<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<item xmlns="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5" itemId="2627" public="1" featured="0" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xsi:schemaLocation="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5 http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5/omeka-xml-5-0.xsd" uri="https://southernmusicresearch.org/items/show/2627?output=omeka-xml" accessDate="2026-11-20T01:17:18+00:00">
  <fileContainer>
    <file fileId="3566">
      <src>https://southernmusicresearch.org/files/original/c72588260e44aa7fdbf331a09032ded2.pdf</src>
      <authentication>60d524f143a92f94b95c110a0c1005d0</authentication>
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="4">
          <name>PDF Text</name>
          <description/>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="92">
              <name>Text</name>
              <description/>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12701">
                  <text>THE

OLD-TIME
HERALD

A

MAGAZINE DEDICATED TO
VOLUME 11, NUMBER 10 APRIL

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

OLD-TIME

MUSIC

2009

$7.50

MAY

JOHN

LOU
OKEH

HENRY

SOUTHWORTH

IN

ASHEVILLE

WORKSHOP
GUITAR

�Third Annua

I

Section with Illegible Text

Mountains^

of the

Song

Festivayj^J
Davis Valley
JUNE 25

at

I

27,

^)|i9Kj^

2009

W^inery

I-8i, Exit

54

Groseclose, Virginia

ADVANCE TICKET PRICING GOOD THRU JUNE 16 '09

THURSDAY, JUNE 25
$20 advance

$25

at the gate
10:00 pm

I

^OOS^REEin
SYMPHONY

I

Stage time: 3:00 pm
Wayne Henderson
Carolina Travelers- Dan Tyminski Band
Farewell Drifters

FRIDAY, JUNE 26
Section with Illegible Text

Jesse
McReynolds

I
II

SOth

I
I

Stage time: 1:45 pm 10:30 pm
Goose Creek Symphony
Michael Reno Harrell
Hillbilly Gypsies
John Cowan Band Lou Reid &amp; Carolina

John

^cowanJ

1

Birthday

Celebration

1

f

I

&gt;20

Stage

advance

$25

time: 1:00 pm

at the

gate
10:00 pm

Dan Tyminski

Jesse McReynolds 80th Birthday Celebration

Curlv Seckler and Willis Spears
Bill

&amp;

Maggie Anderson

Big Country

Paul Williams

&amp;

Bluegrass

LOU REID

the Victory Trio
Moron Brothers

Curly Seckler

Michael

Reno Harrell
Children under 12 FREE with
paying adult.
OF

AT GATE

Theatre

www.songofthemountains.org
Chilhowie,

SPONSORS

NO COOLERS

WBRF-98.1FM

NO OUTSIDE ALCOHOL ALLOWED

in Rural Retreat, VA Sunday, June 21st,
Monday, June 22nd, in Saltville, VA Tuesday, June 23th
&amp; in Marion, VA
Wednesday, June 24th!

WZVA-Z103.5FM

WMEV-93.9FM

WPAQ-740AM

jfa|

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

"Talent

WMMY-1 06FM

16.

EFFECT
2009

j
I
J

I

Jammers and Parking Lot
Pickers WELCOME!

pre-festival celebrations

VA

IN

CAMPING
Davis Valley Winery: (276) 686-8855

FOR MORE INFO

Be sure to visit the

PRICES

AFTER JUNE

MOUNTAINS
Lincoln

I

The Lincoln Theatre: (276) 783-6093
Davis Valley Winery: (276) 686-8855
Bank of Marion locations

THE

SONG

The

TICKETS

WMMT-88.7FM
WETB-790AM

lineup for Song of the Mountains live concerts subject

to

I

Bryant Label Co.
www.bryantiabei.com

WETS-89.SFM WAXM-93.5FM
WORLDWIDEBLUEGRASS.COM
change.

"

||t|

�Brandywine Friends
of Old Time Music
present

City Ramblers'
The Newest
first Farewell Concert

Friday, May 15th, 2009

at 8:00

p.m.

Delaware Theatre Company

at the

200 Water Street in Wilmington, Delaware

folk music's legendary traditionalists. For
Join us for a celebration of the authentic string band sound with
half a century they've played uniquely American string band music. We are thrilled to host one of the final

performances

by this

most entertaining trio.

22 before April
To order tickets, call 502-594-1 100

Seating is general admission. Tickets

on sale

February 15.

For more information

(302) 635-3001

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

1

$25 thereafter

about the concert:

concerts@bfotm.org

www.brandywinefriends.org

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

FEATURES
Lou
By

Southworth, Pioneer Oregon Fiddler/10

Vivian

T.

Williams

John Henry

in

Alabama/14

By John Garst

Mountain Country:
OKeh Records' Historic Asheville

Sessions/24

By Kent Priestley

COLUMNS
HERE &amp; THERE/4

FESTIVAL PROFILE/8

The Bluff Country Gathering
By Bob

Bovee

WORKSHOP/32

Old-Time Guitar:
Dallas Jones of the Leake County Revelers on"Lonesome Blues"

By John M. Miller

DEPARTMENTS
LETTERS/3

CLASSIFIEDS/37
REVIEWS/38

COMING SOON:
Jesco White
The Lunsford Family

�Letters
Regarding reviews
appreciate Doug Van Gundy's
thoughtful review of Brett Ratliff's June
I

greatly

Appal recording Cold Icy Mountain in the
February-March issue. I mean that not so
much because it is extremely positive, al
though that helps, but because he takes tire
time to put tire album in context and is spe
cific in his comments about tire music itself.
It helped me appreciate the CD more even
though I have listened to it at least 70 times,
starting well before its June 2008 release.
Many of you know I try my hand at these

review things, although I haven't for the
Herald since the early 1990s. I wish mine
were as thorough and well conceived as
Doug's. I make lots of mistakes, Doug

but one: he assumed that June Appal Re
cordings, Appalshop's 35-year-old label,

don't roll
that way. June Appal is a nonprofit staffed
with bits and pieces of the time of several
Appalshop staff members. Our new re
leases are completely artist- and produc
er-centric. They raise the money for the

determined the packaging.

We

project (this is a nonprofit, so June Appal
is not a "bank" like traditional labels are)
and have full artistic control of both the

music and the packaging. We have June
Appal Recordings (by the way. that is the
name, not "Appal Shop" as appears at
the head of the review), logo specifica
tions, and UPC code requirements, but
that's about it for design. Despite this de
centralization, I am proud that we have
released two more projects (both reissues
with lots of new stuff) since then.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

While I do tend to agree with Doug about
the legibility of the liner notes, I also think
John Haywood's cover art is distinctive and

eye catching. John is a pretty good Eastern
Kentucky old-time musician himself.
for me to
It has been really beneficial
move up here around these Eastern Ken
tucky old-time styles. Back in 1983

I

lis

Stamper fiddle music from
Knott County for three hours, and heard
lots of recordings, but nothing matches
living among the music. Hearing new
tunes and familiar tunes played com
pletely differently, hearing how West Vir

tened

to Art

ginia and East Kentucky are connected,
meeting folks like Brett, George Gibson,
Roger Cooper, Jim and Ada McCown,

Smith, and John Harrod (just to
and being exposed to so
a few),
many ways to fiddle and play the banjo
it is a whole new world for me since I

Paul

name

came to Appalshop in 2007.

Art Menius

�NOTICE TO TM3 PCBIilC
AT

LOCATIONS ALL OVER BERKELEY, CALIFORNIA.
MISS THE

HOT

DO

OLD TIME MUSIC

CONVENTION
10-13, 2009

SEPTEMBER

Thursday, Friday, Saturday

&amp;

Sunday

FEATURING

MIKE SEEGEH, BENTON FLIPPEN, PAUL BROWN,
TERRI McMURRAY, JOHN SCHWAB, RODNEY SUTTON
PLUS

KNUCKLE KNOCKERS
SUZY THOMPSON

ELIZABETH LaPRELLE

and ERIC

&amp;

SRUARE DANCES WITH

BLACK CROWN STRINGBAND, BENTON FLIPPEN,
MT. DIABLO STRINGBAND

gcMe

STRINGBAND

CONTEST!

RODNEY SUTTON, PAUL SILVERIA
CONCERTS!

WWW.

Funded

in

part

by

Alliance

for the California

SQUARE

DANCES!

Berkeley

Traditional

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Old

WORKSHOPS!

Time Music

Arts, Sage Foundation,

Bill

&amp; AMY

CABARET!

HOFER
KIDS'

SHOW &amp; DANCE!

.org

Graham Foundation, Hellman Family Foundation

�Carolina, April 24 26; Harkin Store State
Historical Site, New Ulm, Minnesota, on
May 24; and the Farmers Market in St.
Paul, Minnesota, on June 6. For more in
formation, visit www.boveeheil.com.

Rorrer, Darren Moore, Jeremy Stephens),
Beverly Smith, Eric and Suzy Thompson,

and Christian Wig. For more information
contact Bob Bovee and Gail Heil (507-4985452,

This

will

bobngail@springgrove.coop).
year's FolkMADness weekend

be May 22

ico.

Among

25 in

Great Big Taters will play over Memo
weekend at the Wheatland Tra
ditional Music and Arts Festival (www.

Socorro, New Mex

the callers are Kathy

rial Day

Ander

son and Scott Higgs, calling to music by
Bag O'Tricks and the Privy Tippers. There
will also be singing led by Nils Fredland,

workshops by Roger Landes, children's
programming by Sean Etigson, tradition
al singing circles with Paige Grant, swing
dance workshops with John Unger, and
music workshops with Hands Five.
Some scholarships are available. To reg
ister, contact Lisa Bertelli

(505-983-1321,

lisa.bertelli@earthlink.net) or Deb Brunt
(505-256-5381, debbrunt@comcast.net).
Seedtime on the Cumberland 2009, the
annual celebration

23rd

presented by Ap-

palshop, will take place June 10 through 13
on the Appalshop festival grounds in down
town Whitesburg, Kentucky. Performers
will include

Ginny Hawker, Kay Justice
and Tracy Schwarz, Lee Sexton, the Elkville

String Band, Brett Ratliff, Rich and the Poor
Folks, the Cowan Creek Pick and Bow AllStars, Ras Alan, Wayne Henderson, Jeni and

Sparky and Rhonda Rucker, Roger
Cooper, Turbo Pro Project, Jim and Ada McCown with Paul Smith, Paula Larke, and
Billy,

John McCutcheon.
Seedtime will also offer film screenings,

contests, gallery exhibits, Singing
on the Mountain, literary readings, a Youth
Bored concert, nature hikes, craft and food
vendors, and the Carcassonne square dance.

picking

on Wednesday and Thursday
will be free to the public, as will all festival
activities before 3 PM on Friday and Satur
day. Admission to Saturday night's square
dance at 9:30 PM will also be free to the
public. Tickets will be available for $10 per
day or $15 for the weekend, with discounts
All events

available for advance purchases, students,
seniors, and groups. Advance tickets sales
will begin April
site
area

1

from the Seedtime

(www.appalshop.org/

web

seedtime) and

at

businesses.

Bands
and Gail Heil's upcoming
the Big Muddy Folk
include
appearances
Festival in Boonville, Missouri, April 3
Bob Bovee

4;

MerleFest in North Wilkesboro, North

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

wheatlandmusic.org)

in

Remus, Michi

gan, and then at the Glen Echo, Mary
land, dances on Friday and Sunday,
and 7 (www.greatbigtaters.com).
of Great Big Taters will
Rothfield
Jane
be teaching an old-time banjo intensive
workshop for intermediate players at

June

5

Community Arts Center,
Voorheesville, New York, on March 28
(www.oldsongs.org). Red Hen will per
the Old Songs

form during the Ballston Spa First Fri
days concert series at the Coffee Planet,

Ballston Spa, New York, on Friday April
3, and will perform at the Old Songs Fes

tival in Altamon, New York, June 26 28
(www.oldsongs.org). Red Hen will also
be appearing at the New Bedford Summerfest International Folk Music and
Arts Festival,

chusetts
com).

in

New Bedford, Massa

(www.newbedfordsummerfest.

For more

information about Great

Big Taters, Red Hen, and Jane Rothfield,

visit www.janerothfield.com.
Final notes
Whit Sizemore of the Galax, Virginia, area
passed away February 25, 2009. He de

parted this life while working on his Car
roll County farm. He was 74 years old.
Whit grew up hearing family and neigh
bors play the fiddle music of the VirginiaCarolina Blue Ridge. His Uncle Gordon
Shinault, as well as Galen and David
Shinault, were very early influences, as
were Roscoe Parish and Jimmy Hawks.
After his father, Robert, traded four

bushels of potatoes for a fiddle for sixyear-old Whit, Doctor W. P. Davis, who
was treating Whit's grandmother in their
home at the time, set the fiddle up with
bridge, strings, and bow. In 1935, Davis
was instrumental with helping to start
the Galax Old Fiddlers' Convention, and
he was also was a founding member of
the Original Ballards' Branch Bogtrotters.
Some of the very first tunes Whit learned
to play were the old Baptist hymns that
his grandmother would sing and hum for
him. Growing up, Whit also had access to

Edison cylinder player and later a VicThis early exposure to the music of
such fiddlers as G. B. Grayson and Kahle

an

trola.

Brewer, and

to

the Skillet Lickers laid

strong foundation for his own fiddling

flourish later in his adult life.
Whit's first band job, though, was as

a

to

a

guitarist. During the late 1960s, he played
with Talmadge Smith and the Piney Woods
Boys.

Their

driving instrumental rendi

tions of "Lee Highway Blues" and "Leath
er Britches" won them the blue ribbon at

convention

tire Galax

in 1969. Whit

picked

up the fiddle again in the early 1970s and
formed the Shady Mountain Ramblers.

During the next 25 years, the band played
hundreds of square dances throughout
the area. They were regulars playing the
dances held at the Fairview Ruritan Club,
the Fancy Gap School, tire Independence
VFW, and the Fries Theater. In addition,

won many first-place awards at
fiddlers'
conventions, including
regional
the 1975 first-place band prize at Galax.

the band

Whit also captured the top prize
in the old-time fiddling contest

at

Galax
both

in

1976 and 1977.

Occasionally the band would travel to
festivals outside their home region. They
spent a week playing at the Smithsonian
Festival of American Folklife in 1977, and
they also traveled to Knoxville, Tennessee,
in 1982 as part of the

World's Fair entertain

ment.

In

1986, they were invited

Jersey

to

at the

represent Virginia

New

to

Brandy-

wine Mountain Music Convention.
In 2005 Heritage Records re-released
the band's three albums on a two-CD
This release (HRCD-23134)
collection.
documents their historic old-time sound
for future

generations.

Whit was also known for his fine fiddle
making. Through the years he crafted
several fiddles and a few mandolins.
Whit and Gelene's son Mike was an ac

complished mandolin player, and

he

al

ways played one of Whit's mandolins.
Mike was well versed in both the old-time
and bluegrass

genres, and he won many

individual mandolin prizes including
place

at

first

Galax on two occasions.

as many friends affectionwas
called
him,
always happy to help
ally
a younger fiddler.
James Burris and Eddie

"Big Howdy,"

Bond are always quick to cite Whit as a ma
the late Greg Hooven.
jor influence, as was
At Whit's graveside service, James Burris
and former band members Dan Williams

�and Tom Norman played and sang "Amaz
ing Grace." The graveside gathering was

large and there were dozens of musicians
scattered throughout.
As a personal note, Whit was my musical
mentor. I grew up in the hollow below his
home, and my first band experience (19741979) was as a Shady Mountain Rambler.
Many, many fine memories remain.
Dale Morris

guitarist and National Heritage
Award recipient John Cephas died on
March 4, at home in Woodford, Virginia.
Blues

He was 78 years old, and is survived by
his companion, Lynn Volpe, and nine

children. Cephas was born in Washing
ton, DC, in 1930, and grew up in nearby
Bowling Green, Virginia. As a child he
began to develop his Piedmont-style
guitar playing skills with the help of his
aunt, his cousin David Taleofero, and re
cords by Blind Blake, Blind Boy Fuller,
and other prominent blues guitarists.
As

a

young man, Cephas served

in the

War, sang gospel music profes
sionally, and worked as a carpenter and
fisherman. He became a professional
blues musician in the 1960s, playing at
first with barrelhouse pianist Big Chief
Ellis. In 1977 he formed a duo with har
monica player Phil Wiggins, a partner
ship that lasted many years and carried
the two men on tour around the world
many times. One of their many albums,
Dog Days of August, won the 1987 W. C.

Korean

Handy Award, and in 1989 Cephas re
ceived the National Heritage Award from
the

National Endowment

for the Arts.

Washington Post report
2003, John Cephas described the
appeal of Piedmont blues. "You hear
that wonderfully melodic, alternating
Speaking

to

a

sisters both played piano, so
grew up
playing the thing by ear in the lulls be
tween their practices. Both sides of the
family are musical. Mom's parents had
their own ragtime band that played all
over the region. Her father was also a
singing master in the shaped note tradi
tion. My father had a fine baritone voice,
as did his father. I first became interested
in traditional music in the early 1980s
when a friend let me borrow some Jean
Ritchie albums and mountain dulcimer
recordings. Soon afterward, I heard the
hammered dulcimer and decided to
I

it. I put together a kit and
started learning tunes."
He
Jim was an exemplary craftsman.
both built and played some of the finest

learn to play

hammered dulcimers

a

the Southern

Craft Guild.

Highland

say,

'I

and

and

finger, you just stop
want to go hear more of that!' It's

instant emotional appeal, and people
all over, wherever they heard it, they're

just drawn to it."

Laura Boosinger

Timothy
away

A.

on the

Thompson,
morning

64,

of March

passed
10

in

Richmond, Virginia. Born in Baton
Rouge, Louisiana, Tim had lived for
much

of his

life

in

Gainesville, Flor

was an engaging raconteur,
avid scholar, and a lifelong musician.

ida.

Tim

Gainesville

in the '60s and '70s

will

home

guitar. Over the years he loved many
kinds of music and played in bands that

Charleston, South Carolina.
Jim's own words, "I was born and
raised in Western North Carolina and
have lived here most of my life. My older
In

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Ole

Time

Fid

lina. He served as the Old-Time Herald's
workshop editor from 2003-2008, and
had also been gathering information
for articles on lesser-known but inter

esting old-time Virginia musicians re
corded in the 1920s and '30s. He was
the author of "Midnight Serenade," an
article on J. W. "Babe" Spangler that ap
peared in OTH Volume 10, no. 7 in Oc
tober 2006. Tim's health had declined in

Gail Gillespie

traditional Appalachian
recordings
music and music from the Civil War era
are well respected
amongst his peers
and fans. Jim earned a Master's Degree
in American history, specializing in the
Civil War. His presentations of the music
of that era were both informative and en
gaging. Many people knew of Jim's skills
in historical research and instrumental
performance. Not all knew that Jim was
a
singer for singers. His beautiful bari
tone voice sounded just right on "Pretty
Saro" or "Going Across the Mountain."
Jim often performed with his wife Sheila
Kay. His musical accompaniment to her
reading from her novel, My Old True Love,
made the words on the page become pic
tures for the listeners of her prose. A softspoken true Southern gentleman has left
us. He will be deeply missed.

in

of

the

in

On Saturday, March 7, 2009, the family
and friends of Jim Taylor were saddened
to learn of his death.
Jim died at his

Mars Hill, North Carolina. He
is survived by his wife Sheila Kay Ad
ams of Mars Hill, his mother June, and
sisters Cherrie Knight and Carol Irving

at

His

membership

Regulars of the Bent Card Coffeehouse

in

Fiddlers

dlers and Bluegrass Festival (Fiddlers
Grove), in Union Grove, North Caro

of

er in

thumb

Time

the last few years and he had recently
retired from his job as an archaeologist
for the Norfolk (Virginia) Department
of the Army Corps of Engineers.

His

in the country.

artistic skill earned him

ering. For many years he had served as
patient assistant to "Miss Tu-Da-La"
(Mary Hardy Roberts) and her First

a

remember Tim singing and strumming
his

candy-apple

red

Hummingbird

ranged from old-time and classic coun
try to honky-tonk and rock-and-roll. In
the last decade, he had returned to his
interest in old-time string band music,
attending jams, fiddlers' conventions,
and the annual Banjo Collectors' Gath

Country-blues and gospel singer, guitar
bassist Bob Guida died suddenly

ist, and
of

a

heart attack while setting up to play a
at the Union Street Public Library

concert

in Flushing, Queens, New York.
carrying his touchstone bass

He was
a

1952

Fender Precision that he called "Number
Nine" (it is stamped with serial #0009)
when he collapsed. Bob was going to do
what he loved doing best: playing music
with good friends, singing, and bringing

joy to his audiences. He especially en
joyed the concert series at the library as it

gave him an opportunity not only to per
form but also to open a discussion about
music history and vintage instruments
with his audience, which ranged in age
from school children to seniors. He had
just told his wife, Phyllis, that he loved
her, via voice mail, moments before he
was taken from us.
Bobby started discovering the world of
blues, country, and sanctified music as a
teen along with his lifelong friend, fellow
78 rpm record geek, and musical soulmate
Pat Conte. The two would form the tra
ditional musical group the Otis Brothers
in the late

1970s, primarily performing as
duo, and making numerous recordings.
Their material drew from and emulated
the blues and gospel songs they grew to
love by listening to original records from
'20s, '30s and '40s, and a wealth of field
recordings. The Otis Brothers continued
to give live concerts and record up until
Bob's untimely death.
Although best known for his "mile-wide"
voice, Guida also worked as a back line bass
a

player, accompanying legendary musi
cians including J. B. Hutto, Hubert Sumlin,

�Otis Rush, Junior Brown, Big Walter Horton, Roy Buchanan, Reverend Dan Smith,
Billy Lee Riley, Charles Brown, Snooky
and Sonny Terry and Brownie

Prior,

Mc-

past few years Guida formed
a
quartette which he called Raoul Otis
and his Blues Serenaders, using his nom
de guerre from his band with Conte.
Bob

Gee.

