<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<item xmlns="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5" itemId="2505" public="1" featured="0" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xsi:schemaLocation="http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5 http://omeka.org/schemas/omeka-xml/v5/omeka-xml-5-0.xsd" uri="https://southernmusicresearch.org/items/show/2505?output=omeka-xml" accessDate="2026-11-20T01:17:35+00:00">
  <fileContainer>
    <file fileId="3430">
      <src>https://southernmusicresearch.org/files/original/a0c93eef0ad08f49e867f7ee02bc4852.pdf</src>
      <authentication>8152d771a659a9252932bff4b2e1f89b</authentication>
      <elementSetContainer>
        <elementSet elementSetId="4">
          <name>PDF Text</name>
          <description/>
          <elementContainer>
            <element elementId="92">
              <name>Text</name>
              <description/>
              <elementTextContainer>
                <elementText elementTextId="12101">
                  <text>CELEBRATING

OUR 21st YEAR
OLD-TIME

THE
HERALD

A MAGAZINE DEDICATED
VOLUME 11, NUMBER

7

MUSIC

OLD-TIME

TO

NOVEMBER, 2008

OCTOBER

$7.50

MANDOLIN BANJOS
f

Are you foe weary
pick up
your instrument &amp; play a tune?
Old "get up and go"
got up and went?
Take the advice of

CREATURE

PROM
THE

BLACK
GOON

John Brinkley
'"Remember, a man is only

Dr.

as old as his glands

5

!"

String
Banjo

The Astounding
Jnlay Work
Will Give You
The Heebie

Dr. Brinkley
performing another
rejuvenating
medical operation.

Jeebiesl

What in the world does Dr. Brinkley have to do
with Old-Time Music? Read this issue to find out!

Featured

in this

SORRY!
Cut of

issue:

Stock

XERA's Dr. John Brinkley
Sen. George Cecil McLeod of Mississippi
The trouble with reviews...

Guarantee

Safe

We © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.
Copyright

Delivery

of

AU

Our

Shipments

�Acoustic
music
careers
grown here
Dear Friend,
independent musician myself,

As an

I

know how hard

it

to get your music

is

right people. That's what led me to develop the OasisSampler

heard by the

radio promotion CD program.

this program, previously unrecognized Oasis clients have signed recording
landed
lucrative sponsorship deals, had their music featured in the soundtracks of
contracts,
Thanks

to

hit HBO series,

and much more.

couldn't be easier: When you order your CDs, just tell us which track of your
music you want promoted to radio on the OasisSampler and we take it from there. There is
absolutely no additional charge for the program. Plus, we send our proprietary radio station
The

program

contact

to you, so you

list directly

receive your song
I

can follow

and stir up even more of

hope we have the opportunity

we can add your

to work

on

music to the prestigious

up
a

personally with the

DJs

and stations

your

next disc manufacturing

music-industry

project,

Sincerely,

Micah

P.S.

May

I

send you

of an OasisAcoustic

what

all the

as well.

I'll

fuss

is

a

President

free sample?

I'd

love to get

a

free copy

radio broadcast sampler so you can see

about

also include

a

and how we can promote your music to radio

copy of our latest, ground-breaking

catalog with your sample.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

so that

tradition that the OasisSampler

series has become.

Micah Solomon

who

buzz.

disc replication

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

FEATURES
Goat Glands and String Bands:
By David Holt

Dr.

John Brinkley /16

Old, New, and Real:

The Case of

Mississippi's Senator George Cecil McLeod/26

By Chris Goertzen

COLUMNS
HERE &amp; THERE/8

ISSUES

IN

OLD-TIME MUSIC/14

Old-Time Herald Reviews
By Alice Gerrard

DEPARTMENTS
LETTERS/2
LETTER FROM THE EDITOR/7

CLASSIFIEDS/32
REVIEWS/34

COMING SOON:

Old-time music

in

digital archives

Vesta Johnson

�Letters
Regarding reviews
Certain CD reviews that appeared in the last
issue of the Old-Time Herald have become

would

of sharp controversy and hard
feelings over the last several weeks. Given the
intensity of the discussion, this would seem

critical.

the

an

subject

clarify our editorial
reviews.
subject of
but afeiv very rare cases, the materials

appropriate

policy
In all

time

to

on the

discussed

in the

for the express

pages of the OTH are sent
purpose of being reviewed.

to us

Art

be aware that if they seek review in
these pages, we can 't guarantee that the review
ers' opinions will be unequivocally positive. We

ists should

consider both our reviewers and our readers

to

highly knowledgeable about old-time music,
and although another listener may have a dif
be

ferent, and

no less valid,

recording,

we believe

response

to

any given

that our revieivers will

express their opinions in a manner that is infor
mative both about the recording and about the
wider context of old-time music.
We feel that Jody Stecher's review of The
Way It Was, discussed below, more than
met these standards. Jody, who has written

reviews for the Old-Time Herald for many
years, was highly complimentary about the

artists' musicianship, but detailed his dis
agreement with the historical premise of the
recording. The historical aspect of this contro
good example of the sort of debate
versy
that we welcome in this magazine. We rely on
is a

our readers

with what

to
is

speak up when they disagree
in our pages.

printed

Although controversies such as the present
one are painful in a community as tightly
knit as ours, we believe that no good purpose

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

be

served

in

ers (or readers) were
It is our

the long

review

run if

discouraged from being

belief that the value of honest

discussion far outweighs
forced congeniality.

the benefits

en

of

to offer my personal thoughts re
one
subtext
of the debate below. Some
garding
the
letters
we
have
received have called into
of

would like

I

question Jody Stecher's authority

the

on

sub

ject of old-time music, citing in alarmingly
hostile terms his Northeastern background
and residence

in

California.

I'm

a

native of

the South, and (although I did not learn from
them my family has included many tradition
al

musicians over the generations.

I

do not

be

lieve that by virtue of possessing this heritage,
I can claim
greater authority about old-time

music than
ground.

a

fellow musician of different back
generations the distinction

In earlier

might have been relevant, but-- while regional
heritage is still very important, and a justifi
able source of pride-- for more than a gen
eration now,

a
large portion of the devotion,
creativity, and labor that has kept our music
so vital has come from people who are neither

from Appalachia

nor

even from

the

South.

It's hard to imagine where we would be today
without the documentary efforts (as well as the

artistry) of the New Lost City Ramblers, Alice
Ray Alden, David Freeman, Andy
Cahan, Bob Carlin, and far too many others to
list-- artists who are not natives of the South
Gerrard,

Appalachians. I'd like to propose to fellow
old-time musicians that the time has come for
ern

us to

dispense with regional antagonism.

Sarah Bryan

�takenly speculated about tune origins and
sources. Again, some specific examples
would be helpful. One might question
the rationale of grammatical corrections

coming together of the banjo and
fiddle in ensemble is not well-docu
mented, but [Cece] Conway [author of
African Banjo Echoes in Appalachia]
does riot find evidence for it happening
prior to the minstrels. In the mountains,
The

the

dated roughly from the Civil War

it

riod until roughly World War

review. Are we to be graded on this as
as our music? This seems like a waste
of readers' time.

in

pe

Finally, I'd like to ask anyone who has

I.

read the review of our CD and this rebuttal

(www.traditionalmusic.co.uk)

to

listen to the CD and the original sources,

and make your own judgment as to what
"authentically old" sounds like. When this

Playing styles found most commonly
in the south-central region [of Kentucky]
include fiddle-banjo combinations asso

music we all hold so dearly is reduced to
mere academics, we have a real problem.
Please see our many positive reviews from
well known experts in the half-page ad we

ciated with African-Americans prior to
the Civil War.
(Special Collections, Hutchins Library, Berea

College, www.berea.edu

a

well

hutchinslibrary

have in this issue.

specialcollections)
The
core

Martin Fox
Fairview, NC

fiddle and banjo ensemble, the
of the mountain string band and

the symbol of the Blue Ridge region for
many Americans, is a prime example of

just saw the review by Jody Stecher of
The Way It Was, by Martin Fox and my

I

new flavor that emerged from the cul
tural stew simmering in the region prior
to the Civil War

a

I was born and raised in the Appa
lachians. Now, that certainly does not
make me an expert and I have never tried

self.

