<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<item xmlns="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5" itemId="2522" public="1" featured="0" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xsi:schemaLocation="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5 http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5/omeka-xml-5-0.xsd" uri="https://southernmusicresearch.org/items/show/2522?output=omeka-xml" accessDate="2026-11-20T01:12:35+00:00">
  <fileContainer>
    <file fileId="3448">
      <src>https://southernmusicresearch.org/files/original/abe3011726c0ea8eb56500f6a7f0ca2a.pdf</src>
      <authentication>60bac5331a8b80c9c6a63247bc02c11a</authentication>
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="4">
          <name>PDF Text</name>
          <description/>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="92">
              <name>Text</name>
              <description/>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12184">
                  <text>February

April

1990

Spring $4.50
THE

OLD-TIME HERALD
A

MAGAZINE

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

DEDICATED

TO

OLD-TIME

Etta Baker
One Dime Blues

MUSIC

�FESTIVALS!

CONVENTIONS!
are
Just Around
Advertise

The Corner!
Your Event
In The

OLD-TIME HERALD
Reasonable

Rates!

Write The Old Time Herald, P.O. Box 51812, Durham, NC 27717
for Ad Rates

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

^OT.D-TIME HERALp^
A

MAGAZINE DEDICATED TO OLD-TIME MUSIC

Vol. 2, No.

3

FEATURES
IN THE BRITISH ISLES
by Joan Kaminkow

7

ONE DIME BLUES
An Interview with Etta Baker
by

IN PRAISE OF BANJO PICKING
by

9

Lesley Williams

WOMEN

"MUSIC IS ABOUT FEELINGS"
An Interview with Tommy Hunter
by

13

Mike Seeger

17

Hilary Dirlam

FESTIVAL GUIDE, 1989

21

COLUMNS
The Dance Beat
Oscar Roberson

"Lean Mean Clogging Machine"

Workshop

Paul Brown

Issues In Old-Time Music
Confessions of a Folklorist
by

5

Phil Jamison

by

16

25

Joe Wilson

Ask Uncle Harold

32

DEPARTMENTS
LETTERS

2

CLASSIFIED

32

REVIEWS

35

�Letters

The Old-Time Herald welcomes letters.
They should be typed or neatly written, and
signed. They may be edited and we will print
them according to space available.
The
opinions expressed do not necessarily reflect
those of the Old-Time Herald.

Hold The

Cake--

Add More Rum
One little thing you might want to
correct: we used ½ cup of rum in the
cake instead of ¼. It won't hurt a thing,
but using ½ cup in the cake will make
everybody happier hal! or taste more
rum, of course. It's ½ cup for the cake
and ½ cup also for the glaze. [See back
cover OTH vol. 2, no. 2 for recipe.]
Ivery Kimble
Laurel Fork, VA

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Score

1

For Harold

this note with respect to
I am writing
the letter written by Harold Hausenfluck
(vol. 1 no. 7) and to the comments that
have followed. In this letter Harold gives

about how old-time country
being interpreted today.
I have had the good fortune of knowing
Harold personally for the last 4 years. I
am familiar with his musical talents and
his knowledge in the field of old-time
country music. He has been a major

his views

music

is

inspiration to me and my studies of this
music.

As far as I am concerned, Harold is an
absolute genius in this field and he
totally devotes himself to it. He truly
does have an "encyclopedic" memory of
the history of original performers and
recordings. He can also take the style of
an old-timer and play it almost exactly

like the original. I have never met anyone
with a talent this exceptional.
I have great respect for Harold's playing
ability, his knowledge and his authenticity
of style. If anyone deserves listening to,
he does. His only fault (if it is a fault) is
that he is a perfectionist.
In your "Ask Uncle Harold" column,

how about
Hausenfluck

asking

Uncle

Harold

he's real!!!

Susan Campbell
Bryn Mawr, PA

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

heroes from the past, and no one should
expect to. Musicians generally accept
this marginal existence as coming with
the territory. The point I was trying to
make from my personal experience was
that

a

full-time performing old-time band

such a marginal operation at best, that
even a small bit of support, say one or
two prestigious jobs out of 52 weekends,
is

can make an enormous
I'm very well aware

difference.
of the limited

funds that folklorists have to work with
and the difficult choices they must wrestle
with. The problem is that they persist in
seeing the issue in terms of whether it is
us or the old-timers who more needs or
deserves their money. This unfortunate
point of view casts the two generations
of musicians as rivals. Obviously the
funds available are woefully inadequate
as an economic assistance program or a
system of rewards. I'm simply suggesting
that folklorists could get more value for
their dollar if they made their choices
based on what would best strengthen the

continuation of the tradition.
I
certainly agree that 'living rooms,
and community dances, and weekend
field parties' are where old-time music is
most at home and I hope with all my
heart that it continues to flourish on that
level. The difficult point I've been trying
to raise in both my articles is that the
world has changed in such a way that the
a tradition even on an
amateur level is increasingly dependent
on some degree of success on a profes
sional level. I don't mean necessarily that

continuation of

people should

be

able

to

depend on

music as their sole means of support. I
mean simply that musicians must be
willing and able to pursue such profes
sional activities as performing, recording,

touring,

teaching,

etc.

With

the

community of old-time music lovers no

longer bounded by geographic areas or
kinship groups, but atomized through
out the country, access to the avenues of
mass

communication

keep the musicians and
touch with each other.

performances, and TV
today's equivalent of

necessary to
their audience in
Records, festival
appearances are
what the house
is

the barn dance, and the street
corner show were to a century ago. The
means of performance are equally
appropriate to their times. The big
difference of course, is that today's means
entail much greater overhead.
It's obvious that the current lack of
party,

performance opportunities for old-time
music is a reflection of the general decline
of interest in things traditional among
the American public at large. Who can
the cause and which
the effect? What seems clear is that these

say for sure which

is

things work like a spiral and that the
current direction is downwards. We can
either do what can be done to reverse the
trend or we can allow it to run down to
the point where old-time music on a
professional level is no longer even a
remote possibility. I'm afraid I don't see
anything built into the system which
would make the present trend auto
matically reverse direction at a certain
point like

pendulum.
are my points again in a
nutshell: 1) the current generation of
old-time musicians is an indispensable
So

a

here

link in the chain of the tradition; 2) some
degree of commercial success is necessary
for the survival of old-time music; and 3)
acceptance of points 1 and 2 by the
public sector folklorists would be of
great benefit to the continuation of the

music we love. No regrets, no resentment,
no jealously, no greed, no blame, no
wishful thinking. I hope I have stated it
clearly enough this time so that you all
may respond to the IDEAS and not get
thrown off the track by what you presume

my ATTITUDE to be.
Those of you who disagree with me,
please take a survey among all the old-

time musicians you know, young and
old. See how many were originally in
spired to embrace old-time music by a
performance or record or other form of
commercial musical activity. If it's not a
clear majority, then I'm dead wrong and
I'll gladly shut my trap. If you have data
to

show that

as

new people are

many

being drawn to the music as back when
the Fuzzys, the Hot Muds, the Gyppos,
the Chokers, the Swamp Roots, the
Corklifters, the Red Clays, et al, were
barnstorming around the country, please
share it and take a load off my mind. If
you have a plan to ensure the survival of
music into the future which does not

include

us

love to hear

so-called
it

'revivalists,'

I'd

and be able to put my

concerns at rest.
Those of you who do agree with me,
please don't get so caught up in the
controversy over the role of folklorists
that you forget what

I

said in my first

OTH article. It would be great to have
some help from the folklore establish
ment but it is ultimately our responsibility,
as old-time musicians and old-time music
lovers to make sure the music has the
commercial success it needs to keep
going. Please, no bashing of folklorists
they are our natural allies, and the trad
ition needs us to be working together
once again.
Mac Benford

Trumansburg, NY

�The Dance Beat

OSCAR ROBERSON
"Lean Mean Clogging Machine''
by

Jamison

Phil

The

dance music

is

almost non-stop

at

the summer fiddlers conventions in North
Carolina. Bands line up backstage for the
contest and come out one after the other
to play their best tune. Out in front of
the stage dancers of all ages, sizes, shapes,
and abilities, take advantage of the endless
supply of dance music.
With sheets of plywood and home
made clogging boards laid out on the
ground, each dancer is on an individualsized dance floor. Some people jump up
from the audience to 'cut a rug' for only
a few tunes, while others seem to be out

there dancing all day and all night with an
endless supply of energy. The dancers
are fun to watch. Especially so are the
older buck dancers, whose styles and
repertoire of steps have not been stand
ardized through lessons or workshops,
but have evolved over a lifetime of
dancing.
One dancer in particular always attracts
bit of attention. Over by the
a good
speakers at the side of the stage, he is one
of those who never seems to tire. Some
times he shares his clogging board with
others, but often he is out there all alone.
He has a repertoire of steps to match his

endless energy and sometimes he looks
as though he is thinking up new steps as
he dances. All of a sudden he'll leap into
the air and click his heels or swing a leg in
a high kick over his head.
His attire is as unusual as his unique
dance style. Decked out in an old-time
outfit with suspenders and a hat that
reads 'Whatever' across the front, he is
hard to miss. His name is Oscar Rober■on, and if they gave out awards for
originality and endurance at these events,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

would win every time.
Oscar is living proof that you're never
too old to start clogging. At age 76 he is a
relative newcomer to the dance scene. In
his youth the only dancing he did was
ballroom dancing. It was not until 1982,
at age 69, that he started to learn clogging
steps. In an interesting twist on the
passing along of a traditional dance form,
Oscar learned, not from his father,
but from his son, Greg, who has been a
member of the Green Grass Cloggers for
he

many years.

Oscar's home is in Robersonville,
North Carolina (pop. 2500), a town
founded by his grandfather, George, in
the eastern part of the state. Until he
general and
farm supply store. Greg was bitten by the
clogging bug before his dad, learning
with the Green Grass Cloggers in nearby
Greenville. On visits home he would
dance for his family, and eventually,
Oscar asked to be taught a step. After
learning a few steps, Oscar began to
show up when the Green Grass Cloggers
performed locally and he started hitting
local music festivals, including the annual
Green Grass Cloggers Day.
Oscar says,
Green Grass Cloggers Day was
observed in Greenville one day
each year and I attended and learned
to clog. Since then I have clogged
100,000 miles and plan to double

retired,

he ran the family

that.
I

do only freestyle, no precision

or team dances. I'm not

altogether

sure about the differences between
buck, flatfoot and clog. At Charlotte
(N.C.) I won the buck contest, but

Union Grove, 1987

courtesy Oscar Roberson

don't remember what I did. Free
style covers most everything.
Raymond Fairchild said that I
clogged like it should be done, said

was the real thing. He's from
Maggie Valley, Clogging Capitol of
the World. Should I argue with
I

him?

have won

a few clogging prizes,
plan to win more. I need to
brush up on what the judges expect.
I think my
steps are too wild for
them, but as long as I get a good,
great, crowd response, I'll keep
I

but

I

Doinc.

Chip Summey, an Asheville in
structor and judge, said that I was a
'real showman.' He said 'really,
really great showman.' Of course
he wasn't making me mad with
statements like that.
At the Mt. Airy clog contest, I

a curtain
call. Called back to
quiet the crowd. Never saw that
before, but I didn't place in the top
four.
Each year Oscar heads out in his
camper van to attend about 35 festivals
across the southeast. I wonder at how

got

�many different places he is mistaken for
He stays in Florida during the
a local.
winter months where he dances at clog
competitions, workshops, and fiddle and
bluegrass festivals. He speaks highly of
the Strawberry Festival and Plant City,
Florida, which lasts for ten days and has
lots of good music and some clogging.
His favorite music events are in his home
state of North Carolina. They include
the fiddlers conventions at Mt. Airy,
Galax and Union Grove.
Wherever he goes, Oscar entertains
the crowd and inspires others to dance.
He has made friends and fans across the
country. Always equipped with four or
five clogging boards, (he owns ten) he
welcomes other dancers to join in.
He says, "There's always room for
everyone, especially pretty girls."
I
asked Oscar to share his thoughts
about music, dance and life in general.
This is what he said.
I
favor old-time clawhammer
banjo music and I like long pieces
(15 minutes). I like many bands:
Doodle and the Golden River Boys,
Dry Hill Draggers. I'd rather hear
old-time. There are some good
bluegrass tunes, but old-time is
better, played fast.
When the string music gives out,
I clog
to country and rock. Good
rock music ain't all that bad, and
the younger groups are using mostly
rock-type music. I still use clog
steps, which puts me way ahead of
the other young people who are
just "hunching."
The old saying, "Every day is
like Christmas," applies to me,

especially if

I

am in the

vicinity of

think "old-time" music,
but I don't think "old-time" any
thing else. I think "young-time"
and look to the future.
Why not?), a
Quid non, (Latin
music.

I

favorite quote by Sir Humphrey
Gilbert. On all my hats wear the
phrase, "Whatever," and on my t1

shirts

1

have, "Lean Mean Clogging

Machine."

I've made more money since
stopped work in the market. While
you're working you don't have
time to make money. You're too

I

a living.
you can cope with change, you
can stay young. If you can't, you

busy making
If

doomed to become old and
complaining. Pay the 75 cents for
coffee and enjoy it. Not much you
are

can do about it.

reach 100 years, I plan
"How To" book and live
out my older years from the sales.

When

to write

I

a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

But

Dizzy Dean says, "If you've
ain't braggin'."
retired at 50 and have been
as

done
I

it, it

swinging free ever since

at

an

accelerated pace. Plan to live to

be

100. Might not make it, but I'll
come closer with a plan.
A good health rule is: Find an
exercise that you like and stick
with it. I've got mine, clogging. I
also hike, walk, rock-climb, bicycle,

white-water kayak. Hope that

and

I

don't sound too much like a human
dynamo, but you either use it or
lose it.
My engine runs on sweat. It's
cheap fuel, but it's hard to come
by

I

have very good oints and exercise
j

(clogging) keeps them that way.

I

can kick higher than my head and

when the band plays a Twist, I
shine.
I seem
to have unlimited endur
ance and can dance from noon til
midnight, with a short supper break.
I have
a good raw diet, and lungs
that hold plenty of oxygen. W atermelon is high on my summer diet
and I believe that it's a super health
food. Lots of water, sugar, and
vitamin A.
I'm looking forward to a great
season in Florida. I know many
people at all the festivals and have
more fun than any one person

should have.

The bluegrass bands don't care
much for doggers, but the oldtime bands love it. Many men and
about all women want to learn to
clog and that is fine with me. Also,
kids like to dance by the hundreds
and that's also great with me.
Let's hope that Oscar continues his
quest and inspires many others to dance;
after all, you are never too old to start.

�If

you

travel

eastwards

across

the

Atlantic Ocean for 3,000 miles, you'll
come to a land mass known as the British
Isles. They say that a few hundred years

or so ago, a lot of folks from the British
Isles went to America and took their
traditional music and dance with them,
thus playing a role in the development of
today's traditional Appalachian clogging
and old-time music c. If you travel back to
the British Isles and spend some time

there, you'll get to see and hear some of
that influential music and dance and find
out for yourself how things came to be.
You'll also see how American old-time
music's sound, look, and feel are slowly
making their way back from the United
States.

for

photo

by Joan

Kaminkow

In Great Britain, folk clubs are a very
popular venue for music, song, poetry,
or monologue. Although most folk clubs
feature professional or semi-professional
performers, many offer regular singarounds where the individual can con
tribute to the evening with his or her
own special talents. These clubs range
from the strictly traditional, featuring
unaccompanied ballads, chanties, etc.,
to an anything-goes type of atmosphere
where one may find the odd saxophone
or a dirty ditty from English music hall
tradition. In either case, songs sung at
folk clubs often contain a chorus where
the crowd loudly joins in. Although
most folk clubs are held in pubs, a pub,
whether it hosts a folk club or not, may
feature evenings devoted to get-togethers

1988 Edale Bluegrass Festival

musicians.

Folk festivals in Great Britain provide
another outlet for amateur or professional
performers, and often provide a special
area, pub, or room for the festival-goer
to join in some type of organized music
sessions. Popular instruments at these
sessions include melodeon, penny whistle,
bodrhan, guitar, fiddle, and accordion,
and it is often here that one may find the
original English, Irish, or Scottish
versions of many songs or tunes of oldtime notoriety. "Soldier's Joy" and
"Fisher's Hornpipe" come to mind as
two of the most traditional tunes often
heard.

Most people in these folk music circles
what bluegrass is, but haven't
a
situation
heard of old-time music
resembling that in the States. There are
many bluegrass clubs and a few yearly

know

festivals.

Bluegrass

audiences

are

enthusiastic and widespread. However,
if one travels around a bit and looks hard
enough, old-time sounds will be found.
From north to south, there are little
pockets of people interested in, if not
dedicated, impassioned, or even hooked
on, the sounds of old-time music. Their
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

IN THE BRITISH ISLES
by

Joan Kaminkow

access to the music, of course, is limited,
so they crave information, new tunes, or

knowledgeable American. There doesn't
a band
devoted entirely to
playing old-time music, probably due to
a

seem to be
the

distances

separating

interested

musicians. Because of the limited access
to old-time music, many of those who
perform it use a standard or limited
repertoire of tunes. However, the ded
icated musician will delve deeper and
pursue further material and instruction.
For example, in 1988 two British
musicians eagerly attended old-time
music

week

the Augusta Heritage
Elkins, W. Va., learning
from such old-time music greats as
Matokie Slaughter, Bruce Greene, and

Workshops

at

in

Melvin Wine.

As far as Appalachian-style clogging
goes, it is a lot easier to find than oldtime music. In the Midlands there is
Chesterfield's Feet First, a large, well-

known group, originally taught by the
Feet First Cloggers from Pennsylvania.
With regular performances at many of
the folk festivals, this group appears to
be the most popular and influential of
the British/American-style
clogging
groups. In the South, there's a group
called the Broken Ankles, taught by a
fellow group member who lived in the
United States for two years. Other groups
like Touch- wood or Roughshod are
scattered throughout the country. The
number of people interested in this
dance style is definitely strong, evidenced
by the 150 or so people who attended
the 1988 weekend workshop hosted by
Feet First, or by the 988 Sidmouth Folk
Festival where the clogging workshops,
led by the Wild Goose Chase Cloggers
from Minnesota, seemed to be the best
attended. Many American-style cloggers
1

continued on page 42

�one-room cabin, living

in that same

on the wages of hard labor,
ing work

basket factory, in
in Gary steel
His wife left about 1960,
in

construction,
mills.

later

a

and

divorced

photo

by

David

B.

Sutton

they
never remarried.

FOLK MUSICIAN
LOTUS DICKEY
DIES AT AGE 77
by Teri

It is

Klassen

unclear now who will fiddle

the 3 a.m. set at Bloomington's all
night old-time dances.
Or who will keep young musicians
awake with endless tales of long

trips, and who will break into song
as soon as eat or breathe.
Quentin Lotus Dickey, who did
all of that and performed at folk

concerts,

schools,

festivals

and

dance camps across the country,
died Thanksgiving night at Orange

County Hospital. He was 77.
Dickey was born and lived in
Muncie as a boy until his parents
moved to a cabin on top of a
southern Indiana hill on Grease
Gravy Road. The spot is just south
of Paoli, about 50 miles south of
Bloomington. Much of Dickey's
life was spent raising eight children

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

includ

and

Dickey

Music was important in his family
when he was a child. But his lifelong
passion for writing songs, in spare
moments at work in the garden or
at night while his children fought
in their beds upstairs, brought little
recognition until he was in his late
60s. The road to folk-world pro

minence led first to Bloomington.
An Indiana University folklorist
who "discovered" Dickey in 1981
and often performed with him said

years did not seem to have
reduced his musical endurance.
"He used to call me at any hour
of the night if he'd thought of a
song, and he would sing as much as
he had composed to me over the
phone and ask me if I liked it and of
course I always did," said folklorist
Nancy McEntire. "He would still
be playing when people one third
the

Dickey made a few trips to Nash
ville, Tenn., in the 1960s to try to
sell his songs. Country singer Ronny
Shaw put "God Made Woman for

the Man" on

45. But not until

a

was retired did he get

Dickey
ional recognition.

nat

McEntire and Massachusetts folk
lorist Dillon Bustin, who studied
in Bloomington and once lived in
Orange County had much to do
with introducing Dickey to the
folk-music world in 1981. Bustin
arranged for Dickey to give a concert
at the Library of Congress in W ashington, D.C. "From then on it was
stream of concerts and
a steady
festivals all over the country,"
McEntire said, including the National
Folk Festival in 1984.
Friends of the family and Dickey's
children said the years since his
music gained recognition have been
the happiest of his life. The day
before he died, in some pain, Dickey
asked his children to pray for his
death. As the words of a gospel
song he wrote indicate, he said he
was not afraid to go.

his age had given in to exhaustion
and fallen asleep."
He finger-picked guitar, and used
it usually as a backup to singing or
fiddling. His fiddle-playing and the
shuffle dance-step he did were gener

Ever onward on my way I'll go.
I'll follow his command.

