<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<item xmlns="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5" itemId="2597" public="1" featured="0" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xsi:schemaLocation="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5 http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5/omeka-xml-5-0.xsd" uri="https://southernmusicresearch.org/items/show/2597?output=omeka-xml" accessDate="2026-11-20T01:11:49+00:00">
  <fileContainer>
    <file fileId="3531">
      <src>https://southernmusicresearch.org/files/original/6310eb98604d7cd0ee5d66a6510cfb6d.pdf</src>
      <authentication>315010377f3234ba76501a1471abc11f</authentication>
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="4">
          <name>PDF Text</name>
          <description/>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="92">
              <name>Text</name>
              <description/>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12536">
                  <text>OLD-TIME

THE

HERALD
MAGAZINE DEDICATED TO OLD-TIME MUSIC
WINTER 2003-2004
$7.25
VOLUME 9, NUMBER 2

A

THE

AKONTING

and the Origin

of the Banjo

BREAKIN'
PLUS

UP

DANCE

CHRISTMAS! CURRICULUM, MUSIC
BEAT/HERE

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

&amp;

&amp;

COMMUNITY PROJECT

IN

NC

REVIEWS

THERE/EXTEND

HOLIDAY

�"Oh

Brother, Here

UJe fire!"

Been Here fill Along.
Ozark Folk
Music

School

March 21-26, 2004

Classes, Workshops, Concerts and

Other flctiuities!

Old-Time Fiddle, Art Stamper; Old-Time Banjo, Clarke Buehling; Cajun Fiddle, Mitchell Reed;
Mountain Dulcimer, Larry Conger; Slide Bar Resophonic Guitar, Johnng Bellar;
Folk Guitar

Plus.

Basics, Robert Gillihan.

Ozark

Regional Music UJorkshops and Gourd Banjo Construction,

Potterg, Weaning and mang more
Drg Creek Lodge

Skillet Restaurant

Heritage Herb Garden

P.O.

Craft

Classes.
Homespun

Gift

Folklore and Music Rrchiue

Box 502 Mount lin Uieui,

OR

72560

870-269-385^^6-898-1066 (U/n)
Ozarkfolkcenter com

Section with Illegible Text

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Shop

Crafts Uillage

�OLD-TIME

THE

HERALD
VOLUME

NOVEMBER

9,

NUMBER

JANUARY

2
2003/04

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

FEATURES

LEARNING TUNES/12

by Tony Goldenberg and Elisa Westal
1000 AFM IS

LOCAL

TAKING CARE OF BUSINESS/15

by Alice Gerrard
'BREAKIN' UP CHRISTMAS!" CURRICULUM, MUSIC, AND COMMUNITY
NORTH CAROLINA SCHOOLS/20
By Ken Jackson
"MAKIN' MUSIC" AT THE TODD COUNTRY STORE/24

by Tammy Sawyer and Joe Morgan
THE AFRICAN AKONTING
By Ulf

AND THE ORIGIN OF THE BANJO/26

Jagfors

COLUMNS
HERE

&amp;

THERE/4

DANCE BEAT/8

Play-Parties, Square Dancing, and
Old-Time Music. By Phil Jamison
"Fly to the East, Fly to the West:"

WORKSHOP/34

Mandolin Questions By Bob Smakula

DEPARTMENTS

LETTERS/2

CLASSIFIEDS/35
REVIEWS/36

IN

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Letters

Long-Time Subscriber Writes
Dear Friends at the OTH,

enjoy each issue of your magazine very
much. The record reviews are exactly as
I

they should be, with complete listings and
detailed comments-all other music maga
zines should follow your example. Some

feature article on
Clayton
Georgia Slim
two
of
favorite
fiddlers.
Rutland,
my
the
work.
Keep up
good
day

I

would like

to see

McMichen

a

or

D.W.F. Malloy
Tifton, GA

(In OTH vol. 8, no.

8 a story by Barry Murphy
mentioned meeting "Granny" Clme. Her grand
daughter, Dot Gudger, wrote us to let us know

about an event

Following

is

in Cora "Granny"

Cline's honor.

Dot's letter describing the event.)

�son and other old-timers. Not recognized
as much as some of the other performers,
even though she has been written up in
several books and magazines, her descen
dants have begun an annual "Cora Cline
Day," to be held the first Saturday of every
Fairfield Church, her home church

at

June

all of her 96

years.

The family was

privileged

to

contact with Richard Flulan,

a

have made
field agent

for Smithsonian Institute in Washington,
who had 28 years ago made a reel-to-reel
tape of Mrs. Cline playing her dulcimer. At

the request of Dot Gudger, Mrs. Cline's
granddaughter, he converted the reel-toreel to

cated

a

it

CD and Mrs. Gudger has repli
and made

available

it

to all

the

family. The family is now looking for a cast
picture of Mrs. Cline that they know exists

with the Opry cast. If anyone
copy of such a picture, the family
would be most appreciative of hearing
from them through the email of
of her

has

a

ddg5@mindspring.com.
The dulcimer has been purchased from
another family member by Mrs. Gudger
and is now on display with a photograph of
Mrs. Cline at the WSM microphone in the
Country Music Hall of Fame Museum. An
audio about her and possibly a CD of her
playing in her later years will be added
soon. Richard Hulan says in the latest book

mentioning Mrs. Cline that she was re

markably fast

in her

playing of the dulci

mer considering her age and how long
had been since she had played at all.

it

As "Rambling Rhodes" of the Augusta
says, the next time you hear a

Chronicle

female playing on the Opry, thank Mrs.

beginning the quest for fe
male entertainers, quite a gutsy move for a
mother of nine in 1925 in rural northern
Cora Cline for

central Tennessee!
Dot Denning Gudger
Cullman, AL

Just as we went to press,

we received

terrible news from Joel Cordle in Georgia
that sisters Molly and Margie of the Myers
Sisters were killed on Oct. 13th in an car
accident on the Blue Ridge Parkway .Their
sister Helen, brother John and his wife

were injured. Helen
Asheville hospital.

remains

in

an

The Myers Sisters quartet were beloved
performers at the North Georgia Folk Fes

tival, singing traditional songs and those
of their own composition, accompanying

themselves on guitars.

A

music on Global Village

recording of their
is forthcoming.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Here &amp; There
by Bill

Hicks

Events and Jams
Fall

gospel and early bluegrass music. Scheduled

Dewey Balfa Cajun and Creole

Week, will be Nov. 2-8, Chicot State Park,
Ville Platte, LA. Info:
337-234-8360;
Nomad Festival of Participatory Tradi
tional Dance and Music, will beNov. 1516, Hill Career High School, 140 Legion
Ave., New Haven, CT. Info: 203-453-3263;
www.geocities.com/nomadfest/

&amp;

Tradi

tional Country Music Convention, will
be Nov. 21-23, Harrietville, Victoria,
AUS. Features Wayne Lewis, Joe Isaacs
&amp;

Pedi, Wayne Henderson, Helen White, Josh
Goforth, Dan Delancey, Linda Thomas,
Ronald, Rice, Carl Jones, Beverly Smith,

Band.

and Lorraine Lee

Info:

www.carpentercenter.com

The North East

www.lafolkroots.org

Harrietville Bluegrass

appear are the Paschall Brothers, Speedy
Tolliver, Mark Campbell, and the Johnnie Hott
to

Kentucky, and Rafe Stefanini.Info:

harrietville@bluegrass.org.au
The Virginia Roots Music concert Many
One Community will be on Nov. 8

Worlds--

in Richmond, VA. The evening will feature
old-time Virginia music including folk,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Conference, will

Regional Folk Alliance

be held

Info: 216-546-7766;

Nov. 14, 15,16.

Kilby. Info: 434-248-5444.

Fiddle

www.geocities.com/palestinefestival.

The 17th Old Settler's Music Festival

www.nefolk.org.

Old-Time Music Workshop, Appomattox,
VA, will be on Feb.1-4, 2004. Instructors
include:Mike Seeger, Jim Lloyd and Steve

Boonville

Wright

Contest, Boonville,

MO, will be on Mar. 20, 2004. Info: Call 660-

882-957, 882-6039.

Palestine Old-Time Music &amp; Dulcimer
Festival, Palestine, TX. on March 25-28,
2004. The old-time world and the dulcimer
world come together for a weekend of vis

iting, jamming learning and sharing. Per
formers include: Tom, Brad, &amp; Alice, Don

Hammonds. Info: Jerry
713-432-1058; pickin@aol.com;

is

set for April 15-18, 2004 at the Salt Lick

Pavilion, Austin,

TX.

Camping

is

available

Camp Ben McCullough. Award-win
ning regional and national artists will ap
at

pear on five stages. The festival is held

during the height of wildflower season.
Other events include: a youth talent
competiton, armadillo races, petting zoo, mon
ster slide, stilt-walking, doll making and more.
Info:

www.oldsettlersmusicfestival.org.

The Watch City Opry will be held every
Sunday from 8-11 pm. at the Skellig Pub on
240 Moody Street in Waltham, MA. The

name refers to the town's reputation for its
clock and watch manufacturing. At each
Opry evening there will be time devoted to
an old-time jam; to songs with old time

accompaniment as well as a presentation
by Opry hosts, Dan Fram and Alan
Kaufman, playing fiddle tunes and sing
ing old-time songs. Info: 781-647-0679
There is a monthly open old-time music jam
session on second Fridays from 7-9 PM at
Lottie Motfs Coffee Shop in Seattle, WA.
Info:

206-725-8199;

www.lottiemotts.com.

Upcoming jam session hosts are: Nov. 14:
Gary Lee Moore; Dec. 12: Cathie Whitesides.
For

comprehensive play lists from past Lottie

Mott sessions, see

http://home.comcast.net/

-blechfam/lottiel.html

Artists and Agents

Belgian musician Gerard de Smaele re
ports the recent release of A Banjo Frolic and
the opening of Banjo! a film and exhibit

dedicated to the banjo. The project was
made possible by a grant given by the
Embassy of the United States in Brussels.
Filmed by Patrick Ferryn and de Smaele in
May 2003 in the United States, the film
accompanies the Banjo! exhibition now on
display at the Musical Instruments Mu
seum in Brussels through February 15, 2004.

�Bob Carlin performed

at the

opening of

the exhibit on October 16th. Copies of the
film are deposited to the Musical Instru

ments Museum, the American Embassy,
and the National Media Center, all located
in

Brussels, and

in

Washington DC.

at

the Library of Congress

The New Southern Broadcasters

(Rich

Hartness, Dwight Rogers, Brian Schmiel,
Tolly Tollefson &amp; Gail Gillespie) will give a
concert on Nov. 7 at the Unitarian Univer
salist Fellowship Hall, sponsored by the
Brandywine Friends of Old-Time Music in

Newark,

DE.

302-475-3454

Info:

www.brandywinefriends.org

Bob Bovee and Gail Heil will be per

forming around the Midwest in November
and December including performances in
Illnois at Western Springs Public Library
on Nov. 14, Wauconda Library Nov. 16,
Mendota Library Nov. 18, Morris Library
Nov. 19, Peru Library Nov. 20, Urbana
Country Dance Nov. 21, Hogeye Concert
in Evanston Nov. 22, Prospect Heights Li
brary Nov. 23, and Orland Park Library
Nov. 25. On Dec. 6 they'll be doing an old
fashioned barn dance at The Loft in Red
Info:
MN.
507-498-5452;
Wing,

www.boveeheil.com.

Blues singer and guitarist Scott Ainslee
has the

following upcoming performances.
Nov. 14, at 8:00 pm, he will play at the Old
Songs Concert Series in Guilderland NY.
Info: Andy Spence, Old Songs, Inc. 518/
765-2815. Nov. 15, at the N.E. Region Folk
Alliance Conference on the Mainstage
Showcase at Kutshner's Resort &amp; Confer
NY. Contact:

ence Center in Monticello,
NERFA

tel.

215/546-7766 info@nefolk.org.

First Friday Concert series at the
Hooker-Dunham Theatre Brattleboro, VT

Dec.

5, at

05301. Info: 802-254-9276, wildroot@sover.net
And

on

of the

cruises

two

(Dec.

7-14&amp;Dec.

l4-21)

Norwegian Cruise Line, sailing from

New Orleans

to the

Western Caribbean.

Info: Sue Carper, NCL scarper@ncl.com
In

Print,

In

School

&amp;

On the Net

Tom, Brad &amp; Alice have

a

new website

running: www.tombradalice.com.
includes show dates and song sound

up and
It

clips. Check it out.
The Traditional American Dance Call

caller and systems administrator from
Youngstown State University The primary

focus was on square dance material from
the "golden age" of squares in the U.S.-- the
'50s and early '60s. The new description for
the group says

listserve for tradi
and

orga

used for communication about
the craft of leading dances and organizing
dance activities. Anyone interested in join
ing the listserve can subscribe by sending a

nizers,

to be

standing ovation for his support of old
time music and his contributions to the
festival. This year's judges, Rafe Stefanini
and Beverly Smith, performed on fiddle
and guitar and made sure that every young
fiddler received praise for playing. This
year's contest results were as follows. Se
nior Old-Time Fiddle: Senior Fiddle-Greg

callers@yahoogroups.com

Buergler, Jay Gimelli, Paul Tooley. Junior
Old-Time Fiddle: Fiddling Claude Mar
tin, Richard Rothwell, Matthew Hall. Se
nior Traditional Fiddle: Lilli Vincenz, Marc

Congratulations

tional

blank
text)

The

(no

subject

and

e-mail message

following

are

to

no

message
trad-dance-

Cheek, Marjo Van Dijck. Junior Tradi

winners of the old-

time band, fiddle and clawhammer banjo
contests at Galax, Va., Aug. 4-9, 2003. OldTime Bands: The New Ballard's Branch

Bogtrotters, Galax, VA; Southern Pride,
Hillsville, VA; Blue Ridge Mountain Ram
blers, Lansing, NC. Old-Time Fiddle: Jake
Krack, Orma, WV; Eddie Bond, Fries, VA;

Meadow Bridge,
Clawhammer Banjo: Tina Trianosky,
Nutter,

ers' Listserve, an electronic mailing list for
callers, musicians, organizers, and other

Jarred

interested people, has moved to a new eaddress. The "trad-sd" listserve, was cre
ated by Ridge Kennedy, a traditional dance
caller from New Jersey, with technical sup
port from Doug Sewell, a modern western

Jefferson,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

it is "a

tional dance callers, musicians

great success. The contest is a tribute to 81
year old fiddler Speedy Tolliver received a

WV.

NC; Marsha Bowman, Ararat,
VA; Nancy Sluys, Westfield, NC. Best All-

Around Performer: Jake Krack, Orma, WV
The Speedy Tolliver Fiddle Contest, held
on Sept. 23 in

Arlington, Virginia, was

a

Patrick Mc Avinue, Erik
Richard
Rothwell, Tom Clautice.
Acheson,
Twin Fiddle, Maya
Adult
Awards:
Special
Traveled: Erica
Distance
Greatest
Renfro;
Fiddle:

Weiss; "Holding the Fiddle Right:" Doc
Rosenstock Linda Kolodziej Award:
Gina Miller for expressing appreciation
for the musical community and what it
has given her.

The Stanly County Boys from Stanly

Co., NC were winners of the Old-Time
Band contest at the Tennessee Valley

Fiddler's Convention held in Athens, AL
on Oct. 3-5, 2003.

(continued

on next page)

�The 2003 State

Fair

of

Virginia fiddle

contest winners are: Senior Fiddlers: Mark

Campbell, Richmond,

VA; Peter

Vigour,

Crozet, VA; Greg Buergler, Chevy Chase,
MD Top prizes in the banjo contest went
to Adam Hurt, Greensboro, NC; Pete
VA; Seth Swingle,
Earlysville, VA. The contests were held

Vigour, Crozet,
Sept. 27-28, 2003.
Final Notes

Elmer

C.

"Shorty"

Terrill,

Missouri

farmer and fiddler, passed away in May at
age 89. He had moved

home

Muscatine,

to a

retirement care

although he
spent the last 20 years of his life in New
Boston, Illinois. Shorty won or placed in
in

Iowa,

just about every fiddling competition in
the upper Midwest during the '50s, '60s
and early '70s. His fiddling was fire to hear.
He was born in Davis County, Missouri on
1914. He picked up the fiddle at age
learned his first tunes from his sister
and his father, an accomplished fiddler.
His major influence was his Uncle George
Terrill, who never recorded. Although he
discounted recordings as a source of inspi

May

Fiddler Mack Magaha died
the Veterans Hospital in

Aug. 15 at

Nashville, TN. He

had been ill for some time though the ac
tual cause of death was probably pneumo
nia. For those too young to remember, Mack
was originally the fiddler for Reno and

Smiley, and then for years was the "danc
ing fiddler" on Porter Wagoner's act and
television show.
During the 1960s he was about the most
visible fiddler on the country music scene,
in an age when fiddling fell into disfavor.
Later he was one of the leading attractions

unique, rich style in
the mode of Kenny Baker, Gene Goforth
and Delbert Spray. Some of Shorty's favor
"
ite tunes were a twisty rendition of Walkin'
My Sleep," "Spider Bit the Baby," "Sally
Goodin" "Ragtime Annie" and "Sweet Liza
Jane." His favorite waltz was "The Other
in

One," a name he could not remember, but
one of only two waltzes he played. Al
though he never recorded commercially,
there informal recordings made of him at
ages 87 and 88 when

a

group of Minnesota
and

old-time musicians rediscovered

played with him. One of my prized posses
sions is a video tape a cousin produced at
Hoedown

age 72

in

Alito featuring Shorty

youthful form ripping about
old-time
tunes with a guitar backup.
twenty
Those of us who knew him long ago as well
as those lucky to have played with and
known him recently-he played actively
until he was 88-will miss this gifted man.
in

great,

--Harold

Maurer

Edna Mae Davis, 79, of Ava, Missouri,
died Aug. 6. She was a Master Artist
with the Missouri Traditional Artist/

Apprenticeship Program and

a major
force in keeping traditional dance alive

in the

Ozarks.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

clawhammer banjo playing of Fred or Kyle,
Paul's energetic guitar work was critical to
the Camp Creek Boys' supercharged sound.
His guitar's interaction with Verlen
Clifton's mandolin provided a rhythmic
understructure other bands couldn't match.
His singing soared with joy. The Camp

reissued on CD

at the

original Opryland amusement park.
of strokes, most notably one in
1996, disabled him seriously.
Though known as a dancer and comic

Creek

(County 2719, The Camp Creek Boys),
modern classic of old- time music.

fiddler, Mack was also a very good, very
innovative fiddler who did what he had to

by

keep working and keep his craft alive.
He was also a veteran of the Korean War.
to

--Charles Wolfe

9,

a

Earnest East, Benton Flippen or Kyle Creed,
and the
distinctive Round Peak

A series

12 and

ration, he developed

younger musicians from far away while
also denying hot local bluegrass groups
many a contest trophy. Along with the
outstanding fiddling of Fred Cockerham,

Guitarist and singer Paul Sutphin, a cen
tral figure in the Round Peak music com
munity who later became a sunny presence
in the wider old time music world, died at
his home in Mount Airy, NC on Aug. 26
after an extended illness. He was 84.
Paul was born on Oct. 1, 1918 on Round
Peak Mountain in North Carolina's Surry
County. He grew up in a log cabin with his
parents, W.P. and Ada Golding Sutphin,
eight sisters and three brothers Surrounded
by the intense music of banjoist Charlie
Lowe, fiddlers Ben, Tommy and Charlie
Jarrell, Fred Cockerham and others, he de
cided to add to the community din by
taking up the guitar. Later in life he loved
telling the tale of spending three weeks
clearing a creek bank for a neighbor when
he was

Boys'

1967

LP,

is

a

The original Camp Creek Boys broke up
1970.
Earnest East formed the Pine

Ridge Boys, and Paul organized the Smokey
Valley Boys with fiddler Benton Flippen.
The Smokey Valley Boys set out on a blaz
ing path of contest wins, taking first place
seven times at Union Grove and countless

trophies

at

other conventions in the South.

The band appeared twice

at the

Brandywine

Mountain Music Convention, and per
formed at the University of Chicago Folk
Festival, the National Folk Festival, the
1982 Knoxville World's Fair and the 1996
Atlanta Olympics. At home, the Smokey
Valley Boys played regularly on Radio Sta
tion WPAQ's Merry-Go-Round program,
and provided music for local square dances
and community functions.
In the

1980s Paul started moving farther

afield, appearing most frequently with
Benton Flippen and me at music festivals
and camps around the country. He played
and sang at the Festival of American Fiddle
Tunes, Pinewoods, the Swannanoa Gath
ering, Augusta, and Ashokan. Irrepressibly sociable, Paul loved traveling to share

thirteen, and using four of the five
dollars he earned to buy his first guitar.
The remaining dollar, he would proudly

his music, and people loved him for it.
When I stopped in at his home, he would

father, who he

make our next trip?" If I told him a camp or
festival had called for the coming summer,
he'd answer, "I'm ready. We'll leave in the

he

to his

proclaim,
gave
recalled was skeptical of his desire to be a
musician. Happily undeterred, Paul took
guitar cues from Oscar Jarrell, and devised

almost invariably ask, "Reckon when we'll

unique syncopated two-finger backup
style that helped propel his bands to fame
and fiddlers
convention wins from the

morning!"
Playing in a band with Paul was a unique
experience to say the least. I had the good
fortune to stand right next to him my

1950s through the 1980s.

spot assigned by him

a

Paul played with all the Round Peak
musicians at one time or another, but his

greatest accomplishments were with the
Camp Creek Boys and the Smokey Valley
Boys.

In the

1960s, the Camp Creek Boys

established a driving, stylish sound in oldtime music that inspired thousands of

frequently in the
Smokey Valley Boys during the 1980s and
1990s. He would often choose the songs
and tunes as we went along. He would call
out breaks if he wanted us to take them. But
more than anything else, he would infuse
the performance with focused energy, in
tensity and happiness that drove the rest of

�us to play harder and better than we thought
we could. "Now boys, push Benton. Push

him!"he'd say

to

Verlen, guitarist Frank

Nashville and was

reputation,

glue and wing nuts, triple pick guards in
use for added protection from his massive,
kneading right hand, his foot stomping on
the stage, he would tear into each tune as if

inventory

he

might sud

Halfway through,
denly shout "Whooh!", as if whipping us
on to still greater speed and intensity. He'd
look to his right, to his left, alternately
grinning and serious, keeping us all in line,
and then out to the audience with a huge

play

it.

grin. He'd suddenly look over to me and
"
the banjo, grin again and say, "Pick it, boy

And great heavens, when he opened his
mouth to sing, he could fry the circuits in
the sound board. Over the years, I saw
more than one startled engineer jump in
his seat and lunge for the mixer as Paul

launched into his first verse.
Some people define what they do, and
Paul was one of those people. He never
claimed to be the greatest technical wizard
on the guitar or the most refined singer on
the planet, or to have the greatest reper
toire of songs. He never aspired to be a

professional musician, instead making his
living and supporting his family with his
own home improvement business. He sim
ply lived well with what he had: a remark

deep natural under
standing of melody and how to bend a
note, a fantastic ear for a good song, and an
able sense of rhythm,

playing. Beyond that, he had an overpow
ering spirit of goodwill and happiness, a
capacity to make the most of life, whatever
the circumstance. Showing up on any scene,
he defined joy and friendship, lifting the

spirits of everyone around him.
At the funeral home visitation, the

com

munity repaid his family. People lined up
into the parking lot for four hours, waiting
And there were remarkably few
when Paul came to mind, so
because
tears,
to get in.

story and a smile. Ap
his
example had stuck.
parently
--Paul Brown
a

Bob Pinson, country music historian and
record collector extraordinare, lost his battle

with

--Roy

some 200,000 recordings.
Pinson was a renowned authority on the
history of country music, helping many
other researchers on projects large and
of

small. His most recent accomplishment was

serving

as

a

discography
which

is to be

consultant on
of pre-WWII

a

monumental

country music

published by Oxford Univer

sity Press.

Marion A. "Peanut"
Sept.

5, in

cancer at age 69.

Though originally
from Texas, Pinson lived for many years in

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Briarhopper Time." Hogan has gone home

but his memory will live on in his record
ings, videos, cds and newspaper clippings.

Pinson's personal accumula

tion of 15,000 records formed the core of
the Country Music Foundations current

Brown, 96, died

Conyers, GA. He played and

recorded with some of country music's
earliest recording artists, including Fiddlin'
John Carson, Mr. Carson's daughter Rosa
Lee "Moonshine Kate" Carson and the Bill
Gatlin Jug Band, and was a member of the
Atlanta Country Music Hall of Fame. From
1947 to 1954, Brown had his own radio
show on WATL radio in Atlanta, and he

"Whitey" Grant

Johnny Cash died Friday, September

12,

2003. He was much larger than a single
genre, a member of the Rock 'n' Roll Hall of

Fame and the youngest inductee of the
Country Music Hall of Fame when he was
given that award at the age of 48, in 1980.
His wife and musical partner, June Carter
Cash, died in May. Though he was suffer
ing from diabetes and a Parkinson's-like
nerve disorder, the loss of June may have
been the final blow from which he never

recovered

witnessed his last show,

June
21st performance
Carter Fold, in
Hiltons, VA. I was there to play with the
I

at

a

the

Original Red Clay Ramblers, and Johnny
simply announced that he wanted to come
sing for June's people, and that he did.
Word had preceded him, and cars were
parked for miles up and down the little two
lane country road that serves the Carter
It was estimated that there were some
about 500 more
1200 people in attendance

Fold.

also performed on WSB radio. Through the
years, he also worked as a taxi driver and at
what would become the Lockheed aircraft

than capacity. They sat out on the hillside
behind and on each side of the building,

plant in Marietta, GA. In 1954, he began

looking in

new career

in

gospel, performing

a

at

churches and senior living centers with his
daughter and a son, Marvin Brown, as the
Brown Family Gospel Singers.

a

unfettered enthusiasm for making music
with other people. With these tools, he
defined a style of old time string band

inevitably would

major force behind the

founding
Country Music Hall of
Fame there. A record collector of legendary

Bode and me as we went on stage. His
Martin D-18 strung up with heavy gauge
strings, its desperate bridge held on with

there would never be another chance to

a

of the

at the stage from the open wall/
windows. Johnny could barely walk, and

was helped to

hits:

Mandolinist Arvil Hogan, half

of the

duo Whitey and Hogan, passed away at 92.
The two began performing in the 30s over
radio in Gastonia, North Carolina joining
the staff of WBT Radio on the Briarhoppers
Show in 1941. Hogan's fans were world

wide and during World War II, the duet
would receive mail from soldiers fighting
in all the different theatres around the
world. It was easy for The Briarhoppers to
draw 10,000 cards and letters a week in the
hey dey of Radio. Hogan was one of the
greatest persons I ever met and one who
always put his fans first. His time was

theirs on all the concerts we worked. Man-

dolinists all around the world wanted to
play like Hogan. I am very proud to know
he lived long enough to receive the North
Carolinas Folk Heritage Award in 2003. All
of the remaining members will carry the
legacy on. "Do Ya'll Know What Time Hit
Is" The answer from the band was "No
Hogan!" Then he would say "It's

a

chair front and center, the

big framed pictures of the Carter Family
behind him on the wall. He played for
about 45 minutes
many of the great old
"Ring of Fire,"

"I

Walk the Line,"

"Folsom Prison," and some lovely old
hymns and ballads. When he left, Dale Jett,
Janette Carter's son and the MC of the
evening, asked that people please give him
room and not ask for autographs, that he
was very tired and ill. He was unable to
walk up or down the back steps into the

dressing room, and so entered and left
through the audience. He had done a great
deal to get the Carter Fold going through
the years, with many appearances at the
Fold Festival that no doubt improved the
draw enormously, and helped Janette build
the venue into the old-time music institu
tion it is today. It is little remembered now,
but in 1969 Johnny Cash outsold even the
Beatles. He will not be replaced in the gal
axy of music.
--Bill Hicks

Please send Here &amp;There items
PO

to

Boxl062, Siler City, NC 27344

Bill at billfid@centernet.net.

