, John Hannah, Arnold
Sharp

Vol. 1, Ernie

ALSO: Clyde Davenport,

Carpenter,

Banjo

Bill

Cornett, Lonnie

1

2005

Seymour, Cecil Plum

ALSO: Band in Transition: The

Camp Creek Boys &amp; The Smokey
Valley Boys, The Roan Mountain

Hilltoppers, Norman Edmonds Vol.
Jimmy Wheeler, Marcus Martin

2,

check made payable to the Field Recorder's Collective to the address below. $15 each
$5 for US domestic priority mail (Ohio residents please include applicable sales tax). Please

order via US mail, send

$20 each DVD PLUS

a

check our Web site for additional discs and discounted sets. We accept Pavpal and credit cards on our Web site.

Field Recorders' Collective, 6206 Washington Street, Ravenna, OH 44266

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

CD,

d

m

The Field
on with Illegible Text

To

Recorders'
Collective

�OLD-TIME MUSIC IN ALASKA:
THEN AND NOW
By Peter Bowers

regular readers of Old-Time Her
ald are well aware, old-time music
is thriving in many areas of the world,
far removed from the tradition's geo
graphic roots in the Appalachian moun
tains. One such place is Alaska.
It may surprise some that Alaska has
a long-lived history of fiddle music that
dates back more than one and a half centuries-almost as long as the music from
the hills of the old-time motherland in
the Eastern US. It is a vibrant musical
tradition that first appeared in the sub
arctic with the early traders, trappers,
gold miners, fishermen, and missionar
ies, then spread to the native cultures,
saw a major resurgence in the 1970s, and
thrives today in bush cabins, villages,
and towns throughout the forty-ninth
state. Alaska is a big state (twice the size
of Texas), with diverse cultures, topogra
phy, and environments. Old-time music
is alive and well, from frozen Nome on
the Bering Sea coast, through the vast
hills and mountains surrounding Fair
banks in the Interior, to the state's largest
city, Anchorage (pop. 600,000), to pictur
esque Homer on the Kenai Peninsula, to
the glaciers and rainforests near Juneau
and fishing communities at the southern
tip of Alaska's southeastern panhandle.

As

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Collections,
Fairbanks

Regions
Polar

Alaska
of

represents

the

of fiddles, guitars, banjos, and mando
lins. Bergman, abandoned by 1913, was
a
gold rush trading post some 50 miles
from the mouth of the Koyukuk River,
a tributary of the Yukon River. A miner
wrote about Bergman in his diary: "This
town, for its size, was one of the tough
est I had ever seen at the time, and the
amount of whiskey those two or three

I

hundred people would get away with
a day was astonishing."

in

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Athabascan Fiddle Music

Origins
Old-time music

in

Alaska has its roots

in the great Interior

The

authoritative study

of

Alaskan In

encompasses

dian fiddle music is The Crooked Stovepipe:
Athabascan Fiddle Music and Square Danc
ing in Northeast Alaska and Northwest Can
ada, by ethnomusicologist Craig Mishler.

miles.) In

I

region and it is on
that region that this article focuses. (In
terior Alaska, as loosely defined here,
roughly 120,000 square
sense, there are two main be
ginnings of Alaskan old-time music: the
original introduction of fiddle music in
the mid-nineteenth century, and Alaska's
version of the great folk music revival in
a

the 1970s.

several accounts, the first
According
fiddler on the Yukon River was a Hud
son's Bay Company employee named
Antoine Hoole, who was among a trad
ing party who established Fort Yukon
in 1847. His French Canadian influence
to

likely helped spread the Anglo-Celtic
music and dance tradition to the local
Indians, a rich tradition that continues
today
sic

as

a

known

unique
as

style of

old-time mu

Athabascan fiddle music.
nineteenth and early

highly recommend this to anyone with
a casual or serious interest in this
music. Mishler observes that,
Outsiders may simply look at Athabas

either

can

as

fiddlers

Indians playing the white

man's music, but they couldn't
ther from

be

fur

the mark.

Although initially
learned from the whites, Athabascan fid
dle music has been cultivated in relative
isolation from mainstream American
country music. Playing strictly by ear
and within a strong conservative tradi
tion that is over [160] years old, Atha
bascan men [and women] have played
a

powerful, beautifid sound and

a

rep

different from any other
music.
style of fiddle
ertoire that

is

singing and dancing
melodic choral singing of hymns
introduced by missionaries. This music

Traditional Athabascan fiddle music de
veloped from two geographic centers with
in the vast Yukon River drainage. "Upriver" music developed among the Gwich'in
and Han tribes of the Alaska- Yukon border

and today is its own unique style.

years later among the Koyukon, Lower Tanana, and Ingalik Athabascans. Although

the

Throughout
twentieth centuries, fiddle music blend
ed with aboriginal

and

developed largely in isolation, with only
occasional injections of new influences,

area. "Downriver" music evolved some 50

Collection,

Library,

M. Hopkins

Rasmuson
E.

Elmer

University

and

oldest photograph
ever published of an Alaskan old time
string band." This and several other pho
tos from this period show combinations
this

David

Alaska

Bergman String Band on the Koyukuk
A Sporty Band. Ac
River, April 1899
to
Mishler, "To my knowledge,
cording

�Allen

Maryanne

Bill Stevens

the music is today undergoing newer influ
and
ences from country and rock and roll
some say is straying from its fiddle native
origins (a source of some disappointment

it continues
among some of the purists)
in a number of remote villages.
Gwich'in fiddlers were actively play
ing for dances in the latter nineteenth
century, and were documented at least as

early as the 1920s. According to Mishler,

the square dances that have been part of
the upriver tradition are most similar to
the old Kentucky running set. Versions of

familiar tunes often have native names,
and include "Soldiers Joy," "Girl I Left
Behind Me," "Saint Anne's Reel," and
"Ragtime Annie," while the Athabascannamed "Neets'ee Tl'yaa" is a tune that is

reminiscent

of

"Whiskey

Before

Break

fast." An all-time favorite is the spirited
"Red River Jig" ("Jig Ahtsii Ch'aadzaa"),

while another, more recent, popular tune
is "Eagle Island Blues." Some of the more
traditional sounds are captured in 1970s
recordings by Craig Mishler. The music

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

of

Charlie Peter of Fort Yukon and others

preserved on the 1974 LP Music of the
Alaskan Kutchin Indians (re-released as a
is

Smithsonian Folkways FE 4070).
Some musicians who maintained the
Indian fiddle tradition over the years in
clude Charlie Peter, David Salmon, Jimmy
Roberts, Lincoln Roberts, Bums Frank,
Silas John, and John Christian. A leading
Gwich'in fiddler in Canada was Charlie Pe
CD,

ter

Charlie, Sr., of Old Crow. Two

contem

Bill was raised in

a

musical community

was motivated to learn fiddle after
hearing a fiddler from Yukon Territory
and

named Paul Ben Kassi. In his twenties, he
moved to California for a job program.
There he connected with the Santa Clara
Valley Fiddler's Association and greatly
expanded his musical influences beyond
his native roots. He took the second place
trophy in the 1978 California Old-Time Fid
dler's Association State Championship,

porary Native elders who carry forward the
Athabascan fiddle tradition today are Bill
Stevens and the Rev. Trimble Gilbert.
Bill Stevens was born in 1933 in a log
cabin on a tributary of the Yukon River.

and competed at Weiser, Idaho, and the Na
tional Indian Old-Time Fiddler's Contest in
Talequah, Oklahoma. He returned to Alas

that Bill has probably done more than any
one else to bring Athabascan fiddle music

each year since 1983 in Fairbanks, bringing
together traditional musicians from far-

Ethnomusicologist Craig Mishler believes

to the

attention of the outside world, and

has helped preserve it for his own people,
through his performances, teaching, and

recordings. Mishler states, "It's no won
der they call him Ch'adzah Aghwaa ('He
carries dances') in Gwich'in."

Shortly thereafter, he became ac
tive in organizing the first Athabascan OldTime Fiddlers Festival. This has been held
ka in 1982.

flung villages in Alaska and Northwest
Canada. Today, over 80 bands and more
than 650 people come to Fairbanks for the
annual event. This past summer, he led a
group of young Native fiddlers from Fair
banks to tire fiddle festival at Weiser.

�Dunklin
Thomas

Trimble Gilbert

Mary Larsen, in her 1999 article on Bill
in Fiddler Magazine,

notes,

Scottish

and

Irish,

(mainly Orkney),
French-Canadian trappers and trad
ers with the Hudson's Bay Company.

Such
tunes as "Nihk'iidoo"
("Eight
Couple"), "Jig Ahtsii Ch'aadzaa" ("Red
River Jig"; actually a reel), "K'oonii T'aii
Ch'aadzaa"
("Handkerchief Dance"),
"Geh Ch'aadzaa"

("Rabbit Dance"), and
Ch'aadzaa" ("Duck Dance")

quickly adopted by the Gwich'in
people and have remained classics in the
music and dance repertoire. Also included
were

[in his music] are old-time tunes such as

"Soldier's Joy," "The Girl

I

Left Behind

Me" (recorded unaccompanied, as was
the Gwich'in tradition until the early
20th century), and "Devil's Dream,
standards in the repertoire.

"

also

Bill's music has taken him far beyond Alas
ka and Northwest Canada to such places as
the

He has recorded six CDs. Bill's

pilation

many of his tunes were brought to
Alaska and northwestern Canada from

"Dat'san

land.

Smithsonian Folklife Festival and Scot

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

com

CD, Bill Stevens: Fiddlin' Through the

Years, A Collection

ofOld-Time Fiddle Favorites

Tenth Planet Records appeared

in 2005

Another Gwich'in fiddler who has done
much to carry on the bush village tradi

tion is the Rev. Trimble Gilbert. Born in
1934 in the remote

of Arctic

mountain community

Village at the edge of the Arctic
Wildlife Refuge, Trimble has worked tire
lessly to carry on this musical heritage
and teach music to kids. Several years
ago, this Episcopal priest and Traditional
Chief of the Tanana Chiefs Conference
was honored as a guest artist at the Fes
tival of American Fiddle Tunes in Port

Townsend, Washington.
and his sons produced

In
a

2001, Trimble
CD, Neets'aii

Gwich'in Fiddlers (Tenth Planet Records).
In the past several years, he has been a

teacher in various remote villages with
a native
village program run by the Rev.
Belle Mickelson, Dancing with the Spirit,
this past summer performed on
regular basis for visitors in Fairbanks.
and

a

One of the remarkable aspects of the
lively traditional Athabascan fiddle style
that deserves a special note is an almost
universal tendency toward crookedness
(containing measures with more or fewer
beats than the main body of the tune), with
a license for the fiddler to
change straight
tunes to crooked variations, and to change
the number of repetitions (keep in mind
that this music has evolved

tion for over

a

centurv and

in
a

near-isola

half).

Pamela Swing and Shonti Elder, ana
lyzing this music in an appendix of The
Crooked Stovepipe, noted two common
kinds of variations: the addition of a
quarter beat at the end of phrases (often
necessitating the use of a 3/4 measure in
stead of usual 2/4), and holding notes at
the end of a phrase as long as two extra
bars. They observe,
...because the strong underlying pat
tern of the fiddler's footbeats keeps pace

with the quarter note beats, any extra
beats do not disturb the flow of the tune.
These extra footbeats do not disturb the

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

the Straw' was a high favorite." Many
other writers, including Robert Service,
the well known "Bard of the Yukon,"
wrote about the lively dances that were

rhythms of either the guitar players or
To [our] knowledge, no other
tradition of fiddling with the same roots

dancers....

so

much melodic, rhythmic, and

structural variation. One may conclude
then that the musical aesthetic of the na
tive Gwich'in vocal tradition has shaped
GwiclT

in

fiddle style.

Kyan Bowers, an avid student and per
former of American roots music, adds,
"in a sense, this crookedness could be

best viewed as
I

form of improvisation.

a

doubt that Native fiddlers consciously

think of this as changing time signature,
but rather are just adding or subtracting
a beat here and there." Track 3 on the CD
Neets'aii Gwich'in Fiddlers illustrates this
phenomenon, and this is recommended

example of what makes
styles
unique. If it were square every time
through, it might be the same melody as
"Whiskey Before Breakfast." However,
"Neets'aiitlyaa"' has evolved into its own
tune, which may be played in a different

listening
some

of

as

an

the

Athabascan fiddle

way each time the tune is performed ac
cording to each fiddler's improvisation.
Music of the Gold Rush

The Klondike Gold Rush of the late
1890s and the Alaskan gold rushes that

followed

(Nome, Fairbanks,

Koyukuk,
huge influx of EuroAmericans to the Athabascan region,
especially in the upriver Gwich'in and
Iditarod, etc.) saw

Han

areas.