I'll trust in him.

He'll guide me right

I

know.

I'm standing on his promise

ally in the old-time hoedown style.
his songs covered a broad

in the hollow of his hand
As ever onward on my way
I'll go. m

But

range of styles and topics.

There are novelty songs, ballads,
biblical and gospel songs, lullabies,
blues, and many love songs, some
playful, some tender, some sensuous,

some haunting. His voice moved
easily from bass notes to falsetto,

untrained, unaffected and true to
the mood of lyrics and melody.

(published

permission

by

of the

Bloomington Herald Times, con
densed from
on

an

11/25/89.)

article appearing

�Blues

OneDime

An Interview
with Etta Baker

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

that if they started me out with the best,
I'd be hooked. They were right.
The term fieldwork belies what a
recording session with Etta Baker is
really like. The setting alone lends itself

Lesley Williams

descriptions which seem just a little
romanticized. Her home of 43 years in
Morganton, North Carolina, is surround
ed by an impeccably manicured lawn
where a stray leaf would not dare to
settle, and a hedge which looks like it was
trimmed with barber's shears. The inside
of her house is as fertile as the outside,
with houseplants in virtually every room.
A cageful of finches chatters away in the
kitchen, taking every opportunity to get
in on recording sessions. Etta herself is a
person of tremendous warmth. Regard
less of how long she's known them, Etta
treats everyone like an old friend. When
first meeting and talking with Etta, you
suspect that you are with a very special
person. When you hear her play, you are

to

sure of it.
Etta is a master of the finger-picking
style of guitar known as Piedmont blues.

With her two- and three-fingered picking
style, Etta creates music not unlike her
self: subtle, gentle, and strong; accessible

by Jon

Zachary,

courtesy

Folklife

Office,

N.C.

Arts

Council

but complex;

photo

by

As

a
folklore intern for the
North Carolina Arts Council's Folklife
Section, one of my first fieldwork exper
iences has been recording guitarist Etta
Baker. I think the office's rationale was

fundamentally

beautiful.

Etta's muse is not confined to music.
Asked how her father, Boone Reid,
made his living, Etta Baker responds that
he was a farmer, hunter and log cutter.
Then she adds, 'He mostly enjoyed life.'
Judging by the spirit which she brings to
everything she does, Boone seems to
have taught his daughter well.

1913 in Caldwell County,
Carolina, Etta grew up in an

Born in

North

environment with music. She recalls that

a child she would wake up to the smell
of breakfast cooking and the sound of

as

her father's guitar. Evenings often drew
to a close with the Reid family playing
music late into the night. Music was in
the bloodlines: her grandfather was a

banjo player; her father played not only
guitar, but banjo and fiddle as well;

�harmonica and Jew's harp were

her

mother's instruments. All six of her
brothers and sisters played instruments,
as did aunts, uncles and cousins. Not
surprisingly, Etta tried as early as possible
to get in on the act. When she was three

years old and still too small to hold the
instrument, she would place her father's
guitar in the middle of the bed and try to
pluck out chords. Her father finally

bought her a small guitar of her own.
Etta also learned to play fiddle, piano
and banjo at

a

young age.

courtesy

Etta

Baker

When she grew older, Etta would
perform 'around the settlement' with
her family. Corn shuckings, entertain
ments, dances there was always a
community social event at which they
could play. The Piedmont music scene in
which Etta grew up was noteworthy in its
degree of racial integration. Etta grew up
playing with white and black musicians,
and for integrated audiences in social
settings as well. As folklorists Glenn
Hinson and Bruce Bastion have noted,
the level of interaction was such that
musicians drew freely upon both Europeon and African-American traditions,
resulting in a Piedmont musical style and
repertoire that was shared by both blacks
and whites. Blacks and whites were inter
woven not only in the fabric of their

L-R Elizabeth

fun.'
It

and

big midnight dinners.

It

home. But she was and is different,
observing, 'I'm happy to be out there."

At any rate she did decide to settle down,
and she and Lee were married in 1936.
Although she played around town
some with Lee and her family, Etta's
playing activities had to yield to other
demands. In 1936, the first of Etta's and

Lee's nine children, twins Darlene and
Irene, were born. For the first eight or
nine years of their marriage, the family
lived in Lenoir, where Lee worked as a
mechanic. The Bakers then moved to
Morganton in order to take advantage of
Lee took a job in
a better school system.
a
furniture factory and in 1949, Etta
went to work at Skyland Textiles. The

of family and job curtailed
Etta's playing in the '40s and early '50s.
"A lot of times I wanted to go on, on the
road, you know, playing my music but it
was hard to do that and raise a family,
and hold on to my job."
Lee's objections also kept Etta from
playing out. "He just didn't want me to
be gone away from home but he loved
my music," she recalls, "and I said well, if
I mean to make home and stick with the
family I got to listen." Though he was a
talented piano player himself, Lee wasn't

demands

was

seemed only natural that Etta, Cora,
Babe would all marry musicians.

Cora married Theopolis 'The' Phillips,
a guitar and banjo player whose brother
A1 also played guitar. Babe married Fred
Reid, a triple threat on banjo, guitar and
harmonica. Etta herself married a piano
player, Lee Baker. Lee lived not far from

Etta, and played at entertainments. Along
with his good looks and his dancing skill,

particularly interested

Etta cites Lee's love of music as the thing
that attracted her to him. 'He loved
music and he was nice looking and he
was just a really nice guy. He was real
good. But it was a long time before
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Moore, Etta, Cora Phillips,

could make up my mind I wanted to
settle down so it [courting] went on for
maybe five or six years.' Maybe this was
because of her independent nature, or
maybe it was her love of travel. Etta says
that most women at this time didn't play
out much, preferring to stay right around

music but in other aspects of their lives.
Etta's own family can claim Irish and
Native American lineages, as well as
African- American.
As a young woman, Etta would 'play
out' with her sister Cora on guitar, her
father on banjo and herself on violin.
She performed with her cousins, notably
Elizabeth 'Babe' Reid, also an accom
plished guitar and banjo player. It is the
gatherings of her own extended family
that Etta recalls most fondly. 'There was
enough of us that we would get started
playing and play every night at one's
house, you know, a different one's house,
for a week. We would get to playing
music and cook at night just like through
the day

"Babe"

1

in going out on
the road. "He just wasn't too much for

wanting to leave

home to

go

anywhere."

Music continued to be a part of her life,
however. Etta played at home in the
evening after work with the children
listening or joining in.

ca.

1924

Although she was not playing in public,
happy coincidence gained Mrs. Baker a
wide audience. In 1956, while vacationing
one weekend at the Moses Cone Mansion
in Blowing Rock, in the North Carolina
mountains, Lee and Etta met a man from
New York who was playing guitar. Lee
told the man that if he wanted to hear

someone really play the guitar,

he

should

hear his wife play. The man then sur
rendered his guitar to Etta and was so
impressed with the results that one week
later he came to her home to record her.
The man was Paul Clayton, and the
recordings he made along with Liam
Clancy and Diane Hamilton became Instru
mental Music of the Southern Appalachians
(Traditions 1007)- Boone, Cora, and
The are also featured on this acclaimed

album.

Though the album provided no infor
mation about any of the artists it featured,
Etta's performance on it made her legend
ary in certain circles. Her performance of
"One Dime Blues" established a standard

among

younger urban musicians who

were the main buyers of the record and
who studied each cut. If you could
achieve the level of finger-picking on the
album, then you were "one diming it."
Presumably it was this album which
provided the impetus to get Etta to begin
playing out again locally in 1958.
In 1967, Lee died of complications
from a stroke he had suffered three years
earlier. His death was sudden, after a
period where Etta gave him physical

therapy and he had made considerable

progress. Etta was and

is

philosophical

think that's why I work
so hard, like I do today. It keeps my
mind on what I'm doing. I don't have
time to think back, well, the years that
about the loss.

we

"I

worked together

in

the

yard

and

�around.

I

to

try

stay away

blurs the tune.

from that

because it's not helping me any. I done
for him what I could do when he was
living and I try to look at it the best I can
through a sensible way. It was time from

and to get

him to go and he didn't have to suffer

anymore."
In 1972, Etta, Babe, Cora, The, and
Fred were all featured on the album
Music from the Hills of Caldwell County

(Physical PR 12-001)*.

In

1973, tran

scripts of Etta's playing also appeared in
Happy Traum's Finger-Picking Styles for

Guitar. 1973 was also the year Etta
left her job at the mill. "One day I just got
the

thinking about it. It was time to leave
there and do something else." That "some
thing else" was to reach a larger audience
with her music. Her performances in the
years since she left the mill include
appearances a the 1980 World's Fair in

984 National Folk Festival
well as concerts in West
Virginia, Kentucky, Ohio, Virginia, and
New Jersey and around North Carolina.
"I guess I've played less right around in
my own hometown than I have anywhere,"
she comments. Along with Cora, Etta
was honored with a North Carolina
Folklore Society Brown-Hudson Award
1

at

as

Wolf Trap,

in 1982, and in 1988 she received
North Carolina Folk Heritage Award.

a

Etta's current repertoire consists mostly
of finger-picked, pre-blues rags and break

downs, hymns, popular tunes, and blues

played

on

the

six

string

guitar.

Her

oldest, those she
learned from her father. These include
"Carolina Breakdown," "Bully of the
Town," "Dew Drops," "Crow Jane," and
favorite tunes

are the

"Railroad Bill." "Lost John" she learned
from her mother. Etta picked up tunes
from commercial recordings. She and
Cora learned "St. Louis Blues" together
by listening to their uncle's victrola. She
also learned a number of tunes from her
"One
in-laws, The and Alfred Phillips
Dime Blues," and "Going Down The
Road Feeling Bad" among them.
Etta has also written tunes of her own.
She tells of hearing chords in her sleep at
the 1980 World's Fair, then getting up in
the middle of the night to work them out
on Cora's guitar. At a performance the
following day, she told the crowd that
she had composed a tune, but that she
had not yet named it. "Play it," they said,
"and we'll name it." "Knoxville Rag" was
the result.
Whatever the source, Etta imbues all
the tunes she plays with her own distinct

ive style. Her playing is characterized by
distinct lines and a delicate touch. Clarity
is something she strives for in her playing.
"I want my music to be clear and not hit a
string that's not necessary because that

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Y ou want to keep it clear
clear sound it's the best to

always play without picks. I don't care
for picks. I have a bunch of them but I
hardly ever use them because you can't
separate the sound.
Etta prefers to use flat wound strings
when she plays for herself, and a light
gauge steel in performance. She plays a
Takamine guitar and often uses a Silvertone amp when she is not playing acous
tically. On one side of the guitar, built
into the wood of the body, is a 3-band
equalizer and her pickup is on the tailniece.
It's

to

Knoxville, the

a

important to Etta that she makes

each tune that she plays her own. "As far

playing other people's tunes, that's
theirs. That's not my music. Now I play
'Careless Love,' which other people plays
it too, but I've got my own way of doing
it. I don't try to play like nobody else."
Etta rarely sings, feeling that her guitar
can say all that needs to be said. She
leaves the singing to daughter Dorothy,
who accompanies her on hymns from
time to time. Once in a great while she
can be talked into singing some blues.
Etta finds playing the blues an uplifting
pastime. "It's something you get out of
the
the blues that'll make you happy
as

song

is

made of someone in distress and

trouble and that didn't happen to you."

Most of the Caldwell County musicians
that Etta grew up with are gone now.
The, Al, and Fred have passed away.
Cora has been slowed by surgery, but
Etta says that Babe is still going and
playing strong. Etta is concerned that the
venues in which she originally played
and learned her music are now gone. She
recognizes that the traditions are not
being passed along the way they once
were. For Lee and Etta, music-making
was a family event. All of their children

learned to play an instrument or sing.
Etta regrets that the same thing is not
true for her grandchildren, but recognizes
the obstacles to their musical instruction.
"Children don't teach grandchildren to
play. Don't have time. I think all of that's
going down the drain." She seems to
wish that her grandchildren could be
immersed in music from the start the
way that she was, but also knows that not
all of them may have an interest. "You
just don't hear anybody starting with the

kids, you know, while they're real young.
See, what they want to do, you can't
force a kid to do something if it's not in
him to want to. Because they'll start it
after you pay a lot into it and he's ready

�to quit and do what he feels like doing.
It's best to find out what's in him before

you start with him."
While Etta laments

that

the

corn

shuckings and house parties where most
of her music used to be heard are no
more, she has had no problems with the
shift from the community social event to
"

the concert or festival stage. W ell, I just
can't tell any difference myself 'cause
anywhere I sit down with my guitar it
just seems like it just comes natural."
The music is the important thing to Etta,
who doesn't make a lot of demands
about where she plays, or with whom.
Ask her who she likes to play with and
she'll give you a list as long as your arm,
naming old-time musicians who play in a
variety of styles. For listening, Chet

Atkins

is

Etta

is

her favorite.

also

an

artist

in

the garden.

Around the side and back of the house
vegetable garden and fruit trees.
more produce than she can
but loves to share her
use,
possibly
harvest with friends and neighbors. She
can give growing tips on any number of
fruit, vegetable, and houseplant varieties.
Not content to give up her gardening in
the cold weather, Etta constructed a
hothouse in her backyard where onions,
are

a

Etta cans

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

celery, lettuce and turnips are thriving.
Her thorough knowledge of plants is
augmented by a knowledge of herbal
remedies. Each fall she travels further up
into the mountains to gather star root,
ginseng, yellowroot, and other herbs she
uses to make her own medicines.
In order to pursue all of her interests,
Etta operates at an energy level that

people

a

fraction of her age

are

hard

pressed to match. She arises between
5:00 and 5:30 each day to attend to her
gardening and housekeeping. She appre
ciates the flexibility that playing concerts
gives her, allowing that the winter slow
down in her performance schedule will
give her a chance to catch up on jobs
around the house. "I have to work real
I'm not going away anywhere
hard
now
'cause I've caught up with all
right
my contracts for now. I can get started
now and I'm cleaning up outside. I have
all my paint ready and I'm going to clean
my panelling, so I can do that, quit when
I get
ready and I enjoy doing it." One
recent visit found her just having de
scended from the roof, where she had
been repairing and painting an eave.
Another arrival found her getting ready
to split the remains of a recently felled

tree for use in
her woodburning stove. Etta's muse is a

forty-year-old

magnolia

restless one.

Etta satisfies that restless muse with
lots of appearances at festivals in and
around North Carolina. Among the stages
she played this year are JazzCharlotte,
"Seedtime on the Cumberland" at
Appalshop, and the "Sounds of the
South" conference in Chapel Hill. The
best part of playing the folk-festival
circuit for Etta is the wide variety of
people she encounters. Etta loves the
fact that she has made so many friends
through her music. "I always love to
meet different people. I love to meet the
ones 1 met years ago, and so it just goes
on and on like that. I don't meet any
strangers. 1 might meet someone I've
never seen before but it's still no stranger.
So, when I see a new face, that's just a
added friend."
The flexibility and friends that come
with her musical lifestyle mean a lot to
Etta, but not as much as her independence.
She informed me that she was far too
young to get married again. "I'm not old
enough for the second time," she laughed.
When asked how old one had to be she
replied, "You have to be one hundred
and four. Then you might be old enough
for the second time but I'm not quite
there."
"Oh, my God, I wouldn't tie myself
down no more, not for nobody. I got

friends. But when

I

get ready to go, you

stay here. I may see you years later.
really care for people. I love people but
not good enough to settle down anymore.
I just
couldn't go through with it any
more." Nine children, 24 years at the

I

mill, three years caring for her invalid
husband so much of Etta's life was
spent looking after others. When Lee
died, Etta thought about all the playing
opportunities she had forgone. "After
Lee passed I started giving up on what I
had lost out on for the past years," she
recollects. Instead of looking to a past of
lost chances, Etta looked to a future that
she could devote to her own interests, a
future full of music. "I've done most of
my traveling after [Lee] passed," she
notes. "I appreciate the years that I had
someone that I cared for but that's over.
I'm ready to do for Etta now. I love
Etta."
"I believe I'd cry if I had to get married

again. In fact, I know I would, if I tried to
live long enough to cry. I couldn't stand
it, ooh, no. The first one I had I loved
him dear enough to go along with what
he asked and what he thought was the
best for me to do, but I'll never lay my
guitar down for nobody else."

*Both the Tradition and Physical albums
out of print. Current efforts are

are

underway

to

Etta's music.

produce

a

recording

of

Lesley Williams is an intern with the
Folklife Section of the North Carolina Arts

Council. She lives in Raleigh.

PLEASE TAKE NOTE: We have
moved to Durham, N.C., and we have a
Please address ALL cor
or items to: Old-Time
P.O.
Box
Durham, N.C.
51812,
Herald,
new address.

respondence and/

27717. First class mail will

be

forwarded

from Galax for a limited time, but 3rd
and 4th class mail is not forwarded.

�When one thinks of the banjo
today what generally comes to mind is a
picture of a man in an ensemble playing
serious, often jazz-like music based on a
style initiated by the most influential and
widely imitated banjoist of all time, Earl
Scruggs. This style is barely 50 years old
and has involved a long evolution since

IN PRAISE
OF

gourd instrument that came here
from Africa in the 17 th and 18th

the

centuries.