Bill Hicks,
or

email

to

�Dance Beat

"Fly to the

East, Fly to the West:" Play-Parties, Square
Dancing, and Old-Time Music

courtesy

Becky

Ogden.

By Phil Jamison

"Come to the Play Party" is an illustration for a CD recording of a folk musical for elementary schools. For more information
J. Webster Vierow.
see www.musiceducationpress.com.
Painting by

on the play and recording,

also known as singing
dances that are accompa
nied by singing and clapping of hands
rather than instrumental music. They range

Play-parties,
games, are

from simple skipping, marching, and play
acting games for very young children, to

courtship and "swinging games," for teen
agers and young single adults, which may
involve choosing partners, kissing, and
other preoccupations

of the adolescent
were common in

years. Play-parties
America during the eighteenth and nine
teenth centuries, and they remained a part
of the dance tradition in the rural parts of
the country well into the twentieth cen
tury, having a lasting influence on old-time
music and dance.
American play-parties were derived

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a variety of sources including older
English singing games, dance tunes, and
popular songs. The earliest play-parties in
colonial America were variants of ones
found in the British Isles and elsewhere in
Europe. As with the British ballads which
came to this country, some of the language
and references to the old country were
kept, but other words changed over time to
reflect their new American setting. In this
country, many of the children's play-par
ties became adopted by African-Ameri
cans, when children of both races played
together, and they are frequently mentioned
in slave narratives. Henry Bedford, a slave
born on a plantation in Tennessee in 1859
recalled singing games he played as a child,
"Goose and Gander," "Hide and Seek,"

from

"Drop the Handkerchief,"

and

"Ring

'round Rosie."
In

addition

to the old

ones transplanted

from Europe, new play-parties were cre
ated in America during the 19th century.

popular music of the day, whether
fiddle tunes played at dances or adapta
tions of songs from the minstrel stage and
elsewhere, these also became a part of the
American play-party tradition. The move
ments of these new play-parties were ei
ther borrowed from earlier ones, or adapted
from the figures of popular contra dances
Set to the

and quadrilles.
The popularity of play-parties in America
is often attributed to the church's condem

nation of dancing following the Great
Awakening of the mid-18th century. The

�fiddle was thought to be the Devil's instru
ment and dancing was considered sinful.

play-parties, which
"playing," not dancing,
some communities, be

and

Singing games

were referred to as
were acceptable in
cause fiddling was not involved. In Singing
Family of the Cumberlands, Jean Ritchie re

to
amuse
the
plays, calculated
""In
a
rival
unauthorized
youngsters.

"autobiography, "Sketches and Eccentricities
of Col. David Crockett of West Tennessee, pub

lished in 1833, an anonymous author de
scribed Crockett's love of frolics and "old
fashioned plays which served to help him

calls many singing games that she played

along amazingly"

as

tells of

child in eastern Kentucky. These in
clude "Goin' to Boston," "Charlie," "Killy
Kranky," "Cedar Swamp," and "Old King
Cole." She has told me that they had square
a

whenever

a

new preacher

came to town, they would

have to quit

dances, too, but

at

courting. This author

frolic following a neighborhood
and
"reaping
flax-pulling" around 1806.
The day passes pleasantly, and happily
a

came on the evening dance. There was no

fashion-no

finery-no short frocks-no
corsetts. They did not encircle each other

while and resort to play
"dancing"
But
before
parties.
long, the restriction
would be relaxed and the square dances
would resume. Play-parties were not
merely a substitute for square dancing
though. Some communities banned playparties along with square dancing, and
elsewhere the two forms co-existed sideby-side. Cultural isolation may have played

throughout the mazy windings

larger part in their popularity than church
repression. They tended to be most com
mon in newer, remote settlements on the
frontier, which were oftentimes lacking
dance musicians. And although the church

enjoyment than a play termed, 'We are on
our way to Baltimore.' This, from its title,
was probably picked up by David, during
his wanderings; and derived its chief charm

for

a

a

condemned dancing

in

both urban and

rural regions, the play-party was popular
only in the country, not in the city.

thought that many of these children's
singing games originated in the upper
classes as imitations and simplifications of
adult social dances. Adopted by the lower
classes in the country, they were perpetu
ated as an"old-fashioned" and"rustic" ru
ral tradition. The most common forma
tions for play-parties are simple versions of
round and longways sets, patterned after
the circle, square, and contra dances. Playparties in the ring formation often involve
circular motion around an extra dancer
standing in the center of the set. At some
point the person in the center either chooses
It is

the next center person, or else forces an
other in by stealing that person's partner.

Most longways sets involve movements
reminiscent of the Virginia Reel. Partners

stand opposite each other in separate lines,
couples often dance down the center and
back, cast off, march down the outside of
the lines, and pass under arches made by

raised hands.
An early reference to play-parties on the

Appalachian frontier comes from David
Crockett's autobiography in which he wrote
of an all-night dance as a young man in
Tennessee

in 1805:

"We

continued our

frolic till near day, when we joined in"some

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

of

a

waltz;

nor were they skilled in the less fashion
able cotillion
Awhile they trip the coun

dance then exchange
amusement less fatiguing, or
try

it

for some

which
Plays which

for one

promises more pleasure
had been fashionable when their grand
mothers were girls, were called up, and
wearied out. Nothing seemed to give more

from the circumstance, that every couple
who composed it, had to kiss each other at
stated pauses. It consisted of a wild and
irregular dance, during which, with mea
sured steps, the following lines were

sweetly chanted:
'We are on our way to Baltimore,

With two behind, and two before;
Around, around, around we go,
Where oats, peas, beans and barley

grow,
In waiting for somebody. (A kiss.)
"Tis thus the farmer sows his seed,

19th century.

Some play-parties consisted of words fit
popular dance tunes, though in some
cases it is uncertain which came first, the
fiddle tune or the play-party. While the old
to

play-parties have disappeared, remnants
of their lyrics are still recognizable in the
nonsense verses attached to many old-time
fiddle tunes still played today. One ex
ample is "Old Joe Clark," which was sung
and danced as a play-party in Virginia,
North Carolina, Tennessee, Kentucky, West
Virginia, Mississippi, Texas, Oklahoma,
and Indiana. The chorus which is some
times sung, "Round and round Old Joe
Clark,"
a

is

likely left over from the lyrics of

now-forgotten play-party.

"Fly

Around

recorded

by
My Pretty Little Miss,"
Samantha Bumgarner in 1924, shares some
of its lyrics

with the play-party,

"Pretty

Little Pink." Also known as "Coffee Grows
on White Oak

T rees," and "Old King Cole,"
game was known in North
Carolina, Kentucky, the Ozarks, and the
Midwest. Other standards from the old-

this singing

time music repertoire, which were once
play-parties, include "Cindy," "Fire on the
Mountain," "Polly Put the Kettle On,"
"Black-Eyed Susie," "Sally Goodin," and
the song "Jennie Jenkins.""
During the 19th century, the play-party

tradition changed as many new ones were
Dance figures such as the
"Grand Right and Left," borrowed from
the newly fashionable quadrilles, became
incorporated, and dance calls replaced
some of the earlier lyrics. New play-parties
set to popular songs, with lyrics suggestive

introduced.

dancing, were also created. These in
clude hits from the minstrel stage, such as
of

dance by the light of the
other popular nine

Folds his arms, and takes his ease,

"Buffalo Gals" (".

Stamps his feet, and claps his hands,
Wheels around, and thus he stands,

moon"),
teenth century songs, such as "Golden
Slippers""and "Captain Jinks." In some
cases dance calls were fit to common fiddle

In waiting for somebody.' (Another kiss.)
David's partner was a bewitching creature,
and ere they had finished dancing 'We are

on our way to Baltimore,' she had led him
For we will here
far on the road to Love

find him, though introduced as

engaged

to be

a stranger,
married before the evening

as

well

as

tunes, such as "The Girl

I

Left Behind Me,"

likely leading to the development of the
singing square dance call. In this way, the
traditions of play-parties and square danc
ing in America influenced and changed

is

each other.

day! In this play-party,

the person in the

One of the most popular and widely
known of the American play-parties was
"Old Dan Tucker." Dan Emmett claimed to
have written its namesake song (the words,

singing game, also known as "Oats, Pease,
Beans and Barley Grows," were popular in
Europe as well as in America during the

(continued on next page)

over.
With such quick results, it is no wonder
that these "kissing games" and play-par
ties were popular with the youth of the

center of the ring chooses someone from
the circle to be his "wife." Variants of this

though not the tune) around 1830. He was
performing it on the early minstrel stage by
1841 and published it in 1843. Within a few
years of its publication, "Old Dan Tucker"

�was widely known, sung, and whistled
throughout America, and prior to the Civil
War it was played and sung as a dance tune
by

slaves on plantations across the South.

The lyrics to Emmett's original chorus were:
"So get out de way! get out de way!
get out de way!
Old Dan Tucker you're too late to

Miller," also known in this country as "The
Miller Boy" and "Happy is the Miller."
(The figures described by Sharp actually

more closely

resemble

different play-

a

party, "Pig in the Parlor.")

come to supper."
By the early 1860s, specific dance fig
ures, no doubt inspired by the lyrics of the
song, had become popular, and "Old Dan
Tucker" appeared as
lished dance manuals.

dance in eastern Kentucky where it was
simply called "Tucker." He related it to an
old English singing game called "The Jolly

Although Sharp saw"Tucker" called as a
square dance, it also existed as a play-party
region at that time. The fact that it
does not appear in William NewelTs 1883
collection, Games and Songs of American
in the

in

pub

in

these

Children (which does include many of the

books as the same as the "Ninepin Reel," or
the "Nine-Pin Quadrille," it became fash
ionable at society dances in American cities
and was described as "a very amusing

other common American play-party songs)
suggests that it become a play-party years

a

quadrille
Identified

dance for the parlor." One of these dance
The Ball-Room Monitor (c. 1866),

after being danced as

a

quadrille. By the

early twentieth century, "Old Dan Tucker"
was a well-known play-party throughout

lists "Old Dan Tucker" as one of the "Pro

the South, the Ozarks, the Midwest, Okla
homa, and Texas. Its inclusion inal911US

miscuous Figures" for the quadrilles. "A

Government publication Social Plays,

in the

Games, Marches, Old Folk Dances, and Rhyth
mic Movements for Use in Indian Schools,

manuals,

gentleman

or

lady place themselves

centre of [the] Cotillion, then eight hands
all balance,
then all turn cor
round,
the
now
ners,
person in the centre will
take the place of

[a

partner in] any one of

[the] couples, while the person discarded
"
or cheated must go to the centre
In 1917, Cecil Sharp encountered the same

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

may have helped spread

it to

remote re

square dance,
gions
"Old Dan Tucker" survived into the20th
century. An early 78 rpm recording which
includes dance calls was made by Judge
Sturday's Orchestra in St. Louis in 1925.
of the

country. As

a

Other recorded versions include those of
Fiddlin' John Carson (1924), Uncle Dave
Macon (1925), and the Skillet Lickers (1929).
In 1926, "Old

Dan Tucker" also appears as

circle dance for "any number of couples"
in Henry Ford's Good Morning, a book of
a

"Old-fashioned Dancing."
Like the 19th century quadrille, the playparty, was also danced with an extra gent,
"Tucker," in the middle of the set. The
lyrics of the verse from one version are:
"Old Dan Tucker's back in town,
Swingin' those pretty girls all
around,
First to the right an' then to the left,
An' then to the girl he loves the

best."
While these words are sung, the dancers
circle to the left around "Tucker." Then
"Tucker" attempts to find a partner while
the other dancers first allemande right their
partners, and then allemande left their

corners.The couples then promenade while
the chorus is sung, and a lone gent is left
over to be the next "Tucker."
"Get out of the way for old Dan
Tucker,
He's too late to get his supper,
Supper's over and breakfast's

cookin',
An' old Dan Tucker stands there

a-

lookin'."
The lyrics to this play-party are

a

compos

number of sources. Only a few of
the lines come from Dan Emmett's original
lyrics. Others are borrowed from an old
ite from

a

English play-party, "Little Sally Waters"
(also known as "Little Sally W alker") which
contains the line, "Fly to the East, Fly to the
"
West, Fly to the one that you love the best.
(A variant of this is also used as the title of
a fiddle tune, "Been to the East, Been to the
West," recorded by Mississippi's Leake
County Revelers in 1928. Perhaps at one
time this tune was also

a

play-party.) "Old

Dan Tucker," like many of the other Ameri
can play-parties, was

hybrid incorporat
variety of sources:
dance figures froml9th century quadrilles,
lyrics from both old English singing games
and the minstrel stage, and a tune popular
ized on the minstrel stage.
ing elements

from

a

a

Play-parties are no longer a part of our
popular American culture, but I have been
told that some do still survive in Amish

communities

in Pennsylvania. And though
now
mostly obsolete, traces of
they
them can still be found. Some of these old
singing games remain preserved as songs,
now a part of the elementary school music

are

�(1898). New York: Dover

curriculum and culture. These include

&amp; vol. II

"London Bridge," "Farmer in the Dell,"
"Ring Around the Rosy," "Skip to my Lou,"

tions, 1964.

"Paw Paw Patch," "Mulberry Bush," and
other children's songs with movement.

Even the modern, commercialized "HokeyPokey" has its roots in a play-party. Its
well-known music and words were writ
ten in the 1950s, but the dance
are

similar

to

a

movements

that originated in now-forgotten play-par
ties remain attached many old-time fiddle

tunes, likely to be sung by unsuspecting
musicians for many years to come.

play-parties, see:

Botkin, B.A. The American Play-Party Song.
(1937) New York: Frederick Ungar Pub

lishing Co. 1963.
The Frank C. Brown Collection of North Caro
lina Folklore, Vol. 3, Folk Songs From North
Carolina. Henry M. Belden and Arthur

Palmer Hudson (ed.), Durham, North Caro
lina: Duke University Press, 1952.
Gomme, Alice Bertha. The Traditional Games
of England, Scotland, and Ireland, vol.

Newell, William Wells. Games and Songs of
American Children. (1883)New York: Dover
Publications, 1963.
Randolph, Vance. Ozark Folksongs: Volume
III,

Humorous and Play-Party Songs. (1946)

Revised edition, W.K. McNeil, ed. Colum
bia: University of Missouri Press, 1980.

in the

play-party popular

1880s, called "Right Elbow In" or "Ugly
Mug." And to this day, nonsensical lyrics

For more on

Publica

I

(1894)

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Phil Jamison
caller,

and

is an

old-time musician, dance

flatfoot dancer. He

is

assitant direc

Swannanoa Gathering
Wilson College in Asheville, NC.
tor

of the

at

Warren

�Learning

Tunes

Goldenberg and Elisa Westall

by Tony

began with "Fortune" at the
Brandywine festival in 1976. On a
all

It

friend asked me to
festival with him. A latestart banjo player,
jumped at the chance
trip back east,

a

go to the

I

and

immediately lost myself

in the

rich

ness and intensity of the old-time music
scene. Many of today's popular and well-

Mom's house I listened to the tape again.
After I returned to Seattle, I listened to it
hundreds of times, trying to understand
the sound. "Who is this player? I won
dered. When will I ever hear him again?"
Thus my efforts to learn fiddle tunes be
gan. Twenty-five years later,
see him in my mind.

I

still hear and

recorded players were scattered about. At
the time, knew hardly anyone and simply
followed my ear. It wasn't until several
years later that came to know and follow

have
passed many a morning hour before work
with my fiddle and a tape machine. I have

players by name.
On Sunday afternoon, I wandered by the
Highwoods Stringband camp and there
was this fellow playing "Fortune" on the
fiddle. The Highwoods were playing with
him; I remember Walt Koken walking

learn. For instance, how does my current
favorite fiddler learn new tunes? Still ques

I

I

around, playing

a

low accompaniment. The

unknown fiddler was burning up the

strings. had never heard music like this
before and was galvanized.
fumbled for
and
turned
it
machine
on, know
my tape
and
then
there
that
was
ing
going to learn
to play the fiddle. Moments later, my ride
I

1

I

was ready to leave and reluctantly I took
my leave. I'll never forget walking back
wards, bumping into people, barely able
to tear myself away from that unbeliev
able sound.

All the way home
thought about that
and the moment
reached my
I

session

I

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Several

hundred tunes later,

often wondered

if

there isn't

a

I

better way to

tioning my methods and unsure of the best
advice to offer beginners, I decided to put
the question to old-time musicians all over
the country. I asked how they choose, learn
and listen to tunes. How do they break a
tune down and what methods do they use
to practice? The responses have been so
thoughtful, detailed and articulate, I have
quoted many of them

at

length in this

article.

Choosing Tunes

Most often, people hear a tune some
where and then want to play it themselves,
usually from a recording. Sometimes play
ers receive tunes the old fashioned way,
through direct transmission from another
musician. Some busy folks limit their
choices to what friends are playing, for

convenience sake. Others tailor their choices
upcoming events, such as dances or
festivals. Several people say they have a
to

quick ear and can pick up a tune on the fly.
They learn a tune and play it during a

session; however, the real learning comes
later with further study. The unconscious
is also a storehouse for tunes heard some
where once upon a time and tucked away

deep in the mind, until they return seem
ingly out of nowhere, of their own sweet
in this case some swear, the tune
will
chooses you. Perhaps "the tune chooses
you" phenomenon explains the compul
sion to pursue the tune you can never get
quite right, no matter how long you work

Somehow it belongs to your family of
tunes and your destiny is to return to work
on it again and again.
David Mount, a fiddler from Portland,
on it.

a fascination with trying
tune's secrets. He chooses tunes

Oregon expresses
to

learn

a

techniques he needs to learn as a
If something unusual catches his
he
will
ear,
try to figure it out. A similar
idea made its way into a conversation I had
with a fiddler at Weiser this spring. His
initial attraction to a few notes or one sec
for the

fiddler.

tion of

a

tune inspires him to learn

it in

order to capture that essential sound. All
the musicians who responded to my ques
tions made a similar comment. Players hear

�a

tune and want to make

it

their own: it's an

of love.

expression

Learning A Tune
Some More

Listen, and Listen

doing mindless chores, like dishes or laun
dry or running errands. One wondrous
young player from Portland, Oregon de
"hanging out with a tune."
Suzy Thompson is a fiddler and singer
from Berkeley, California. She has played
in many bands and currently plays with
the Bluegrass Intentions, Suzy's Floozies,
and the Piedmont Avenue Logrollers. Suzy
takes notes on a tune as she studies it. She
also believes that singing the tune tran
scends many personal limitations on the
instrument. It allows one to work with the
melody in different ways and to be cre
ative.

it as

tend to agree and think singing
tunes leads to developing your own style.
Daniel Steinberg, from Mountain View,
I

California, has been learning and teaching
traditional music for 25 years, plays with
the Hillbillies from Mars, and directs com
munity chorus in the San Francisco Bay
Area. Daniel also uses singing as a learning
tool, but with a different focus: "I think of
it as 'active listening' where you are follow
ing the line of music so carefully that you
recognize where it diverges from your

expectations."
Seattle's Pete Martin takes notes, saying,
whole piece interests me, I tran
scribe as closely as possible how the player
played the tune, with emphasis on how
"If the

this player

David Lynch describes it, "I perceive
old-time fiddling as a collection of small,
universal phrases little tune modules. For
As

Nearly everyone says they listen, listen,
listen, and listen some more
mostly while

scribes

tener learns to distill them from the tune.

bowed everything.

"

He goes on

say he wants to know what makes a tune
appealing and to this end, tries to educate
himself through study. He then perfects
to

sound as much as possible before
"changing the tune to fit his personality."
He believes this exercise gives him the
tools to make his sound diverse. Pete plays
fiddle and mandolin and plays with Rural
Delivery, New Radio Cowboys, and Coy
ote Choir. He gives lessons and runs Petimar
Press, which publishes instructional mate
rial and recordings for mandolin and fiddle.
The Bones of the Tune
The first things Daniel Steinberg listens
for are the downbeat, the key, and familiar
phrases. "What is the skeletal essence of
the tune? That is, what notes or sounds
seem to define the flavor of the tune, as
opposed to notes and phrases that connect
those essential parts?" There are of course,
phrases that are particularly characteristic
to old-time music and the experienced lis
the

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

most tunes,

matter of pulling the
out
of
mental
phrases
my
library and link
them
David
is a fiddler and
ing
together."
it's

a

graphic designer living

maintains

in

Asheville, NC.

Old-Time

thorough working knowledge of

a

tune.

The next step seems to be adding personal
style to the mix. It is as if each tune has its

own genius. The chemistry happens when
we can capture its essential nature and
express it anew through the medium of our
own style.

David Mount echoes this sentiment, and
"I often recommend
that
a
balance
to
strike
between
ob
people try

Music
at
www.oldtimemusic.com.
Homepage
Rusty Neithammer, an old-time fiddle

also cautions:

and banjo player living in Philadelphia,
Pennsylvania, follows a similar course and

source and taking a more organic approach.
What worked well for me was to pick a few
'touchstone' tunes I really did try to get

He

the

adds that he looks for the chord progres
sions. He pays particular attention to bow
ing. "When beginning to learn a new tune,
I
try to latch on to where the major down

bows (pulls) and up bows (pushes) occur."
He also spends time figuring out how to
chain together bow movements. Watching
people play also facilitates learning. Suzy
Thompson finds this helpful for learning
how a piece is bowed: "I try to watch the
other fiddler's bow hand and imitate those
motions. I think it helps to just imitate the
shapes that the right hand makes,
feel of the rhythm."
Pay Attention

to

to get the

Details

Once they get the bones of the tune down,
players return to their source or recording
and listen yet more closely, to flesh out the
piece. Seattle's multi-instrumentalist, W.B.
Reid, plays with many groups including
Hold the Wheel and the Todalo Shakers, as

well as with his wife, Bonnie Zahnow. He
elaborates: "The most important part of
deeply believe, one is
unable to hear all the nuances of the tune
until trying to play it. I can hear a tune
this process is that,

I

many times and get a kind of sketch of it in
my mind, but after the first attempt to play
it, I go back to the recording and invariably
hear things in the tune I wasn't able to hear
before." Once you have the basic shape of
the tune down, it can be tempting to gloss
over phrases that are either difficult or less
to the ear. To enter into the true
character of the tune requires listening at a
deeper level. Reid continues, "If you listen

interesting

great fiddler carefully, you'll hear pas
sages that make the tune take an unex
to

a

one which would be diffi
cult to repeat without focused study. A less
careful player plays the tune and it seems

pected route

sessing about getting tunes exactly like the

one I remember was Clyde
Davenport's 'Liza Jane.' I worked on it off
and on for years and when
finally saw
him do it at Fiddle Tunes (the Festival of
American Fiddle Tunes in Port Townsend,

perfect;

I

Washington) I was able to track his bow
perfectly. That taught me a lot and doing it
with a broad variety of tunes helped me
develop a sense of what authentic old-time
playing felt like. But I would have gone
crazy if I'd done that with every tune

I

learned!"
Return to the Source

corresponded with uni
versally emphasized the importance of re
The musicians

I

turning to source material regularly. Suzy
Thompson advises, "Don't forget to re
fresh and renew yourself at the wellsprings
of old-time music. Go back to the source
often and over

a long period of time." The
current generation of teachers and fiddle

masters includes some fine, fine musicians,
but keep in mind

they are secondary
sources. Avail yourself of the primary
source material recorded earlier in this cen
tury by the older generation of musicians
who resided much closer to the living root
of the old-time heritage.
Practicing and Remembering Tunes
Pete Martin distinguishes between play
ing and practicing. "When I practice, I start
on the fundamentals of the

by working

instrument: very slow scales for intonation
and ear training, very light touch exercises
to work on without using too much muscle
force to get the job done and correct ergonomic positioning." This can help prevent
injury. David Mount works on technical
problems while he plays a tune, often while
walking around the house. He sometimes

sound the same, yet some intangible
thing is missing."
Add Personal Style While Remaining True
to the Tune

practices

Most of the respondents to the question
naire expressed a similar drive to gain a

those of us who literally know hundreds of
(continued on next page)

to

in

front of

a

mirror. Then there are

the folks who don't practice, they just play
in sessions and that becomes their practice.
Remembering becomes a real issue for

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

tunes and have too much crammed into
our brains besides. Often, all that's neces
sary is to be able to recall those first few
notes and then the rest of the tune follows.
Everyone has their little tricks. These in

clude keeping a tune list and carrying a
notebook with tune titles accompanied by
the key or first measure. I have for years
my central
learning tune for one week and I return to
it for a few minutes of each practice ses

had

a

"Tune of the Week."