(Joseph Wilson and Wayne Martin, "A

a lofty goal, but I am pretty sure
have better first-hand knowledge of the
music from that region than a Brooklynborn California resident who made refer
ence to "our Appalachian mountains," as
if he were a part of it, in his review. The
review was all about slamming the liner

for such

Brief History of Blue Ridge Music," in
Fred Fussell and Cedric N. Chatterley's
Blue Ridge Music Trails: F inding a Place in the
Circle, UNC Press, 2003)
Mr.

I

Stecher also took issue with our style
He says we have not captured the

of play.

way music sounded
century; instead, our music
reflects the way fiddle and banjo music
sounds today. However, he cites no sourc
true essence
in

of the

the 19th

Is there
that
research
supports any
any published
of his assertions? He doesn't give any. I
don't know how music from that time pe
riod sounded, and I don't think that Mr.
Stecher does either. We don't have any re
cordings from that period, so the best any

es for any of the "facts" he cites.

of us can do is to

attempt

to

play the

mu

sic in the style we think may be accurate.
Regarding the grammatical form of our

notes, and Martin directly. Martin is not
only my best friend but a true player and
active supporter of the area, the people,
He is appreciative to
and their music.
be mingled with our heritage, and has
never attempted in any way to become
the typical outsider that wants to show
us how it was and how it should be.
Jody spent nine-tenths of the full-page
review giving the reader a lesson in cor
rect punctuation and how things were
done 200 years ago, which many people,
myself included, could debate and reject

He took the entire project
into his own interpretation
pertained to what we were trying to

as [not]

liner notes, Stecher says: "The liner notes

and

are

as it

detailed and problematic with frequent
oxymorons, impossible anachronisms,
mistaken speculations about tune origins,
tenuous links to fiddling sources, mis

factual.

wound

it

We have several active mu
sician friends in Southwest Virginia and
East Kentucky who agree that his feeble

accomplish.

phes, although they may be misplaced,
Stecher
they didn't wander anywhere.
does not give examples of any of his other
criticisms, and having reread the notes,
I
didn't see
I
simply can't find them.

attempt of being a self-appointed "Oz" as
to what the later 19th century presented
as old-time music and how it would have
sounded is simply not accurate.
Lastly, everyone is a critic in some fash
ion, and what is good is always to the eye
and ear of the beholder. This was not a
music review. If it had been I would not

the

be

spellings and wandering apostrophes."
found one misspelled word, but that was
error. Regarding apostro
a typographical

oxymorons and impossible anachro

nisms.

I

also do not believe

I

have mis

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

I

sending this

to

you.
Jeff

Winegar

�More on The Way it Was Review
Martin Fox and Jeff Winegar received
some undeserved criticism in Jody Stecher's review of their CD. The main point
of

contention

is that the CD, by its title,

treats banjo /fiddle duets as the norm in
the 19th century, while the evidence to
support this resides in the "almost none"
category. Stecher does restrict his argu
ment to Appalachia, but folks were set
tling that area in the 1790s and they came
from

the
is

East

where

the

documented.

fiddle /banjo
have been re

pairing
searching this question for my set of CDs
subtitled Fiddling on the Frontier. Here is
some of what I've found.
There is Nicholas Creswell's account in
1774 of "Fiddle and Banjo played by two
I

negroes." In late colonial /early repub
lican times both Ben Carter, grandson of
Robert "King" Carter in Virginia, and
Randolph Jefferson, Thomas' brother,

fiddlers/ violinists

both

are

de

scribed by their slaves as seeking solace
among the slave musicians until late in
the night. These slaves presumably had
both fiddles and banjos. An 1843 cover
lithograph for the sheet music to Jim
Crow Polka shows a caricature of four
black minstrels, two of whom are play
ing fiddle and banjo. An 1853 watercolor titled Lynchburg Negro Dance shows
three black musicians, two on banjo
and fiddle. An 1863 painting by John
Ehninger called Old Kentucky Home por
trays a black man and his son on fiddle

albumen print from the
1860s entitled Black Musicians in Minstrel
Line features four black musicians, two
with banjo and fiddle. These are just a
few; there are others. Dena Epstein in
Sinful Tunes and Spirituals cites further
references; George Gibson cites a num
and banjo. An

examples of the gourd banjo in
Appalachia, one destination for escaped
slaves who are documented by Robert

ber of

Winans as playing both fiddle and ban
Admittedly, most of what I've cited
here is from the African American expe
rience, but other authors, for example,
Gerry Milnes in Play of a Fiddle, attest to

jo.

the cross-cultural environment
musicians in West Virginia.

among

a whole, I think there is enough
both
circumstantial and direct,
evidence,

Taken as

for

me

to

conclude that the pairing

of

the fiddle and banjo was not uncommon
throughout the 19th century. How much

is needed? That will be differ
ent for each person and those steeped in
academia may require more "proof" than

evidence

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

I,

but the number

criticism

is

of

words devoted

disproportionate

to

differ
would be

to the

ence in proof requirements. It
more prudent to say that we know it was
done; we don't know how it sounded.
Christian Wig

�He recorded

at the end of the cylinder
which had begun in the last quarter
of the 19th century, and he recorded on a
disc. Edison was still issuing some cylin
ders in 1925 but by then they were were
transferring the music from disc mas
ters. By the 1920s Edison was recording
directly to discs and issuing the music as
both 78 rpm discs and, in smaller quanti
ties, as Blue Amberol Cylinders.

era

My apparent quibbles about grammar
were meant to be a door to the bigger ques
tions about music and music history. For
instance my remark about apostrophes
had more significance than the scolding
school teacher stance for which it was mis
taken due to my clumsy presentation. The

missing apostrophe in "Highlanders Fare
well" is connected to some fascinating
music history. As many of us remember,
Emmett Lundy introduced one of the two
renditions he recorded (for the Library of
in 1941)
with a story connect
tune
to
this
a
Scots
ing
Highlander bid
As such
farewell
to
his
sweetheart.
ding

Congress

would be "Highlander's Farewell.
a fragment of a
mag
nificent 10-part Scottish strathspey entitled
"The Highlanders' Farewell to Ireland."
The apostrophe in this case refers to the
entire regiment. The tune was published in
1781 in Alexander McGlashan's Collection,
and several times in the 19th century. It's
played often in its full glory in Cape Bret
on, Nova Scotia. Parts of the original tune,
slightly transformed, make up the fourpart Irish reel "Farewell to Ireland," which
the title

"In fact this tune is

legendary County Meath fiddler Frank
Higgins recorded for Regal Zonophone
just a few years before Lundy recorded his
version on the other side of the Atlantic.
The statement that "Highlanders Farewell
"
was "probably at least fairly common in
tire
O'

the early days of the Galax, Virginia area"
example of what I meant by "specula

is an

tion." Another example is the question of
whether The Wounded Hoosier is related
to the Irish air "The Wounded Hussar." The
titles certainly sound similar but the melo
dies of these two tunes are unrelated. The
Wounded Hussar is a popular melody that
has been recorded many times under that
name or as "Captain O' Kane," named for
the 17thcentury Antrim warrior known as
Slasher O'Kane. The melody of "The Wan
dering Hoosier" is derived from the well

known Irish air, "The Blackbird," a tune
long associated with both fiddle and harp
in both set dance and slow air versions. It's
also a much loved song, a political allego
ry of many verses in which the blackbird
represents none other than Prince Charles

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Edward Stewart himself. This tune is a sib
ling of the melody that Edden Hammons
played as "Queen of The Earth and Child
of The Skies." Sam Bayard has
its use as

Again

documented

burial march in Pennsylvania.
apologize to all I offended and

a
I

also to Mary Z. Cox, in whose CD review
I also failed to find the
appropriate words
and tone.