In the

hard to imagine this world without Bob
Guida. We know he has his "two wings

'round my head ...on my feet ...tiyin' away
heaven gonna be my home."
In the words of Raoul Otis: "To live for to
day, and love for tomorrow, is the wisdom
of a fool." Bob showed me his love each
day we chatted or played music together.
Steve Uhrik

had just finished recording a gospel proj
ect and was in the process of final mixing.

He was noted for his genuine and seam
an attribution
lessly loud singing style
that must have been inspired by his tireless
love of tlie music and deep spiritual faith.
Guida was just as at ease singing the Louvin Brotiaers' "There's a Higher Power" as
he was Little Walter's "My Babe" or Little
Feat's "Fat Man in the Bathtub." He also
fingerpicked a mean version of die Third
Man theme on guitar.
His passion as a musicologist, archivist,
and vintage instrument expert led to his
working on a book about the birth of the

electric guitar.

The Story of Paid A. Bigsby:

Father of the Modern Solidbody Electric

Gui

Andy Babiuk, was just published
February 2009, with title page contrib
utor credit to Bob Guida for his decades
of research on the subject. Bob's histori
tar, by

in

knowledge about instruments and
twentieth-century American music and
recordings could fill volumes and he was
cal

often called upon by writers, guitar deal
ers, and collectors as a consultant.
Bob grew up in Flushing, New
and was

devoted son

York,

parents Robert
E. and Carolyn Guida. He was a funeral
director by vocation and entered his fam
ily's funerary business located in Corona
after graduating from McAllister Institute
a

to

New York City, where he received an
Associate's Degree in Funeral Service.
He is survived by his loving wife Phyl

in

mother-in-law Josephine Frangione, sisters Suzanne Knips and Caro
lyn Clarke, brothers-in-law Bob Knips

lis Guida,

and Tom Clarke, his nieces and

nephews

Theresa Knips, Stephen Knips, Margaret
Mana Clarke, Thomas Clarke, Rusty and
Michelle Munno, Anna and Gino Iannuzzi, grand-niece and -nephew Kristen

Landolfi and Joseph Munno, cousin Ed
one of
Guida, and cousin Louie Kromm
the original Otis Brothers. He also leaves
behind on this earth the many friends
with whom he shared his love, music,
and enormous sense of humor. Bob had a
profound effect on just about everyone he
came in contact with, whether as a friend,
co-worker, performer, fellow musician,
or spiritual advisor. His premature pass
ing has deeply saddened us all. It will be

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Shulberg, AKA Citizen Kafka,
swooped this sphere on Saturday after

Richie

noon, March 14, 2009. Richie was the
leader and the brilliant, chaotic brain be
hind the Wretched Refuse String Band.
Shulberg's contributions extend well
beyond Wretched Refuse or the spinoff
Citizen Kafka band. Richie and Pat Conte
The Secret

collaboratively produced
seum of Mankind,

Mu

brilliant, ear-opening
collection of music from around the
globe; the project embodies Richie's (and
Pat's) madcap eclecticism. In collabora
tion with fiddler Kenny Kosek and actor
John Goodman, Shulberg produced The
Citizen Kafka Show, an over-the-top blend
of satirical comedy and improvisation
that aired on New York's WBAI.
I first met Richie
in the summer of 1973;
he was playing on the street with Alan
Kaufman, Michelle Weiss, Mike Schlea

singer, Bob Jones, and my old friend and

companion David Markowitz.
invited
me to sit in, beginning an
They
association with Richie and Wretched
musical

Refuse that lasted over
that time,

35

years.

Over

countless great musicians have

added their talents

to the core

band, in

cluding Andy Cahan, Andy Statman,
Kenny Kosek, Matt Glaser, Jeff Berman,
Jon Sholle, Tony Trischka, Larry Packer,
Lisa Gutkin, and others.
Wretched Refuse started out as an oldstring band, but largely through
momentum, it eventually
Shulberg's
mutated with a mixture of influences. In
ever-changing proportions, these includ
time

ed rock-and-roll; jazz ranging from King

Oliver through Slim Gaillard, through
Charlie Parker, Monk, and Ornette Cole
man; comedy inspired by Abbott and
Costello through Ernie Kovacs; Mad

magazine; and profoundly irritating tele
vision commercials. Although it could
never substitute for an in-person, onstage

a
good taste of
Richie's humor and the Wretched Refuse

frontal assault, you can get

repertoire on The Wretched Refuse String
Band (Betrayal Records BCD-1001).
My very first on-stage performance
with Shulberg was at a square dance

and concert event on the South Street
Seaport pier. We were in the middle
of some tune, when Shulberg noticed

promoter getting into his car and
cautiously backing out of the pier. Un
daunted that we were in the middle of a
the

tune, Richie muttered: "(Expletive)! He
hasn't paid us yet!" With that, Shulberg
jumped off the stage, and directly onto
the hood of the promoter's old sedan.

Somehow he managed to exact the eve
ning's wages before the guv drove off.

rejoined the band after a yearstint with a band in Alaska.
For a couple of months, I stayed at the
communal Wretched Refuse apartment,
sleeping on a mattress surrounded by
Richie's collection of 78 rpm records with
discs and shards of 78s all around. This
was simultaneously where we gathered
In 1975

I

and-a-half

our repertoire, and Party Central,

featur

ing extended 78 spinning with Shulberg

didact.
have

as DJ and
If

we didn't

an

official gig, we

played on the streets of Greenwich Vil
lage, and divided the loot over a commu
nal dinner at Hong Wun in Chinatown.

Shulberg knew the owner, cooks, and
waiters by name, and they treated him
an old friend. Virtually everyone
knew and loved Richie; from his band
regulars to those who knew him from

like

pinch-hitting as a sideman
casual bluegrass gigs.

in

countless

Really, whatever tickled Shulberg usu
ally inspired the rest of us, but at its core
and largely because of Richie, the band

remained more faithful to the spirit of
old-time music than many bands with the
typical repertoire and typical instrumenta
tion. Some may remember the Darco String
Band Festival with Shulberg resplendent in

pseudo-Hasidic garb, leading our bizarrely
costumed band

in

a

set ranging from "Gas-

pe Reel" to "Peanut Butter."

Over

the

last decade

or

so,

declining

crushing combination of
heart problems and Multiple Sclerosis
increasingly inhibited his ability to per
form. When health and medication per
mitted, Richie's spark was undiminished
health due

and

it

to

a

inspired us all.

On Monday, March 16, 2009, Richie was
laid to rest by friends who were simulta

neously filled with sadness and buoyed
up by memories of his humor and our
musical adventures together. We should
all be so

lucky.

The Wretched Refuse String Band will per
form a memorial concert for Richie on May
9

at

Jalopy (www.jalopy.biz) in Brooklyn. Qff
Marty Cutler

�Festival Profile

THE BLUFF COUNTRY GATHERING
By Bob Bovee

breakfasts. Even though it has a popula
tion of fewer than 900 people, the town
has about twenty bed and breakfasts!
Food is, of course, an essential element.
For the first four years of the

Gathering

there were four different sets of cooks for
these meals; in fact, Gail did all the lunch
preparation herself the first year. Since
2003 the kitchen staff has been Bob and
Diana Suckiel and their crew from Kan
sas City, providing such treats as smoked

salmon, pulled pork barbeque sandwich
es, spring green salad, flourless chocolate
cake, and baklava.
The Friday-night concert always fea
tures all the members of the staff, and
sometimes surprise guests. Doug Lohman
of Armadillo Sound in the Twin Cities
handles the technical production. Since
he's a fine musician himself, playing
old-time, Cajun, and bluegrass, he does
He also
a sensitive job with the audio.
recorded most of the tracks used on the
Bluff Country Gathering CD, which was
released in 2005 and features many of the
performers who played between 2000

In

1998,

Gail Heil

decided

found an
festival for

to

old-time music camp and
the Upper Midwest. Inspired by the Fes

Fiddle Tunes in Port
where we had
a
couple of times,
performed and taught
a
she began planning
similar, but much
be
held
in Southeast
event
to
smaller,
Minnesota. Her idea was to focus on tra
ditional American fiddle music, featuring
masters to teach the instrument, and also
to put on a concert and an old-fashioned
barn dance during a long weekend.
Looking around for the ideal location,
Lanesboro became the natural choice.
It's a beautiful small town located on the
tival of American

Townsend, Washington,

should have held

a

maximum

and 2004. On Saturday night is the barn
dance, with dances typical of the Mid

of 100, and

windows were opened so those who
couldn't get in could hear the show. This
success convinced us that the Gathering
was going to be an annual event.
the

Starting in 2000 we rented both the Lanes
boro Community Center and the Sons of
Norway Hall. Registration was limited to
75 and quickly filled up. Old-time musi
cians in the Midwest were hungry for this
kind of first-hand experience with great

musical

masters.

That

year

workshops

were also expanded to include banjo and,
in subsequent years, guitar and mandolin.
Every year is different, depending on who
is on the staff, but workshops have includ

harmony singing, harmonica, banjo and

Root River about 120 miles from the Twin

ed

Cities, and within easy driving distance
of Chicago, Madison, Milwaukee, and
Des Moines. Gail and I had been hold
ing the Lanesboro Barn Dance at the Sons
of Norway Hall there for several years.
This building seemed to offer all that was
needed for a modest camp festival with
and a small
a maximum of 60 students
staff, but it was evident after the first year
that the Bluff Country Gathering needed

fiddle duets, clogging, dance calling, string
band dynamics, and sessions on fiddle or

larger space. The entire staff for 1999's
first festival was Dwight "Red" Lamb,
Chirps Smith, Dan Gellert, and Gail Heil,
and the limited student quota was easily
filled. When it came time for the Fridaynight concert, which was open to the pub
lic, 140 people jammed into a space that
a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

banjo repertoire, banjo and fiddle show
cases, and folklore sessions.
By 2001 the demand was such that the
registration limit was raised to 100, where

remained. Although this means
that some people get left out if they
are too slow in signing up, many of the
campers have expressed their wish that
the number not increase. It's a comfort
able size for everyone, almost feeling like
a family reunion.
Campers are on their
own to find lodging, and about a third of

it

has

them opt for the municipal campground
in the park just adjacent to the two build
ings. The rest stay in motels or bed and

west, South, and West: squares, big cir
cles and reels, along with some couples
dances. Again, the staff provides the mu
sic, usually in three bands over the course
of the evening. It's a treat to watch over

following the lead of such mas
terful callers as Dot Kent, Beverly Smith,
Pop Wagner, Nancy Mamlin, Paul Tyler,
Corey Mohan, and others.
Over the last ten years the Bluff Coun
200 folks

try

Gathering has presented

a

long list of

fine old-time players as staff. The roster
includes (with apologies to those not men

tioned) Clyde Davenport and Michael DeFosche, the Canebrake Rattlers, Vesta John
son, Bob Carlin, the Double Decker Stringband, Kim and Jim Lansford, Geoff Seitz,
Tracy Schwarz and Ginny Hawker, Tom,
Brad, and Alice, James and Rachel Bryan,
the Rhythm Rats, Glenn Ohrlin, the New
Southern Broadcasters, Melvin Wine and
Gerry Milnes, Dick Kirnmel,
and Christina Wheeler, Kerry
and Jenny Traynham, Dave
Molsky, Rafe Stefanini, Walt

Rhys Jones
Blech, Mac
Bruce

Rice,

Koken

and

Clare Milliner, Rayna Gellert, Jimmy Trip
led, and W. B. Reid and Ron Cole.

The 2009 Bluff Country Gathering takes
place May 14-17 with a topnotch staff,
as usual. This year it's Eric and Suzy

Thompson, Beverly Smith, Skip Gorman,
Christian Wig, and the New North Caro
lina Ramblers. For more information,
visit www.boveeheil.com.

�top to bottom, Kerry Blech and Bob Bovee; the Sons of Norway Hall; Clyde Davenport,
Rick McCracken, and Sally Sublette.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�LOU SOUTHWORTH,

PIONEER OREGON FIDDLER

by Vivian

T.

Williams

middle of the nineteenth
century was a place where people had the
opportunity to overcome unpromising
origins, leave behind their lives in the East, and
start afresh. Lou Southworth, an African Ameri
can slave, seized the opportunity to change his
life dramatically, with the help of his fiddle.

The brethren wouldn't stand for my
violin, which was all the company I had

Far West in the

They said

most of the time.

it

was full

of all sorts of wicked things and that it
belonged to the devil. And it hurt me a

The

good deal when they told me that playin'

proceedin' unbecomin'

fiddle is
Christian

in the

told them

to keep

a

a

sight of the Lord.

to a

So

I

me in the church with

the fiddle if they could, but to turn me
out if they must, for I couldn't think of

parting with my old-time friend.

They

turned me out.

Southworth played the fiddle for danc

An Alsea Valley oldin Waldport.
timer said, "Oh, boy, could he play the
fiddle! He would sing, 'Old Nigger Lou,'
and he would get out there and dance
with it." Since dancing was one of the
es

Louis (or Lewis) Alexander Southworth
was born into slavery in Tennessee on July
His father's surname was Hunt
4, 1830.
but
he
took the surname of his master,
er,
At age two he was
Southworth.
James
taken to Franklin County, Missouri, with

undoubtedly where he
learned to play the fiddle.
In 1853, when Louis was in Iris early
twenties, James Southworth took him over

his family.

the

This is

Oregon Trail

to the

Oregon Territory.

Slavery had been declared illegal in Oregon
in 1844, and black people were excluded by
law from the territory from 1848 to 1854 and
again in 1857. In 1854 Louis Southworth

to settle on an abandoned Or
Land Claim near Monroe, in
Donation
egon

was allowed

$400 toward his freedom. He made a fi
nal payment of $300 to James Southworth
in 1859, and became a free man.
In

1868

Southworth moved

to

Buena

Vista, Oregon. Here he purchased
and established a blacksmith shop
He learned to read
livery stable.
write, joined the Victoria Lodge of

land
and
and

Ma

sons, and got married. In 1880 he moved
with his wife and stepson to Tidewater,
about five miles up the Alsea River from
He made a living farming,
Waldport.

hunting, fishing, ferrying passengers and
cargo across and up and down the river,
and helping with the hay and wheat har
vests near Philomath and Corvallis. He
donated land for a local schoolhouse,

dently James needed money, so Louis soon
left for the gold fields in the Jacksonville
area of southern Oregon. He earned $300,

chair of the school board, and
had a horse that he trained to do tricks in
Oregon State Fair shows.
Southworth had been an ardent sup
porter of Abraham Lincoln, and he al

which he gave
for his freedom.

a

Lane County. Because times were so hard,
James Southworth moved in with trim. Evi

to

James in partial payment

In the fall of 1858 he

went

to

Yreka, Cal

ifornia, to mine for gold. When he dis
covered that he could make more money
with his music than he could mining,
he taught violin and played for dance
schools in Yreka and in Virginia City, Ne
vada. Louis Southworth was not the only
person to benefit from the fact that fron
tier communities often placed a higher
value on music than on other profitable
activities. Dr. William Allen of Oregon
City wrote in 1851 that he made more
money playing his violin and teaching

dancing than he did practicing medicine.
money that Southworth earned from
his music enabled him to pay another
The

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

served

as

On Election Day in 1880,
fierce southwest storm was blowing
across Alsea Bay, raising whitecaps on
the water, and Southworth's neighbors
were afraid to cross the bay to the polling
place. With two oil drums rigged up on
the front and back of his boat to provide
extra flotation, he was the only one to

ways voted.

cross the bay to vote that day.

Southworth's wife died in 1901, and a
year later, he moved to Corvallis. He got
along well with his neighbors there, who
raised $300 to pay off his mortgage. He
was a religious man, and joined the Bap
tist church. The church objected to his
violin playing, however, so he stopped
attending. In a 1915 interview with the
Corvallis Daily Gazette Times he said:

most important recreational activities for
the pioneers, a good dance fiddler like
Southworth was recognized as an impor
tant asset to the community.
As an active and involved citizen, he
earned the respect of his neighbors

within the constraints

of

the

era's in

equality. Benton County pioneer Theo
dore P. Bevens recalled, "He was a fine
blacksmith and lived last on Alsea Bay
where his stepson still lives. He pros
pered and used to dress well and drive
He was respected by
a fine black team.
all and treated almost as an equal even

Southerners."

by the

When he died in 1917, the townspeople
lined up for blocks to pay their respects.
In 2002, after three

the US Board on

years of controversy,

Geographic Names vot

ed to change the name of Darkey Creek,

which crossed Southworth's Alsea River

to Southworth Creek. How
ever, the road that runs along the creek
retains its original name.

homestead,

Lou Southworth believed in the capacity

music to supply entertainment, spiritual
comfort, and emotional release. He spoke
at length in Iris interview with the Daily
of

Gazette.
And

I

sometimes

think

that

when

you go up yonder and find my name
to your surprise in the Big Book, you'll
meet many a fellow who remembers the
old

fiddler who played "Home Sweet
"
"
"Dixie Land, "Arkansas Trav

Home,

eler," "Swanee River," and other tunes
for the boys who were far away from

home for the first time.

And some of the

�University Archives
State
Oregon
courtesy

Lou

Southworth

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Lou

Southworth

fellows will tell how the poor, homesick
boys listened to the fiddle during the
long winter evenings until they forgot
their troubles so they could sleep as they
had slept under their mothers' roofs at
home.
And they'll talk over the days

when there was not society for men like
us out West; when there wasn't any
Bible, and hymn books were unknown;
when playin' poker and buckin' faro
were the only schoolin'

a

fellow ever got;

when whiskey ran like water and made
the whites and Indians crazy; when men
didn't go by their right names and didn't

down soft and gentle-like and the fiddle
seems to sing the songs of slavery days
till the air grows mellow with music and
the

old-time feelin' comes back, and

I

can

hear familiar voices that are no more.
There are things a plain old man can't
tell in words, and there are feelin's that

won't fit into common, everyday talk like
When

mine.

plenty of rosin on
player's feelin' fine, and

there's

the bow and the

the fiddle pours out great torrents of mu
sic that calm down till he hears the bob

white's whistle and the rustlin' of the corn,
and the whippoorwill and mockin' bird
sing for him, and

forgets what

care what they did, and when there was
no law, and the court was the man who

come

carried the best six-shooter.

make everybody

And when they have talked over those
early days, the fellows will say: "Where'd

plain man has feelin's he can't describe.
But he knows he's happier and better,

we all been and

what'd we all done

in the

mines, but for Uncle Lou's fiddle which
was the most like church of anything
we

had?"

the good

For the boys used to think
Lord put a heap of old-time

religious music into my fiddle; and the
old-time religious music is good enough
for an old man who's done some mighty
hard work in eighty-five years.
But I forget the work I've done and
the years I've lived when my bow comes

he

to

ought not

to

he

remember and he wants

glad

then

it

is that

to
a

He
and his next day's work is easier.
has a smile and a kind word for every
one he meets, and every one has a smile
and a kind word for him. The world is

heavenly

to

nigh on to

that man, and his feelin's are

religious.

Vivian Williams was born and raised

in Taco-

ma, Washington, and is a Pacific Northweststyle fiddler and a historian of fiddle music in
the pioneer West.

�Augusta

Center

Heritage
Davis

&amp;

Elkins College, Elkins, WV

Section with Illegible Text

Spring Dulcimer Week

April 19-24

Spring Dulcimer Week
Mac/die McNeil Coordinator
Neal Walters autoharp

Cajun/Creole Week
Early Country Music Week
Blues Week
Guitar Week
Irish Week
Bluegrass Week
Swing Week
Roots &amp; Rhythm
Discover Augusta Week
Old-Time Week
Vocal Week
Dance Week
Augusta Festival

July
July
July
July
July
July
July
July
July

26-31
26-31
26-31
26-31
August 2-9
August 2-9
August 2-9
August 7-9

John Huron

October Old-Time Week
Old-Time Fiddlers' Reunion

Oct. 25-Nov.
Oct. 30-Nov.

Mike Compton

5-10
5-10
12-17
12-17
19-24

Ray Belanger
Guy George

www.augustaheritage.com/store.html
NEW

Augusta Master Series film:

Bernard Cyrus
JAncient Sounds

idiCd Orchids

OThamr. dulcimer

int.

adv. hammer

dulcimer

jM:|
Ml

JB

dulcimer

mtn. dulcimer construction

'

Old-Time Week
j

Joe Newberry Coordinator
Sharon Gilchrist bass
Laura Boosinger

beg. banjo

Cathy Barton int. banjo
Mac Ben ford adv. banjo
Chance McCoy beg. fiddle
nt. fiddle
Dave Bing
Rate Stefanini

int.

Clay Buckner adv. fiddle
Dave Para int. guitar
adv. flat
Robin Kessinger
1
1

I

1

I

fiddle
j

pick guitar

mandolin
j

October Old-Time Week
Coordinator
Gerry Milnes
Bernard Cyrus guest master artist
beg.-int. fiddfe
Erynn Marshall
Dave Bing int-adv. fiddle)
James Bryan int.-adv. fiddle

Jones guitar
MacTraynham
Carl

ygyBaugrrs-

j

styles
beg.-int. banjo

int.-adv. banjo

Vírgínía
Wonderful

Wild and

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

dulcimer

beg. mountain dulcimer

Thomasina Levy adv.beg. mtn
Tull Glazener int.-adv. mountain

West

Section with Illegible Text

JHpl

jflfl

hammer dulcimer

Karen Ashbrook

Anne Lough

'iv/d-

Now available from our online store at

int.