It is

can usually remember

sion. After

a

the tune;

not, my rule is to hold

if

week,

I

it

over for

second week. This motivates me to learn
it the first week so I can move on to that
next amazing tune I want to learn.
So What Does It Mean
I was
moved by the willingness of my
friends to take the time and care to listen
and apply themselves to hearing what is
being played, and not to what they think is
being played. Their effort to balance be
tween copying a tune exactly and being
a

artistic is the key to developing a personal
style. It was suggested that learning a few
"touchstone" tunes, as close as possible to
the original, would be helpful. David
Mount said that this method allowed him
to get a good "sense of what authentic old-

time playing felt like." Some of us think
that it's important to limit your exposure

only to music that is relevant to the sound
you want to have. I and others feel less

inclined to be so restrictive. Many people I
spoke with swear by their variable speed
tape decks. They allow the listener to slow
things way down, and hear deep into a
tune. My machine will slow the mightiest
players down to where you can hear each
and every note, one at a time. It is money
well spent. If I'd had that machine in 1976,
I
might have figured out how James Leva

played "Fortune" so inspiringly.

Tony Goldenberg lives and works
penter

in

Port

Townsend,

WA.

as

a

car

He started

in 1976 and has played for
dances
and
festivals. He was recorded
many
with the band Lost Rosin, and appears with
them on the the CD Young Fogies Vol. 2. He

playing the fiddle

is currently learning to play West African dun
dun drums for the weekly African dance class in
Port Townsend, WA.

Elisa Westall

craftsperson.

is a

dedicated fiddle student and

�Local

1000

AFM

Is Taking

Care of Business
Edited by Alice Gerrard
from an interview with
John McCutcheon

circuit have led a solitary life. One-night stands.
years those of us touring on the folk, bluegrass and acoustic music
No
No
health
insurance.
No
conditions.
way to get good, affordable insurance for our
pension.
Unpredictable working
instruments. No one to stand up for us and help us get the respect we deserve as hardworking professionals. And not much

For

to join the American Federation of Musicians (AFM).
American Traveling Musicians Union. We're
have
changed and now we have an AFM local just for us: Local 1000, the North
Things
and
for
created
musicians,
run
a democratically
people just like you. And no matter where you live in
traveling
by
organization
website.
the
www.locall000.com
for
1000
is
Local
Canada or the U.S.,
you!-- from

reason

The Beginnings

"Will you still love me?"
Well, the answer

is

maybe, and maybe not.

What are we musicians going to do when we get
old and possibly unable to travel around any
more and make

a

living

we've been used to?

as

at the

Most of us over 50 are certainly
point
where we're not fond of sleeping on floors and
couches that become your bed in the living room
only when the party is over.
It seems to me that for traveling musicians,

joining Local 1000

is a no

brainer. For

a

little

of hassle you get benefits that are huge.

pension plan

is

bit

The

amazing; the instrument insur

ance plan is one of the best I've encountered;
and the hospitalization, although not the best, is
at least
a

something, especially for someone with

family.
who

the president

of
John McCutcheon,
Local 1000, and one of its founders and most
eloquent supporters, was in Durham for Tommy
is

Thompson' s funeral and memorial service. The
next day we sat down together to talk about
Local 1000. He filled me in on what was going
on in the early

1970s

A.G.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

1000 had its genesis in the re
musicians'
co-ops that were spring
gional
30
some
years ago," said John. "[Mu
ing up
"Local

sicians] recognized they were part of a
community-- they played music together,
cared about one another, and in some respects
had similar lifestyles. They looked
it
for a way to provide for one another
wasn't
that
the
was obvious
marketplace
going to provide for them. They didn't fit
into the paradigm of how musicians got
together in unions, for instance, because
the unions at that time mainly dealt with
large ensembles of people who, in the tra
ditional trade union setup, came to work at

who traveled around for
living, whether we were playing for
dances or coffeehouses, or festivals or
school jobs, or nursing homes or librar
who make all or part of our living in
ies
the musical world, we were shut out of the
structure of what the musicians' union was
"So those of us

a

at

that time. And there were also
in that

a

lot of

musical world who felt inde

people
pendent, and bought into the very care
fully constructed anti-union rhetoric that's
been foisted on us since World War II.
"So we banded together in these small
regional groups and there was an attempt
to start the Southern Appalachian Musi

the same place.

cians' Co-op. We had a meeting at High
lander [Folk School in Tennessee]. There

worked for the same employer and so the
union could wrap their head around that
and say 'ok, we'll go in and negotiate a
contract with benefits, etc.'

unlike many of our friends, we got paid

If you played in a Broad
band,
you showed up every day at
way pit
the same place for work just like if you
were an auto worker or a coal miner; you

were old and young
mostly people who
were deriving some or all of their living
from playing music. Now, like all of us, we
were also playing in jam sessions and our
whole social life was involved in old-time
music and bluegrass music as well. But

�sometimes and depended upon that

to

make our living and raise our families. So
we started talking with one another, how it

might work, and we had two or three meet
ings, we had a newsletter, and we eventu
ally found that most of us were a lot more

something that

as

you know,

is

a big thing to us now. And we were looking
for a way to share the resources that we had

tracts when you get a job. 1) to pro
tect the job, so that you have a writ
ten agreement, so that the union can
defend the job if necessary; 2) to get
access to the health care plan; 3) to
get contributions in your name into
the musicians' pension plan. Do you
a contract? No. As John
don't want to file a con
tract, fine. No pension, no health
plan, no contract protection. But the
union is not going to come after me
and hassle me, because that was my

have to file
said, "If

I

own choice. Our attitude is, listen, if
you don't want that protection, fine,
you're on your own. But most
people, when they start getting the
benefits that come with the contract
say they're going to file a contract
every time, because this is really

worth it."

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

accomplish on our own.'

clarion call," John said. "These

the strain of no money or expertise. Any
one who's ever tried to start an organiza

anything

There are three reasons to file con

was

[was that] all the regional co-ops indepen
dently seemed to be dealing with the same

insurance. We were all so young with the
exception of Nimrod [Workman, the tradi
tional singer] and a handful of other people,
that we weren't thinking of retirement or

contract?

us could

democratic organizations; let's change
it." Thus started a series of meetings with
the international leadership of the AFM,
the largest entertainment union in the
world, and "the only ball game in town."
He continued, "and we thought, well, we
could reinvent the wheel, but we've al
ready been there. We saw it with the re
gional co-ops they just collapsed under

they wanted to be able to communicate
with one another somehow. And we also
were looking for a way to provide health

a

theirs. They not only have the pocketbook
issues but they understand that this is a
way to accomplish as a group what none of

interested in playing music and deriving
the benefits of this organization than in
actually running it. None of us were orga
nized, none of us were bureaucrats, and
eventually, like most of the regional co
ops of the time, it collapsed under the
bureaucratic weight of its own incompe
tence. Something your readers will rec
ognize I think.
"But the common thread through all this

three basic things: as the region and the
community got larger and more disparate

Why file

that strongly about our own [AFM] union,
as all these people we support feel about

vis

vis gigs. We wanted to have

a

where people
work was.

a

place

could find out where the

a

are

tion knows this. So much to the credit of
the [AFM union officials] they started in

stituting some changes."
The New Deal committee consisted of
people who were members of their own
local unions who would pay $35 a year to
join the committee and would try to be a
sort of conference within the union lobby
ing for the concerns of the traveling musi
cian. "And we convinced the AFM that the
traveling musician is never going to have
the force in a democratic local that a big
block like a symphony or recording musi
cians have. We're never there for meetings

don't have enough power to
wield
so we convinced them, which is
the most amazing thing when you think
and we

was an effort to
it was
national musicians' co-op
called Hey Rube. And I was actually on the
first board of directors along with Utah
Phillips, Pop Wagner, Charlie McGuire it
was mostly driven by people who had
"So in [about 1979] there

have

"It

a

back on it."
They had to get legislation drafted that

would amend the bylaws

non-geographical local

to

to

allow for

a

exist. They got

been involved in the June Appal co-op up
in Minneapolis/St. Paul, or the Buck and
Wing in Boston; there was another one

some help from some pretty influential
people inside the AFM, due to some con
nections John O'Connor had made over

gig list together; we did all this research on

and organizers of the original New Deal
Committee, and he is Secretary-Treasurer

called Wildflowers in Saratoga Springs
mostly people from that who got together.
We actually hired staff people; we put the

the years from being active in the Seattle
Local. O'Connor was one of the founders

health insurance."

("for life we jokingly say") of Local 1000.
"We got some delegates at the convention

At about this same time John became a
member of the American Federation of

of 1991 to

Musicians [AFM] for,

O'Connor.

same reason that
a

gig,

and

I

a

puts it, "the
I had
lot of people do
as he

recording session with

major label
had to join." In about 1986 John and

a

a

several others who were involved in help
ing out with strikes and other labor issues
were sitting around trading war stories
about the Brookside strike or the JP Stevens
campaign or the Hormel meat packing

"and one of us, probably Charlie
'wouldn't it be great if we felt
said
King,

strike

introduce the language," said
"It was fairly controversial, but
in the end the convention voted to refer the
matter to the AFM Executive Board, who
granted us a charter in 1993. It was the
first ever non-geographical charter in
AFM history."
Local 1000
"We started with about 50 members,"
McCutcheon continued. "Little by little we
were able to find creative ways to access a
lot of the benefits that people really care

�about to the point that we have a very basic
health care plan, and that, for someone
who has nothing, is a great step forward.
We're an organization in flux, too, so we're
working really hard to find alternatives
that are more comprehensive, but for right

now

you have a hole in your heart? You
can't get health insurance? You can get
health insurance with Local 1000, and they
will not turn you down. You can have
AIDS and they will take you. And ask
anybody who has managed to cobble to
gether some kind of a retirement plan,

what their retirement plan looks like right
now in light of what has happened to the

economy

in the

past few years, and they'll
is worth a half or less of

tell you their plan

what

it

used to be. But because of the nature

of the AFM plan there is no reduction in
benefits. It's a fixed benefit plan the way
pension plans used to be before all the
bosses said 'no we don't want the burden
of financial responsibility falling on the
company; we want it to fall on the work

ers.' But the AFM plan is still a fixed plan,
it's solvent, and it's paying out.

"Right now we have about 400 mem
bers; people are not only joining, they're
taking advantage
getting health care, get
ting involved with the pension plan, or
they're finding out the instrument insur
ance plan is the only way to really protect
gear, PA system, recording equipment,

banjos, and fiddles

and it'll replace them,

not just give me some depreciated value."

Remember all those dreaded days of flying
and trying to carry your instruments on
board? And never knowing whether the
gate agent or flight attendant would in an
agreeable mood, and having instruments
taken from you at the last minute and put
below
and all the stress from the uncer
tainty and arbitrariness of the "rules"? Well,
the AFM has successfully negotiated with

the Transportation Safety Administration
the right for musicians to carry on their

instruments on airline flights in addition to
the one carry-on and one personal item.
See the Local 1000 website for the
downloadable document that you can carry
with vou.
Why Be in A Union?
"It's the same reason that people who
throughout time have gotten together with
other people who are interested in some of
the same concerns," said John. "There are
practical concerns. We're sitting here the

day after Tommy Thompson's memorial

service. People knew Tommy in a lot of
as an inspirational
different capacities

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

teacher, as
in his

a

friend. But they also knew him

professional incarnation

as an actor,

songwriter, and as a musician, and
that's how he made his living. And the oldtime music community [also consists of]
people who play for their own enjoyment,
and some of whom decide that this is going
as

a

to be the
to

kind of work they're going to do
their families. Now, some

maintain

people do

it

full time, some people do

it

part time, but I read recently that 80 per
cent of the people in the AFM are part-time

musicians. So we're not talking about some
one who has to be making 100 percent of
their living performing or even in multiple
musical activities. Most people sort of
cobble their livelihoods together.
"If we were doctors, one of the first thing
we would do when starting our profes
sional life is join the AMA. If we were
dentists we would join the ADA. The AFM
is our

professional organization.

It's the

only organization that exists in this conti
nent whose sole purpose is to advocate for
the rights and the well being of musicians.
Even a group like IBM A [International Blue-

grass Music Association] is a trade organi
zation, which takes into account not only
the musicians but also the people who hire
the musicians. And many times there are

disagreements that arise, concerns that arise
if you are the person
the
person hiring. That doesn't
working or
we
have to introduce an
mean that
adversarial relationship, but the concerns
nevertheless, are different.
"And I have found that besides thepocketbook issues that a union is charged to be
concerned with, you could talk to any
worker, whether they are a teacher, a nurse,
an auto worker, when it comes right down
that are different

about dignity or respect. Are you
your work being treated fairly, and are
you able to do this in a dignified manner?
"Here we are today after Tommy's me
morial service, and what I look forward to
to it, it's
in

time when the cost for care for some
one in Tommy's position would not have
been an issue, because people will have
their pensions and health care.
is the

"We're all in this together. We are inter
ested in making sure that we don't have to
have these endless benefits for people that
never really raise enough money to make a
true difference in a person's condition. We

believe that we can actually strengthen the
community. And if somebody wants to
have a benefit for somebody who's de
voted their whole life to making our com(continued

on next page)

�The Pension Plan

let's hand this money
to them and say, 'Great
go to the Baha
mas with your family, have fun with this,

munity better, great

every job you file a contract for, a
certain amount of your fee (10-15%) is
dedicated to the pension plan. At the

don't just hand this to your cardiologist,
because that'll be all taken care of.' That's

current payout rate, for every $100 that
is sent in to the pension plan you will
get $4.65 per month return at age 65.

came out of the old-time music com
munity and I still consider that my home.

For

There

is

a

five-year vesting period dur

ing which you must earn
in
to

at least $1500
contract covered wages to be eligible

collect

a

pension

at

age 65. At the

current rate of payout, within two years
after you start collecting your pension
you will have received in monthly pay
ments over 100% of what was contrib
uted to the fund. On the website are
ways to calculate what you might be
able to collect

at

age 65.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

our dream.
"I

mostly doing my own stuff right now,
if someone came to my show from the
old-time music community they'd prob
I'm

and

ably say 'well I can see that he probably
came from the old-time music community
but what he's doing right now isn't oldtime music,' and that's cool. They would

probably say the same thing if they went to
an Iris Dement concert, or a Robin and
Linda Williams concert. We got involved
in this music because we fell in love with
the music, but more than that we fell in love
with the elders; some of them we know,
were destitute in their old age; some of
them lived long, healthy lives and died
a fiddle in their hand. And as we get
older now, we're seeing that we are the
same age as some of the people we fell in
love with. And when Roscoe [Holcomb] or

with

[Stamper] or Nimrod [Workman] or
any of those people passed away we wished
there could have been more that we could
have done to show them how much they
I.D.

I feel
that way about Tommy Th
ompson, that this is a way for those people
who are making some or part of their living
[as musicians] can look forward to being
treated with dignity and respect in their

meant.

old age, and in their young age. I really
want to let people know that it doesn't

have to be the way it's always been. This is
not something you have to wait till you're
80

It's
"I

years old to have dignity and respect.
something that should be there all along.
know a couple of things about the old-

time music community and that is that
nobody who makes a livingby playing oldtime music depends solely on the old-time
community for their financial support. And

while we know that we're not depending
on the community for the totality of our
income, we have to know that our home
community understands our needs and
can respect them. We're not trying to say
that we want to be paid every single time

we open our case in a jam session or at a
festival, but we want to feel like our fami
lies will be taken care of and that we're

respected. And some of that respect comes
in the

form of compensation.

It

comes in the

form of just general attitude from tire com
understand that every
munity 'Okay,
I

now and then you have to dress up nice
and stand up in the spotlight in front of a
microphone. That's okay, I'm not into that
and I may not even want to go to that, and
I
certainly wouldn't want to pay money to
go to that, but I certainly won't stand in
your way. I think if you're gonna do that
then I think, yeah, you ought to be paid to
do it fairly. You don't have to make a
killing but I respect your right to make a

living and

I

want you

to be

happy and be

taken care of.'
"A lot of

musicians have other jobs that

cover their health insurance or pension
you teach in a school, you work in a factory,
and this is what we do. And we're taking

we're trying to do this,
people's cooperation, and
that's all we're asking for. We're saying
please rethink your notions about what the
musicians' union is and what it isn't, and
about what our old age and our present age
is and should be. You know, everyone of us
knows that the great musicians in our field
are just as good as any musicians in any
other field Why should they not ha ve health
insurance?
"We know that music is part of our life,
and we create a lot of that music. But we
also fell in love with a lot of this music
because of people who were paid to do
that, whether it be Clarence Ashley, or
whether it be Fiddling John Carson, or
Uncle Dave Macon or the Carter Family, or
.whoever it was
the Red Clay Ramblers
that sparked that interest, they were people
who cared enough to leave their families
and their neighborhoods, even though that
was sometimes hard, and go on the road
and play music for a living. And we under
stand that that part of our life is worth
something, and we're trying to determine
exactly what it is worth so we can pave the
care of business,
and we need

way not only for our friends, but those of us
who are coming afterwards. It's something
that we're charged to be concerned with.
We hope that we're doing it in a sensitive
way, that we believe actually strengthens
the community. We're not interested in
going in and saying you ha ve to be union to
play in a jam session or whatever. The
decision to join the union that is something
that

everybody's going

to

make on their

own. We're not out there strong-arming

people. Hopefully we're creating a com
munity filled with enough positive ele
ments that people will say, 'yeah Alice
Gerrard retired with a pension. The first
folk musician ever to do that. And she
started very late in accruing that, and wow,

�John McCutcheon
"I was a college student in 1972 in Minne
sota. I learned to play the banjo, which is
the ultimate cultural denial. I remember
hearing Old-Time Music at Clarence
Ashley's, and I said, "my rich friends are
going to France; for my junior year I'm
going to Kentucky. And with a banjo and
a

backpack I hitchhiked

to

what

I

thought

was going to be a three-month project
not only was there all this music going on
but the reform movement with the United
Mine Workers; Jock Yablonski had just
been killed, and Arnold Miller and the
Miners for Democracy were just starting
to go on, and the

anti-strip mining move

ment was going on, and people wanted
square dances and they wanted a fiddle
contest to raise money for this and that
and

it

was like, oh, this is what

thought music should do
community life-so I lived

be
in

I

a

always
part of

Knoxville

few years; got hired at Clinch Valley
College where I started an old-time mu
sic program up there similar to what
David Holt was doing at Warren Wilson
for

a

[College in Swannanoa, NC]. I would
finish my last class on Friday and get into

my little pickup truck and go off and

play [the weekend nights] someplace,
then I would go all the way back, sleep in

Monday morning class. Finally after a year
of that I said, I can always come back to
teaching, I'm going to give [music] a go,
because I don't want to be an old frustrated

never got paid; if there was $1000 left over
from the project you'd give it to the musi
cians."
John worked with Rounder Records

guy saying would've, could've, should've.
It'll go five years, maybe, and people will
get tired of me.

and when he went to Nicaragua they put
out a double album of music John col

did when

first went

"One of the things
south was I did a lot of recording and
I

I

I

did

banjo, or the dulcimer, or guitar and I'll
discover that there's still something new
in there that kind of leaks out that I hadn't
ever thought about before. ""He tours and

when you're not treating someone as an
informant when you're just hanging out
with them, all of a sudden they are inter
ested in you as a musician, because"they
were musicians. So I had these wonderful

relationships with people."
John was one of the people
planning for Appalshop,

involved

in the

the

co-op in
and
June
Appal
Whitesburg, Kentucky,
Recordings became the outlet for many of
the recordings John made with musicians
like Will Keys and Tommy Hunter, Nimrod
Workman, Pigmeat Jarret, I.D. Stamper,
Addie Graham, the greatballad singer from
eastern KY and many others, getting grants
to help fund the production of the record

ing about it. That's what our experience is
at the Folk Alliance, at festivals, it's the 40-

long time but it's finally starting to hap
pen. And I guess I must have cared about it
more than I even thought did to stick with

a

way

to do that.

"The work with Local 1000 started 30

years ago, I remember reminiscing [re
cently] with Utah Phillips about when he
and I got involved in this effort to organize
it's like herding cats; all these
musicians

independent minded people who want
good things but are independent minded.
we work together we can accomplish
some of these things but it really does take
working together; and Utah is almost 70
If

and

I

just turned 50 and we were

reminisc

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

John's production company,

again. But I would be at Roscoe's [Holcomb]
house and there was stuff I recognized had
never been on any of his records. And

ing about what long, good work it's been.
And in this impatient society there's a great
deal of satisfaction in knowing that it took

that?' And we offer

is

Appalseed

totally unscientifically; I wasn't
folklorist as I was reminded again and

it

look what she was able to do in the space of
four or five years. Imagine if I'm starting at
40 because that's when people start think

year-olds. They come up to you and say
'you know I've been thinking, I've been
doing pretty good, I've been paying my
bills, and making good music, I'm respected
and all of a sudden I realized, I'm 40 years
old and I have not put a dime away for
savings; retirement has not been a part of
my monthly bill cycle. How can I change

written since the

and he says "I'm writing more than I've
ever written, I'll pick up the fiddle, or the

ings. "You know, those of us who did this

my office

that had been

revolution called Nicaragua Presente

trained

a

college, get up and teach

at the

lected

a

I

it

for 30 years."

Alice Gerrard

is a

musician and founder of the
in 1987, and founding

Old-Time Music Group
editor of the

Old-Time Herald magazine.

has recently retired from the editorship

magazine

in

order devote more time

to

She

of the

music

and family. She performs with Tom Sauberand
Brad Leftivich as "Tom, Brad &amp; Alice."

performs

lot, and is gone about 100 days

a

a pact I made with my family
effort to accomplish the impossible
feat of not only being able to make your
living [playing music] but also celebrate

a

year. "It's

in an

your 25th wedding anniversary; to have
kids that will actually talk to you for more
than two minutes on the telephone, and

you know your neighbors. I
all these songs that are
have to be in
about community life,
formed. And I like to garden, and I like to

to feel like

feel

if I'm

writing

I

fly fish.

do 'em.

I

have lots of hobbies and I like to
you told me right now, you'll

If

never have to step in another airplane,
that'd be pretty great."

�Breakin' Up Christmas!
The Curriculum,

Community
Project
Carolina Schools

Music

and

in North

By Ken Jackson

exciting day for me. Not only was Santa Claus coming, but our friends and relatives were coming to our house
Finally the people came for the party. The band called The Smokey Valley Boys played the music
ate
danced
and
I
danced
so much and ate so much that I suddenly got sleepy, though I couldn't fall asleep. I just sat
people
supper.
24,1 920, was

an

for the Breakin' Up Christmas party!

Decemberfloor
as

on the

and watched everyone else dance. Every one got tired but, they still kept right on a going. Finally the next morning came.
I don't have to
sleep on the cold floor. We also got to open our presents
I had lots
of fun with that doll. I will never ever forget the party we

We put the furniture back into the house. I was glad because I got my bed back. Now
this morning. We didn't get much. We each got one thing. I got a corn husk doll.

had the night before.

From

a

fourth grader's writing assignment, Cedar Ridge Elementary School, Surry County, North Carolina.

Christmas party was going
family farm
in Surry County, North Carolina. Four eld
erly musicians pulled up their chairs, got in
tune, and started playing-fiddle, banjo,
Once again,

a

on at the site of the old Clifton

guitar,

and

mandolin percolating away

while the floor filled with flatfooters.
Santy Claus come, done and gone,
Breakin' up Christmas right along.
Way back yonder, a long time ago,
The old folks danced the do-si-do.
The music careened along while the high-

spirited

partygoers danced, laughed,

talked, munched molasses cookies and
apple cider. When the music
stopped, everybody sat back down on the

sipped

gym floor

at

Cedar

Ridge Elementary

School. Teachers shushed the assembly of
fourth graders, and they listened to the

Smokey Valley Boys

Benton Flippen,

Bode, Paul Sutphin (who passed
away on August 26, 2003), and Verlen
Frank

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

reminisce about the twelve con
secutive days of "Breaking Up Christmas"
parties that would be held each winter of
Clifton

their

childhood, with the old-time music,

dancing and good cheer that the revelers
shared. As it happened, Cedar Ridge El

about the history of what they used to do

at

Christmastime

and how the tradition got
started in the area because our school is

right in Round Peak, where, you know, a
lot of this got started."
For a Round Peak-area school to invite

ementary has some pretty interesting con
nections to that old-time holiday tradition.
The school itself was built on land that
had been part of Verlen Clifton's family
farm, and one of the teachers attending the

the Smokey Valley Boys to perform for the
kids would seem to be a natural, and might
have happened in any case. But what went

party with her class was the Paul Sutphin

performance. Rather,

's

daughter Rhonda McHone. In the days
before, McHone had played the CD Blue
Ridge Mountain Holiday for her class. The
CD is an NPR radio program produced

narrated by Paul Brown, rich with
stories, reminiscences, and old-time mu
sic, and prominently featuring the fiddle
piece "Breakin' Up Christmas." "We lis
tened to the song and we learned the
words," McHone said, "and we talked
and

on at Cedar Ridge Elementary in

Decem

ber of 2001 was much more than an isolated
it was something that
came out of the innovative statewide Cur

riculum, Music, and Community project,
designed to bring local musicians and mu
sical traditions
with an emphasis on lo
cal
into schools. Not only would the stu
dents be exposed to live music and the
people from their community who made it,
but the teachers would craft the school
experience to make the learning of diverse
subjects more exciting and interesting, and

�strengthen a sense of community partici
pation in the schools.
The seed for the project was planted in
May of 1998 when Dr. Madeleine Grumet,
then the new dean at the University of
North Carolina's School of Education in
Chapel Hill, went on a faculty bus tour of
North Carolina. One of the stops was at the
venerable Ole Time Fiddlers' &amp; Bluegrass
Festival at Union Grove. Inspired by the
event, Grumet got the idea that North
Carolina's rich musical heritage might
to

somehow

be used to enrich the public school
curricula. She didn't have far to go to find
the right

person

to

work on the idea. Dwight

Rogers is a fine old-time banjo player liv
ing next door to Chapel Hill in Carrboro,
who with his wife, Gail Gillespie, has played

music for some 30 years with
as the Bucksnort Barn Dance
such
groups
Band, the County Commissioners, and the
New Southern Broadcasters. Rogers also
happens to be associate professor of edu
cation at UNC. "She [Grumet] knew that I
played the banjo and was interested in old

You're invited to

a

Breaking

up

Party

Christmas

Day: December 24th
Time: 10:00am until you can't dance anymore.
where:
The Morton Home Place
Directions:

3rd

on

old-time

Flippen

Bring your
will be

dancing

Rd,

we

Covered, dish. So

Bring

dwrch

white

house on right past snood
Can

chow down!

all

shoes.