Jody Stecher

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

can be justly described as a master musi
cian for his instrumental playing (on all the

instruments) and particularly

string band

for his singing.

has made

a

In all of

those 43 years, Jody

very modest living solely by

playing and teaching music, with

an

even

less lucrative extra through his writing for

number of musical journals.
I
oppose the conceit of folklorists

a

and

other authorities who shrug off the expres
sions of those not born to their music. In

stead I take the view that any musical form
is a cultural language that can be learned,

brilliantly so, by the non-na
and this Jody has done in spades. No
better testimonial to this ability has ever

sometimes
tive

been furnished than one

I

heard from an

pedigreed) musician
at a 1977 festival after a Jody performance
of old-time music: "That little bald-headed
sonofabitch can sure sing."
old Missouri

(read:

Hank Bradley
Seattle, Washington

�Letter from the Editor
member of the generation of old-time musicians who were introduced to the Old-Time
Herald as children or teenagers (the latter, in my case), I owe much of my understanding of
this music and its history to the body of work that the magazine has established in its first twenty
years. The contributions that Alice Gerrard, the magazine's founder, and Gail Gillespie, Editor in
Chief since 2003, make and have made, both as scholars and as musicians, enrich the contempo
rary world of old-time music immeasurably.

As

a

After five years, dozens of issues of the magazine, countless all-nighters spent editing, and far
too many festival hours spent running the sales booth rather than playing music, Gail has decid
ed to retire from the Old-Time Herald. The role of an editor is largely played behind the scenes, so
oftentimes readers may not know a whole lot about the person who orchestrates the magazine.
On the occasion of Gail's retirement from the Old-Time Herald, allow me to introduce her to those
of you who may not know her personally.
Gail Gillespie is, of course, an old-time musician

who plays just about
every instrument you can think of. She is head-spinningly knowledgeable about old-time music.
If you need to know the Buckle Busters' children's dogs' shoe sizes, I suggest that you consult
Gail. During all these years that she's been editing the magazine, she and her husband Dwight
Rogers have also been tireless supporters of local music here in Central North Carolina, organiz
ing jam sessions, spreading the word about area events, and coaxing shy musicians past their
reticence. Dwight and Gail have two great daughters, Amy and Nora, and a granddaughter, Coralee Rogers- Vickers, who is perhaps the cutest child ever to be bragged on by a doting Mamaw
and Papaw.
and

a

great one

at that,

The Old-Time Herald staff would like to express our gratitude to Gail for her
as

outstanding work

editor of this magazine.

Another person who deserves a great deal of credit for the OTH's longevity and success is
Executive Director Katherine Meehan, whose expert management has kept us afloat in a time
when many larger magazines are giving up the ghost a real feat. Katherine too is leaving the
Herald after years of dedicated work. Her legacy is an organizational infrastructure so sturdy and
efficient that it's hard to believe old-time musicians have been within a mile of it. Thank you,
Katherine, for your great stewardship.

Upon Gail's retirement, I've slid over into the editorial chair. I am honored that Gail and Alice
have tapped me to continue their work (and am glad that they'll still be close at hand!), and I'm
delighted and lucky to have as my colleagues Artistic Director Steve Terrill, and Ruth Eckles, our
brand-new Business Manager. I hope that readers of the Old-Time Herald will also continue to
help guide it, by sharing your thoughts about the music in general and the magazine in particu
lar whenever you take a notion. The best ways to reach me are by email (editor@oldtimeherald.org)
and on Facebook; communications by more antiquated means, like the telephone (919-419-1800)
and MySpace, will also find their way to me. Please keep us up to date on old-time doings in
your area, and don't hesitate to share ideas about what you'd like to see featured in this maga
zine. It's like the Cofer Brothers say: When you get a good thing, shove it along.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Sarah Bryan

�The California Banjo

Gathering
October 17-19, 2008
Doubletree Hotel
Sacramento, CA
Featuring:
Mike

Clarke

Seeger

Buehling
Sammy Shelor
Peggy Seeger
Tim Weed

Buddy Wachter
Mick
Bill

Moloney

Keith

Gordy Ohliger

Iffim

sessions

Luthiers

Collectors

Concert
Open to the Public
Oct. 19, 2 to 5 p.m.

^|Pre-register

or

Information

vuww.thebanjoman.com
(209)352-5190

/j

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�tions will be made use of, (3) anticipated
research outcomes (e.g., print publica
tions, audio /video documentaries, tune
transcriptions, lesson plans, public per
formances, Web-based resources), (4) the

length of time needed for the project (one
month minimum, three months maxi
mum), and (5) preferred dates of resi
dence. Also required are three letters of

recommendation from colleagues famil

with applicant's work. For graduate
degree candidates, the recommendations
must include those of the professor di
recting the applicant's research and the
iar

department chair. Applicants

are

respon

sible for contacting all persons providing

recommendations. For information about
Berea's Sound Archives and other tradi
tional music collections, see www.berea.
edu

hutchinslibrary specialcollections
specialsound.asp. Proposals or inquires
should be sent to: Harry Rice, Special
Collections &amp; Archives, Berea College,
Berea, KY 40404, harry_rice@berea.edu.
The Charlotte (NC) Folk Society has
been holding its jams and concerts at the

Central Piedmont Community College
campus for twenty-six years, but this
fall will be moving to a new and bigger
venue at the Great Aunt Stella Center,
a former church downtown with a 400seat sanctuary, ample parking, and great
The Folk Society's events,

acoustics.

which are family-friendly, open to the
public, and free (donations are always
appreciated), are made possible in part
through a Cultural Project Grant from
the Arts and Science Council, and the
Grassroots Program of the North Caroli
na Arts Council. Visit www.folksociety.
org for this fall's concert schedule.

Artists and Recordings
Bob

Bovee and Gail Heil will be
at the Rochester
(MN)

performing
Public

Library on October

11;

National

Music Museum in Vermillion, SD, on
Oct. 17; Crosscurrents in Kansas City,
MO, Oct. 18; Great Plains Bluegrass and
Old Time Music Association concert
and fiddle workshop in Omaha, NE, on
October 25; "Kids in the Rotunda" at

Overture Center in Madison, WI, on
November 15; Neenah (WI) Public Library

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

on

November

23;

Ginkgo Coffeehouse in

MN, on Dec. 4; Rhein River Arts
Center in New Ulm, MN, Dec. 6.
St. Paul,

Serenaders

(Madison,

WI).

Neo-Tradi-

tional Band: Special Ed and the Short Bus

(Richmond, VA); La Vivelle (Kensington,
Windy City Clock Jobbers (Chi
cago, IL); Poor Taters (Athens, WV); Vin
MD);

Congratulations

egar Creek Constituency (Lancaster, PA).

Contest winners at this year's Appala
chian String Band Music Festival (Cliff
top, WV), include the following. Fiddle:
Erynn Marshall (Gibsons, British Co
lumbia); Rayna Gellert (Lexington, KY);
Chance McCoy (Greenville, WV); Emily
Schaad (Boone, NC); Christina Wheeler,
(New York, NY). Youth Fiddle: Isaac Ak
ers (Chapel Hill, NC); Tessa Dillon (St.
Albans, WV); William Brauneis (Wash
ington, DC). Senior Fiddle: Walt Koken
(Avondale, PA); Jimmy McCown (Hardy,
KY); H. O. Jenkins (Dobson, NC). Banjo:
Tim Bing (Huntington, WV); Bob Smaku
la (Elkins, WV); Jim Holland (Athens, AL);
Chad Ashworth (Nitro, WV); Cathy Fink

(Kensington, MD). Youth Banjo: Corbin
Hayslett (Amherst, VA); Daniel Rothwell
(Smyrna, TN); Silas Akers (Chapel Hill,

NC). Senior Banjo: Jimmy McCown (Har
dy, KY); Reed Martin (Cabin John, MD);
Marvin Gaster (Sanford, NC). Traditional
Band:

New

Mules

(Bloomington,

IN);

Red State Ramblers (Lexington, KY); Or

pheus Supertones (Avondale, PA); Uncle
Henry's Favorites (Crozet, VA); Magnolia

Best Original Song: Special Ed and the
Short Bus (Richmond, VA). Best Original
Tune: Windy City Clock Jobbers (Chica

go, IL). Old-Time Fiat-Foot Dance, 15 and
under: Rebecca Molaro (Asheville, NC);
Alice Jamison (Asheville, NC); Zoe Norris (Asheville, NC). Old-Time Fiat-Foot

Dance, 16-40: Becky Hill (Nashville,

Josephine Stewart (Charlottesville,

MI);
VA);