Sam Herrmann
j

H

□eg. hammer dulcimer

j

�JOHN HENRY IN ALABAMA
by John Garst

Was John Henry a real person who raced a steam
drill? If so, where?
My conclusion is that it is beyond reasonable
doubt that John Henry was an ex-slave from

Mississippi who died at Dunnavant, Alabama,
in 1887 or '88, probably on September 20, 1887.
I
choose the wording "beyond reasonable
doubt" carefully This is the standard of evidence
for conviction in a criminal case. Direct evidence
circumstantial evidence is suffi
is not required
cient. The evidence for John Henry at Dunnavant

circumstantial.
"Beyond reasonable doubt"
does not mean that there can be no doubt at all; it
means that doubt is not reasonable.
is

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�ballad

A

is

story told in song.

a

can "Folk Heroes."

John

best known through his ballad.
notice in print was in 1909. The
earliest known text was collected in 1905.
The 1920s brought sound recordings and
intensive study by rivals Guy Johnson
and Louis Chappell. Each spent at least
eight years studying John Henry. John
son published his findings in a book in
1929 and Chappell followed with his
book in 1933.
Together they gathered nearly sixty ver
sions of the ballad and a great deal of tes
timony. Johnson cast a wide net by plac
is

Henry

ing requests

Henry

in the

consideration

John Henry.
At least eight scholars have looked

ously
has

at

Bunyan, although there are plenty of recent
there are no old
ly written ones. Similarly,
Bill
or Mighty Casey.
Pecos
about
songs
In
a

of

seri

Every one of them
that John Henry was

Unfortunately, neither

a

at

He became
as

a

considering the evidence, let's
the broad

picture and answer

a

few general questions.
Isn't John Henry fictional, like Mighty

Pecos Bill,
Casey (of "Casey
and Paul Bunyan? I group these four to
gether because the United States Postal
Service did so in 1996, when it issued a
set of stamps honoring them as Ameri
at the Bat"),

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

leg

dur
Billy Lyons in 1895 in a St. Louis bar,
nick
His
a hat.
over
some
horseplay
ing
name was "Stack," so he was "Stack" Lee.

testimony, indirectly relevant documen
tation, and other items.

look

is

No.
endary imply
have
real
legendary
gained
people
Many
status. Here are four legendary but real
Americans. Casey Jones was a locomotive
engineer who died in 1900 in a wreck at
Vaughan, Mississippi. Lee Shelton killed

steam drill. We are left with ballad texts,

Before

be

that he is fictional?

news account

document John Henry's race with

He

is

nor an archival record has been found
to

celebrated in

possible. It is not a tall tale.
Doesn't the fact that John Henry

probably a real person. However, this is
It seems likely that the
a biased sample.
take the effort to
would
who
only people
be those who
would
study John Henry
were inclined at the outset to think he
was a historic person.
We need evidence, not opinion polls.
What counts as evidence? All relevant
items... ballad texts, testimony, news
accounts, archival records... any thing
and everything.

is

He is not fakelore.

genuine folk tradition.
longs
Isn't the story of Jofin Henry a tall tale?
There are tall tales about John Henry: he
dug a tunnel all the way from Rome, Geor
And that wasn't
gia, to Atlanta in one day.
a thousand
had
over
He
his best day.
all
them
he
and
women,
happy.
kept
Even so, the basic John Henry story
that he raced a steam drill, won, and died

John Henry.

concluded

contrast, John Henry

folk ballad.
to

The data gathered by
form the primary

basis for any serious

from

Bill, and Paul Bunyan from genuine folk
lore, they have been called "fakelore."
I
know of no old songs about Paul

nation's African American
He was rewarded with

Johnson and Chappell

is

of

North Woods lore, but the form in which
we know him today is also an invention
To distinguish
of professional writers.
characters such as Mighty Casey, Pecos

information about John

newspapers.
many responses.

inventions

professional writers. Paul Bunyan

Its first

for

Two of them, Mighty

Casey and Pecos Bill, are

known

"Stagolee."

in

ballad and legend

Frankie Baker killed her

man, Allen Britt, in St. Louis in 1899. She
is the "Frankie" of "Frankie and Johnny."

Allen was known as "Al," and "A1 Britt"
became "Albert" in tradition. Later, in a
tin-pan alley rewrite, "Johnny" replaced
"Albert." Delia Green was a 14-year-old
Savannah girl who was shot and killed
Eve gath
by her boyfriend at a Christmas
ering in 1900.

She is

remembered

in the

ballad "Delia," which is well known in
the Bahamas as "Delia('s) Gone": "Delia
Delia gone."
One more round
gone
from the
America
As a reintroduction to
the
of
a
folksong
Bahamas, it was
staple

craze of the 1950s and '60s. Johnny Cash
recorded two versions, released in 1962
and 1994.

Don't most folk ballads tell fictional sto
No. As MacEdward Leach wrote,
"... folk ballads have their inception in
event." In 1964 folklorist G. Malcolm
Laws listed 256 native American bal
lads that were active in tradition. Laws
groups "John Henry" with nineteen oth
ers that he considers to be "Ballads of the
Negro." Of these nineteen, eleven are
known to be based on historic events and
the other eight could be. The majority of
Laws's 256 native American ballads have
historic roots. On this basis alone, it is

ries?

more probable than not that John Hen
was real.
ry's contest with a steam drill
Folks
What about local traditions?

around Leeds, Alabama, say that John
Henry beat the steam drill in the Dunnavant Valley, outside the east portal of
Oak Tunnel, the "short" tunnel, a couple
of miles south of Leeds. They say that,
and they believe it. One local man told
me that he grew up hearing stories about
John Henry and that they were always

�told

as

truth

no

qualifications

no

doubt about
John Henry was here.
Should we believe these stories? Well,
when I was growing up, I heard about
hoop snakes and whip snakes. A hoop
snake takes its tail in its mouth and rolls
after you. A whip snake sinks its teeth
into your nose and beats you with its tail.
These stories were always told as truth
no doubt about it
no qualifications
into
a
hoop snake or whip
you might run
it

snake at any time.
Should we believe these stories? Ten
thousand dollars has been on deposit in
to be
a New York bank for many years,

own stories about John Henry. These sto
ries are told as if they were true

no

quali

no doubt about it John Henry
fications
was there in about 1871, helping build the
C &amp; O (Chesapeake &amp; Ohio) railroad.
That's not all!
John Henry has been
claimed for other places
Jamaica and

Virginia in particular.
that John Henry raced a steam
I doubt
drill and died at both Dunnavant and Big
Bend, or Jamaica, or Virginia.
Should local traditions be disregarded?
Certainly not! The fact that not all local
John Henry traditions can be right does
not imply that they are all wrong. In addi

person to provide real
hoop snake. As for whip
snakes, some snakes are called that be
cause they resemble whips. No flagellat
ing behavior is known.
Without evidence, we cannot believe sto
ries about hoop and whip snakes, no mat
ter how earnestly we may be assured that
they are true. Similarly, without evidence,
we cannot believe John Henry legends.
DunnaThere is another consideration.

tion, tradition is important in its own right,

not the only place with a local John
Around Big Bend Tunnel,
tradition.
Henry
in southern West Virginia, they tell their

as that at Big Bend, and

to the first

given

evidence

vant

of

a

is

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

whether

or not it is

historically correct.

Tunnel is
Talcott, West Virginia, home of an an
nual celebration, "John Henry Days." A
The east portal

of Big Bend

at

strong legend associates John Henry with
Big Bend Tunnel. It is hallowed ground.
Mere facts cannot change that.
end is well worth celebrating.

Similarly, the legend
well worth celebrating.
It

at

Dunnavant

It is

it

That leg

just as

is

strong

may be older.

should be celebrated, no matter what

the historic facts may be.

Even so, I believe that he was a real per
son. Let's turn to the evidence.
First, consider Big Bend Tunnel. As far

popular vote of ballad singers is
concerned, Big Bend wins hands down.
A common line in the ballad says that
John Henry was at "Big Bend Tunnel on
the C &amp; O road." About 40% of the bal
lad versions collected by 1933 place him
as the

Bend, on the C &amp; O road, or both.
Today, that's about all you hear sung.
Is this evidence in favor of Big Bend?
Of course it is, but it's not very strong
evidence. As folk songs are passed from
at Big

one person to another, they change, they
mutate. Words and phrases are misun
derstood or forgotten. Ideas and lines are
brought iir from other songs. Sections that
seem to be missing are filled in with some

Half-recalled passages are re
sometimes with changes in
Finally, locales are changed.
meaning.
Sometimes people prefer to sing about lo
cal places instead of distant ones. Thus, in
one song the "Wexford girl" has become
thing new.

constructed,

the "Rexford girl," "Oxford girl," "Expert
girl," "Export girl," "Noel girl," "Waco
girl,"
etc.

"Lexington girl," "Knoxville girl,"
a folk song cannot be as-

The locale of

�Illustration by

J. J.

Lankes, from Roark Bradford's John Henry

sumed to be the original locale, nor can
be

assumed

to be

it

historically correct.

that the John Henry ballad
started out specifying some other tun
nel and some other railroad, but came

Suppose

as "Big Bend Tunnel on the
road." This phrase sings well,
probably better than the original, and

sung

easily understood.

fame of Big Bend Tunnel,

"Big Bend Tunnel
but not so easy to

on the C

&amp;

Vagueness
witness. Further, the incident

he

de

scribes, one that did not attract a crowd
or cause excitement, is not the kind of
stuff from which legends are made.
Despite this, Johnson concluded reluc

most
tantly that Big Bend Tunnel was the
John Henry site. Chappell was

probable
not reluctant

it
It

it.

Coupled with the

that makes
to ballad singers.
attractive
especially
is easy to imagine mutations leading

Brothers, 1931

contradictions impeach

him the weight
Big Bend was
to find significant
failed
He
paramount.
additional evidence, but he didn't need

C &amp; O
is

&amp;

and

this

For "Big Bend Tunnel on the C &amp; O
road," there is another consideration.

to be

Harper

to

O road"

of the

local

at all.

To

tradition

at

be
Big Bend was John Henry's place
cause tradition said so.
As

a

of the

consequence

studies of John

imagine those leading
That
it.
from
phrase is so attrac
away
tive that it seems unlikely that it would
mutate further. It is a stable end point.
This is another reason to suspect that it
was not in the original ballad and is not

son and Chappell, the notion that John
Henry was at Big Bend Tunnel became
the received wisdom.
Although there

historically correct.

seventy years.

Steam drills were not used in the con
struction of Big Bend Tunnel. Even so,
drill could have been brought
a steam
there for a trial and pitted against John
Henry.

There is testimony to this effect.

However, testimony about John Henry

Johnson and
a dozen men
about
interviewed
Chappell
who had worked at Big Bend Tunnel as it
was being bored. They split evenly, half
claiming that John Henry had been at Big
at Big

Bend is incoherent.

Bend and the other half denying it.
One of those denying it, Sam Wallace,
was adamant about it. He was there all
the time. He knew all the steel drivers.
If anyone had raced a steam drill at Big

Tunnel, he would have known
about it. It didn't happen!
Another man, C. S. "Neal" Miller,
claimed to have seen John Henry race
the steam drill, but he was a very poor
witness. He gave few details. He didn't
see much of the "test," as he called it. As
he went about his regular work, he just
looked in on it once in a while. It did not
attract a crowd nor cause any excitement.

Bend

He told Johnson that John Henry "over
did" and "took sick and died soon after
that," but he told Chappell that John

Henry was killed later in

an

accident.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

have been a few skeptics, this received
wisdom stood without a serious alterna
tive in the scholarly literature for over
and Chappell's
I read Jofmson's
was left with an uncomfortable,
unsettled feeling about their conclusions.
Each time

books,
In

I

the summer

of 2001

Whitehead's novel,

I

read

Colson

John Henry Days.

Be

ing fiction, the novel contributed nothing
to the search for John Henry, but it got me
thinking about it and prompted me to re

read Johnson's and Chappell's books.
It finally dawned on me that their data

I be
flatly contradict their conclusions.
lieve that their data eliminate Big Bend
Tunnel as the John Henry site. It is in

conceivable

to me that

locals would have

given such incoherent testimony if John
Henry had been there.
So how did John Henry come to be asso
ciated with Big Bend Tunnel? There is both

testimony and alleged documentation of a
well-known steel driver at Big Bend named

John Henry Martin. He did not race a steam
drill, and he lived for years after the tunnel
was completed. When the John Henry bal
lad reached the Big Bend vicinity, people

probably remembered John Henry
Martin and identified Jvim with the hero.
This would have been part of the relocalization of the ballad to Big Bend.
If not Big Bend, then where?
Perhaps
Dunnavant, Alabama. As far as I am
there

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

J.

J.

Lankes,

from R. Bradford's John Henry

aware, this is the only other location
with a long and strong local John Henry
tradition. But we have to do better than
merely invoke tradition.
I
judge C. C. Spencer to have been the
best witness turned up by Johnson or
In 1927 Spencer was about
Chappell.
54 years old and lived in Salt Lake City,
Utah.
tation

wrote

In

response

for John

to

Johnson's

solici

Henry information, he

long, detailed letter. At about age
14, he had been an eyewitness to the con
test between John Henry and the steam
drill. He named the place, the railroad,
a

and some nearby places. He gave John
Henry's last name, told where he was

from, gave two of his bosses' names, told
where one of them was from, and noted
that he thought John Henry had been a
slave in this boss's family. He told how
the contest came about, how prepara
tions were made for it, and how a crowd
of several hundred witnessed it. He de
scribed John Henry's death in sufficient
detail that a present-day physician has
been able to give an informed opinion of
its cause (ventricular rupture).
He told
how John Henry's wife had been sum
moned when he was dying and how she
cradled his head in her lap.
When Johnson asked Spencer for more
information, he replied with a second
long and detailed letter. He was a will
ing informant who did not avoid details.
Indeed, he even gave an exact date for
John Henry's death: September 20, 1882.
All of this marks Spencer as a potential
star

witness.

Further, Spencer's is part of an island of
coherent testimony involving four other

informants. F. P. Barker of Birmingham
and Glendora Cannon Cummings of East
Lansing, Michigan, named Alabama as the
John Henry site. Johnson tried but failed to
locate the places to which these Alabama
claims referred.
he gave

up on

When his leads dried up,

Alabama and cast his lot

with West Virginia.

1931

The fourth

informant whose testimony

ties in with the others is

C. S.

Farquharson,

of the Public Works

Department of Jamai
ca, who corresponded with Chappell.
Later, after I had found the location
described by Spencer, Barker, and Cum
mings, I became aware of the comments
of Mrs.

C. T. Davis, of Leeds, Alabama,
who was quoted in a 1955 Birmingham
news article by Warren Musgrove. Part
of Davis's testimony reinforces a part of
Spencer's for which, until recently, there
was no other confirming testimony.
In October of 2008 I conducted a tele
phone interview with Robert Moore, 86,
a native of Leeds, Alabama, now
living in
whose
father
knew
men
who
Birmingham,
had worked with John Henry. His testimo

ny agrees with that Davis and Cummings.
Thus, the island of coherent testimony

now

involves

six

informants,

Spencer,

Barker,
Cummings, Farquharson, Da
vis, and Moore. Their testimonies don't

agree in every detail, but they do agree in

some that are particularly important, and

their disagreements are understandable.
Spencer and Barker agree that John Henry
was at "Cruzee" "Cursey" Mountain, Al
abama. Cummings and Moore agree that
he was at Oak Mountain, also in Alabama.
Spencer, Barker, Cummings, and Moore
agree that it was in the 1880s. Spencer
said 1882, Barker "somewhere about"

Davis and
1882, and Cummings 1887.
Moore said that it was when the railroad
was being put through the Leeds area,
which was 1886-88.
Spencer, Cummings, and Farquharson
agree that John Henry worked for Shea
(Shay) and Dabney (Dabner).
Spencer and Davis agree that John
Henry and one of his bosses were from
Moore agrees that John
Mississippi.
was
from
Henry
Mississippi.
Spencer
says Holly Springs. Davis and Moore
don't mention

a

town.

a moment. These
people gave their information 40 to 121

Let's ruminate on this for
six

�years after tire incidents they describe, and
they lived in distant places: Utah, Alabama,
Michigan, and Jamaica. It is not reasonable

imagine that they had been in contact
with one another or were colluding in any
to

in

various combina

way. Yet they agree,
tions, about aspects of John Henry.

They couldn't have been making things
up. If they had been, how often would
two people pick "Cruzee"/"Cursey"
Mountain as the place where John Henry
worked? How often would three people
pick the names Shea and Dabney for his
How often would two people
bosses?
decide that John Henry and his boss were
from the same place in Mississippi?
Never. The probability that they could
invent independently the information
they agree on is so low that it might as
well be zero.
This information has a source. What
is it?
Perhaps some published fictional
story? None has ever been found.
Could the source be some orally circulat
ing story with no foundation in fact? De
tails such as "Cruzee" "Cursey" Mountain
and "Shea and Dabney" would be strange
inventions for a widespread fictional story.

is nothing particularly attractive or
impressive about them. Why would they

There

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

be

It is

is a

recalled if they were fiction?
unlikely that the source of information
circulating fictional story.

invented

or

The most likely source of the Alabama
claims is history itself. The best expla
nation, by far, for Spencer's excellence
as a witness and for this island of coher

ence in John Henry testimony, spanning
six informants, is that John Henry was,
in fact,

a

Mississippian who worked

for

Shea and Dabney at "Cruzee" /"Cursey"
Mountain, Alabama, in the 1880s.
Where is "Cruzee" "Cursey" Mountain?

Neither Johnson nor Chappell could find
it. In the summer of 2001 1 sat in my office
pondering these names. They don't agree
precisely, so perhaps neither is precisely
correct. What do they sound like?
As I mulled this over, "Coosa" popped
I
thought I'd heard tire
Coosa River called the "Koosee." Indeed,
in the oldest literature, the name is spelled

into my mind.

"K-O-O-S-E-E."

"Coosa," "Koosee," "Cru

zee," and "Cursey" all sound a lot alike.
When I realized this I Googled "Coosa

Mountain." I got a railfan hit that men
tioned both Coosa and Oak Mountains
at Dunnavant, Alabama, and a railroad
tunnel through each of them.

That was real pay dirt. Although Spencer

and Barker had put John Henry

at

what

I

now thought was Coosa Mountain, Cummings had specified Oak Mountain. Here
are both, just two miles apart, on the same
This was the beginning of the
documentation confirming the testimony

railroad.

outlined above. I had found the place in
Alabama: Dunnavant, Shelby County.
This confirmed some of Spencer's addi

tional testimony. He said that Red Moun
tain was about 15 miles away. So it is.
He said that Rising Fawn, Georgia, was
near. It's about a hundred miles away
It

didn't take long

(Columbus
extended

to

discover that the

Western) Railway
from Goodwater,
In
to Birmingham in 1887-88.
the process Coosa and Oak Tunnels were
bored. Construction began early in 1887,
and the new line was opened on July 1,
1888, about six months behind schedule
due to extremely hard rock encountered
in the middle of Coosa Tunnel.
(Steel drivers say that rock is really hard
when you drill on one hole all day, and
then you have to mark the spot with
C &amp; W

&amp;

been
Alabama,

had

chalk, so you'll know where to put the
drill the next morning.)
Now I needed to find Shea and Dabney.
I

still haven't found Shea, but the Chief

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

In Roark Bradford's 1931
John Henry, the hero's
"
wife was "Julie Anne.

Illustration

Engineer for the C &amp; W was Captain
Frederick Yeamans Dabney. "Captain"
was his Civil War rank and his title, used

constantly ever after.

Captain Dabney was born in Virginia
moved to Raymond, Hinds
County, Mississippi, later that same year.
His father was a lawyer and judge. His
was a family of American aristocrats
who placed great value on education and
Educated in civil en
accomplishment.
in 1835 but

gineering at Rensselaer, he had already
begun his career in railroad design and

construction when the Civil War broke
out. His family opposed secession but
cast their lot with the Confederates once
the war began.
Fred Dabney served the

Confederacy
He designed
and supervised the construction of the
defenses at Port Hudson, Louisiana, on
the Mississippi River, and he managed
those defenses.
After this stronghold
had repulsed attacks in May 1863, the
laid

later, on July

siege.
9,

Forty-eight

days

after they had heard that

Vicksburg had fallen on July 4, the Reb
els surrendered. The Union gained com
plete control of the Mississippi River.
Fred Dabney was sent to tire Union prison
on Johnson's Island, Lake Erie, Ohio, where
about three hundred men died from harsh
conditions, illness, and starvation. Captain
Dabney's health suffered for the rest of his
life. One possibility is that he contracted
tuberculosis at Johnson's Island.
On May 24, 1865, he married his neigh
bor, Agatha Ann Moncure. They settled
at

Crystal Springs, Copiah County, Mis

sissippi, about 20 miles south of Ray
mond. Continuing his career in railroad
construction, he held several positions,
including that of General Manager of the
Vicksburg, Shreveport, and Pacific Rail

By late 1886 he had become Chief
Engineer for the C &amp; W and was about to

road.

build its extension through Dunnavant.
Spencer wrote that John Henry and his
boss were from Holly Springs, Mississip
pi.

but

There is
it is

fused

it

J. J.

Lankes

Henry were from the same
place makes John Henry's home Crystal
Springs, or a nearby place, as well.
According to Spencer; tire steel driver's hill
name was John Henry Dabney, and he had
probably been a slave in the Dabney family.
Captain Dabney's uncle had a large plan
tation about ten miles south of Raymond,
Mississippi. John Henry might have been
one of the 154 slaves he owned in 1860.
However, there is another possibility.
In 1860 Captain Dabney's father owned
eight slaves. In a memoir by Letitia Dab
and John

Captain Dabney's youngest sister,
a fond mention
of a slave boy,
Henry, who was a teenager during the

ney,

there is

In 1869 a black Henry Dab
married
ney
Margaret Foston in Copiah
In the census of
County, Mississippi.
1870 he is 20 years old.
Thus, he was
born in 1849-50. In the census he does
farm work. He appears as Henry "Dabner" in the census of 1880. We have no

Civil War.

in

Artillery and Engineering.