1

hat

instrument was handmade

from whatever organic materials would
have been available. The sound was quiet

often solo but soon after Africans
brought here as slaves they no
doubt began producing music differently
and in different combinations than they
had in their homeland.
We know very little about the music
from this era since few writers thought

and

were

or everyday music was
worth writing about. It was only after
Anglo-American people began playing

that vernacular

the instrument

in the early

1800s that

some writers began taking note. What
we do have are a few travelers' accounts
and artists' drawings and paintings from
around 1800. And they show only AfroAmerican men (no women) solo or in
ensembles, with the banjo. Similarly,
until the late 1800s, drawings, photos,
and written accounts all suggest that only
Euro-American men played the banjo.
Around the turn of the century, however,
one begins to see photographs of women,
either holding the instrument in a dreamy
pose in a formal drawing room setting,
or, perhaps a little later, with a formally
arranged string orchestra.

whether AfroI have often wondered
American women picked the banjo. I
feel that when Elizabeth Cotten played
the banj o around 900 she was probably
1

I have talked
with many Anglo-American old-timers
in the mountains who tell me that their
fathers and mothers picked the banjo
before the turn of the century. Why,
then, do we not have accounts of this
either visually or in literature? I believe

because it was not
is primarily
considered dignified for a woman to be
seen with a banjo, which was then con
sidered a rollicking party and dance
instrument. And when the banjo became
more dignified and classicalized in the
late 1800s, we begin to see evidence of

Jones

not the first to do so. And

what had been going on to some extent
all along. I have known a number of
women who picked the banjo in the early
Elizabeth Cotten, Hattie Stone1900s
man and Sara Boggs (Dock's wife) to
name but a few. Their styles varied from
the quiet to the lively and raucous. Often
their picking was solo or as accompani-

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

courtesy

Loyal

this

Lily May Ledford

BANJO-PICKING WOMEN
by

Mike Seeger

�ment to an old-time song.
As mountain string bands developed
in the early 1900s they consisted mostly
of men, in public at least. Again, 1
suspect this was because it was "frolic"
or party music and it could get pretty
rowdy. The banjo at this time was giving
way to the guitar as support to the fiddle,
and was less suited than the guitar to the
new hillbilly songs. But in the 1930s the
banjo sometimes took on a new role
within performing string bands in a style
based on the old Kentucky rapping or
frailing stroke. This type of banjo lead

communicated unmistakeable excitement
with its strong, driving melodic breaks,
using

a

banjo picking in the late 1960s. I have a
number of tapes made of her in the '50s,
'60s, and early '70s which I expect to edit
into a couple of LPs.
he next generation younger, Lily
May Ledford was also from Kentucky,
and at least as well known and nearly as
influential as Cousin Emmy. Her touch
was stronger and more percussive than
I

Cousin Emmy's and to me the excitement

and drive of her playing could parallel
that of Earl Scruggs's early recordings.
She was the instrumental mainstay of the

Coon Creek Girls,
band

organized

an

all-woman string

by John

Lair

in

the

1930s. John Lair had also been

a

formative

influence with Cousin Emmy (and would
soon be with the Amburgey Sisters as
well). The Coon Creek Girls played
mostly at Lair's Renfro Valley Barn
Dance and recorded a few nice 78s in the
1930s. Lily May also played fiddle and
guitar, and sang. Her stage presence was
energetic and in later years, reflective
and regal. She was a big influence on me
and on my brother, Pete. Some of my
earliest remembrances of banjo picking
were some handcut radio transcriptions
of the Coon Creek Girls playing "Cindy"
and "How Many Biscuits Can You Eat"

guitar and string bass for rhythmic

support. As far as I can tell from early
recordings and recent interviews, this
style was initiated and played by women,
all of them from Kentucky. Some of the
groups consisted solely of women and
many of the best known players were
encouraged and managed by promoter
John Lair.

Certainly Cousin Emmy was the first
probably the most influential of
these banjo-picking country entertainers
to establish herself. Born and raised in
western Kentucky just after the turn of
and

the century,

she came from

a

family of

musicians. She was without a doubt the
most energetic old-time music performer
have ever seen. She often led

1

a

large

troupe of musicians and dancers in the
rough and tumble thirties, sang in a clear
limber voice, and played more than a
dozen instruments. Her image was one of
brash banjo picking woman. Her rapping
style was fast and smooth and she could
also play the picking, or chord style on
slower songs. She was a spirited musician,
tall, blonde, and charismatic. She played
of songs on the banjo, from
a variety
"Old Timbrook" ("Molly and Tenno doubt learned from her
brooks"
a

family) to pieces of English ballads such

"Scat Tom Kitty Puss," or tum-of-thecentury sentimental songs such as "Little
Joe." She played a variety of radio stations
and shows throughout the South and
Mid-west in the 1930s and 1940s. As a
result, the range of her impact on other
as

she

recorded

Music

very

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Country

unfortunately

little. Her Decca album has never been
re-issued. Her Folkways album with the
New Lost City Ramblers (FTS 3 1 0 1 5) is
still in print and is a good example of her

courtesy

but

Foundation

banjo pickers was, I believe, considerable.
For instance, while she was in Wheeling
West Virginia, one of her banjo students
was the now legendary Grandpa Jones.
Her Decca 78s of the mid-forties intro
duced her to an urban audience as well.
In the 1950s she appeared in a number of
second-or third-rate Hollywood films,

Cousin Emmy

�Queen of England at the
White House in 1939. Those recordings
and some of the best 78s by the Coon
Creek Girls are on Old Homestead 142.
It's an excellent LP and a good repre
sentation of them at their best. They
recorded again in the 1960s (County
712) and Lily May recorded a solo LP in
the 1980s (Greenhays 712).
After these two pioneer Kentucky
banjo picking women there were several
others from a still younger generation.
Molly O'Day's banjo-picking style was
in a sense a mixture of Cousin Emmy's
smooth sound and Lily May's percussive,
for the King and

punchy rhythm. She leaned more towards
the country music of the 1940s so her
banjo picking was a smaller part of her

song using a picked, not rapped 5-string
probably played by her husband
banjo,
Lynn.
There were several other banjo-picking
women that were active in the 1940s and
'50s. Jean Chapel (Mattie O'Neal), one
of the Amburgey (Amber) sisters was
from Neon, Kentucky, and first learned
banjo from her father, and by watching
herself in a mirror to get the hang of it.
She plays a variety of instruments and
still plays music, mostly as a rock and
roll entertainer. She has written a number
of country hit songs. She recorded my
favorite of her songs about 1952, "You
Can't Live With 'Em (And You Can't
Live Without 'Em)" with her sisters,
Martha Carson and Bertha Woodruff.
She played a driving clawhammer-style
banjo and sang lead on the song. It's been
re-issued on Library of Congress issue

repertoire than songs that used Hawaiian
guitar. Like Cousin Emmy she was a
beautiful singer and had old songs such
as "Barbara Allen" in her repertoire.
Some of her best gospel songs recorded
in the 1940s have been re-issued on Old
Homestead 101, including four examples

of her banjo picking at its best. Two LPs
of more recently recorded gospel songs,
some with banjo, are on Old Homestead
312 and 313. My favorite of hers, "Poor
Ellen Smith," is not to my knowledge
re-issued. She appears on two other Old
Homestead LPs playing old-time banjo
rhythm behind brother Skeets William
son's fiddling on one. On the other,
mostly a nice selection of re-issues of her
best 1940s recordings, there is only one

LBC 7.

Another good player about whom

1

have been unable to learn anything was
Katy Hill (Helen Osborne). She played
faster and with a harder sound than any
of the players I've written about here
she had that driving Kentucky sound.

She played briefly with Charlie Monroe
in the 1940s and appears on two LPs of
his radio shows, County 538 and 539.
As with all of these banjo-picking women
it is a pity that she didn't record more.
No discussion of banjo-picking women
can be complete without Olabelle Reed.
Her North Carolina banjo-picking style
is different from the players
I
have
mentioned above, who were all from
Kentucky. Her style is less driving and is
a hybrid
of clawhammer and western
North Carolina "up-and-down" picking.
She was influenced by players in her
native North Carolina but also, I'm sure,
by the recordings of the women mentioned
above. In the 1960s she began to con
centrate on her songwriting and is best
known for songs such as "High on the
Mountain," and "Only the Leading Role
Will Do." She can be heard on Rounder

0021 and 0077.

Sometimes when

I
see Doily Parton
think that some part
of this older banjo tradition is continuing.
But among most modern players their
mountain music identity becomes diluted
as they reach for ever larger audiences.
And it was the commitment to country
identity that was one of the strongest
elements in the music of the older banjo-

courtesy

Country

Music

Foundation

picking the banjo

Molly O'Day

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

I

picking entertainers.

An exception to
this is the playing and stage presence of
Roni Stoneman; her drive and sense of
humor remind me of Cousin Emmy. But
both Parton and Stoneman play in Earl

continued on page 43

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Flyin' Cloud

Records

Doug Rorror
Rt. 2, Box 436
Madison, NC 27025
FC-001

OLD HOLLOW

STRINGBAND

Old time

music from North Carolina
CASS $8.00

FC-007

VARIOUS ARTISTS
Virginia Carolina Sampler
Lonnie Austin, Wayne
Henderson, others
CASS $8.00

FC-010

CONTEST FAVORITES
Wayne Henderson, Robin

Kessinger (guitar)
LP or CASS

$8.00

Please include $1.50 handling for US
residents; Canadian residents $4.00.
NC residents add 5% sales tax.

�"MUSIC
IS

ABOUT
FEELINGS"
An Interview

with

Tommy Hunter
Hilary Dirlam

courtesy

Tommy

Hunter

by

I

asked Tommy Hunter why he
felt a musician might turn to the fiddle
rather than another instrument. "It's just
something in that person," he told me. "I
think he's born with that in him." Tommy
Hunter could have been talking about
himself. Having decided upon the fiddle
at the age of seven, he's never looked
back. "The fiddle was it," he says.
Tommy Hunter was born in 1919 in
the community of Laurel Branch in
Madison County, North Carolina. "When
I was growing up we lived in a log cabin
on my grandfather's farm. We didn't

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

have electricity; we used oil lamps. We
got most of our food from the garden. If
you didn't have food to put away for the
winter
well, you had it rough.
"My daddy and grandfather were both
carpenters. They had a sawmill at one

time, too. That brought in some money.
There were never a lot of jobs in Madison
County, but society had changed and
you needed more money than before
when you could get all you needed from
the earth.

"We used
it was
then

to
a

walk

to

school

back

two-room schoolhouse.

was only six months out of the
I could get
I read everything
then.
year
back
hands
on
then,
especially
my
Western magazines."
Tommy's family is descended from
the Scotch-Irish people who settled in
the mountains of western North Carolina
around two hundred years ago. "Those
Scotch and Irish people must have liked
these highlands because a lot of them
settled here," says Tommy, adding "I've
got some Indian blood too, which I'm

School

proud of."

Tommy's family heritage also includes

�in the key of G."

Tommy Hunter's father, Roswell Gar
land Hunter, born in 1898, played the
five-string banjo with the band. "There

usually a banjo player around
back then [in the early '20sJ. It didn't
that's
really get popular till the '50s
when it come in. My daddy played in two
styles. He played in the two-finger style
some. It's not what you call clawhammer
or drop-thumb style, it's smoother. It's
also more complicated than it looks
because it gets every note. He could also
play a three-finger style. It's not Scruggs
style. He played similar to Van Epps, a
classical banjo style, using all his fingers,
but he olaved traditional, not classical.
"He also made the first set of picks
that was probably ever made. He wanted
to pick the strings up with his fingernails,
but they were too soft and they broke.
Well, back then you could go to the
store and buy a can of milk for a nickle.
He cut picks out of one of them just like
his fingernails. Then he made one for his
thumb, and after he got used to playing
with them he never had to worry about
wasn't

breaking his nails."
Tommy says there was one radio in
Laurel Branch when he was a small boy.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a

When Tommy was about 20, just
before World War II, he got his first job
playing out, on his own, without other

radio.

little store, hardly bigger than
this kitchen. People would crowd in on
neighbors and friends of
Friday nights
and listen to the Grand Ole
the family
Opry."
"Back then fiddle players used gut
strings that would have to be retuned all
the time because each time you played
they'd get jerked out of tune. Then
a

members of his family band. "One morn
ing I got up early, caught a bus, and went
to Asheville. I went to WWNC (an
Asheville radio station still sponsoring a
live traditional music show). The Morris
Brothers was playing there then. I asked
them for a job, and stayed with them for
about a year. They were mainly singers,
and I was their fiddler. We played every
day on the radio. Then World War II

they'd play on those old hard-wound
steel strings. It was tough, but they could
play on them almost as smooth as gut.
Sometimes you'd see a fiddle player
whose bow didn't have more than 20

came along."

Tommy went first to Ireland, where he
heard Irish music for the first time. "It

hairs on it. A lot of times there was no

helped me understand a lot not play
like them, but to understand the music.
My battalion had an orchestra, and I
played guitar in it. We played popular
music of the day; 'In the Mood,' and

money to buy a good fiddle bow. The
itself might be good but it is

fiddle

amazing to me how they could handle the
with those
and sound good
music
terrible steel strings and just a few hairs
on the bow!"
Tommy's grandfather's fiddle was

already ancient when he started playing
it. Legend has it that the fiddle had been
hidden in a rock crevice during the Civil
War to keep the Yankees from stealing
it. Tommy's uncle still has Uncle Jim's
fiddle, and Tommy says it still sounds
good, although "you can see where a
little mouse went in there and built him a
nest."
Tommy began learning by listening.
"My grandfather didn't sit me down and
play for me to learn from, I just had to
get it when he played. I used to slip his

fiddle out and play it or try to play
it
and put it back without him noticing.
It think he knew, though. I was always
afraid I'd get quarreled at about his
fiddle, but that never happened. If I got

to hear him play a tune two or three
times I got to where I could whistle a
little of it. When I got to hear him play
the same tune again, I could get it on the
fiddle."
T ommy was playing in his family band

songs like that. I wrote a letter home to
the folks saying not to worry about me, I
was playing in an orchestra. I thought
that would make them feel better."
Tommy sent his fiddle back home,
though, when his battalion was sent to
North Africa. From there he went to
Anzio Beach. It was four years before he
returned to the mountains of western
North Carolina.
Tommy then married, and worked in
construction and as a radio and T.V.
repairman.

He

though. Mostly

never
he

stopped playing,
played with his family

band.
In

1961

Tommy Hunter's Carolina

String Band, as it was then called, traveled
New Jersey to make a record for

to

Prestige International (No. 13026). The
Hunter Brothers, another configuration
of Tommy's family band, played at the

the age of twelve, and got his first
fiddle as a teenager, up in Virginia. "We
moved up to southern Virginia for a few
at

years, and I made friends up there. One
of them had a fiddle, and I had a shotgun.
it for that fiddle. Some days I
I traded
didn't play; I had duties, school and all,
and doing chores for my parents.
days I had to go into the fields and
But most of the time I got to play
wanted to. "While Tommy was

Some
work.
when I
still

a

teenager, he went to a fiddlers convention
at the
Marshall schoolhouse (several
miles from his home). "Fiddlin' Bill
Hensley and some of the other old
fiddlers from all around was there. They
had a good show, and that was one thing
that spurred me on and made me try
harder."

Hunter

music isn't so strong in the generation
after me. The heritage has gotten lost in
the shuffle, I think."
Uncle Jim's Band, as it was called then,
played for various get-togethers all over
Madison County, including square dances
for which they got paid, "which made
"
them professionals, says T ommy Dances
back then were often held in peoples
houses. "They would walk in from all
directions. The house would be full, and
there would be people standing out in
the yard
just to hear them play. It
doesn't happen that way anymore. T oday
it has to be on a stage, and formal. But
back then, people would dance in the
living room, if the foundation was strong
enough. They'd move the furniture out,
and folks would get up and buck dance
all night. Fiddlin' Jim's most-requested
tune was 'Sally Goodin,' which he played

remember when my uncle got

Tommy

existed for nearly a hundred years now.
"Everyone in my family could sing or
dance or play an instrument, although

"I

He had

courtesy

rich musical tradition. His grandfather,
James Wylie Hunter, and his great-uncle,
Jess Hunter, were both fiddlers. "They
called my grandfather Fiddlin' Jim, Singin'
he could do it all. I've
Jim, Dancin' Jim
never heard one to this day that could
outdo him. He could just make you
stand up and take notice."
Tommy figures that in one incarnation
or another (with older members dropping
out and being replaced by younger
musicians) the Hunter family band has
a

Tommy's parents, Roswell Garland Hunter
Bailey Hunter ca. 1915

&amp;.

Orla

�Philadelphia Folk Festival

in the mid'50s. "Obray Ramsey, one of my brothers,
and I went; it was the biggest festival I
ever played in. Judy Collins, Theodore
Bickel and Mississippi John Hurt were

there. I just loved his guitar playing. I
went over and listened to him play, but 1
never did introduce myself. He wouldn't
have known who I was, anyway! Every
body had a little program set, 15 or 20
minutes. I remember we played 'Buffalo
Gals,' and the last tune was 'Billy in the

Lowground.' People really seemed to
like it. believe that was the farthest Pve
ever traveled to perform.
Tommy met Manco Sneed once, in
1

the early '60s.
I had heard about Manco Sneed tor

a

long time. People told me he lived in
Cherokee, and I kept hoping I'd see him.
One day I was driving through Cherokee
and I thought 'If I'm ever going to get to
see him it's going to be now.' 1 got
directions at the service station, and
found where he lived. He lived in a little
cabin, and he was sitting outside on the
porch. I said, 'I've heard a lot about you;
I'd love to hear you play,' and I got my
fiddle out and handed it to him. He laid
my fiddle up on his arm and said, 'This is
isn't it?' I guess he was
a factory fiddle,
used to playing a homemade fiddle. He
was a very friendly person. He played for
about half an hour. 'Lady Hamilton'
he played that, and 'Paddy on the Turn
pike,' and 'Three Forks of the Big Sandy.'
That was the only time I ever saw him.
And I was always glad I stopped. Some
times you just have to make things
happen, and that's what I done."
started
In the early '70s, Tommy
playing with the Hornpipers, including
Mack Snodderly on twin fiddle and
Carroll Best on banjo. In 1986 Tommy
began putting in occasional appearances
with the Carroll Best Band, although ill
health is now preventing him from playing
much.
In 1 976 T ommy recorded an album of
his tunes, Deep in Tradition, for June
Appal, accompanied by J ohn McCutcheon.
Tommy has received numerous awards
for his fiddling, including at least eight
from the Asheville Folk Festival and
several for his contributions to the
Bascom Lamar Lunsford Festival in Mars
Hill. He received the Appalachian

Consortium award

1971, played

in

grandfather

was

took

'Sandy

River,'"

lot to learn

says
right."

Tommy.
Tommy's grandfather and his great uncle
"It

a

it

great early influences on
Tommy's style, playing different styles
and tunes. "My grandfather used the
bow, moved with every note. One tune
he
he played was 'Bonaparte's Retreat'
called it 'The Downfall of Paris.' I learned
it as best I could, and I wouldn't change it
for the world." Tommy feels strongly
about his own fiddle playing, emphasizing
the fact that he has worked hard to
develop his own style, regardless of his
great love and respect for his early
influences. "I didn't copy anybody," he
states, going on to say that if someone
had wanted to, it would have been
impossible before the advent of tape
were

also

recorders. "When my grandfather took a
notion to play and he played when he

wanted to, not when somebody else
wanted him to I had to listen and get
those tunes. He never did set me down
and go over them with me."
Tommy feels that his own style can be
defined by his distinctive phrasing and
where he places ornamentation in his
tunes. And although he has adapted his
grandfather's style, "smoothing it out,"
as he says, Tommy feels that his use of
the shuffle also helps to define his style.
"Back then fiddlers shuffled all the time,
that's what put the spirit in it! I make a
lot of my notes using the bow rather than
noting them." Another thing distinguish
ing T ommy 's playing is that it is as much
for listening as it is for dancing. Each

in

in

Tommy

Mountain Magic Festival

Hunter

the Festival of American Folklife for the
Bicentennial, and was given an award as a
Master of Old-Time Music at the 1980

W aynesville,

In 1989, Tommy Hunter received the
North Carolina Folk Heritage award.

"The

first tune

I

learned

from my

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Courtesy

North Carolina.

for Prestige in the early '60s. L-R: Obray
Ramsey, George Fisher, Tommy, (sister) Nan Fisher.