Anna Carter (Minneapolis, MN). OldTime Fiat-Foot Dance, 41-59: Ira Bern
stein (Asheville, NC); Andy Edmonstone
(Rosewell, GA); Jay Bland (Kennesaw,
GA). Old-Time Fiat-Foot Dance, 60 and
older: Thomas Maupin (Murfreesboro,
TN); Daniel Butner (Winston-Salem, NC);
Mary Butner (Winston-Salem, NC).
After last year's Clifftop, we neglected
to

announce contest winners

Our

apologies

and

belated

in the OTH.

congratula

tions to the winners of the 2007 contests,
who were as follows. Fiddle: Mike Bry
ant (Harriman, TN);

Stephanie Coleman

(Durham, NC); Mark Simos (Watertown,
Chance
MA);
McCoy
(Martinsburg,
WV); Darin Gentry (Brevard, NC). Youth
Fiddle: Meade Rickter (Sugar Grove,
NC); Jordan Rast (Lancaster, PA); Riannon Fowler (Scott Depot, WV). Senior
Fiddle: Jim Cauthen (Birmingham, AL);
Benton Flippen (Mount Airy, NC); Walt
Koken (Avondale, PA). Banjo: Adam
Hurt, (Winston-Salem, NC); Brien Fain
(Stuart, VA); Hilarie Burhans (Athens,
OH); Frank Evans (Toronto, Canada);
Bob Smakula (Elkins, WV). Youth Banjo:
Frank Evans (Toronto, Canada); Corbin

Hayslett (Amherst,

VA); Cole

Holland

(Athens, AL). Senior Banjo: Walt Koken
(Avondale, PA); Jim McKown (Hardy,
KY); Mac Benford (Trumansburg, NY).
Traditional Band: New Dixie Entertain
ers (Harriman, TN); Orpheus Super
tones (Avondale, PA); Haywire Gang
(Natural Bridge, VA); Clef Twangers
(Watertown, MA); Cork Burners (Clay,

Neo-Traditional Band: Old-Time
Liberation Front (Lancaster, PA); Hound
Dog Hill (Churchville, VA); Pan-Demonium (Greensboro, NC); Common Taters
AL).

(Fayetteville, WV); Bull City Six Shoot

NC). Best Original Song:
VA).
Dog Hill (Churchville,
Best Original Tune: Bull City Six Shoot
ers (Durham, NC). Old-Time Fiat-Foot
Dance, 13 and under: Molly McGuigan
ers (Durham,

Hound

�Haley McGuigan (Hel
lam, PA); Rebecca Molaro (Asheville,
NC). Old-Time Fiat-Foot Dance, 14-59:
(Hellam,

Ira

PA);

Bernstein (Asheville, NC); Josephine
(Charlottesville, VA); Ryan

Stewart

Clover-Owens (Ithaca, NY). Old-Time
Fiat-Foot Dance, 60 and over: Thomas
Maupin (Murfreesboro, TN); Margaret
Hale (Ferrum, VA); Mary Butner (Win
ston-Salem, NC).
At this summer's Old Fiddler's Con
vention in Galax, VA, the following art
ists took home awards in the old-time
categories. Best Ail-Around Performer:
Old-Time
WV).
Jake Krack (Orma,
Fiddle: Jake Krack (Orma, WV); Nancy
James Burris
Sluys (Westfield, NC);
(Galax, VA); Helen White (Mouth Of
Wilson, VA); Crystal Blevins (White
Top, VA); Richard Bowman (Ararat,
VA); Paul Muller (Ashland, VA); Kilby

Spencer (Crumpler, NC); Bill Birchfield

TN); Nick McMil
(Roan Mountain,
lian (Mount Airy, NC). Youth Old-Time
Fiddle: Adam Larkey (Erwin, TN); Car
son Peters (Piney Flat, TN); Kali Taylor
VA); Sarah Seymour
NC); Erin Hall (Radford, VA).
Clawhammer Banjo: Trish Fore (Low

(Barren
(Lenoir,

Springs,

NC); Alan Rutherford (Indepen
dence, VA); Sarah Garbade (Mouth of
Wilson, VA); Marianne Kovatch (Morgantown, WV); Mac Traynham (Wil
lis, VA); Adam Hurt (Winston-Salem,
VA); Marvin Gaster (Sanford, NC); Tina
Gap,

Steffey (Jefferson,
(Mount Airy,
VA).

Youth

NC);

NC); Kelly Breiding
Brien Fain (Stuart,

Clawhammer Banjo:

Jared

Boyd (Laurel Fork, VA); Ben Hill (Galax,
VA); Chris Johnson (Sparta, NC); Chris
topher Cason (Elkin, NC); Andre Lamb
(Sparta, NC). Dulcimer: Tim Thornton
(Shawsville, VA); Gin Burris (Hillsville,
Don Newhauser (Charlestown,
VA);
IN); Kimberly Dean (Roanoke, VA); Dot
Christenson (Lexington, KY); Katie Cannaday

(Calloway,

(Independence,

Nancy Tuggle
David Parks (Dub

VA);

VA);

lin, VA); Sheri

Sigmon (Rocky Mount,
Massie (Wytheville, VA). Au
Ronnie Burroughs (Keysville,

VA); Stan

toharp:

Fredrick Douglas (Pickens, SC);
David Kirby (Peachbottom, PA); Glenna
Anderson (Christiansburg, VA); Rhoda
Kemp (Roanoke, VA); Tony Mabe (Wal
nut Cove, NC); Jimmy Handy (Wool
wine, VA); Ros Wynn Roberts (Hillsville,
VA); Jeannie Crane (Lewisburg, WV);
Edward Anderson (Christiansburg, VA).
VA);

Guitar: Steve Lewis (Todd, NC); Wayne

Henderson

(Mouth of Wilson, VA);
Scott Fore (Radford, VA); Brandon Da

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

VA); Mark Unruh (Hockes
Will
sin, DE);
Jones (Cana, VA); Henry
Boitnott (Roanoke, VA); Austin Mikeal
(Lansing, NC); Mike Brown (Woodlawn,
VA); Buddy Dunlap (Wardensville, WV).
Folk Song: Leslie Dunbar (Eagle Rock,
VA); Heather Mabe (Walnut Cove, NC);
Karen Yates (Morehead, KY); Trevor
McKenzie (Rural Retreat, VA); Albert

vis (Galax,

(Marion, VA); Tyler Wil
liams (Johnson City, TN); Kim Dunham
(Saltville, VA); Tiffany McNeely (Cor
nelius, NC); Ashley Jones (Cana, VA);
Kim Allison (Johnson City, TN). Dance:

Blackburn

Kenny Monahan (Rural Retreat, VA); Ju
lie Shephard (Greenville, VA); Mitchell
Robinson (Galax, VA); Michael Sexton
(Hillsville, VA); John Perry (Indepen

dence, VA); Marsha Todd (Mount Airy,
NC); Amanda Fithan (Pulaski, VA); G. W
Gibson (Abingdon, VA); Cherie Quinn
(Ferrum, VA); Angela Hale (Elk Creek,
VA). Old-Time Bands: Cabin Creek Boys
(White Top, VA); Whoopin' Holler String
Band (Orma, WV); Blue Ridge Moun
tain Ramblers (Low Gap, NC); Southern

Pride (Galax, VA); Ubiquitones (Greens

boro, NC); Grayson Highlands Band
(Jefferson, NC); Pilot Mountain Bobcats
(Westfield, NC); Backstep (Mount Airy,
NC); Slate Mountain Ramblers (Ararat,

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Mac

Sara

Creepers (Morgantown,
Virginia Carolina Band (Indepen
dence, VA); Smokey Valley Boys (Mount
Airy, NC); Zephyr Lightning Bolts (State
Road, NC); Roan Mountain Hilltoppers

Garbade (Mouth of Wilson, VA); Cody
Jackson (Austinville, VA). Autoharp: Jo
Ann Redd (Galax, VA); Glenna Ander

Ramblers (Galax, VA); Sweetbriar Jam
(Lenoir, NC); Wide Open (Laurel Fork,
VA); Old-Time Tradition (Laurel Fork,

VA);

VA);

Virginia

WV);

(Roan Mountain, TN); Dry Hill Drag
gers (Ferrum, VA). Youth Band: Kickin'
Grass (Hillsville, VA); Chestnut Creek