Yankees

by

a
Holly Springs, Mississippi,
obvious now that Spencer con
with Crystal Springs. Since Cap

tain Dabney was from Crystal Springs,
Spencer's and Davis' testimony that he

direct information that this Henry Dab
ney is Letitia's Henry or the legendary
steel driver, but he is certainly a prime
candidate for both.
So far we have a star witness, six in

formants

offering

coherent

and documentation

aspects of

Dunnavant

testimony,

confirming several
this testimony, all supporting

John Henry site.
Dunnavant's local leg
Adding
end. I first became aware of it through
an issue of The Right Way, a Central of
Georgia magazine, that commented on it
briefly. Then I found, among Johnson's
as the

to this is

papers

at

the

University

of

North Caro

lina, a copy of an article that appeared in
the Central of Georgia Magazine, October
1930. This article includes a photograph

steel drill sticking up from the rock
of Oak Tunnel,
said to be the last one driven by "Jawn
Henry" before he died.
The article indicates that Dunnavant's
John Henry legend was old in 1930. Ac
of

a

outside the east portal

cording to Jerry Voyles, a Leeds resident,
was old when his grandfather heard

it

it in 1912.
Thus, the legend may be oral
history that goes back to the time of John
Henry's death in 1887-88.
Johnson informant Sam Wallace, who
had worked at Big Bend Tunnel while it

�was being bored, had never heard of John
Henry until people started coming to the
Big Bend area asking about him. Chappell

visited in September 1925. Although ver
sions of the ballad mentioning Big Bend

were extant earlier, there is no evidence of
It
a substantial local legend before 1925.

possible, even probable, that the solidi
fication and proliferation of the Big Bend
is

legend was prompted by Chappell's 1925
visit and inquiries. Johnson speculated
as much. It was then reinforced by John
son's and Chappell's books.

The 1930 Central of Georgia Magazine ar
a text of the Jolrn Henry bal

ticle includes

lad collected in Alabama by Peter Brannon
and containing the lines, "The Central o'

Georgia Rail Road
me."

The C

&amp; W

Gonna be th' death o'
was owned by the Cen

tral Rail Road and

Banking Company of
which
was
called the "Central of
Georgia,
ballad text places
Another
early
Georgia."
John Henry on the "Georgia line."
What can we make of the fact that

a

couple of dozen early ballad texts put
John Henry on the C &amp; O and two put
him on the Central of Georgia? As noted
earlier, the popular vote of singers is very
weak evidence. Singers sing what they
like, and once an attractive line such as
"Big Bend Tunnel

on the C

&amp; O

road"

enters tradition, more and more singers
will take it up. Consequently, common
elements of a mature ballad must be re
garded with suspicion. They are likely
to have been in the original only if they
were attractive to singers.
but a rare
It may seem counterintuitive,
element of a ballad demands serious con
sideration. If it were attractive to singers, it
wouldn't be rare, so why is it found at all?
It is likely to be a relict, a residue from an
early version, still recalled by one singer or
a few. It may be from the original ballad.
Thus, the rare "Central o' Georgia Rail
Road" and "Georgia line" should be
taken seriously. The common "Big, Bend
Tunnel on the C &amp; O road" should be

viewed with suspicion.
Are there other elements

of

the John

Henry ballad that point to Dunnavant?
Yes. Here are some of them.
Ballad texts almost always refer to John
Henry's boss as "Captain," not "boss,"
"overseer," "foreman," etc. Although
"Captain" was a common title for any
white boss, Captain Dabney held the rank
literally. That could account for the nearly
universal use of "Captain" in the ballad.
Some ballad texts have people "out

hearing of John Henry's death
and catching an "east-bound train" to go

west"

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

"where John Henry's dead." John Henry
relatives and friends lived in
Mississippi, west of Alabama.
Dabney's

Two ballad texts put John Henry be
tween two mountains. This makes perfect
sense for the Dunnavant Valley, which
lies between Coosa and Oak Mountains.
It doesn't make much sense for Big Bend,
where there are mountains all around.
One ballad stanza states that the Cap
tain (Tommy in this version) "Loved John
Henry like his only son And Cap' Tom
my was the whitest man on earth." Fred
Dabney greatly admired his uncle, who
was noted for his humanity toward his
slaves. After the war, the uncle remained
friends with some of his ex-slaves. Fred
was about 15 years old when the Henry
His
Dabney of the census was born.
sister Letitia was fond of the slave boy

These circumstances suggest that
Fred Dabney could have loved John Hen
ry Dabney "like his only son."
One ballad text says that John Henry's
hammer could be heard in Chattanooga,
This is a
"two hundred miles away."
Henry.

plausible tall tale for Dunnavant, which
is actually about 135 miles from Chatta
nooga, as the crow flies, but Chattanooga
would be an unlikely choice for a ballad
maker at Big Bend.

Another ballad text gives

a

day of the week

for John Henry's death: "John Henry died
on a Tuesday." Spencer said that he died on

September 20, 1882, but in fact the year had
to have been 1887, the only September dur
ing which the C &amp; W was under construc
tion. September 20, 1887, was a Tuesday.
For
or

random choices

day is

1

in

7.

neither was

a

the

of

both, the probability

of

date,

day,

agreement on

Therefore it is likely that
random choice. The most

likely interpretation is that both date and
day represent historic fact.
The late Neal Patman, a blues singer from
Athens, Georgia, sang "Maggadee" as the
He told me
name of John Henry's wife.
that his father had sung it that way.
The

Henry

of

Dabney

the

1870

sus was married to Margaret.

cen

She was

"Margaret Dabney" and could have been
called "Maggie D." "Maggadee" sounds
very much like "Maggie D."
In the

ballad as

day, John

it is

Henry's wife

commonly sung to
or woman is almost

always "Polly Ann." Polly has long been
a
popular name in ballads. I doubt very
much that "Polly Ann" was in the origi
nal ballad or that

it is

historically correct.

too good to be true. Further, it de
rives plausibly from "Maggie D" through
is

It

"Mary Magdalene,"
of

which are found

and "Mary Ann," all
in versions of "John

Henry." "Polly" is a nickname for "Mary."
In the ballad, John Henry is taken some
times to the "new buryin' ground" and
"buried in the sand." Also, "And every
locomotive come roarin' by
Says there
lays that steel drivin' man." Sand Ridge
Cemetery is 1.8 miles, as the crow flies,
across a valley from the C &amp; W tracks,
from which there is an unobstructed
view of Sand Ridge.

Although

the

earliest

marked

graves
Ridge Cemetery date from the
turn of the twentieth century, there are
many unmarked graves of unknown
date. It is not known exactly when Sand
Ridge Cemetery was created. However,
a genealogist claims that Godfrey Isbell
was buried on Sand Ridge in about 1882.
in Sand

This suggests that Sand Ridge Cemetery
existed by 1887, when it could have
been new.
Margie Isbell has been told that a black
man is buried at an edge of Sand Ridge
There is at least one other
Cemetery.
site, outside the present fence, that looks
like a sunken grave.
All

of this suggests that John Henry
lie
buried at Sand Ridge Cemetery.
may
Are there elements of the John Henry bal

lad that point to Big Bend Tunnel?

Except

�for explicit mentions of Big Bend Tunnel
and the C &amp; O road, I have not found any.

Are there elements of the John Henry
ballad that are not consistent with Dunnavant? In addition to the same exceptions,
"White House" is mentioned sometimes.
This could be a reference to the Virginia
Penitentiary, which would point to Lewis

Tunnel, Virginia, as the John Henry site.
Otherwise, I have not found anything
in the ballad that is not consistent with

Dunnavant

as the John Henry site.
That completes the presentation of the
evidence considered here. What evi
dence do we lack? We don't have a news
article, "Steel Driver Dies After Beating
Steam Drill."
The few C &amp; W records that I have seen
are not very helpful. We have no reports
from Captain Dabney and no correspon
dence between him and other executives

of the C &amp; W,

except

E.

C.

Moncure, an

other Mississippian, who was the title
and land agent for the C &amp; W. We have no

contractor's reports and no contractor's
correspondence with Captain Dabney.
The Georgia Historical Society holds a
large number of records from the Central
of Georgia, said to fill about 500 boxes.
records are clearly incomplete.
Also, they are not well cataloged. Finding

These

something

is

hit-and-miss proposition.
contemporary diaries or let

a

We have no

ters that tell about the

man.

steel-driving
hundreds of people
witnessed the contest between John Henry
and the steam drill, as Spencer claimed,
wouldn't many of them have written about

This bothers me.

it in

some form?

If

The problem,

I

suppose,

that such ephemera tend not to survive.
Even so, sometimes miracles happen. I am
is

hopeful that contemporary writing about
John Henry may yet surface.
Right now, we must be satisfied with
what we have. What is that, all told?
We have a star witness, C. C. Spen
who gave Iris testimony in 1927. He
claimed to have known JoJm Henry and
to have witnessed the events leading up to
his race with a steam drill, the contest itself,
cer,

and John Henry's death. He gave many
details, including that the full name of the

steel driving man was JoJm Henry Dabney,
that he had a boss named Dabney, and that
they were both from Mississippi.
We have five corroborating witnesses,
in distant places, from the late 1920s

through

They verify the place as
the time as the 1880s, the

2008.

Dunnavant,

names of John Henry's bosses as Shea
and Dabney, and the home of John Henry
and Dabney as Mississippi.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

We have documentation that Captain
Frederick Yeamans Dabney was the Chief

Engineer for the

C &amp; W,

that he built its

extension from Goodwater to Birming
ham between 1886 and '88, and that his
home was Crystal Springs, Mississippi.
We have documentation of a Henry who
a slave to
Captain Dabney's father and
teenager during the Civil War. We also
have documentation of a Henry Dabney
who lived near Crystal Springs after the
War and who was about 37 years old in
1887. hi 1869 he married Margaret Foston.
We have a strong local tradition that
John Henry raced a steam drill and died
near Dunnavant, Alabama, while the C
&amp; W was being extended from Goodwa
ter to Birmingham. From the John Henry
ballad, we have a number of lines and

was
a

phrases that are consistent with his hav
ing been at Dunnavant.
In

my opinion, all of this adds up to over

circumstantial evidence that
Henry was a real man who raced a
steam drill and died at Dunnavant.
Dunnavant is the only proposed John

whelming
JoJm

Henry location with a strong and coherent
local tradition that has reinforcing ties to
documentation and the ballad. Big Bend
Tunnel, West Virginia, has only a tradition.
Jamaica has a weak tradition in which Jofm
Henry died in an accident between 1894

there is good evi
is too late
dence that the ballad was sung by 1888. The
Virginia speculation is based on insufficient
facts. There is no evidence that JoJm William
Henry, leased to a C &amp; O contractor from the
Virginia Penitentiary, was a steel driver, no
and 1896. This

evidence of
that he died

a

contest, no definitive evidence
Lewis Tunnel, etc.

at

Those who would place John Henry at
some site other than Dunnavant have the
burden of providing a reasonable expla
nation of how all the evidence outlined
I have not been
think of such an explanation, and I
aware that one has been proposed.
the best explanation is that stories

here came to exist.

Henry
ion,

at

it is

Dunnavant

is a

By far
of John

are true. In my

beyond reasonable doubt.

John Garst

able to
am not

opin

retired University of Georgia

chemistry professor who has been interested
He has
in "John Henry" since about 1960.
also uncovered interesting facts about "Way
faring Stranger," "Man of Constant Sor
row," "Ella Speed," "Delia," "Batson," "Red
"
River Valley, and other songs.
This

is a

revised version of a lecture presented
Henry Day Celebration in Leeds,

at the John

Alabama, September 15, 2007.

�MOUNTAIN COUNTRY

OKEH RECORDS' HISTORIC ASHEVILLE SESSIONS

by Kent Priestley

guitarist, Henry Whitter, slid his chair across the floor to bring his instrument
little closer to the recording machine's sound-gathering
horn. A harmonica dangled from his neck on a wire
truss; he made a tentative puff on it and looked over to the
man behind the controls.
Next to Whitter was Kelly Harrell, a singer who'd trav
eled down with him from the same part of Virginia. Harrell
tugged absently at his shirt collar. He cleared his throat.
"You boys ready?" the engineer asked. The men nodded. They shouldn't have been so nervous
they'd made
after
all
but
never
then, you
recordings before,
got used
to it. Making things worse was the fact that the room was
so damn hot. They'd been in here for just a few minutes, but
already their shirts were soaked through with sweat.
And now it was time. The engineer made a three
count and tilted a finger their way. On the bed of
the machine before them, a wax platter began
spinning. As it turned, a metal blade sliced
into it and trimmed a delicate rind from its
surface. Whitter led the song off, puffing the
melody out on his harmonica once around
before Harrell squared his body to the horn
and began to sing:
The
a

was homed about ten thousand years ago
There was nothing ever happened I don't know

I

saw Pharaoh and his daughter shooting craps for a quarter
And I heard him say, 'Oh girl I've won your dough.
I

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

'

Drawings by Phil Blank

�Piano
Piano

Serenata
Sapphire

Silhouette
Soliloquy

Solo

Fever

Spring

Piano

That Futuristic Rag
Solo

Doll

piano

Dance

MAJOR,

BOWES',

THEATRE

Thf w2rs

T

Feeds

40813

lfp 40999
40930

Down

Engineer

Farmer

Deal

Your

Let

41073

O? M n

ne tonka

Don't

Fare You
Clarke

CAPITOL
TRIO

Tv/rvctm-v Of

nv

ELECTRIC

41073
40931
40901
40867
40867

Solo

Records

OKER

The Quality

Go

The Mogull
Well, Old Joe

On

Is

Man

The

Them All

ao^ekR^lrulen£i

Wil°
VV

Gonna Swing On The Golden

Gate

Bound For Alabama
Honest Farmer, The
Hell

YouCa^^Stop-

If

45096
45176
4uu.,8
40071

io9Ai
45159
45159
40411

CIIALLIS, BETII AND
TAYLOR, NOEL
Get
-Em
In
A
Rumble

Seat
Nothin'

i

Baby'

My

8548
8548

Been

k's All

ley

t.

Again

rfuflililll

[)W

Vkfl
Your
Step-V^QM|ii||
Count

ia2Hr5£J5p

T

40204
Alabama Gal
40108
Arkansas Traveler
The
7006
Ahead,
Coach
Baggage
Be Kind To A Man When
40050
He Is Down
Billy In The Low Ground 40020
Boil Them Cabbage Down 40306
40419
Boston Burglar, The
40038
Casey Jones
40119
Cat Came Back, The

Charming Betsy

Joe

Eyed

mental
Death Of

Floyd

InstruCollins,

Return?
Weevil

Ever

Boll
Cowboy

neyTS^S5255S^^^^^^
40306
Bill
1

Tniiv
JOHN

40363
45122

ffig

40085
7004

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Steamboat

45139
Swanee River
There's A Hard Time Com-

ing
Tom Watson
To

Welcome

Home

Special
The Travelers

In The Hay
In The Straw

Turkey
Turkey

when Abraham And Isaac
Rushed The Can
When You And I

Were

40411
40050

A

Are

45162

All Depends On
Contralto
My Blue Heaven
'

too

Vocal
Dream

Busy!

Was

8475
8536
8596

8596
Vocal
Who's
Wonderful?

It

A

Who's
Marvelous?
belle

You

Miss

Lee

Anna-

8536

Joy

BE

Lady Out

DELK

40181

400"0
Maggie
Never Miss Your
Mother Until She Is Gone 4994

Henry's Made
Of Lizzie

Eolks

cash

45001
45167
40230

Will

CHALLIS'

To-

RECORDS
avm
4207
Medley
Christmas Hymns n/r„jiQ,,
Christmas Song (Chantique

Young,

You

House

LILLIG
|(KgTIAX.
she sweet Contral-

vtM5n

,v,
FIDDLIN

CARSON,

Dixie
Dixie

W,

No

f*

A

45208

45100

You^5X^^^^^HHIHBjHVVnW5F!V7V!MW91^^^^HC9w

Everything

Cotton

t,tt
BILLt

IBD,

Jelly Roll Queen
Oh Yeah!
'Tain't None 0'Your^b^M^^H|^H^yUAjajUjUSLUifH^HKJHKfLried
You're
Man

Cares

■ways

.1

45213
45208

Duet

Hand
Gonna Make You

watch

Vocal

Me

o

I

Yourself

ine-ss

45203

Done452()3
AND WHITE
four Mother

AN|
Blues

--Vocal

The Lone

)n

BUTTERBE
Z

BILL

,RS,

^45213
To

40987

The Moonlight, The Star41015
Ught And You)
410,5
We L°e "
CHICAGO FOOTWARMERS
8533
Ballin' The Jack
8599
Brush Stomp Fox Trot
Blues&gt;Em
Get
Again
8599
Fox Trot

°m4n&lt;.20

A

(But

Mind

On My

40987

CHRISTMAS

To

Oh

f"1
O!
O

4u.ni

Noel)

de

The World!
All

Come,

Little

hem
Thou

Ye

Faith-

Bethle
Of Twy.,Town_ nf
Joyful

StfS^ht,
Silent Night,

(O

Sane-

Holy Night
Holy N'ght

4207

409.4

40.1.4

4bl0
3024

�The voice was an odd quantity. Phrases
spilled from Harrell's mouth in a long
and lagging way. He inserted dips and
swoops in his verses, beating words that
didn't have an obvious relationship with
each other into something like a rhyme.
It was
strange voice, but it sold records.
The next morning, the Asheville Citizen
had the story: "There is a lot of respira
tion and perspiration connected with the

making of phonograph records. This was
demonstrated in the recording labora
tory of George Vanderbilt Hotel yesterday
when the OKeh Record Company began
making
"Today,

a

series of 'hill country records.'"

a

number of singers and players

from the mountain country will be tried
out before the reproducing device," the
Citizen story

continued. "The first test

is

said to be one of the severest experiences
the singer or player ever has to undergo
and more difficult than an appearance

before a large audience."
It was the last week of
August 1925, and
the music industry had come to Asheville,
North Carolina. Its temporary home and
workshop was a turret-like structure
atop the Vanderbilt's roof, where, ear
lier in the week, the OKeh men had as

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

sembled their make-do "laboratory." The

walls were hung with blankets in order
to mask the faint clack of the trolleys, the
bleat of horns and human voices rising
from Haywood Street below, and the pe
riodic rumbles and moans of the Vander
bilt's own elevator. The "reproducing de
vice" was put together and leveled, and
chairs set out for the musicians.
In

charge of all of this was Ralph

S.

Peer,

artists-and-recording director for New
York City-based
General Phonograph
and
its
OKeh Records. It
label,
Company
was an increasingly familiar routine for
Peer: arrive at a Southern city, set up, au
dition whichever musicians responded
the

to

company's advertisements,

win

now the talent from the chaff, make some
wax "test" records and return to New
York with a crate of potential releases.
Already that year, Peer had led nine of
these "field recording" excursions, in
cluding two dates in Atlanta, one in St.
Louis and another in Kansas City.
OKeh's Asheville stay, the Citizen report
was "the first time phono
graph records have ever been made in the
Carolinas." But already the company had

explained,

found the atmosphere of Asheville "to be
the best in the country for the reproduc
tion of the human voice and instrument
music." It was expected, the story went
on to relate, "that the company will make
the

majority

of its

Southern records in

this city."

years before, with the record
business under assault by a new tech
nology radio
Ralph Peer struck on
an idea. The industry's standard fare
operatic sopranos, marching bands and
were losing their ap
jazz orchestras
peal. Peer, though, believed there was
a market for records that had
yet to be
Three

exploited. The secret, he figured, lay in
"ethnic" music: Hungarian violinists,

Russian singers, German polka bands,
Swedish choirs. And though at first he
was reluctant, in time Peer turned his
attention to the American South, with
its simmering stew of blues, gospel,
string bands, hoary balladeers and

cornpone humorists.

Rather than bring those artists up

the

company's

headquarters

in

to

New

as was the custom, Peer deter
mined that it was in OKeh's best in
terest to bring the recording studio to
them. The formula was working, and
by 1922, the South had given OKeh two
popular new categories: "race records,"

York,

performances
by
and gospel

blues

African-American

singers,

and

"hill

country records" by artists who tended
to be rural and white.
This wasn't the first time the industry
had flirted with rural music. In 1914 and
again in 1916, Columbia Records record
ed a fiddler from Clinton, North Caro
lina, named Don Richardson, including
his version of an old-time standard with
a
unique spelling: "Arkansaw Traveler."
In 1922 the virtuosic Texan fiddler Alex
ander "Eck" Robertson was recorded in
New York by the Victor Talking Machine
Company, but for the most part Robert
son's sides and those of earlier fiddlers
were little more than novelties, only hint
ing at the rich seam of black, Cajun, and
Anglo melodies circulating below the

Mason-Dixon Line.

During a field-recording date in At
lanta in 1923, Peer minted what would
be the

industry's first "hill country"

star.