Part

a

of that

onslaught

of

course included music and
humanity
dance. While the popular notion of the
Klondike, Nome, and Fairbanks dance
halls and saloons conjures up more of the
of

ragtime and gay-nineties styles, old-time
dance music was a vibrant part of the
miners' lives and musical repertoire. Di
aries and historical photographs of min
ers, especially those in the far-flung tent
camps and the log cabins of the remote
gold diggings, reveal many of the tunes

we hear today. One excellent study of
gold rush music by Jean Murray, Music of
the Alaska-Klondike Gold Rush, documents
many standard traditional songs such as
"Buffalo
Me,"

Gals,"

"Home

"The

Sweet

Girl

I

Home,"

left Behind
"The

integral part of the miner's social life:
Virginia reels, square dances, waltzes, co
tillions, and schottisches.
Murray observes,
...miners enjoyed singing, the theater
an

Cat

Came Back," "She is More to Be Pitied
Than Censured," "Marching Through
Georgia," and "Old Folks at Home."
One account of the day observed that,
"the good old fashioned dances were the
most popular. The miners and the stam-

peders loved the schottische, the polka,
the square dance, and such... 'Turkey in

was

their first choice
dance. ...Square dances, reels, and

vaudeville,

and
a

but

waltzes might be part of every evening if
a
fiddler or mandolin player was in the
neighborhood. Dances were a tradition
the

along

especially

Yukon

before

the gold

on the upper river

rush,
if the

number of times a song is mentioned [in
diaries and gold rush accounts] is any
indication of its popidarity then "A Hot

Time in the Old Town" has no equal. A
popular gold rush parody of that tune is

"Song of the Salmon" written by J.C.
Kellum in 1903.
During and following the gold rush,

old-time music was played wherever
musicians and their fiddles, banjos, man
dolins, and /or guitars came together.
This was especially true during the long,
dark winters people spent in their isolat
ed cabins and villages. Although music
was played for personal entertainment
and rural dances, it does not appear that
the commercial heyday of old-time mu
sic in the 1920s-1930s, facilitated else
where by radio and records, had much of
an influence on Alaska. A review of some
of the

commercial advertisements

in the

Fairbanks newspaper shows increasing
popularity in country music in the 1950s
and 60s, but old-time string bands are
largely absent.
Doc South: Mover and shaker of the
Alaskan old-time music revival
Many observers of the Alaskan non-Na

tive traditional music scene regard Har
old "Doc" South as the key figure in our
old-time music revival of the early 1970s.
I first
met Doc in the mid '70s and had
the pleasure of visiting the retired psy

at his home in Palmer, Alaska, in
March 2009, along with fellow musicians

chiatrist

Section with Illegible Text

permits

Danny Consenstein and Tom Hart.
Doc was born in Bloomington, Indi
ana, in 1928 to Garland "Jack" South and
Lula South. The South family's playing
is recorded in the Indiana Collection of
the American Folklife Center, Library
of Congress,
by folklorist and friend
of the family Guthrie T. "Gus" Meade.
Gus pursued

a

graduate degree from the

�Folklore and Ethnomusicology De
partment at nearby Indiana Univerand got together
play fiddle with Doc and his fam
ily on a fairly regular basis. Meade,
who died in 1991, left Indiana in

sity-Bloomington,
to

1961, and in 1965 began working at
the Library of Congress Folk Music

Archives. He
for his

is

perhaps best known

monumental work,

A Biblio-

Discography of Commercially Recorded
Traditional Music. Bob Black, another
musician, also recorded some of

South family's music; according to
Doc, "he used to follow me around
with a notebook."
Doc learned fiddle largely on his
own. According to Doc, it was his
cousins, living in nearby Sullivan
County, who "loaned me my first
banjo and fiddle." When asked what
kind of music this was, he replied,
"Back then it was all 'just music,' not
really country, not really bluegrass,
not really old-time. When someone
wanted you to play they'd just say
'bring your music.'"
A major influence on his playing
was fiddler and friend of the fam
Jimmy
Campbell,
originally
from Monroe County, Indiana (also
ily

recorded

in

the

American

Folklife

Center, Library of Congress; not to
be confused with the more famous

bluegrass fiddler of the same name).
According to Doc, his dad was 19
and just

home

from World

when he first met Campbell.

War

I

Doc

and his family played with Jimmy
over the years, and much of Doc's
fiddle style (which he later brought
to Alaska, what Doc calls his ver

sion of the "Nashville shuffle") can
attributed to Campbell. Doc said
that when he was 16, Jimmy played

be

him the tune "Stoney Point," which,

always figures, "somehow moti
vated me to learn more."
he

Doc increasingly performed out
side his family circle and informal
jam sessions. Along with his friend
Bob Black, he performed in the early
1950s on an old-time music program

a
weekly university radio sta
tion run by Bruce Buckley. Doc later
played fiddle and called dances on

on

the

commercial

country

TV

show

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Steve

grown up under the musical influ
ences of Jimmy Campbell.) Later,
up until 1970, while living in Laurel,

Stolee

called Hayloft Frolic, hosted by Bob
Hardy. (Both South and Hardy had
Doc South and Tom Hart (in hat) at the Howling Dog Saloon, Ester, around 1974.

�Stolee
Steve

The original Sidewinders,

1978. Left

to

right: Kent Setzer (fiddle), Tom Hart (guitar), Bob Brom (bass), Danny Consenstein (fiddle), Robin Dale Ford (banjo).

Indiana, he called square dances for the

local city recreational department. With
big grin, he said, "people used to think
did this for a living."

a
I

In 1970, having completed his university
program and now licensed as a psychia
trist, he moved to Alaska, where he got a

left the

for the State

sure do". They said they had a job at the
Howling Dog at Ester and asked if he'd

Bloomington
region's own old-time music and
dance revival. Had he remained, and judg
ing by his subsequent influence on Alaska,
he undoubtedly would have been a central
figure in that cultural awakening.

Shortly after moving to Fairbanks, Alas
ka, he saw an ad in the local paper that
there was country dancing at the Grange
Hall at 21-mile Chena Hot Springs Road.
He soon found himself playing banjo and
some fiddle with a band called the Pleas
Playboys,

consisting

of Milt

Fuller (fiddle and steel; from Montana),
his wife Ruth Fuller (bass), and Ron
Thomas (lead vocals, guitar). By Doc's

account, they played country, traditional,
old-time, "whatever we could play."
One day, his son came home and told
Doc that an old-time band was going to be
playing near the university. Shortly there
after

and

rowdy

ironic that Doc
area just on the eve
It is

of that

ant Valley

a

Alaska office, saying,
"We heard you play the fiddle." Look
ing these hippies over, Doc said dryly, "I

job with the State of Alaska

Mental Health Clinic.

couple of young musicians with

band called the Sidewinders named Dan
ny Consenstein and Kent Setzer emerged
from their cabins in the woods and, with
some trepidation, knocked on the door

somewhat

coincidently

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a

of his

University

of

play with them. Doc asked, "When do
we start?" The answer was "tomorrow
night." The rest is history.
he blending ot Doc s strong tiddimg
1

and dance calling with the youthful en
thusiasm of the Sidewinders is arguably
the

foundation

of

the

old-time

string

band revival in Alaska. Aside from
several bands playing the very unique
Athabascan fiddle music in isolated vil
lages, there were no other bands I know
of who were playing Appalachian string
band music in Alaska at that time. The
Sidewinders (not to be confused with
the modern North Carolina band of the
same name) formed in 1970 and were

originally comprised

of

Danny Consen

(fiddle and banjo; today an envi
ronmental consultant in Anchorage and
fiddler in such bands as Danny and the
C Notes), Tom Hart (fiddle, guitar; and
stein

fiddler with Raisin' Holy Hell and Lost
Dog), Kent Setzer (fiddle), and Bob Brom
(bass). They were joined on clawhammer
banjo in 1974 by Robin Dale Ford, today a

nationally -recognized singer-songwriter.
According to Hart, a local farrier-black
smith, the Sidewinders were originally

a
jug band, and didn't really get
groove of old-time until they re
cruited Doc, "someone who could really
drive that melody with his fiddle."
The Sidewinders were very much in the
mold of other young bands of the late
'60s and early '70s who actively sought

more of
in the

out old recordings of the likes of Tommy
and J. P. Fraley.
They spent hours in their log cabins dur
ing the long, dark Alaskan winters, avid
ly listening to LPs of the old-timers, and
to the New Lost City Ramblers and other

Jarrell, Fred Cockerham,

contemporary revival bands. In many re
spects, the Sidewinders were the north
ern counterpart of the

Highwoods String
Band, whom many credit with kicking
old-time music into overdrive, especially

during the "festival years," and eventu
ally

influencing hundreds

of

musicians

several
meet up with
the Highwoods, and finally caught up
with Walt Koken and crew during an east
across

the

country.

They

times without success

to

tried

�coast visit in 1974 at a festival in Amherst,
Mass. During that same tour, while mak
ing forays out of a farmhouse in western

Pennsylvania, several of the Sidewinders
made the pilgrimage to meet icons like
Tommy Jarrell and J. P. Fraley.
According

...the trip that winter was a tune-col
lecting and fiddler-meeting trip. Fresh
off the southbound mid-winter ferry from
Haines [Alaska], Danny and I drove in

our newly purchased $150 Rambler sta
tion wagon from Seattle to the farm in
the rest of the crew.

got started, the guys in Sidewinders all
got jobs on the pipeline and left town." For

to meet up with
We stopped every

night to play for gas money and inquire
about local music. Meeting and stay
ing with Art Rosenbaum in Iowa was a
highlight... 1 was and still am amazed
and humbled at the power this music has
to open people's hearts and homes.

The Sidewinders
were the old-time
house band during the early to mid-'70s,
playing at the original Howling Dog Sa
loon in Ester, Alaska (today the self-proclaimed "People's Republic of Ester").

current,

(The

locally-famous,

Howling

Dog Saloon in nearby Fox is not the
same building; the original half-fallen
down, rotten building was torn down
in the '80s to make way for the Golden
Eagle Saloon, which today stands a few
yards away from the original site). For
many of us who square danced all night
long in the original Howling Dog, there
are

indelible memories

of Doc

South'

s

dance call
ing, the non-conforming log and lumber
construction, leaning walls, beer-soaked
sawdust on the floor, and dance floor
that bounced wildly with each stomp.
wild fiddling and energetic

frontier in many ways:
of
us
came
to Alaska searching for
many
an alternative lifestyle. We lived in cabins
This

in the

was

the

woods without electricity

or

run

ning water; we moved far away from fam
ilies; and for those who stayed, we grew

a loose-knit community. In
many respects, our friends were our sur
rogate families. Although many learned
or brought music that had originated
elsewhere, tire music community thrived

up together as

the cabins in the hills surrounding
Fairbanks and grew up together, forming
in

bonds that last

Old-time and
hliippTa^c; miNtr was fbp rjprfprt medium
By the mid 1970s, the Fairbanks scene
to this day.

changed. For the first few years of that
decade, it was quiet; in many ways Fair
banks was a sleepy little town that had
been built of and by the gold rush only
seventy or eighty years earlier. In 1975,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

backwoods, low-income, low-main

the

tenance types like the members of the
Sidewinders, the prospect of high-paying
pipeline jobs was too much to resist. Doc,
of course, wasn't as tempted because he
had a secure (and vitally needed) job
with the State.
Doc remarked, "Once the construction

to Hart,

western Pennsylvania

however, that changed, when the TransAlaska Pipeline construction started in
earnest and Fairbanks was transformed
almost overnight into a boom town not
unlike those of the old wild West. For

him, it meant a transition to a new band,
the Doc South Family Band. Joined by his
sons Dan and Bill, Robin Dale Ford, an
other banjo player named Brent Edwards
and whoever else was in town "off the
line" (back from pipeline construction for
R&amp;R) on any given weekend, they contin
ued to fuel the strong interest in old-time

music and square dancing that the Side
winders' energy had begun. Especially
prominent in the South Family Band, of
course, was Doc's wife Louise, who sang,
played bass, and in many ways was the
"glue" that held the band together.
the midst of

In

pipeline madness, the

Tanana Valley Community Col
asked
Doc if he would respond to
lege
a
strong grassroots interest, and teach
local

traditional music, old-time square and
round dancing. Doc obliged, and did this
for five semesters altogether. (My brother
Doug and I first met Doc at these classes.)
As a measure of this music's popularity
in this frontier boom-town, Doc com

mented, "That first class had 47 people in
there!" He told all the Tuesday-night
sic class
on

people

Thursday

class,"

so there

mu

that, "Y'all have to come

night to play for dance
were some pretty large

dance bands for the class.
Many people currently active in the oldtime music scene in Alaska owe their start
to, or were at least heavily influenced by,
Doc, these classes, and/ or the old Howl
ing Dog square dances. These include
Robin Dale Ford, who credits Doc with
getting her started on banjo. Dave Mannheimer (currently an Anchorage judge,
years part of the bluegrass band McCloud) was affected by Doc, as was Tom
Walker, a commercial fisherman, and
Ken Roy, who later played guitar and
sang with Doc. The Rev. Belle Mickelson
was another influenced by Doc's classes,
which she "didn't realize until after
wards were classes, assuming instead
they were just big fun jam sessions."
for

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Wessler

Deb

Doc South

at the

Granite Creek Festival, 2009.

Belle, the mother of Bearfoot Bluegrass'
guitar player Mike Mickelson, is well

known for teaching traditional music to
Alaska's youth. She started the Cordova
4H Bluegrass and Old-Time Music and
Dance Camp in 1995. Belle was recent
ly ordained as an Episcopal priest and
now teaches music to native kids up and
down the Yukon River with her Dancing
with the Spirit music program.
Another Alaskan character heavily in
fluenced by Doc during this period was
Michael "Wolf" Cartusciello, a mainstay
of the popular late-'70s-early-'80s Slop
Bucket Band of Denali Park, and later
leader of the band Fiddlin' Wolf and the
Trail Boys, during his unsuc
cessful (albeit not overly serious) run for
Alaskan Governor. Wolf currently splits
his time each year between Alaska and
the area around Austin, Texas.
According to Doc, "One tall blonde fel
low in class had to drive his dog team
20 miles to Nenana [about 60 miles from
Fairbanks], where he still had to get his
truck started at 50 below zero." This was
Kim Blair, now a log building contractor
and superb mandolin builder /player,
who by the late '70s was playing with
Slop Bucket, and later with the Estes
Brothers Band of Nenana.
Doc and his family moved from Fair

Campaign

banks to Anchorage in 1979, after Doc
became chief admissions psychiatrist at

Alaska Psychiatric Institute. Doc contin
ued his ever-popular and inspiring teach
ing of old-time music and dance well into
the 1980s. At the Mountain View Commu
nity Center, he taught traditional music
classes until about 1985, when he retired
from his job and moved to Palmer. There,
among many others, Doc hooked up with
Kenny Karabelnikoff (a talented guitar
player and "my most regular attendee")
and Tom Walker, who came back to town
periodically from fishing. Along with an
Irishman named John Walsh, this became
one of the better-known Irish bands in
Alaska at the time, the Muldoon Celidh
Band, which played for years at places
such as McGinleys, Snow City Cafe, and
The Doc South Family Band continued to
play, in differing configurations and

some

times under other names such as the Thunderpluckers, up until the late 1980s. Doc
was joined by others such as fiddler Shonti
Elder (originally with the "Open Road

String Band"), Maureen Kelly, Stephanie
Schmidt (Bissland), and Deb Wessler (who
joined the band in 1984, was partner with
Doc's late son Bill and played for years as
Homespun). Some of the places the family
band played in the '80s included the Wil
low Trading Post, Montana Creek Lodge,
KSKA Alaska Bluegrass Festival, Alaska
State

Fair

in

Palmer, and the Anderson

Bluegrass Festival.