Recording

�tune

is

well

your wits about you!"
"Crossing the Shannon"

thought out, with much

("Tommy
Hunter's Reel #2") was written in about
fifteen minutes. "1 never changed a note
but it took me awhile to
after I wrote it

to details. Each tune is
distinctive, set off by Tommy's precise
and beautiful noting, phrasing, and bowing

attention

patterns. Difficult to describe in words,
it is as if he is able to pick out the core or
heart of each tune and communicate that
to the listener; this is where his technical
ability is directed.
Another important factor defining
Tommy's style is the tunes themselves.
Although he has a repertoire of several

hundred

tunes and songs,

get the notes right

including

in the key of G. He played
"
other tunes in E, too. One tune, "Horse
shoe Bend," Tommy plays cross-tuned
in A; another, "Cluck Old Hen" (again,
no relation to the better-known version
of this tune in A) is played in "Bonaparte's
Retreat" tuning with the G-string tuned
down to D.
"My grandfather could play for I don't
know how long without playing the same
tune starting with 'Nancy Rowland,'
'Sandy River,' 'Cumberland Gap,' (which
he called 'Roaring Branch'). I guess I play
most of the ones he played. He played
I don't
one called the 'Jersey Quickstep'
recall that one
and other two-steps. He
'
'
played W agoner "T ennessee Wagoner
called
and one
'Kentucky Wagoner.'"
Tommy says he has always liked the
keys of G and C, although he likes A for
volume. He pays great attention to tone.
"When you set up a fiddle, it takes a
while for it to settle in, to where the
vibrations are right. When you play,
you're creating a tremendous amount of
vibration. Sometimes I want to tune the
fiddle way down, to where it sounds
right for my mood. I don't tune it down

courtesy

Tommy

Hunter

standards, the tunes closest to his heart
and the ones he plays most often are the
40 some tunes he learned from his greatuncle and his grandfather.
"The way they played back then, they
didn't think so much about what key
they were in. They were after a certain

sound." Tommy says that one of his
grandfather's tunes, "Ryestraw" (no
relation to the "Ryestraw" in A and D)

Tommy &amp; Nina Hunter

ca.

1941

was played

to any particular spot."

Over the years, Tommy has written
fiddle tunes, as well as learning tunes
from other fiddlers. "I started writing
tunes back in my teens. What started me
out was that I liked variations, but not
too many, and not too great. I listened to
lots of different styles of fiddling and got
the sounds in my head. I have been able
in
to remember those different sounds
the music business you've got to have a
and that helped me
good memory!
with
my
style
regard to writing
develop
my tunes, and helped me remember
them." Some of Tommy's tunes can be

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

I

had to practice."

don't know where the tunes that
write come from. I hear a lot of sounds.
"I

I
1

always have music going on in my head,
unless something else 1 absolutely have
to think about is going on. And some of
the sounds sort of take hold. I guess
that's the best way to describe it."
Tommy has spent time at fiddlers
conventions, both as a contestant and as
a judge. "I have won several first places,"
Tommy says, "but there's a contest
circuit type fiddling and I never have
gotten into it. The style doesn't have
anything to do with old-time fiddling. I
didn't want to sit there all winter and
practice one tune so I could go out and
win something in the spring. That just
wasn't my thing, so I didn't do it. I
wanted to be free to play whatever I
wanted
'Turkey in the Straw' or what
ever!"

fiddlers conventions
Tennessee, and for
several years at Fiddlers Grove. "I don't
really like contest judging, but some

Tommy judged
Mars

in

Hill,

at

in

body had to do it. There are a lot of
musicians who want to play in competition
and you can't have a competition without
judges. I always tried to pick out the ones

courtesy

Tommy

Hunter

I

ca.

1946

heard on his June Appal recording; others
are in the music archive at Mars Hill

College. Some

are currently played by
other fiddlers in the area.
When write a tune sometimes get
the first part all at once, and then I have
sometimes
to hunt for the second part
that will match the first part. When I
wrote 'Tommy Hunter's Reel' 1 had
heard 'Rutland's Reel,' which is a fine
tune. I wanted to write something on
I tried
that order but not really like it
to write something to suit me." "Tommy
1

1

Hunter's Reel" is a hauntingly beautiful
four-part tune, moving from D through
C and ending in A minor. "Y ou' ve got to
be sharp to play it
you've got to have

thought should win, and tried to live

with my feelings about it."
Tommy's feelings about traditional
music go very deep; music, he says, is
ultimately about feelings. "Nobody can
write fiddle music down. This doctor
over at Mars Hill College, he wrote down
the notes. But you can't write down
someone's feelings. If you learn it from
notes you're just playing what the other
person plays. Y ou're not putting anything
individual into it. I think I've had feelings
that maybe the music was inside me
before I ever played, before I knew what
I was trying to do. It was already there. I
don't know why I love those old tunes
but I do. I've played other
their sounds
kinds of music, and I could have gone on
to another newer kind of fiddling. But
over the years I've stuck with my base, so
to speak. My first priority has been those
old tunes. And that's why I believe I've
earned the right to be called an old-time
fiddler."
wish to thank Wayne Martin for his
assistance in preparing this
H.D.
article.
I

technical

Hilary Dirlam
editor of the

is

OTH.

a

musician, and associate

�FESTIVAL

GUIDE,

1989

Seed catalogs, W-2 forms, and valentines are hitting the mailbox, so our thoughts naturally turn to which fiddlers conventions we
can cram into our calendar this year. Everybody has their own must-do events, but for a look at what else is around for 1990, we
offer this selection of festivals, competitions, and camps. So shake out the sleeping bags, count the tent shakes, cozy up the fireplace,
find a great old-time event missing from this list, drop us a line and we 11 include it next
in
and
1990 weekends. If
pencil

your

you

year.

Bear in mind that dates can change due to flooding, earthquakes, and other catastrophes, so check betore you loaa up tne
doesn t indicate this, please check to
Winnebago. Bear in mind, also, that some competitions require pre-registration. If publicity
because
for
to
find
you didn t pre-register.
competition
make sure. Don't drive a long distance, only
yourself ineligible

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�and the Augusta Heritage Center host many concerts, workshops, etc., throughout the spring
on all events.
for
information
them
Write
and summer.

NOTE: Both the Ozark Folk Center

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�bers."

Issues In Old-Time Music
off that young urban musician tag.
acronym is YURM and he could
brand himself and others for life. Second,
nothing could be further from the truth.
The few folklorists who ever think about
it like revival musicians almost as much
It may seem
as they like themselves.
rival the
could
that
any group
impossible
revival in admiring itself, but they do.
Mac's account of folkie travails in the
to lay

The

The Issues In Old-Time Music column
was established as a forum for the expression
of ideas and points of view, some of which
Points of view
controversial.
be
may
expressed in this column are not necessarily
those of the Old-Time Herald.

a culprit for changes
eroded professional opportunities in

late '70s tries to find

Confessions Of
Folklorist
by

that

A

old-time music. He offers folklorists as
the evildoers in his scenario in a mental
process that is reminiscent of the pulp

Joe Wilson
to introduce myself.
devil incarnate, the folklorist who

Please allow me
I'm the

stopped the annual booking of the High
woods Stringband at that ultimate status
conferring event, the National Folk Fes
tival.
Moreover, I'm not born again;
that was fourteen years ago and I'm to
tally unrepentant and absolutely certain
was the right thing to do.

it

My first confession is that I'm not re
ally a folklorist. Folklorists are members
of an academic discipline, and I'm terribly
undisciplined, no good at university de
partmental politics, and a failure at con
I
go through entire
ceptual thinking.
I have
days without defining anything.
been reading books written by folklorists
for over thirty years and dabbling in their
pond, but I've never loitered at a univer
sity long enough for them to invite me to
engage in that rite of passage where mor
tarboards are worn and sheep hides dis
tributed, with the participants becoming
what one of my mountain friends calls
"talking doctors." I think they'd let me
be a folklorist if I would submit my head
for two or three years of probing and
stuffing, but there's a part of me that
prefers being the red-headed stepchild in
the family.
Nobody expects much of
there's
so
always a chance you can
you,
offer

a

happy surprise.

Moreover, I have become important to
folklorists because I can be counted on to
buy almost any new book about folklore.
Due to the small sales of most folklore
books, this gives me an enormous lever
age. Who would risk offending a happy
and gullible steady customer?
Mac Benford believes that young urban
revivalist musicians have a problem with
folklorists. I feel I should first urge him

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

mystery where one begins to suspect the
poor butler on the third page.
Mac mentions me by job in 1976, "the
prospective director of the NCTA," and
The "input"
recalls "providing input."
was that Mac and others thought the or

ganization that employs me should be
come a booking agency for Highwoods

and other performing groups. Mac said,
"We just want to earn our living at this
the way Gid and Riley and those guys
did." I was dumbfounded, so taken aback
that the phrase has

remained intact

in my

memory.

What stunned me was that Mac didn't
that Gid was a chicken farmer,

know

McMichen

an

automobile mechanic, and

did a blind man's act on the
street with a tin cup. They didn't make a
living from being the Skillet Lickers.
Mac had assimilated the sound from those
old 78s, but the players of that music re

that Riley

mained as remote

as if

they had lived on

They'd be
come a romantic vision, cheery fellows
who tootled about the South making a
good living playing old-time music.
Has any old-time musician ever earned
the other side of the moon.

a

living

playing

instrumental

thought

I

it a

funny comment then,

The
but now it seems almost profound.
new set of values says that it is better to
be a professional artist than a good barber

music?

One can point to the Carter Family,

the

Mainers, Uncle Dave, Jimmie Rodgers,
Fiddling John, and a few others, but their
living came from vocals or showman
ship.
When folk arts apprenticeships were
invented a few years back, Kathy James
wondered if it might be a good idea for
the young learners to also learn the trades
"The people
of their master teachers.
who are learning from Dewey (Balfa)
should learn to drive a school bus, and
those Tommy (Jarrell) is teaching should
learn how to scrape a gravel road and
make moonshine," she said. "We'd have
great music and lots of bright young bar

who is the best fiddler in town. Is it? I
asked the opinion of former Kentucky
coal miner and present Tennessee hog and
cattle farmer and very fine fiddler Kenny
Baker. "Put me down on the side of good
barbers," Kenny said.

My second confession is that I was not
I
didn't say,
totally candid with Mac.
in
country music
"Mac, professionalism
and you're no
is a crooning game
I
liked Highwoods and had
crooner."
heard them a lot, and I knew Mac was no

I'd spent some
crooner.
years in
a
bit
time
work
of
Nashville, including

ing for Marty Robbins, so I knew about
the right song and right voice formula,
but I figured Mac had a better friend than

me who could tell him the hard truth.
I'll admit that Mac is better in the vo
cal department than me, and I have a
record of me and others that proves it.
I
sing people think I'm having
severe gastric distress. If I continue, they
Mac's career as a
fear it is terminal.
crooner snagged on the fact that he sounds
more like me than he does Marty Robbins.
What Mac s article in the spring issue
of the OTH makes clear is that his better

Whenever

friend didn't tell him the hard truth about
his crooning abilities. More to the point,
Mac is still singing the same "song" he

did when he visited me in 1976. He is
saying that folklorists have not helped
him and other tradition borrowers become

professional musicians.

In my case he is
right. We have very different ideas of
what my job is.
He says that being booked on the Na

tional and Smithsonian festivals helped
He believes I
his group obtain jobs.
should plan the National Folk Festival
with an eye to providing those selected
with entries for their resumes and clip
pings for their press kits. But the option
is more mine than his, and that is not
what
It

choose to do with my life.
borders on the busny-tailea side ot

I

the paranoid to say that government folk
lorists shut down the '60s-'70s boomlet
In Mac's telling the
in old-time music.
two or three minuscule efforts the gov
ernment began in the direction of folk arts
in the

1970s were staffed by enforcers for

political right who were fearful that
government funds would be used to sup
the

port "radicals." In fact, the old-time mu
sic boomlet closed down on cue with the
rest of what has been called "the great
folk music scare of the sixties." There

came

a

day

when people who had been

�generally supportive were not

as

inter

ested as they had been. There are morn
ings when the nation gets up and changes
its mind.

Mac seems to think that lots of gov
ernment money is being spent on folk
music, and he is concerned about getting
his part. I'm going to be helpful and give
him directions on how to get some.
Follow the Capital Beltway west until
you come to the Big Rock Candy Moun
tain

exit.

Go past the champagne foun

tain and trickling whiskey creek and the
yard where the roast pigs are running
about squealing to be eaten. Back your
truck up to the money elevator and tell
the guy with the white beard and red suit

'er up. While he is indulging you,
climb to the top of the tank and look for
folklorists cavorting in the national trea
to fill

sury in the manner of

Scrooge McDuck.

Don't worry if you can't see them. The
lack of any evidence is half of the enjoy
The other half is
ment of an illusion.
slicing it so thin that no one recognizes it

baloney.
Most of the "government" money
spent on folk music goes to revival per
formers. Every year I see twenty or more
brochures which show the touring per
formers that regional and state arts agen
cies are supporting.
Virtually all are
from the revival. I have never been con
cerned to the point of counting, but it is
It is
at least 90 percent, perhaps more.
the same with folk music in the schools
programs. Revival performers can cope
with the bureaucracy, and they get all the
jobs. Nor does the situation differ when
park and recreation departments hire folk
Almost ALL the public
musicians.
money I see being spent on folk music
goes to revival performers.
The National Endowment for the Arts
(NEA) is the source of much of the
as

"government" money spent this way by
state and regional arts agencies. It is not
much in relative terms; the Federal gov

ernment spends a miserly
budget on music of all
funds remain pegged at
were when Ronald Reagan

portion of its
kinds.
These
the

level they

came to office.
Yet in many states more than half of the
state arts budget comes as a block grant
from the NEA. The block grant is not
all. The last time I saw an accounting,
more than half of the states were getting
virtually all of their folk arts budget from
NEA program funds.
Regional associations of state arts

agencies (the Western Arts Association,

Southern Arts Federation, and others) get
most of their operating funds from NEA
block grants, and then, like the states,
solicit additional NEA funds for programs
such as folk arts.

They are also like the

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

states in expending virtually all their folk
on

and

performance support
touring
revival artists who can cope with yearand-a-half-in-advance application deadlines
and procedures that require skills in
accounting, press agentry, and futurism.
So it is a fiction to say that the revival is
wronged in the distribution of
public funding for the arts.
The only place where this imbalance is
given any attention is the NEA's tiny
Folk Arts Program where there's some
being

concern with originality and the pressures
on folk communities. But even the little
Folk Arts operation has an apprenticeship
program which, though it also puts some
funding into the hands of the master
teachers,

is

mainly

a

fits revival artists.

program that bene

Mac categorizes some folk festivals as
"government" festivals. The three festi
vals that he mentions by name, The Na
tional Folk Festival, The Festival of

American
Mountain

Folklife, and the Brandywine
Festival, are like most other

being funded by a variety of
sources, public and private. Anyone who
thinks the "government" will fund more
than a small portion of a festival is a re
cent arrival, newly fallen off the turnip
wagon, or perhaps a Rip Van Winkle.
You didn't hear about the election of
Carter, Reagan, or Bush, Mac?
Okay,

festivals

in

hunker down here and I'll tell you about
triple whammy that hit the old smoke

a

weed-and-have-free-music bunch.
While I'm getting Mac straightened
out about funding, I'll deny his assertion
that my employer, the National Council
the

for

Traditional

Arts

(NCTA),

is

"coordinating government tours and festi
vals." We've organized fifteen national
tours in the last ten years, paying our
way with whatever federal, state, local and
private grants we could attract, and with a
lot of local sponsor and box office in
come. The biggest source of funds for us
and the local sponsors is, of course, the
box office. I know of eleven other orga
nizations that have tried folk music tour
ing in this period. We're notable because
we are still

in

the game after the others

quit.
but

Why did they drop out? I'm not sure,
I think
it was because it was so terri

bly easy. The profits were huge, border
ing on the astronomical, and they possi
bly grew weary of spending them. Some

people can't stand
The NCTA is

a life of ease.
private non-profit or

up to
a

ganization and no one has ever told me
where a government festival is that

I

Tell me where they are,
Mac, and I'll go there and coordinate as
hard as I can. Uh, one more thing, Mac.
You say the NCTA may become the
could coordinate.

"National Council for Dying Cultures"
because we prefer traditional to revival,

now book may not
have the vitality to hold audiences, that
you are denied access to audiences you
helped to create.
The total audience for the 1974-76
National Folk Festivals, the last three
which had Highwoods in a starring role,
The
ranged from 12,700 to 17,400.
the artists

that

1987-89
123,000

we

Nationals

to

165,000.

had audiences of
So if the National

dying, the wake

is really big!
and genres of mu
other
groups
Many
sic were involved, but if you want credit
for the size of the earlier audiences, you
can have it. Uh, would it be fair for me
to attribute the tenfold increase in the re

cent audience

to your absence?
Okay,
won't do that. But don't get the
big head about what you did for the Na
tional Folk Festival. It was even bigger

okay,

I

today in 1936, before either of us
was born.
Mac sometimes invents positions lor
I
can't
folklorists, then bops them.
than

imagine any folklorist claiming to be a
do know
dispassionate scientist. But
some that despise all folk music and feel
I

that

the hair on the tip of the tail of
folk studies that tries to wag
Most of the 1,100
whole animal.
it is

the dog of

the

members of the American Folklore Soci
ety have nothing at all to do with folk
music.
They know little or nothing
about it, and are likely to remain
disinterested. Those interested in it to the
point of doing any serious work in music
the exact number
is fifty or less
depending upon how seriously one defines
"serious."

Ethnomusicologists

are

more

con

cerned with folk music than folklorists
and are increasingly a presence in arts or
though
ganizations all over the country
I don't
know anyone of that persuasion
who is much interested in old-time mu
sic. A real steel belted six ply folklorist
teaches at the university level, does re
search, feels some pressure to publish,
and hopes for a sabbatical every seven

in order to do something interest
ing. People who have skills in the field
but are employed off campus are known

years

The
two confusing jargon terms.
most common one is public sector folk
lorist. How does that grab you? Univer
sities are more likely to be "public sec
tor" than not, but jargon does not need to
make sense. The term academic sector
by

folklorist

is an

obvious corollary, but

is

not used.

The second harebrained term is applied

folklorist and supposedly separates the
workaday person from the theoretical
folklorist (though no one uses that term).

�sometimes exact mental revenge

I

by

thinking of my campus-bound colleagues
unapplied folklorists.
There have been some terminology
Until recently people who
changes.
worked off campus, especially those
without advanced degrees, were called
as

folklorists.

amateur

retrograde

in my

Being somewhat

thinking,

I

better than the others and if

I

like that one
ever give up

my red-headed stepchild tag and promote
myself to folklorist, that's the kind I want

like being associated with wellintentioned potential bunglers. Eric Hoffer observed that those who could claim
least credit for themselves were quick to
claim all credit for their race, nation, or
region. He could have added profession.
An exaggerated
emphasis upon the
his
of
profession is a refuge
importance
to be.

I

marginally competent,

for the

a

claim for the eternal sophomores

I

tional

Folk

a

do.

Folklorists have been ambivalent
about folk festivals from their begin
nings. The first multi-ethnic festival was
More
the first National, held in 1934.
than a half century later it seems a won
drous affair, a roster of legendary folk
performers presented by a dozen of the

most productive collectors and folklorists
of the time. But the earliest report on it
in the Journal of American Folklore drips
What good could come of
suspicion.
this?

Here's
never been

a
a

there's
major confession:
time when folklorists were a

majority of the programming committee
that selects artists for the National Folk
Festival. The people who serve on that
committee, including folklorists, have
this in common: most are revival musi
cians. Our chairman is a banjoist who
has been a member of the Board for 19
He is a lawyer with a pro bono
years.
account for the NCTA, and his service
has to be measured in the thousands of
hours. He is also a bit of a wag, and
once commented that revival musicians
had developed two ways of thinking about
"One group wouldn't think
the festival:
of booking

themselves

on

it,

suggested a sharpened re
self-appointed national trea

status

benefactor of old-time music,
receiving applications and delegations,
giving grants and interviews. He'd not be
sitting in the corner glowering, smoke
coming out of his ears, worrying about
what

I

in the

had, he'd

If he

They never performed on
recall a comment from one
of them: "This festival is reserved for
some very special people; but for them it
would not be worth the effort."
it.

Another

and

the

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a

Festival

in

an

especially

pushy way: "Tell him that if we ever do
change our policy, he'll have to go to the
back of a very long line."
So I urge any of you who have been
irritated at folklorists to recognize that
they have not wronged you. A few of our
profession may
pedagogic brethren
like folk music, but most are no more
in that

likely

to

promote its performance than an
is likely to promote better

entomologist

treatment for fleas.