OKeh had come to the Georgia city to
record blues and gospel performers, but
toward the end of the company's resi
dency there, Peer was introduced to Fiddlin' John Carson, a white musician from
the north-Georgia hills. Peer recorded

Carson
has

it

in

grudgingly, country music lore
conditions that were less than

ideal. The sound of Carson's record, Peer

would later say, was "pluperfect awful."
Nevertheless, a test pressing of 500 of
Carson's debut

"Little Old Log Cabin
A-side and "The Old

in the Lane" on the

Hen Cackled and the Rooster's Going to
Crow" on the reverse
sold out in the
span of an afternoon.
At first, OKeh took to calling the music

Carson and others who fit the same
profile "hill country" or "old-time." It
would be a few years before the success
of

a band
from Galax, Virginia, would
lend the genre another name: "hillbilly,"
a title that stuck until the 1940s, when it

of

was replaced by "country."
More than even Atlanta, Asheville held
the promise of "hill country" talent. For

one, Peer had a reliable local informant
Bascom Lamar Lunsford, a Leicester
song-catcher who also practiced law in
in

Asheville. As

a
young man, Lunsford
traveled throughout Western North Car
olina, selling fruit trees and gathering
scraps of melody and verse. He called at
remote mountain cabins and lingered in

company of musicians and singers,
acquiring, by one estimate, at least 3,000
songs and other folkloric materials in the
course of his life.
Already in 1924, Lunsford had been
recorded by OKeh in Atlanta, waxing
the

two songs:

"I

Wish

I

Was

a

Mole in the

�he learned from a fel
Rutherford College, and
"Jesse James," which Lunsford got from
Sam Sumner of Bat Cave, North Caro
lina. This, Peer must have realized, was
a good person to have around.
"Asheville in the 1920s was an interest

Ground/' which
low student

at

ing place," observes Bob Carlin, author
of String Bands in the North Carolina Pied
mont. "It was a very sophisticated place
in many ways, but it was also right in
the middle of the mountains. There was
industry there and opportunity, but very
soon after you got out of the city limits,
you were in the heart of the mountains
and there was a lot of music to be had."
Artists from Western North Carolina
had been recorded in the past, but well
outside of their own setting. "Previously,
if you wanted to record, you had to travel
to New York," Carlin notes, citing the ex

amples of Samantha Bumgarner, Eva Da

vis, and Ernest Thompson, who in 1924

recorded in New York for Columbia.
"That was a pioneering session for this
music," Carlin says. Bumgarner, who
was from Jackson County, is said to have
been the first five-string banjo player ever
recorded, and the first woman to record

music that could be considered "country."
"But it was a new thing to make record
ings in the South," Carlin notes. "And the
Asheville sessions were an early venture
of the companies out of New York and
into the Southern mountains."
Peer wasn't guided by any notions of
historic preservation. He wasn't a folklorist, and had no particular interest in
the rustic arts. He'd come to Asheville
in hopes of nosing out talent that would
make his company money. With him to
the mountains, Peer brought OKeh's re

cording engineer, Charles Hibbard, and
the

company's general-sales representa

tive, G.

S.

Jeffers. Up from Atlanta for

the event was Polk

C.

Brockman, OKeh's

regional-distribution chief.
The OKeh men wore fine suits and had

refined air about them, not unusual for
guests at the Vanderbilt. What set them
apart were the things they brought with
them: piles of heavy blankets, trunks filled
a

with mechanical apparatuses, tins clink
ing with fine metal styluses, crates packed
with hundreds of carefully wrapped wax

discs, legal forms and ledgers.
Whitter and Harrell, the Virginians,
were the first to survive the OKeh test
in Asheville, and they went on to record
perhaps a dozen more sides that hot
August afternoon before yielding their
seats to a pair of banjoists from Winston-

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Salem named R.B. Smith and S.J. Allgood. The latter recorded but one side, a
rendition of "American and Spanish Fandango" that ran three minutes and

sounded as gentle
"unusually fine."

as

waves tickling

a

lakeshore.

It

was, the Citizen related,

The hotel OKeh had picked as its home base hadn't been there a year before.
Asheville, the seven-story Vanderbilt was brand-new, part of a

Like much of

wave of freshly built upscale lodgings in the city. Though it lacked the scale
and outward refinement of the nearby Battery Park Hotel, the Vanderbilt
was posh throughout, from its tiled reception room to its Grand Ballroom.
Above it all was the Vanderbilt's roof garden, with its whitewashed wood
pergola and dance floor beneath, open to the evening stars.
Days prior to the start of recording, the would-be stars of hill-country music
crowded the Vanderbilt's lobby, hoping for the opportunity to sit before the
horn. And what a sight they were: milling about the reception area and the
sidewalk outside, the roughest among them in crumpled felt hats and worn
shirts, with instrument cases in their callused hands.
Recording began at the Vanderbilt on Tuesday, August 25. A fresh-faced singer
of 35, Kelly Harrell was a renowned entertainer and sometimes mill-worker
from Drapers Valley, Virginia. A year before OKeh's Asheville date, Harrell had
gone to New York to record for the Victor Talking Machine Company, but Peer

had since made him

a

better offer.

Harrell's accompanist in Asheville, Henry Whitter, despite
possessing only a faltering musical ability, was shaping up

reputation for
OKeh's go-to
backer for its old-timey selections. Described in the company's catalog as
"the most novel entertainer for he plays a harmonica and a guitar at the same
time and never misses a note," Whitter was labeled by the trade publication
a

as

Machine World as nothing short of "a mountain star."
Ernest V. Stoneman, an autoharp player and balladeer from
Galax, Virginia, waxed 10 or more sides in the Vanderbilt's rooftop hot-box,
including "The Sailor's Song," "Blue Ridge Mountain Blues," a spry number
The Talking

A day later,

called "The Fancy Ball" and "John Hardy."
By Thursday, with his brother Blackwell chirping along on fiddle, the sing
ing attorney of Leicester, Bascom Lamar Lunsford, had recorded two sides
at the Vanderbilt, including "Fate of Santa Barbara," a song commemorating
the California city's earthquake of just two months before. "Fate" sat neatly
within a hot sales category known as "event songs"
songs of trapped spelunkers, wind-whipped fire, shipwrecks, and God's obvious hand in them
which had become central to OKeh's catalog. On this count Lunsford gave
the company what it wanted.
Also that week, Lunsford wrote an event song called "The Last Battle,"
or "Bryan's Last Battle," which told the story of the Scopes "Monkey Trial"
which had finished just a month before, after which the prosecutor, William
Jennings Bryan, promptly died. Later, Lunsford would record the song un
der the title "Evolution."
Following Lunsford into the studio was Fisher Hendley, a banjo player and
singer from the North Carolina Piedmont. After Hendley's turn at the hom came
a duo named J. D. McFarlane and
Daughter who recorded two tunes on fiddle
with piano accompaniment: "Devil in the Woodpile" and "Whistlin' Rufus."
On Tuesday of the following week, the duo named the Carson Brothers was
joined in the OKeh laboratory by autoharp player Roosevelt Smith. Their entire output from that day whispered from beyond the grave, including such
toe-tappers as "Oh! We Miss You," and "Don't Grieve Over Me."
Even by the standards of the time, the Asheville sessions were unusually
well-stocked with banjo players. "One of the interesting things about these

sessions

is the variety of banjo styles," observes Wayne Martin of the North
Carolina Arts Council. The Asheville sides hint at a world of styles on that
instrument before a certain banjo player from Shelby, North Carolina, swept

them away.
"When Earl Scruggs came on the scene in the 1940s, his style was so perva
sive that everyone who played a banjo ended up playing three-finger banjo,"
Martin says. "But back in this time, there was an incredible variety in the way
the banjo was played."

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

i
1

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�in Asheville from Independence, Virginia, was
33-year-old banjoist Wade Ward, who played his instru
ment in the clawhammer style. Ward's four sides were never
issued by OKeh, but at least one of the test records he re
survives. In his
"Married Man's Blues"
corded that day

Pond, Tennessee, Harris' command

the

phrasing

book Country Music Records: A Discography, 1921-1942, Tony
Russell referred to this glimpse of a young Ward, who in his
autumn years was studied and emulated by a generation of

Harris' advanced age at the time of his recordings has led
more than one music historian, including the late Charles

Turning up

old-time revivalists, as "tantalizing."
From West Asheville came Ernest Helton, a half-Cherokee
musician with lustrous black hair and lean, film-star good
looks. Helton's talents on several instruments were in demand
around the mountains, and in an Asheville City directory of
the time, Helton was listed under that rarest of occupations,
the "professional musician." Though a gifted player of oldtime music, for the OKeh sessions Helton chose to play a for
parlor-piece on the banjo called "Royal Clog," a melody
made up of ascending and descending scales bridged by pecu
liar chromatic flights.
Later that day, OKeh captured one of just six recorded sides by
of Hel
J. D. Harris, a senior fiddler and sometimes band-mate
ton's who lived near Asheville at the time. Born in 1868 in Flag
mal

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

of the bow and his tight
mention his legendary repertoire would
inspire a number of fiddlers from the region, including Chero
kee's Manco Sneed, Bill Hensley of the Avery's Creek section of
Buncombe County, and Marcus Martin of Swannanoa.

not

to

Wolfe, to suggest that his playing embodied the sound of fid
dling from at least as far back as the time of the Civil War, and
perhaps earlier. Harris recorded but one tune in Asheville, a
solo fiddle piece called "The Cackling Hen."
"Listening to Dedrick (J. D.) Harris makes me think of a pas
sage in Cecil Sharpe's diary from 1916," says Adam Tanner,

Weaverville, North
three weeks on
Carolina. "Sharpe talks about traveling
to
listen to a few
Asheville
to
Hot
from
horseback
Springs just
select men and women sing." Harris's "Cackling Hen," Tanner
added, "is similar to the songs Sharpe went out of his way to
an

old-time and blues fiddler who lives

in

for

hear, in that [it is] repetitive and odd, otherworldly, and beau
tifully unpredictable." By the time he sat for his sole Asheville
recording, Tanner suggests, Harris "may have been one of the
last of

a

generation

to

play

a

dying music."

What wasn't recorded in Asheville is arguably more tanta
lizing than what was. Stories are still in circulation that the
"Singing Brakeman" Jimmie Rodgers showed up but failed
to impress the OKeh men. If Peer had any knowledge of Rod
gers' presence in Asheville in 1925, he never spoke of it, but
the story persists nonetheless. Within a year's time Rodgers

was indeed living in Asheville, playing house parties around
the city with Ernest Helton. But exactly when he arrived re
mains in question.
Other musicians are said to have missed out on the Asheville
date as well. "One of the musicians who was a big influence
on [Earl Scruggs] was Smith Hammett," Carlin says. "Hammett never recorded. But supposedly he was on his way to
Asheville for these sessions and his car broke down. For what
ever reason, he didn't make it. So, that might have been a way
that we could have heard Smith, and been able to make a more
direct connection between Earl and him."
Both the Asheville Citizen and the Asheville Times attached con

siderable moment

to the

studio appearance on September

1

Em-

mett Miller. A blackface and vaudeville performer from Macon,
Georgia, Miller was in Asheville that week with Nan Fitzgerald,
"Juvenile Comedienne

in Songs and Dances," playing to nearat
the
crowds
Theatre, located on the corner of
Majestic
capacity
College and Market streets downtown. In a Majestic advertise
ment in the Times that week, Miller was hailed as both "Asheville's

Favorite Blues Singer" and "OKeh Record Star."

Miller's output while in Asheville was modest but influential.
With the piano accompaniment of Walter Rothrock, Miller re
corded a self-written number, "You're Just the Girl For Me," as
well as, "I Never Had the Blues (Until I Left Old Dixie Land),"
"Big Bad Bill (Is Sweet William Now)" and, most interesting to
country music historians, what would be just the second record
ed version of the Irving Mills number "Lovesick Blues." Despite
Miller's obscurity today, his Asheville sides demonstrate that

his "blue yodeling" presaged Jimmie Rodgers' by at least a few
years and Hank Williams' by nearly a quarter-century. In 1949,
Williams would have a number-one hit with "Lovesick Blues,"

even
Last

as
to

Miller's own career was evaporating.
record was the Vanderbilt's house band, the Foor-Rob-

inson Carolina Club Orchestra. The previous week, tire Citizen

�reported

that

the

orchestra was "putting

finishing touches on preparations

the

for

recording some of the numbers that have
been so popular with dancers in the Vanderbilt ballroom." With temperatures in the
was the

high 80s, Wednesday, September 2,
hottest of OKeh's ten-day stay in Asheville,
and the band suffered considerably in the
Vanderbilt's "laboratory." Nevertheless, the
orchestra managed to record two numbers,
"Rose of the Nile," an exotic, snake-charmer
melody, and "Collegiate," a zippy time with
a rah-rah
college chant at its center.
And then it was over. Even as the orchestra
members filed out of the makeshift studio
and toward the bar for a drink, the blankets
were being folded, the chairs stowed and the
'reproducing machine' sent down the Van
derbilt's elevator. Peer had what he wanted,
60 test records to take back with him to New
York. OKeh never returned to Asheville,
even though Peer had told a Citizen reporter
on his way out of town that he was "greatly
pleased with tire results obtained here and

with the co-operation by local people."
"The OKeh company,"
continued the
Citizen report with more than a little hope
fulness, "expects to make Asheville head
quarters for summer recording on account
of the

superior quality

which

is

ideal for their purposes."

quality of air notwithstanding,

the

The

sound

phones, which relied on direct sound pres
sure to activate the reproducing device's
needle. That same year, the electric micro

phone was introduced, becoming more or
a year's time.
Two summers later, under the banner
of the Victor Talking Machine Company,
Peer's work would carry him to Bristol,
Tennessee, a city that today claims itself to
less universal within

"Birthplace of Country Music." At

the famous sessions there, along with

a

list

musicians including OKeh's Asheville
alumni Ernest Stoneman and Henry Whitter, Peer would capture the first sounds of
of

Rodgers and the Carter Family.
would soon
reduce musicians such as Kelly Harrell,

Jimmie

The success of those two acts
the

strange-voiced singer from Drapers
Virginia,

Valley,

notes

to little

more than foot

country -music history.
Harrell's career would not outlast the
Depression. Whatever his skills as a
in

singer and a songwriter, the fact that he
couldn't play an instrument made him a
dim prospect in the eyes of A&amp;R men for

whom the bottom line was everything.
But in Asheville during the last week of
August 1925,

all

ter's version of the murder ballad "Wild
Bill Jones,"

with

"I

Was Born About Ten

Thousand Years Ago" on its reverse.
Above the description of the songs is a
snapshot of the two men, taken on the
Vanderbilt's roof after their recording ses
sion. Harrell's shirt hangs loosely about
his small frame, the top button sprung
open. He looks tired from his time spent
in the "laboratory,"

arms slack at his side.
him, the larger Whitter stands
more proudly, his Gibson guitar angled
across the front of his body. Both men are
squinting into the late-summer sun.
"The rich-voiced Kelly Han'ell has made a

Next

to

record to be proud of," reads the description
beneath the photo. "First because it consists
of two very fine songs, and second, because
he is such an

accomplished singer."

"Be sure to get this record," the

catalog

says, "and learn what you missed."
Kent Priestley is

a
freelance writer living in
Knoxville, Tennessee. He is the author, with
Jon Elliston, of North Carolina Curiosities

(The Globe Pequot Press,

2

007).

of the air here

on the Asheville records was not good. In
1925, OKeh still employed acoustic micro

be the

announced
Asheville recordings in its holiday
catalog, including Harrell and WhitAt the turn of the year, OKeh

the

was promise.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

This article first appeared in the Mountain
Xpress.

�Workshop

OLD-TIME GUITAR:

DALLAS JONES OF THE LEAKE COUNTY REVELERS
ON"LONESOME BLUES"
By John Miller
Transcriptions by John Miller, Walt Koken, and Clare Milliner
When you listen to the early recordings of old-time music, it doesn't take too long to real
ize that quite often, what makes a rendition of a tune or song most distinctive is the way

which the accompanying musicians go about the business of supporting the melody.
Nowadays we may take it for granted that old-time rhythm guitar playing is going to be
played with a flat pick in the "boom-chang" fashion, with more or fewer bass runs depend
ing on the taste and facility of the individual doing the playing. That wasn't always the
case, though, of course, and still isn't in some quarters.
Dallas Jones, who played guitar for the Mississippi band the Leake County Revelers, has
long been a particular favorite of mine. His playing wasn't flashy or calculated to dazzle
the listener, but he had perfect time at any tempo, and a mysterious ability to make every
thing around him just sound better. He was a thoroughly musical player. If we look at
how he functioned in his back-up role on one of the Revelers' tunes, from beginning to end,
what we find might yield some ideas that could be usable in other tune or song contexts.
in

"Lonesome Blues": the melody
"Lonesome Blues" can

be found on Mississippi String Bands, Volume 2 (County
County Revelers, Vol. 2, 1929-1930 (Document DOCD-8030).
Despite its title, "Lonesome Blues" is not a 12-bar blues, but rather a relaxed, medi
um-tempo 32-bar fiddle tune with eight-bar A and B sections that play and repeat.
"Lonesome Blues" is played in C, and has a simple chord progression that is the
same in both the A and B parts:
or on Leake

CO-3514)

I

C

I

C

I

C

I

C

I

C

I

G7

I

G7

I

C

I

The rendition of "Lonesome Blues" by the Revelers' fiddler, Will Gilmer, is mas
terful, with a beautiful use of slides into fingered notes that are in unison with
open strings. As you look at the transcription of the melody of "Lonesome Blues"
below, the slide-notes are preceded by an arrow with an "s" above it. Similarly,

any note that has both an upward and

a

which Will Gilmer played the same pitch
the next lower string simultaneously.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

downward stem indicates
as an

open string and

a

an instance in

fingered note on

�Dallas Jones' Back-up

to

"Lonesome Blues"

Dallas Jones' right-hand accompaniment style for "Lonesome Blues" contrasts
bass notes struck by the thumb (probably
wearing a thumbpick) with three-note
chords plucked (NOT strummed) on the first three strings of the
guitar by the in
dex (third string), second (second string), and third
finger (first string). In the tran
scription presented below, the bass notes are indicated by note name. The diagram
immediately below shows where the pitches he struck are located on the low E, A
and D strings of the guitar.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�The three-string treble plucks that Dallas Jones employed are indicated in the transcription by the vertical lines in each
measure. When playing in C, measures 1-5 and 8 of each part of the form, Jones played the top of the C chord, with open
first and third strings and the second string fretted at the first fret. When playing in G7, in measures 6 and 7 of each part
of the form, Jones played the top of a G7 chord, with open second and third strings and the first fret of the first string.
Since Jones used the index finger of his left hand to fret the first fret of the second string in C and the first fret of the first
string in G7, the use of the left hand is economy itself. Indeed, you can use the index finger to fret every note that is on
the first fret, right across the neck of the guitar, the second finger to fret notes that fall on the second fret (B and E, in the
bass) and the third or ring finger to fret notes that fall on the third fret (G or C, in the bass). Easy!
As you look at the transcription, the number to the far left of a line indicates the time through the form that is being
played, the letter the part of the tune (A or B), followed by the number of the time through that part of the form. Note
that the Revelers played the A part of "Lonesome Blues" three times instead of the more normal two times the first and
fourth times through the tune. Similarly, on their fifth pass through the form they played only one B part, perhaps be
cause they were running out of time.

To get some sense of how the notes and pluck signs work into the count, I'll give a couple of examples. If you look at the
first measure in line 1 Al, the count is 1
2
with C struck on 1, E struck on 2, and treble plucks on the +s of beats 1 and 2.
In the second measure of line 1A1, the count is once again 1
2
but in this instance, C is struck on 1, G is struck on the

treble plucks fall on the
of 2, simultaneous with the G in the bass. Note that this technique of
of 1, 2, and the
chord
in
the
treble
while
plucking
simultaneously striking a string in the bass cannot be duplicated with a flat pick alone,
can
achieve
the
effect
though you
by using the pick to strike the note in the bass and the remaining fingers in the right hand
to pluck the treble strings.
of 2, and the
a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�At no point in the course of this ren
dition does Jones do one of his treble
plucks, other than on a beat or on the
of a beat. He does get some synco
pation in his bass notes, though. If you
look at the last measure in line 1A2, the
count could be expressed as 1
2
a,
with the eighth note C struck on the "a"
of the

second beat

of the

the measure.