VA). For full contest results, visit www.

oldfiddlersconvention.com.
At the 42nd Annual Old Time Fid
dlers'

and

Bluegrass

Convention

in

Fries, VA, Billy W. Bourne of Fries won
the Henry Whitter Award, and was

named Best All-Around Performer.
Winners in the old-time music competi

Traynham

(Willis,

VA);

H.

son (Christiansburg, VA); Edward An
derson (Christiansburg, VA); Bill Birch
field (Roan Mountain, TN); Stan Spen
cer (Stuart). Folk Song: Jessie Lovell
(Fries,

VA);

Lloyd

Elizabeth Vaughan (Fries,
Richardson (Warrensville,

NC); Audrey Sams (Dublin, VA); Erica
Weiss (Cambridge, MA). Dance (16 and
over): Kenny Monahan (Ivanhoe, VA);

Justin Jackson (Austinville, VA); Shane
Bond (Fries, VA); John Perry (Indepen
dence, VA); Susan Aske (Colfax, NC).
Old-Time Bands: Pilot Mountain Bob

Widner

cats (Westfield, NC); Grayson County
Ramblers (Mouth of Wilson, VA); Cabin
Creek Boys (Independence, VA); Buf
falo Mountain Boomers (Willis, VA);
Old Number 6 (Independence). Youth
Clawhammer Banjo: Jarrett Boyd (Lau
rel Fork, VA); Miguel Villarreal (Glade
Valley, NC). Youth Guitar: Joseph Bur
cham (Ashburn, VA); Monica Santos

Nancy Sluys (Westfield, NC); Justin
Jackson (Austinville, VA). Old-Time
Allen Rutherford
Banjo:
(Indepen

(Sparta, NC); Chip Moyer (Sparta, NC);
Jesse Allen (Laurel Fork, VA). Youth
Old-Time Fiddle: Veronica Randolph
(Front Royal, VA); Timothy Hale (Gal
ax, VA); Kitty Amaral (Elk Creek, VA);

tions include the following. Guitar: Ger
ald Anderson (Troutdale, VA); Stanley

(Hillsville, VA); Gary Lowery
(Marion, VA); Carl P. Brickley (Saltville,
VA); Eddie Day (Rural Hall, NC). Old
Time Fiddle: Brian Grimm (Indepen
dence, VA); Adrian Powell (Lexington,
Bowman (Ararat, VA);
KY); Richard

dence, VA); Trish Fore (Lowgap, NC);

Sara Bobbitt (Woodlawn, VA); Abbey
(Elk Creek, VA). Youth Dance
(16 and under): Lindsey Jackson (Aust

Hensley

inville, VA); Stephanie Gibson (Galax,
VA); Rose Randolph (Front Royal, VA);
Dawson McKay (Crockett, VA); Steven
Dunford (Fries, VA).
This
Historic Happy Val
year's
Old-time
Fiddlers' Convention
ley
took place over Labor Day weekend
in Caldwell County, NC. Contest win
ners were as follows. Old-Time Banjo:
Chris Miller; Mary Dickerson; Michael
Fox. Old-Time Fiddle: A. G. Edmonds;
Steve Kruger; Amanda Wright. Dance:
Amanda Wright; Mary Dickerson;
Dane Summers. Autoharp: Doug Pratt;
Gail Deal; Mary Umbarger. Mandolin:
Daniel Bishop; David Wiseman; Chris
Laws. Guitar: Steve Lewis; Elia Lau
ren; Clarence Green. Bluegrass Fiddle:
Jeff Michael; Danielle Bishop; Lucas
Pasley. Bluegrass Banjo: Steve Lewis;
Eric Ellis; Perry Woodie. Twin Fiddles:
Nathan Taylor and Emily Shaad; Mike
Fox and Richard

Shook; Jeanne Green

Marshall Goers. Old-Time Band:
Tap Water; New River Rock Skippers;
Smokey Valley Boys. Bluegrass Band:
The Williams Family; Carolina Drive;
and

High Country Drive.

�Final Notes

Northwest musician George Chudacoff
passed away early Monday morning on
August 25, 2008, at his home in Vancou
ver, Washington. George was well known
and highly

especially
bluegrass and flat-picking circles
Portland

respected,

Vancouver

area.

He

in

the

of the

taught

guitar, banjo, and mandolin throughout

Northwest

the

and

the annual Puget

at

Sound Guitar Workshop.
George was 59 years old and had battled
cancer for two and

a

half years. He out

lived his prognosis by about a year and a
half from the time he was diagnosed.
George recorded a CD entitled Unfin
ished Business, which features talented
as Carol Harley and Lau
Misty River, Wayne Hen
derson, Helen White, and others. The CD
represents George's thirty-year career of
playing, recording, and teaching music
in the Pacific Northwest.
The magazine Victory Music Review re
cently reviewed the highly praised CD, and

musicians such
ra

Quigley

of

available for purchase via CD Baby.
Even though the Northwest music com
munity has lost a wonderful musician,
it is

his music will

continue

to live!
Jim Portillo

a

medic with the 29th Infantry Division.

He served in the
and

invasion

of

Normandy

continued fighting until the end

of

the European Campaign, then returned
home to Lick Creek where he resumed
working the family farm. For much of his
life Hick lived as

a

bachelor and farmed

land owned by his family.
During his
time as a farmer he produced wheat, bar
ley, corn, and tobacco, ran a dairy opera
tion, and operated a sawmill at his home
to meet local building demands. He con
tinued to farm and run the sawmill until
his retirement sometime in the 1970s. In
1977 he married Sue Taylor Atkins, who

Community Hospital

in

Marion, Virginia.

brothers. He is survived by his wife, Sue
Atkins Edmonds of Atkins, Virginia; two
step-sons, John Atkins and Randy At
kins, both of Atkins, Virginia; three step

daughters, Jeffie Campbell and husband
of Marion, Virginia, Cindy Sneed
and husband John of Spring, Texas, and
Anne Reedy and husband Jack of Hous
ton, Texas; one sister-in-law, Juanita Ed
monds, of Christiansburg, Virginia; three

Bill

step-grandchildren

and three

step-great

Hick was laid to rest at
grandchildren.
Chatham Hill Cemetery in Chatham Hill,
The cemetery is secluded and
Virginia.
lies on a small knoll overlooking Rich Val
ley, offering peaceful, pastoral views
the surrounding countryside.

of

Born in 1913, Hick lived nearly his en
community of Lick Creek in
Smyth County. During World War II he
was drafted into the Army and became
tire life in the

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

miss him greatly!

Shay Garriock

Fiddler and fiddle maker Clifford Hardesty, 87, of Canal Lewisville in Coshoc

ton County, Ohio, died on July 8th. Born
in 1921, he was one of the nine children

fiddling. He began playing in his late teen
years and was almost entirely influenced
by notable fiddler Beverly Thomson and
his two older brothers, all of whom lived
on a farm less than one mile from Hick.
He was also influenced by early country
recordings, his favorites being those of
Fiddling John Carson. Hick was later in
fluenced by some bluegrass and modern

of John (a coalminer and farmer) and
Florence Hardesty of Coshocton County.
He began to play music at the age of ten,
when he borrowed his older brother's
fiddle and taught himself to play "Red

a

country artists, but throughout his
dling career he maintained a pure
time noting and bowing style. His
was truly old-sounding, rhythmic,

fid

old-

style
and

had many unique varia
lively,
tions of standard tunes that were won
derful, crafted through time by his sub

He was preceded in death by his parents,
Charles and Alice Edmonds, and four

learned from this very kind man. The
chance will not come again, and will we

guitarist, singer, and storyteller.
Hick was best known for his old-time

is

and

Virginia fiddler Boyd Wilbert "Hick" Ed
monds died on June 24th at Smyth County

on, living only in our memories, imagi
nation, and music. We are delighted
that Hick's fiddling will be carried forth,
and are grateful to have befriended and

he

sistence upbringing and long agrarian
life with few influences from outside his
community. Hick was a tenacious fiddler
too, being able to saw out tunes up until
a vear before his death.
Hick has received several awards for his
fiddle playing the most notable of these
being in 1998 when he won the second
place in the Senior and fourth in the Over
all Old-Time Fiddle categories at the Ap
palachian Stringband Festival in Clifftop,
West Virginia. Hick's fiddle playing was
almost always accompanied by his wife
Sue on guitar, and their duet playing has
become much admired around Smyth
County.