�Alaska old-time music since the 1970s
Since the great folk revival, old-time
music has taken hold anew and spread

throughout this vast state. With space
limited, and since this article focuses on
Interior Alaska, I just briefly mention the
each area
regions beyond the Interior
(think of large "counties," each the size
of states) deserves its own treatment in
future articles. Today, old-time music
flourishes in Anchorage, with the likes of
Brian DeMarcus (an original member of
North Carolina's Green Grass Cloggers)
and his band Fat Weasel, fiddler Sherri
Hadley, the Hamre Family Band, Danny
and the C Notes, and a new hot old-time
band, the Pilot Cracker Playboys. Talkeetna and Homer are two smaller towns

with a vibrant old-time music scene, the
former home of the Simpletones and the
latter home to Scotty Meyer, keystone
of the

Improbabillies band (with Richie
Sterns, Forrest Gibson, June Drucker and
Grant Dermody). Farther to the south, Ju
neau has long been a hotbed of old-time

music, with musicians such as Jack Fontanella, Bob Banghart, Sean Tracey and
the Panhandle Crabgrass Revival Band.
Seasonally, Robert "Bobo" Bell climbs
off his fishing boat, wipes the fish guts

off his

Helly-Hensen rain gear, picks up
his banjo, and along with his band Rai
sin' Holy Hell, plays in Juneau bars and

neiehborhoods.

Another artist with Alaskan roots is Ken
Waldman, who has drawn on his 23 years
in Alaska to produce poems, stories and
fiddle tunes that result in a completely
unique style. A former college professor,
Waldman has published six full-length

poetry collections, a memoir, and has re
leased seven CDs that combine old-time
Appalachian-style
string band music
with original poetry. Since 1994, he has

performed throughout the country as
Alaska's Fiddling Poet. Combining both
his fiddle and a repertoire of writing ex
ercises, he has led workshops in over 160
schools in 30 states nationwide, and has
been a guest writer at over 80 colleges
and universities.
Since the 1970s, traditional

music has

few comparatively large fes
(Juneau, Anchorage, Anderson),
many are small and below the radar, and
are deliberately kept that way. This may
a

tivals

Alaskans' "We don't care how
Outside" mentality. I noted
with some humor a few years back when
be part of

they

do

smoky campfires and blue tarps
sheltering participants from the moun
tain winds, playing in the shadow of the
tallest mountain in North America, and
square dancing at midnight. Those who
survived the night were treated in the
morning to a break in the chilly wind and
clouds, and strong cowboy coffee, rein
stice,

deer sausage and eggs, more old-time
tunes, and gospel music led by Alaskan

transplant Ginger Boatwright.

The Alaska Folk Festival in Juneau is
the largest and most well-known festi
val in the state. Started in 1975 as the
First Annual Southeast Alaska Folk
Festival, this week-long event now at
tracts some 450 folk musicians and sev
eral thousand spectators in concerts,

dances, workshops, and 24/7 jamming.
The latter is especially prevalent at the
old gold rush Alaskan Hotel on Frank

which on almost any night
the
festivities will see old-time,
during
and /or Cajun music in
Irish,
bluegrass,
its rooms and hallways. A guest artist(s)
lin Street,

invited each year; no other musicians
Old-time musicians who have
appeared as guest artists have included
Mike Seeger, Hedy West,
J. P. Fraley,
is

are paid.

Ralph Blizard, Ginny Hawker, Kay Jus
tice, Tracy Schwartz, Mac Traynham,
Tom, Brad and Alice, Bruce Molsky,
and the Carolina Chocolate Drops.
Other festivals around the state in
clude Fairbanks (one-day winter and

summer festivals featuring mainly local
musicians), Anderson Bluegrass Festival
(the largest summertime music festival
in the state,

Talkeetna

been well represented at festivals and
other events around the state. While
there are

the organizer of a small (here un-named)
festival at an old gold rush town south
of Anchorage actually changed the date
of the festival just weeks before when
word had leaked to the Anchorage Daily
News. The organizers wanted the focus
to be "music, not Woodstock."
Observations of a recent festival near
Denali Park capture a few vignettes of
just how radical the Alaska old-time
music scene can be: non-stop jamming
until 7 am, light-all-night summer sol

it

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

just north of Denali Park),

Moose Dropping Festival

(a

quaint little historic town several hours
north of Anchorage), and the Anchorage
Folk Festival (which sponsors several

events throughout the year). Another
small, selective festival which has fo
cused on old-time music over the years
is the Boardwalk Boogie in Pelican, (a
four-and-a-half-hour
ferry ride from
Juneau), which last year celebrated its
10th

anniversary and featured "Outside"

�bands such as Foghorn and the Wilders.

big events sometimes include
old-time music, such as the midnight
sun festivals in Fairbanks or Nome, the
Other

start or end of the 1,000 mile-long Yukon
and
the week-long celebrations in March
marking the end of the 1,200 mile-long

Quest sled dog race in Fairbanks,

Iditarod sled dog race in Nome.
Alaska has a lively dance scene, es
pecially contra dances. Well-organized
groups in Fairbanks, Anchorage, and
Juneau put on dances throughout the
year and host annual summer dance
at

camps

selected

beautiful

locations

Alaskan wilderness. In addition,
a
surprisingly large number of music
camps exist for a state with a population
as small as ours; these draw top instruc
in the

tors from all over the country. Two of
the big attractions of these camps, for
both students and guest artists alike, are
their spectacular outdoors settings and

intimate atmosphere.

The mindset and intensity of Alaskan
old-time musicians could perhaps be
best summarized by none other than
the late Mike Seeger. In 1982, Mike was
the guest artist at the Alaska Folk Festi

val in Juneau. In those years, the festival
ended with an all-night jam and dance
in the old Gold Rush part of town along
Franklin Street. I was playing banjo as

large amorphous jam and hap
end up next to Mike, who was
pened
at the time playing a borrowed bass. As
I recall,
to ward off the cold and drizzle,
someone had loaned him a winter parka.
As he peered out of the fur-ruff-rimmed
hood, he leaned over to me, and, half
part of

a

to

shivering, said, "You guys

are all crazy

up here!" Given the context of that night
and the untamed Alaskan old-time mu
sic scene in general,

I

think most of us

would agree, and would even take that
as a compliment.
Originally from the hills of Pennsylvania, Pete
Bowers moved to Alaska in 1974. He plays
banjo and guitar

in

the

temporarily-dormant

old time band, Five Buck Fiddle, more recently
with the Blaze Kings, Dang! and Lost Dog.

An archaeologist
ing firm

in

and part-owner of

Fairbanks,

he

can

be

a

consult

reached

at

pmb@northernland use. com

Acknowledgements:
Thanks to Doc South, Tom Hart, Danny
Consenstein, Robin Dale Ford, Deb Wessler,
Craig Mishler, Belle and Mike Mickelson,
Ryan Bowers, Maryanne Allan, Steve Stolee, Molly Proue, Trace Gentis and others
who have offered helpful suggestions.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

View of square dancers from the stage at the 2009 Cantwell festival, near Denali Park. Scotty
Meyer and Danny Consentien playing fiddle.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Gentis
Trace

�AN INTERVIEW
WITH MARK CAMPBELL
By Laura

Chessin

it's not festival season, Mark Campbell can be
found Saturday mornings in the back-yard work

shop

When

of

a

local instrument builder, leading

a

banjo

workshop followed by a fiddle workshop. Each
week Mark introduces a different Virginia-based
tune and breaks down rhythm, bowing patterns, and fingering details
with local musicians committed to bringing their playing up to a level
that reflects the heritage of Virginia old-time music. Campbell's new
role as a teacher is backed up by his forty-plus-year commitment to ex
ploring and preserving the traditions of his home state, Virginia. In 2007
he was designated a Master Fiddler by the Virginia Foundation for the
Humanities Apprenticeship Program, honoring his accomplishments
as a collector and now as a teacher and mentor of Virginia traditions.
He has won the West Virginia State Folk Festival fiddle and banjo com
petitions, the Cliff top fiddle championship, and the Virginia State Fair
fiddle championship, and is currently the judge for the Virginia State
Fair fiddle and banjo competitions. In the tradition of old-time fam
ily bands, the Campbell Family Band features Mark on fiddle, his wife
Marty (Gravett) on cello, and their daughters Molly on banjo and man
dolin and Mauren on guitar. They perform for workshops and dances
throughout Virginia. Mark also performs with Jimmy Costa (banjo) and
Jim Lloyd (guitar); and with daughter Mauren, Gregg Kimball (guitar

and banjo) and singer Cheryl Warner presenting a range of Virginia
roots music.
The idea for this article evolved over a period of a few years as I
experienced first-hand the evolution of Mark Campbell into an in
sightful and effective teacher: leading his students not just to learn
tunes, but to think about style in a consistent and specific way. I sat
down with Mark, a friend, neighbor, and teacher, on several occa
sions and recorded our conversations.

Let's

start at the beginning.

How

far

back can you trace your passion for oldtime music?
it

goes back to my father

guess
taking me to the Highland Games,
before I could hardly remember,
with the drums and the march
ing and the whole thing. I still love
rhythm and dance. I guess
rhythm
that's why I like playing dances, be
cause it's all about the rhythm. It's a
I

communication between people,
agreement between everyone.

an

When did you first pick up what was
first, banjo or fiddle?
My family moved to Waynesboro
in 1962 and our

neighbors were mu

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

sicians
a

and had cut
banjo players
record at the local record printer. A

folksong.

thought

I

ing. There was
in the area.

a

it

was very excit

folk revival boom

Everybody was learning

play banjos and guitars, and so I
learned both at the same time, as I
recall, pretty much in the same pe
riod. I was ten or eleven years old.
I
remember there was a music
to

festival

Eastside Speedway.
about
By then, just
everything was
the

at

bluegrass. I showed up at the fes
tival looking for anybody playing
old-time and demonstrated what

I

could do.

I

guess the old guys there
pretty unique that some

thought it
body was still

playing that style.

�Chessin

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

at James

River State Park

in

Nelson County,

Virginia. Groundhog

Day Festival, January 31, 2009.

Laura

Fiddle workshop

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Craighurst

Rob

Yellow Mountain String Band on the National Mall,

They stuck me up on stage with a
microphone in front of my banjo.
was pretty nervous.
I
was flattered they put me up
there. I think they thought it was
interesting that young people were
still picking up the old style, and
that was very memorable, the con
trast between the old and the new.

I

a pivotal time, wasn't it? Just
sources of old-time were still

That was

when

around and there was some hint that
this was something really special worth
trying to preserve.
Well, yes, that's what I'm saying. To
there's a very thin thread, you
know. Down around the Galax area
there was still plenty of old-time, but
me,

you compare the bands, bluegrass
old-time was like three to one, and
that's not too unlike the numbers
nowadays. There was a time when
if

to

the

of my generation
started
flocking to Galax.
really

young people

The folks who were in large part lead
ing the old-time music revival.
Yes. The young, more free-flowing
type of people were tending toward
the old-time. The more liberal peo
ple, to put

it

frankly.

l-r,

Connie Barnett, Armin Barnett, Carl Baron

Mark.

The more liberal freewith
a more conservative
flowing types,
view of music. You're starting to make
connections at the festivals, then, about
music styles. How did you start identi
fying the old-time masters?
When I first went to Galax, I really
I was so overwhelmed
didn' t know
by the amount of bluegrass I really
had trouble finding any [old-time].
But I had friends back home play
ing folk music and we started figur

Ironic,

huh?

ing this out together. I had already
got up with Pete [Vigour]. We were
in the church folk mass choir. One
day he and I were walking out
he was a year older than me and I
guess we were in high school by this
and he said, "You got a ride
time

home or anything?" I said, "No, I'm
going down to the library. I want to
look up how to make guitars." He
stopped for a second and said, "I'll
go with you. My dad's got tools in
the basement." So we started build
ing guitars. In fact, we each made a
guitar. During that time we started
looking up musicians around town.

Around town?
Pug Allen was our neighbor over in
Stuart's Draft.

He had

a

house across

�from tire Meadow Muffin Restaurant
I wasn't
a fiddler then so I
really

people down. "Come down and visit

and

didn't appreciate

should have,

him as much

as

Then

in

me.

Melvin was

I

we

I'm just off the Interstate."

retrospect.
started getting out to festivals in South
west Virginia Galax and Stuart.
Stuart is where we ran into Herbert
[Pitzer] and Harry Dickson, West Vir

before

ginia musicians, and that was

Listen,

these

looking

for

introduction

to

the

a

real

old-time world.

were walking across the outfield
and they asked us to come up and
play with them on stage and I had
We

no idea what the tune was. Pete has
a washtub and I had
my Sears &amp; Roe

buck guitar, and

went

to

was a D tune that
"The Cuckoo's Nest"

C

it

the

at Glenville
element showed

fixture

a

hippy

up, and he and

a lot of
people were
disturbed
that
here
were these
really
with
no
shoes...
And
he ac
people
talked
to
his
who
said,
tually
pastor

form of

of

you know.

people
music and

are

coming
music is a

of goodness,
ministry
Melvin fully embraced

everyone after that. Many people see
Melvin

as

a

second father, frankly.

He invited me out to his house for
lunch on the way to a festival one time
and he was learning "Dubuque" from

or

something like that. We totally
messed it up and then afterwards,

tape he got from a young person in
Ohio. I bet that Melvin showed me this

they said, "Thank you, boys, thank
you," and we thought, "Wait a min
ute, we totally screwed up the open
ing of the festival" and we couldn't
believe they were thanking us.

tape because he was saying to me, "I'm
Melvin Wine, I'm in charge of my mu
sic, I'm going to learn what I want to

a

learn and this

was really at this time that these festi
vals
small home-grown festivals were
popping up on farms and raceways.
Yes, the late '60s and early '70s.