And

at the

if

doing this smoothly

drag the
thumb from the C note on the fifth string
to the E note on the fourth
string, in one
motion.
If you try to strike
the two

occur in the first measure of line 3A1, in
the transition from the second measure
of line 3A2 to the third measure, in the
transition from the first to second mea
sure in line 4B2, in the transition from

second measure in line 5A1,
the second measure of line 5A2.

the first to

you work through the transcription
several times, so that you are able to do
it with an unimpeded
rhythmic flow,
you will be doing fine.
The point of looking at a player's work
to such a degree of detail is not to memo
rize what was done, but to get an idea of
the player's musical language and how
much of that language it seemed ap
If

propriate
in

to the

terms

player

of variety,
ent elements in the

to

bring to bear

introducing differ

course of the rendi

tion while keeping other parts the same
As we look at what Dal
throughout.
las Jones played on "Lonesome Blues",
we can see that he did not vary what he
played over the G 7 chord from the begin
ning to the end of the rendition-- in that
respect, his choices there can be viewed
as definitive.
He tended to resort to a

straighter

"boom-chang"

approach

for

parts than he did for the A parts.
There is no way of knowing for sure why
the

B

he did this, but

it

constantly in the here-and-now as you
make your way through the repetitions
of the tune.
It

should be mentioned, too, that Dal
thumb and fingers approach
playing old-time back-up can work

las Jones'
to

faster tempos too, if you substitute a
dow nward strum or brush for the treble
pluck he used for "Lonesome Blues". I
wish you joy in working some of Dallas
Jones' approach into your own old-time
at

guitar playing.

is to

notes with two separate motions, you
will either break time or give the phrase
a
bumpy emphasis quite different from
that of Jones' playing. Other thumb rolls

and in

harmony, things stay fresh, and you are

end of

you look at the first
measure m line 1 A3, you can see that his
bass continues from the C note that con
cluded line 1A2 on up into the E note
that begins line 1A3. What Jones was
doing here is a thumb roll, much the
same as was commonly utilized by the
blues guitarist Blind Blake, and the se
cret to

is holding a C chord.
His ap
if variety
proach offers a good lesson:
in attack and notes in the bass is
great
est where there is the least variety in the

harmony

may have been because

the fiddle goes low for the B part, and he
could have felt that too much activity in
the bass of the guitar under that would
be

The greatest degree of
distracting.
variation in his guitar part occurs in the
first five bars of the A parts, where the

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

John Miller has been listening to, playing,
teaching, and recording old-time, country
and

blues,
close

many

other

of music for

styles

forty years. He resides in Bellingham,
Washington, with his wife, Ginny Snowe. He
to

can be reached at

john@johnmillerguitar.com.

Walt Koken and Clare Milliner are the authors
of the forthcoming Milliner-Koken Collection
of Traditional American Fiddle Tunes. In

formation
be

on the book and their

recordings can

found www.mudthumper.com.

�Steve Kaufman's

Acoustic

Kamos

June 14-21: Flatpicking, Fingerpicking, Fiddle, Bass, Dobro,
Old Time Banjo and 7VewMountain Lap Dulcimer
June 21-28: Flatpicking, Bluegrass Banjo, Mandolin and

AfewSongwriting/Vocals
June 14-21: Flatpicking
Roily Brown, Mark Cosgrove, Dan Crary, Cindy Gray, Steve Kaufman, Jeff Jenkins,
Mike Maddux. Fingerpicking: Chris Proctor, Steve Baughman; Bass: Rusty
Holloway;
Fiddle:Bobby Hicks, Stacy Phillips, Casey Henry; Dobro (tm): Johnny Bellar, Fred Sokolow;
Lap Dulcimer: Mike Clemmer; Old Time Banjo: Evie Laden, Laura Boosinger
June 21-28: Flatpicking: John Carlini, Beppe Gambetta, Cindy Gray, Mike Kaufman, Robin
Kessinger, Uwe
Scott
Eric
Krtiger, Tony McManus,
Nygaard,
Thompson; Mandolin: Robin Bullock, David Harvey, John Moore,
Andy Owens, John Reischman, Don Stiernberg, Tim Worman; Bluegrass Banjo: Bill Evans, Casey Henry,
Bill Keith, Jens Krtiger, Gary Davis; Songwriting/Voice Class:
Kathy Chiavola; Jam Instructor: Keith Yoder;
Kamp Doctors: Ken and Virginia Miller, Bryan Kimsey, Jim Grainger

Call 800-FLATPIK

865-982-3808

to

Register

Musical Event Like None Other
Held each June in Maryville, 77V

A

Your

Specially designed for Ultra-Beginners through Professional
Locdted On The Campus of Maryville College in Maryville, TN Just 1 7 mi. So. of Knoxville,
Call or Write for your Kamp Brochure or go to www.acoustic-kamp.com

$775.00 Paid Registration Entitles
Rotating

2

You To:

Hour Classes with ALL of the Main Teachers

Gold Award Winning

All Meals and Lodging (Companion Packages available)
Structured Slow and Afternoon Medium Group Jam Periods

More Classes
More Education
More Fun More Friends

Structured Stylistic Jams: Swing, Old Time, BG, Vocal, Gospel
Master Classes and Afternoon Specialized Sessions

Ensemble Work, Open Mike Time, Afternoon and Nightly Jams
Admission to All The Nightly Concerts
Scholarships Available at http://duscholar.home.mchsi.com/
We'd like

to thank

77V.

Scholarships Available

JoiMJune!

I

Weber Mandolins, Codings Guitars, Ken Miller Guitars and Deering Banjos

tor donating instruments tor our big Door Prize Give Away!

More

to be

added!

Limited Spaces -Registrations and Kamp Info: www.flatpik.com
Register On-Line
Register Today
Steve Kaufman's Acoustic Kamp
PO Box 1020, Alcoa, TN 37701
Gold Award
Every Year
since 2002

'800

865-982-3808 (Operator's and Tape Machines are Standing
FLATPIK
steve@flatpik.com
www.flatpik.com

Interested

in

being

corporate sponsor?
Write steve@flatpik.com

By 24 hours)

a

The 2009 Kamp Series is Sponsored in part by
Acoustic Guitar Magazine, Codings Guitars,
DR Strings, Elm Hill Meats, Fishman Transducers, Flatpicking Guitar
Magazine, Gold Tone,

Thl^fThis

0pporturjity!

Comp-U-Chem, Deering Banjos,

Heritage Instrument Insurance,
Homespun Tapes, Huss and Dalton Guitars, Janet Davis Music, Mandolin Magazine, Martin Guitars, Mass Street Music, Naugler Guitars,
The Picking, Pick 'N Grin, Shubb Capos, Taylor Guitars, Waverly Tuning Machines, Weber Mandolins and
Wood-N-Strings
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Classifieds

Musical Instruments

Recordings, Books, Instruction

INSTRUMENTS FOR SALE: GUITARS:
1994 Martin OM-28, $1,600; 1960 Kay K-l
cutaway Arch top, $650; 1980 Guild D-35,
$850; 1998 Martin 000-17 Custom, $1,900.
1930's BANJOS: 1925 Vega Whyte Laydie
#7, $7,500; 1890 S.S. Stewart American
Princess, $1,250; 1988 Goose Acres, fancy
engraved inlay and Electric style rim,
$3,000; 2000 Bart Reiter Grand Concert
Several great fretless banjos from $850 to
$1,200; New Enoch Tradesman. Fretted,
$895. MANDOLINS; Breedlove OO &amp; OF
from $975; 1924 Gibson A-2Z, Snakehead
$5,000; 2 recent Michael Kelly F style,
$450 each; and more! Get the details at
Smakula Fretted Instruments' website:

www.smakula.com

or call

304-636-6710.

tersection

of

blues,

country

old-time,

and Cajun songs. Also available:
Eric's
Real"
instru"Thompson's
(bluegrass

mentals

David

Grisman,

Jody

Stecher,

fiddle rags /blues
songs CDs, "No Mockingbird" and "Stop
Tony Rice, etc.); Suzy's
&amp;

2

Listen"; Todalo Shakers "4th St. Mes-

saround" (Eric &amp; Suzy, WB Reid, Frannie
Leopold). $15 each, add $2 s/h per order.
Eric &amp; Suzy Thompson, 2935 Piedmont
510-848-5018.
Ave, Berkeley CA 94705.

www.ericandsuzy.com

DUSTY STRINGS ACOUSTIC MUSIC
SHOP in Seattle stocks fine new and

used

instruments: guitars by Martin,
Collings, Taylor, Huss &amp; Dalton, Goodall, Dell'Arte, Eastman, and Gitane; ban
jos by Deering, Huss &amp; Dalton, Ramsey,
Lee, Vega, and Goldtone; mandolins by
Collings, Weber, Eastman, and Mid-Mis
souri. Call toll-free 866-634-1662 or email:

musicshop@dustystrings.com.
Equipment
ODD SIZE REMO RENAISSANCE
&amp;
FIBERSKYN BANJO HEADS- Most siz
es from 10" to 12 1/8", $19 to $21; Good
quality calfskin banjo heads, $25; Excel
lent quality calfskin banjo heads, $45;
cases for 11" rims $105 plus
Smakula
Fretted Instruments,
shipping.
PO Box 882, Elkins, WV 26241, 304-636TKL banjo

6710,

&amp; SUZY THOMPSON'S new CD,
"Dream Shadows" is their first duo re
lease in 18 years! Suzy &amp; Eric continue
their long-standing love affair with South
ern music of the 1920s and 30s, at the in

ERIC

www.smakula.com.

WWW.FIELDRECORDER.COM, Tradi
tional Music CD and DVDS ranging from
Appalachia through the Midwest to Tex
as; fiddle, banjo, Cajun, gospel, ballads,
photos, histories, MP3s and MORE!

FLATFOOTING WORKSHOP IN
STRUCTIONAL video by Ira Bernstein.
1-3/4 hours, 27 steps, beginning to ad

vanced. Easy to follow. Each step clearly
broken down and taught. Also includes 3
performed pieces. Step manual and two
different concert performances also avail
able. 179 Flint St.,

Asheville, NC. 828-255-

9393; IraTenToes@aol.com.

BLUEGRASS MUSIC PROFILES magazine
features personal interviews with bluegrass
music artists. $15 yr for six issues. BMP, P.O.

Nicholasville, KY, 40340. www.
bluegrassmusicprofiles.com; 859-333-6465.
Box 850,

CLOG PALACE MEMORIES: Were
you there? Have a story to tell, or a me

Grants

mento

TROUBADOUR

AID

FOUNDATION,
INC., a California not-for-profit corpora
tion, is accepting applications from qual
ified performers of Traditional Ameri
cana Roots Music to augment the fees
they

receive through

limited

grants

to

qualifying institutions. Performers must
meet certain criteria, including an annual

to share?
Visit www.clogpalace.
com or write Julie Mangin, 1611 Dennis
Avenue, Silver Spring Maryland 20902.
"IT

TAKES

BANJO"

on-line

A VILLAGE

TO

TUNE

A

Bumper stickers. $3.00. Order

at:

www.whiskeypuppy.com

WWW.LADYMULESKINNERPRESS.
Fea

gross receipts ceiling of less than $60,000
and travel of at least 20,000 miles annu
ally in the United States by motor home

turing: singing governors; fiddling sena
tors; buttons; the brother duet as spiritual

or

metaphor;

similar conveyance.

For

further de

tails, contact: Administrator, Troubadour
Aid Foundation, Inc., P.O. Box 9109, San
Rafael, CA 94912-9109.
The

Old-Time Herald accepts classified

COM: writings by Burgin Mathews.

the prison-album tradition;
chain-saw fiddles; Dolly Parton; a pray

ing dog; Hank Williams' epitaph; boiled
peanuts; more.

ads at the cost of 50$ per word,

For more info e-mail advertising@oldtimeherald.org

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

or call

minimum $8.00.

(919)419-1800.

�Reviews
Ernest

V.

Stoneman:

The Unsung Father
of Country Music,

1925-1934

nest V. Stoneman Trio; The Lightning Ex
press: Ernest V. Stoneman; Old Time Corn
Shuckin' Part 1, Old Time Corn Shuckin'
Part 2: Ernest V. Stoneman and The Blue

instruments

Ridge Corn Shuckers; Are You Washed in
the Blood: Ernest V. Stoneman and His Di

the

xie Mountaineers; When the Snowflakes
Fall Again: Frank Jenkins' Pilot Mountain
eers;

The Wreck on the

Ernest

C &amp; O:

V.

Stoneman; Once I Had a Fortune: Ernest V.
Stoneman and The Dixie Mountaineers; The
Road to Washington: Mr. and Mrs. Ernest
V.
Stoneman; He is Coming After Me:
Ernest V. Stoneman and His Dixie Moun

taineers; Say, Darling, Say: Justin Winfield;
Nine Pound Hammer: Ernest and Eddie

5-String Productions 5SPH001

Dear Old Step Stone:
Mr. and Mrs. Ernest Stoneman John Hardy:
DISC

1:

Goodbye,

Justin Winfield The Resurrection: Ernest
Stoneman and His Dixie Mountaineers; West

Virginia Highway: Ernest V. StonemanKahle Brewer; The Titanic: Ernest V. Stone
man; The Spanish Merchant's Daughter:
Stoneman Family; The Burial of Wild Bill:
Frank Jenkins' Pilot Mountaineers; Sweep
ing Through the Gates: Ernest V. Stoneman
and His

Dixie Mountaineers; Long Eared
V. Stoneman
and His Grayson
County Boys; The Religious Critic: Ernest
V. Stoneman;
Possum Trot School Exhibi
tion Part 1; Possum Trot School Exhibi

Mule: Ernest

tion Part

2:

Ernest Stoneman

and The Blue

Ridge Corn Sluickers; I Am Resolved: Ernest
Stoneman and His Dixie Mountaineers; A

Message from Home Sweet Home: Frank
Jenkins' Pilot Mountaineers; The Wreck of
the '97: Ernest V. Stoneman Trio; Mountain
eer's Courtship: E. Stoneman-Miss I. FrostE.
V.

Dunford; No More Good-Byes: Ernest
Stoneman and His Dixie Mountaineers;

The Ragin Sea, How it Roars: Ernest V.
Stoneman and The Blue Ridge Corn Shuckers; The Face That Never Returned: Ernest
V. Stoneman; Ramblin'
Reckless Hobo: The
Sweet Brothers; Hop Light Ladies: Ernest V.

Stoneman and the Dixie Mountaineers; All
I've Got's Gone: Ernest V Stoneman and
His Dixie Mountaineers
DISC 2: Goodbye, Dear Old Stepstone:
Ernest V. Stoneman and His Dixie Moun
taineers; The Railroad Flagman's Sweet
Pilot Mountaineers;

heart: Frank Jenkins'

There's

Light Lit Up in Galilee: Ernest
V.
Stoneman and His Dixie Mountaineers
Sourwood Mountain: Ernest V. Stoneman
and His Dixie Mountaineers
The Orphan
Girl: Ernest V. Stoneman Too Late: The
Stoneman Family The Fate of Talmadge
a

Osborne: Ernest V. Stoneman; I Know My
Name is There: Ernest V. Stoneman and His
Dixie Mountaineers; Flop Eared Mule: Er

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Stoneman; All

Got's Gone:

I

Ernest

and

Eddie Stoneman

Ernest V. Stoneman and his family need
little introduction to old-time musicians
fond of a sentimental country song, a

lively dance tune, or an entertaining skit.
As the subtitle of this collection notes,
however, Ernest Stoneman (1893-1968),
the patriarch of the Stoneman family was
unsung by the larger world of Ameri
can popular culture. Though his and
his family's music had come briefly to
the attention of the public through Those
Stonemans, a television show aired briefly
in the late

1960s,

E.

V.,

as the

jovial be

ret-wearing "Pop,"- was getting on up in
years, the spotlight was directed toward
his talented, attractive, and energetic
children. Most histories of country mu
sic that celebrate the origin of commer
cial country music in the legendary July
1927 Bristol

Sessions fail

to

mention him,

in on the Carter

usually zeroing

Family

and Jimmie Rodgers. This release will go
a
long way towards making up for that

neglect, since its focus is squarely on the
extraordinary E. V. Stoneman. It is all the
more special that it came out just as Er
nest was finally inducted into the Coun
try Music Hall of Fame. As his daughter
Patsy Stoneman writes in the booklet's
introduction, "His induction was a long
time in coming.

was beginning
to wonder if I would live long enough
to see it happen. But it happed, a short
In

fact,

I

while before my 83rd birthday."
Though he may have been "unsung"
by the music-listening public, E. V. and
the music of his extended family and
neighbors have been dearly beloved for
decades by old-time music enthusiasts
and record collectors. A stunning pho
tograph
and

1910

taken
by

Dunford, later

sometime between 1905
photographer Alec "Eck"
to

become one of Stone-

man's musical sidekicks, served us as the
image of mountain musicians. A neatly
dressed family holds mail order string

in front of a rough-hewn
log house and stone chimney. Seated in

foreground are a trio of women with
fashionable long dresses and Victorian

pompadours. Front and center, Myrtle
Stoneman holds a parlor guitar. She is

flanked by Sophiimia and Betty Leonard
who hold their autoharps flat across their
laps in the old-fashioned manner. Stand
ing behind them Burton Stoneman and J.
William Frost appear actually to be play
ing their instruments: Stoneman cradles
his fiddle vertically and Frost curls his
right hand over the banjo strings in twofinger picking position. We are familiar
with this picture because Mike Seeger
borrowed a copy of it from Hattie (Frost)
Stoneman for the cover of the 1960s edi
tion of the New Lost City Ramblers Song
Book. And thus it was that small-town,
suburban, and city kids just getting se
rious about the music saw this portrait

dignity and resourcefulness of ru
mountain people. When we saw the
Stoneman name on a record, we bought
of the

ral

listened, and tried to learn.
That beautiful photograph plus a trea
sure trove of equally evocative pictures
and rare memorabilia appear in the Hank
it,

Sapoznik's notes to this truly blockbuster
new two-disc set. Over the years there
have been reissues that included E. V.
Stoneman's music, most notably around

1980 when County Records issued Round
the Heart of Old Galax, a three-LP set that
featured the music of Galax and Car
roll

County. However,

E.

V.

Stoneman

and the bands he put together of family,
friends, and neighbors are the sole sub
ject of this project. Thus, for many of us
this is the collection of classic-era Stone

man recordings we've all been waiting
for. That it should be on the relatively
new small label, 5-String Productions,
which until recently has concentrated on

recording living musicians, is a delight
ful plus. This project was the brainchild
of Hank Sapoznik and Chris King, and
was made possible by its being released
by Tim Brown /5-String Productions. The
music comes from 78 rpm recordings in
the collections of Chris King, David Free
man, Rich Nevins, and Gregg Kimball.
E.

V.

Stoneman's daughter Patsy Stone

Chris King, Ken Landreth, Dave
Freeman, Rich Nevins, Jeremy Stephens,
and Eddie Bond provided the images,
many of which had never before been
man,

published. Many experts, including

�Ken Landreth, Joe Wilson, John Cohen,
and Marshall Wyatt gave

Mike Seeger,

advice. Hank Sapoznik's notes deserve
special mention. Sapoznik, who gave us
the wonderful Charlie Poole collection a
few years back

You Ain't Talking to Me:
Charlie Poole and the Roots of Country Mu
sic) has put together an essay that is en

tertaining, informative, and puts Stoneman and his music in context, providing
vivid picture of the world in which he
and his family lived.
Ernest Van Stoneman (1893-1968) was
a

born

in Carroll County, Virginia near
what would later become Galax. From

childhood,

he sang and played guitar,
autoharp, banjo, and harmonica, his
music sustaining him through times as
tough as a Dickens novel.
Orphaned
at age three, he was
brought up by his
father and cousins, all of whom loved
music. The music sustained them all
through terrible times. When he married
Hattie Frost, who also grew up in a mu
sical family, the clan was extended. The
couple had 14 children, most of whom
became professional musicians. Though
Stoneman had worked in regional mines
and textile mills, his primary occupation
was carpentry. He managed to establish

professional career just on the eve of
Depression. The story is that when
he heard a recording by fellow Virgin
ian Henry Whitter, he was convinced he
a

the

could do better job of singing. He made

his first recordings in 1924, and among
them was "The Titanic," which turned

out to be one of the biggest hits of the de
cade. Following this were many sessions
in

a

variety of groups made up of family

and friends, some of

whom happened

to

be

extraordinary singers and players.
Those who haven't had the pleasure of
hearing Stoneman's music will be treated

here to

output

a

fine representation of his total
ranging from solo performanc

small and large string bands and
gospel singing groups Stoneman assem
bled from among his talented neighbors
and family.
Stoneman's voice, guitar,
harmonica, and autoharp were central
to the sound of each band with which
es to

he

played.

In the

beginning,

as on "The

Titanic," the recording that launched his
career in 1925, he sang and accompanied

himself on autoharp and harmonica. His
voice has an unaffected directness rarely

heard today, his voice soaring easily to
high notes. Adding to the overall charm

occasional unusual placements of
syllables over the melody: "hus-baaands
are his

and wives, little children lost their lives."

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

The autoharp was Stoneman's first and
last instrument, his accompaniment on

"Titanic,"

and, in later life,

his

instru

mental choice for the 1960s television
shows. With the addition of harmonica,
held in a special rack of his own inven
tion that rested on his chest, Stoneman
became a one-man band. Though known
for championing the autoharp, Stoneman
actually played guitar for the majority of
recordings, and he had an impres
sive instrument, a big Galiano that lent
a rich bottom end to the bands in which
he played, punctuating the music with
clever descending bass runs. Though
perhaps taken to an extreme in "The
his

Old Hickory Cane," the runs and over

all bass-treble alternation worked well
with string bands, and inspired genera
tions of guitarists. With the addition of
his wife Hattie Frost Stoneman's fiddle
and vocals and her brother Bolen Frost's
banjo, as on "The Spanish Merchant's

Daughter," Stoneman had his basic full
sound. Hattie's sweetly piping
voice, like his, had a fresh innocence. The
high frequency tones she hits in "There's
a Light Lit
Up in Galilee" and "Swinging

band

Through

the

counterpoint

Gate"
to

make

the lower

an

engaging

male voices.

Hattie's fiddling was usually
drowned out by her husband's harmon-

Though

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

ica, we get a chance to hear it when his
lips leave the harmonica to sing the vers

Washington," a version of
Charlie Poole's "Whitehouse Blues." Her
es on "Road to

though cut from plainer cloth
than that of fellow Virginians Posey Rorer and Kahle Brewer and North Carolin
ian Frank Jenkins, is clearly in the same
stately rolling style. When it came to fid
fiddling,

dling, Stoneman played with some of the

best to draw a bow
particularly Kahle
Brewer and Frank Jenkins.
To sum up, this is essential listening,
among the finest reissues I've heard in
a long time. It has it all: excellent tune
selections, clean but not overly cleaned

sound, a well-written and beautifully
illustrated booklet, encased in an attrac
tive recycled cardboard cover that also
serves as the case for the two CDs. If you
are not familiar with the music and many
bands of Ernest Stoneman, get this im
mediately.