More recently they gained the

appreciation
far and

of

old-time music listeners

wide with the release of their CD

Whoopee Liza Jane in 2003.
Hick was one of the last
in

followed

Valley,"

by

Round the Mountain" and "Can

"Coming
I

Sleep in

Your Barn Tonight, Mister?" As a young
man he farmed and worked hauling coal
and lime with his '39 pickup truck. He

later went into the fuel business, operat
ing a service station in West Lafayette. In

1973 he began teaching himself to build
fiddles, of which he built scores over the
course of the next thirty-five years. Hard
esty appears on multiple recordings (in
cluding Clifford Hardesty: Ohio's Master
Fiddler), and played and demonstrated at
many festivals throughout the nation. He
was a teacher and mentor to many musi

cians in Ohio and beyond.

Folk and jazz musician Artie Traum died
on July 20th. Traum was brought up in the

young man was exposed
Greenwich
Village folk and
thriving

Bronx, and as
to the

a

blues club scene in the 1960s. With his
brother Happy, Traum performed at the
1969 Newport Folk Festival, and toured

widely

surviving "old-

Virginia and the Southern
Appalachian region. Fortunately, quite
a few
of the younger musicians have
been lucky enough to experience Hick's
fiddling and life, perhaps most notably
within just the last few years when all
but a few of the old-timers have passed
timers"

River

in the

early 1970s. In the '70s and

'80s, Artie Traum was part of the Upstate
New York folk musicians gathering known
as

the

Woodstock

Mountains

Review.

Throughout his life, Traum was a prolific
performer, recording artist, and producer,

who also wrote instructional books, pro
duced documentaries, and took part in a
great many other creative endeavors

�Banjo
News Letter
THE

5

STRING BANJO MAGAZINE

Call or Write
for a FREE

Sample Copy
Profiles, Tablature, Reviews

MP3s at

www.banjonews.com

PO Box

Banjo Newsletter
3418, Annapolis, MD 21403
(800) 759-7425

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�music; some only want to review reissues
of classics; some know a lot more about
blues or Cajun than others; and so on.

The review process goes thusly. CDs are
sent in to the OTH. Decisions are made as
to what to review and what not to review
based on a number of criteria. Does it gen
erally fit into the genre of traditional music?
(Believe it or not, the OTH gets a lot of stuff
that doesn't by any stretch of the imagi
nation have any connection to traditional
music). Is it an important reissue? Does
it

seem,

good CD
or any CD by

to be

listening,

unknown musician

by an
a

at first

known musician who

a

is out there

work

ing?
space available in the magazine?
So, from the very beginning of the process
decisions are being made about what to
review and what not to review. These de
cisions can be to some extent subjective.
Then the reviewer is chosen depending
Is

on his or her availability,
i.e., "Here's

of the genre

and
a

knowledge
banjo /fiddle

recording. Let's give it to Sam Reviewer
since he plays both and is knowledgeable

about the genre." Beyond that, it comes
back in, is edited, and goes to press.
Here is an excerpt from the guidelines
the OTH sends out to reviewers.

very conscious of how angry he was, and
at the same time scrambling (unsuccess
fully) to remember what the review said
as he brought up point after point. After
I
got home a few days later, I looked up
the review, and was surprised to see that
in general it was a very positive review.
There were a few things the reviewer took

issue with, but they appeared

However

minor.

this

is

cally positive the review may be, are in
clined to remember mainly the things the
reviewer doesn't like or takes issue with.
I have
talked over the years with many
about
the issue of reviews and how
people
they

should

fer widely.

It

be

handled.

should print anonymous

need to have

dif

Opinions

has been suggested

that we

reviews. As one

magazine that prints anonymous reviews

puts it: "[Reviews are] contributed individ
ually by a selection of our various reviewers
[named at the beginning of the reviews sec
tion] cowering under the cloak of collective
Here are

anonymity."

couple of samples

a

from that magazine's reviews section:
utterly forgettable
even the participation

We believe that reviewers

to me to be

the thing
artists, no matter how criti

I've found

and

can't

a

to develop their voices. Revieioers
have opinions and the old-time music com
munity needs to accept that. If you record

salvage

this

pile

of [name]

of crap

chance

The title song
have heard

something and put it out there, it will be
reviezved. Artists won't always like what a
revieiver says, or they may

review--

in a

obligation,
views, is to
as

be

Our

as a

magazine with critical re

be as

straightfonvard and honest
't

subscribe

to the

notion

that if you can't say something good, you
shouldn't say anything at all. We subscribe
to the

notion that honest criticism will help

set

musical standard and maintain

a

the

integrity and credibility of the OTH. Otherwise it just becomes a fanzine.

Over the years, artists have taken issue
with reviewers in different ways. Some
times they write in and say so, other times
they resort to name-calling on the Inter
net. I once had someone corner me and
bring up a review that had been printed
at least a couple of years before. He had

been carrying around a lot of anger for all
that time at what he felt was an unfair re
view, and he was shaking his finger in my
face, saying things like, "You're the editor,
you should be more responsible for what
people say," and a lot more about the per
ceived unfairness of the review itself. I was

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

to

anything

[the] first track on

a

I

CD

improve.

always had a policy of not
anonymous reviews, though

The OTH has

disappointed

or they may be ecstatic.

possible. We don

that fails

bad as

is as

printing
that might be one way

to go.

suggested that we shouldn't
that reviews are the an
do reviews at all
tithesis of what the old-time music com
It

has been

munity

is all

about

and that we should

just list releases, or a brief description of
the kind of music they contain. However,

think people really like the rbview section
Surveys have indicated that
the reviews are one of the more popular
features of the magazine, keeping people in
and there's a
touch with what's out there
lot out there. What with the availability of
I

of the OTH.

digital home recording, recording a CD is
within most people's reach.
It has been suggested that when we get
a
negative review, we also print
review of the same recording.

a

positive
It's

also

been suggested that people stop whining
and grow up. It's a never-ending subject,
and I personally don't think it can be re
solved to everyone's satisfaction. But it is
definitely worth talking about and keep
ing the door open to discussion

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

GOAT GLANDS
AND STRING BANDS:
DR. JOHN BRINKLEY
by David Holt

do the Carter family, the Nazis,
the FCC, the AMA, 12 million De

Whatpression dollars, goat glands, coun

try music radio, rock and roll, and 16,000 pairs
of gentlemen's testicles have in common? The

answer

is Dr. John R.

Brinkley.
One day in the fall of 1918, in Milford, Kan
sas, a forty-six-year-old farmer named Bill
Stitts worth came to see Dr. John Brinkley with
a problem.
Stittsworth said he had lost his
vigor and didn't have any "lead in his pencil,
no powder in his pistol." The farmer looked
out the window, and watching the frisky bil
ly goats, said, "Too bad I don't have a billy
goat's glands." He said, "Doctor, I want you
to transplant them into me."
A few days later Stittsworth returned to the
clinic ready for the operation. Dr. Brinkley
entered the operating room with his mask,
rubber gloves, white gown, and a small tray
with two goat testicles in the center. After the
man was anesthetized, the Doctor cut a small
plug from the fresh goat gonads and inserted
it in a hole made in the man's testicles.
When the farmer healed up he reported that
"his pencil was full of lead... frisky again."
Nine months later, Stittsworth and his wife
were thrilled to have a son, whom they ap

propriately named Billy.