The

Boys

mokey Valley

playing.

Ya'll

time music, and she just kind of laid it on
me. And so I immediately called Wayne
Martin [folklife director for the North

Come!

Carolina Arts Council] and Glenn Hinson
[chair of UNC's Folklore Curriculum."

became
co-directors.
project's
Coincidentally, around the same time,

Rogers and Hinson ultimately
the

Wayne Martin and the NC State Arts Coun
cil

had been conducting community meet

ings in western North Carolina to gather
ideas for the Blue Ridge Heritage Initiative.
During those meetings, residents of the

region said that they wanted their tradi
tional culture validated through public
school experiences, and that they wanted
long-time musicians deeply rooted in their
communities to bring those traditions into
the schools.
What

emerged from the discussions

Students

at Cedar

Ridge Elementary, Low Gap, NC, designed invitations
as part of the CMC project at their school.

both parents and community members-but also vice-versa, a way to take the kids
out to the

community,

so they can

under

stand more of their roots."
One of the things that distinguishes the
project is the way that

it

involves teachers

among Rogers, Hinson, Martin and com

in developing the curriculum. "We're not
creating lesson plans for them to teach;
they're co-constructing lesson plans with

tional music into schools is not a new idea,
they didn't want to create another 'artist in
the schools' program. "Instead of just bring

us and the artists." Rogers and his

munications professor Larry Grossberg,
was a unique vision. While bringing tradi

rators looked to
gram for

a

collabo
non-music oriented pro

a

model.

"I

guess the thing that

strangers
perform," Rogers said,
"we were as concerned about the stories

influenced me the most was the National
Writing Project. It's mostly run by teach

that came out of the music, and the people,
as we were with the actual aesthetic of the

ers, and there's

ing in

music and

to

the

musical

performances."

Rogers sees one of the major goals of the

a way to connect the com
munity and the school. "It becomes a ve
hicle for people to come back into schools,

project as being

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

to

a

"Breakin'

Up Christmas" party,

a

core group of teachers

who've been involved

in it for

They're not told what to
ideas and then they take

do--

a

long time.

they're given

and apply it. So
what's similar about that, too, is that this
project is school specific, site-specific, and
it

that's why we've been using this term

'local

music'
"
music.'

as

opposed

to just

'traditional

The project started out small in 1999. The
connection with the Blue Ridge Heritage

Initiative

led

to

mountainous Caldwell

County being chosen for a pilot project
with fourth grade teachers at Gamewell
Elementary School, located just south of
Lenoir. The fourth grade was chosen because
that grade's social studies curricu
lum focuses on North Carolina. In July of
that year, the project team met for a week at

Gamewell Elementary. Led by Rogers and

Hinson, the team included four Gamewell
teachers, other UNC faculty, staff from the
N.C. Arts Council and the N.C. Museum of
History, and the director of the Caldwell
Arts Council. The teachers met with blues
musician Etta Baker, old-time musicians
and potters Glenn

and Lula Bolick, and

(continued

on next

page)

�dancers

review the project's progress

to

and plan for each new year's activities. A
variety of old-time and roots musicians
and dancers participated in the

including flatfoot dancer

workshops,

Joe Sam Queen;

fiddler and banjoist Kirk Sutphin; fiddler
Eddie Bond; two-finger banjo picker A.C.
Overton; the classic Round Peak stringband
the Smokey Valley Boys; the bluegrass gos
pel duo of Tony and Gary Williamson; and
the African-American a cappella gospel

Sydney

Brown

singers the Badgett Sisters.
Following the summer workshops the
teachers returned to their communities and
their schools, full of ideas for how the project

(Benton Flippen, Verlen Clifton, Frank Bode, and the late Paul Sutphin)
fourth grade "Breakin' Up Christmas" party at Cedar Ridge Elementary School, Surry

The Smokey Valley Boys

play for

a

County, NC.

ballad singer-historian
all of

Bobby McMillon,

whom performed and discussed the

very concrete way the concepts of range,
median, and mode. The project also be
a

dents would bring examples of their own
favorite music to class, learn interviewing
skills, and practice those skills on each

vehicle for involving the children in
writing projects. Gamewell students used
newspaper stories from the Charlotte Ob
server to write ballads
like the one about
bears in Eastern North Carolina getting hit

experiences. The project would be high
lighted by a gathering of the children and

dents' oral communications and analytical
skills were honed in interviews with their

project with them. Over the week a plan
evolved for the 1999-2000 school year: stu

other. Then they would interview immedi
ate family members about their musical

their families for

a

visit and

a

performance

by Glenn Bolick. The children would then
go out into the community to interview

elders and collect music and stories from
them to share with their classes. And all the

activities would be tied to the North Caro
lina Standard Course of Study in social
studies, language arts, science, and math.

came

a

by cars on highways, or about the moving
of the Cape Hatteras lighthouse. The stu

parents about their musical tastes. At two
family nights during the year, students
sang, played instruments, emceed, and
ushered, helping with their performance,
leadership, and organizational skills. The
students' critical thinking skills were chal
lenged as they noticed and debated varia
tions in ways different musicians and sto

So

rytellers presented the same material. And
getting to the heart of what social studies is

music was woven into the core curriculum,
drawn into the central work of the school.
Teachers came up with a number of cre
ative ways to involve music in teaching the
standard subjects. Take math, for example.
Gamewell teacher Gretchen Griffith had
each of her students make a diddley bow, a
type of simple one-stringed instrument that
many traditional blues guitarists had

in part

rather than just being presented to the
students in limited special events, local

about
traditions and heritage
students and teachers both made new con
tacts in their communities and learned to

might be implemented. Back at Cedar Ridge
after the 2001 workshop, McHone and other
teachers planned for activities and lessons
during the term that included a visit by a
local harmonica player, square dancing,
and the Breakin' Up Christmas activities

culminating

in the

Smokey Valley Boys'
performance in December. McHone's di
rect family and community connection to
old-time music made the Smokey Valley
Boys a perfect choice for an artist visit, and
the "Breakin' Up Christmas" theme was a

natural, too. "It just dawned on me one day
about how you could use that story, or use
the tradition that they talked about in our

classroom," McHone said. "And so we
worked on that, we compared traditions
now to traditions then, and then we had
them [the Smokey Valley Boys] to come in
and play the song, and talk about how

Christmas was when they were children."
McHone wove "Breakin' Up Christmas"
into her lesson plans. "We did some graphic
organizers where the kids had to do com
parisons and contrasts of Christmases long
ago and Christmases now." For fourthgrade narrative writing, she had her pupils
imagine that it was Christmas back in 1920,
and write

a

two-page paper about

it.

"They

had to pretend that they were a child back
then, and what they did to prepare the
house, and then they had to write about the

party, and they had to write about the
"
Christmas the next morning. McHone also

identify local artists.
The seminal experiences of the Gamewell
teachers were shared with other teachers
during summer and winter workshops and
conferences as the program expanded into

incorporated the theme into her social stud
ies lessons. "Some people think that "Break
ing Up Christmas" dated back to the time

schools

started out on as youngsters. She then had

in Ashe, Caldwell, Durham,
Haywood, Orange, Surry and W ilson coun

talking about slavery in North Carolina in
social studies."

ties over the next four years. At those con
ferences the participating teachers joined

and plot on paper the length of each one
from shortest to longest
thus learning in

with the CMC's academic and Arts Coun
cil faculty and with musicians, singers, and

After four years of such experience by
teachers and students in the six partici
pating county school systems, anecdotes
and comments by teachers, students, and

her pupils measure their bows, all of differ
ent lengths, calculate the range for the lot,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

of the Civil War and the

slaves," she said,

"so we talked about that because we were

�dents, and several of them
from Cedar Ridge started

go

ing. Now he comes to Cedar

Ridge every other Wednes
day, and a lot of the fourth

on their own, and have already written grants

spark an

interest

it." In fact, four

in

of the six

counties participating

in the

CMC project paid for instru

ments

lessons

music

and

with grant money provided
by the North Carolina Arts
Council to local arts councils

Sydney

Brown

as

succeeding

point out that the project is
in ways that were hoped for by

its

to

instigators.
making gains
across subject

Teachers report students
in academic performance
areas, and some students
have a difficult time with

who normally
academics responding positively to the
CMC project activities. "Some students who
are otherwise bored with school perk up
when the music is introduced to their les
sons," Rogers said. "There's no doubt that
[the kids] are writing more. They write
thank-you notes to the musicians; about
the songs they sing, invitations to the mu
sicians to come. .so there are real opportu
nities to write about something meaning

common theme in
teachers' reports, whether as increased
awareness of and pride in the music and
traditions of the elders in their communi
ties, or in students working together "like a
ful."

Community

is

a

family," and more of a community atmo
sphere developing in the participating
schools.
Perhaps it's not surprising that some of
the kids have developed a keen interest in
the music itself. McHone says that a num
ber of her students took to the music enough
to want to learn to play it. "Jimmy
he lives in Low Gap and has
Vipperman
a violin
in
Mount Airy has gotten a
shop
grant to hold jam sessions every Thursday.
He provides the instruments for the stu

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

part of the Junior

Appa

of the teachers have said that they'll
to

continue

cover some expenses.
Because of the wealth of traditional

mu

North Carolina, most of the music
brought into schools so far has been that of
sic in

old-time, bluegrass, and other roots musi
cians. As the program evolves, musicians
representing other traditions or forms of
local music may be brought into schools.
"Around here [Chapel Hill] they might
bring in a garage band, because it's a musi
cal form that's

represented in this area,"

lachian Musicians project.

Rogers said. Or teachers may invite hip-

Rogers believes that the
kids are challenged to look

hop or conjunto musicians in counties where

in

parents seem

a

at the

music.

of local

three that doing the banjo,

helped

the Smokey Valley Boys' old-time

UNC Chapel Hill with the par
musicians like the Gos
ticipation
W
illiamson Brothers Alice
the
ubilators,
J
pel
at

Gerrard and the Deer Clan Singers. In anticipa
tion of the inevitable end of this funding, some

and several that doing the
guitar. I think that [CMC]

to

institute

graders participate. So I have
three or four in my class that
are doing the fiddle and two
or

Children dancing

and four more schools. The expansion be
gan with a successful 2003 summer teacher

music and musicians

new ways. "It's definitely

made music more real to kids

those are important musical forms.
In a state where old-time music has an

illustrious history and is still a real if not
pervasive presence in the lives of some

in terms of a human en
think, because of the notes I've
seen them write to the musicians. It's also
changed their minds about what they think

communities the CMC project has in
jected the music into the school curriculum

for example, one of the posters
corny
[drawn by the students] in Ashe County
was 'Square Dancin' Rocks!' And I think
it's introduced them to people of another

in

deavor,

I

is

that they just

wouldn't other

generation
wise have been introduced

to in

school."

The project had been planned to sustain
itself by drawing music and dance into the

central work of each participating school,
developing relationships with local neigh

bor-musicians, and by developing com
munity support and understanding of the
project. Yet even with all of its reported
successes, the continued existence of the
CMC project is not guaranteedtin an era of
budget crises and diminished funding for
the arts.

Over the next two years funding came
from a variety of sources. In 2001 a major
grant from the NEA allowed expansion of
the project and the hiring

of

a

nered continuing support for the next two
years from the Z. Smith Reynolds Founda
tion and again from the NEA, allowing its
to

include about

20

ways that are fundamentally different

from more typical presentations by artists

schools. Although promoting old-time
music is not its primary mission, the project
exposes many kids to the music in a less

passing and more engaging way. In places
like Surry County, elders who still carry
the traditions of earlier generations can
share their histories, culture, and musical

sensibilities with the schoolchildren. The
kids can get to know the local music and
musicians that they otherwise may not
encounter. And some of the kids are stimu
lated to learn to play banjos and fiddles and
guitars themselves, to learn the old tunes
and styles, to get the sounds and the stories
in their heads. If it does nothing else, the

CMC project may help to assure that oldtime music continues in some way to be a
vital part of the local cultural life in some

North Carolina communities.

full-time

coordinator, Sydney Brown. That same
year, the North Carolina Arts Council
committed funding to support artist visits
to participating schools. When NCAC was
unable to fund it further, the project gar

expansion

in

more teachers

Kenny Jackson is best known for his award
winning old-time fiddling though he is also a
banjo player and guitarist. He is a
sought-after teacher of traditional music. Kenny
makes his home in Fayetteville, NC and per
forms with Big Medicine.

singer,

�at the Todd Store

Music

Makin'

Sawyer
Morgan

by Tammy

Tammy

Sawyer

and Joe

Jam Session

call

at the Todd

it

"makin'

General Store.

mu

sic," an accurate portrayal of
the

dozen

or

more musicians
to play old

who congregate
Old-timers

time music

at

Todd General Store on Fri

day nights. The store was founded in 1914
and is on the National Register of Historic

Located between Boone and
Jefferson in northwest North Carolina, it is
Places.

sound of fiddles and
setting
the
visitor back to an
dancing feet, taking
time.
earlier simpler
an ideal

Musicians

for the

Troy

McGuire and Sam

Gobble were instrumental in organizing
the jam sessions that began in the spring of
2000. Since the jam's unpretentious in

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Playing

are (l-r) Troy Mccjuire, Sam Gobble,

ception, the general store has become

a

favorite gathering place for musicians and
listeners alike. A forum has been estab
lished for sharing and preserving old time
fiddle tunes and songs from the 1920s and
earlier that have been passed down from

generation

widely

to

generation.

known

pickers

Frequently,
Wayne

like

Henderson, Helen White, Cecil Gurganus,
Alex Hooker, Mark Rose, Steve Kilby, and
several others join McGuire and Gobble in
the mix. However, it's not about who is the
best.

It is

the love of traditional music and

determination to keep it alive that are
most important. Talented university stu
dents Justin Stiles picking guitar, Wayne
the

and Fred McBride.

Woods hammering notes on the banjo, and
mountain dulcimer player Dustin Sechrest
of Todd represent the younger generation
that enthusiastically join the Friday night
fun. Sometimes fiddlers as young as eight
show up, one from as far away as Montana,
and the musicians patiently allow them to
practice a few tunes, encouraging them to
continue the tradition. Perhaps one day
they will be passing down their knowl
edge to the next generation of aspiring

musicians.

An interesting point about
is that it's not

a

a

jam session

show, so you don't know

or how many will be
playing until they arrive. Throughout the

which musicians,

�evening musicians file into the store with
instruments in hand prepared to join the
group. A jam session often has musicians
of various skill levels, and old time music
allows for both experts and beginners to
play together. It can sound like an orches
tra with lots of fiddles, several banjos and
guitars, a mountain dulcimer, a mandolin
and uprightbass. Other nights it's a smaller
group, allowing for more singing from
within the circle. To the delight of the lis

teners,
of his

the

as

Henderson

progresses

evening

pick some
favorite tunes on one of his fine hand
is

usually induced

to

made guitars. The jam attracts pickers and
visitors from near and far. Musicians come
from many different North Carolina coun
ties, as well as southwest Virginia and east
Tennessee. There have been several visi

Hol
Switzer
land, Hungary, Germany, Tibet,
tors from other countries, including

land and Italy.

Frequent visitors Deborah Jean Sheets, a
teacher at Watauga High School, and Helen
White, a counselor with the Alleghany
County school system, are also doing their
parts in keeping traditional music alive.
Both work with interested students at their

respective schools teaching old-time tunes
at after school programs.
The old-time music at the Todd Store
makes people want to move and on any
given Friday night, several local residents
are ready to dance and kick up their feet to

the beat. Starting at about 6:30, between 50
and 100 listeners begin to filter in and out of
the store. They sit by the wood stove, on
handmade benches around the old wooden

counter,

or

stand between the shelves of

groceries and homemade jams and honey.
Visitors and residents come for commu
nity fun and fellowship and to appreciate
the music and musicians.

Families with

small children and the elderly show up and
leave early, while others show up a little
later and stay till the music ends, some
times as late as 1:00. It is a wholesome,

clean, fun atmosphere enjoyed by all ages,
providing a chance to visit with neighbors,
hear the latest news, and make new friends.
All the musicians

expressed thanks to
former store owner Joe Morgan for encour
aging the formation and continuation of
the jam. He is also the driving force behind
establishing a weekly summer concert se
ries in Todd that remains extremely popu

your grandma, bring your friends, or bring
your instrument and join the old-time com

munity jam session!

Tammy Sawyer

is a

musician and biologist
NC and is a frequent

a

from Wilkes County,
attendee of the Todd jam session. She believes

CD by many of the Todd jammers, which is
available at the store. If you are ever in the

people really like old-time music, but they just

lar. He also

supported

vicinity of Todd,

the recording of

North

Carolina, bring

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

what Riley Baugus once told her, that most
don't know

it.

�and the

The African Akonting
Origin of the Banjo

Ulf Jägfors

Ulf

Jagfors

by

Patron Correa, of the Manjago ethnic group in Amon, Guinea-Bissau,
plays a three-string buchundi, a close relative of the akonting, 2003.

over 40 years I have been fascinated
with the American banjo-especially

For

its African history. Though I had long
been playing banjos and had accumu

lated

a

large collection--

picking up different

stringed instruments during my frequent trav
world-by mid-1980 I began to
take banjo playing more seriously. Soon I was

els around the

hooked on minstrel banjo music, inspired by an
a CD) issued
by Bob Winans, The
Early Minstrel Show. That led to an increas
ing interest in learning more about the origin of
the banjo and its related music. In the early

LP (now

attended the first Maryland Banjo
Academy and learned about gourd banjos
nineties

I

video made by the late Theo Lissenberg
of gourd banjo workshop with Clark Buehling,
the late Scott Didlake, and Mike Seeger, re

through

a

a

corded at the 1992 Tennessee Banjo Institute.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

When

I

entitled

attended

the

first banjo conference

"Before

the

in

Banjo"

1997

in

Charlottesville, Virginia, my interest was fur
ther spurred when I had a chance to see and talk
to scholars on the subject like Dena Epstein,
Bob Winans, Cece Conway, joe Ayers, Ed Britt,

Mike Seeger, and many more.
to

discover--

It is therefore amusing
after
traveling the world in the pursuit of my banjo

interest--

which

I

that much valuable information for
had been

searching for

was readily available all along

so
in

many years

working

in

Stockholm since the '80s. Mr. Jatta,

who was born

of

in the Jola

village
Mandinari
in Gambia, had studied economics as a gradu
ate student in the United States from 1974-83.
While there he became aware of the American
banjo and was immediately struck by the

instrument's similarity to a gourd-bodied in
strument found among his own Jola people that
akonting. When I saw and heard
an akonting at that lecture in 1999 I too was
struck by its resemblance to the banjo.
he

my own back

knew

as the

The story

I

will relate

to

you in this article is
I am sure that

yard here in Sweden. The key to unravelling
some of the secrets of the origin of the banjo lay,

certainly not the entire truth and

for me, in a chance meeting with a banjo enthu
siast born and raised in West Africa but who

ans.

lived

in

Sweden.

In

1999

I

attended

a

lecture on

the African origin of the banjo. The speaker was
Mr. Daniel Jatta, an economist who had been

it

will spur further debate among banjo histori
I believe that it adds interesting and worth

while information

about

the

mystery

origin of banjo and its relationship

to

of the

existing

African instruments.
--Ulf Jägfors, Tyreso, Sweden

�Rogers
by Nora
Drawn

Map of western Africa and the home of the Jola people.

Most music historians agree that the fore
runner of the banjo came from Africa
most likely from West Africa carried to
the New World on board slave ships in the
17th through 19th centuries. The African

musicians who played the gourd-bodied
instruments that were the banjo's ances
tors probably came from the part of West
Africa that stretches from the part of the

continent encompassed by modern Senegal
and Gambia southward to Nigeria and also
eastward into what we now call the Sahel
(the broad arid region just south of the
Sahara dessert that stretches eastward
across the continent). Arabic manuscripts
indicate that lute-like instruments have

been played in this region for at least 700
years
very likely even earlier than that

of

emerging over such an enormous region
especially if you think about how difficult
and slow the means of communication were

These few ethnic groups may well have
been responsible for the spread of the banjo
like instruments over the whole New World
From which area and from which instru

at the

time. One theory for this rapid spread

that many of the slave ships began to
bring musicians on board for the two-month
is

New World. They were cap
tured so that the slave could receive exer

voyage

to the

cise by being forced to dance on deck. By
this means, the slave traders hoped to re

duce the death toll during the crossings.
Once the slaves arrived at their destina
tions, the poor survival rate continued. The
slave owners realized that they needed to
keep better care of their slaves. Since drums

were not allowed, for fear of communica

since oral traditions indicate that lute playing
goes back to the ancient Ghana Empire, which

tion, dancing and banjos became accepted
forms of entertainment and developed all

disappeared in the 11th century.
During a relatively short period of time

over the region.

from the 1650s to the 1850s contemporary

observers recorded that the slaves in the
New World danced to the music of a gourdbodied lute instrument called variously
banza, banjer, or bangoe. Their descrip
tions come from a huge region encompass
ing northern South America through the Car
ibbean archipelago, and up to the southeastern
states of America.

It is

truly remarkable that

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

musicians from just a few ethnic groups
related ethnic groups within one region.

simultaneously we see the same type of
instrument with about the same name

The fact that practically the same name
shows up all
banza, banjer and bangoe

over the region also indicates that there

common origin. This suggestion
might
is particularly strong if you consider the
great number of ethnic groups and lan
guages represented by African peoples that
werebrought to the New World. That there
was a common name for the instrument
indicates that there might have been a group
be

a

or

West Africa did the banjo de
my opinion, most likely the first
velop?
and probably main areas were the regions

ments

in

In

surrounding the modern countries of
Senegal, Gambia, Guinea-Bissau, and
was from this part of Africa that
the slave trade began to the New World.

Guinea.

It

An estimated number of 500,000 slaves
were deported from just these areas be
tween 1650 to around 1810. This is a small
portion of the estimated number of all Afri
can people taken as slaves to the New World

(almost 12 million) during the time period.
African Lute Family Instruments
Eric Charry, who is a professor of music

Wesleyan University, is an expert on
traditional musical instruments of West
at

Africa. In his articles and in his book about
West African stringed instruments, Mande
Music, Charry gives very detailed descrip
tions of the historical background of the
many lute and harp instruments in this
region. In the West African Sahel and Sa

vannah areas

as

well

as

along the coast,

(continued on next page)

�originates from the

Arabic-Egyptian
"longneck lute," the
tambur. These in
struments, have dif
ferent names in dif
ferent ethnic groups.

construction,

The

size, and number of

strings

the short neck types

Ulf

Jagfors

with

names like
xhalam (also spelled
xalam and pro

nounced "halam"),
ngoni, and koni.

Arabic "traveling
salesmen" and Jihad
conquests probably

there was

a

dizzying variety

of

skin-head,

plucked, lute-like instruments with gourd
bodies. Charry's system of classification
helps sort out the large numbers of instru
ments by putting them into four categories
based on construction and playing style.
1.

Internal Spike (short dowel stick) lutes with

oval

body

of ivood-( koni,

xhalam/ngoni/

all four basically the same in
kontingo
strument), the molo and gurkel.
2.

this family of instruments to
West Africa during the Middle Ages. We

introduced

know that an Arabic writer visiting the
court of the Mali Empire around 1350 de
scribed it. The professional musician and
verbal artists calledGriots exclusively play
such lute-like instruments with fan shaped
bridges. The word griot is of French origin;
in

Arabic translation, the artists are known

as Jalis.

Internal spike (short dowel stick) lutes with

griot/jali "internal spike" lute in
is built around a hollow piece of

The

round gourd body -instruments of this type
include the molo (with a gourd body),

strument

konde and kabula. Both types of internal
spike lutes (wood body &amp; gourd body)
have a bridge attached to the neck through
the skin head. The neck (dowel stick) stops
inside the body and is held in position by
the skin head and the tension of the
strings. The neck is about one foot long
and round, the strings attached by
twisted leather strings.

skin

a

Internal pass-through-body dowel stick lutes
with a round gourd body-ihe distinction is
3.

that, unlike the above, in this type of instru
ment the bridge rests on the skin head The
long neck is made of a type of "bamboo"
papyrus grass that grows in the area. Ex
ample: akonting, buchundi and entofin.
Harp lutes like the kora, a griot (more
later on griots) instrument, and simbi, donso

4.

dgoni, kamale ngoni. These show up in a
different in social context from the preced
ing instruments and are played in a differ
ent manner. They are hunters' and griot
instruments they have a dowel stick that

wood,

or in rare

covers

the

cases

a

gourd. An animal
A round

hollow part.

wooden stick forms the neck. There

are one

seven strings attached to the neck held
by leather rings. The upper short string is a
to

drone string, like the banjo. The next two

melody strings, which are fret
strings
ted with the left hand. The lower short
strings, one to four are all additional drone
are

strings. A typical playing technique that
have video recorded from
jali and

a

a

I

Gambian, Wolof

Mali, Mande jali shows the fol

lowing playing pattern: Up-picking of the
melody on the two fretted long strings,
brushing down with the back of the nails
over all the strings; and sounding the upper
short string with the thumb. This is the only
playing technique have been able to video
so far. However, jali instruments with fewer
strings: one, two or three string instruments
I

seem to mostly be played with the back of the
nails in a stroke style. This method is also
sometimes used for other North African lute

gourd body and they are

instruments such as sinter and gumbri.
The biggest difference in construction
between the so-called "internal spike" lutes

One of the most widespread and wellknown internal spike lute types probably

and today's banjo is in the way the neck is
attached to the body of the instrument. In

passes through
played like harps.
a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

and
is part of it
the end of the neck
projects upward through a hole in the skin.
The strings are also attached to the end of
the neck. The fact that the bridge does not
rest on the skin makes

it totally indepen
influence on the skin
head. Smart guys, weren't they? The disad
vantage is that the instruments constructed
in this manner lose volume and therefore
are more suited for accompaniment with

dent of weather's

also vary.