Stu

was a town festival. It didn't last
long. When I graduated high school,
I moved
across to Charlottesville to
attend the University there. I met
Armin Barnett from Chicago, and he
was studying with Franklin George.
Armin and Bill Hicks were going out
art

in that area. We actually
"Alternate Galax Festival"
outside of Charlottesville one year.
We were tired of the crowds at Galax.
Peter Hoover, Gerry Milnes
and I
think Alan Jabbour was there. Armin

collecting

had

an

and Bill Hicks and Carl Baron, those
It was a
gathering of the young

folks.

collectors

that point. Peter Hoover
had just finished a trip up and down
the Shenandoah Valley, but by then,

I

choose

to

learn

a student of
my fa
student of the guy across the
river whose music I appreciate."
He also played "Wednesday Night
Waltz" in his style, which is very dif
ferent from the slick version most

to

do

it.

ther and

It

how

is

I

am both

a

folks learn from.

I

still play

it. It's an

absolutely charming piece.
Melvin was extremely popular, but

at the same time, his fiddle style is
very embedded in their family tradi
tion and it's very different.

Really unique.
It's absolutely
to
a

unique style, and
Melvin, there's
really get
lifetime of work. I was learning
a

into

something the other day, and

it gets
very particular sound. You've re
ally got to approach it on his terms,
a

in his

style, and it's very difficult.

at

the focus had turned over into

Green

brier towards

West Virginia. I went
over and met the Hammons family
and then started going up to Glen-

ville, to the West Virginia State Folk
Festival, and that's where I met Melvin [Wine]. That's where I met all the

people that

I

really ended up study

ing for the next thirty years:

Melvin

Wine and Ernie Carpenter and Wil
son Douglas.

Melvin Wine

as

older masters

seemed

of his role as

a

much

as

to be

any of the

very aware

teacher. Always inviting

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Who else have you studied?
Well, I was really enthralled with
French Carpenter. He cut an album,
or half an album, some of the pretti
est tunes I've ever heard, so I really
started studying him. I could hear
French Carpenter through Ernie and
Wilson Douglas, a protege of French
Carpenter. I started doing the circles
that Wilson Douglas did and I'm
really just now just starting to real
ize what the circles will do for the
French Carpenter style.

What about Virginia fiddlers?
I was
going between West Virginia
and North Carolina, and Southwest

Virginia hadn't really gotten much at
tention. The highest-profile Virginia
fiddlers weren't really as celebrated as
they should' ve been. They were put

commercial stage of Galax but
weren't
they
put into an institutional
like
I
mean, in West Vir
setting
on the

ginia, Davis and Elkins sponsored the

Augusta Heritage Series where you
could do workshops with those guys.
That gets to the issue of style. As you

were collecting, coming home and re
ally studying how a tune goes, were you
consciously saying you're going to play
the tune in So-and-So's style?

collecting I'm sit
them and seeing
ting
what they're doing and trying to
learn as much as can when do see
them. Melvin's got a very different
Yes, but as I'm

with

there

I

I

a North
Carolina style,
thing that really struck
me was the contrast. At the first of

style from
and

one

June, I'd be listening to Tommy Jar-

weekends

rell and two

listening

later, I'd be

Melvin Wine. They're

to

very different

fiddlers

resolve this

and

I

tried

my mind. A lot
of people were either Round Peak
fiddlers or West Virginia fiddlers.
When I was in Charlottesville, I was
sort of equidistant from the two but
I was
really stunned by how they
were really two different camps.
I
was still studying architecture
at that point and trying my best
to learn, but it was really rather
slow, so when I graduated in'77, I
concentrated on collecting. Most of
my stuff, the bulk of my collection,
really starts then. The following
year I came to Richmond and met
Harold [Hausenfluck], By the time
I
got here the old-time music scene
to

had

blossomed,

in

the

Wednesday-

night dances with Harold leading
the music. Armin pointed out to
me how Harold had such a deep
grasp of the music.
Had you already made that connection
between music and dance when you
moved to Richmond?
Yes. When I was in college, we had
dances. In fact, we had the Camp
Creek Boys come up and do a dance,
and that was really special because
it was Fred Cockerham
and Kyle
Creed and
who
else
came
forget
I

that time. Kyle Creed brought
his banjo albums up and sold them
up at

�Herzog
John

Mark Campbell

Coffee House. Kyle
sold
his style on the
really
world. Today, in every session the
at

the

Prism

Creed

banjo

playing

is

basically

domi

nated by a Round Peak/ Kyle Creed
style influence.
Do you hear something in Harold's music
that caused a shift in your own playing?
Well, the banjo and fiddle: it's all
linked. I started out playing what
some people would consider a folk
style banjo but it really is based on

Samantha Bumgarner's style, which
is a pretty normal style. And Phoeba
Parsons of West Virginia. Actually
she used to do vaudeville and she had
her banjo, but she had that
one deemed here recently

as
"a

some
loping

style of banjo playing" which was a
much broader geographic style.
Then when I was in Charlottesville,
I was
playing Round Peak banjo, but
when I met Harold, I started playing
my old loping style again.

"Loping," can you explain that?
To me the Round Peak style of

rhythm is "dink-a-dink-a-dink-adink", while the old loping style
is more like "dink-ditty-dink-

ditty-dink."

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Right. Now, what about the fiddle?
I
started out learning West Vir
ginia fiddling, and then figured if I
was going to play all the great Vir
the music
ginia stuff I was hearing
Harold was recording and learning
from
then I was going to have to
learn to shuffle. Harold's a big shuf
fler and it really fits with the banjo
style that he plays. He understood
the Virginia fiddle and banjo styles.
Harold is a unique fiddler in that he
does his own arranging. I think it's
brilliant arranging: firmly based on

Virginia-style

musicians.

You

can

hear what that is if you listen to the
collections of folks like Harold and
Mac Traynham, Mike Seeger, and
Skip Ashby.
One thing I've learned from Harold

was

to

listen

to the

bow changes and

the open strings and the very small
things Harold can hear so well. May

because he's blind.
Most all the musicians he record

learned from Harold how to listen
open strings, and also where the
bow changes and how a person is
attacking a piece of music. I've retroI

to

applied that and
able to hear more.

as
I

I learn more
I'm
think in old-time

music, it's almost impossible

to

sep

arate technique from the tune, and
when people say "Make a piece of
music your own," I think that means

you're going to take your I guess
your range of techniques and apply
it to any tune. And to me, that's put
ting you in front of the tune. And if
you have one style, you're going to
change the tune from the style you
it in to your style.
When I want to make something

heard

my own, I go learn the style that
my favorite version was played in.

mean, that might be an artificial
construct too, but to me, I like a tune
because of its style.
I

be

ed are now gone. The only way to
learn is exactly the way Harold had
to learn all his music, by listening.
Harold became an expert in that. Of
course, he was also a piano tuner,
so he knows his music. He can hear
that stuff so well.

You're listening to all those details like
where and when the finger's placed and
as you say, how the bow changes

Mostly where the bow changes. The
lingers tell you the tune, but it's the
right hand, the bowing hand, that's
all the texture and that's all the his
tory of that region and of that person

�and of that person within his region.
When I'm learning a tune I try to
imagine I'm just sitting there next
to

grass.

them, next to this musician and

learning

it

stroke

for

stroke,

fin

was sitting down with
these guys. So it's out of respect
that I want to learn their style. It's
out of respect for the person, but at
the same time, it makes it very dif
ficult to learn more than a couple

styles. I consider myself a West
Virginia fiddler that has pretty well
indoctrinated himself in Virginia
fiddling, but I really have never
conquered North Carolina fiddling.
of

think he was capable of so many
styles, and I can hear that he plays
tunes very different one from an
other. The Ed Haley style is a very
broad thing because he was very
well traveled and he was capable of
soaking up not just tunes but styles.
So you can't just play an Ed Haley
style. It's sort of a set of styles.
I

course, and trying

to

learn

a

nist has got to recognize that, too.
The old guys rue the fact that the
music has gotten faster and, in fact,
I wonder
if some of that isn't older

people slowing down and trying

tune but

This is true, too, and to me, that's the
self I put into it. When I'm playing a

certain style,

if the banjo player's not
going to be playing that style, I need
to change the style I'm playing. The
music is fluid. I almost have to go

I

broke them down to their bowing.
I was
just learning "Bob Wine's Tune"
and, of course, Bob is of the older gen
eration. He's Melvin's father. Melvin's

"triple lick" (as Harvey Sampson calls
it) is

very similar to Lundy's shakes.

opens up a question about really iden
tifying these specific regional styles.
When you study art history and archi
tectural history really small things like
ornament details can travel halfway
around the globe with trade and military
conquests. Do you think that it's kind
of a romantic notion that specific styles
are specifically rooted in place and don't
ever move? I'm sure historians think
about this a lot more than we do.
Yes. Well, I don't think that music
is so rooted in the hollows.
think
are
much
more
mobile.
I've
people
been researching Peter Hammons.
He was in Kentucky. Then he moved
It

What are you listening to? What are
you hearing?
Well, of course, I have the Lundy recordings. I think of him as
a
"strutting fiddler." Lundy him
self says that music back then was
slower and I began to think about
that: that a lot of the session music
is really highly influenced by blue-

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

I

time-sensitive
sensitive because
as

as it is

regionally

they're playing
the exact same thing at the same
it's

time,

an

if

indication

that

that

might have been the prevalent style

that time.
think what you have to ask is,
"Where was somebody at a particular
time and what were they playing?"
The Galax area tunes and the Round
Peak tunes, there's a huge overlap
at

I

Then getting back to this idea of a Virgin
ia style: how would you describe that?
Well, there's almost a one-to-one re

lationship between the drop-thumb
of the banjo and the "cut back" or
shuffle of the fiddle bow. I think

You've said that sometimes the distinc
tions in style are not that distinct.
Yes. I worked really hard to learn
an Emmett Lundy piece and then
was working on a Melvin Wine piece
and it was almost exactly the same
bowing. In fact, it was very difficult
to keep the two tunes apart once you

back and refresh to the basics and to
influence the people around me. All
of a sudden there's a commonality of
sound and all of a sudden you reach
that sound where it all makes sense.

your own style evolving?
Oh yes. I've been concentrating
much more on Virginia music and
particularly music from Galax north
because that's where I started.

to

enjoy the music before they're gone.

of

movement going on before

with geography. You can see the Em
mett Lundy licks in the new Round
Peak music but it's been very much
changed, probably by time and the
influence of modern music.

rhythm and, of course, an accompa

then every time we play something
like Sally Anne you play it a little dif
ferently. You pull a note here, push a
note there.

Is

lot of

the 1870 census. Style might be just

and probably the difference between
may have more to do with time than

tragedy to me.
Ed Haley played a lot of schottisches, polkas. And if you listen
to Jabbour's
collection of Henry
Reed, that's got marches, polkas,
and waltzes. I love to change up the

I've studied Ed Haley at length, but

studying your playing,

into western West Virginia, then he
moved into southeastern West Vir
ginia, then he probably moved to
central West Virginia. So there was
a

this music

I'm

it's got the big

And it's driving.
And it's driving. You know, you
listen to Lundy and it's delicate and
it's got a hop-step in it, which has
sort of been left out in the modern
session music. It's one thing I'm
trying to recall. It's almost more im
portant to be dance music, of differ
ent types of dance, than it is just to
be gung-ho hard-driving. There're
plenty of Southern Highland schottisches. Leaving those behind is a

ger for finger, because, you know,
the way I spent my youth learning

Well,

It's fast and

double bass, and the banjo is almost
a rhythm instrument. Almost an ac
companying instrument.

the

banjo

the

bowing style

style has

really

in Virginia

pushed
and in

North Carolina, more than in West
Virginia where the fiddle really takes
the lead. Round Peak fiddle seems
to have a more continuous shuffle,
while the Virginia style seems to use
the shuffle more sparingly. More at
the end of phrases.
I've always enjoyed the

breakdown

into its constituent pieces
and rebuilding it back up. To me, it's

of form

architectural construct: music as
a
flowing architecture. In fact,
in school I heard them call architec
ture "frozen music."
So when I play a fiddle tune, it's
breaking it down in time and for
me, space, because it's spatial. The
an

sort of

is spatial and the right
hand is breaking down the rhythm.
You've got the overall rhythm, then
you've got the pulsing within that
and then the breakdown of the notes
and then the breakdown of shuffle
within that. And then comes the flu

fingering

it, the fluidity and the em
Different
fiddlers have their
phasis.
little signature slides and holding of
certain notes, so I try to replicate that
with them. I try to replicate being

idity of

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

with the people that did these tunes.
a
way of a honoring them,

To me, it's

you know, playing in their way, in
their style. It means I've taken the
time to figure out what they're doing
as if they taught me. In some cases,
they have.

Most of the sources are no longer around
beside. The direct transmis
sion of traditions has really changed.
for us to sit

think so. I'm sure that when
War II broke out and the
whole idea of "staying home on the
Yes,

I

World

mu

farm" literally changed, that the

started changing. Many of my fa
vorite fiddlers died about then: Fid
dling [Cowan] Powers of the Powers

So much stuff
all those digital ar
chives online. Or, how many versions of
"Soldier's Joy" on YouTube? 150? What
we've been talking a lot about here is
building an attitude about studying the

masters and their style.
That's exactly what I was getting
to. That's why I think I'm so inter
ested in Virginia music, because it's
our own heritage and it hasn't been
studied as much as other regional
styles. Because I'm learning, too, you
see I've had to go back to the sources
and not only refresh but learn more,
so I have jumped into the teaching
role in part to learn myself.

sic

had

heart attack
Family
the night I was born. And Ed Ha
ley died, I think, in 1951: two years
before I was born. So there wasn't a
chance to learn directly from these
people. There wasn't that much be
ing

passed

his

fatal

down and, of course,

bluegrass came along

same

at that

time. Exactly post-War. Some people
say the traditional died at that point,
but we know better.
Well, direct transmission of many sourc

died, maybe. But the values are per
sistent, and the respect for styles. I think
es

it's part

of

a

larger

phenomenon

that

makes old-time interesting and exciting
to young people now: this new revival.
The move away from things manufac
tured and disconnected from human ex

perience, an appreciation for communi
connection and working with your
ty
hands, DIY.
And now

the

young people

is

problem
that there

for
are

the
so

many options. How do you decide
what you're going to play? I went
through my period of learning from
those meager recordings I had. I
wore out the Camp Creek Boys al
bum. With the coming of the web,
there are tens of thousands of outlets
for source material and now these
kids can sort of tap into that and tell
each other about it and then they
can go off to the festivals. So they're

This is a prefinding their values
but
now
the
screening,
screening is
not just the people that have access
to the festivals or somehow access
to music by accident, but they access
it because people of like values can
send them a link to YouTube. And
it's that easy.

think what we're doing in the work
shop is learning how to really break
down a tune. How to listen critically.
back to cir
Pay attention to rhythm
I

cle

and watch the bowing as

bowing

much as listen.