�The Doctor is in
No one was more

delighted than

Dr.

realize he had a po
Brinkley. Quick
tential financial bonanza, Brinkley hired
to

publicist and built

a

an

ad

campaign

around "Billy," his wondrous new opera
tion, and the great doctor himself.
But Dr. Brinkley wasn't a real doctor.
He had been brought up poor in the
mountains of Jackson County, North Car

olina, near Cullowhee. Born July 8, 1885,
went to live with his Aunt Sally when
his parents died. He left home, married a
local girl named Sally Wike, and became
he

a

snake-oil huckster in

a

traveling medi

cine show.
It

was in the medicine show that Brin

kley realized the value music had in get
ting and holding an audience. As musi
cians playing traditional mountain music

drew in the crowd, Brinkley would play
the part of a doctor and make the pitch
for his alcohol-based remedy. It was
here Brinkley learned his smooth patter,
which folks said could charm a wagon
out of ditch.
After the medicine

show folded, he
South Carolina,
where he opened Electro Medical Doc
tors. For $25 he and his partner James
Crawford injected patients' rear ends
with colored water. It was guaranteed to

moved

cure

Greenville,

to

everything from gout

to

cancer, plus

improve patients' sex lives. After several
months of taking in wads of cash and
racking up unpaid debt around Green
ville, they skipped town.
The pair traveled to Memphis, where
Brinkley met and married Minerva Jones,

a real physician. Brinkley
spoil the wedding festivi
ties by telling her he was still married to

the daughter of

didn't want

to

Sally Wike.

It wasn't
long before the Greenville,
South Carolina, sheriff captured him and
Crawford and threw the two of them

Greenville County jail. With bor
rowed money they were able to pay off
their debts and jump back into helping
mankind with their medical miracles.
in the

John Brinkley had always wanted to be
real doctor, but he didn't want to bother
with all that pesky education, so in 1915
he attended a diploma mill called the
a

Kansas City Eclectic School of Medicine.

medical doctor in

Kansas, Arkansas, Texas, and Connecti
cut. In fact, he began referring to himself

simply

as

"Doctor."

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Historical

a

Society

diploma that allowed

State

a

him to call himself

Kansas

For $150 he got

�Medicine

the

in

early

1900s was just

recover from its deregula
tion under Andrew Jackson's presidency
(1829-1837). Basically, any citizen could
to

beginning

practice medicine without fear of repri
sal. Although allopathic or "Western sci
entific medicine" was beginning to take
hold, there were many other schools of
thought. Eclectic medicine, homeopathy,
naturopathy made use of botanical
remedies. There was very little regula
tion by the government. America was
and

"No

dice,"

said

Mr.

Fritz.

weeping
dollars

Mrs.

to

Brinkley

"Two hundred

a

more

operation." She was able to
garnish wages until the bill was paid, but
or no

Mr. Fritz

unfortunately

said after the

op

eration he was "much worse than before
Brinkley worked on him."
If you wanted the very best, you could
pay $5,000 and get human glands sup
plied by prisoners on death row.

natural

breeding ground for quacks,
especially since many of the "scientif
ic" doctors were no more able to cure a
disease than the naturopaths. (Andrew
a

Jackson likely died from an overdose of

calomel [mercurous chloride] and sugar

of lead [lead acetate], prescriptions given
to him by his allopathic doctor.)

Moving

Milford

to

After his medical degree was pur
chased in Kansas City, Brinkley's wife
Minnie read in the newspaper that a
doctor was needed in Milford, Kansas,
a small town near the center of the state.
They moved there just as the 1918 flu
pandemic was breaking out. In one of
his few non-self-serving acts, he drove
all over the county doing his best to help
the
It

ford

victims.

was after
that

he

year of practice in Mil
performed the first goat

a

gland operation.
Times were hard, but many men weren't.
The Doctor's high-priced goat gland place
bos worked just often enough to get people
talking. The word began to spread. Prob

lem customers were bullied or paid off.

Articles appeared in newspapers and
started coming from all over the
country to Milford, Kansas, to drop their
men

pants and pay big bucks to get as frisky
as a goat again. Soon he was making half
a

Fritz hoped he'd give him the operation,
maybe not even charge him at all.

million dollars

a

year. He became the

Midas of Milford, with

a

16-room hospital

that could not keep up with the demand.
$750 was a lot of money in 1918 (about

Turn Your Radio On

Brinkley's

publicity

with

campaign

Billy caught the attention of Harry Chan
dler, publisher of the Los Angeles Times.
He brought Brinkley out to California for

operation for some of his staff (and
possibly himself), as well as a few of his
wealthy friends. While he was in Los
Angeles, Chandler showed Brinkley his
the

new radio station, KHJ, one of the first
in the nation. Doctor realized radio and
his big con were made for each other. He
could put his message into almost every
home in the Midwest.
Radio was new. There was no standard
format or even advertising, but more
importantly to Brinkley, there was al
most no regulation.
When Brinkley returned to Milford he
built a studio and a hundred-foot radio
tower on the grounds of the hospital, and
started KFKB, "Kansas First, Kansas Best,
the sunshine station in the heart of the
nation." Much of the programming was
Doctor's talk about medical troubles.
"Don't let your doctor two-dollar you
to death
come to Dr. Brinkley
take
of our

advantage
I

compound operation

can cure you the same as

Hopkins

I

did Ezra

Possum Point, Missouri."

of

"Bedroom problems? Tired by nine PM?
Old get up and go just got up and went?
Remember a man is only as old as his
glands. And
He

Dr.

Brinkley

is

here to help."

would croon into the microphone,

"Observe

the

rooster

and

the

capon.

stead of putting in a plug of goat gland
into the man's testicles he simply put in
a sliver of
goat testicle in the man's scro
tum and sewed it back up. It was faster,
created less infection, and seemed to

overlook tire $200 shortfall. Brinkley
seemed like such a nice Christian man that

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Brinkley refined the operation. Now in

Society

mortgaged his farm for $550, and hoped
that Brinkley, seeing that he had put up ev
erything he had to raise the money, would

tects them, but the capon eats the food
the hens scratch up. He will even sit on
their eggs. Do you want to be a capon or
a rooster?"

Historical

The rooster will fight and work for his
flock. He stands guard over them, pro

Kansas State

$7,000 in today's currency), but it was
a small
price to pay to make a man a
man again. If you couldn't afford the
full operation you could get injections
or elixirs to drink, most of which were
colored salt water.
A Nebraska farmer named Joseph Fritz

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Minnie and

Dr. John Brinkley preparing

a

goat gland operation

at their

hospital

in

Milford, Kansas.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

have the same rejuvenating placebo ef
fect on many of his patients.
Typically,
the body of the patient would absorb the
goat glands as foreign matter, but infec
tion and sometimes death were trouble
some side effects.
Behind the hospital was a herd of
Toggenberg goats that the patient could
select from, or if the patient had a partic
ularly frisky goat at home he could bring
it along. Many people did travel
halfway
across the country with their own espe
cially horny goats.
Doctor had a low-key, friendly voice and
could free-associate for hours over the radio:
"My friends, note the difference between the
stallion and the gelding. The stallion stands
erect, neck arched, mane flowing, chomp

ing the bit, stamping the ground,
the female, while the

seeking
gelding stands around

half-asleep, cowardly, listless. Men, don't let
this

happen

to

you."

There were very few radio stations in
the entire country at that time. The radio
was something new and miraculous in
itself, a voice out of the sky. Rural folks
around the country sat around the radio
all

evening listening

to

the Doctor and

Midwestern
musicians like Fiddlin' Bob Larkin and
hillbilly

music

on

KFKB.

Cowboy Slim Rinehart kept the rural lis
teners tuned in.

was voted the most popu
station in America. Dr. Brinkley

In 1929 KFKB

lar radio

was making money hand over fist, and
he spent it just as quickly. The town of
Milford loved him. He bought a limou
sine, jewelry, a yacht, even an airplane.
He bought new uniforms for his Milford
Goats baseball team, paved the streets
of Milford, built a park, and built a new
post office to handle the 3,000 letters he
received daily.

Medical Question Box

colored water. He told the radio audience
what drugs to buy from pharmacists
who were in on the scam. The pharma
cists kicked back one dollar to Brinkley
on each jar sold (at about six times nor
mal retail) and kept the rest of the money.
The pharmacists loved it.

Don't Mess with Doctor
Doctor had his enemies. One of the
most determined was Morris Fishbein,
editor of the Journal of the American Medi
cal Association. The AMA was a growing

but not very powerful organization and
had no real authority except a bully pul
pit. Fishbein was determined to bring
Brinkley down even if it took years.