Most common are

Daniel Jatta with his akonting.

"internal spike" lutes the neck is actually
attached to the skin head itself and it ends
about two-thirds of the way onto the lower
part of the body. The bridge is attached to

singing. According to Eric Charry, jali lute
music may also show influences from Ara
bic music. Yoh can hear short sound and video
clips of players of jali lutes on Charry's wonder
ed]
ful website: echarry.web.wesleyan.edu/
As a whole, however, the "internal spike"

lutes are not very similar construction or
playing style to the American banjo in the
Southeast. This is relevant if we consider

written documentation through the popu
larity of minstrel music from the 1850s to
the 1860s as an indication of how AfricanAmericans might have built banjos and
played them. We have to remember that all
early minstrel players claim that the music
they played and the banjos they used came
from the African American population. The
style and form of their instruments is quite
different from modern African "internal
spike" lutes. Despite this, until recently,
the primary candidate generally put forth
as ancestor of the American banjo has been
this

widespread and well known West Af

"internal spike" jali lutes.
And, until recently, most scholars had over
rican family of

looked a picture of an African instrument
described as an ancestor to the banjo in Pete
Seegers' book How to Play the Five String
Banjo. The instrument shown in his book
has different and far more banjo-like con
struction than the jali lutes. The picture in
his book had been given to Pete by the late
Melville Herskovits, a noted musicologist

Northwestern University

Evanston,
Illinois. Where he got this picture that he
claimed was the African prototype for the
at

in

banjo has not been sorted out yet, and Pete
Seeger says he does not know. The more I

learned

as

I

became interested

in banjo

history, the more I had a feeling that some
thing didn't add up when historians con
sidered that the described short-neck jali
lutes were the precursors of the banjo. The

playing technique, harmonies, and con
struction were not at all like banjos from
the New World, but up until 1999 and my

�banjo. The two other strings are fretted
melody strings. The only tuning used is the
a

following: the short drone string is like the
fifth string on the banjo; the middle string
same note as the first string; the
longest first string is the same as the third
string on the banjo. Though the heads are
now of goat or cow hide, they are said to
have originally been made from lizard
skins. The akonting looks exactly like the
is the

Africanbanjo ancestor Pete Seeger depicted

Ulf

Jagfors

in his

Jola master dancer

Nazer Sambo

in

action, accompanied

by

akonting and wood clappers.

Mandinari, Gambia, 2003

fortuitous meeting with Daniel Jatta and

tion.

Daniel Jatta and the Jola People

Daniel comes from one of the oldest re
corded West African ethnic groups, the
Jolas, who live in a part of Senegal in a
located along
region called Casamance-Casmance River which runs into the Atlan
tic south of Gambia River, stretching down
into the northern part of Guinea Bissau.
The Jolas belong to a group of people who
speaks Bak languages (bak means coast in
Mandinka). Other ethnic groups belong
ing to this language group are Manjagos,
Balantas, and Papel. They all live along the
coast and up the river valleys where they
grow rice, make palm oil and palm wine,
and raise hogs. The hogs are significant
culturally since these are people that have

resisted Islam until recently. This has iso
lated them from the outer world and from
their Islamic neighbors to a large extent,
and their old traditions have survived more
strongly than in other nearby ethnic groups
that have embraced Islam.

The Akonting

Returning to the lecture that I attended
Daniel Jatta told us that his father
a
played lute instrument, which was called
in 1999,

akonting

and that

nails and use the thumb to pick up the short
"drone"
as
do
American
string
clawhammer players. Even if African
Americans in the past might have used

"up-picking" on the banjos in certain areas,

my introduction to the akonting, there was
no better theory about the African connec

the

book 40 years ago.

Another remarkable thing is that the play
ing technique is pure down-stroke
"clawhammer" technique. The Jolas play
with the back of the long or index finger

it

was one of the

Jolas' oldest instruments. During his stay
in the United States Daniel had come in

Africa in 1985 he was eager to learn more
about the rare instrument. His father, who
played it himself and knew of other play
ers, obtained an akonting for his son and
taught him to play. In the following years,
Daniel began to search out players of the
instrument and in 1995 began videotap
ing players of the akonting on location

in

West Africa.

between the

akonting and the banjo? First, the akonting
always constructed with a large gourd as
body instead of a hollow piece of wood.
The available pictures showing banjos in
the New World
show us that all of
is
a

a

a

more commonly played style on the

banjo by the white minstrel players. This
guitar style was later transferred to "classi

playing. Many believe that clas
sical banjo playing developed during the
(continued on next page)
cal" banjo

bash/gourd

body. As it does
on a banjo, the
neck
of
the
akonting pierces
through the gourd
body and the
bridge rests on the
skin head. The
akonting of today
has
generally
three strings but

earlier, perhaps,
four strings. The
upper one is con

"drone" string in

Jules Ekona Jatta, is

larities between the banjo and the Jola
akonting. When Daniel went back home to

the same way as is
the fifth string on

music festival

Ulf

Jagfors

contact with the American banjo and

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

imitating the black players. The white
people called it "stroke style." The Jola
people in Senegambia call it "o'teck" which
means "to stroke the akonting." Not until
around 1860 did the up-picking style be

cala

siderably shorter
than the others
and is used as a

it was
there that he was first struck by the simi

banjo instruction books from the 1850s and
'60s and white minstrel banjo players were

come

What are the similarities

them had

it's only the down stroke style of playing
that we see in a number of early minstrel

in

a

Jola master

akonting player. Here

Banjul, Gambia, 2002.

he

plays

at a

�Ulf

Jagfors

Detail from a drawing by Hans Sloan of a two or three-string gourd "strum-strum," Jamaica, circa 1700 (center). Compare the shape of the strum
strum with the modern folk lutes from Mali (left) and Cameroon (right).

1920s and '30s into three-finger picking,
which became the groundwork for bluegrass banjo playing.
There are further clues which strengthen
the theory that the akonting really is the
most likely father of the minstrel banjo. In
addition to the fact that the instrument is
constructed like a banjo, we asked about
the name "banjo." Daniel Jatta has a theory
that has attracted some attention. The neck
of the akonting is made of a local species of
papyrus plant, which is as strong as the
Asian bamboo. In the Mandika language
this plant is called "bangoe." Daniel con
tends that the instrument has gotten its
name from its neck.
When Samuel Charters visited Gambia

around 1980

to

collect information for his

book The Roots of The Blues, he recorded a
song by one of the most prominent

Mandinka jalis, Alhaja Fabala Kanutheh.
The song contains the story of how the
Portuguese, in the 15th century, came to
Gambia to buy slaves. One sentence, in this
rather long song, issued on a Folkways LP,
is interesting. In Samuel Charters' transla
tion and spelling

it

goes like this:

"And they came to this place and they
found people cutting the sticks they called
'bang'

and

the

Europeans

asked them,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

'What are you cutting?' and they said they
were cutting the sticks called 'bangjolo,'
and the Europeans wrote down the name."
The name of the capital city in Gambia is
Banjul that means the island where the

bang "papyrus" grows and where the first
Portuguese people met the inhabitants.
There are some interesting circumstances
within the Jola group pointing toward the
fact that they as a group were affected by
the slave trade. In the past, as now, the Jola

celebrate the completion of a large task by
gathering under the palm trees at nights in
order to play instruments like the akonting
and drums, drink palm wine, get drunk,
and make a lot of noise. Because the Jolas

lived along the coastline and close to the
harbors which were built by the Europeans
and from where the slaves were shipped,
such festivities made them easy prey for
the slave traders, who needed musicians
on the ships. When Daniel started to play
the akonting his grandparents warned him
not to play the instrument in the jungle,
because if he did the devil could take him
and he would never come home again.
Daniel says that Jola drummers, even to
day, refuse to play outside the area of the
village. Other Jola akonting players in
Senegal and Gambia told me that the eld

warned people never to
in the jungle if they
saw footprints of white men's shoes. Until
formal schooling became more universal
erly generation

play the instruments

in the 1950s, the Jola

oral

transmission

people depended on
group's history.

of the

Because of this, there are still such stories
200 years after the slave trade ceased in this
region.
There are

a

few other clues that point to

the importance of the influence of the Jola
ethnic group. Sambo and Juba 0ibba) are
very common last names in the Jola ethnic

group. Banjo authority Bob Flesher writes
in his book Origin of Negro Minstrels, that he

found the following notice in
newspaper from around 1850:

a

New York

"In the

1840s

when Negro Minstrel shows were form
ing, there were very few black performers
to put on a show because most were en
slaved. I have found only one, a black man
nicknamed Juba who was a dancer in New
Y

ork City and

undisputedly the best dancer

around." "Juba"
strel tune or

a

way

is

of

also

a

name of

performing

a

a

min

minstrel

tune. With the earlier mentioned note from

New York

I favor a
theory that it originates
from the Jola last name.
In spite of the above facts, some scholars
still believe that the short-neck lute could

�have contributed to some part

have had an impact

of the

development of the banjo.
And I agree. But I am not so

on the

sure that it was the jali instru
ments that influenced banjo de

theory seriously and
will concentrate part

velopment.

I

believe that were

years ago,

masse

to the

in

transported
New World. In my

lays in America and
hope some of the
banjo experts will con
tinue their work trac

I

Ulf

Jagfors

ing as much evidence

a member
of the Jola ethnic group from Guinea-Bissau now living
Gambia.
He
Banjul,
plays a three-string akonting that he built, in his palm leaf
shed on the beach outside Banjul, 2002.

Esa Jesus Jarju,
in

cieties in West Africa. That is in contrast to
nearly all other types of folk stringed in
struments. These are now on the brink of

extinction and some of them have probably
already vanished forever and we have very
little record of their existence. It is possible
that this is because in the past so many folk
musicians playing such instruments were
captured

as

slaves, but more probably their

disappearance

is the

about

much of the work here

ships. There were such no other
jali instruments available, apart
from the Jola akonting lutes.
It is also remarkable to find

and balafons are in good condi
tion and flourish in today's so

trying to find more

this possible alterna
tive development. But

opinion there must have been
some other kind of more com
monly used folk instrument that
allowed the slave traders to find
enough musicians to take on the

ternal spike" lutes, kora harps,

of

take this

information

en

that all jali instruments from
the past such as short-neck "in

I

of my future research

not enough available jalis, 200
to be

development

the banjo.

result of the ongoing

influences from Islam in the region. Most
of the jali musicians probably remained in
Africa with their instruments and were
accepted by the Muslim societies, as their
music was part of the Jali/Griot tradition
that praised Allah, kings, and warlords.
Only among ethnic groups that have re
sisted Islam has there been preservation of
some part of the old traditions and culture.
A few

examples of such groups are the
earlier mentioned "bak" language ethnic
groups like the Jolas, Manjagos, Pepel and
Balantas.
What do we know about West African

picture of the two string banjos (strumstrum) that Hans Sloan described and drew
around 1700 in Jamaica. Very little is known
about the use of most of the other folk lute
instruments in West Africa and I fear that it
is perhaps too late in some cases to really
find any more information about these
ancient musical traditions However, apart
from the Jola akonting lute the other "bak"

language groups

difference

tuning and the way of
I have seen and video
recorded Manjago buchundi players who
just strum the strings with the thumb or
pinch the strings with two fingers. The

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

is in the

Balanta people told me that they played the
buchundi the same way as the jalis play the
xhalam or ngoni, that is, a type of strum
that is similar to the technique Pete Seeger
made popular through his banjo instruc
tion manual.
Several knowledgeable banjo historians,
have pointed out that there could possibly
ment

fingers. On the previous page is a picture of
one such lute from Cameroon and also a

people, Manjagos,

playing the buchundi.

be

gourds for the body, and the bridges are
cylinder shaped and not fan shaped as are
the jali instruments. They normally have
fewer strings, one to three, and the necks
are sometimes much longer. Many of them
are also played with a plectrum not the

of

Balantas, and Papel have a nearly indentical
instrument they call the buchundi. The

ber of folk lute instruments

same principle as the jali instruments. The
main difference is that they always use

as

possible. George

Gibson from Kentucky

hasdoneagreatjobhere.
I will do what I can from
the African side.

Search
for
Akontings and Akonting Players in Africa
The

folk instruments other than the jali lutes?
According to Eric Charry there are a num
built on the

supporting this theory

an

alternative early banjo develop

the use of multiple tunings; several
drone strings and up-picking
because this
is

something

that has been

documented

in

I had
the first chance in 25
return
to
Gambia.
This time I joined
years
Daniel Jatta, my local guide and organizer

In July 2002
to

venue that was
held in the capital Banjul. We spent a lot of
time video-recording as many akonting
of the "Origin of the Banjo"

players as we could find, but we also made
a recorded and interviewed the best xhalam
player from the Wolof ethnic group in
Gambia, Abdullah Seine, a jali. He played
a number of tunes for us in a
very typical
up-picking style, brushing down and not
ing the drone string, and stated that this
was the only way the xhalam is played. We

were also able to record

a
couple of Jola
akonting players. Esa "Jesus" Jarju played
a blues for us that sounded like an early
version of a 12-bar blues. It turned out to be
a modern
composition by him. But the

most astonishing experience for me was
the meeting with the nine-person song and
dance group, Si Jambukan De Saful (Trans
lation: "We play even if people think we
are nothing.")The group came from the

Casamance area in Senegal and they only
speak a little bit of French and the local Jola
dialect. Four of them have the last name
Sambo. The music they performed stunned

the Southern mountain areas for many gen
erations. Influences for this line of develop

me because

ment could have come from African lutes
other than the Jola akonting. So far I have
found it harder to find much direct evi

of the

dence supporting this theory. But it seems
plausible that other type of lutes and lute
harp instruments from West Africa also

it

was close to old-time Ameri

can minstrel music

featuring the playing

akonting lutes and with call and

response singing. The group also performed
a dance, called Da Nick, which resembled
African-American flatfoot dancing, per
formed in a way that I imagine it might
(continued on next page)

�pour the water over yourself. But some
body had used the bucket as a toilet. I had
no shower that morning.
Later, when we had safely returned to
Gambia, we searched for and found the
only known family, Landing Jibba (Juba?)
in the village of Brikama, who played the
Jola folk harp named furakaf or simbi. The
furakaf is a six-string harp instrument with
a big half gourd for a sound chamber. It is
not fretted and its player sits on the floor

with the harp resting in front of him. One or
two other assistants beat the rhythm on the
gourd with a pair of sticks. I made some
good video recordings of their playing and
also brought home a furakaf harp.

Ulf

Jagfors

The experience that I gained during my
two trips to Senegal, Gambia and GuineaBissau has shown me the importance of

The central square of Amon, Guinea-Bissau. Amon
and has no modern amenities.

have been done in the slave quarters 200
years ago.
I was
even more surprised when they
a
played
song called "Sambo Mambo,"

which more

or

less is the same as the first

part of "Camptown Races." There went a
theory up in smoke that I have heard music

scholars express claiming that the distance
between the music tradition in Africa and
its development in America make it impos
sible to trace any individual tunes.
only say that they may be wrong.

I

I

can

now feel

that the distances are much smaller than

most people imagine. I am glad that I could
make some very good video recordings of

what experienced and I hope to able to
issue a CD and a video with the Jola music
within the near future
This past summer (2003), Daniel and
went back for the second time with the
intention of documenting the different
I

1

types

of

akonting

a

trip

points (because of guerilla activities and a
recent civil war). In Guinea-Bissau every
village had set up its own toll system, since

government had not paid the

salaries to the civil servants for more than
eight months. Every toll passing took hours
of

negotiations over

located deep

in the

forest

the fee. We lost

a

lot of

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

at the

total picture of musical ex

pression dancing, singing, harmonies,
instrument tunings, and playing tech
niques

not focusing narrowly on the de

of the banjo. Daniel Jatta and I
will continue to pursue our research in
West Africa and will try to follow all pos

velopment
time because of that problem.
After much difficulty we found

a

very

sible threads we find. By doing that, I be
it will be easier to understand what

remote village in the forest populated with
both Manjago and Balanta people. Sadly,
the Balantas had no buchundis available
because the only one had been destroyed
during a lively night session. In one of the
houses were the Manjagos lived we found
a very
old, half blind, man who had a
buchundi strung with wire from a mos

lieve

quito net door. (Haven't we heard about
that from the United States as well?) The

ing, and dancing may have had a major
impact on the birth of early minstrel music

old man played a couple of tunes for us,
using just the two outer strings. We also
recorded an interview with him about

his musical background. The language
was Manjago or the local Portuguese

Creole dialect.

Our overnight

lodgings

in the

only avail

able "inn" in one village in Guinea- Bissau
was rather primitive. The temperature in

around 105 degrees F and we slept on a
sheet of dirty madras covering on a con
crete platform as a substitute for a bed. The
local people were dancing in the restaurant
to modern Afro-pop until early morning.

a

the central

is

through south

very difficult journey. We had to
pass about 25 military and police check
was

tiny village

the concrete room with its straw roof was

in

ern Senegal down to Guinea-Bissau in or
der to find some Balanta people who played
the akonting's close relative, thebuchundo.
It

a

more

lute playing

detail. We also made

is

looking

When they quit, the local dog family started
a chorus of howling outside my room. When
the dogs stopped, all the roosters in the
village filled in. When I drifted off to sleep,
I was awakened
by a tickling sensation on
my face from the antennae of a three-inchlong red cockroach. The shower room was
fitted with a barrel of water and a bucket to

may have happened several hundred years
ago in America.

Here is a short summary of what
tried to say in my humble English:

The

Jola

akonting

is the

I

have

closest relative of

the American banjo we have seen so far.

The

people with their playing, sing

Jola

development of the drone gourd
found
in America.
banjos
The jali/griot musical tradition and its
instruments have been over-emphasized
by historians as likely precursors to the
development of the banjo and AfricanAmerican folk music.
Other folk music instruments like the
and the

buchundo, folk harps, gourd fiddles, and
gourd lutes with cylinder shaped bridges
may have had as important a role as the jali
instruments
The transition of the round-neck African
lute instruments to flat fingerboard and
peg-equipped banjos has not been clarified
and must be further investigated.
Today we have a much better picture of
what could have happened when Africans
brought the banjo's ancestors to America.
But the total historical truth will probably
never be revealed. As I write this Daniel
Jatta and

our

next

I

are in the

trip

to

process of planning
Gambia, Senegal, and

�Ulf Jagfors,

is

considered

an

expert

in

the

history of the banjo. He has a collection of some
70 banjos and banjo-like instruments. He is a
old-time band, Hawkins Backstep
where
he sings and plays banjo, tenor
Buddies,
and
harmonica.
He is also a member of
guitar,
member

in the

the American Folk music

Association, based

in

Stockholm, Sweden. Send questions and/or com
ments e-mail: ulf.jagfors@telia.com. Address.
9, S-135 52 Tyreso, Sweden
Daniel Jatta is an economist who now makes
his home in Sweden. He welcomes questions
and/or comments or booking for akonting per

Johan Mickels vag

formances. He may be contacted at the address
below: Daniel Jatta, Skollerstagatan 25, S-124

Ulf

Jagfors

65 Bandhagen,

Ulf Jagfors plays

a

Jola entofin type of

akonting

Guinea Bissau in the first weeks of July
2004. This time we hope to dedicate our
time to the investigation of short-neck lute
traditions within different ethnic groups,
looking at matters such as playing tech
nique and use of bird claws as picks. We
also want to document gourd fiddle play
ing and locate more akonting players in the
Casamance area. Anyone who is interested
can join us in our fieldwork.

private banjo museum

in his

in

Stockholm.

Books of interest:
Sinful Tunes and Spirituals, Dena
ISBN: 0-252-00520-1 (cloth)
0

J.

Epstein,

252 07150-6 (paper)

African Banjo Echoes

in

Appalachia:

Traditions, Cecelia Conway,

A Study of Folk

ISBN: 0-87049-893-2
That Half-Barbaric

Twang:

The Banjo hi

Ameri

Popular Culture, Karin Linn, ISBN:

can

252-01780-3 (252-06433-X,

U. of

111.

0-

Press)

Daniel Jatta is working actively to set up
a folk music center in Gambia to
preserve
some of the old musical traditions that are

Mande Music: Traditional and Modern Music

rapidly vanishing into the shadows. We
fear it is nearly too late in many cases. By
informing all the media in Gambia about
what we are doing, we have gained some
positive attention. As a white man, how

per) 0-226-10161-4 (cloth)
Many Thousands Gone: The First Two Centu

ever, my role is always questioned and, to
be more effective, the project must ulti
mately come to involve more local people
as well as those of African descent. Schol

from Slavery

research work from
arly support
American
institutions
should be of
any
and
would
be
most
welcome.
great help
Please contact me or Daniel Jatta for further

Dena

information.

April 1984
"West African Harps," Eric Charry, Journal
of the American Musical Instrument Society,

for our

For further

site:

of the Maninka and Mandinka of Western Af
rica, Eric Charry, ISBN 0-226-10162-2 (pa

ries of Slavery

in

North America, Ira Berlin,

ISBN: 0-674-81092-9 (paper)
With

Banjo on my Knee: A musical Journey

a

to

Freedom, Rex Ellis, ISBN: 0-

531-11747-2
Here are

a

few articles of importance:

"The Folk Banjo: A

documentary History,"
Epstien. Ethnomusicology, Vol. 19,
No 3 September 1975
"Senegambian Archetypes for the Ameri
can Folk Banjo," Michael T. Coolen, West
J.

ern Folklore,

reading, visit the gourd banjo

www.dhyatt.cm/history.html.

gourd banjo article by George Gibson
valuable complement to this article.

The
is a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

20, 1994

"Plucked Lutes
cal

in

West Africa: An Histori

Overview," Eric Charry, Galpin Society

Journal 49, 1996

Sweden.

�Workshop

Mandolin Questions
Smakula

of

come

questions

Here are the
the

answers

Q:

3
I

a

again.

a

standard Gibson style

cover. There are 12 hooks on the
8

almost one hundred years ago, however
not necessary to hook your strings

it is

around them.
play, my mandolin's strings pro
ringing sound between the bridge and

Q: When

give.

tailpiece and only
4

again

top mandolin questions and

My mandolin has

tailpiece with

up

and

horizontal hook and bring the loops wind
ing around a vertical hook to prevent the
loop's winding from slipping. [See photo]
The superior string manufacturing of the
twenty-first century makes those extra
hooks unnecessary. These hooks are on
brand new tailpieces as a holdover from

strings. What are the extra

When the above referenced tailpiece
was invented in the early 1900s mandolin E
and A strings were available as bulk wire.
A:

You would buy a length of wire long enough
for 2 strings and make your own loops. You

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a

a

I

the tailpiece. Is there

a

to

way

eliminate those

unwanted tones?
A: On

hooks for?

would then put the plain string loops in

duce

Gibson style tailpieces

I

glue on

a

The intended

you are playing. The rubber works signifi
cantly better than a piece of felt that is

commonly found on tailpieces.
Good ideas for eliminating those tones on
a Monteleone or Allen tailpiece had been
eluding me until recently when flipping
through the latest Elderly Instruments cata
log my eye was caught by the Webber
Wood Nymph. The Nymph is a small
damping device easily attached to the
strings between the bridge and the tail
piece.

could probably make some

You

thing like this, but for $15, let Sound To
Earth, the makers of Webber Mandolins,
do it for you.

a

tradi

tailpiece. Note the

rubber glued to the top edge of the tailpiece
dampen unwanted harmonic vibrations.

piece of rubber, cut from an old innertube,
to the front edge of the tailpiece. [See photo]
The string vibrations are absorbed by the
rubber and give you the tone of the notes

use of the extra hooks on

tional Gibson style mandolin

E. If

the tuner tells you the

E

note at the

to

12th

carefully move the bridgeaway
from the nut towards the tailpiece. If the E
at the 12th fret is flat, you need to move the
bridge towards the nut. Always check that
the open string is in tune before fretting
at the 12lh fret. When you have the E
fret is sharp,

string right on, set the
same manner.

G

string in the

If you have an older Gibson mandolin
with its original fretboard, I do not recom
mend setting the bridge to be in tune at the

12th fret. As discussed in these pages (see
OTH vol. 5, #2) older Gibson mandolin
fretboards are not in tune all the way up the

neck.

If

the bridge is set to be in tune at the
it will be 10 to 20 cents flat at

12th

fret, likely

the

3rd

fret.

I

recommend setting bridges on

in tune. Are tliere

these mandolins so that the intonation is

place by string tension. That makes them

correct at the 4th fret.
Tune the E string, then fret the E string at
the 4th fret. The tuner should read G#. Again,

Q; My nuindolin doesn

't

play
any adjustments that will cure my problem?
A; Most mandolin bridges are held in

movable.

bridge can be
bumped and when a mandolin bridge
moves a little it can create a big intonation

Occasionally

a

problem.
To set a bridge for correct intonation, make
sure the nut is set at the correct height and
the neck is straight. Install a new set of
strings, but only bring the E and G strings
to pitch. Using an electronic tuner, play the
E string open and tune it. Then fret the E
string

at

the

12th fret.

As the

12th fret is

octave, the tuner should register close

the

to an

when you have the
string

E

string set, tune the G
4lh fret. The tuner

and fret at the

should read B.
And now the answer you've been wait
ing for: A violin burns longer!