Oh, yes, it's all about bowing. And
rhythm. I mean, especially if fiddling
is based on dance, and if you think
about it, a fiddle had to carry all the
I mean,
baggage
right up through
the Hammonses. They didn't have

guitar. The guitar is very late to the

mountains and
I

so

the

older styles

really like are the styles that hold

down the rhythms necessary to ac
complish the job.
I'm really happy to have a banjo
class, too, because, as we were say
in

ing before,

Carolina

and North
and the fiddle

Virginia

the

banjo
tied together. So if
teach
fiddle
and banjo at the
you
same time, then you can develop
that style together and it makes a
are

integrally

lot more sense.

You talk about how

old-time traditional

place in the modern
world and I'm wondering how that
fits
or doesn't fit
with what you were
thinking about when you were study
music has

a

real

ing modern architecture.
Well, I guess I see modern archi
tecture as sculpture. I went through
the education that architecture is
the machine for living and I think

we live very differently now, but I
think socially the old music is better
community-based than our modern

institutions.

I
mean, look at square
dancing. At the end of the evening
probably at some point, you get to
hold hands
swing and look in the

eyes of every woman

in

the

hall.

�Mark

at John

Hartford's house, playing Ed Haley's fiddle.

And I can guarantee, I picked my
wife out because she was the best
swinger in the hall. It was right. You
know, it was right. There was a bal
ance
here's a girl that's 5'2" but we
could perfectly balance.
That's important to you: to connect. I've
heard you say that when you're play
ing a tune in a style that you've really
thought about, people stop and listen.
You say you play for other people.
You can play music to please your
self, and that's how you usually
start out. You've got to please your
self first, but you can throw a lot of
imagination into what you're doing.
You imagine it's great, but the next
level is what somebody else thinks
of

your music and

you've got

to start

all

of

a

sudden,

playing the mu

sic to please them. Well, it's been my
philosophy that if you execute to the

degree that the famous musicians
before you did, if you do it to an
equal level of expertise, people will
hear and know something's going
on that's special. They don't know
what it is. And the same with archi

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

We used to use a term [in
architecture school], the immediate
obviousy when something is im

tecture.

something that's real
but
ly meaningful
you have to think
about it.
We have our community of folks
working on style. At the jam
So you get to

mediately obviously correct.
Well, it has an aesthetic experience and
even if people can't identify what that
is

last night,

tunes that

Army holding

gun.

that's what was powering
other communities.
that

ar
memorial

is moved to the next level where it
becomes meaningful on so many
levels. Everyone's name is there.

You

and

community

can go and copy a name out
see who the contemporaries

name and so forth. And
down
into it, then you come
you go
back out of it. It has a million times
more power than a statue of some

with

just as

are of that

guy holding

a

gun.

Because people can connect on
level. It's such a simple idea.

a

personal

and

these

From experience, it's clear to me
music communities such as
Mount Airy and Galax have lasted
and prospered owing to their dedi
cation and respect for their tradi
tions. I will always work to build a

That is the

The Vietnam

bringing

the power of the community

lowest-common-denominator
chitecture.

were

style we've been
playing, and it was very excit
ing to play a new tune. So that's

exactly, they still enter into it.
It's like the Vietnam Memorial.
There's something right about it.
And it's so powerful. There were
people who wanted to put up a
statue of a guy of the Vietnam-era
a

people

fit the

a

of

old-time musicians

strong historical identity
it has always been done, one

friend at

a

time.

Chessin, who teaches graphic design
Virginia Commonwealth University, is a
fiddler and a student of Mark Campbell and
Virginia styles.This interview was very much
a collaborative
effort and an ongoing conver
Laura

at

sation through both words and music.

�I

Old-Time Tune Books from Mel Bay I

Old-Time Festival Tunes for
Fiddle &amp; Mandolin

Old-Time Cowboy Songbook
by Will McCain

by Dan Levenson
Over 00 Old-Time festival favorites
1

fiddle and mandolin. Includes
lines of tablature: one basic and
one advanced as well as standard
notation and suggested chords.

for

21 023 BCD

'

248pgs

$29.95

2

Clauson

Relive the Golden Days of the
West with this comprehensive
collection of music, history, and
the legendary characters of the
West. Includes melody line, lyrics,
and guitar chords.

95350

160pgs

$19.99

MEL

BAY

Order online, www.raelbay.com or call,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

1-800-863-5229

a

�So Why Old Time?
That's the question that propels this feature length
documentary forward
Why, in the 21st Century, do so many people across the
world build their lives around songs that were considered
"old" 100 vears aqo?
After

a

year of traveling through

Appalachia to create this film,
Horse Archer Productions

brings you into the world of Old
Time music to share in the
community and fellowship that
defines this culture.

Shot entirely in HD against the
backdrop of the oldest
mountains in the world, this film
takes you from house jams to
large festivals, from front
porches to the backwoods,
from up in the hills to just down
the road to bring you the
passion of this music.

Special features include extended performances, crew
interviews, and more.

WWW. WHY
You can order online or

order by mail:

OLD

TIME

COM

contact Horse Archer Productions

info@horsearcherproductions.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

to

�Reviews

for RCA Victor

The Carter Family-The Acme Sessions 1952/56
AP Carter,

between August 1927 and

October 1941. Ten years after their last
recordings, a "fast-talking minister and
businessman" named Clifford Spurlock
(the quote comes from Zwonitzer and
Hirschberg's biography of the Carter
Family) persuaded A. P. to go back into
the recording studio to make records
for Spurlock's Acme Records. A. P. per
suaded Sara's son Joe, who persuaded

Janette Carter, Joe Carter,

Sara Carter Bayes

his sister Janette, and happiest of all for
lonely A. P., Sara agreed to participate.

(Her husband Coy Bayes

stayed away)
recorded 58 sides altogether; the
first 26 in a series of sessions in 1952, the
They
JSP Records JSP 4201

Disc

1:

A,

4201

rest in 1956.

B

Pretty Raindrops*/
Side
Somewhere*/

There's

The Original Carter Family sound was
a

Bright
Climbing
Zion's Hill*/ Longing for Home*/ Rail
roading on the Great Divide*/ Live On
Down the Line*/ No More Goodbyes (At
Home with our Saviour Above)*/ On
the Rock Where Moses Stood/ Storms
Are on the Ocean/ Soldier's Beyond the
Blue*/ Sweet Fern/ Wild wood Flower/
Keep On the Sunny Side/ Sow 'em on

the Mountain/ I'll Be Satisfied* Room in
Heaven for Me/ Gently Lead Me*/ Ship
Ahoy*/ Hill Lone and Grey/ Beautiful
Isle O'er the Sea/ My Wildwood Rose*/

When the Sunset Turns
Blue to Gold*/ I'm Thinking
Tonight of my Blue Eyes/ Little Moses/
Western Hobo/ Beautiful Home*/ I Shall
The

Titanic*/

the Ocean

Not Be Moved*
Disc

2:

My

Dixie

Darling/

Wabash

Cannonball/ Meeting
Air/ Ship
Ahoy*/ Wade in the Water*/ Jesus Hold
My Hand*/ Fate of George Alley on En
gine 143*/ Anchored in Love/ Curtains
in the

of

Night*/ Angel Band*/ Redemption
Song*/ Gold Watch and Chain/ Worried
Man Blues/ Wayworn Traveler/ Home
stead on the Farm/ Grave on the Green
Hillside/ Waves on the Sea/ Wildwood

Flower/ Keep On the Sunny Side/ Moth
erless Children/ Two More Years (And
I'll Be Free)*/ Broken Engagement*/ The
Last Letter*/ On the Sea of Galilee/ Mrs.
Jimmie Rodgers Visits the Carter Family
(parts 1 and 2)*/ I'm Thinking Tonight of
My Blue Eyes/ Midnight On the Stormy
Deep*/ Railroading on the Great Di
vide*/ Wildwood Flower
*not

recorded

distinctive, wonderful, and capable of
being deconstructed and imitated. With
a

few exceptions, Sara sang lead;

was

if

there

second voice, Maybelle sang tenor,
and A. P. would sometimes add a lower
part, "bassing in," as he called it. May
belle played guitar, usually with a thumb
a

or

capoing so as to play
using C-position chords. Sara played
rhythm autoharp; less often, she played
a second
guitar. A. P. did not play. For the
Acme sides, we have either Janette or Joe
pick,

tuning

(sometimes both) playing guitar in their
aunt's style and Sara playing rhythm au
toharp. Judging by vocal range (Sara by
now had been a heavy smoker for over
thirty years, and her voice had dropped)

Sara is still

singing lead, and Janette is
singing Maybelle's tenor. A. P. contrib
utes his usual bass-baritone line, and Joe
sings, we are told, a few times.
Re-reading what I have written, it
seems like trying to explain the beauty
of rainbows to a blind person. It feels re
ally good to hear another two full CDs
of songs done in the Carter Family style.
As can be seen from the asterisks above,
nearly half these songs are ones not re
corded by the original Carter Family.
Some of them are already fairly well-

known ("The Titanic," "Railroading on
the Great Divide," "Gently Lead Me,"
and others) thanks to revival bands that

somehow got copies of the Acme records
of learned them directly from the Cart
ers.

(Department of Synchronicity: In the
New Lost City Ramblers DVD, you can

watch and hear Mike Seeger talk about
in her home in An
gels Camp, California, and hearing her
sing "Railroading on the Great Divide"

visiting Sara Carter
by

the

original

Carter

Family (see below)
The Original Carter Family, Sara, A. P.,
and Maybelle, as most Old-Time Herald

readers know, recorded almost 300 songs

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

and hearing her say "I'd really like it if
you did this song." Mike paused and said
"It's quite an experience to have a song
pitched to you by Sara Carter.") Some

are completely new to these ears (start
ing with "Pretty Raindrops") while oth

show what relatively common songs
"I Shall Not Be
Moved" will sound like when done by
Carters. There are also songs recorded
by the original Carter Family which are
being re-done by the Acme group. To
pursue the visual metaphor, this is the
chance to view Monet's water lilies at dif
ferent times of day. Have you ever won
dered what "Wildwood Flower" would
sound like sung by the Carter Family in
ers

such as "Angel Band" or

harmony? Or thought that "Engine 143"
would make more sense with a couple
more verses in the middle?
The only thing that keeps me from giv

ing an unqualified recommendation is
my belief that this should not be the first
Carter Family CD in your collection. If
you don't have any, buy a few original
Carter Family CDs first, and then, once

you are hooked, buy this. (Even though
there are the typical sketchy JSP "liner
notes.") Please.
PETE PETERSON

�Over

a

decade ago now, this Norton, Vir

ginia-based musician's initial commer
cial records, all made between 1927 and
1929, saw reissue on Revenant records,

a

label bankrolled

by steel string acoustic
giant John Fahey. Since the label

guitar
also reissued everything from outtakes of

avant-blues sculptor Captain Beefheart,
the minimalist drones of Jim O'Rourke
and the deathless two-chord mania of
rockabilly god Charlie Feathers, Boggs, a
quarter century or so after he died, found
an audience well outside the perimeters
of the folk scene that had initially wel
comed his rediscovery in the 1960s, the
one that heard him via college and folk
festival appearances like this one at Ap
palachian State University in Boone,
North Carolina. And there's simply no
way to hear so much as a few notes of
opening tune "Down South Blues" with
out immediately understanding what all
the fuss had been about.

Pensive, moody, at times painfully
hesitant and a small village away from
hi-fi, the stuff on this disc further proves
what a complete musician Boggs was. He
brought

a

seriousness

to the

all too

term "banjo

often either pre

phrase
ceded or followed by bad jokes. Anyone
with copies of the '20s recordings, or
better yet, the Folkways LPs seen to by
Mike Seeger, already knows the material.
This disc merely echoes the other record
ings' might, which doesn't mean it's not
indispensable. "Rowan County Crew,"
"Drunkard's Lonely Child," and "Prayer
of a Miner's Child" are perhaps even
player,"

a

more harrowing here than on their stu
dio counterparts due to the fact that there
was an audience present to bear witness.
If Boggs' life was more peaceful in the 35
or so years between his Lonesome Ace
recordings and Seeger's fateful '63 vis
it
during which time Boggs didn't even
own a banjo one can't help but wonder

just how much music like this weighed
on his mind. And it's difficult to say what
was more disturbing for Boggs, hearing
it in his head and not playing it, or finally
trotting it all back out again.
Yet, as painfully intense as his music
could be, he seemed to feel right at home,
telling lengthy stories about his record
ing career and subsequent retirement,
his account of the disaster that inspired
"Coal Creek March," which is perhaps
the most declamatory tune on this disc,
and even humorously of his own birth.
Between the ballads and blues are clogs,
light-hearted tunes and traditional piec
es,

including

a

rare stab at

clawhammer

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

playing ("Hook and Line"). Elsewhere,
song collector Kate Peters Sturgill, cousin
P. Carter,
provides not only back up
guitar, but a few tunes of her own, spell
ing Boggs. Unfortunately, his playing
behind her is awkward
at one point, he
tunes in the middle of one of her songs.
But once he gets into his version of the
standard, "Reuben's Train," which rides

of A.

on

a

suspense on par with Clouzot

Hitchcock,

you

forget

all

about

it.

or

By

closes with "Cuba," he
render all notions of musical

the time Boggs

manages to
boundaries quaint. Like other twentieth

century musical masters such as John
Coltrane, or the above-mentioned Fahey,
Dock Boggs worked within a well-rooted
tradition. Yet his music is so singular it
obliterated the very framework it leaned
on. Perhaps this has helped

spread his
music across boundaries not previously

delineated

in SDace.
BRUCE MILLER

To order:

www.fieldrecorder.com

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

ing Down to Jordan: Ernest Thompson
Go Wash in Jordan Seven Times: Rev J C
Burnett
Wade in the Water: Birmingham
Goin' Down to the River
Jubilee Singers
of Jordan: J E Mainer s Mountaineers

photographs are stunning, indi
vidually and as a collection. They cover
roughly the first half of the twentieth

"Record collectors and photograph col
lectors share many traits," writes Jim Lin
derman in the introduction to Take Me to
the Water, a new book and CD from Dust

while

the

in the

foreground, prepare

to-Digital. The comparison
The intimacy

of

very true.
experiencing an artist's
is

voice through the first-generation me
dium of a 78 rpm record is closely akin to
staring into an old photograph, seeing a
moment of the long-ago past with a clar
ity that's only one step removed from the
real thing. There's the fun of the hunt as
well; there's nothing like leaving an an
tique or junk shop with a stack of old re
cords or old pictures, and the satisfying

grime on one's fingertips that comes of
handling dusty shellac records or sifting
through photographs backed with that
powdery black paper used in old photo
albums. Take Me to the Water brings to
gether a remarkable photo collection
that of Jim Linderman, who collects pho
tographs of immersion baptisms with
a soundtrack
of baptism-related music
from the 78 rpm era.