If

you are already

a

fan, drop

everything and order this set ASAP.
GAIL GILLESPIE
To order:

www.5-string.com

�field recordings, and all of them excellent.
They are arranged in six categories that
Work recognized: social songs, the quar

singing, blues, and
Harp. Readers of the
Old-Time Herald whose interest centers on
string band music will want to have this
disc for the two banjo-fiddle duets by Na
than Frazier and Frank Patterson, "Poor
tets,

congregational

Colored

The

Sacred

Black Sheep" and "Texas Traveler." These
two musicians can be heard as well on the
landmark Altamont issue on Rounder, a
collection of Stu Jamieson's 1940s record
ings of black string bands in Tennessee.
These wonderful performances
(with

verses sung along with the picking and
fiddling) leave no doubt about the deri
vation of the signature white mountain

fiddle-clawhammer banjo
black frolic music-making.

pairing from

have recently seen some commentary
deprecating the influence of formal, clas
sical music on black sacred music at edu
cational institutions like Fisk University,
I

proposing that polished "concert" spiri
tuals compromised and sentimentalized
the spirituals in part to please white au
diences. In fact the highly arranged and

harmonized

performance styles that
in part developed in African American
institutions were embraced
learning
and developed in the black churches,
and flourished in the twentieth-century

quartet styles.

exquisitely

A

tightly

harmonized

executed and
performance

like "Daniel Saw the Stone" does offer

a

contrast with the rougher and powerful
rural call-and-response style in "Egypt
Land," though both are superb examples
of the variety and artistry in African
American sacred music. Yet another style
heard on the energetic "Great
tend," which Work recorded in
Alabama, in 1938; a group was
from The Colored Sacred Harp,
is

can

American book

in the

God At

singing
Afri

fa-sol-la nota

tion best known in Original Sacred Harp,

compiled by white singing teacher

B.

F.

White. Work was clearly astonished at the
of the people, with no formal
music training, "native to that rural sec
tion! Not one of these was a professional
musician... and the book was compiled
with no outside stimulation or sponsor
a cul
ship and with no hope of profit
tural creation. This certainly was folklore

musicality

in its

highest expression."

There is just one work song on this disc,
"My Captain's Angry," sung by A1 Wash
ington. It is a masterful solo performance
of a song that Washington surely had
learned in a work gang, and it carries a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

dignity and protest that run

through this genre. Also represented here
by a single track is the blues. Nemerov

relates that Work happened on Joe Hol
mes, a blues singer on a Macon, Georgia,
train platform when he was on his way
to judge and record the now-legendary

blues festival in nearby Fort Valley. Nem
erov appreciates that Work used one of
his precious discs to record Holmes' fine

singing and guitar work. Good as it is,
Holmes's blues is clearly derived from
styles heard on countless 78 rpm records
from

the

'20s

and

'30s

by

artists

like

Scrapper Blackwell and Big Bill Broonzy;
and it is good that Work documented
the middle Georgia blues less frequently
heard on commercial discs.
Work collaborated with Alan Lomax
in fieldwork in the Mississippi Delta in
1941 and 1942. This work led to the first
recordings of plantation worker McKinley Morganfield, even then known by
his nickname, Muddy Waters
of course
later to become an urban blues great. A
short interview by Work of Waters and
musical partner Son Sims is short

his

revealing of the musicians' creative
process. There has been some contro
versy and discussion about whether the
famous Lomax gave sufficient credit to
the contributions of his African Ameri
but

colleague, but this is not the place to
embroiled in that. Suffice it to repeat
Nemerov's characterization: "John Wes
ley Work, III, was a modest man. Without
that modesty, he might be better known
can

be

today." Fortunately, this beautifully pro
duced and annotated release does much
to make better known and appreciated

scholarship, and the music
documented.

the man, his
he

ART ROSENBAUM

Dothan,
an

of

message

To order:

www.springfedrecords.com

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

anyone and everyone with an inter
est in Missouri fiddling. The book and
CDs are not quite the be-all and end-all
of Missouri fiddling, but this collection
does go a long way in presenting a de
tailed picture of traditional fiddle music
for

in the

Show-Me state.

In his

preface

to

the revised

addition,

Marshall discusses how the original proj
ect came about and how it was nominat
ed for a Grammy award. He touches on
the roles that various individuals played
in producing it, and some of the techni
cal difficulties that he and the Williams

encountered

in trying to reproduce this
new edition. Also interesting is Mar
shall's description of the changes in the
fiddle community in Missouri since the
initial release of Now That's a Good Tune.
Fiddling remains a vital means of cul

tural expression in the state, despite the

dramatically reduced number
contests

fiddling

once
in

the

Missouri

of fiddle
outlet
for
primary

and the

disappear

ance of many community dances. As he

notes, new technology has made avail
able new means of learning to play, swap
ping tunes, etc. There continues to be an
active interest in fiddling among scholars
in the state, and folk festivals, fiddlers'
gatherings, and small community events
to provide venues for old-time
fiddling throughout the state.
The book contains an extensive and

continue

detailed essay by Marshall in which he
discusses regional stylistic characteristics
and variances as applied to fiddling in
Missouri. This material provides much

insightful information, and may be very
useful in dispelling some misconceptions
of fiddling in Missouri, such as the notion

a
singular Missouri style. In
essay Marshall describes three dis
tinct regional styles represented in the
state
Ozark style, Little Dixie style, and
northern Missouri style. (Others have ar
gued that these can be broken down even
further, but that's a subject for another

that there is

his

To

somewhat, Ozark
hard-driving hoe-

Upper South who brought their
culture and agricultural practices with
them. Little Dixie fiddling also tends
towards driving dance music, but the
tunes tend to be somewhat more intri
cate in melodic structure. Tunes in flat
of the

keys such

as B-flat, F, and E-flat are far
more common in the region, too. (There

are exceptions, of course.) Because of its
historical ties to the South, Little Dixie
was also the home to several renowned
African American fiddlers, among them,

Driver, Walt Dougherty, and Bill
Katon. These gentlemen have left their
mark on the repertoire of Little Dixie fid
dlers. The third style discussed by Mar
shall is North Missouri style. He notes
that this style is more complex and the
Bill

tunes are often played

at

a

much slower

pace than in other areas of the state. The
area's original settlers tended to come
from the Northeast and eastern Midwest,
and this may have had an impact on the

playing styles and repertoire found

in

this part of the state. Marshall carefully
notes that these are very broad catego
ries at best and a lot more listening and

study needs

to be

done before any final

pronouncements are made. In the essay,
he also discusses the various contexts in
which fiddling continues to thrive in the
state, i.e. dances, contests, religious ser
vices, etc., and includes some discussion
of

repertoire and accompaniment.

The book includes updated biographies
of all the musicians (unfortunately, over

half of them have died since 1988), tune
annotations, with a few transcriptions,
and

a

detailed bibliography and discogra-

phy. The latter are both sadly out of date.
However, a major plus is the numerous

photographs, some recent and others per
haps 100 years old, of musicians scattered

throughout the book. They are worth the
price of the set all by themselves.

revelatory in some
ways. They present mostly older fiddlers
The recordings

are

from all across the state playing in
eral different

styles.

For

sev

some of these

generalize
fiddling emphasizes
downs intended for the vigorous square
and jig dancing indigenous to the region,
which comprises much of the state situ
ated south of the Missouri River, exclud
ing the Bootheel in the extreme southeast

represented on recordings, though most
were of the privately recorded and sold
variety. Almost as interesting as who ap

corner. Much of the Ozarks was original
settled by people from the mountain

not included here. However,

day.)

ly

regions of Tennessee, North Carolina,
Kentucky, etc., which one could argue
is reflected in the music. The Little Dixie
region was settled by Anglo-Americans
from the lowland and Piedmont regions

folks, this may have been the first time
they had appeared on a recording of any
kind. Some, on the other hand, were well

peared on these records was who was
a

complete

ly accurate and representative sampling
would have taken several albums such
as this one, and at any rate, the issue has
become less critical as a series of CD re
leases by fiddlers from all over the state

�have become available in the intervening
years thanks to Rounder Records, Voy
ager Records, County Records, and the
Missouri State Old-Time Fiddlers Asso
ciation, among others.
This brings us to the music itself.
The first CD displays the talents of six
very different sounding fiddlers-Carol
Haschall, Vesta Johnson, Gene Goforth,
Dean Johnston, R.P. Christeson, and Nile
Wilson-each playing four tunes, every
one a keeper. The second CD follows a
similar pattern and features Cyril Stin
nett, Lyman

Walsh,

Enloe, Pete McMahan, Bob

Howe Teague,

Bill

Eddy,

and

Charlie Walden. Again the selections are
very diverse and include some pieces not
often heard outside of a very small area
(i.e. Enloe's "Call Your Dogs and Let's
Hunting," Teague's "White River,"
and all of Nile Wilson's tunes). I found
Gene Goforth' s selections, along with

Go

Cyril Stinnett's,
and found

to

be

quite

interesting

them often.
However, I was particularly taken with
the playing of the two women fiddlers
here. Both have very distinctive styles,
play nice tunes, and demonstrate their
abilities as good dance fiddlers here. As
their biographies reveal, both also had

myself listening

some illuminating

stories

to

to

tell

about

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

growing up playing fiddle in an era
when prevailing attitudes about women
fiddlers was not positive, to say the least.
This collection of recordings stands up
well twenty years after its initial release,
and, along with the book, makes an im

portant contribution, once again, to the
rich and diverse heritage of American
fiddle music. It also makes for some fine
listening. Hats off to Howard Marshall
and Voyager Records.
JIM

To order:

www.voyagerrecords.com

NELSON

�Byrd Moore and his Hot Shots. Finally, I
recommend "Saddled Up My Old Gray

Mare," which is not the one who ain't
like she used to be, but the one who

converted

to Christianity. Previously I
was only familiar with the Library of
Congress 1939 recording of this song by
Austin and Esther Harmon of Maryville,
Tennessee. McMillon's is more complete,
and a lot easier to listen to.
Less successful is "Cabbage Head
Song" ("Our Goodman" or "Drunkard's
Special"). McMillon's use of a drunken
slur for the husband's part strikes me as
unnecessary, and his falsetto is a little flat
when he sings the wife's part.
Much of this CD is a reissue of the
1994 Ivy Creek cassette A Deeper Feeling.

Songs that were not on that recording are
marked with an asterisk.
LYLE LOFGREN
To order:

www.ivycreek.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

The recordings on this CD come from
two very distinct periods in the band's
history. Tracks 1-18 were recorded by
Ray Alden on one of his cross-country
trips back in 1984, and represent the only

available recordings of this particular in
carnation of the band. Although the pho
tograph on the CD sleeve shows him on
the mandolin, Chirps had left the group
several years earlier and Gaye Harrison

was ably handling the mandolin chores.
The group at this point was as harddriving a square dance band as one could
find anywhere, then or now. The tunes on
this CD, despite some

familiar-sounding

titles, are all relatively obscure, played by
fiddlers most of whom were born before
1900, and not heard outside of a small re
gion in either central or southern Illinois.
Garry and others in the band collected
these tunes during field recording trips in
the 1970s, and learned them and worked
them up into band masterpieces. The liner
notes indicate from whom the tunes were
collected, and where each source fiddler
lived. According to stories told over the
years, some of the fiddlers, such as Pappy

Taylor of Effingham and Noah Beavers of
Elkville, provided the band with many
tunes and a lot of inspiration. Whatever
the case, between their fieldwork and per
formances the Indian Creek Delta Boys
an

developed

enormous and important

repertoire representing an otherwise un
documented aspect of American fiddle
music. These recordings are studio quali
ty and among the best, in my opinion, that
the group has ever produced. In addition,
the source recordings of many of these
pieces and more (in musical notation as
well) may be found in Garry Harrison's

monumental book Dear

Old Illinois.

The remaining tracks here were record
ed in 1994 and give us an idea of what the

final incarnation

sounded

of the

"Crick

Delters"

Several of the tracks-"I
Won't Get Drunk No More," "Jack of Dia
monds," "Ida Red," and "Trailin' a Blind
Drunk Cripple"-appear on the limitededition cassette tape released in 1994, and
I
suspect the rest were recorded at the ses
sions which resulted in that tape. The band
by this time had been pared down to a trio
consisting of Garry on fiddle, John Bishop
on guitar, and newcomer Dave Danner
like.

on banjo. Even as a trio, these guys were
one of the hottest bands around. The fo
cus seems more on

a

classic 1920s Galax

sound and less on playing
obscure Illinois fiddle tunes, despite the
inclusion of Pappy Taylor's "Devil in the
Haystack." As sources for the songs, the
string band

�band took "Water Bound" ("Way Down
in North Carolina") from a recording by
Fields Ward and the Grayson County
it in the key of E),
and "Ida Red" from the Ernest Stoneman

Railsplitters (and set

version of the song. "I Won't Get Drunk
No More," though taken from a song col
lection in the possession of an older Illi
nois resident, is given the full string band
treatment here. "Jack of Diamonds" was
derived from a Tommy Jarrell recording

and features spot-on three-part singing on
the choruses. Rounding out the collection
a
couple of Garry Harrison originals
which sound right at home alongside the
material he collected from older players

are

over the years, and that's quite an accom

plishment. Highly recommended.

JIM

To order:

NELSON

www.fieldrecorder.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

some fine smaller ensemble work. Most
notable is a group led by Mac Benford
on banjo and vocals, which also includes
Kenny Hall on mandolin, and (perhaps)
Bob Potts on fiddle. These guys nail two
Charlie Poole songs, "Beale Street Blues"
and "The Highwayman," and without
trying
play the songs note for note,
to
manage
get the feel of the North Caro
lina Ramblers down pat. Larry Hanks
to

does

a

nice job on "Railroading

Across

the Great Divide," with fine accompani
ment from Kenny Hall on mandolin and

Jody Stecher on lead guitar. Another out
standing smaller group including Stecher
(and Hank Bradley?) plays a mighty fine

rendition of "Jack of Diamonds" (featur
ing Stecher's singing) and "Sugar in the
Gourd" on just two fiddles. With Sue
Draheim on fiddle, Jody Stecher and Eric

Thompson trade guitar leads on "Say Old
Man" and "Fishing Creek," with Stecher

getting in some almost Jerry Garcia-style

licks on the latter.

Listening to this CD over again, I hear
more subtlety in some of the tunes and
in

the

playing

the music on

throughout.

Although

couple of the tracks here
as
sounds,
Jody Stecher put it, like "a
bunch of disparate voices playing more
or less the same tune at more or less
a

the same time" (nowhere is this more
evident than on "Angeline the Baker"),
when everything actually falls into place,

it's more like John Cohen puts it in his
notes: "dazzling and woozy music, done
by

dazzling and woozy musicians."
JIM

To

order: www.fieldrecorder.com

NELSON

�sensible

distinction

CD is between

Jerry makes

on the

clawhammer and three-

finger banjo Ken Landreth doing excel
lent duty as the three-finger stylist behind
"Pretty Polly Ann" and "Full Moon Reed"
for example, while various notable claw-

hammerers and three-finger players take
turns with many of the other tunes. This
enhances the presentation of each tune,
since each accompanist has his or her own
is

the case with

the Wolfe

Brothers,

includes occasional singing on this
CD, even though vocals and pure-T fiddle
music have tended to part company in the
evolution of American fiddling to the
consternation, no doubt, of Tommy Jarrell's
ghost, even if in some cases a misguided

Jerry

"singer" might well cause said ghost to do
some spinning. At any rate, Jerry has al
ways gotten that singing has a place in oldtime music. Here he even includes some
to the tune "Walk
great lyrics of his own
to
Kansas."
Other vocals ap
John
Along
on
pear, tastefully,
"Pretty Polly Ann" and

"Huckleberry Girls," the latter featuring

Marvin Gaster on the voice and banjo, the
lyrics penned by Dale Morris.
The tune sources reflect the truth of our
world we manage to get around a lot,
and when we sit home, the music comes
to us from near and far away: Brian Duffy
of Salem, New Jersey; Roscoe Parish of
Carroll County, Virginia; Benny and Lew

Thomasson

of Texas; Tony Ellis of Ohio;
from
the fiddling Lundys of
Jerry Lundy
Virginia and Delaware; Dick Hutchison
and Bob Walters, Ozark and Missouri fid
dlers; Mark Schatz of Maryland; Norman
Blake of Rising Fawn, Georgia, to name
is

some of the sources. You can see the scope
of Jerry's knowledge and interests.

playing, Jerry CorrelTs
Ernest
style
Hemingway school,
as contrasted with the school of, say, Wil
liam Faulkner (or Eck Robertson, or Clark
Kessinger). He likes to play the tune at
As

far

as

the

is of the

a
speed at which the individual notes
might possibly be comprehended, and
with precision and clarity. The latter two
attributes are enhanced by his bowing
style, which is in the main a matter of one

note per stroke, with a minimum of
fling and slurring to keep the swing
As an arranger, Jerry then enhances
melody with his choice of sidemen;

shuf

alive.
each
there

duets, fiddle-guitar du
duets, fiddle-fiddle
duets, as well as some solo fiddle pieces
all with just enough rhythm side to keep
the whole experience warm and cozy. An
intermediate fiddler should be able to lis
are

fiddle-banjo

ets, fiddle-mandolin

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

ef

Personally, I like many of these tunes a
My favorites include "Walk Along

lot.

John to Kansas," both for the tune and for
the lyrics and how Jerry fits them to the

tune. I also really like how Jerry uses oc
taves in this tune
the elegance of this fair
ly
is

common way of varying a melody, as it
utilized in this particular case, is just ter

rific.

personality.
As

ten to this CD and, with patience and
fort, learn some tunes.

There's also quite

a

bit of

understat

ed

sophistication in Jerry's arrangement
of the ending. Also a lot of fun: "Frisky
Jim," a classic
in the Shucks"

Missouri-style tune, "Bush

(can't never beat a Benny
tune), and the ender, "Flannery's Dream," another three-finger banjo
collaboration, with a Kentucky source

Thomasson

and Ricky Skaggs' fingerprints. This lat
ter tune, according to Jerry, has picked

story often associated
with French Carpenter. In "Flannery's,"
the tune is "dreamed up" by a prisonerup the apocryphal

fiddler, who wins his freedom.

Needless

to say,

I'm very

happy

to see

that Jerry Correll has put out a fiddle re
cord. He is a fine fiddler, and well deserves
the recognition such

a

project accords him.
BILL HICKS

To

order:

Jerry Correll,

Creek, VA 24326

r

586 Possum

Run, Elk

�HI

Dream
Shadows
Release
Thompson
New

From Eric

&amp;

Suzy

OLD-TIME MUSIC, COUNTRY BLUES,
&amp; CAJUN SONGS
"A

"

superb listening experience
Old- Time Herald

Also available:
Eric's "Thompson's Real"
(bluegrass instrumentals David Grisman,
Jody Stecher, Tony Rice, etc.)

Suzy's

"No Mockingbird"

(fiddle rags

'&amp;

Todalo Shakers "4th
(Eric

&amp;

and "Stop

&amp;

Listen"

blues songs);
St.

Messaround"

Suzy, WB Reid, Frannie Leopold)

S 15 each, add S3 s/h oer order.
Send check to:

Thompson
2935 Piedmont Ave.
Berkeley CA 94705
Eric

Section with Illegible Text

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

H

�recorded

in

Portland, and Stumptown of

that city created the attractive and eco
logically correct package design. Like

lot of pared-down productions with
sensible recycled cardboard one-piece
covers, the notes are necessarily sparse,
a

but there's more information regarding
sources to be had online as well as con
tact

information

if

you have questions.

I

give this release a happy thumbs-up. It's
got a lot going for it: exhilarating listen

ing for both the aficionado or newbie, a
variety of sounds, an interesting mix of
old favorites and less-heard tunes, and

top-notch sibling-tight musicianship.
GAIL GILLESPIE
To order:

www.myspace.com/themacraesisters

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

with acoustic instruments. Yet this is not
just a captured jam. There are tight if sub
tle arrangements and small details.
In
deed, they call the CD a "concept album,"
which surely implies that thought as well
as passion went into the project. Whether
there were any punch-ins or vocal overdubs, I can't tell. That's all that matters.
The "concept" at hand is that all the
music on the CD comes from an assort
ment of sources in Kentucky.
As we

know, Kentucky is one big wellspring of
the old-time, and it's not accidental that
the state inspired an entire sub-genre

of

old-time which flourishes on

its

own

even as we speak I speak of bluegrass,
of course. And indeed, the Red Staters
include a song from the Monroe Broth
ers, Messrs. Bill and Charlie. They know
what they're doing: sources include Snake
Chapman, Burnett and Rutherford, Ed
Haley, Dee Hicks (Tennessee border), J. R
Fraley, Clifford Hayes and the Dixieland
Jug Blowers, Santford Kelly, John Salyer,
Jimmy Wheeler (Ohio border), Doc Rob
erts, and Red Allen
among others.
As you can imagine, with such a range
of

sources,

the

Red Staters

offer quite

the variety of music on this CD. It ain't
just one tune after the next. And when

they come to singing, the band gives us

capable old-time-style vocals which are
perfectly blended into the instrumental
sounds. Although the Cohens pretty near
drove "Man of Constant Sorrow" into the
ground like a peg in search of a second

helping of Peking duck, the band revives
it in the old style, with the mysterious

"gappiness" that seems to be a hallmark
days and a bother to musicians
who recorded the classic in more modern
times. Other pieces which reveal this
open-mindedness about time include the
nifty "Cumberland Blues," and the Red
of earlier

Staters' take on Fraley's "Maysville,"
which John Hartford has also covered in
earlier days. It's very instructive to com
pare the two versions, and I'd guess that
Mr. Fraley has himself recorded a version

somewhere

or

other.

give a particular shout out to
Mr. Pappas, who plays excellent fiddle
throughout the CD, exhibiting many of
the details that a band fiddler must ex
cel at to get the job done right. Pappas
can play the dickens out of a tune, evoke
touches of both the rural and more "up
town" styles that his sources as a group
embody, and also play nicely behind vo
I'd like to

cals.
a

On the whole, the Red Staters exhibit
quality not always in evidence in any

genre: taste. Nobody grandstands, and
they all seem happy to have created this
an old-time band.
very delightful whole
The CD ends with a subtle nod to our

modern

reality,

conceptually

speaking.