Bob

Smakula

is

a

musician and resident of

Randolph Co., WV. He is the proprietor fo
Smakula Fretted Instruments, specializing in
the restoration

instruments.

and sales of vintage stringed

Smakula

been repairing stringed instru
ments for over 30 years now (a scary
thought!). Over the years the most com
monly asked question from non old-time
musicians has been "What's the difference
between a violin and a fiddle?" but I'll
answer that one later.
Among mandolin aficionados a number
have

I

Bob

by Bob

�Classifieds

Musical Instruments
INSTRUMENTS

SALE. GUITARS:1949

FOR

Martin D-28, $7,000; 2000 Martin D-15, $500;1964
Martin 0-16NY, $1,650; BANJOS: 1930 Orpheum
#3 Special $2,450;
1909 A.C. Fairbanks

Tubaphone #3, flowerpot peghead inlay $3850;
1892 S.S. Stewart Universal Favorite $1,000; 1912
Fairbanks by Vega Imperial Electric $1,650; Re
cent left handed Whyte Laydie copy, $650;

MANDOLINS:

1957 Gibson A-40 $900; New
Breedlove Quartz with binding $1,000; Banjo
Ukes: Several from $150 to $450 and more. Bob

Smakula, Smakula Fretted Instruments, PO Box
882, Elkins, WV 26241, 304-636-6710, email;
smakula@meer.net
WORLD'S

LARGEST SELECTION-- New-

Used-Vintage

guitars,

banjos, mandolins,

archtops, wood &amp; metal body Dobros, Nation
als. Mandolin Brothers, 629 Forest Ave., Staten
Island, NY 10310. Free Catalog. 718-981-3226.
Call for no-charge evaluation of your vintage
fretted instruments.

Recordings, Books, Instruction
FOR SALE: 78 Auction list (37c SASE) Set sale
78 $2.00*, LP $2.00*, CD $2.00, Cassette

lists:

$2.00 ^refundable with purchases). Lots of bar
gains. DISC COLLECTOR, P.O. BOX 315,
CHESWOLD, DE 19936

WHEN THE CACTUS

BLOOM, the new
from Bob Bovee and Gail Heil on
IS IN

recording
Copper Creek features old-time cowboy songs,
Ozark tunes, and more. To order (CD only), send
$15.00 plus $2.00 shipping to Bob Bovee &amp; Gail
Heil, 18287 Gap Dr., Spring Grove, MN 55974.

FLATFOOTING

WORKSHOP

INSTRUC

TIONAL VIDEO by Ira Bernstein. 1-3/4 hours,
27 steps, beginning to advanced. Easy to follow.
Each step clearly broken down and taught. Also
includes 3 performed pieces. Step manual and
two different concert performance videos also
available. Inquire: 179 Flint St., Asheville, NC

DOWN IN LITTLE EGYPT, a new CD recording
Midwest fiddling at it's best.

by Churps Smith.

order: www.vigortinerecords.com

To

or 314-

432-0861.
OLD-TIME

MANDOLIN INSTRUMENTALS
Bros. 25

73 minutes long. CDs $15.00, cassettes
$10.00 plus $1.00 shipping. Make check payable

tunes,

Dennis Buckhannon. Write: The Buckhannon
St. Charles, MO 63302-6165.

Bros., PO Box 6165,

RECORDINGS: Cassettes, CDs,
Videos, and Books. Featuring Appalachian Banjo
&amp; Fiddle music, Storytelling, Ballads &amp; BlueIVY CREEK

grass. Visit us on the web. www.ivycreek.com.

28801. 828-255-9393; IraTenToe@aol.com.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Equipment
REMO RENAISSANCE BANJO HEADS Now
In

Stock. $22

to $24;

odd size Fiberskyn banjo

heads, Most sizes from
Gut

10" to 12

1

/8", $19 to $21;

string banjo strings $17; TKL banjo cases
for 11" &amp; 12" rims $95 plus shipping. Smakula
5

Fretted

Old-Time Herald

Instruments, PO Box 882, Elkins, WV
26241, 304-636-6710, email; smakula@meer.net

zuill accept

classi

fied ads at the cost of 35 cents per word,

minimum $5.00. Any grouping of letters
numbers

Little River Stomp by the Buckhannon

to

The

must

be

is

counted

received

weeks prior

to

as one word.

by the

or

All ads

first of the month,
publication.

6

�Reviews

Down

the

in

Basement Joe
Bussard's
Treasure Trove
of Vintage 78s

1926--

1937

1004

Stripling Brothers:The Lost Child ;BigBillBroonzy:
How You Want It Done?; Luis Russell &amp; His
The (New) Call of the Freaks; Dixon

Brothers: The School House Fire; Weems String
Band: Greenback Dollar; Blind Gary Davis: You
Got To Go Down; A A Grey and Seven-Foot Dilly:
The Old Ark's A'Moving; James Cole's Washboard
Four: Runnin' Wild; Charley Jordan: Keep It Clean;
Bill Johnson's Louisiana Jug Band: Get The "L" On

Down The Road; Sweet Brothers
Old

Hen

pied 180 square feet of shelf space running
high and 30 feet long across a wall of his

sent proportionately the types of music in his
collection. For example, there's only one Cajun
track on the CD because Cajun records represent
such a tiny fraction of Joe's collection. (An excep
tion to this would be postwar records- although

of and

is a sample
immense collection.

Old Hat, CD-

Stoneman:

stories from Joe about many of the records. We
transferred 85 of these tracks onto digital tape.
From that group, I made a final selection of 24
tracks, with the thought that these would repre

ment. This CD

Various Artists

Orchestra:

Five years later, he also had a driver's license,
which expanded his hunting ground indefinitely,
and his collection soon numbered in the thou
sands. Fifty-five years later, his collection occu

b

Ernest

Got A Bulldog; Coleman &amp; Harper:
Cackle; Bessie Brown: Song From A
I

Cotton Field; Gene Autry: Atlanta Bound; Soileau
and Robin: Easy Rider Blues; Bill Brown and his

a

6

feet

base

tribute

to this

There are no bad cuts on this CD, as would be
expected from a selection drawn from a pool of
some 50,000. The range of musical styles goes
from solo five-string banjo to full jazz orchestra.
There are string bands, blues guitarists, gospel
singers and the singing cowboy, Gene Autry.

my cues from Joe."
The notes to this CD are excellent. They

Among the many unusual items is "Greenback
Dollar," by the Weems String Band, which dis

clude detailed information on

plays extraordinarily complex string band play
ing. The melody, carried by two fiddles, is sup
ported by a fingerstyle banjo over a bowed cello

cations, labels, numbers and matrix numbers.
Each selection also receives a paragraph of gen
eral background information. The extensive 72

like the harpsichord and cello of a baroque con
certo grosso. The Uncle Dave Macon selection
may come

as a surprise to those to whom he is a
raucous comic vaudeville performer. "Uncle
Dave's Beloved Solo" is a set of variations on the
hymn "Rock of Ages." The theme is opened with

followed by

Brownies:

seven strong chords and
of six variations played

Hastings Street; Fields

intricate single-string banjo work you will ever
hear. There is also Long Cleve Reed and Little

Hot Lips; Uncle Dave Macon: Uncle
Dave's Beloved Solo; Blind Blake-Charlie Spand:
Ward &amp; The Grayson County
In Mind; The

Railsplitters: Ain't That Trouble

Corley Family: Give The World A Smile Long Cleve
Reed and Little Harvey Hull
Down Home Boys:

Original Stack O'Lee Blues;
Royal Flush Orchestra:

Fess Williams and his

Hot Town; Gitfiddle

Jim:

Paddlin' Blues; Grinnell Giggers: Plow Boy Hop

Harvey Hull's recording

is

a series
some of the most

in

of "Original Stack O'Lee
is one of only 55 re

page booklet of notes to this CD provides a brief
biography of Bussard along with a series of
outstanding, well chosen, photographs. The 45
color and black and white photographs that
appear

in the

notes do more than simply deco

rate the booklet; they help tell the story. There
are pictures of Bussard enraptured with the

music he

is hearing, Bussard in despair over lost
recordings and pictures of Bussard with his
record collection and his excellent sound equip
ment. There are photos of some of the musicians

and full size photos of some of the labels of the

under the bed

excerpted

photo

graphs is accented by two photos of Bussard's
The notes are
cat with the record collection.

some

and adapted, without credit, from
Wyatt's article on Bussard that appeared in the
Spring 1999 issue of The Old-Time Herald.
The picture of Bussard that emerges from the

thing like 20 CDs of Rev. Gary Davis available,
they might have given his space to someone

booklet, both the text and the photographs, is
that of an intense, opinionated man whose love

of an old man in rural

Virginia.

not only one of the finest private collections of
78rpm records in existence, it is better than most

the choices on Down in the Basement. With

well.

including artist credits, recording dates and lo

rare recordings on this CD. The series of

is the

as

in

selections

leased by the Black Path label in Chicago. Black
Pattis are among the rarest in the world, and,
when Bussard found this one, it was stored

Bussard's collection of over 25,000 record
mostly old-time country, jazz and blues-ings--

institutional collections

all the

Blues." This 1927 record

Joe
is

many of these, I decided to focus just on
the prewar recordings.) So you could say that I
made the final selections, but I definitely took

Joe has

It

only copy known

would be possible

to
to

It

exist.

quibble with some

of

whose recordings

But you can' t fault the choice on musical grounds.
This 1935 performance displays Davis's singing

page

Rodgers' recordings from the local music store
but was told they had none. Figuring that, since

and spectacular guitar work at their best.
Down in the Basement is the by-product of

lecting 78s and his love for the music, "We walked
in and went down the hall to the bedroom, and

Rodgers had made so many records, somebody
must have some, the 11-year-old Bussard started
going from house to house, asking people if they

visits producer Marshall W yatt made to Bussard
to gain the use of some of his recordings for CDs

he pulled this box out from under the bed. .Then,
all of a sudden, I spotted the first Black Patti. Oh

he has produced for Old Hat Records. The pro
cess of reducing Bussard's enormous collection

my Gaahd! It was all I could do to keep my
hands from trembling!
There was a balcony that ran the whole length

And sure enough, at one
house, a woman gave him a box of records that
included two by Jimmie Rodgers. In the process,
had any old records.

he also picked up some other records he liked;
so, knowing a good technique when he had one,
he continued

later, he had

a

canvass the town.

Five years
collection of hundreds of records.
to

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

down

to

a

generally available.

are less

single CD was

a

collaborative

one

between Marshall Wyatt and Bussard. As Wyatt
later described it,

"I

lot of time with Joe
was able to get a feel for

spent

a

playing records, and
his favorites, and a knowledge of key records in
his collection. And got a chance to hear detailed
I

I

for old

music

boundless. His enthusiasm

Bussard, it appears, didn't set out to own such
collection; it seems to have grown up around
him.
In 1947, he tried to buy some Jimmie
a

is

is

also quotable, and the notes contain page after
of

Bussard describing his adventures col

of the store.

And halfway along the balcony was

shelf with, I'd say, five or six thousand records.
kept feeling like the balcony was tilting and
a

was going to slide over the top of the rail down
to the floor below, "Wait'U you hear this one!

I

I

�"Uncle Dave's Beloved Solo!" He was the great
showman who ever walked the stage... You

est

gotta listen
Orchestra...

Fess Williams' Royal Flush

to this!

By God, this is jazz!" Bussard

comes
exuberant, single-minded, fanatic whose
enthusiastic love of old-time music is matched
only by his desire to share it.
The sound quality of this CD ranges from very
of f as an

good

to

excellent.

Surface noise

is

audible on

many of the tracks, but you can also hear Big Bill
Broonzy's pick snap each string of his guitar on
"How You Wantlt Done?" Billjohnson'sslapped

bass, on the Louisiana Jug Band's "Get The "L"
On Down," sounds like it is in the room with
you.

And

Blind

Blake's guitar and Charlie

Spand's piano, on "Hastings St." come through
with a clarity many will not believe possible on
an old 78. The

remastering by Christopher King
and the digital mastering by Robert Vosgien are
well done. But there is another reason for this

wonderful sound. The quality of electrically re
corded 78s as opposed to the early acoustical
disks
was much higher than many people real
ized. One of the Bussard quotes in the CD notes

explains that, "Recording technology in the late
'20s was advanced, very advanced! But the play

back technology was crap! Those old Victrolas
sounded like crap! It took fifty years for the
playback technology to catch up with the record
ing technology."
This is true. Early recordings were much bet
ter than the early record players. When sound

engineers realized that there was
those

a

lot of music in

that no one was hearing,

grooves
they
went on to develop "High Fidelity" playback
systems that would let people actually hear what
was on their recordings. And many of those old
78s had wonderful sound. havehad people assume
I

that 78rpm recordings

I

transferred

to tape

were

modem stereo recordings! And my equipment was
nowhere near

as good as Bussard's.
This 24 selection, more than 70 minute CD

introduction

to a great collection of
old-time
music.
Fortu
early recordings
nately, it is an introduction that is easy to follow
up. Joe Bussard's website, www.vintage78.com,
enables you to browse his entire collection. It is

gives us

an

of

divided into seven categories: Old-Time Coun
try, Country Blues, Country, Jazz/Blues Sing
Bluegrass, Black Gospel and Jazz. And
Bussard's generosity and willingness to share
his music extends beyond record companies
ers,

producing CD reissues. You can order cassette
copies of anything you want at prices that range
from 750 to 500 per selection. And while you're
at it, you might want to visit Old Hat Records at

www.oldhatrecords.com

and see just what CDs
Marshall Wyatt produced with 78s he got from
Bussard.
A. V.

Shirk

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�had

a

vision

of

issuing

a

variety

of

Kentucky old-

time music from its storied past. The first install
ment of this plan was manifested by Richard

Nevins' then-new record label, Morning Star
Records. Three recordings, on vinyl, with exten
sive notes, came out with string band/fiddle
music that had been recorded by the Gennett
label of Richmond, Indiana. There were plans to
bring out more recordings, but the vinyl record
ing industry went down the tubes. Gus Meade,
alas, died a few years later, way before his time.
Not that long ago, we started seeing interesting
anthologies of old-time music on the Yazoo la
bel, again helmed by Richard Nevins.
The Music of Kentucky

on Yazoo,

in

appeared

In

1995,

two volumes

lovely set mixing 78 rpm recordings

a

and AFS [these instantaneous disk recordings
cited above
the acronym stands for what the

archive then was called,

The Archive of Folk Song

Library of Congress] sides. That set, how
ever, was only a teaser for what would show up
in 2003. Feast your ears, and eyes, upon this set.
at the

Upon opening the box, one

is

greeted by

a

5-

1/2" by 11-3/8" 32-page booklet, very impres
sive. It features a lot of great photographs of
many of the artists whose music graces this set,
and also

a

few others. Richard Nevins penned
a
lengthy essay about the com

the preface and

mercial recordings and the artists who made
them. Charles K. Wolfewroteasimilarly lengthy
essay about the AFS field recordings and artists.
Therein follows CD by CD listings of all the
songs/tunes and performers, with a key that
identifies nearly all the artists on most tracks.
Also enclosed is a facsimile of a letter from Green
Bailey to Doc Roberts and the back cover con
tains the lyrics to James Howard's "The Old Fish
Song." We also get a couple pages of advertise

ments
to be

listed

for related

sneezed

is

not

also recommend every title
section," especially the afore

at, as

in the "ad

mentioned

Yazoo merchandise. This
I

CDs, The Music of Kentucky
Mr. Nevins took great pains, I am told,
2

to

locate the best-quality recordings for those tracks
he

wished

to

issue on this set. The mastering

process took about two years. Nevins has a great
reputation as a 78 mastering expert, so be as
sured that the sound quality, for the most part, is
the best one could generate from these old re
cordings. How much filtering

or

equalization

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

one should use on these recordings is a matter of
personal taste. There could have been more digi

cleanup than is heard on most of these sides,
it is far supe
but I certainly can live with this
tal

rior sonically to

some

of these

previously issued recordings

pieces. There

is a

point

of

of

dimin

has yet to be copied or even
as such is

signature

a

Dock Roberts

is

has even more

a

of their

well-mimicked, and
music, so beautiful.

yet another major figure who
showing here than first obvious,

as he is not the" name" on all the

recordings herein

He fiddles

on which he plays.

gorgeously be

ishing returns in noise suppression, so if one is to
"err," better that the erring on the conservative

hind Ted Chestnut and Green Bailey and duets
nicely with Jim Booker on "Sourwood Mountain."

side, so that little or no music signal is lost. That
said, there is nothing at all wrong with the pre

The

sentation herein, once one understands that there
will be surface noise from the friction of the
playback needle in the musical grooves, not to
mention pitting and erosion from seventy-plus
years of enthusiastic playing.
Although the booklet notes are an excellent

exposition

of the time and place

that these

re

cordings were made, and include mini-biogra
phies of most of the primary characters, there
might have been more. Perhaps there could have
been more comparisons and contrasts of style
and repertoire, perhaps a bit about song/ tune
history and etiology. Who influenced whom on
this set, who was 'covering' what other popular
artists of the era and which of these Kentucky

artists were to become influential
There

is

a

themselves?

bit of this already going on in the notes,

but the package would have been stronger had
there been more. Most probably cost was an
So perhaps these suggestions I just made
had already been considered. But I still will
whine about it, for I find this to be a very impor

issue.

tant set, and as such, deserves as much

documen

tation as possible. Also, I have a strong sense of irony
in that this is dedicated to Gus Meade, a person who

was consumed by details and minutiae.
The largest presence here is by the Burnett

Rutherford

&amp;

They were based around
on
the
Cumberland Plateau, and
Monticello,
were already seasoned performers when the
circle.

recording industry beckoned. They account

for

over 20 of the tracks here, and I'm not complain
ing one bit (well, maybe they could've slipped in
another artist in lieu of a couple of these espe
the use of both

"All Night
cially considering
Long Blues"and "Richmond Blues," the identi

Bookers, African-American musicians

extraordinaire, were strong influences on Rob
erts' music, so how fortunate we are to have
some of their music here. Jim Booker's brothers
Joe and John even took turns backing Roberts on
guitar in his August 1927 session, producing 8

issued sides. This occasion seems to imply a
shared recording date among The Booker Or
chestra, Taylor's Kentucky Boys (in which Jim
was the fiddler, with an otherwise EuropeanAmerican band) and Doc's ensemble, but the
dates for known sessions don't quite mesh. Be
it may, there is still a lot to be told and to
hear regarding the give-and-take between Black
and White old-time musicians. Meanwhile, we'll

that as

just sit back and enjoy what we already have.

Fiddler Andy Palmer stands as a giant in my
eyes, as his masterful performances on several of
the Jimmy Johnson String Band sides will won
derfully illustrate. His sides are the very exciting
1932 recordings, not the JJSB's 1931 recordings
where Lee Smitha's and Dewey Akers' doubled
fiddles didn't quite add up to the power and
grace of Palmer. Not bad, mind you, but we are
comparing them with one of the major fiddlers
in a state overflowing with them. A sidebar here
perhaps on William Houchens, like Palmer from
Anderson County, would have been appreci
ated. Not only was Houchens one of the earliest

country musicians

to

record, but his first tune,

a

medley beginning with "Arkansas Traveller,"
features one of Palmer's favorite numbers,
"Shippen Port." Houchens' "Big-Eared Mule,"
from 1923, presages John Salyer's rendering of
that number that really did not become public
until the 1980s. And the venerable Doc Roberts

covered

a

few of Houchens' medleys not only

cal song done twice by the same band, though

with the same sequence of tunes, but also in an
imitation of his style. It's a shame he did not

with different personnel) Their vocals are strong,
confident, and the instrumentals and accompa

make the cut for this set, but perhaps will appear
on a later Kentucky-themed set on this label.

niment sure. Rutherford's eely, sliding phrasing

One can only hope.

Another
dance here

I

am so glad to see in some

is the

abun

fellow who ends the last disk,

the Rev. Buell Kazee. For some reason he seems
to

have

escaped

the scrutiny

of

most of the

current generation of enthusiasts. Hailing from
Magoffin County, he had a masterful touch on
the 5-string banjo and offered wonderful texts
on lyric songs and ballads, but primarily ballads,

a
galloping, breakneck banjo cadence be
hind the slow lyric line. He had a strong, full,

with

controlled voice, which usually occasions some
one citing his formal voice training. But I find a
lot of the hill country still there in his recordings.

This man had dirt under his torn fingernails at
some point of his life, he lived the life, walked

�the walk, he remembered.

Similarly

in

a

He was the real deal.

way, we are treated

vocals

to the

and banjo of Justis Begley (is that really a photo
of him in the booklet? I've seen that photo

many

times and it's always been presented as an un
known/ unnamed banjo player. Did it finally get
identified?), who presents not only fine picking
on "Run Banjo," but

gives the fullest text to date
chestnut "I've Been All Around This
World," but with his own twist, in time. Begley
claims it as his own, and have no doubt that this
for the old

I

particular text is his. We are treated to several of
Walter Williams' unbelievably fast banjo num
bers, he who most know as a sometimes accom

panist to Bill Stepp. We have Marion
Underwood's brilliant fingerpicked "Coal Creek
and his fine interlocking duets
March," too
with Jim Booker. Dad Crockett also contributes

lovely banjo song with "Sugar Hill," as well.
I better
leave the 5-string alone, now, so
don't shortchange some other great perfor
a

mances with my omission; it's become obvious
that even if had the entire issue this quarter,
could easily fill it with commentary on this set.
I

There was

I

I

a wide
variety of traditional music in
before
World War II and this collec
Kentucky
tion seems to at least touch most of it. We have

the string bands, the virtuoso solo

instrumental

ists, lyric singers, balladeers, music secular and

religious of all sorts.
perfect of course, but
less.

It is

It

is

stimulating, not

all

massive effort nonethe
a must-have item for most home collec
my opinion. Kudos must go out to the
a

tions, in
ramrod of this project, Richard Nevins, and

to all

who contributed, to writing, locating the bestknown copies, who helped every inch of the
way. It is a remarkable feat to all this together. I
think this set will

estimable company,
And

it

sets

in

find itself in some pretty
like the Smith Anthology.

may grow, if Yazoo adds similarly-themed
the future. I've always thought of the

1920s as a Golden Age of recorded old-time
music, but with the reissue, availability and new
issue of precious gems in the recent past, may
I

reconsider and pronounce these days
Golden Age.

as the true

KERRY BLECH

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

minstrel songs, sentimental songs, and break
downs. Several of these musicians heard on this
collection

McGee, Boggs, Roberts, Hutchison,
are known
Burnett and Rutherford, especially
to have learned directly from African- American

players. Others such as Hensley seem to have
learned from recordings, which from 1922
onward were largely responsible for spread
ing blues across the country and across the
color line.
The performances are uniformly magnificent,
to represent the

and have been carefully chosen

variety of white responses to the stimulus pro
vided by the new form of the blues. These range
from Hensley's exquisitely worked out copy of

Blind Lemon Jefferson's recording of "Match
box Blues" to Boggs's shattering and musically

unique adaptation of a conventional blues song
to his "graveyard" banjo style and brink-ofbreakdown emotional singing. Frank Hutchison,
perhaps the most emotionally convincing white
performer

to

play

in a

recognizably black style,

wild slide guitar "Cannonball Blues."
The five fiddle instrumentals remind us of Alan
Jabbour's contention that truly American music
began with the syncopated playing of nineteenthprovides

a

fiddlers, and these
raggy fiddle-tune "blues" performances may
actually represent some of the oldest sounds to
century African-American

be heard on the album.
The

white

respective

players

contributions
to

the

fingerpicking guitar lie lost

of

black

development
in the

and

of

unrecoverable

past. By the time guitarists were recorded, mas
ter pickers of both races were ready to be heard.
Here, Sam McGee, Dick Justice, David Miller,
and Clarence Green display guitar solo work of

stunning quality, playing which must have had
an extensive history in black and white hands
long before these musicians picked up a guitar.
We may never know exactly where such playing
came from, but here it is to be savored and
learned anew.
For many students of old-time recordings, the
of the album will be Lester

revelation

McFarland's bottleneck performance in open D
tuning of "K.C. Whistle Blues," beautifully
played with a haunting boogie-like bass figure
between the stanzas, and sung in a wistful, re
laxed voice. Unfortunately, nearly all of
McFarland's many recordings are in duet with
the insufferable Robert Gardner, and "K.C.
Whistle Blues" may be only a tantalizing sample
of a solo repertoire we will never know.
Moving from the sublime

to the

ridiculous,

we note the Lowe Stokes rendition of "Left All

Alone Again Blues," a performance of a 1920
pop song which is a blues only by courtesy of
that word being used in the title. This cut

repre

sents Stokes's and Clayton McMichen's attempts
to join fiddle-band music with downtown cafe-

society sophistication, one of the dead end ex
periments in old-time music, but which in this
case resulted in an irresistible blend of zany
lyrics

with infectious

duet ragtime fiddling.