The

century,

decades.

the majority dating to the first

Many depict large congrega
tions assembled on the banks of a river,

tism.

preacher and

Others

show

the

candidate,

for the

smaller

bap

gatherings,
and sometimes only the preacher and the
candidate are in the frame. In formally
posed scenes, all eyes are on the camera,
while in many other pictures all eyes are
on the baptism in progress. Candidates
are shown before, during, and after im
mersion
being dipped backwards, fully
submerged, splashing out of the water in
their soaked garments. Baptisms are in
rivers, lakes, and millponds. In several
photographs, baptism take place in holes
cut in the ice of frozen rivers.
The book is designed and printed in

Dust-to-Digital's characteristically beau
tiful quality,

in rich

photographs
are presented

fill the

sepia tones. Some
pages, while others
in such a way as to convey

sense of the photograph as an object
showing the full print, borders and all,
a

or

the board backing of cabinet cards. Spe
cial thanks to the designers of this book

reproducing the backs of so many
photographs. Collectors find that
sometimes the story told on the verso is as
for

of the

picture itself. The back
particularly intriguing, showing
heavy water stains, as if the photograph
itself had been submerged.

compelling

as the

of one is

An essay by Luc Sante gives

a

helpful

explanation of the various practices of
immersion baptism in different denomi

nations. Further illuminating what may
unfamiliar concept to some of this
book's audience are a selection of Bibli
cal references to baptism. The book con
cludes with Steven Lance Ledbetter's de
tailed and engaging notes to the music.
Tucked neatly in the back cover, among
be an

endpapers, is a CD that
will be of great interest to readers of this
magazine, a wonderful collection of oldtime and early gospel recordings of songs
about baptism. The disc begins with a
dramatized baptism scene issued by that
wave-printed

most prolific preacher of the early 78 rpm
era, Rev. J. M. Gates. The wish to be bap
tized, he declares, "is as much natural as
it is for a little duck to desire water." Rev.
Gates sings and enacts a baptism, while
the brethren and sisters gathered to por
tray an assembled congregation "amen"
and "all right" their encouragement.

Washington Phillips

then

explains the

�beliefs and doings of the various denom
inations in his "Denomination Blues":
"The Primitive Baptists they believe/
You can't get to Heaven unless you wash
your feet

the Missionary Baptists they
believe /Go under the water and not to
wash the feet."

After the hypnotic "John the Baptist" by
Moses Mason, familiar from the Har
Smith
ry
Anthology, Dock Walsh sings the

Rev.

first country gospel song in the collection,
"Bathe in that Beautiful Pool," with slide
A few tracks later, Walsh returns
with the Carolina Tar Heels, in a won

banjo.

derfully eccentric performance of "I'll Be
Washed," in which the suspenseful vocal
arrangement gives the impression that the
musicians are crouched in a dark corner,
waiting to spring out at you.
Elder J. E. Burch introduces his sermon
with a poignant reminder of the era and
original audience of these recordings:
The

subject

in

which we will use

at

this hour, it might seem a little common,
but it's true. The subject is WASH. You

wash-ladies understand that it's essen
tial that you wash your garments clean.
in the same like mind, our God al

And

mighty wants His garments clean.
The sermon gathers steam until the
congregation breaks into song with a
highly syncopated clapping and stomp
ing, a clever transition into the next
track, Frank Jenkins' super-syncopated
"Babtist fsicl Shout."
The album, which contains 25 tracks, is

well-balanced mixture of country string
band performances and African American
preaching and quartet singing. The selec
tions are well chosen, and thoughtfully
sequenced. My quibbles with the album
are few. One track seems out of place, Bill
Boyd and his Cowboy Ramblers' "Sister
Lucy Lee," a comic song about baptism at
odds with the deep sincerity of the other
performances. And while the sound qual
ity is excellent nearly throughout, one
pair of tracks, the two sides of Rev. R. M.
Masse/ s "Old Time Baptism" are taken
from a copy of the record with so much
stripping and surface noise that the listen
er has to strain to follow the performance.
The recording couldn't be more relevant
a

collection, but given

to this

its

condition,

might have been better left out.
Those are small criticisms, though,

what
to

is

a

very special release.

Take

of
Me

the Water is

presented

a moving and gorgeously
collection that readers of the

Old-Time Herald will enjoy very much.
SARAH BRYAN
To order:

www. dust-digital.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

This band has always walked

between old-time

and

a

bluegrass, espe

cially in the vocal arrangements.
lier and Joe

fine line
Jim

Col

Newberry have voices that

well suited for both, and Kenny Jack

are

son, with

a

background

in

bluegrass and
the old-time

almost 30 years served
trenches, also has a delightful voice. Al
though I miss LaNelle's vocals, the songs
here are still beautifully performed.
Most old-time bands nowadays are
lucky to have one good singer. Big Med
icine has four! It's not fair... And let's
in

not forget that they are all proficient on

many instruments.

Although this is not just
the songs stand out for me.

a

vocal album,
First of all the

choice of material is excellent, drawn from
sources from Jimmie Rodgers to the Wat
son Family, and Joe Newberry frimself,

contributes his own composition
"What Does the Lonesome Dove Say?,"
which the title of the CD refers to. Joe is a
top-notch songwriter with a gift for com
posing songs that sound timeless. It's a
rare gift and it shows in this song. And
who

ers of

instrumental fiddle tunes.

Kenny
solid fiddler and guitar and
banjo player, and, of course, a fine sing
er.
Joe Newberry excels on banjo and
guitar. Jim Collier has contributed to the

Jackson

is

a

recent return of the mandolin to old-time
music, and here he displays his expert

picking on it and on guitar as well. Bobb
Head, as previously mentioned, ties it all
"Lady of the
up with his bass playing.
Lake," from Norman Edmonds, is true

original version down to the typi
"
Texas Gales
Uncle Norm end tag.

to the

cal

Blackberry Rag" is a nice tribute to one
of Jim's main inspirations, the Watson
Family of Deep Gap, North Carolina. Jim
spent some time with Arnold Watson
when he was a young man, and he even
still owns the harmonica that Arnold
played on "I'm Troubled" from the Wat
son Family album. "Dunbar," "Brushy
Run," "I've Got No Honey Baby Now,"
"
Tie your
"Fire on the Mountain," and
Old Dog, Sally Gal" are all well played in
full string band fashion.
If I haven't made it clear yet, I like this

let's hear it for the return of "whoo-hooing!" I think a CD of Joe's songs is over
due. "Lone Pilgrim," one of Jim's favor

band and this CD. Do yourself a favor
and add it to your collection today.

ites,
capella, and is slightly
arranged
faster than the Doc Watson original, but

To

is

a

the result is, once again, excellent.
"Red Rocking Chair" is the

version

too many younger oldtime musicians sing and record too many
times, and I swore if heard it again I'd
scream, but this one is, again, nicely
that I've heard

sung by Joe and by Kenny Jackson, and
found myself liking it a lot. Their way
still retains power without causing this
reviewer a musically induced diabetic
coma.
Kenny trades his fiddle for the

I

guitar on "My Rough and Rowdy Ways,"
classic that the band handles
a Rodgers

masterfully.

"The

Waves on the Sea,"

from the Carter Family via the Johnson
Mountain Boys, is also well performed.
Bobb contributes some fine singing and
guitar playing on "Bury Me Out on the
Prairie," a Delmore Brothers song I wasn't
familiar with, and a nice surprise too.
Jim takes up the fiddle duties on the
Stanley Brothers' classic "Meet Me To
night," with tasteful bluesy breaks and
also
and

The last song
a fine
lead vocal.
final cut, "The Tombigbee River,"

sometimes called "The Gumtree Ca
and it's a lovely waltz-time love
that
song
always evokes for me visions

is

noe,"
of

peace and older, simpler times.

As much as they are

Big Medicine

are

a
great singing band,
also great interpret

RAFE

order: www.bigmedmusic.com

STEFANINI

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

The Singing Cowboy
Jules Allen
BACM CD C 250

The Clouds Will Soon Roll By
Johnny Bond

BACM CD C 248

Find 'em Fool 'em Leave 'em Alone
Jimmy Dean

BACM CD C 252

Singin' on the Range
Art Dickson
BACM CD C 243

Pioneering Canadian Cowboy Group
Charlie Herald and his Roundup Rangers
Section with Illegible Text

A

Lonely Ranger Am

I

Roy Rogers

BACM CD C 251

the British Archive of
Music
(BACM) is described as
Country
"a library of over 500,000 country music
tunes, history and biograplrical works,
plus magazines, publicity data, sheet mu

On

its

website,

sic, song books, photographs, videos, and
all manner of memorabilia and artifacts...
the

Archive not only houses US recordings

but country music from all over the world

where the media, record producers, or seri
ous collectors may come and browse."
The Archive's catalog contains over 250
offerings, including sets like most of those
above, whose focus is on less traditional
sounds and styles from the Southwest
that dominated country radio and mov

ies after 1935, and whose historical inter
est may trump aesthetic appeal.
These

performers, along with many others like
them, represented the evolution of coun
try and Western music as it adapted to
evolving tastes and new mediums. They
achieved varying degrees of stardom, do
ing so less as bold stylists or innovators
than as journeymen entertainers respond

ing to the tastes of their record, radio, TV,
film, and

community audiences.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Unless

BACM's

mistaken,

I'm

diverse

catalog takes advantage of computer tech
nology to produce CDs and printed notes
in

limited quantities.

If

the

on-demand

process isn't particularly profitable, it is an
efficient way to make obscure and over
looked material available, allowing both
individuals and institutions to build repre
sentative to comprehensive country music

reference collections without huge invest
ments. Transfers are usually made from
collector copies of commercial pressings, so
sound quality can vary from track to track
and from one set to another. Nevertheless,
the following collections perform a service
and provide

documentation

of artists and

songs unavailable elsewhere.
Jules Allen U88d-iy4ZJ was

a

working iex-

cowboy who made early (1928-29) ver
sions of songs that even then had become
part of the folk song canon, thanks to John
Lomax and other collectors. Sylistically Al
len is a forerunner of Burl Ives, whose lowas

key vocals, simple guitar accompaniments,
and preference for narrative songs were a

catalyst in the folk revival a generation later.
Unhappily a few others are in a harsh black
face dialect;

at

least one ("Po' Mourner")

is

offensive enough that a warning about its
content would have been appropriate.
Oklahoma-born
Johnny Bond (1915for writing some
is
remembered
1978)
classic country songs ("Ten Little Bottles,"
"Cimarron," "I Wonder Where You Are
Tonight," among others), for his long
residency on Gene Autry's Melody Ranch
CBS radio show, and for his book-length

treatises on Tex Ritter and the recordings
of Jimmie Rodgers. This CD is compiled
from 1950s broadcast transriptions and
commercial discs, and some tracks are ap
parently published here for the first time.

1928) is another Texan,
performing career took off in

Jimmy Dean
his

(b.

though
Washington, DC, where he was discharged
from the Air Force in 1948. Sporting an ac
cordion, Dean and his Texas Wildcats host

a local TV show in the early '50s that fos
tered the developing careers of Roy Clark,
Billy Grammer, and Patsy Cline. Its success

ed

led to further Jimmy Dean TV shows in 1957
(CBS) and 1965 (ABC), before he graduated
from show biz to become the titular head of

successful sausage factory in 1968. These
recordings include the early hits "Bummin'
Around" (1952) and "Big Blue Diamonds"
a

(1955), but not Dean's biggest success, "Big
from 1961. Incidentally, the un

Bad John"

identified bluegrass banjo player on the
cover snapshot is Smitty Irvin.
Art Dickson's name is new to me. He

composed original cowboys songs

in the

�1930s and '40s, and recorded a number of
them with his Lone Star Serenaders and
Harmonicowboys on 1940s Lang-Worth
radio transcriptions, which included cov
er versions of other contemporary coun

songs. Dickson's singing style is old
fashioned and a little stentorian; his band
features prominent accordion and violin.
try

Charlie Herald (1891-1960) from Mani
with his Roundup Rangers

toba recorded
from 1933-35,

who mixed

a
group of young musicians
Scots-Irish dance tunes with

cowboy-theme songs and old standards, a
unique fomula designed to match western

Canadian tastes.
Fiddle, accordion, and
harmonica are featured, and the leader's
exuberant tuba is prominent too.
Even
though most of Herald's records were made
for RCA in Montreal, their sound quality is
barely adequate, and some pressings used
for remastering have audible wear.
The Roy Rogers collection assembles se
lected solo recordings from 1938-52. Un
like Gene Autry, Roy didn't have many
record hits, even though his movies were

always popular. The sources are Colum
bia, RCA, and Decca 78 rpm discs

original sound quality
ter than the

is

whose

considerably bet

low-end transfers on this CD.

DICK SPOTTSWOOD
To order:

www.bacm.users.btopenworld.com/

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�The New Lost City Ramblers
I've Always

Been

a

Rambler

Yasha Aginsky

lEDET^BONSOIR.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Dvds

Arhoolie AF DVD 204

Some time in the middle of this wonder

Schwarz tells the story of
who
came up to him after a
somebody
Ramblers performance, and said "I've
did you
been wanting to ask you.
want the violin to make those noises?"
If you play old-time music (especially
ful film, Tracy

fiddle) you can appreciate this story.
Perhaps the greatest contribution that
the Ramblers have made was to show
us that yes, you DO want the violin to
make those noises, and what's more, it's
fun to listen and dance to, and best of
all, to make them yourself.
Are there any of us who are unaware
of our debt to the

blers?