All

is

programming

of

course

hell else could it
discriminatory.
be? Some are chosen and others are left
What

in

unpicked on the vine for the bugs. Is that
fair? Of course not. If you must have a
group to blame for being left on the vine
with bugs chewing on your backside, feel
free to resent red headed stepchildren.
the Na
Here's another confession:
tional Folk Festival never stopped book
ing
or

revivalists.

Revivalists of one kind

another have been booked on all

festivals.

51

But Mac is right, there was

major policy change and it amounted
more than withdrawing the automatic
nual invitation to

Highwoods.

a

to

an
Basically,

it was a decision to put a much greater
emphasis upon the traditional, to get as

close

to the

original

as

possible,

sent the rare rather than

the

to

this
his

He is not. A British
critic calls him "execrable scum, a copy
machine, a hand linked to an eye without
passing through a brain."
There's a perfectly fine replica of the
in
Park
Parthenon in Centennial
that
was
The
Tennessee.
Nashville,
glory

workshops, managing stages, organizing
segments of
the festival.

Is

for

considerable skill?

it just happened.
Two of these volunteers would have to be
considered among the finest banjoists
performing. Five of them were fieldworkers for the festival, and all worked on
it in one capacity or another: leading

joists of the Board,

sure, a mediocre revival banjoist who had
been trying to book himself on the Na

Scholars sometimes suspect the rest of
commercializing the good and pure.
Mac was
Too often we are innocent.
amazed to find all those old-time bands
imitating Highwoods around the country.
That was clearly a missed opportunity.
He should have developed franchise sales,

McHighwoods plan.

have issued to his fakes.
dabbler admired and revered

perts

sponse

us of

now be

gree

to

work force.

a

that defies detection by respected
specialists. One could make a scrapbook
of the certificates of authencity that ex

other group can't think of anything else."
At one point in the early '80s there
were seven banjoists on the NCTA Board,
all but one performing in old-time styles.
No one planned to have that many ban-

pre

common

place.

Are we the only arts presenters who
prefer originals? Are we singular in pre
ferring the rare? If anyone can confirm
that we are, I promise to call a meeting of
our programming committee that will be
devoted to self criticism in the Maoist

style, followed by flagellation and mass
resignation.
There's a German painter, recently re
leased from a prison term for forgery,
who can imitate the style of any of a half
dozen famous European painters to a de

Greece is beautifully kept on a manicured
green, the columns all standing and the
Yet few come to see this
roof intact.
exercise in civic pride. But there's no
want for visitors at the site of the ancient
wreck in Athens. Standing on that hill
side one is awed by concepts that arose
from tribalism. How on earth did hardscrabble farmers, open boat fishermen,
and keepers of sheep and goats conceive
and create at an architectural level that has
dazzled men for more than two thousand
One feels affinity, sympathy, a
years?
closeness. Is it possible to feel close to a
concrete company and architectural copy

cats in Nashville?
Yes, we know that traditional arts ex
ist along a continuum, that even the most
traditional artist has made choices that re
flect an evolving. So why do we prefer
the less evolved? There are at least three
good reasons. One is justice. The most
original artists in our world of art tend to
be hidden from view. You can see every
thing else labelled folk
see the originals.

Second, this

is

but

it is

hard to

where we are needed.

The rest of the great array of artists la
belled folk tend to take good care of
themselves. There are, of course, com
plaints from artists who try to work as
folk professionals, but they are much like
the complaints one hears from other pro

fessional

musicians

which

is

to

say

they are reasonable complaints but there
is no special case for advocacy in them.

Third, virtually all presentations that
labelled folk have dropped the less
evolved in favor of artists who are of the
All
revival or, more likely, popular.
pressure on those who present is to make
are

everything look and sound like everything
else. "Purist" is the common pejorative
In more than
for anyone who resists.
like this, I
work
of
doing
thirty years
can't recall anyone ever asking for more
but only
purity. Everyone wants less
until they get it. Then the event looks
like all the rest and is boring and dies
without anyone noticing.
The revivalists found at the National
in recent years have most often been
Asians, Africans, and performers of vari
ous minority arts: American Indian

�dancers, klezmer musicians, and more.
Revivalism is easier for our programming
committee to accept when the originals
are very distant or very rare.

Are we

in

We hold to a
consistent?
We are.
slightly higher standard of authencity in
selecting Anglo-American and AfricanAmerican artists than we do when the
artists are from the Pacific Rim, Africa,
America.
troubled by all this? Not much.
Consistency is a trait as overrated as vir
ginity and nearly as useless.
Whenever anyone suggests that all the
very different people who wear the labels
folk, traditional or even old-time should
start pulling in the same direction, you
can be certain that that person is either
terribly idealistic or as dumb as a shovel.
I
think it is fine for us all to go off in
different directions; I choose what to do
with my life, and have no suggestions
or Latin

Am

I

about what you do with yours.
I've noticed that some from the oldtime revival no longer come to the Na
tional Folk Festival and I think that is
okay. I'm reminded of boyhood experi
ences with old field baseball.
My

That violates

precepts that most educated

Americans revere

much as they do
Here the race is not to the

motherhood.

as

swiftest, nor honors

student that

to the

raised his hand most often.

The one who

has worked hardest is not automatically
promoted, and the brightest is not neces

sarily considered the best. Here there's a
terrible perversion of conventional Amer
icanism, and the Social Register is used
for

doggie paper.

What seems to irritate people most is
our denial of the central religious tenet of
the intellectual portion of the great
American middle class. Their religion is
art and we
art can be

deny that access to an area of

bought.

There's no difficulty in buying your
way into most arts circles. If you wish
to be punk, you buy a tube of wax, put
your hair into five spikes, and spray them
with green paint.
You buy skin-tight
black vinyl pants, a red vest, three chains,
pointy toe boots, a safety pin for your
ear, an electronic keyboard, and five punk
records. You've paid your money and you
are punk from the first day. No one will
ever question it.
Some try to buy being folk with an
other uniform: DeKalb Corn or John

younger cousin Mattress owned all of our
team's equipment and held it hostage to
Captains didn't
being chosen captain.
have much to do, but Mattress considered
it an honor, and if not chosen he slowly
gathered up bat, ball, and mitt, all our
equipment, and trudged home, the epit
ome of spurned rectitude.
(His public
nickname was a bowdlerizing of Mattress
Ass, given in honor of his habit of aris

Deere cap, overalls, clodhopper shoes,
faded shirt, open-back banjo or factory
fiddle, and all of Tommy Jarrell's records.
You put on the uniform, buy a road atlas
detailed enough to show Galax or Mount
The gentle folks
Airy, and go there.
thereabouts will accept any waif that
wanders in, and musical ones are espe

ing late.)

cially treasured.

terrible thing, and the
only good that ever comes from it is song
writing royalties, self understanding, and
second marriages. It is especially hard on
folkies because they are so sensitive.

Rejection

is a

A long line of

folkies were upset with

before Mac came along. A few years
back the Old Time Herald's associate edi
tor, Brad Leftwich, opined in an Ohio
folkie rag that Howard Sacks and me were
using processes similar to Nazism in se
Does
lecting artists for the National.
us

imagine that we open program
committee meetings with a session of
goose stepping and seig heiling? Are all
negative pejoratives equal in his view?
Brad

Back in the '60s an Alabama Kluxer rag
called me a Communist for what I still
think was relatively good work, but no
one else has linked my name to Nazism.
But I'm not terribly offended by such
brickbats. They're a lefthanded rave re
view, and I treasure them.
I suppose we
seem terribly perverse

because it is not only the sound that is
being judged, but the family tree -past
and future
of the people making it.
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

harmless process. If one is
dissatisfied with the family fate gave him,
it is okay to adopt another.
But fairness
demands that one be more than a young
cuckoo. Do you know the ingrate habits
of that bird that Tom Ashley sang about?
The cuckoo lays its eggs in the nests of
It

seems

a

other birds and they unwittingly raise its
young. The noisy and aggressive young

cuckoo often pushes

its

nestmates

the

natural offspring of its adoptive parents
over the side, out of the nest, and to
A hard corollary?
death.
Yes, it is
very hard and applicable only to a few.
But there really are ethical considerations

learning traditional skills and combin
ing them with non-traditional skills (such
in

self advertising) and going into
competition with traditional people.
Those sensitive enough to wish to
avoid young cuckoo habits could start by
not squawking about there being a few
places reserved for the originals of our
as

world of art, for the carriers of tradition.
They could also organize their thinking
and rely less on imagination in locating
their place in this world of art.

revivalist tendency to invent
impossibly romantic theory about folk
music, pass it back and forth as a formu
lation from anonymous folklorists, then
at an appropriate moment, to do a skin
There's

a

an

head baseball bat attack upon the theory
and folklorists

in general.
good example is the "isolated
mountain community" theory for the de
velopment and continuation of style in
old-time music. "They're all gone now!"
we hear from Mac and others, suddenly
there are no isolated places or people.
Any old retrograde geezer chugging down
the interstate is a last gasp ahead of the
actuary and probably can't hold a crowd
with his performance standards. There's a
self serving summary:
"They're dead,

A

we're it."
Yet I've never met a person who knew
their butt from third base in this area of

study

who thought that

isolation

had

much to do with the origin of style or its
continuation over time. Yes, I know that
many have speculated about it in print,

including some of the bigger windbags of
and I hold to what I just
folk music
said.

Among those otten explained by
physical isolation theory are my old
The
friends Stanley* and Ray Hicks.
supposed impenetrability of the Beech and

Wolf Scratch mountains have been de
scribed in magazines and newspapers that

range from The New Yorker to surburban
shoppers. Johnny Carson has had to en

dure repeated refusals to come chat from

both.
But Stanley

has a house on top of a
mountain because he wanted one there.
He keeps to his daddy's traditions because
he feels they are good. He made tires at a
factory at Radford, Virginia, during World
War II. He worked for several years at a
chicken processing operation in Burling
He
ton, N.C., far from the mountains.
worked for another food processing

in upstate New York. Isolated?
Ray has left less often, but to attribute
his great storytelling skills to isolation is

operation

idiocy.

Mac believes that isolation once kept

people distinct, but that it has ended and
He
that blob culture now takes over.
says, "People can no longer be born into
culturally distinct isolated geographic ar
eas. They just don't exist. We are now
all part of the homogenized blend, like it
In these and other comments
or not."
Mac reveals himself as a evangelist for
the

plasticus

His family

boobus americanus cult.
his community became

and

culturally mainstream, and Mac found the
water terribly tepid and perhaps even a bit
polluted. That is evidence of good taste,
but Mac is over his head in the main-

�stream and can't imagine other fluids such
as duck soup, sheep nanny tea, and home
brew with raisins.
The punk rocker with the five green
spikes on his head and the safety pin in
his ear agrees with Mac, and is running as
fast as he can from his perception. I pre
dict that he will eventually be found at
the mourner's bench in Mac's church, be
ing forgiven and sent forth wearing a

DeKalb Corn cap.

Mac is sometimes wonderfully evan

He says, "...we are the ones
which
(sic) the tradition is now
through
We
are
the link between its past
flowing.

gelical.

and its future and there is no other.

If

old-time music is played in the 21st cen
tury, it will be because of us and this will
be as true in the rural South as anywhere
else."

Jeez, old friend, I hate to rain on your
parade, but I think it is also flowing
through the Indians of the sub-arctic and I
their grandchildren
The
do in yours.
continuing
Athabascan Indians of the interior and
north of Alaska received mail only twice
have

more

faith

it

in

than

I

year during the 1920s and 1930s, but
they could send furs to Sears Roebuck and

a

they could receive crank-up phonographs,
records, fiddles and guitars. Now they
have a great fiddler's convention every
November, flying into Fairbanks from
the upriver and downriver Yukon villages,
some from north of the arctic circle in
Alaska, and others from Canada's most

remote reaches.
The tune heard most often from the
stage in the cozy Fairbanks Eagle's Hall
is More Pretty Girls Than One derived
from the 1930s Arthur Smith recording.
The recorded repertoire of Mainer's
Mountaineers is also well known. These
and other early hillbilly items are mixed
with old tunes from the early fur trade.
The fiddlers from Arctic Village and Old
Crow (Canada) clog their feet in the Que
bec manner and the Old Crow guitar
players clog along with the fiddler.
The second most common tune is The
Red River Jig, a favorite dance and tune

of the fur trade. It is well known among
Mitchif Indian fiddlers of North Dakota's
Turtle Mountain Reservation, descendants
of the Cree and Chippewa who were the
foot soldiers of the fur trade. Athabascan
Indian old-time fiddlers also play some

Scottish tunes from Hudson Bay
employees of long ago, a few French

tunes, and lots of items from 1920s-toHank Williams country music. The last
of the great North American primeval
hunting tribes, they neither sow or
gather, fish are for dogs, and men hunt
and eat meat. They are among the several
groups of "no others" the tradition is

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

beautiful moment well
worth remembering, but surely not wor
The past is an
thy of fixative worship.
inescapable guide to the future, but it

flowing through, but don't worry about
slighting them. They've not heard about
Highwoods or any other revival bands, so

passed, perhaps

you're even.
Mac and I inhabit two very different
worlds of old-time music. His consists
largely of revivalists and a few old-timers
who inspired them, now almost all de

ceased.

He sees

need not be more than that.
Moreover, men are most ridiculous
whenever they try to appear to be what
The resulting incon
they cannot be.

revivalists everywhere,

the burnt corkers of the last century, the
perpetrators of the urban old-time music
scare of twenty years ago, and their pre
sent followers, whom he imagines will
carry it to the future. He sees its creative
peaks as those times when it almost be
came commercially viable.
My world of old-time music has many
players in a variety of traditional forms in
many places and is in a state of robust
health. No one worries about commer
cializing it, and the '50s and '80s seem as

important

as

the '20s and '60s.

see re

I

vivalists too, and there are some good
musicians among them, but they just

nor

don't seem that all-fired important

numerous

in a

qualitative sense.

I'd

guess

there are more really good old-time fid
dlers playing right now in the State of
Missouri than there have been good re
vival fiddlers in the entire country in this
century.
The largest group of "no others' the
stringband tradition is flowing through is
has

always flowed

same group
through. They may pick up a
item from popular performance,
vival, or the church, but they
their own and they can digest
what the great musicologist
the

it

nonfolk
the

make
a

re
it

lot of

Charles

Seeger called "nonfolkness." The folk
have swallowed whole genres of popular
On the
music without even burping.
other hand the nonfolk have
with folkness. They spend

a

a

tough time

a

lot of time

attributing and apologizing, classicizing
(only Round Peak style is real old time!),
and worrying about non-acceptance. The
highest goal is to create a sound indistin

guishable from one made by an old farmer
sixty years ago. It seems a paltry goal.
Old farmers tend to approve, but they
would approve even more if the goal was
to improve the sound.
In one of my favorite Homer and
Jethro routines, Homer stuck with a chord
too long, and Jethro protested. "You need
to get around more on that thing, go up
and down the neck like Chet Atkins," he
said. "You seem hung up in one place."
"Chet and them other guys are looking
for it," Homer responded. "I've found it"
Getting stuck in one place is as dan
Close
gerous for styles as for tunes.
the
best
black
is
a
creative
hole,
imitation
that the artist can create amounts to
nothing more than a moment already

gruity is a basis for comedy in cultures
that range from the tribal to the very so
men dressed as women,
phisticated:
women imitating the work movements of
men, white men in blackface, black men

whiteface.
There's a comment in the Bible about
it being easier for a camel to go through
the eye of a needle than for a rich man to
enter heaven. Thus far I've been able to
with the
avoid close relationships
wealthy, but I'm sure they think that ter

in

Are there any wealthy re
vivalists who would like to discuss the
discrimination inherent in being left out

ribly unfair.

and off the stage of the Na
tional Folk Festival? I'd like to talk to
But for a change just to those
them.
concerned with being left out of heaven.
Those worried about being left off the
National Folk Festival should pray.
Can we get really honest with each

of heaven

other and admit that old-time is a part of
folk music and thus the property of the

lower classes? Yes, I know that in this
great republic it is considered terribly un
patriotic to admit that there is more than
middle
one class even though its name

presuppose the existence of upper and

But I think I have the
lower classes.
I come
from a family in one of
right.
those lower classes, born in a two room
house at the head of an Appalachian hol
low, no electricity, no running water.
My mother was nineteen when I was
born, and I was a second son. She sang
ballads she'd learned from her grandmother
and my dad was the tenor in a gospel

harmonica player.
a good
Among the uncles, aunts, and cousins
there were fiddlers, banjoists, and gui

quartet and

tarists.
Mac speaks of having "...had the poor
fortune to be separated by age and
geography from the older southern musi
cians." Age is not an important factor in
his separation from the culture, and
region matters very little. Most of the
really good traditional musicians I meet
are younger than he is, and sweat stained
people exist everywhere and always have.
Only a pedant would ask that they be
defined. They do not remain fixed in time

performing arts museums, and they
define tradition as they move with it,
Sometimes they let old things die, and
as

that is okay if
to

die.

it is

time for that old thing

�Items from folk culture may have
value after death. There are a few people
in every age who learn from dry bones in
glass cases, from the shadows of what
once was on film, from field recordings
and the reports of

scholars housed

in

communication.

We are not the only people who have
struggle with these issues. My friend
Jill was for a time lawyer for the Mu
seum of New Mexico. One of the Mu
seum's sites is the ancient Palace of the
Governors in Santa Fe. For generations
Indians from various pueblos have sat in
the plaza at the front of the Palace, sell
ing handmade jewelry. A few years ago
to

non-Indian makers of handmade jewelry
wished to sell from that site. But the
Museum said this public place was re
served for an Indian tradition. There was
lawsuit and the Museum won its case of

a

Indian arts advocacy.

There's much glib generalizing nowa
days about what is called "cultural con

servation," but the term precedes any real

process or definition. It is a catch phrase
created for grants committees and budget
planners and reflects the flimsiness of
sloganeering, the petty posturing of ap
plicants and boosters. When our most
respected public institutions are asked to
preserve, they still must respond with
embalming. We've learned how to pickle
King Tut and how to keep the right
amount of humidity around the stuff he
had, and that is progress. Perhaps in the
next century we will get beyond
mummification and imitation and become
as adept at easing the transitions of life as
we are those of death.
I find it ironic that Mac does not know
how fortunate he was to be born in the

suspicious
saying he

middle class.

I'm

even

that he is pulling our crank in

admired older southern moun

tain culture. He never became part of that
culture, and he could have. If he had by
now spent twenty-five years on the
Piper's Gap road near Galax, he'd be
nearly indistinguishable from other

Grayson County residents.

good pickle by squirting vinegar on
cumber, it has to soak awhile.

mu

seums and archives. But the cemeteries
of a culture are always distant from its
birthing places, and there's not much

great American

You have to be more, stay longer,
and absorb some of what caused the cre
You can't make a
ation of the artistry.

style.