Beware:

this one

will be ringing

unbidden

through your head for days.
The package adds up to a must-have record
ing. The digital remastering by Robert Vosgien
is matchless; Kerry Blech's very complete and
Afri
literate notes are exemplary; the subject
can-American influences within and upon oldtime music

is

endlessly fascinating and re

warding; the performances are as great as you
will hear on any reissue this year.
JON PANKAKE

�valleys but flows on down to the flat lands. "Half
to Nowhere"
is a fine honky-tonk that
sounds like something Buck Owens might have

where. "Quoi tu"? It works I think!
The best comparison for this new duo

been singing in I960, though Carol Elizabeth has
written it much more recently than that. My only
production remark might come here I think

of the next recording
Hazel
and Alice. Their range
project
probably
is similar, and if there's not a high mountain
voice alive that really touches Hazel at her re
markable best, well, these two are as honest and

Way

it'd be just fine to hear a little snare beat on this,
two-steppers can keep it tight when they're
shuffling the sawdust.
so the

tme slide guitar player, and she
shines on the next cut, "You Don't Tell Me That
Laurel

is

a

It's a sweet sad song
slow dance, and a dip during the tasty
mandolin break would be more than appropri

You Love Me Anymore."
for

a

favorite song on the CD has

ate. But my

to be

"Why You," another Jones original. This one

ought

covered by EmmyLou

to be

someone
don't nail

or

Lucinda

or

not that Carol Elizabeth and Laurel
it,

but I'd like

to

see them make some

real jack for all this great singing they're doing.
"Why You" is a classic, cut in the Cajun mold, a

great smart hook that resonates as well as makes
me smile:

"Why You, I'm glad it's you, no you can't be
mine it's true

Another life, another door, why you,

I

guess

it

had to be you."
Along with the pain that only southwest Louisi
ana can generate on the morning after Fat Tues
day, seasoned by the roux of 7ths and the mandolin
trills, there's predestination in there, and the sorrow
of
it's

love for the one who can only hurt. Great song, and
probably not too late for one French verse some

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

hope they're able
are

already

to

and

I

get out and tour some, and

thinking

is

true to themselves as Gerrard and Dickens were
when they met up and started harmonizing in
the early '60s. This music never dies.
--BILL

HICKS

�site it's interpreted as a subtitle, but it might be
the printer's designation of ink color on a mockup

anything else you care to specu
Other bits of tight focus mystery include
the use of sounds between cuts
scraping chairs,
of the cover, or

late.

possibly a bit of church service
unexplained, they become fragments of a dream
the listener can't quite remember. +"I don't know
where we were or what we were doing, hon, but
he had on this scratchy blue workshirt with an
mumbles,

oil stain on the cuff." "Pass the coffee, sweetie."
to

I'm not proposing to decode all this, but only
note that such introspective details suggest an

attention to the art of the whole. (I'm reminded
of similar touches in Gillian Welch's "Time the
Revelator" the dress the artist wears in a photo
is mirrored in the design of the label, and lyric
lines such as "the great emancipator took a bul
let in the back of the head" float in an amazing,
surreal

way from song to song on her CD.)
Kazor closes the CD with his "So Many People,"
which drops "yellow mercury preacher" into a
phrase. The tight focus is also caught in the
instrumental musical details, most vividly in the
use of mortar &amp; pestle in "New Lost Mission
Blues," an original instrumental by Kazor and
Lucas lamenting the "gentrification of the Mis
sion District" of San Francisco. This listening

with

no-space cut to a haunting trio of "Shady
utilizing a baritone uke and Lisa and
Stephanie's fine vocal harmonies. Then comes
the title cut, "Unfortunate Rake." This song,
essentially introduced by what precedes it, is a
a

Grove,"

mix of traditional lyrics and original music by
the band's lyricist, Jeff Kazor, and it exemplifies

what the Jades
music. "Rake"
"Streets of

aiming for, over all, in their
is in the long tradition shared by
Laredo" in this version with a female
are

tragic heroine, dying of syphilis and mercury
poisoning, mercury being the "cure" used in the

good old-timey days of yore. It's a vice-ful city
song, a done-wrong song, and in its graphic
details escapes the more romantic 19th Century
parlor and cowboy traditions. A note reveals
that one of the side effects of the old mercury
cure was copius salivation
and this detail is
lovingly rhymed into the chorus each time round
"my poor head is aching, my sad heart is break
ing, my body salivatin' and I'm bound to die"
The Kazor

Berman harmonies are haunting, and

very modern in a rooted sort of way. The effect
overall is this interesting mix of realistic tight
focus detail that creates almost a surreal effect.
The band makes attempts in other ways to focus
on these tight vivid details
there are two Kazor

originals, "Yellow Mercury No.

2"

comes first,

a

tragic ballad about the Love Creek
Flood of 1982, and then later, in+"Yellow Mer

coda

to his

cury No. 1," a love-separated song which maybe
refers yet again to the flood tragedy. In this song
there's af'yellow mercury sky." The booklet
also sports

a

small mysterious line below the
on the Copper Creek

title: "yellow mercury"

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

experience is somehow what it might be like to
lie paralyzed on a cot in some bamboo stockade
in the Congo
riveting, yet sinister and mad
dening too, sweat and paranoia. And then you
the tune is
to add what the notes say
"about" gentrification. Gentrification! Really??

have

Bummer! Perhaps fortunately, programmatic
music has always been a sort of silly idea as an
instrumental "Lost Mission Blues" stands quite
on it's own.

Maybe this gives you some idea of this fine
want to stress that it's a wonderful, artfully

CD.

I

complete project, far and away better than al
most anything you're ever likely to hear on the
radio. You will, of course, hear a cut or two on
your local NPR affiliate's roots show (let'shope!).
am of the opinion that people who want to play
I

"old-time" music in the world we live in have to
to grips with that essential, existential fact.

come

We may love the simplicity of the fiddle and
bow, the acoustic thrum of guitar and banjo,
even the mortar and pestle and quill whistle, but

we can't just go back there to that simplicity, we
can only utilize it here, in the ever present, where
there are 8-year-olds carrying AK-47s in

Kinshasa, heads rolling down the street in Tel
Aviv, pretty widows strapped with explosives
executed at close range in Moscow opera houses,
Native- American single mothers who may get a
mountain named after them in Arizona, but
don'tcome home to their babies. Thejades really
get this in their own very individual way. I'm
delighted that they're making records and creat
a
following. This one will give you a lot of
listening pleasure, and perhaps some discom
fort too. This is as it should be.

ing

BILL HICKS

�plays Jew's Harp and sings "Did

he

Y ou Ever See

the Devil, Uncle Joe" ("Miss McLeod's Reel," not
the Fiddlin' Powers version), for example, you'd
think he'd spent his whole life on a sprung couch

front porch twanging out that one song. But
right after that comes "Blow the Horn, Blow,"
where he shakes a rattle, sings, hoodies, and
on

a

plays quills (soprano panpipes) all at once. This
one seems to come from a different lifetime

different front porch. The effect is like
whole slew of different expert tradi
tional musicians. He even plays a Scandinavianstyle waltz ("Grandpa Jim's Waltz"). His play
spent on
a

CD of

a

a

ing style here reminds me that

a harmonica was
mouth organ when was a kid.
In some cases, Mike follows his sources closely
both in vocal and instrumental styles. "Johnson

called

a

I

Jinkson" is an old ballad collected in a California
labor camp in 1940. Troy Cambron, the per
former, played guitar and sang very simply, and

does Mike. On "Golden Willow Tree," he
follows Justus Begley's clawhammer banjo style,
and on "Freight Train," he comes closer than
most imitators to Elizabeth Cotton's classy rag
so

time guitar picking. Mike was the one who origi
nally taped her version but has not previously

recorded it himself.
About one-third

songs use banjo ac

of the

companiment. Whereas

stage banjoist like
Grandpa Jones cranked his G tuning up to A for
more brilliance, Mike explores low tunings. In
some cases this is because he is using a gourd or
a

gut-strung instrument, but in others it's because
the low tuning goes well with the song, particu
larly when he's singing songs influenced by Josh
Thomas, a North Carolina musician who would
not have been noticed if Mike did not keep his

memory alive. He uses a similar approach to
"Spoonful," from Will Slayden, a Tennesseean
who also used a banjo. In spite of having been
processed by another musician on the way,
Mike's version sounds very much like Charlie
Patton's original recording, which used a guitar.
With war horses, the kind almost everyone
knows, Mike chooses alternate approaches. In
addition

to

using

a

See the Devil, Uncle

Jew's Harp on "Did You Ever
Clarence
J oe?" Mike modifies

Ashley's "Coo Coo Bird"

to

become

a

Josh

Tho

mas piece with gourd banjo. The stringband
"Little Rabbit, Where's Y our Mammy?" becomes
an open-tuned guitar solo. "Don't Let Your Deal
Go Down" uses a fiddle and harmonica combi
nation that sounds like an accordion. The slurred
vocal delivery would fit right in at a backwoods
still.
believe that "Sail Away Ladies" is done
exactly the way Henry Thomas would have
done it if he had been so inclined, and if he had
used an autoharp as well as quills.
I

These performances are convincing and com
It's hard to imagine another way of

pelling.

doing each one after you hear Mike do it. highly
recommend this recording. You will enjoy it at
the same time it expands your musical horizons.
I

LYLE LOFGREN

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�mandolin along with his older brother
on guitar.This in itself makes the set
special; until now, the only way one could own
the entire output of The Monroe Brothers was to
a. collect their 78s, all thirty of them, or b. luck
onto the Japanese produced
CD set with no

looking in its day, yet solidly based in the string
band tradition of the southeast it also serves to

English liner notes. I'm sure many readers own
or have owned the two album set RCA issued in
the 70s, but it included only 36 of the 60 record

of recordings
Monroe ever made, although a wonderful vin
tage photo of the group graces the cover of the
book accompanying the box set. It was a band in

Bill on

Charlie

ings. Not only are all 60 numbers here, but the
excellent 80 odd page book accompanying the
set includes extensive, knowledgeable and well
written notes by Charles Wolfe, outlining in
some detail how younger brother Bill grew out
of his duet experience with Charlie
into "The

his Bluegrass Boys recordings! It is The History
of Bluegrass 101, the first week's lectures at least,

boys and girls, in audio form, with a hard cover
book featuring wonderful photos of all the bands,
early recordings

and albums, and

a

complete

discography by bluegrass expert and former
Bluegrass Boy Neil Rosenberg. In Bear Family's
usually exhaustive style, we have many alter
nate takes from these sessions, in addition to
every released performance by The Monroe
Brothers and The Bluegrass Boys from 1936 to
1949.This is the first time that all this material
has been available in one place, ever, and if you
are passionate about the history of this music
and you can afford it, you will want this set.
First of all, and amazingly enough, we have

here the entire output of The Monroe Brothers,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

have taken their place

in the

standard repertoire,

these recordings that did not survive to become
part of what we now think of as bluegrass,
although both were perfectly good musicians.

in their

own right

to

warrant their niche

of them, the

that has become

Their contributions

heard

in this

history of old-time country music, along
side The Carlisles, The Delmores, The Blue Sky
Boys, and others. A real measure of their endur
ing influence is the popularity of The Three Pick

somewhat jarring anomalies. But

album, DVD, and TV show; their material
and material they influenced a good bit of the

and alternate takes from these

formative years, and give us our best idea of how
Monroe developed bluegrass." This is a lofty
claim, but there is truth in it. This is certainly the
most complete audio picture of Monroe's devel

recordings of the first Bill Mon
roe and his Bluegrass Boys but also, in the same
box set, the complete Columbia Bill Monroe and

transition, a band with a leader searching for a
sound, and this particular groups' output con
tains relatively little memorable music. Although
many if not most of the songs and tunes here

become bluegrass peeking through, but perhaps
that's fanciful, and besides, who cares? Bill and
Charlie are wonderful enough and special

dis

repertoire since the beginning of his career. Al
though their repertoire is largely traditional and
many of the titles are familiar to fans of brother
style duet singing, Bill and Charlie's duets are
unique for that time, and remain vibrant, excit
ing, and fresh to this day. These are landmark

quite bluegrass

the least coherent and

is to

The music contained

Brothers and the 1940, 1941, and 1945 RCA Blue
bird recordings of the seminal pre- kinda but not

these ears

sound is not yet the bluegrass
familiar to us. The old-time
banjo of David "Stringbean" Akeman and the
accordion of Sally Ann Forrester are elements on

repertoire of that program. Doc Watson has
always been a staunch Monroe Brothers fan and
has included Monroe Brothers material in his

Monroe

to

some

ers

of The

features

musically distinguished group

their intense, high pitched vocal duets and their
fierce instrumental work. From this vantage

in the

plete RCA Bluebird recordings

important compo

and although Monroe continued to perform them
throughout his career, and in fact re-recorded

enough

opmental years we are likely to have in the
foreseeable future.lt includes not only the com

an

Father OF Bluegrass." Among brother duets in
the southeast, Bill and Charlie were unique for

point, it isn't difficult to imagine that one
cerns the hint of Bill's future design for what

on these 6 CDs, Charles
Wolfe says in his excellent notes "constitute the
most complete picture we have of Bill Monroe's

demonstrate that blues was

nent of Monroe's music from the very beginning.
The next session, from 1945 for Columbia,

recordings, for lovers of old-time music and
bluegrass as well
In addition to the complete Bluebird record
ings of The Monroe Brothers, we have here the
earliest post Brothers recordings of Bill Monroe
and His Bluegrass Boys from sessions for RCA in
1940 (eight selections)andl941(eight selections),

sessions featuring the vocal talents of
Clyde Moody and the amazing fiddling of the
great Tommy Magness, the 1941 recordings fea
the 1940

ance

in

Monroe's propulsive gui
highlight of the 1941 session is
Wooten and Monroe's version of the then rela
tively new fiddle tune "The Orange Blossom
of

Special," a recording whose popularity greatly
enhanced OBS' rapid elevation among fiddlers
to standard
and, eventually, classic status.
Monroe's first recorded version of the tradi
tional classic "In The Pines" is here as well. This
is

wonderful stuff, very innovative and forward

are

fu

Road
Life

Blues, ""Footprints In The Snow," and"Bluegrass
there are also twelve alternate takes
Special"
of
of

various numbers, including three alternates
"Nobody Loves Me," featuring the lead vocal

and prominent accordion of Sally Ann Forrester,
a previously unreleased version of" 'Til Have
New Life." It is on these recordings that two
important members of what was soon to become
the most important band in the formative years

and
A

of

bluegrass make their first appearance; Howard

"Cedric Rainwater" Watts, and
tioned Chubby Wise.
in

the

aforemen

The legend goes that it is on the next session,
September of 1946, that modern bluegrass

came into being, and perhaps
because on that occasion, for the
elements which came to define
meant were present
and have

sic version

A

sessions

bluegrass standards "Rocky
Blues, ""Kentucky
Waltz, ""True
ture

classic first Monroe interpretation of Jimmie
Rodgers' "Mule Skinner Blues," featuring an
outstanding Monroe vocal and driven by a rare
work.

are

also on

Monroe's music. Among the seven titles

ally unchanged ever since.

tar

it is

these recordings that the dark, smoky, gorgeous
fiddle of Chubby Wise makes its first appear

turing fiddler Art W ooten and Pete Pyle, among
others. The 1940 session also features the now

recorded example

context

These

are the

that is the case,
first time, all the

what bluegrass
remained virtu

recordings of the first, the clas
Monroe and The Bluegrass

of Bill

boys. They feature, besides Monroe and his
mandolin, Lester Flatt on guitar and lead vocals,
Earl Scruggs on banjo, Howard "Cedric Rainwa
ter" Watts on bass, and Chubby Wise on fiddle.
This is the band every other bluegrass band was

modeled upon during

that genre's formative

their recordings have achieved
status, and they are all here, along with
ous alternate takes.
years,

classic

numer

All the recordings of this brilliant,
groundbreaking band were made during four
days

of

recording sessions and have maintained

�their iconic status to this day, representing
ably the most complete realization of

prob
Bill

Monroe's musical vision on records, although
the man went on to lead wonderful bands and

innovative and imaginative music

make

for

another fifty years. These were the first, and in
many ways, they remain the best.
This classic band was short lived, as bands
with several innovators tend to be, breaking up
after less than four years together. Their entire

recorded legacy

group was recorded in four
in
the
days
recording studio, September 16 and
17, 1946, and October 27 and 28, 1947. To some
as

a

extent, for better or worse, the music (and the

industry those recordings helped spawn), has
been trying to catch up ever since. Earl Scruggs
with his lightning fast three-finger roll style on
the banjo has historically been noted as the cru
cial new ingredient which made this new group
harden into the prototype for all that was to

come, but

it

would be

a

mistake

to

minimize the

importance
Chubby Wise's gorgeous tone
and smooth fiddle or Lester Flatt's tight lipped
of

lead vocals and impeccable rhythm guitar. They
were giants, and remain so, and this boxed set
goes

a

long way toward putting all that into

proper perspective.
After the well chronicled dissolution of the
Flatt and Scruggs version of Bill Monroe and his
Bluegrass Boys, precipitated by Flatt and Scruggs'
desire to go make some history of their own,

included here as well. The band includes
Monroe and Chubby Wise, along with newcom
ers Mac Wiseman on guitar and vocals, Rudy
is

Lyle on banjo, and Jack Thompson on bass. The
session, held in October of 1949, resulted in the
release of four titles," Can't You Hear Me Callin',"
"Travelin' This Lonesome Road," "Bluegrass
Stomp, "and "The Girl In The Blue Velvet Band,"
all of which have become standards of the bluegrass repertoire over the years. This was to be
Monroe's final session for Columbia., reputedly

because Monroe,

a

proud man, was uncomfort

able remaining on the label with his erstwhile
proteges, Flatt and Scruggs, and his main com
petitors, The Stanley Brothers.

This last session
of

reasons.

is

interesting

find, for instance

for any

number

fascinating that
although Flatt and Scruggs are now gone, the
music has taken a form that would not change
much stylistically for the remainder of Monroe's
I

it

testament both

to the importance
group in defining the genre, but
also a testament to Monroe's ability to incorpo
rate the abilities of his best musicians into a

long career,

a

of that first core

larger whole, an ability Monroe shares with
bandleaders as diverse Duke Ellington, Bob Wills,
Dizzy Gillespie, and Clifton Chenier, to name a
few. That he may have managed to take more
credit than was his due for the creative endeav
ors of band members is

a

subject, perhaps, for

another forum.

Monroe was

to record only one more session for
Columbia before departing from the label, and it

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

RANDY PITTS

�riding the edge between fiddling and
a skateboarder rides a
railing in

violining like

Golden Gate Park. That's the drill with these
tunes: they are all stated melodies to start
with, it's not just vamping in the changes. But
they still have to swing. Otherwise it all col

lapses into Gunther Shuller land, which isn't
a
good plan.
Suzy also takes the listener through a rag

such

tune journey, from the formal

fiddle-tune style

of

a

"Red

to

the more

Apple Rag,"

a

"Dickson County Blues" (both from Arthur
Smith). On these two she has the able support
of Bill Evans, about as solid a Scruggs-style
banjo player as you can find, and she'd get
many a holler with these uptempo burners.
Each cut is

a

step

fox-trot rhythm,
where you have
and, bless patty,

in the trip. A
a

to
if

burner, an easy

slow complex divigation
count to find all the parts,
you try

session without getting

to sit in on

such

way. If you run
into Suzy in the rag frame of mind somewheres,
stick a little note on your hat that says, "Got a
chart for this?" and offer
gang looks dry.
And then Suzy

in the

to go for

drinks

gives us some

if the

vocals--

blues kinda require some words after all. Her
choices here are just spectacular.
"Handy
Man Blues"

person

to

is from Victoria Spivey (the only
have recorded with both Fats Waller

and Bob Dylan, Suzy tells us in the notes.) I've
a lot like it from Bessie Smith

heard something
too. Don't play

it

for your

inlaws

if

they're of

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

the hardshell persuasion,

though

in that

case it's

certain

they need to hear it. "Frosty Morning
Blues" is from Bessie Smith as well-- and Suzy
sings these two in that '20s style that predates the

intimacy of a Billie Holiday. (Probably the Shure
company has a lot more to do with the evolution
of vocal

phrasing and style that we will ever
know.)"Prodigal Son," from Doc Boggs, is one of
the great songs of all time, and Suzy does it proud
with an assortment of glissandos, scoops and

in some haunting low
tuned banjo. Her own "No Mockingbird," which
she tells us that her husband Eric describes as
"Memphis Minnie on acid," is a terrific slow blues

swoops. Jody Stecher adds

utilizing negative metaphors

to

describe the sad

ness that blues are about:
"I'm

drowning

in the deep

muddy waters

of

the murky river,
I'm falling from the tip of the iceberg into

frozen water,
Oh, give me some air, stand back and give me

some air,
Someone throw me a rope I don't want
where I appear to be headed,
Down where no mockingbirds sing."

to go

a great bluesy cuatro on this one, with
Suzy providing the rhythm guitar. It's a worthy
title cut, and of course she's buried it in the middle

Eric plays

of the set. Elegant. Le Duet Thompson, this time
with Eric playing the great lead guitar lines he's

famous

for, returns later for "Lonesome Shack," a
by
Robert
Johnson
song that might have been sung
but comes from Memphis Minnie herself. It's a

great closer to the singing section of the CD.
There's not a cut on this project that isn't worth
many listens. Go get yourself one. Get several.

Christmas

is

coming.
BILL HICKS

To order:

www.nativeandfinerecords.com

�choice

to

accompany

it

shifting between the

major and the relative minor. Williams' own
"Church On Fire With The Word Of God" fol

difficult to communicate how differ
ent Robert Pete Williams sounded from most
music that you hear. According to Dr. Oster,
who recorded him extensively, Williams most
lows.

It is

often improvised his lyrics, and since his guitar
parts also had a strong improvisatory founda
tion, what you wind up with is a song made up
on the spot. (Williams did play occasional stan
dards too.) Williams' vocals had

a

raspy, chant

ing declamatory quality, and his guitar playing
treated the instrument pretty much as some
to

thing

play lines and keep time on, with almost

chordal content

at all, except in as much as the
created
open strings
harmony or discord with
whatever line he happened to be playing at a
given time. His sound haunts me, and I have the

no

feeling that at any given time in his perfor
mances (and I say this non-perjoratively) he
really did not know what was going to happen
next. Sure, he recorded religious songs here, and
blues elsewhere, but he existed at such a remove
from those two traditions as they are normally
that he really merits some special
listening. And since Robert Pete Williams has
five solo numbers here as well as three others on
which he supplies accompaniment, this CD is a

expressed,

good place to start that listening.
The recording abounds in exceptionally strong

bass singers. Tom Dutson performs "Little School
Song" and "Dig My Grave With A Silver Spade"
(recorded by Lemon Jefferson as "See That My
Is Kept Clean") backed by Robert Pete
Williams, and Mr. Dutson's incredibly deep and
rich voice provides an odd reminder of banjo

Grave

player and singer Vester Jones, from the old
Folkways recording, "Traditional Music From
Grayson and Carroll Counties." The amazing
Roosevelt Charles does an impassioned unac
companied version of "Let My People Go."
There

is

some great quartet singing on here,
Quartet performs "Brother
narrative that tells the story of Noah

The Angola

too.

Norah,"

a

and the Ark, and Angola Quartet #2, featuring

lead singer Willie Joe, along with Roosevelt
Charles, Edward James and Willie McGee, does
an

exciting version

of "I'm

Stranded On The

Banks Of Ole Jordan." Among the cuts that Chris
Strachwitz added to the program are two re

corded by the Angola Quartet (actually a sextet)
from Camp A. The addition of the two extra
voices on "See How They Done My Lord" and
"Be With

Me Jesus" make

harmonies
them with

for incredibly

rich

so thick you feel like you could cut
a

knife.

One of the cuts added to the program by Chris
Strachwitz, "Rise and Fly," is in fact not a spiri
at all, but a secular number in which a group
singers pass the lead singing role around
while delivering verses commenting on their
lives in prison, with the back-up singers hum

tual
of

ming

for

accompaniment and joining

last line of each verse.

The song has

in on the
a

sort of

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

"Roots of Rap" feel to it, and it is particularly
to hear the different character that

interesting

each singer brings

to his

lead role.

The program concludes with three numbers
by the Angola Choir, conducted by Murray Ted

Macon, with piano accompaniment. These songs
are "I Take Jesus" (recorded by John Hurt as
"Beulah Land"), "Each Day" (done by Bluegrass

Beautiful Life") and "Steal Away
These performances are just beauti
ful, striking a perfect balance between looseness
and tightness, and it is a treat to hear Mr. Macon
groups

as "A

To Jesus."

directing the singers and giving cues as the
songs go along. The program closer, "Steal Away
To Jesus," is unearthly, sung with tremendous
dynamic control and expression, and
not want

it to

I

really did

end.

give this CD the very highest possible rec
in addition
to admiring the work of the various musicians
presented here, I really admire the work of Dr.
Harry Oster. He was my idea of what a folklorist
should be. His writing on the music he recorded
I

ommendation, and would add that,

was always clear and perceptive, without

theo

retic academic axe-grinding. I applaud his life
work and thank him and the men who per

formed the music on this CD.
JOHN M. MILLER

�Stringbands" or as inarticulable as Harry Smith's
famous "Anthology of American Folk Music,"
an S-F offering that won a Grammy. The notes
indicate this recording is an anthology, describ
ing the contents as "old-time social and instru
mental stringband music spotlighting instru
mental prowess." But what we have here is
something much more limited: white mountain

music from Virginia, West Virginia, North Caro
lina, Tennessee, Kentucky and Georgia. "Fine
Times At Our House" (Indiana) is the only piece
whose origin lies outside that region, and "Jay
bird March," an example of black southeastern

US ragtime guitar picking, is also atypical of the
collection. Ten of the 29 pieces are solos or use

instrumentation not typical

of

full-blown Appa

lachian stringbands, and most are songs: only 11
are completely instrumental. The "instrumental
prowess" spotlighted here is not shallow virtu
osity, a thousand meaningless notes per minute,
but powerful artistry. You could learn to play
most of these pieces well enough to feel good
about

it.

in the olden days we made Listen
copying items we wanted to hear
think Jeff Place, who chose the
repeatedly.
songs, ignored the Mission Statement and used

Way back

ing Tapes,

I

this approach. It depends on individual taste, is
quirkier than any concept, and is more intro
verted than either a sampler or an anthology. It's
a collection
of pieces you enjoy. This is an
excellent Listening CD, with great performances
by some of the premier artists in the field. I find
it interesting
and laudable that the selections
avoid the false distinction between "authentic"

just

Down That Lonesome Road /Gordon Tanner, Joe
&amp; John Patterson Down Yonder/ Etta Baker

Miller

Phillips: Jaybird March /New
Ramblers: John Brown's Dream
&amp; Cora

During
owner

a

of

2200 LP

from all

Lost

City

long and peculiar career, Moe Asch,

Folkways Records, published some
albums devoted to traditional music
over the world. After his death, the

Smithsonian

Institution acquired this treasure,
their
pledge to continue the Folkways
fulfilling
practice of keeping all of the catalog in print. For
most of the collection, this means burning CDs
to order, so it's a demand-side business. Even an
avid website

searcher

is

unlikely

to

find and

order "Drums of the Yoruba of Nigeria" or "Pete
Steele: Banjo Tunes and Songs" without already
that such Folkways gems exist.

knowing

This recording

is

one of

a

series of survey CDs

that S-F has put out to publicize the collection.
With all these riches, what do you pick? During
the 1960s folk boom, the Sampler LP was the

method used by companies such as Elektra. A
sampler was a broad, shallow skim of the por
tion of a catalog that executives thought would
appeal

to

most listeners. You bought the

sam

pler, and they expected you to come back for
complete LPs of your favorite artists. This CD is
a
sampler by that definition. More
than half of the items included here have not been

certainly not
reissued

as S-F CDs, so must be burned to order.