To

New Lost City Ram

generalize:

I

know very few

whose involvement with old-time
music cannot be traced to the New Lost
of us

City Ramblers

either directly to them,
through listening to Highwoods or
Fuzzy Mountain, who in turn got start
ed by the Ramblers, or a later genera
tion. Now that the Ramblers have, sadly,
played their last concert, a fifty-year ret
rospective seems a fitting tribute. Thanks
or

Yasha Aginsky, Arhoolie, and others,
we have that tribute.
This film shows the history of the NLCR
to

both in interviews and with concert foot

age from their formation in 1958 until
almost the present day. The film is not
chronological; we see John Cohen, Mike
Seeger, Tom Paley, and Tracy Schwarz as

young twenty-somethings, the older men
in their seventies that they are today, and
everything in between. Long hair and

drop with
time and go back up as we go back to

beards come and go, voices

young Ramblers.
One of the things that pleasantly sur
prised me was how much footage was
available from the early years. In one
of Pete

Seeger's "Johnny Appleseed"
columns from the mid-'60s, he com
plained about how humanity was los
ing the opportunity to SEE and hear

�a

lot

of

music because

a

good video

camera cost about ten thousand bucks.
Fortunately for us and for this film,
people thought the NLCR worth re
cording, so we have not only the Folk
ways records from those days but also
video recordings and films made at
concerts and TV shows. There are also
many short segments of the Ramblers
with rediscovered old-time musicians
from this time period.
This is not a conventional movie. It does
not have a plot, nor does it discuss ex
cept briefly the obstacles that have been
overcome if you have spent your adult
lifetime having always been a Rambler.
Moreover, this film is not all about the
NLCR, but features footage of other
musicians. Some the Ramblers discov
ered, or rediscovered: Clarence Ashley,
the Balfas, Sara Carter, Elizabeth Cotten,
Roscoe Holcomb. Some are among those
they have inspired: David Grisman, Rayna Gellert, the Carolina Chocolate
Drops.
But the focus is on the Ramblers them
selves, their singing, playing, and inter
actions with each other.
I don't believe that
any piece of music is
in
its
performed
entirety; you get a verse,
chorus, and an instrumental break, and
then on to the next song or topic. To get

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�the whole

song, you'll need to buy one
you won't be able to

of the NLCR CDs

watch them, but you'll hear them doing
it. At one point there is a voice-over by
Bob Dylan, saying how the band listened
to all those old 78s and field recordings
and selected out the best, and that "the
Ramblers themselves have stood the test
of time, just like the

originals."
Many people in the old-time commu
nity understood how important it was
that this film be made and supported
it

during

its

production.

Particular

due not just to director Aginbut.
to
sky
Suzy Thompson, who is one
of the three producers listed in cred
its at the end. What we get to see on
the DVD is the result of many hours
spent watching and listening to film,
videos, and still shots, and putting it
all together. Thanks in part to Suzy's
drive, Mike Seeger was able to see and
enjoy the final cut of I've Always Been
a few
months before he left
a Rambler
us. The last song of the film is the Delmore Brothers' "Gonna Lay Down My
Old Guitar." I cried.
Dr nnorl
caw "Romm m pnrl pH ?"
credit

is

T

PETE PETERSON
To order:

www.alwaysbeenarambler.org

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�which, of course, was one of the aims of
the show in the first place. The programs
on these DVDs come from the time when
Flatt and Scruggs were for the most part
still playing for the friends and neigh
bors down home, before "The Ballad of
Jed Clampett" and the theme from Bonnie
and Clyde carried them to national atten
tion and brought about a sea change to
their repertoire. In the notes to the DVDs
Scruggs is quoted as saying that the tar
get audience for the shows was "mainly
rural people," and that the broadcasts
were scheduled
around suppertime
when viewers would be done working in
the fields for the day.
There is plenty of wonderful music on
these DVDs, as there is on earlier volumes
series. To paraphrase Lester Flatt:
Gang around the old TV set and enjoy
some of the finest music the South had to
in the

offer.

Goodness gracious, it's good!
PAUL

To order:

F.

WELLS

www.shanachie.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�right across the planet? How much was
lost when fiddlers in the 1930s started
overwriting their memory banks with

Nashville

recordings

or

professional

"barn dance" radio broadcasts of "Black
Mountain Rag" and "Rubber Dolly/' or

sweet innovative

swing music of
territory dance bands like Milton
Brown's and Bob Wills' out in Texas?
At the Titanic contests and conventions
Dr. Goertzen discusses, such as Athens,
Alabama, Galax, Virginia, and Weiser,
Idaho, as well as some of the smaller
regional events such as the annual con
test in Tuscaloosa, Alabama, only a small
number of the hundreds of fiddlers in at
tendance sign up for the contest. Many
shun the contest entirely, keeping to
the
the

themselves

their

and

in the tent islands

picking buddies
festival camp

in the

grounds or nests of folding chairs down
the hallway, where jam sessions (often
unfriendly toward outsiders) and social
izing are paramount. Likewise, most of
the diehard contest fiddlers never bother
to wander over to visit the bluegrass,
Irish, Appalachian, or swing music sub
urbs at these big events. In post-folk
song revival and post-fiddlers' associa
tion times, walls have been mortared up
between those who like fiddle contests
and those who don't, and everybody's
biases now have a venue. A book like
Chris Goertzen's can help everyone see
some of the broader history of contesting
and help us consider adopting a more
generous and informed view of fiddlers'
contests in the richly complicated flow of
time, taste, and music.
Weiser style, along with the Appala
chian-based generalized fiddle style,
which are the two major non-regional
viral fiddle styles (there are others, such
as Irish

fiddling and Cajun fiddling, but

these nationalized styles have, as far as
can tell, virtually no impact at major
old-time fiddlers' contests) are forcing
I

out of existence or driving underground
great regional and ethnic fiddling styles
and old dance music repertoires. People
like Chris Goertzen prefer cultural versa
tility, diversity, complexity, and choice,

but, as he says in a valuable section on
Senator George Cecil McLeod and his

fiddling family

in

Mississippi,

today's

one not very
(contest) "purist attitude
tolerant of heterogeneity of repertoire or
style." (Readers of OTH will recall Chris
Goertzen's article on McLeod in the No

vember-December 2008 issue, and

a

pre

vious article on McLeod in the fall 2004
issue of American Music.)

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

In

another insightful

ertzen writes about

a

observation,

Go

state fiddle contest

Jackson, Mississippi, that is happily
decorated with numerous child violin
ists. Goertzen takes up the issue and his
account will sound familiar to those who
take part in fiddle contests anywhere in
North America:
in

this contest is primarily for kids
and few are skilled. That most are new
to the craft is made clear by who accom
panies them. Some have their parents
on

stage, but most have

supporting

their teachers

them on guitar. Two studios

dominate.

...a

proficient

in

solid professional fiddler

various American

styles

Irish fiddling, teaches
most of the kids who actually sound like
fiddlers. Even more youngsters study
and

in

modern

who are classical musi
a couple
cians but know little about fiddling. It's

with

common nationwide for violin students
in the Suzuki method to be dragged to
any chance to perform
them."
But, however cute
"good for
these kids may be, and however valuable

fiddle contests:
is

them the experience may be, when
they arrive in droves the beginners' por
tion of any fiddle contest becomes excru
ciating for the audience. If these children
to

skipped the contest, would it shrink out
of existence? Or would more real fid
dlers show up? Will some of the budding

violinists

seduced by fiddling?
have
been to contests where
Many
that scenario is replicated.
Goertzen
wonders if the scores of "cute" and
amazing young violinists in contests are
be

of us

helpful

not helpful in nourishing the

or

deeper traditions and the time-honored
community of vernacular fiddle music,
a community where fiddlers used to pay
their dues before being crowned by the
tribal elders. It is a tough question, and
anyone who comments on the absurdity
of a well-polished teenage violin student
fiddling memorized book tunes in an
old-time fiddler's contest "against," let's
say, Buddy Thomas, Joe Pancerewski,
Pete McMahan, Tommy Jarrell, or Major
Franklin always sounds inappropriate

narrow-minded.
Goertzen's discussion of the big events

between contests in the Appalachians
and Southeast, where the competitions
are "ensemble oriented" with many di
visions for different kinds of bands and
instruments and where the banjo (the
banjo!) is still respected, and contests
in the Midwest and West where most
fiddlers' contests focus solely on the
violin (often there is a category for best
accompanist, which there means best
swine guitarist).
At Weiser, the contest claims to be "na
tional." But this is much too ambitious
and

nection between fiddling and dancing
has snapped under the weight of Weiserstyle fiddle and guitar playing (accom
paniment style is crucial to the overall
effect), and through the evaporation of
old-time dancing in many communities.
As Phil and

Galax,

the

author writes about
drawbacks of festival

gigantism were said

to be

virulently ac

tive." He confirms the presence of the
virus but winds up having a fine time.
Goertzen draws important distinctions

Vivian Williams often say,

many excellent young contest fiddlers
have never seen anybody square dance,
nor have they had the opportunity to
play for dancers. The administration
Weiser actively supports and tries to
attract concert violinists-cum-old-timefiddlers, professional fiddlers from coun
try

the

experi

ing "the" national contest. As Goertzen
writes, Weiser does fit the bill as "argu
ably the largest American fiddle contest
and certainly the one that is the most
broadly publicized and most efficiently
run." I'll vouch for that.
As Goertzen implies throughout his
book, fiddle contests once were danceoriented. A good, seasoned dance fiddler
with good "drive" and a good tune could
do well in the competition. This old con

like Galax and Hallettsville are impor
tant features of his book. At these large
and successful festivals with contests
as

my

recent years.) Only in the 1960s did the
Weiser chamber of commerce crank its
PR into overdrive and lay claim to host

at

"all

In

several other contests have been
as important and attractive to fiddlers
over the years, not least the big bash in
the hills near Galax, Virginia. In its early
years in the 1950s, the Weiser administra
tors used the word "national" simply to
mean that anyone from any state in the
Union (and Canada, too) was invited to
compete. (We had one of those national
contests in Salisbury, Missouri, in 1967,
modeled on Weiser, and a bunch more in
the very strange place called Branson in

and

attached,

self-congratulatory.

ence,

music shows, Nashville cats, young
entertainers, and anybody with a Texas
address. But even these pooh bahs of
the profession won't win at Weiser un
less they perform in the national contest
style and can fiddle "Sally Johnson" and
"I Don't Love Nobody" pretty much like
Mark O'Connor or Terry Morris did it

�decades
favorite

ago (fill in the blank for your

Texas-based National Contest
Style champ). But remember that fiddle
contests have always been for listening.
They've always been concerts.
Goertzen offers solid documenta
tion of the Weiser experience, from the

weirdness and self-delusion

of

judging
(with a nice account of the judges' per
functory question-and-answer session
before the contest), to festival camp
ground neighborhoods such as Stickerville (mainly Appalachian fiddlers
who avoid the contest, interspersed
with some equally fine swing and jazz
musicians), the Institute, and Tin Town
(rows of motor homes near the football
field where most of the "contest" style
fiddlers jam), and other pockets of vi

tality and delight running the gamut of
world fiddle styles. Having judged at
Weiser as well as competed in the con
test, Goertzen's account feels spot-on to
me. Unlike most contests in my experi
ence, at Weiser the judges are seques
tered, back in the high school library.

This

is

supposed

to

help solve prob

lems of fairness and objectivity, but as
a former
judge at Weiser I can tell you

doesn't. Another device to at
fairness
tempt
(impossible, of course;
a
is
judging
subjective act) is the system
with
five judges, the scorewhich,
by
the
keeper ignores
high and low scores
(in 2009 Weiser went to three rather
that

it

than five judges, and the jury is out on
it improved things). Just don't
go to Weiser and expect to place high
by playing anything but National Con
test Style, a style that embraces "a pure,

whether

nearly classical tone over the rhythmic
drive that the best Texas fiddlers have."

Fiddling in major contests is no longer
a
regional expression. It's national, or
should we say global.
The

laudable attempt

fiddle styles
many
both

by

regions

to

be

fair

to

all

drawing judges from

has

had

residts

uneven

within any given year of the con

test and over the years. There's just too
much variety in North American fid
dling to allow any truly balanced evalu
ation of apples versus oranges versus
grits. One long-term struggle between

styles
in

has

Weiser,

elaborate

been

resolved:

informally

one must play

linear western

in

one of the

styles

to

win.

No matter how skilled fiddlers
in

may be
(say, one of

rhythm-oriented style
the southeastern old-time styles.
they
stand little chance for prizes unless they
a

are in one of the senior brackets. This is

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

one of the reasons that the old-time play
ers who camp in "Stickerville" seldom

ture time to dicker and deal.

enter the contest arena.
I here
are other important themes in
Chris Goertzen's fine book, such as his

visit

Hallettsville.

to

Frolics"

lettsville
fiddling

"Fiddler's
and state competition at Hal
is
is

a

The

big event in

a

very important.

state where

Hallettsville

(and the major competition at Crockett
as well) has been influential across the
contest fiddling landscape, and it is
where, as Goertzen says, "real" Texas

style contest fiddling prevails. A chapter
on the action "away from the stage" of

fers valuable documentation and com
mentary. As we have noted, much of

excitement and action at a fiddler's
contest is over in the campground, cof
the

fee shop, parking lot, and motel lobby,
where people congregate to enjoy mu
sic, food, and socializing. The fiddle
contest crowd is a community. Much
of the attraction is, as Goertzen writes,
"food, fun, and carnival," and, as he
suggests throughout the book, much of
it is layered with the bittersweet
vapors
of nostalgia, mythic history, and selec
tive memory. The carnival aspects of the
fiddle festival are especially important
to family and friends who may or may
not be avid musicians or diehard fans
of old-time fiddling. Families can plan
vacation trips around the dates for Cliff-

top, Athens, or Weiser, and there is typi
cally something for everybody.
One of Goertzen's commentaries con
cerns the importance of what are of
ten called "fiddle jockeys," people and

sometimes
tents

to

music

stores

who

set

Amajor portion of Southern Fiddlers and
Fiddle Contests presents information the
author derived from interviews with a

number

of

through

a

fiddlers. Goertzen worked
questionnaire to elicit no
tions of their activities, backgrounds,
learning experiences, attitudes toward
contests, tastes. In this complicated
and thought-provoking section of the
book, we have comments and glimpses
of a wide range of "southern" fiddlers,
meaning they appear in this book on
"southern fiddling and fiddle contests"
and that the author had the

nity to interview
known, such as
Ludiker, Richard
Bates, and Daniel

Bill

Birchfield, Tony
Bowman, Jimmie Don
Carwile, and all have

interesting things

to say.

followed by interview
material from Richard Bowman (Virgin
A final chapter,

ia), Bobby

Taylor (West Virginia), Lark

Reynolds (Kentucky), and Wes Westmo
reland

III

Meanings

(Texas), is called "Styles and
in

Southern

Fiddling."