Waltz," tastefully played (of
course) by Pappas and the group, comes
from Ali Bain, the great Shetland fiddler.
Ali toured the states many times with the
"Margaret's

Boys of the Loch, and his tunes, or some
of them, stayed beJiind; and J. P. Fraley, a
waltz king if there ever was one, learned
this one.
Shades of Chief O'Neill. And

congrats to the Red State Ramblers for
making a fine album for all of us to enjoy.
BILL HICKS
To

order: www.old97wrecords.com

�Clyde's Lost Girl

The Dying Californian

McCaw's Red River
East

Lightning
Bill Cheatham

Jig

Mustache Wax

God the Spring of All My Joys
Man Can I Have Your Daughter

in the

My

Say Old

many years now, recordings of old
time music have diverged sharply be
tween field recordings and studio re
cordings, separated by what has seemed
like an unavoidable trade-off between
For

the energy

of the

performance and the

sound quality of the record. We all have
our favorites of both
the stack of studio
albums
that
we seem to return
produced

again and again, and then the piles of
warbly cassettes and, more recently, tera
bytes' worth of MP3s' that miraculously
capture a really hot session at a festival
somewhere, but also the footsteps in a
nearby gravel patch, the clink of bottles,
four people having an animated discus
sion not far away, and the swooping
to

growl of someone starting a car. The
studio albums can be clean and beauti
ful in a way that field recordings never
can be, but at the same time, when listen
ing to one, it's sometimes hard to shake
the feeling that something has been lost.
Old-time in the studio isn't the same as
the music you hear at two in the morn
the music that seems to
ing at a festival
be the

of

huge and

im

pulse
something
to articulate, but which compels
so many of us to drive dozens of hours

possible
to

mountaintops and fairgrounds

to tap

into it, for just a few hours, a few days.
And damned if Light and Hitch's selftitled album doesn't catch some of that

indefinable energy.

It

makes sense that

this should be the case: the members

Light and Hitch

of

Mary Jane Epps and

Aaron Olwell on fiddles, A. D. Norcross
on banjo and vocals, Michelle Orozco on
banjo uke, and Joe Dejarnette on bass

found themselves jamming together for
a
year and a half at festival after festival,
and just after Mount Airy in 2007, they
decided to record the sound they were
making. So they drove to Dejarnette's
family house, put up their tarps in the
yard as if they were still at Mount Airy,
set up their microphones, used a car for
a control
room, played for three days,

and picked the stuff that sounded best.
And the best stuff sounds extraordinary.
"Pretty Polly," paired with "Cuckoo,"
outdoes Man Alive's version in hypnotic
creepiness. And "The Road to Malvern"
is an expression of almost pure joy. The
tune itself, written by Jim Childress, has
the bob and weave of an instant standard,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

but it's

propelled by the sound of discov
musicians that they are re

ery among the

ally rocking this thing. They hold a spark
in their hands for almost three and a half

minutes that doesn't go out, a spark that
more rehearsal would have smothered;
we're all lucky that the tape happened
be rolling when they played it.

to

The Flat Iron String Band's debut album
(also self-titled) is a bit more convention
al; the band sounds like a band in that ar
rangements have been worked out and
the harmonies are clearer and surer. But
the album still feels like, and was, a live

performance, warm and full of energy. On
the fiddle tunes, the band
J. P. Harris on
banjo and vocals, Sabra Guzman on gui
tar, uke, and vocals, and Amanda Kowalski on bass
puts a tough strut underneath
fiddler Nick Stillman's sweet and earthy
swerve, and the resulting groove bears
all the marks of four musicians playing
close together,

listening hard. The dark,
gorgeous "Clyde's Lost Girl" is a real
standout, as is the band's muscular take
on "Lightning in the East," which makes
that tune's trademark high squeal in the
second part not sound gimmicky. But the
band really shines when Harris and Guz
man harmonize as well, as they do on an
energetic version of "Stagolee" and the

desperate, dignified ballad "Dying Cali
fornian." Guzman has a classic country
voice, Harris a raspy lower tenor, yet they
come together with liquid ease.
The Light and Hitch and Flat Iron al
bums are most remarkable, however, for
a shared
aesthetic, partly due to the pro
ducer they share Joe Dejarnette (yes,
also the bass player on the Light and
Hitch record)
who is able, miraculous
ly, to bridge the divide between studio
and
the

field

recordings.

On both

records,

musicians treat the tunes right, but

both also have the sound of a good studio
record: You can hear clearly what every
one is doing all the time, and the results

warm, vibrant, and true, like what it
might sound like if you were lying on the
ground at a festival, the musicians in a
circle around you, and everything else
are

too far away to hear.
But the aesthetic is also part of
al sensibility that permeates the

a

gener

younger
generation of old-time musicians, which
happily has multiplied several times over
in recent years. Much of that sensibility
is, in a word, punk. It's do-it-yourself
and emotionally immediate, concerned

much with the energy behind the
tunes as the tunes themselves. Well-worn
standards ("Cider" and "Old Kentucky
as

Whiskey" for Light and Hitch; "Bill
Cheatham" and "Sugar in the Gourd" for

Flat Iron) lie side by side with more ob
scure material, unified and enlivened by
the musicians' enthusiasm. Just as punk

was both

a reaction and return to
previ
ous forms, so these records take pages
from their predecessors: the experimen
talists of the 1980s, the folk revivalists,

and

especially the source material. And
sounded like

just as punk, to some ears,

what used

to be called garage rock, so to
my ears do Light and Hitch and Flat Iron
sound deeply traditional in the best and

most effortless sense: they've listened a
lot to the people who came before them,
and they pay respect with every note, but
the music is their own.
BRIAN SLATTERY
To order:

Light and Hitch, 780 Rabbit Den Rd.,

Hot Springs, NC 28743, 800-357-4019;
Flat Iron String Band,

flatironstringband

www.myspace.com/

�In his

notes to Nighthoots and Morningsongs,

Davidson writes, "This is a sampler of
what we've been playing around here late
Around Brasstown, we play music.
ly
It's a regular part of everyday life. People
play whether anybody is listening to them

Jan

or not."

Brasstown,

tiny community

on

North Carolina, is a
the North Carolina-

Georgia line, deep in the mountains.
the

home of the John

C.

Campbell Folk

mixture of
whose
families
have
lived
in the
people
area for generations, and other folks who
were lured to this corner of the mountains
because of their love of blacksmithing, pot
tery, weaving, or any of the many other arts
taught at tire Folk School. Such an interest
ing and creative crowd is bound to have
School,

and

the locals

It's

are

a

pretty diverse musical tastes, and this CD,
produced by David Brose, contains music
that is "old-time,

classical,

original, jazz,
spiritual, and just plain odd."
That describes it pretty well: tire songs and
tunes range from "Midnight on tire Water"
(done as a pretty bouzouki-guitar duet by
George Kraschaar and David Brose) to
standard,

Hoagy Carmichael's "Old Rocking Chair"
sung by painter Hunt Smith. My favorite

pieces on the disc are "Free Little Bird"
played on banjo and sung by Jan David
son, whose singing has an appealing,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

gen

tle

quality that reminds me of Bascom La

mar Lunsford

and

a

smooth rendition of

"You Are My Sunshine," by J. D. Robinson,
who's the Chief of the Volunteer Fire De

partment in Brasstown. Many of the artists
on this collection are not only neighbors
but family, giving the music a laid-back,

Sunday-afternoon-at-home feeling:
are

these

people who know each other well play

ing shared favorites. It's

a

fun portrait of

a

unique community.
Though the John C. Campbell Folk School
is best known as a center for craft, it also
hosts music events throughout the year
that are well
dances, concerts, classes
worth checking out if you're in the area.
SARAH BRYAN
To order:

www.folkschool.org

�had

I

a

school teacher aunt when

I

was

Raleigh in the '50s, who
used music liberally in her 5th grade
classes, possessed a grand piano in her
living room, and taught piano to chil
dren after school and on weekends,

growing

up in

now and then. She generously made
an effort with me, but piano (unfor

tunately for me) didn't "take." I did
a lot of interest in music, and was

have

in the strings program
Raleigh city schools offered in
those halcyon days of yore, and now
and then Aunt Libby would bring re
cords over to the house to widen my
knowledge. (I was of course already

slogging along
that

to Elvis, Chuck Berry, and
Little Richard
they were just "on the
radio.") One time she brought this LP
featuring Rev. Gary Davis on one side,
and a South Carolina bluesman named
Pink Anderson on the other. Wish I
still had the thing it went where ever
my baseball cards and 45 rpm records
went. If you find them in your travels,
let me know.
I was
struggling to learn some guitar at
the time Aunt Libby laid the Rev on me.
My parents had bought me a blue metalflake Silvertone archtop from Sears for
Christmas. Since the action was akin to
that of a Dobro, and I didn't understand
that the action could be adjusted, and
since the strings were made of barbed wire
(just what they had back then in the Eisen
hower years, kids when we had to walk
to school through the hurricanes and bliz
zards), I had pretty much bested a circle of
chords, learned "Tom Dooley" and "Did
He Ever Return," and gone back outside

listening

Dvds

to

play catch.

Rags and Minstrel Show Songs of

Rev. Gary Davis, Taught by Ernie

Hawkins

DVD

GW982/83

Ernie Hawkins: guitar; ivith audio and archival
clips of Rev. Gary Davis

Buck Dance
Devil's Dream
Sally
Where'd You Get Your Liquor
Twelve
Sticks
Fast Fox Trot
St. Louis Tickle

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

to that Gary

Listening

vis stuff was amazing.

Da

even figured out
a
tiny bit of what he was doing, like pull
ing off a three note run in my favorite song
I

on the disc, "Little More Faith in Jesus."
I also
loved the way he'd have a conver

sation with the guitar, playing a phrase,
then saying "Huh? Unhuh!" It was near
impossible to get all the words for many
years, until recently actually, I thought
he was singing, "Heard a little voice in
side my watch saying little more faith in
Jesus" at one point in the song. 'T' ain't
so. Lightnin' Wells dug out a Gary Davis
recording and, with more educated ears
and Lightnin's help, I finally heard what
the Rev was actually singing: "I heard a
little voice but saw no one.
record was, I
never had the chance to hear the Rev live,

Anyways, inspiring

as the

watch anyone play in his two-finger
style, although for some reason I ended
or

up playing guitar in the same two-finger
(thumb first finger) way. (It's also a banjo
style of playing, and Rev. Gary also played

it turns out.
Think Will Keys.)
All this personal history makes this Ernie
Hawkins teaching DVD extra juicy for me,

banjo, as

even

if he doesn't happen to teach "Little
More Faith." If you actually do the work,
by the time you learn a few of these pieces
you will also be able to work out "Little
More Faith," because you will have begun
to master the Gary Davis style.
Ernie Hawkins is a terrific teacher, and

DVD is set up for learning. (Teaching
DVDs, generally, are a really wonderful
way to teach music.) First Mr. Hawkins
plays the selected piece, then talks about
what's going on in a general way, e.g.,
what key the piece is in, what the basic
chords are, how chords can move up the
guitar neck in different shapes (F-shape
C, A-shape G, etc.), and how wonderful
melodic phrases can be built using the
shifting chord shapes plus a few passing
notes here and there. Then he breaks the
tune down into smaller parts, working
slowly tJirough each phrase or measure.
After that, there's a nice section for each
piece where he uses a split screen, with
one part on the picking hand, the other
on the chording hand. Then there's a fi
this

nal reprise of the full piece played mod
erate tempo, and if it's available, an ar
chival bit of the Rev himself playing the

piece (wherein you realize the Rev was
playing it fast). There's also an accom
panying booklet with each song in both
conventional notation and in tab.
Since the most distinctively personal as
pect of these pieces is Gary Davis' right
hand or picking technique, Mr. Hawkins
spends a lot of time explaining what's
going on with the picking in each piece,
literally note by note, or finger /thumb

/thumb. With tire two-finger
there
are actually at least three ba
style,

by finger
sic
up

possibilities (as, with bowing, there's
/down; ditto flat-picking): you can

pick up with your first finger (1), you can
pick down with your thumb (2), and you
can pinch with both together (3). But as
it turns out, you don't have to alternate,

finger-thumb-finger-thumb,

although

in

that's what hap
pening pretty much. Here Mr. Hawkins
reveals some Gar}' Davis "secrets": you
can also play syncopated phrases using
a

lot of finger picking

two

thumbs

again), two
pinch, a thumb,

(think banjo

fingers, two thumbs,

a

Toss in a couple of hammer-ons and
pull-off and you start having a pretty
complex piece of music. Slide up the
etc.
a

�neck while this is going on and you get
the girl at the end of the night.
Ernie Hawkins had a relationship to
Gary Davis much like that of Alan Jabbour to Henry Reed, as it turns out. As
a
teenager, he sought out Davis and
literally learned at his knee. There is,
therefore, a very personal tone when
Mr.

Hawkins recounts

to us his

ries of the Rev as he works

piece.

This is

Hawkins

a

memo

through each

bonus for the viewer.

a very calm,
kind
teacher taking a workshop from him
in some teaching situation such as Au
gusta Heritage would, I'm certain, be a
true delight. He has done other DVDs
in this series which, I'd predict, are as
enjoyable and fruitful as this one. I'd
recommend them all.
According to the biographical notes

Mr.

is

also

on the disc box, Mr. Hawkins, after his
studies with the Rev were over, went and
got himself a degree in philosophy. As

have one of those myself, which has
stood me in good stead through decades
of fiddling and stone-laying, I have to
what
give Ernie a personal "shout-out"
we cannot speak of, we must pass over
in silence, unless we can find a way to
I

hammer-on

till we get to the next finger

thumb lick. At the end of the DVD
there's a short clip of the Rev hammer
ing and pulling a whole time through
the piece while he raps time on the back
of the guitar with his picking hand, and
makes his patented vocal comments on
or

the performance. Great God, y'all.
one is special for sure.

This

BILL HICKS
To

order: www.guitarvideos.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�AMERICA

KEEPING

WEIRD

OLD

Smithsonian Folkways Recordings

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

FOLKWAYS.SI.EDU
Save 20% through

888-F0LKWAYS
2/28/09

on

CD

or

800 410-9815

Orders with Code HERALDFW08

�Xt&gt;

L3
v.

5-STRING
PRODUCTIONS

Jus-

#1 0

f Ifcele-asedlf

Cataloochee

Bowling Green

Carol Elizabeth Jones

Alice Gerrard

&amp;

An

Mike Seeger

Evening at WPAQ, 1984

Benton Flippen

the

&amp;

dozen songs about living, loving,
and leaving life in the Appalachian
mountains.

Extraordinary performances by
two iconic musicians. Includes
three tracks with the legendary

5SP08001

Tommy Jarrell.

Recapture a memorable night of
music with one of the South's most
powerful old time string bands.

5SP08003

5SP08004

A

Smokey Valley Boys

More Great Releases:
From Mali to America SSP06004
Cheick Hamala Diabate and Bob Carlin

Birdie

5SP07001

Wayne &amp; Margaret Martin
and Craig Johnson
The Road To Agate Hill 5SPO6003

Alice Gerrard, Gail Gillespie,
&amp;

Sharon Sandomirsky

It's About Time 5SP07003

John Hoffmann

Ernest

V.

Big Ears

Stoneman:

The Unsung Father of

Falls of Richmond

Country Music

Matt Brown

Ernest
Ernest

V.

V.

Stoneman
Stoneman, pioneering

An

reveals Matt to be

Red Clay Country
Paul Brown

a

composer and performer, defined

multi-instrumentalist

the formula of "three chords and

5SP08002

the truth" and became the first
rural singer/songwriter of the
20th century to record.

compelling
and singer

SSP06002

The Rest is Yet to Come SSP04004

Double Decker String band
Lone Prairie ssposoo7
Matt Brown with Paul Brown
&amp; Beverly Smith
Old-Time Fiddle Lesson Vol.

On

The

1

SSP07002

the Edge

5sposoo4

Cliffhangers

Clifftop Notes Vol.

1

ssposoos

Mark Simos &amp; Friends

www.5-string.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Mac Benford

Matt Brown

5SPH001

334 West Union Street, West Chester,

&amp;

s. sposoo6

Mark Simos &amp; Friends

intimate solo recording that

PA

19382

info@5-string.com

U

Known for their Reputation ssposoo2
The Hoover Uprights

�</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </file>
  </fileContainer>
  <collection collectionId="65">
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12031">
                <text>Old-Time Herald</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12032">
                <text>Presented in partnership with the nonprofit &lt;a href="https://www.wholesouth.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"&gt;Whole South Heritage Works&lt;/a&gt;, &lt;em&gt;The&amp;nbsp;Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;collection includes digital copies of every issue of&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald Magazine&lt;/em&gt;, 1987-2023.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Founded in 1987 by legendary musician Alice Gerrard,&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/em&gt;served for more than 35 years as a leading voice of the old-time music community worldwide&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;. Its&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="wixui-rich-text__text" style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt; 130-plus issues, all accessible here, contain a vast wealth of information that can’t be found elsewhere. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Issues include:&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent" data-testid="inline-content" class=""&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent-gridContainer" data-testid="mesh-container-content"&gt;&#13;
&lt;div id="comp-mf5sjgaq" class="ku3DBC zQ9jDz qvSjx3 Vq6kJx comp-mf5sjgaq wixui-rich-text" data-testid="richTextElement"&gt;&#13;
&lt;ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;deeply researched explorations into the history of old-time string-band music and related traditions&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;in-depth articles from respected historians, musicians, and writers&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;historic photographs, many of them previously unpublished&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;detailed discussion of the contemporary culture of old-time music and dance&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;field reports from regional scenes&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;interviews and oral histories&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;extensive album reviews, spotlighting both new releases and reissues of historic material&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;remembrances of departed musicians, including local community players typically overlooked in the national press&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;/ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Also included are robust community discussions and long-running, often fiery controversies waged in readers' letters to the editor.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Originally based in Galax, Virginia, the magazine was published for most of its run in Durham, North Carolina. Founding editor Alice Gerrard was succeeded in that position by Gail Gillespie, then by Sarah Bryan.&amp;nbsp;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;The Southern Music Research Center and Whole South Heritage Works are grateful to our community of donors, whose contributions made possible this significant digitization and archiving project — and to Alice Gerrard, who paved the way and made this whole thing possible.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;em&gt;A logistical note: Click on any issue's title or thumbnail image to access that entire magazine. On some screens, the PDF reader may initially display only a portion of the page. To view the issue more easily, click the "Presentation Mode" icon in the toolbar above the issue — four small arrows pointing outward in all directions. Then you can use your finger or your computer's arrow keys to scroll through the pages. Happy exploring.&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
  </collection>
  <elementSetContainer>
    <elementSet elementSetId="1">
      <name>Dublin Core</name>
      <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
      <elementContainer>
        <element elementId="50">
          <name>Title</name>
          <description>A name given to the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12702">
              <text>&lt;p&gt;&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;, Volume 11, Number 10 (April-May 2009)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="41">
          <name>Description</name>
          <description>An account of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12703">
              <text>&lt;p&gt;&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;, Volume 11, Number 10 (April-May 2009)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Contents include:&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Lou Southworth, Pioneer Oregon Fiddler,” by Vivian T. Williams&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“John Henry in Alabama,” by John Garst&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Mountain Country: OKeh Records’ Historic Asheville Sessions,” by Kent Priestley&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Festival Profile – The Bluff County Gathering,” by Bob Bovee&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Workshop – Old-Time Guitar: Dallas Jones of the Leake County Revelers on ‘Lonesome Blues’,” by John M. Miller&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Final Notes” include obituaries for Whit Sizemore; John Cephas; Jim Taylor; Timothy A. Thompson; Bob Guida; and Richie Shulberg&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="40">
          <name>Date</name>
          <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12704">
              <text>2009</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
      </elementContainer>
    </elementSet>
  </elementSetContainer>
  <tagContainer>
    <tag tagId="1004">
      <name>2000s</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="1591">
      <name>2009</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5533">
      <name>Bob Bovee</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6326">
      <name>Bob Guida</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6320">
      <name>Dallas Jones</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6324">
      <name>Jim Taylor</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6323">
      <name>John Cephas</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6318">
      <name>John Garst</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6317">
      <name>John Henry</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6321">
      <name>John M. Miller</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6207">
      <name>Kent Priestley</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6315">
      <name>Lou Southworth</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6319">
      <name>OKeh Records</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5413">
      <name>Old-Time Herald</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="1417">
      <name>Old-Time Music</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6327">
      <name>Richie Shulberg</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6325">
      <name>Timothy A. Thompson</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6316">
      <name>Vivian T. Williams</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6322">
      <name>Whit Sizemore</name>
    </tag>
  </tagContainer>
</item>