Anthology, a more respectable method,
involves selection based on a concept. The crite
The

ria

could

be

something

as

simple

as

such

folk,

"Alabama

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

folk"

Roscoe Holcomb,

as

such as the McGee

"professional
and

Brothers,

"citybillies" such as the New Lost City Ram
blers. Scholarship in this field is finally employ
ing more musicology and less anthropology.
I've listened to this recording repeatedly, and
it as a technological replacement
listening tape, even though I already have
many of the songs in my LP collection. If you
aren't familiar with the performers, though, this
CD could work for you as a sampler. If you like
a
particular artist, the excellent notes tell you

greatly enjoy
for

a

where

to

go to find more. There's lots more
in the Folkways collection, and

fabulous music

you wouldn't go far wrong ordering at random
from the S-F catalog. Still, this CD is a good guide
for

recommend you buy
government entity you can

the perplexed.

contributing
proud

to

a

I

it,

be

of.
LYLE LOFGREN

�and the staccato attack probably makes most of

these melodies easier

bowed. If you're
the clawhammer

to

hear than were they

banjo picker-- particularly of
and you want to learn
variety-a

some good tunes, brother come on down.
even if you already know some of these

And
I

ex

pect there are few players who don't know "Rag
time Annie" and "Bull at the Wagon" at least--

you don't necessarily know them this way. I've
played "Bull" for years, and hearing it again
here has made me dust

it

off;

it's one of my

favorites on the CD.
The sound quality on the CD is excellent, the
transfer to digital flawless as far as I can tell. I
hope seeing it in it's bright new packaging will
encourage Bertram to go back to the studio for

another effort soon.
BILL HICKS

To Order:

levybutler@olympus.net

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Retreat, Virginia who happens
and a heckuva
multi-instrumentalist
gifted
nice guy to boot) joins forces with Kirk and Lisa
on a number of tracks. "Peacock Rag" features

mayor
to be

of Rural

a

Kirk's bluesy fiddling and just the right and
righteous raggy feeling of Lloyd's banjo and
double-tracked banjo-uke, with Lisa snaking her
bass runs up and down the neck. It is a real eye-

opener, but it seems only tame in comparison to
another of my favorite tracks, "Chinese Break
down," a joyous romp through this chestnut
with Kirk on fingerpicked banjo, Jim on
fingerpicked banjo-guitar, and Lisa on thumbpicked guitar.
one

is on the

I

dare you

to

stand still while this

box.

hauls out the banjo-guitar to join Kirk
(fiddle) and Lisa (guitar) on the CD's grande
Jim

finale, a conflation of "Home Sweet Home" and
"Silver Bells," of which I will talk more about
later. I am struck by the double picked banjos by
Kirk and Bill and by Pat Conte's channeling of
the great Ben Jarrell on fiddle. This piece puzzled
me so much that

I

finally had

to

contact Kirk

to

replied that it had
been a number that Da Costa Woltz's Southern
Broadcasters played, with Ben Jarrell on fiddle,
but they had never recorded it. Kirk learned it
from the playing of Ben's son, T ommy, but when
find out more about

he heard

it

it. Kirk

twinning ban

he virtually heard the

jos. What vision and what execution. We hear
from this group again on a Da Costa Woltz
of Texas," with Eddie
Bond singing. It's gritty, it's authentic, it sounds
like it came from May of 19 and 27. It is so
lyrically faithful that you radio programmers

favorite, "The Yellow Rose
relation

sometimes called "Texas

the tune

to

it is

Quickstep;"

more akin

to

a

fractured setting

"Don't Drink Nothin'

(the one in the key of D).
But Corn" might be an

anthem

it

of the tune "Liberty"
to

some, but

is

one heck of

tune,

a

played about as well as you'll ever hear it right
here. Both these tunes came from fiddler and
banjo player Taylor Kimble, of Laurel Fork, Vir
ginia, about 55 miles north of Walkertown.One
of the

relatively newer names found on the win
at upper south fiddlers' conventions is

ners' lists

that of Eddie Bond. He lends his fiddle, banjo
voice to these proceedings. Kirk

and powerful

and

clawhammer banjo,

over-

plays picked
dubbed, with Eddie on fiddle and voice, and

Lisa on guitar on the opening track, "Fire on the
Mountain" and on "John Hardy." The same trio
knocks out "John Henry," but with Kirk on

fiddle and Eddie on banjo. The sound on these is
pretty much what you might hear from a win
ning string band at those fiddlers' conventions.
Let me take this moment, too, to discuss the
sound mix. am
the instruments
I

here seems
or

to

a

huge

fan of

mixing nearly

all

same level, but the policy
have been to have the fiddle and/

voice way out

at the

in

front

in the

mix.

I

guess that

okay by me if it is a fiddle recording or a
singer's CD, but in this case, Kirk Sutphin, plays
is

banjo a lot and seems to me
mix on too many occasions.

buried

There

is so

in the

much

banjo playing styles here, it is no
nuance, but one of the features, one of

of

variety
longer

to be

a

the most

important aspects

of this

recording.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

There are parts of the New Camp Creek Band
tracks where I can barely hear Tom Mylet. I've

played with him many times and he does not
play quietly, believe me. And he should be heard.
Kirk brought in Richard and Barbara Bow
man, on fiddle and bass respectively, to join with
Lisa on guitar, and Kirk on banjo for a rousing
rendition of the great regional favorite, "Sunny

Home

in Dixie.

"I've heard that nearly everyone

region has played that piece, but the bestknown renditions were cut by Frank Jenkins'
Pilot Mountaineers in 1929 and the one made by

in the

John A. and Bess Lomax in 1937 of John Rector
&amp; His Wildcats. Richard's setting has the same

understructure as both these classic recordings,
but his ornaments and phrasing are totally his
own and are quite tasty. Perhaps my favorite
I Can Read
My Title
Clear," featuring the powerful voice of Keith
Hiatt and fiddle accompaniment by Kirk. Hiatt's

track on this CD is "When

delivery is superb and coupled closely with
Kirk's bow work evokes pleasurable visions El
der Golden Harris, a preacher from near
Hillsville, Virginia who accompanied his own

singing simultaneously on the fiddle on his hand
ful of recordings. Keith Hiatt lives in Reidsville,
in the vicinity of Eden, North Carolina (which is
the heart of Charlie Poole country and was also
home to Lonnie Austin and is home to Doug

Rorrer's Flying Cloud studios where this was
recorded) and is fast becoming, based on this
sole recording, one of my favorite singers. The
Amazing Jim Lloyd (both the barber and vice-

out there should preview it before playing it on
the air, as you could find yourself in a mess of
trouble. Kirk also favors us with a double- tracked
solo number, "Peek-a-boo Waltz," on fiddle and
banjo. And speaking of
fingerpicked

fingerpicked banjo, that leads us into my final
tale here, about the finale piece of "Home Sweet
Home-Silver Bells." Kirk had purchased the
Frank Jenkins banjo, which is ideal for
fingerpicking. In trying to authenticate thebanjo,
he and Lisa tracked down H.O. Jenkins, who is
the grandson of Frank and son of Oscar Jenkins
(who'd recorded 3 LPs on County with Tommy
Jarrell and Fred Cockerham many years ago).
Kirk learned this conflated tune from H.O. He

typically played it with his father Oscar in twin
fiddle competitions. It also is the version of
"Home Sweet Home"" that Grandpa Sidney
Sutphin played. Kirk wrote me, "I have tried to
make

very much a 'Frank Jenkins' style tune
is what I hear." Amen, Kirk, thanks for

it

since that
setting

it

like that;

it is

a

winner.

not only an entertaining CD

is

I

feel that this

is

has significance.

features a great variety of pure old-time tradi
tional sounds that are drawn from a relatively
It

small geographical region.
to

the personal,

styles
house

all
in

By

paying attention

micro-regional, and regional

a 50-mile radius of Kirk's
Walkertown, we can find a wide vari

found within

ety of material, style, and interpretation.

And

�even within one family, we can find variety, as
time passes, among the fiddling of Ben Jarrell,
his son Tommy, and his grandson B.F. These are
all things that one can learn to be aware of and
can increase one's appreciation of the nuances of
the music. Kirk's CD is almost a textbook to that
end. I love it and highly endorse it. Kudos to all
the musicians and production staff for jobs well-nay, excellently--

done.
KERRY BLECH

To

order: Old 97 Wrecords,

Lexington

336-275-7286
info@old97wrecords.com

Ave., Greensboro,
(phone/fax)

1400

NC 27403,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

musicologist, educator, bandleader, choir

that the mixture of musics from the African

Ameri

de

director, and pianist," in the course of complet
ing research for his doctoral dissertation, which

can and white American traditions is what

was entitled

Particular high points among the perfor
mances on the record include Clarence Harmon's

A Study of Selected Folk Songs Col
lected Mainly in Southern West Virginia Dr. Reese,
who at the time the music was recorded, in 1949-

was head of the music program at Bluefield
State College in southern West Virginia, and
1953,

was awarded

a

Ph.D. in musicology in 1955 from

the University of Southern California for his
fieldwork and dissertation. It is apparent from
Joseph Bundy's liner notes to this CD that Dr.

man of many parts (he studied
with
Arnold Schoenberg) who
composition
touched many lives during his career as a musi
cian and music educator, and it is heartening to
see how he devoted so much energy to the
collection and preservation of the folk songs of
Reece was

a

the people who resided in his part of the world.
W ith one exception, the performances on Work
&amp; Pray are sung without accompaniment. If that
sounds like it would make for a pretty severe-

sounding program, listening

to the

disc proves

The songs show a tremendous vari
some are beautiful and some are rough, as

otherwise.
ety

the renditions themselves.
Notes on the
various singers are brief (in three instances, the
singers are unknown), but provide enough back
ground to put a picture in your mind of the
person making the music. Photographs of a few
of the singers fill out one's sense of them all the
are

more.

One interesting aspect of the singers for

me was the variety of

professions represented
among them: high school teachers, retired rail
road workers and miners, proprietor of

a

school

dance, physician, college president, rever
ends a real cross-section of people from the
southern West Virginia area. It's good to be
reminded that every body is Folk.
of

The performances
recorded, and it is

are generally very clearly
a treat
to be able to hear

singing so well, the subtleties of pitch and tone
and the way notes and phrases are made. In
deed, the specificity with which pitches are often
sung in these performances reminded me of
some of the great old-time fiddlers, who of course
were influenced by singers too, and brought to
mind a great quote from the jazz musician Ornette
Coleman, who once observed,

"You can play
sharp in tune or flat in tune." A lot of the juiciest
and most expressive notes to sing or play won't
be found on

piano. A high percentage of the
songs use pentatonic scales,
either a major pentatonic
do-re-mi-sol-la-do,
or a minor pentatonic
la-do-re-mi-sol-la, which

melodies

is

to

a

the

sometimes called the blues scale. These same

scales

are

commonly found

fiddle tunes

of the

in

the songs and
of the Afri

white neighbors

can-American singers on this CD, and based
purely on the sound of the performances here, it
is clear that music was a real meeting ground for
the people of the region.

As Dr. Reece noted in

his study, a number of the songs and perfor
mances do not have what he termed a "Negroid"

quality, while others are distinctively so.

It

seems

fines

particular type of American sound.

a

"Linin' Track," a song used to guide workers in
their lifting and placing of the steel rails. Albert

McCoy's "Ten Pound Hammer" has an unusu
ally pretty melody and takes the form of a 16-bar
blues, with the second melody line repeated.
Memphis Temple Garrison sings a beautiful
version of "Steal Away" learned from her mother,

who was born into slavery. The singing of
Waldo Dickason, a retired railroad worker, re
minded of the tone and sound of Dillard Chan
dler. A number of the songs are tantalizing,
because they include only one verse and a cho
rus. Perhaps that is all the singer could remem
ber of the song. Dr. P.R. Higginbotham, does a
great rendition of the bluesy work song, "I Got A
Mrs. John Wade shows

Letter."

a

finely con

trolled sense of time and phrasing on "Good Old
Chariot." Frank Wade's pitch on "Lord I Don't
In the Storm" is similarly con
trolled to a striking degree. Rev. R.L. Pollard,
who was the head dishwasher at Bluefield State

Want To Die

College at the time the recordings were made,
sings three hymns, "Ride On, Jesus," where he
sings both calls and responses, "Rock Me
I Won't
Stop Praying," with
response line, "That's what Sa

Chariot" and "Lord,
the memorable

tan is grumbling about." An unknown singer
does "Prepare Me, Oh Lord," one of the stron

gest hymns I have heard.
This CD presents music which can be felt and

valued

in so

many ways

simply

to

listen

to, to

learn and sing along with, or to arrange in differ
ent ways and sing with instrumental accompa

niment.

There

start to

is

such

a

rich selection of songs

will not be too long before we
hope
hear people sing many of them. Thanks to

here that

I

it

Dr. Reece for his work, the

many people who sang

for him, and West Virginia

this music available.

It

University for making
needs to be heard.
JOHN M. MILLER

To

order:

West Virginia

Morgantown, WV;

University Press,
www.wvupress.com

�Grey Eagle/Chased Old Satan through
of January/Boil
Them Cabbage

the Door/8th

Gabriel/

Down/Garfield/Whistlebee/Angel
&amp;
Line/Horseshoe Bend

Hook

a fine old-time trio that hails from
Alabama.
The band is named after
Birmingham,
an old, mule-powered carnival ride, and is made
up of Jim Cauthen on fiddle, Duncan Blair on

Flying Jenny

is

banjo, and Joyce Cauthen on guitar. Jim and
Joyce are probably best known for their work in
another Alabama string band, Red Mountain
White Trash, but this CD may change all that. It
is

definitely one of the more pleasant discoveries

I've made lately.

What they guys are not is one of those oldtime music power trios. Rather than knocking
you over the head to get your attention, their
music relies on subtlety and understatement,

gently drawing you in. Despite utilizing the
almost standard format of fiddle, clawhammer
banjo, and guitar, the band has a delightful and
unique sound. This has to do with a couple of
things, one of which is the band's repertoire.
Joyce and Jim have spent years researching the
fiddling traditions of their native state, and much

material draws upon that research. In fact,
fourteen fiddle tunes played here, nine
were learned from Alabama fiddlers. The rest
of the

of the

come from fiddlers from Tennessee or Georgia
whose influence extended into Alabama and

beyond and is still felt today. A brief look at the
list of tunes reveals some familiar titles like
"Forked Deer," "Dance Around Molly," and "8th
of January." However, the
are anything but common.

versions played here
Listeners will recog

nize other well played, if more familiar, num
bers like "Boil Them Cabbage Down," "Hook
and Line," and "Horseshoe

Bend." The several
songs interspersed throughout come from a va
riety of sources, both old (Carter and Young's "A
Lazy Farmer Boy") and more contemporary
(Norman and Nancy Blake's "Angel Gabriel"). They
are sung in a sincere and heartfelt manner and
contribute greatly

to the

overall feel of the CD.

Another thing contributing to Flying Jenny's
unique sound has to do with the manner in
which they approach the tunes and songs in
their repertory. Some bands tend to try to mold
their material to fit their sound with the result

being that every piece sounds the same. Flying
to be guided by
their choice of material, exploring the intricacies

Jenny, on the other hand, seems

possibilities of each individual piece and
allowing those explorations to guide the way.
and

They know when to add the extra little push that
makes for a good dance tune like "8th of Janu
ary", or how to bring out the delicate stateliness
of one of those crooked, archaic pieces like
"Jenny
Broke Her Wooden Leg a'Dancing at the Ball."

addition to be well chosen and played, the
material on this CD is well recorded and mixed.
The accompanying notes give sources and a
brief history of the tunes and songs.
In

JIM

To order:

NELSON

www.bamalong.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�ful, but always full of pep, making this CD a
joyful listening experience. Rafe's notes provide
the listener with a brief background of each tune,
including his sources. He also briefly describes
the fiddles and bows used on the recording,

giving credit

to their

makers

as well.
JIM

To order:

NELSON

www.rafestefanini.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�very much like the one sung to "House
Watson on the
Carpenter"
by Annie
tune

is

Folkways

"The

Watson Family album.

interesting that Debby homed in on
a
girl being lured to her death by

I

think

it

tune about

a
a

ghost sea

captain. The "Amazing Grace" legend is that it
was written by a reformed sea captain who used

command the ships that carried the slaves to
America from Africa. Some of us talk about that
to

"something" in traditional music and folklore
that makes sense in these unconscious connec
tions. "Back Burner Man" is

a

song from Wanda

Jean Wangford that was written in 1956, which
explores the idea of keeping an extra man on the

side. The Motherlode

Chorus joins in on that
one. Debby plays guitar and W.B. Reid is back on
fiddle.
with

a

After"

Booze," the CD ends

"Goodbye

Carter Family waltz tune, "Valley of the

Shenandoah." Debby plays fingerpicked banjo
again, with fiddle and with harmonies. We re
turn to home and hearth with the last song.

Considering that Debby McClatchy has ex
perimented with different musical genres over
the years, it speaks well for the vitality of the
music that such a seasoned musician has chosen
old-time music as a way of expressing her view
of the

world.
PAT WALKE

To order the CD, make

a

check for $17.00 per CD

(includes shipping) made out to Debby
McClatchy and send it to the following address:
Sunhearth, P.O. Box 302, Dutch Flat CA. 95714

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Also included in this DVD is an excellent
interview between Alan and Ms Hebert, in which
Alan recounts his introduction to the violin As a
child

in Jacksonville, Florida, in a
good public
school system with an endowment for strings,
Alan was "issued" a violin-though as he says,
"if I'd known would turn out to be 6'5",
might
I

I

have picked the cello or the bass."
He had given up violin playing pretty much
by the time he got to Duke University grad

school. Then Holgar Nygard, who went on to
found Durham NC's wonderful Festival for the

Eno River, played some field recordings in a
seminar he was teaching, and
Alan was captured by fiddling. Although Alan
has always stressed the idea that he is but the
messenger, the tune carrier, it's very nice and
fitting that his public get to know a bit more
about who he
this kind and generous person
who has endowed all of us in the old-time world
is--

so

bountifully through the years.
In

short, this is

whole class
buckaroos
portrait

in
for

a

great instruction video--

a

fiddling you'd pay hundreds of
if it were "live."
And a nice

of one of the most

important fiddlers

of

our era, Alan Jabbour.
--BILL HICKS

To Order:

Groove Workshops, PO Box
2632, Amherst, MA 01004 dhebert@crocker.com
In the

www.dhebert.com/inthegrooveworkshops

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�String Ttaw

200^

Olcf-time ^Vsir \A/eef:ehiJ

*Wfc 11,12,13 5

ft

String Thaw will welcome in the
Old-Time Music festival season
with a weekend celebration at
Penland School of Crafts in the
Blue Ridge Mountains.

Thursday evening-March 11-Dlnner.
jamming, local old-time concert
Friday March 12th- Jamming with
Beverly Smith &amp; Carl Jones, tour
Penland campus, visit local artists,
Penland Gallery Opening with old-time
performance, more jamming
Saturday March 13th- Instructor
workshops, Community Dance,
jamming
Sunday. March 14th-Breakfast flnal
jam

Fees:

Long Weekend $290
Thurs-Sun room&amp; meals
Weekend $220
Fri-Sunday room&amp; meals
Dav Student $115.00
Fri-Sunday &amp; meals
Workshop Only $70
No meals/housing

All of the above fees In
clude jamming and social

gathering in the evenings.
Due to limited enrollment
register by December 15,

Workshops
Craig Johnson, Wayne &amp; Margaret Martin-Singing
All levels
Rhonda Gouge &amp; Rob Levin-Intermediate/AdvancedLead and Rhythm Guitar
Bob C arlin-Banj o-I nter mediate/Advanced
Rayna Gellert-Fiddle-Intermediate/Advanced
Margie Meisenheimer- Flat Foot Dancing/Clogging-All Levels
Contact:
Hilary Dirlam

828-689-3740

silverc@mindspring.com

Kl+p:/
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

www.

Stringthaw

Section with Illegible Text

�Ye&gt;

You've been writing songs since age

Performing them since age

LS

1

I

I

Y-^

HZ

M

5

1

Recording every chance you get

DON'T YOU DESERVE OASIS?
Look, there are plenty of other CD manufacturers

out there that claim

to be

cheaper than

us.

And some

a

competitor

that probably are. But we've never heard
J

claim

to be

better than

us.

Once you've worked with

Oasis, you'll know why.

OASIS
U

CD

J

MANUFACTURING

oasisCD.com
If you have

a

CD

that needs replication, we invite you

(888)296-2747, visit
oasisCD.com, or shoot an email
to info@oasisCD.com.

to call us at

The trusted name in
disc manufacturing.

toll-free (888)296-2747
tel (540) 987-8810
fax (540) 987-8812

email info@oasisCD.com
web oasisCD.com

But only if you're looking for the best.

12625

Lee Hwy.

Box 214

SperryviHe, VA 22740
Oasis reviews received
masters using Repli CheckMember

to

protect against piracy.

96% customer approval rating

as

of

1

1/1/02

INCLUDED WITH YOUR CDs: The OasisSampler CD Radio Promotion Program
National Distribution via cdstreet.com, CD Baby, Amazon and more
The Sonicbids Electronic Press Kit (EPK)
Consideration of your music by Soundtrack Express
Direct upload of your title to SoundScan
Display boxes and more I
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

j

�</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </file>
  </fileContainer>
  <collection collectionId="65">
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12031">
                <text>Old-Time Herald</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12032">
                <text>Presented in partnership with the nonprofit &lt;a href="https://www.wholesouth.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"&gt;Whole South Heritage Works&lt;/a&gt;, &lt;em&gt;The&amp;nbsp;Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;collection includes digital copies of every issue of&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald Magazine&lt;/em&gt;, 1987-2023.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Founded in 1987 by legendary musician Alice Gerrard,&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/em&gt;served for more than 35 years as a leading voice of the old-time music community worldwide&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;. Its&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="wixui-rich-text__text" style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt; 130-plus issues, all accessible here, contain a vast wealth of information that can’t be found elsewhere. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Issues include:&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent" data-testid="inline-content" class=""&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent-gridContainer" data-testid="mesh-container-content"&gt;&#13;
&lt;div id="comp-mf5sjgaq" class="ku3DBC zQ9jDz qvSjx3 Vq6kJx comp-mf5sjgaq wixui-rich-text" data-testid="richTextElement"&gt;&#13;
&lt;ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;deeply researched explorations into the history of old-time string-band music and related traditions&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;in-depth articles from respected historians, musicians, and writers&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;historic photographs, many of them previously unpublished&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;detailed discussion of the contemporary culture of old-time music and dance&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;field reports from regional scenes&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;interviews and oral histories&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;extensive album reviews, spotlighting both new releases and reissues of historic material&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;remembrances of departed musicians, including local community players typically overlooked in the national press&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;/ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Also included are robust community discussions and long-running, often fiery controversies waged in readers' letters to the editor.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Originally based in Galax, Virginia, the magazine was published for most of its run in Durham, North Carolina. Founding editor Alice Gerrard was succeeded in that position by Gail Gillespie, then by Sarah Bryan.&amp;nbsp;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;The Southern Music Research Center and Whole South Heritage Works are grateful to our community of donors, whose contributions made possible this significant digitization and archiving project — and to Alice Gerrard, who paved the way and made this whole thing possible.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;em&gt;A logistical note: Click on any issue's title or thumbnail image to access that entire magazine. On some screens, the PDF reader may initially display only a portion of the page. To view the issue more easily, click the "Presentation Mode" icon in the toolbar above the issue — four small arrows pointing outward in all directions. Then you can use your finger or your computer's arrow keys to scroll through the pages. Happy exploring.&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
  </collection>
  <elementSetContainer>
    <elementSet elementSetId="1">
      <name>Dublin Core</name>
      <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
      <elementContainer>
        <element elementId="50">
          <name>Title</name>
          <description>A name given to the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12537">
              <text>&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/em&gt;, Volume 9, Number 2 (Winter 2003-2004)</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="49">
          <name>Subject</name>
          <description>The topic of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12538">
              <text>Old-time music</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="41">
          <name>Description</name>
          <description>An account of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12539">
              <text>&lt;p&gt;&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;The Old-Time Herald, &lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Volume 9, Number 2 (November 2003-January 2004)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Contents include:&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Learning Tunes,” by Tony Goldenberg and Elisa Westal&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Local 1000 AFM is Taking Care of Business,” by Alice Gerrard&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“‘Breakin’ Up Christmas!’ Curriculum, Music, and Community in North Carolina Schools,” by Ken Jackson&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Makin’ Music’ at the Todd Country Store,” by Tammy Sawyer and Joe Morgan&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“The African Akonting and the Origin of the Banjo,” by Ulf Jagfors&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Dance Beat – ‘Fly to the East, Fly to the West:’ Play-Parties, Square Dancing, and Old-Time Music,” by Phil Jamison&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Workshop – Mandolin Questions,” by Bob Smakula&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Final Notes” include obituaries for Elmer C. “Shorty” Terrill; Edna Mae Davis; Mack Magaha; Paul Sutphin; Bob Pinson; Marion A. “Peanut” Brown; Arvil Hogan; and Johnny Cash&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="40">
          <name>Date</name>
          <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12540">
              <text>2003</text>
            </elementText>
            <elementText elementTextId="12555">
              <text>2004</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
      </elementContainer>
    </elementSet>
  </elementSetContainer>
  <tagContainer>
    <tag tagId="1004">
      <name>2000s</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="2782">
      <name>2003</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="2640">
      <name>2004</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5428">
      <name>Alice Gerrard</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6075">
      <name>Arvil Hogan</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5889">
      <name>Bob Pinson</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5572">
      <name>Bob Smakula</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6071">
      <name>Edna Mae Davis</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6067">
      <name>Elisa Westal</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6070">
      <name>Elmer C. “Shorty” Terrill</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6068">
      <name>Joe Morgan</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="4006">
      <name>Johnny Cash</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5746">
      <name>Ken Jackson</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6072">
      <name>Mack Magaha</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6074">
      <name>Marion A. “Peanut” Brown</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5413">
      <name>Old-Time Herald</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="1417">
      <name>Old-Time Music</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6073">
      <name>Paul Sutphin</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5474">
      <name>Phil Jamison</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6012">
      <name>Tammy Sawyer</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6066">
      <name>Tony Goldenberg</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="6069">
      <name>Ulf Jagfors</name>
    </tag>
  </tagContainer>
</item>