But learning

a

hundred and fifty tunes in a style does not
open a culture. Do the brass band mem
bers in the New Orleans 7th Ward wel

come the white boy jazzmen from Omaha
as long lost brothers whenever they blow
into town, knowing many of the same
tunes? Do plains Indians give barbeques
to honor the Boy Scouts who have be
come expert in rendering Indian dances?
They do not. Folk and tribal people
tend to be cordial, but brotherhood is
more than a hundred and fifty tunes in a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

I

find

it

as

playing

a

cu

bizarre that Mac sees his banjo
part of handed-off tool epi

logue that extends to west Africa through
the 19th century blackface minstrels. The
banjo did come from Africa, but it had
been evolving on these shores for two
centuries before the minstrels took it up.
They claimed that their songs and tunes
came from slaves. Performers who had
never been south of Baltimore concocted
stories about visits to plantations. And
of course there was not a word of truth in
the stories. They drew upon their Anglo
Irish

and

musical precepts, performed

items from a broad range of European
folk traditions, and wrote thousands of
the common popular solution.
others
So why a claim of African ancestry for
In most cases even the
their music?
banjo had come to the burnt cork boys
via southern whites, so why this false
claim that was to be repeated for a
Why so much insecurity
generation?
about who they were and their creations?
The political essence ot revivalism is

found

in

populism,

an

assumption that

superiority of an earlier age.
points
It looks backward and longs for a lost
to the

agrarian Eden when the laborer had good
prospects, the farmer had abundance, there
were no beggars, people sang around a

flawless common
a nearly
endowment of rich resources was held in
campfire, and

lands, minerals, and culture. It says that
we have but to throw off the present er
rors (Mac's Eisenhower years) and become
unified to regain this lost Eden.
It stems from an ancient urban belief
that virtue and quality is first given to

basic people; that the veneers of civiliza
tion mask more than they reveal, that
open spaces and hard work build character.
It

is

found

in

many

cultures

and

is

The star blazed over the most
humble abode in Bethlehem, a stable, the

timeless.

were poverty-stricken, poor
shepherds were given the honor of
welcoming, while wise men had to travel

couple

far and pay tribute.

What did the burnt cork boys give the
African American for his banjo? They
gave him unmitigated hell and beat him
over the head with it for most of a cen
They portrayed him on stage and in
more akin to apes
a subhuman
find
other images as
To
people.
mean as theirs, one must see illustrations
made during the first European witch
tury.

print as
than to

burning mania or in Julius Streicher's
ghoulish Der Sturmer of the 1930s.
Mac's view of art is totally concerned

with object and item; they send out mes
sages and are separable from their cre
ators. So a fine copy is as good as an

original, and banjos and quilts are encoded
with information from the past. This is
object worship.
Mac says that in gathering material for
his article, he found stories "ranging from
the amusing to the infuriating, reflecting
the current attitude of the folklorists to
Well, I
wards so-called 'revivalists.'"
but I
the
for
stories
folklorists,
tell
can't
few anecdotes of my own. I came
job after years of interacting with
serious collectors and learners who took

have

a

to my

re
pride in accuracy, and had considerable
truth.
the
for
gard
first week at the NCTA
I was in my
when I noticed the record, picture, and
press release burble for Marie. She was

a Vogue model with a fiddle.
The burble said that she was a fiddler but

beautiful,

classically trained and could "fiddle the

socks off most old time fiddlers." I've
had a long acquaintance with old time
fiddlers. I met Charlie Bowman, Arthur

Smith,

Pappy

Kessinger

and

Clark
McMichen,
If
Benny Thomasson.

Marie could fiddle their socks off, she had
I
to be great.
put the record on the
turntable with considerable anticipation.
Early in the first side it became obvious
that either the old time fiddlers in Marie's
neighborhood were in a terribly weakened
condition or her burble writer was deaf.
Other disappointments followed. An
audition cassette from a band on the coast
found its way to my desk and I found it
amazing. These folks were playing tunes
from a Tommy Jarrell album in the same
order that they appeared on Side 1 of the
knew the order because I'd
I
record.

helped choose
in the

putting
later

a

it,

cutting up the tape and

paper leader.

manager-performer

A few days

telephoned me.

Here's how I recall what was said.
"Yes, Ma'am, I did get your cassette
and it is very nice. You're coming along
fine, getting a good string band sound, so
keep on doing it."
"So you'll hire us for the National
Folk Festival?"
"Well, Ma'am, we hire just one oldIt is not an
time band for the festival.

old-time festival

or

country music festi

val, we have to cover lots of bases, many
very different ethnic and regional musics,
and we're planning to hire Tommy Jarrell
this year and I know you would not want
to

compete with him...."

(interrupting) "Why not? You call it a
national festival, but it looks very skewed
to the east to me. You need to hire some
people from out here, get some regional
balance."
"Are

you telling me that your band

�wants to compete with Tommy, playing
his music?"

He doesn't own the
"Oh, come on.
He got it from somebody too,
It is an international music
didn't he?
now, not just a little localized sound. He

music.

may be a link in a chain, but we are too,
and a link beyond him. You need to have
a broader program, you've had bands from

that little area for years, now you need to
represent the places it has spread to."
"Do you think I'll be able to find a
Monterrey Jack cheesemaker in West

Virginia?"
"I

"If

don't understand."
everything is from

everywhere and

has to be equally represented, I'll need to
find a Monterrey Jack cheesemaker from
West Virginia for our crafts and foodways
area."

think you'll be able to do it, and
you know what you can do with it when
you do." (Hangs up).
"I

Clog dance salespersons are

as

ubiqui

tous and necessary to the clatter and bang
business as frilly skirts and pubescence.
The one that called in the fall of 1978
came on like he was King Kong and we
the keeper of the banana tree. A deluge of
adjectives described the dancer's costumes
and the names of respected people who
admired them came in a torrential gush.
When there was time to get in a word
edgeways, I asked: "What kind of band
supplies your music?"
"Band?" he asked, his voice rising in
outrage. "Do you think I'd be so unpro
fessional as to use a BAND? They get
out of time, they're difficult to work
with, and our routines are very precise.
We use recordings, good recordings, we
are not the kind of group that would use a

BAND."
"But dancers get out of time at least as
"We
often as musicians," I protested.
could do that in reverse and put a band on
stage and let them play and project slide
That might work
pictures of dancers.
even better, people like live music and
we'd have less than half as many people
on for a moment, de
I talked
to pay...."

veloping the idea, and heard him mutter,
"I don't believe this!
just before a click
announced that my ruminating further
"

would amount to a soliloquy.
They were a young couple from the
New York City area and I believe he was
the fiddler and she the banjoist, and they
were sure that a lack of social connection
had prevented their being booked on the
This was the
National Folk Festival.
third time they had applied, and they had
come by to argue a point without asking
was the proper one to argue.
"We don't believe you need a codger
connection to play this music well," she
if

it

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

"I know that some others feel that
you have to mess around with those old
people, but we can't see how it helps

said.

musically."

"We just
He was even more explicit:
don't think that you need to associate
with a bunch of unwashed old geezers to
sing and play these tunes. We feel it is a
better use of our time to rely on record
ings and people we can relate to in other

ways."

I
get to be the hero in most of my
stories, and this time I really did rise to
the occasion. I quoted Hank Williams to
"... needs to
them, his dictum that one
have walked in the row and smelled mule
farts to sing hillbilly songs." An uneasy
disquiet settled on the room and they soon
excused themselves, citing another ap
pointment. Of course I'm not absolutely
certain that mule farts help a lot, but who

am

I

to

argue with Hank?

few
months before his
A
Thomas
Jefferson
death,
(Tommy) Jarrell
visited Gambier, Ohio, in the company of
his good friend and fellow musician Andy
He and I
Cahan to perform a concert.
Howard
and
beside
Judy Sacks'
lingered
barn while the others went into their fine
old farmhouse.
Tommy was feeling his
years, and we reminisced about old friends
and all night sessions of some fifteen
years before. He said that most people of
his years were lonely, but he never had
been, the musical visitors still came al
most every day, and sometime two or
three groups in a single day.
you know who did that," he
he gave the names, one after
list of the less-than-a-dozen
him available to all the rest,

recorded his music and put

"But now

said.

Then

the other,

a

who made
those who

it in the

hands

of players everywhere, those who took
him west and north to concerts and festi
vals, those who made his movie, all who
gave something important back to this
most generous man. I don't think he for

The names ended and
anyone.
"Not a
Tommy paused for a moment.
would
have
thing
happened
goddamn
got

without them," he said.

The originals of our world of art need
Some who
do-gooders.
were a friend to Tommy may bristle at
that term, but I think it a good one. The
particular set of do-gooders with whom I
the support of

associated amount

to a Board of
and some
five
employees,
twenty-seven,
There's no
three hundred volunteers.
members, no mailing list, not even a
statement of purpose beyond what non
profit incorporation requires. No one in
the group is very wealthy or especially
famous, and we have no guarantees, no

am

continued on page 43
31

I

�CLASSIFIED
The Old-Time Herald will accept
classified ads at the cost of .50 cents per
word, minimum $7 00. Any grouping of
letters or numbers is counted as one
word. All ads must be received by the
first of the month, 2 months prior to

publication.

SUBSCRIBE

Old time string bands, bluegrass, gospel.
1920s-1960s. Send $1.00 for catalog.
Joe Bussard, 6610 Cherry Hill Dr.,
Frederick, MD 21701.

282-1219.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

our

Mi.

48901 (517) 372-7890.

DISCOUNT

10,000 titles.
blues, jazz, old time
country, and much more, listed by
category of music and by artist. ELDERLY
INSTRUMENTS 1 100 N. Washington,
folk,

POB 14210-BG34,

(517)372-7890.

ence answered promptly and in depth.
Or,

919-383-5750.

45&lt;f

S.A.S.E. brings

current listing. Subscriptions with extra
services $5.00. Harry &amp;c Jeanie West,
3815 Tremont Dr., Durham, North

Carolina 27705.

RECORDS, CASSETTES, COMPACT

DISCS! NEW FREE
CATALOG with over

BLUEGRASS &amp; OLD-TIME
INSTRUMENTS, new, used, vintage.
Free, friendly advice. All correspond

FINE

monthly

prices. $4.00/year ($8.00
overseas). Current issue free on request.
ELDERLY INSTRUMENTS 1100 N.
Washington, POB 14210-BG34, Lansing,

ELDERLY
Fiddler with FlattSIMS
Scruggs team (1949-52). Musical tapes,
video.
instructional books, &amp;. tapes
Free brochure. Benny Sims, 318 Swanee
Dr., Johnson City, TN 37601 (615)

BENNY

to

to-earth

Bluegrass,

COUNTRY MUSIC CLASSIC TAPES:

NOW

used and vintage instrument list with
hundreds of quality instruments at down-

Lansing, Mi. 48901

INSTRUMENTS. Send

for

WORLD'S LARGEST SELECTION
NEW-USED-VINTAGE guitars, banjos,

mandolins, archtops, wood &amp; metal
body Dobros, Nationals. Mandolin
Brothers, 629 Forest Ave. Staten Island,
NY 10310. FREE CATALOG
718981-3226. Call for no-charge evaluation
of your vintage fretted instruments.

THE

MANDOCRUCIAN'S DIGEST

discount catalog of acoustic
instruments and accessories. Flatiron,

America's only MANDOLIN publication!

Deering, Shubb, Martin, Stelling, Reiter,
Stiver, Wild wood, and much more.
ELDERLY INSTRUMENTS 1100 N.

styles.

our

free

Washington, POB 14210-BG34, Lansing,
Mi.

48901 (517)372-7890.

Interviews,

instruction,

Quarterly

$14.00).

reviews.

All

$10/year (foreign

Sample-$3.00. NILES
HOKKANEN, POBx 1935-H, Martinsburg, WV 25401.

�P

Everybody naturally wants
to hear the best music
4000
t

CANDY FROM STRANGERS
The Dixie Dartin's

t

PINES AND SHORE

4001

SONGS

4002

Merce Ridgway and the Pinehawkers
WHERE THE CRICKETS FIDDLE

I

Jim

OF THE JERSEY

7.00

9019

7.00

9020

7.00

Albertson

9021

4003

MOVING DAY

7.00

4004

Beeman Band
HOTEL PLACENTA
Ken Haferman and Rob Hunter

7.00

BALALAIKA RUSSE IN CONCERT

7.00

9022

The Barbara

I
I

6000
j_

Balalaika Russe

9024

8000

THROW YOUR TIME AWAY

8001

The Otis Brothers
LET IT ROLL!

8003

RIGHTEOUS

8004

WALKING BLUES

8005

|i

9000
9001

9002
9003
9004

I

I

9005
9006
9007
9008
9009

I

9010
I
1

9011

9012

t

7.00

7.00

9013
9014

9015
9016

T

9017
It

2

9600
7.00
9601

7.00

A

C-02

THE 1935

7.50
C-04
7.00
C-05

7.00
C-08

THE WILDCATS
The Wildcats

7.00
C-09

MIND -BANDS

7.00

Andy Cahan

C-10

DOWN HOME RAG

7.00

C-ll

Vesta Johnson

GOIN' UP TOWN

P. O.

BOX 447, CROWN POINT,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

IN

46307

7.00

3
g

g
g
S
3

(219) 769-6217

3

g
g
5
3

7.50
7.00
7.00

g
gS

3
S(

3
7.50

Produced by the National Council for Traditional Arts

GRAND CANYON COWBOY BAND

Reunion concert, Prescott Hall Museum
STAND BAYOU
Stand Bayou Cajun Band
DUETO CHUBASCO
Linda O'Hagen, Peter McCracken, David Cahn

7.50
7.50

7.50

GOOD COMPANY

7.50

The Allen Street String Band
THE PRIDE OF GLENCOE
Lotus Dickey and friends

8.00

IN

g
g
g3

ft
7.00
7.00

Old Time String Bands, Vol. 2
UP AGIN THE MOUNTAIN (with booklet)
Everett Pitt, ballad singer
FEAST HERE TONIGHT!
Rabbit In a Log (Skip Gorman and Rich Starkey)
THE RISKY BUSINESS BLUEGRASS BAND
Risky Business Bluegrass Band
THE COWBOY TOUR (with booklet)

C-07

SOUTHERN CATALOG

1.50

1

C-01

C-06

The Ross County Farmers

7.00

Also Available through Marimac

7.50

7.00

by W.K. McNeil
MAKE ME A COWBOY AGAIN FOR A DAY
Cowboy song anthology
CHEVROLET SIX
Oscar Ford with McMichen, Stokes, Puckett
JOHNNY'S GONE TO WAR
War song anthology
IT'LL NEVER HAPPEN AGAIN

MOUNTAIN MUSIC

8.00

The Kimble Family
THE FIRST TIME
Lotus Dickey and Friends

8.00

DANCE AROUND IN YOUR BONES

8.00

Laketown Buskers
8.00
UNCLE HENRY'S FAVORITES
Jim Childress, Pete Vigour, Ellen Vigour, Mark Bcall
8.00
JACK KNIFE AND THE SHARPS
Jack Knife and the Sharps
PLEASE ADD $1.50 PER CASSETTE FOR POSTAGE AND

GOING ACROSS THE RIVER TO HEAR
7.00
C-12
MY BANJO RING
Carlic Marion with Andy Cahan
NON U.S.A. ORDERS:
ALL PRICES ARE POST PAID WITHIN THE U.S.A.
HANDLING. INDIANA RESIDENTS MUST ADD 5% STATE SALES TAX. Marimar
9018

2

7.50

Dance Band
FARMER'S FROLIC
The Fish Family

Joe LaRose

f

9200

7.00

7.00

Golden Age gospel anthology

Old Time String Bands, Vol.
9111

FLUKE HITS

7.00

5

g
gS

7.00

7.00

JOYFUL NOISE, VOL. 1
Golden Age gospel anthology
A JOYFUL NOISE, VOL.2

A

g

7.00

9110

in Philadelphia
GOIN' DOWN THE COUNTRY
Steve Garcia and Matt Levine
GOING NOWHERE FAST (with booklet)
Uncle Willie and the Brandysnifters
WHEN THE YANKEES CAME DOWN
Major Contay and the Canebrake Rattlers
BEHIND THE TIMES
Bob Bovee and Gail Heil
STILL LAZY AFTER ALL THESE YEARS
The Lazy Aces String Band
OLD TIME FRIENDS (with booklet)
Produced by Ray Alden
IN THE HILLS OF HOME (with booklet)
Raymond Smith and Bob Cowan
TRADITIONAL FIDDLE MUSIC OF MISSOURI
Charlie Walden with Emily and Dennis Buckhannon

(formerly C-03)

ft

&lt;2

9109

TUESDAY NIGHT LIVE

7.00

3

7.00

7.00
7.00

7.00

Annotations

9108

LOVE THEM DUCKS
Half Shaved

7.00

g
g2

9106
7.00

Conte

3

7.00

7.00

Old Time Music

j.

I

BLUES

BACKSIDE OF BUNCOMBE

The Volo Bogtrotters
TAKE ME AS I AM
Bruce Molsky and Bob Carlin
THE VOLO BOGTROTTERS

gS

7.00
7.00

EVOLUTION GIRL
The Double Decker Stringband

of their first tape

7.00

THE COLD-WATER PLEDGE, VOL.1
Moonshine and temperance anthology
9105 THE COLD-WATER PLEDGE, VOL. 2
Moonshine and temperance anthology
9104-05 THE COLD-WATER PLEDGE (Booklet)
9104

John Cephas and Phil Wiggins
CRYIN' WON'T MAKE ME STAY
Bob Guida
FORKED DEER
Dan Gellert and Shoofly
SONGS THAT SCARE ME
Pat

i

f

9101

Bill Ellis

I

I

7.00

7.00

I

I

9100

7.00

8002

The Ill-Mo Boys

Re-issue

7.00

John Cephas and Phil Wiggins
IN THE LAND OF CORN AND WINE
The Otis Brothers

I

I

9023

COME ALL YOU WADDIES
Bob Bovee
TIMELY OLD TUNES FROM ILL-MO
AND BEYOND

1

Recordings

g
3
3

g
g
3
3

g
g

3
ft

g
g
g
3
3
g
g5
3
3
2

�Sales

County
53
EH
EH
mJ

/tV
W"\- yAw

INTERNATIONAL

FC-007
*ROU-0237
'CCLP-0107
*BSR-1001

CO-756

AT-103

ELD-003
ELD-004

JB

■E
■U

*JA-051
"CCS-110

CO-513
CO-411

"ROU-0236
OH-184
*BR1-010

OT-128
CO-717
CO-516
*CMF-011

CO-519
HER-063

^B
PU
^JB
L^^B

PL|

LJfl

CO-786
CO-787
OH-198

CO-511

"CO-506
MARLU-8901

CO-403
AH-002
OT-112
HER-070
"FF-415

FF-480

PJ
UP

HER-067
*JA-055
*JA-056
CO-533
*CO-734
FF-468
MRDB-0105
"AJA-5058
*ROU-0122

CO-548

BLUEGRASS

MUSIC

^JB

H

HJ

ACCEPTED

ASSOCIATION

NEW RELEASES
MASTERS OF TRADITIONAL MISSOURI FIDDLING Lovely 2-LP set with huge booklet
VIRGINIA-CAROLINA SAMPLER Featuring Lonnie Austin, Jim Scancarelli, Wayne Henderson, etc
LIBRARY OF CONGRESS BANJO COLLECTION Super set of 1937-46 field recordings by John Lomax
CARTER FAMILY "Diamonds In The Rough" Lovely issue of 1941 Border Radio transcriptions
BLUE SKY BOYS "There'll Come A Time" Excellent reissue of early 1936 recordings
TOMMY JARRELL "Sail Away Ladies" One of his best LPs
great old time fiddle
POSSUM UP A GUM STUMP Commercial and field recordings of Alabama fiddlers
FRENCH MITCHELL "First Fiddle" Fine fiddle LP by 71 year old West Virginian
THE MUSIC NEVER DIES"AVandalia Sampler 1977 -87" Lovely 2-LP set of West Virginia musicians
LEE SEXTON "Whoa Mule" Excellent old-time banjo/fiddle LP by this Kentucky musician
DELMORE BROTHERS "Sand Mountain Blues" Excellent reissue of their classic 1940 s King sides