De

spite the rather misleading title (a num
ber of fiddlers discussed in this book are
not Southerners),

this chapter presents
ideas.
A
suggestive
fairly complex pas
sage analyzes one of the ironclads of the
American repertory (traceable to Britain),
"Leather Britches," comparing notated

versions

one from the 1790s (Scotland),
Appalachia (Virginia, Brian
Grim), and one from Texas in the Texas
contest style version (Jimmie Don Bates).
Here Goertzen offers further explanation
of Texas fiddline:
one

from

Texas

up

sell and swap violins, bows, cas

opportu

them. Some are well

fiddling, and

contest performance,

by

extension

is more

most

oriented to

accoutrements as well as other
instruments, books, recordings, and the
like. Most fiddlers take time to wander
by the sales and swap area, sometimes

ward melody, both the relatively involved

asking

ways audible, but

es, and

a "vendor"
to check over a vio
bow for needed repairs. It is a
pleasant moment simply to visit about
this or that tidbit of fiddle lore with an
other person who digs the subject. Some
fiddle jockeys and shop owners set up
basic tools and equipment so they can
re-hair bows or make emergency adjust
ments and repairs on the spot
an im
portant service for fiddlers who may be
in dire need or who may live far from

lin

a

or

violin shop. Occasionally

a

lucrative

deal is struck for the vendor, a surpris
ing bargain had by a customer, but in

most cases the result is good public rela
tions and the likelihood that a potential
customer will contact the shop at a fu

original contours that begin

a

performance

and the subsequent pervasive variation of
those. The melody is always there, and althe

surface

is in

constant

and fascinating flux (emphasis mine). The

version transcribed herefrom
of Jimmie Don Bates

is

the

playing

fairly compact.

(it) certainly doesn't reflect the even more

leisurely and luxuriant unfolding of ideas
its unusual brevity
typical of jamming.
presents an especially clear demonstration
of the essential features of Texas fiddling.
He was accompanied by two guitarists
playing chunky, crisp jazz chords in the
The resultant to
typical Texas manner.
tal form of the performance is logical and
dramatic, a kind of musical narrative very
different from the texture-based complex

ity of old-time versions,
in

length quite

a

bit

which can vary

without changing

the

�general affect. Put more simply, old-time
versions show their historical affiliation
with

able

vary in
on
the
that
is, having a tune's
length
spot,

dancing

by

being

to

length in performance gracefidly subservi
ent to function. Texas fiddling, which co
alesced after the link between fiddling and
had become

dancing
forms determined
needs, and

is

exclusively musical
more wedded to situations
by

where the audience
and especially

weak, can focus on

to

is

listening attentively,

contests.

Goertzen transcribes and writes about
"Mississippi Sawyer" as well, and dis
cusses .the Texas contest fiddlers' ap
to "Dust}'

Miller,"

an

important
number on the Weiser style fiddler's list of
money tunes and a tune the margins of
which are pushed even further outward.
The goal of the Texas and Weiser contest
style breakdown fiddler is quite different
from the goals of the Appalachian contest
fiddler (and the Missouri contest fiddler
of the past) whose contest versions of
the same tunes may be "dressed up" and
"progressive" but do not launch what in
North Carolina or Missouri they consider
unnecessary new parts or distracting fire
works and rhythmic variations. The best
Appalachian contest fiddlers seem to val
ue subtle variation within the inherited
borders of tradition more than extrava
proach

gant forays beyond, and therefore many
would say that Appalachian style contest
fiddlers remain more connected to the old
expectations and needs of a set of old-time
square dancers.

Goertzen winds it up with a visit to the
annual fall fiddler's convention in the
comfortable, leafy college town of Ath
ens, up in the northern

Alabama

hills

halfway from Nashville to Birmingham.
It lies in one of the iconic cultural and
geographic hearths of old-time fiddle
and dance, the Tennessee Valley. This
great weekend is sponsored by Athens
State College and much of the campus
is

turned over to the event.

In

popula

tion, the Athens festival rivals Galax
and Weiser, with up to 20,000 visitors.
Some fiddlers consider it their favorite
contest and come year after year for the
fine jam sessions if not for the fleeting
moment on the contest stage in front of
the massive Roman columns on the col

lege's historic administration building.
But while this is one of the most enjoy
able, diverse, and "user friendly" of all
North American contests, it must be
mentioned that the Texas-derived Na
tional Contest fiddle style has come to
be dominant at Athens, too.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

There is

a

division

sic Old-Time

at

Athens for "Clas

Fiddle." But here

as

else

for the bulk of their fiddlers, but

I

also sense

that Goertzen feels that they illustrate

quali

separate division proves noth
The
focused "contest fiddlers"
most
ing.
enter the open divisions, and in those
divisions the Texas-derived Weiser style
brings home the bacon. Moreover, the
Classic Old-Time fiddlers do not have a
chance to compete in the finals on Sat

ties that, even if changing, make their pre
ferred fiddling styles "regional."

(age 15 through 59). This means that, no
matter how fine a fiddler may appear in
the Classic Old-Time Division, Texas-de
rived National Contest Style is preferred
and will be featured in Saturday night's
main event. The same few multi-part,

and present; it's all memory as repaired

where,

a

regions
share.

Weiser "Sally
or
Denver,
Branson,
Johnson," "Dusty Miller," "Sally Good-

in," "Tom and Jerry," "Grey Eagle," and

other venerable

old-time

fiddle

tunes

nuclear-powered "con
test tunes." Goertzen's discussion of
the judging, the Junior fiddlers' perfor
mances and styles, the Saturday night
converted

into

showdown

for the top trophy, purse,
and "King" title, and his post mortem

comments,

are

trenchant.

The author suggests that contests such
contests as Athens, Galax, and Weiser do
remain "regional" contests, mainly because
they draw from their geograpfiical regions

mod

of southern American

...at

all

fiddling

fiddle contests, they keep

and qui
traditional what they can,
so
is
conve
modernize
when
doing
etly
nient and doesn't undercut the general
ambience.
everything at a fiddle con
test explores diplomacy between past

urday night, when the Tennessee Valley
Fiddle King is decided in a play-off be
tween the winner of the Senior Division
(age 60 and up) and the Junior Division

high-octane breakdowns (hoedowns)
mounted in full contest array are played
by the Junior fiddlers, as Goertzen says,
arguably the best fiddlers in the various
divisions, at Athens as at Hallettsville,

are

these differences in style

est when compared with how much the

nostalgia, and' all in the service of
maintaining a comforting-- and invigo
rating--picture of small-town life in a

by

rosy past, back when people got along,
tried hard to do their best, and loved a
wholesome frolic but, above all, cared for

family and community.

would have appreciated many more
photographs, old and new. And I'm still
I

not entirely comfortable with the book's
title
the title focuses on the South and

Southern fiddlers and the book spends a
lot of time in Idaho and talking about Na
tional Contest fiddling. But I congratulate
the

University Press

of

Mississippi

for

bringing out Southern Fiddlers and Fiddle
Contests. Chris Goertzen's very personal
and pithy account of his adventures on
the contest trail, Southern Fiddlers and
Fiddle Contests is

guaranteed

to be

highly

interesting
anyone interested in the
dynamics of American vernacular music.
to

Highly recommended.
HOWARD W. MARSHALL
To

order: www.upress.state.ms.us

�AUGUSTA

HERITAGE CENTER

Davis

Oc^ob
Jones

ZJ

plus

Fiddl

rs5

Reunion I
1

1

I
f

Halloween Square Dance

October 30, 8:00 pm, $5
The Pit, Hermanson Center
Music by October Old-Time Week staff
Friday,

Saturday, October 31,

Appalachian Culture
Culture

yl rthts

dester l/flcfd

Gospel Sing

unifiers,

mmmmmmm mm
available from our online store

10 am

-5 pm,

FREE

Fiermanson Center Lounge
Dozens of performances by invited old-time masters
and younger old-time musicians from all over West
Virginia. A freestyle clogging and flatfooting contest
wili be held on the stage in the afternoon. Exhibits
and sales by instrument vendors nearby. Tune and
song swaps feature traditional singers from all over
the region, and jam sessions go on far into the night.

int.-adv. fiddle

&amp;

I
I
I
I

Fiddlers' Reunion

int.-adv. fiddle

Appalachian Dance

""

(Costumes encouraged but not required.)

beg.-int. fiddle

dnA,

me

October 50-November

1

int.-adv. banjo

tp/ue&amp;t "yHdSter
(Syrus

Now

November

beg. -int. banjo

Erynn Marshall

Gerry Milnes
LOU Maiuri

Old-T

guitar styles

MacTraynham
Riley Baugus
Dave Bing
James Bryan

campus, Elkins, West Virginia

Old-Time W eeic

er

October
Carl

Elkins College

&amp;

Sunday, November

1,

10am-

11:30 am,

I!

I
I
I
I
I

FREE

1

at

www.AugustaHeritage.com/store.html

NEW Augusta Master Series film:

NEW Augusta Heritage Recordings CD:

Bernard Cyrus

FTmer

Ancient Sounds

(old-time banjo)

dL

WiCd Orchids

(old-time fiddle)

Tunes from ^anford and

West Virginia
Wild and Wcmderfid

Section with Illegible Text

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Tap

dA

�SMITHSONIAN
FOLKWAYS
proucfCy

presents
the

new aCSum

son

Ut^

J°rgecf6y

S"raft

8ran€ther
r

rWe°*V

/"'her Qrf

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Section with Illegible Text

ORDERING MADE

CONVENIENT!
on the

vte

by pbujisi
888-FQLKWAYS

J

o

Smithsonian Folkways

�</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </file>
  </fileContainer>
  <collection collectionId="65">
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12031">
                <text>Old-Time Herald</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12032">
                <text>Presented in partnership with the nonprofit &lt;a href="https://www.wholesouth.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"&gt;Whole South Heritage Works&lt;/a&gt;, &lt;em&gt;The&amp;nbsp;Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;collection includes digital copies of every issue of&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald Magazine&lt;/em&gt;, 1987-2023.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Founded in 1987 by legendary musician Alice Gerrard,&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/em&gt;served for more than 35 years as a leading voice of the old-time music community worldwide&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;. Its&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="wixui-rich-text__text" style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt; 130-plus issues, all accessible here, contain a vast wealth of information that can’t be found elsewhere. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Issues include:&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent" data-testid="inline-content" class=""&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent-gridContainer" data-testid="mesh-container-content"&gt;&#13;
&lt;div id="comp-mf5sjgaq" class="ku3DBC zQ9jDz qvSjx3 Vq6kJx comp-mf5sjgaq wixui-rich-text" data-testid="richTextElement"&gt;&#13;
&lt;ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;deeply researched explorations into the history of old-time string-band music and related traditions&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;in-depth articles from respected historians, musicians, and writers&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;historic photographs, many of them previously unpublished&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;detailed discussion of the contemporary culture of old-time music and dance&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;field reports from regional scenes&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;interviews and oral histories&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;extensive album reviews, spotlighting both new releases and reissues of historic material&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;remembrances of departed musicians, including local community players typically overlooked in the national press&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;/ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Also included are robust community discussions and long-running, often fiery controversies waged in readers' letters to the editor.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Originally based in Galax, Virginia, the magazine was published for most of its run in Durham, North Carolina. Founding editor Alice Gerrard was succeeded in that position by Gail Gillespie, then by Sarah Bryan.&amp;nbsp;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;The Southern Music Research Center and Whole South Heritage Works are grateful to our community of donors, whose contributions made possible this significant digitization and archiving project — and to Alice Gerrard, who paved the way and made this whole thing possible.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;em&gt;A logistical note: Click on any issue's title or thumbnail image to access that entire magazine. On some screens, the PDF reader may initially display only a portion of the page. To view the issue more easily, click the "Presentation Mode" icon in the toolbar above the issue — four small arrows pointing outward in all directions. Then you can use your finger or your computer's arrow keys to scroll through the pages. Happy exploring.&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
  </collection>
  <elementSetContainer>
    <elementSet elementSetId="1">
      <name>Dublin Core</name>
      <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
      <elementContainer>
        <element elementId="50">
          <name>Title</name>
          <description>A name given to the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12716">
              <text>&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;, Volume 12, Number 1 (October-November 2009)&lt;/span&gt;</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="49">
          <name>Subject</name>
          <description>The topic of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12717">
              <text>Old-time music</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="41">
          <name>Description</name>
          <description>An account of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12718">
              <text>&lt;p&gt;&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;, Volume 12, Number 1 (October-November 2009)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Contents include:&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Trends in Old-Time Banjo Playing Part 3,” by Ray Alden&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Old-time Music in Alaska: Then and Now,” by Peter Bowers&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“An Interview with Mark Campbell,” by Laura Chessin&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Rememberances – Mike Seeger: An Appreciation,” by Paul Brown&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="40">
          <name>Date</name>
          <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12719">
              <text>2009</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
      </elementContainer>
    </elementSet>
  </elementSetContainer>
  <tagContainer>
    <tag tagId="1004">
      <name>2000s</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="1591">
      <name>2009</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6340">
      <name>Laura Chessin</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6339">
      <name>Mark Campbell</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5563">
      <name>Mike Seeger</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5413">
      <name>Old-Time Herald</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="1417">
      <name>Old-Time Music</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5415">
      <name>Paul Brown</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6338">
      <name>Peter Bowers</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5588">
      <name>Ray Alden</name>
    </tag>
  </tagContainer>
</item>