30
WHITTER Lovely set of songs and ballads from 1927
"Waitin' For The Evening Mail" Great reissue of Puckett's 1930 s recordings
BLUE SKY BOYS "In Concert 1964" Super live concert from University of Illinois
Vol 3" Fine reissue of early 1920s recordings
UNCLE DAVE MACON "Hillbilly Blues
EARLY ROANOKE COUNTRY RADIO With Tommy Magness, Roy Hall, Roanoke Entertainers, etc
PIONEERS OF CAJUN ACCORDION 1926 -36 With Joe Falcon, Amade Ardoin, Amade Breaux, etc
Vol 2 Featuring Tommy Jarrell, Oscar Wright, Fred Cockerham, etc
CLAWHAMMER BANJO
Vol 3 Great old-time recordings
CHARLIE POOLE &amp; THE NORTH CAROLINA RAMBLERS
THE BRISTOL SESSIONS Lovely 2-LP set of the 1927 Bristol, VA/TN recordings by RCA Victor
Vol 2 Features Arkansas string bands of 1927 -30
ECHOES OF THE OZARKS
A TRIBUTE TO TOMMY JARRELL With Mike Seeger, Paul Brown, Andy Cahan, Brad Leftwich, etc
GETTIN' UP THE STAIRS Recent field recordings with Clyde Troxell, Clyde Davenport, etc
FIVE MILES OUT OF TOWN More field recordings with Virgil Anderson, Dee Hicks, etc
GID TANNER &amp; HIS SKILLET LICKERS "Early Classic String Bands" from 1934 recordings
MOUNTAIN BLUES Reissue with Sam McGee, Jimmie Tarlton, Dock Boggs, Doc Roberts, etc

GRAYSON

&amp;

5.00
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50
8.00
8.00
$15.00
7.50
7.50

SKILLET LICKERS Old-time tunes recorded form 1927 thru 1931
Clayton McMichen, etc
nice
LULU BELLE &amp; SCOTT Y "Tender Memories Recalled" From early 1950 s radio shows
ROANE COUNTY RAMBLERS Their complete recordings of 1928-29
GREAT BIG YAM POTATOES Anglo-American Fiddle Music From Mississippi -with booklet
JIMMY TARLTON &amp; TOM DARBY Fine reissue of 1927 -1932 recordings
THE OLD TIME WAY The music and times of Luther Davis, Roscoe Parish, w/booklet
A. ROBIC &amp; THE EXERTIONS "Old Time Music Dance Party" Mike Seeger, Paul Brown, etc
WALT MICHAEL &amp; COMPANY "Step Stone" Features hammered dulcimer, fiddle etc
GALAX INTERNATIONAL 2-LP set featuring Mike Fenton, Kazuhiro Inaba, etc
MORGAN SEXTON "Rock Dust" Traditional Appalachian ballads with banjo &amp; fiddle
RALPH BLIZARD &amp; THE NEW SOUTHERN RAMBLERS "Blizard Train" OT fiddle from Tennessee
ROUND THE HEART OF OLD GALAX
Vol 1 Featuring the music of Ernest Stoneman
BONNIE RUSSELL/RUSSELL FAMILY "Mountain Dulcimer
Galax Style" (Cassette only)
CRITTON HOLLOW "Great Dreams" Recent old-time music by this West Virginia group
MILL RUN DULCIMER BAND "You've Been A Friend To Me" Old-time, traditional, sentimental music
JIMMIE RODGERS "My Old Pal" Reissue of 18 songs from 1927
32 sessions
Import
NORMAN BLAKE/RISING FAWN STRING ENSEMBLE Featuring Nancy Blake, James Bryan
RIDIN' IN A OLD MODEL T Features Dixie Ramblers, Rector Trio, Ray Brothers, etc
by an

asterisk

"

$7.50

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

1

1A.

5

7.50
7.50
7.50
8.00

$7.50

7.50
7.50
$12.00
7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50

1^1

1^4

LX
LJH

B^J
IJ|

$7.50

7.50
7.50
7.50

$7.50

UB

$7.50

UBl

8.00

$10.00

7.50
7.50
$12.50
7.50

$7.50

7.50
7.50
7.50
7.50

$10.00
7.50
7.50

L|^H

B^
LJ|

")

to 3 LPs, add $3.00 for 4 or more LPs
&amp; HANDLING: USA ORDERS: Please add $2.00 for first
CANADIAN AND FOREIGN ORDERS: Please add $5.00 postage and handling charges for up to 3 LPs,
then $1.50 for each additional LP. MINIMUM FOREIGN order is 2 items.
CANADIAN ORDERS Must include Postal Money Order in U.S. Dollars only.
SEND ALL ORDERS TO: COUNTY SALES, DEPTH, BOX 191, FLOYD, VA. 24091 (703) 745-2001

POSTAGE

WQ

1

RILEY PUCKETT

(Above albums available on cassette as noted

■Q

H
H

WORLD'S LARGEST SELECTION OF BLUEGRASS and
OLD-TIME MUSIC RECORDS
MEMBER OF

GREY- 101

[Tl

RECORD ALBUMS-ALL IN STOCK
W
READY FOR SHIPMENT

fJB

jTjA

�Reviews
Artists and record companies
please
send records and tapes for review to The
Old-Time Herald, P.O. Box 51812, Dur
ham, NC 27717. Do not send to indi
vidual reviewers.

Davidson's banjo tends

to lack

cohesion

and drive,

while the guitar of Brooke Moyer is too quiet and
undefined to provide the foundation the band
needs. "Cotton-Eyed Joe," a fiddle/banjo duet,
manages to express some energy through sheer
will-power, but speed and dynamics can never
make up for a basic lack of flow to the music, and
the effect sounds forced. Caleb Finch sounds like a
talented musician but he plays too many notes, too
quickly, without benefit of a coherent style. On
slower numbers, such as "Jack of Diamonds," he
gets a pretty melodic sound, but the faster numbers
are quite stiff.

However, according to the title, the major focus
of this album is the singing, and there are some fine
vocals here. I prefer Moyer's style, but I think both
Brooke Moyer and Eric Davidson show a lot of

SONGS OF
OLD TIME
AMERICA
Iron

talent. (Linda Higginbotham)

Mountain

To

order: Peach Bottom Records, 10153 1/2
Riverside Drive, #314, Toluca Lake, CA 91602.

String
Band
Brooke
banjo

Moyer-vocals, guitar;
Caleb Finch-fiddle.

Eric Davidson-vocals,

Dixie/Jack of Diamonds/John

Henry /Weeping

Willow/Cotton-Eyed Joe/Constant Sorrow/
Walking Cane/Devil's Curst Wife/FDR/ White
house Blues/Pretty Fair Miss/Lazarus

This old-time band from California was complete
unknown to me when their album arrived at my
door; I had no preconceptions about their music.
Unfortunately, everything that is wrong with this
album tends to leap out on its first cut, '"Dixie," and
it took me a while to regroup and listen further. I
am glad that I did. Needless to say, I have mixed
feelings about this band.
was able to
Eric Davidson is the only member
glean any information on. He evidently spent time
recording Wade Ward and other traditional artists
for Folkways Records. This fact, along with the
choice of material on the album and general tone of
it, lead me to believe this is a band with strong
traditional sympathies. However, this has not
translated into a direct, gutsy, traditional sound.
Perhaps folky-sounding old-time best describes
their music.
One of the best things on the album is the singing
of Brooke Moyer. On both harmony and lead, her
voice has an honest, straight-forward quality that
enlivens even a well- worn favorite like "Weeping
Willow." (Eric's harmony on this cut is also nice.)
Brooke sings with a genuine feel for both traditional
ly

I

old-time

(as on "John Henry") and early bluegrass
(as on "Lazarus") styles. Her harmonies are espec
ially nice. She knows when "less is more" and often

remains on the same note to great effect. Her
choice of notes on the a cappella "Pretty Fair Miss"
is wonderful. With the dearth of good traditional
vocalists performing, Brooke is a welcome addition
to the performing circuit.
Eric Davidson is, in some ways, a more accom
plished singer than Moyer. But he has not overcome
(or perhaps chooses to include) an affectedness in
his singing which makes his vocals sound too much

like folksinging for my old-time taste. Be that as it
may, Eric is a good singer, and the singing on this
album ranks high among old-time bands in general.
Overall, the instrumental are competent but
uninspired. This band does not deliver the punch
that characterizes old-time music at its best.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�artistry, lacked the energy of the Skillet Lickers or
the moving sentiment of the Carters; and Roberts'
more limited touring activities surely lessened his
chances of stardom in the emerging country music
system. He retired to playing local dances while
fiddlers like Clayton McMichen and Arthur Smith
were furthering the modernization of southern
fiddling. In the 18 years before his death in 1978

Roberts was visited by folklorists and was gratified
by a renewed interest in his music.
A discography of the nearly 80 sides Roberts
recorded is provided, along with notes on the tunes
included on the present set. The notes are inform
ative when they pin down a title like "Way Down
South" as being the Kerry Mills ragtime piece
"Whistlin' Rufus." (Roberts' son James explained
the name change: "A lot of the recording executives
couldn't tell one fiddle tune from another, and the
fiddlers soon figured this out. When some studio
boss rejected a tune because he had already cut a
version on that label, a lot of fiddlers just changed
the name of the tunes and went on and recorded
what they liked.") But Wolfe is less helpful when
he fails to spot "The Devil in Georgia" as "Tee
totaler," associating it incorrectly with the "Stony
Point" ("Pigtown Fling") tune family; or when he
calls "Deer Walk" a "rarer localized eastern Kentucky
tune"
it is actually the well-known "Forked Deer."
As a link between older fiddle styles and modern
fiddling, and as a stylist in his own right, Doc
Roberts has his place in the story of southern
fiddling. His work is well served by this wellpresented and interestingly annotated collection.
(Art Rosenbaum)

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Car/Easy Rider/Old Master's Run Away/Buck
Dancer's Choice/Charming Bill/No One Else Can
Take Your Place/If Could Hear My Mother Pray
I

Again
Sam and Kirk McGee from Williamson County,
Tennessee, hooked up with Uncle Dave Macon in
1925 and began to broadcast on Nashville's first
radio station. As members of Uncle Dave Macon's
Fruit Jar Drinkers, and as charter members of The
Grand Ole Opry, the brothers helped shape the
history of country music as it began its metamor
phosis from local and family entertainment to
become a staple of the national mass media.
This welcome reissue from Old Homestead
documents the comparatively little-known career
the McGees enjoyed apart from Macon and the
Opry and the Dixieliners, as recording artists in
their own right. Their discography is brief but
startlingly good. Even if they had never appeared
with Macon or on the Opry, and these sides,
recorded between 1926 and 1934, were the only
legacy we had from the McGees, we would still
honor them as giants of old-time music.
On first hearing, the solos and duets of Sam and
Kirk sound quaint. Unlike contemporaries such as

Jimmie Rodgers, the Carter Family, the Mainers
and Monroes, Arthur Smith, or even such obscure
bands as The Roane County Ramblers, the McGees
weren't shaping their music progressively and
moving it toward some future destiny as bluegrass,
swing, or country. Their performing style and
repertoire appear to have jelled sometime around
1915, in that fascinating and unrecorded postragtime era when many kinds of 19th-century
music were merging, dying, and giving birth to the
new musics of the twentieth century. The brothers
continued to play much the same music for the
next half-century and attracted no disciples or
imitators until their discovery by folk revivalists
in the late '50s. None of the songs on this album,
for instance, were picked up from the McGees by
later musicians in the way that the blue yodels of
Rodgers continued to be sung by honkytonkers in
the 1940s, or that Monroe and Carter songs live on
in the bluegrass tradition. The McGees' "Salty Dog
Blues," with its raggy, irregular rhythm and minor
key, could not be played by a bluegrass band in the
way that the Morris Brothers' slicker version can
It just sits there in all its idiosyncratic
pure and unredeemable old-time.
The great beauty and value of the McGee
Brothers solos and duets lies precisely in their

be 'grassed.

loveliness,

quaintness.

of old-time

them we can clearly hear the making
music out of its component nine

In

teenth-century parts ragtime piano, parlor guitar,
sentimental songbook balladry, vaudeville and

popular tunes, minstrel show and blues, cylinder
recordings, fiddle tunes, and Anglo-American
ballads. Often, the brothers will nakedly juxtapose
quite separate traditions: the misnamed "Knoxville
Blues" actually consists of a pair of guitar solos, a
waltz right out of the genteel parlor tradition of
picked displays in Sevastopol or fandango open
tunings, and a driving blues break from the newer
black guitar tradition. "No One Else Can Take
Your Place," a duet by Kirk and his relative Blythe
Poteet, links a sob-drenched stanza in 1890s 3/4
time with an insouciantly syncopated boop-a-doop

1920s chorus.
As performers, the brothers delved into a greater
spectrum of older musical traditions than did any
other old-time greats, yet, curiously, each brother
seems to have chosen different traditions within
which to specialize. Kirk preferred sentimental
songbook tearjerkers, yet was the more effective
blues singer of the brothers. Sam's history of
learning blues licks from black players is well
known, yet unlike other blues-oriented guitarists
such as Frank Hutchison, Sam could also play with
delicacy, a touch very much in debt to parlor guitar

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

and piano music. His "Franklin Blues" (which will
appear on a promised volume two), for example,
has nothing to do with the blues, but must certainly

as a piano instru
mental.
Most listeners will find Sam's guitar displays the
album's highlights: here are "Railroad Blues" and
"Buckdancer's Choice" in all their glory, the
tantalizing snatch of the "Amos Johnson Rag"
tossed off as a punchline at the end of "The Ship
Without a Sail," and the glorious "Easy Rider"
probably the
accompanied on the banjo-guitar
greatest performance of raggy picking on old-time
records, socked out with all of Mr. Sam's show
manship and comedic gusto.
The sound transfer is decent: the McGee solos
and duets first appeared on Vocalion and Gennett
78s, discs often of marginal sound quality even
when found in mint condition. Collectors will
welcome the opportunity to replace their aged
tapes of these masterpieces. Charles Wolfe's excel
lent notes, based on his interviews with Sam and
Kirk, provide much valuable insight into the
diverse traditions which lie behind the music of the
McGees. No old-time music collection can be
without this record. As Uncle Dave would say,
we'll
"Hallo, folks, talk about hot air and wind
give you something real now, right from Tennessee.

have had an earlier incarnation

Let's go!"

(Jon

and Marcia Pankake)

�North, she made songs that were bitterly auto
biographical. In 1939, a few years after leaving
Kentucky, she recorded for the Library of Congress
traditional and of her
a great body of songs, both
own authorship, as well as much narrative material
on her life. It is from these recordings that this LP
was compiled. This collection stresses her protest
included are two religious songs but none
songs

of the secular folk songs and ballads that she
recorded. The editors acknowledge that this choice
does perpetuate the unbalanced view of Aunt
Molly as a mountain-grown radical. On the other
hand, since it does focus on the power of her
achievement as a maker and singer of songs of

life-and-death struggle, it etches her clearly as a
monumental figure in this idiom. And this album,

which has been out for a few years but deserves a
wider audience, will remind lovers of "old-time
music" that such music served (and still serves
today, viz. the bluegrass, hymns, and union songs
today during the Pittston coal strike) not only as
and dance music,
of political and social

entertainment, self-expression,
but also

as

an

instrument

action.

Alan Lomax recorded and interviewed Aunt
Molly for the Library of Congress, and his appraisal
of her art is prominent on the front of this record's
jacket, underneath a stark photo of the singer:
"Aunt Molly Jackson and Texas Gladden were the
finest traditional singers I met in the United States

Her songs of protest can only be matched by
those of Woody Guthrie, but they were more
we
passionate than his and they cut deeper." While
have the jacket in hand, let's turn it over. Another
photo shows Aunt Molly in full mountain getsun bonnet, long dotted dress, apron, smoking
up
but sitting not in a rocking chair
a corn-cob pipe
but in a swivel chair in front of a typewriter, an
ironic image of the hillbilly lady ready to do battle
with the city slickers on their own terms. Or rather
on her terms, as she could use the language as
cuttingly as anyone. Also on the back of the jacket
is

her

recollection of having

had to use

a

gun to get

food from the commissary to feed children of
in
striking miners: "'Well,' I said, I'll see you
they're
I have to feed some children,
ninety days
they have to eat now, and I'll pay you,
starving
don't worry.' He says, 'Aunt Molly Jackson, don t
I
you offer to walk out with them groceries.'
reached under my arm and I pulled my pistol and I
walked out backwards and said, 'Martin, if you
God knows
try to take this grub away from me,
1

that if they electrocute me for it tomorrow, I'll
shoot you six times in a minute." Strong stuff, this,

and its end-jus tifies-the-means attitude poses some
serious moral questions. But the story, as well as
the best of Aunt Molly's songs, came out of a
more
period of incredibly bitter strife. And, as one
sentence from the jacket informs us, "over 70,000
men were killed in the coal mines of Kentucky
the
during Aunt Molly's adulthood." (I'll miss
footgraphic and informational power of the
square LP jackets when they're all replaced by
those little oblong plastic boxes.)
Also provocative is Aunt Molly's "Holiness
Church Monologue" where she states that some
services were more orgies than religious meetings,
but it is clear that her bitterness comes from a
sermon about her praying in jail couldn't the
preacher tell those were not tears of religious
emotion but of rage against the mine operators
who had her framed as a "dangerous element"
when she was trying to get the miners to "stand
together to get a decent wage to keep their children

from Qfarvina?*'

Aunt Molly Jackson's protest songs are the heart
and soul of this album. They are sung unaccompanied,
in the rubato tight-throated intense style of the
Kentucky mountains. (I find her voice thrilling,
much better suited to the irony and anger of

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

protest then the smoother voices that gave us the
topical songs of the 1 960s But her voice belongs to
When Alan Lomax played her
a rural sensibility.
singing over the radio in the 1940s, he reported
that kids from Brooklyn said she sounded like a cat
yowling, while their counterparts in Oklahoma
said it was the most beautiful music they had heard
on the radio!) Most often the songs here are
reworkings of older models, as is the first cut
"Hard Times in Coleman's Mines" which uses the
"Hard Times in
Jail" format as a vehicle for a
song that Aunt Molly actually sang outside the
mines of Bell County to urge the miners to come
out on strike. "I Love Coal Miners, I Do is set to
the "New River T rain" structure and was composed
on her first trip North, when she was singing to
solicit contributions to the miners' cause; it is part
homesick lament, part abbreviated life history to
introduce her to her new public: "Christmas Eve
on the East Side" is

a

bitter comment on living in

a
New York without "gas or electric to make
cup of tea," and complaining that "starvation and
misery is all that is free for poor struggling masses
like you and like me." While self-pity and left-wing
rhetoric do not entirely rob this song of its impact,
Aunt Molly's strongest songs come from her
Kentucky experiences. "Fare Thee Well Old Ely

it is based on the Civil
Branch" is one of her best
War song "Fare You Well, My Darling" and
perhaps also "Old Joe Clark" (suggesting that those
and is sung with
two folk songs are related)

masterful phrasing and intensity fitting to the
sardonic words "I'd rather be in Pineville jail with
Than to be in old
my back all covered with lice
Hughes's coal mines digging coal at Hughes's
price." "Join the C.I.O." "I Am a Union Woman")

or
set to the tune of "Lay the Lily Low
"Jackard," the same melody that Florence Reese
used for her great song of the Kentucky labor
struggles, "Which Side Are Y ou On?" Aunt Molly's
song underscores her repeated assertion that her
radicalization came not from outside influences
but from her own experiences.
The booklet of notes to this LP contains excerpts
from John Greenway's 1953 book American Folk
songs of Protest as well as comments by the editors
is

life, especially her conflicts and
personality changes after she had to leave her home
for the North. Texts for the songs are given, but not
for the spoken narratives; this would have been
useful, as well as notes on the songs, their traditional
models, and the circumstances of their composition.
Listeners are referred to the Library of Congress
issues for half a dozen traditional songs sung by
Aunt Molly Jackson. As she recorded several
hundred songs for the Library of Congress, we can
hope that Rounder one day is able to do so as they
album
say they hope to here, and release another
presenting other aspects of her repertoire. (Folk
ways 5457 The Songs and Stories of Aunt Moll
Jackson presents Aunt Molly telling her stories, but
on Aunt Molly's

y

the songs

are

sung

by

John

Greenway.) But

certainly concur that this kind of collection was
first priority, presenting the searing protest songs
of a great American voice. (Art Rosenbaum)

I

a

�families and communities. All shaped their music

to its mature form during the decade of the 1940s.
And all three had a poet's gift to apply the
techniques and emotion of hymn singing to secular

music, revealing to us the bitter, hard-times feelings
that underlie the often banal or sentimental lyrics
of the non-traditional material they performed.
Like Emily Dickinson, they liked a look of agony
because they knew it was true.
In contrast to Williams' meteoric rise and fall,
and to Monroe's honored longevity, Molly O'Day's
career was both modest and brief, spanning scarcely

more than

a decade.
She became a professional
1939, spent the war years scuffling
between radio stations throughout the rural South,
and recorded 36 sides for Columbia between 1946
and 1951. By 1950 she had begun turning away
from show business toward a life devoted to her
church, and, stricken by tuberculosis, she retired
in 1952. She was just 29.
To consider Molly O'Day's career is inevitably
to raise the specter of gender roles in professional
country music. In some ways, her career seems like
a restless
search to establish a female image that
would permit country audiences to accept her
music. At 16, La Verne Williamson began her
career as "Mountain Fern," a rustic comedienne in
hairbow, polka dots and high-topped shoes. By
1941 she had metamorphosed into the glamorous
"Dixie Lee," clad in fringed leather skirt, western
shirt, and cowboy boots and hat. By the mid- 1 940s
La Verne had chosen her final nom de plume of
Molly O'Day, and performed in crinolines and
ruffled gingham with a Hedy Lamarr gardenia in

singer

in

her hair.

One imagines with difficulty how she would
continued her music into the 1950s and
1960s. Could she have fronted her own band like
Bill Monroe and entered the competitive bluegrass
and park show circuit? Many of her Columbia
sides, such as "Traveling the Highway Home" (Co
20890), prove she had the moxie to dominate a
crack hillbilly band at full throttle, but the bluegrass scene of the '50s and '60s, with its comic drag
interludes and boob jokes, was hardly hospitable
to women. On the other hand, had she followed
Hank Williams to Nashville and a glitzy career on
the Opry she would most likely have been forced
have

into

a

Patsy Cline mold

a

honky-tonk chantoosie

torching out the hurtin' songs. Neither choice
seems satisfying; no alternative seems imaginable.
The Soul of Molly O'Day is in fact a field
recorded in Molly's home
recording done in 96
in Chesapeake,
Ohio, with Molly on banjo and
lead vocal, accompanied on guitar and vocal
harmony by her husband Lynn Davis. These
1

1

recordings first appeared on a Rem LP, subsequently
reissued in the 1960s on the Starday and Pine
Mountain labels. Something of a "last sessions" for
Molly, these sides sound relaxed and comfortable,
a loving husband and wife singing old-time gospel
songs together in their living room, not too
different from stuff Charles Faurot and Mike
Seeger were collecting and issuing on County and
Folkways in those years.
Only 38-years-old, Molly had by this time
undergone lung surgery for her tuberculosis, and
some of the power and urgency was understandably
gone from her singing. Yet her voice was still solid
and moving, and we are treated to more of her
galloping Kentucky banjo here than we are

to hearing on her Columbia 78s.
"Coming Down From God," "Traveling the High
way Home," and "When the Angels Rolled the
Stone Away," especially, rekindle the old pentecostal fires that once raged just below the surface of
the Columbia 78s, and Molly's solo on "I'll Face
Nobody's Record But Mine" provides as moving a
last testament as we could want from this great and
unjustly neglected singer. This record will nicely

accustomed

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

supplement Old Homestead's 1975 reissue album

of many of Molly's Columbia masterpieces (A
Sacred Collection: Molly O'Day With the Cumberland
Mountain Folks, Old Homestead OHCS-101). The
"Volume One" implies a forthcoming Volume
Two which will presumably reissue Molly's final
home-recorded sessions of 967-68, once available
on a local Cincinnati label but long since out of
print. With Molly's recorded legacy so scantily out
of proportion to her stature in old-time music,
every O'Day disc is of course a precious document.
Molly O'Day died of cancer in 1987, neglected
but by no means forgotten. Many who attended
1

last summer's Zimmerman, Minnesota, bluegrass
festival felt the weekend's high point was Laurie
Lewis's solo at the women's music workshop of
Molly's old hit, "Teardrops Falling in the Snow."
Laurie introduced the song as a tribute to Molly
and proceeded to perform it stunningly, seemingly
inspired by the moment, by the good talk of
women's contributions to country music, by some
memories and feelings the song evoked for her as
woman and performer. At song's end, Laurie was
in tears, as were many in the audience. As we say,
by no means forgotten. (Jon and Marcia Pankake)

�PEACH BOTTOM RECORDS

&amp;

CHASE MUSIC GROUP

PROUDLY PRESENT
THE LATEST ALBUM FROM THE WORLD RENOWNED

IRON MOUNTAIN
STRING RAND
"SONGS OF OLD TIME AMERICA"
FEATURING SUCH
CLASSIC OLD TIME
SONGS AS:

'JOHN HENRY

THE DEVILS
CURSED WIFE
WHITEHOUSE BLUES

DIXIE

TO ORDER RECORDS OR

CASSETTES

SEND $9.00 PLUS $2.00 (POSTAGE

&amp;

HANDLING). CALIFORNIA RESIDENTS
ADD 6.5% SALES TAX.
TO:

PEACH BOTTOM RECORDS
C/O CHASE MUSIC GROUP
RO. BOX

11178

GLENDALE, CA 91206

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�tunes didn't appeal to me. Whether it's from a
violin orchestra or from a synthesizer, violin-styled
music just doesn't blend well with any form of
traditional country music.
West Virginia native David Morris is certainly a
talented autoharpist, and this cassette will appeal
to autoharp fans, and also to people who enjoy
music that is relaxing and peaceful. If you get a
chance to see David Morris in person, request him
to sing some of those old Stanley Brothers songs.
(Dale Morris)
To order: KidTown

Ivydale, WV 25113.

DAVID
MORRIS

AUTOHARPIST
KidTown
Traditional 2FR-88
David

Buddy Griffin-fiddle,
Morris-autoharp
guitar, mandolin; Sadie Faircloth-synthesizer

bass,

97 /Little Rosewood
the
Mockingbird/Where
River Shannon Flows/Home Sweet Home/Mary

Old Kentucky

Casket/Listen

Home/Old

to

of the W ild Moor
I

the

/Blues/ Over the W aves/J

ust As

Am

The first time I saw David Morris was in 1 97 5 at
the old Carter Family store in Hiltons, Virginia.
The Red Clay Ramblers were playing, and during
intermission Morris sang a couple of songs with his
guitar as backup. His stirring rendition of a Carter
Stanley song literally brought goose bumps to this

listener.

This cassette of 10 instrumentals offers a different
view of Morris' talents. He is an accomplished
autoharp player. He is creative, and he gets a lot out
of an autoharp, utilizing all of the instrument.
Almost all selections are traditional ones and slow

paced in tempo. I thought "Just As I Am," "Over
the Waves," and "Old Kentucky Home" were the
top tunes. This is a well-recorded and well-played
collection of music. The backup musicians do an
admirable job with some very nice mandolin
playing by Buddy Griffin.
On the negative side, there are only 10 numbers
presented, and the use of a synthesizer on some

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Traditional,

Box 77, Rt. 16,

�what to do with 'Fine Times at Our
tune which inconveniently crosses octaves
and puts impossible notes in impossible places.
Mullenex has turned the tune into a banjo show
piece, placing all the melody on the high strings,

wondered

House,'

a

and amazingly managing to play all the notes by
virtue of a lot of thumb and some quick lefthand
work. However, 1 find myself listening more to the

maneuvers than to the music, and instead of
hearing a whole tune, I hear a percussive sound of
closed strings, and the bumpy sounds of so many
hammer-ons and pull-offs. miss the ringing, open
strings that are such a distinctive feature of the
banjo. These distractions occur in varying degrees
on some of the other tunes as well: 'Falls of
Richmond' 'Big Scioto,' 'Lost Indian.'
On other pieces, the melodic technique is blended
well into the whole tune. "Roses in the Morning," a
Clyde Davenport tune, is particularly beautiful.
There is a pleasant contrast between melodic
sections and non-melodic sections, and because
the tune is generally not as complicated as 'Fine
it
Times at Our House,' the prestidigitations
requires are not as distracting. "Calloway" is also
beautiful, a slow and moody banjo piece in which
precise playing combines with open strings for
some lovely effects.
Mullenex also plays some fiddle and some
mandolin. On "Cumberland Gap" he dubs the
fiddle and banjo together to get a sawing, hurdygurdy sort of sound. "Silver Lake," from Mose
Coffman, offers some fine old-time mandolin
playing: the tune has a slightly midwestem sound,
both sturdy and delicate, and Mullenex handles
triplets and other ornaments without letting them
disturb the tune's steady stride.
Despite the temptations of tape and electronics.
the
Mullenex avoids too much overdubbing
back-up guitar work is very capably done by Tom
King. This tape keeps to a solo and duet sound,
which is well-recorded, so that the sound of each
instrument is rich and full.
Given the space available on the cassette insert,
this tape includes quite a bit of information about
the sources of the tunes. Still, a few more notes
would have been helpful. I would have liked to
know more about the banjo tunings used, and
about George Landers, the source given for "Rolling
1

Mills.'

This tape offers some very good music, and
Mullenex is to be commended for drawing such a
variety successfully together, and for playing so
well (Molly Tenenbaum)
order: Bluestone Productions,
299A, Bluefield, VA 24605

To

Rt.

2,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Box

�While some argue that the look of
Appalachian clogging is bound to change

to Great Britain, others
it returns
work hard to capture the American oldtime look and feel.
In the British Isles, dance appears to
play an inferior role. It is often found last
on the bill at festivals, and there are
usually limited funds available for dance
performances. Many dance groups per
form for free and at festivals often seem
as

be worked harder than musicians,
although most dancers appear to take it
in stride and give their all. Summer folk
festivals are the most popular performing
venues for traditional or folk dance

to

groups, or "sides," and often present
such dances as the Morris, Garland,
English Clog, Long Sword, or Raper
Sword.The Sidmouth Folk Festival, Broadstairs Folk Week, and the fairly new
Harrow Festival have more emphasis on
dance than most other festivals. However,
the Tylde Festival in Lancashire does
feature a regular English clog dance
contest. Appalachian-style clogging has
recently created a great amount of interest

enthusiasm,

and

performances

and

are

workshops

well

and

attended.

American-style square dances

are

also

and can often

in

increasing
popularity,
be found at festivals along with barn
dances, ceilidhs, dancer's dances (for the
more experienced dancer), as well as the
highly popular "late-night extra!" Most
of these dances consist of circles, squares,
longway sets, and polkas. These are done
to the music of a traditional-style dance

band, which invariably features a melodeon and a variety of other instruments,
often including saxophones, keyboards,
fiddles, guitars, and bass. A recent
addition to the scene are bands that are
markedly louder and have more of a
rock/funk factor. Although the sedate

country dancing still
bands like King Edward the II,
Moth, the Oyster Band, or Gas
V seem to be making their mark in
of new-wave dance bands.

and genteel English

exists,
Tiger

Mark
an era

In

October

of

1988 the Horseflies

went to the British Isles for a whirlwind
tour. Although the band played in various
rock clubs, they also reached some folk
audiences. Despite their recent addition
of percussion

and

synthesizer,

"folk"

audiences seemed to appreciate The Horse
flies' talents and were even moved to
leave their chairs and head for the dance
floor, unable to remain quietly seated.
Jim Courza is a performer from Amer
ica who currently makes his home in the

United Kingdom. Many of his songs and
tunes come from the Appalachians, and
played on the hammered dulcimer, can
be heard at many folk clubs and festivals
Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

throughout

the

country.

Sara

Gray,

another American artist making her home
in

the United

Kingdom performs fre

quently and receives widespread recog
nition for her talents. The success of
these performers in addition to the excite
ment created by a visiting Appalachian
clogging group proves that there is a
strong interest and support for this style
of American music and dance.
So, whether you're interested in re
searching roots, or observing the current

British interest in American old-time
music and Appalachian-style clogging,
or even in performing yourself, if you
make the trek to the British Isles, you'll
be on fertile ground.
For more information there are two
good sources: write for the Folk Directory
put out by the English Folk Song and
Dance Society, Cecil Sharp House, 2
Regent's Park Rd., London NW1 7 AY;
and Festival Guide, Folk Festival Guide
'89, 8 Donaldson Rd., Shooters Hill,
London SE 183JY. Send for U.S. prices.*

�FIDDLE &amp; DANCE
at Ashokan!
This summer Fiddle &amp; Dance returns to
Ashokan, a secluded camp in New York's
Catskill Mountains. Come join us for classes
and workshops in music or dancing plus

plenty of jamming, dancing, delicious food,

swimming and canoeing.
CLOGGING
CALLING

CONTRAS

SQUARES

STEP DANCE

SET DANCE

SWING JITTERBUG
COUPLE DANCES
TWO-STEP FIDDLE BANJO GUITAR

MANDOLIN

ACCORDIAN

PIPES

STORYTELLING
SINGING
BAND CLASSES
AND MORE

PIANO

SOUTHERN WEEK
July 29

Aug

5

Old Time, Appalachian &amp; Cajun
Dewey Balfa, Ralph Blizard, Paul Brown,
Ginny Hawker, Gordy Hinners, Phil Jamison,
John Krumm, John Lily, Sharon Leahy,
Millie Ortego, Tracy Schwarz &amp; more.

CELTIC WEEK
August 5 II

Irish, Scottish

&amp;

Cape Breton

Harvey Beaton, Tony Cuffe, James Kelly,
Carl MacKenzie, John McGann, Hamish Moore,
Chris Norman, Joe &amp; Siobhan O'Donovan,
John Whelan, Barbara MacDonald
Magone, George Marshall, Laura Scott &amp; more.

Ed Pearlman,

WESTERN

&amp;

Aug

SWING WEEK
18

12

Swing, Country

&amp;

Western

Iliro Arita, Junior Daugherty, Dixie Doughboys,
Matt Glaser, John Krumm, Molly Mason,
George Marshall, John McGann, Pam McKeever,
Kathleen Myers, Ann Percival, Jay Ungar &amp; more.

TEACHERS PLAYSHOP
August 22 25
Music, dance, songs, games, storytelling,
rhythm, movement and building self-esteem.
For teachers, parents, performers, day care
workers, librarians and all who love to work
Peter and Mary Alice Amidon,
with children.
Mary Cay Brass, Leslie Elias, John Krumm,
David Levine &amp; Sam Moffat.

NORTHERN WEEK
Aug 26

Sept

1

New England, French Canadian &amp; Swedish
Peter Barnes, Pierre Chartrand, Nick Hawes,
David Kaynor, Stephane Landry, Mary Lea,
George Marshall, Molly Mason, Bob McQuQlen,
Lisa Omstein, Leif Stinnerbon, Jay Ungar,

Wild Asparagus

and more.

Call or Write for complete brochure:

FIDDLE

&amp;

DANCE

RD 1, Box 489,
West Hurley, NY 12491

914-338-2996

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�FESTIVALS!

CONVENTIONS!
are
Just Around
Advertise

The Corner!
Your Event
In The

OLD-TIME HERALD
Reasonable

Rates!

Write The Old Time Herald, P.O. Box 51812, Durham, NC 27717

for Ad Rates

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�X0

L3
V2
#3

Etta Baker
Gardener,
Herbalist,
Mother of 9,
Blues Guitarist
Extraordinaire...

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </file>
  </fileContainer>
  <collection collectionId="65">
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12031">
                <text>Old-Time Herald</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12032">
                <text>Presented in partnership with the nonprofit &lt;a href="https://www.wholesouth.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"&gt;Whole South Heritage Works&lt;/a&gt;, &lt;em&gt;The&amp;nbsp;Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;collection includes digital copies of every issue of&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald Magazine&lt;/em&gt;, 1987-2023.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Founded in 1987 by legendary musician Alice Gerrard,&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/em&gt;served for more than 35 years as a leading voice of the old-time music community worldwide&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;. Its&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="wixui-rich-text__text" style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt; 130-plus issues, all accessible here, contain a vast wealth of information that can’t be found elsewhere. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Issues include:&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent" data-testid="inline-content" class=""&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent-gridContainer" data-testid="mesh-container-content"&gt;&#13;
&lt;div id="comp-mf5sjgaq" class="ku3DBC zQ9jDz qvSjx3 Vq6kJx comp-mf5sjgaq wixui-rich-text" data-testid="richTextElement"&gt;&#13;
&lt;ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;deeply researched explorations into the history of old-time string-band music and related traditions&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;in-depth articles from respected historians, musicians, and writers&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;historic photographs, many of them previously unpublished&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;detailed discussion of the contemporary culture of old-time music and dance&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;field reports from regional scenes&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;interviews and oral histories&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;extensive album reviews, spotlighting both new releases and reissues of historic material&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;remembrances of departed musicians, including local community players typically overlooked in the national press&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;/ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Also included are robust community discussions and long-running, often fiery controversies waged in readers' letters to the editor.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Originally based in Galax, Virginia, the magazine was published for most of its run in Durham, North Carolina. Founding editor Alice Gerrard was succeeded in that position by Gail Gillespie, then by Sarah Bryan.&amp;nbsp;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;The Southern Music Research Center and Whole South Heritage Works are grateful to our community of donors, whose contributions made possible this significant digitization and archiving project — and to Alice Gerrard, who paved the way and made this whole thing possible.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;em&gt;A logistical note: Click on any issue's title or thumbnail image to access that entire magazine. On some screens, the PDF reader may initially display only a portion of the page. To view the issue more easily, click the "Presentation Mode" icon in the toolbar above the issue — four small arrows pointing outward in all directions. Then you can use your finger or your computer's arrow keys to scroll through the pages. Happy exploring.&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
  </collection>
  <elementSetContainer>
    <elementSet elementSetId="1">
      <name>Dublin Core</name>
      <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
      <elementContainer>
        <element elementId="50">
          <name>Title</name>
          <description>A name given to the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12185">
              <text>&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/em&gt;, Volume 2, Number 3 (Spring 1990)</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="49">
          <name>Subject</name>
          <description>The topic of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12186">
              <text>Old-time music</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="41">
          <name>Description</name>
          <description>An account of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12187">
              <text>&lt;p&gt;&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;The Old-Time Herald&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;, Volume 2, Number 3 (February-April 1990)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Contents include:&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“In the British Isles,” by Joan Kaminkow&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“One Dime Blues – An Interview with Etta Baker,” by Lesley Williams&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“In Praise of Banjo Picking Women,” by Mike Seeger&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“‘Music is About Feelings’ An Interview with Tommy Hunter,” by Hilary Dirlam&amp;nbsp;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“The Dance Beat – Oscar Roberson - “Lean Mean Clogging Machine,” by Phil Jamison&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Workshop,” Paul Brown&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Issues in Old-Time Music – Confessions of a Folklorist,” by Joe WIlson&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="40">
          <name>Date</name>
          <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12188">
              <text>1990</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
      </elementContainer>
    </elementSet>
  </elementSetContainer>
  <tagContainer>
    <tag tagId="2159">
      <name>1990</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="999">
      <name>1990s</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5561">
      <name>Etta Baker</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5476">
      <name>Hilary Dirlam</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5560">
      <name>Joan Kaminkow</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5566">
      <name>Joe Wilson</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5562">
      <name>Lesley Williams</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5563">
      <name>Mike Seeger</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="1417">
      <name>Old-Time Music</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5565">
      <name>Oscar Roberson</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5415">
      <name>Paul Brown</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5474">
      <name>Phil Jamison</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5490">
      <name>The Old-Time Herald</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5564">
      <name>Tommy Hunter</name>
    </tag>
  </tagContainer>
</item>