Fishbein wanted Brinkley's medical li
cense revoked for "organized charlatan
ism." In 1930 the Kansas City Star pub
lished the names of five people who had
died at Brinkley's hospital since the fall
of 1928. His signature was on their death
certificates. Later that year it was dis
covered that actually 42 people had died
there. Some hadn't even been sick when
they arrived. His license was revoked.
At the same time, the Federal Radio

Com

mission withdrew his license for KFKB.
A lesser man might have folded. But
when Doctor's balls were to the wall,
what did he do? He ran for Governor of
the state of Kansas in 1930. His slogan
was, "Let's pasture goats on the statehouse lawn."
There were only five weeks until the
election and he would have to run as a
write-in candidate. But Brinkley had a
few tricks up his sleeve. In his private

plane he visited every county in the state.
It was the first time an
airplane had been
used in a political campaign.
A big crowd would be waiting. Some
one would look up and shout, "There he

plane would circle overhead.
be met by a marching
band. Women in nurses' outfits presented
lollipops and balloons to the children.
At a rally he would have preachers and
musicians entertain the crowd and cheer
leaders would lead a chant to teach the
spelling of Brinkley's name. He drew
huge crowds for the spectacle.
His opponents were boring bureaucratic
men who began to worry they would lose
the election. With three days to go they
is," and his

started an extremely popular
radio segment called "Medical
Box." Listeners would write
questions about their medical
Doctor would prescribe the

In 1928 he

half-hour

Question
in

asking
problems.

right combination of his special elixirs.
"Dear Doctor," said one young lady,
"When female cramps get a grip on me, I
can't do nothing. Can you help?"
"You'll need to take Tonics #27 and #52
for four weeks. It will cure you right up.

But oh, my friends, you must help me.
Remember your letters asking advice
must be accompanied by two dollars."
Doctor had 1,500 drug stores carrying
his tonics, which were made mostly of

The plane

would

passed legislation that said any other
spelling besides "J. R. Brinkley" would in
validate the ballot. As it turned out, Doc
tor won the popular vote in Kansas and
three counties in Oklahoma, but 50,000

�Society
Historical
State

Kansas

In his

1930 bid

for

Governor of Kansas, Brinkley used his private plane

votes were disqualified for incorrect spell
ing. Dr. Brinkley lost his bid for governor.
The time had come to leave Kansas.

to

fly to even/ county in the state. It was the first use of an airplane in

came the most powerful station the world

million-watt XERA.
The station was so powerful that it would

has ever known

electrocute birds
Not in Kansas Anymore

pliances

To make sure no competition sprang up,
Doctor completely demolished his hos
pital in Milford, leaving a pile of rubble.
He moved his entire operation to Del
Rio, Texas. Del Rio was right on the bor
der with Mexico, and at the time Mexico
was angry with the US government for
not letting it have any frequencies on the
radio dial. They invited Brinkley to build
as

powerful

a

station

as he

would like on

the Mexican side of the border, and blast

back into America. And so in 1932, Dr.
Brinkley built 50,000-watt radio station
it

XER in Villa

Acuna, Mexico.

In 1935 it

be

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

spark,

in

turn

mid-flight, make ap
on car

headlights,

make the hair on your arms stand up. If
you had a telephone in Del Rio all you

could hear on it was XERA. Bedsprings
made a perfect antenna so the sounds of
XERA played through your dreams. You
would be lying in your bed and up from
your springs you'd hear, "How many of
you suffer from indigestion, bloating,
belching, and embarrassing gas?"
Old cowboys remembered when they
were mending fences around Del Rio they
could poke

a

tin can onto one of the barbs

of the fence and pick up XERA.

you were
riding along on your horse you could hold
a foot-long
piece of barbed wire in your
If

a

political contest.

teeth and pick up XERA in your head.

The station reached
everywhere in
America, into Canada, across the North
Pole, and into Russia. The KGB used the
station to teach English to its spies. In fact,
when the ionosphere and cloud cover

were just right you could hear XERA any

where in the world, including Australia
and Indonesia.
Country Music was the Lure
Brinkley
mentalists,

programmed
storytellers,

gelists, politicians, and
music. He could afford
in the

business

Brothers,

the

to Del
Pickard

clairvoyants,

preachers, evan
hours of country
to bring the best
Rio: the Delmore
Family, Lonnie

Glosson, the Callahan Brothers, Gene
Autry, Jimmie Rogers, Red Foley, Patsy

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Montana,

J.

E.

Mainer's

Mountaineers,

and from his home town of Sylva, North

Carolina, banjoist Samantha Bumgarner
and fiddler Harry Cagle. He was even
able to lure away from Poor Valley, Vir
ginia, the first family of country music,
the Carter Family.

years passed.

The Circle is Broken
It was the steady income and the warm
winters that got the Carter family all the
way down to Del Rio. The Carter Fam
ily was famous in the Southeast but not
nationally. They had never been able to

make
the

a

good living from recording. Once

Depression

hit, record sales

complete

stalled. But in Del Rio they would each
get $75 a week and not have to deal with
travel, audiences, fans, or agents. Because
ly

of the

unbelievable reach

of XERA,

they

would amass thousands of new fans and
Sara Carter would find her long-lost love.
The Carter Family had become one of
the biggest names in early country music
in the South with songs like "Wildwood
Flower," "Keep on the Sunny Side," and
"Will the Circle Be Unbroken." Sara's
compelling voice was at the heart of their

sound. Maybelle was the guitar genius
and harmony singer. A. P. wrote or found
their songs and sang bass in the trio.
A. P. and Sara were married, but it was
a
strange relationship. A. P. was quiet,
and

prone to take off walking
down the railroad tracks and not come
back for days or even a month at a time,
looking for new songs.
While husband A. P. was wandering off
in the Virginia hills, Sara fell in love with
A. P.'s first cousin, Coy Bayes. Coy was
quirky,

family got to Cali
fornia, Sara didn't even know where Coy
was. And because he hadn't received any
letters, Coy had decided that Sara had
lost interest in him.
Sara and A. P. divorced, but continued
recording and working together. Seven
By the time the Bayes

In 1938 Dr. Brinkley invited A. P., Sara,
and Maybelle Carter to play on XERA.
The problem was that Sara and A. P.'s re

lationship was

to

to

hear back from him, she stopped writing.

don't care."

A. P. I'll do as I durn well
don't need his permission."
Patsy: "A. P., Sara says she will be hap
py to sing an old favorite tonight."
I

N ormaily Sara would just smg her songs
without ever saying a word to the radio

audience. But on this still desert night in
1939, feeling particularly lonesome, she
stepped up to the mic in the XERA studio
and said she was dedicating this song to
Coy Bayes, somewhere out West.

It

had

been eight years since she had seen

or

heard from him.

T'would been better for us both had we never
In this wide and wicked world ever met.

For tlie pleasures we've both seen together
I am sure love we'll never
forget.
Oh, I'm thinking tonight of my blue eyes

Who

is

sailing far over

the seas.

Oh, I'm thinking tonight of him only

And

in

New Mexico, then finally settled in Indi
an Valley, California, an old mining area
250 miles north of San Francisco, exactly
in the middle of nowhere.
Sara wrote him many heartfelt letters
but got no answer. Coy's parents had
been hiding her letters. When she didn't

I

"Tell

Sara,

please.

I

wonder if he ever thinks of me.

Oh, you told me once dear that you loved me

little Poor Valley, Virginia, in 1931, the
kind of scandal for which somebody was

moved out West. They first moved

tonight.

Patsy would turn to Sara and say, "A.
P. would like
you to sing whatever selec
tion you'd like this evening, honey."

for days at a time when A. P. was gone.
Of course, when A. P. found out, he
was hurt and furious. This was a painful,

likely to be killed.
Coy's father couldn't allow it to destroy
his family. He packed up the entire Bayes
clan, including 32-year-old
Coy, and

wouldn't

between them while they were all three
standing in the same room.
A. P. would say something like, "Patsy,
tell Sara she can sing whatever she wants

tall, fun-loving, and 14 years younger
than A. P. Sara and Coy would sneak off

embarrassing, and dangerous scandal

so bad that they

talk to each other. Country singer Patsy
Montana had to deliver the messages

And you said tliat
But

a

zue never

would part.

link in tlie drain has been broken

Leaving me with

a

sad and aching heart.

XERA was so powerful

it

reached all

the way into that little California town
in the Sierra Nevadas, 1,700 miles away.
As luck would have it, Coy happened to
be

listening that night

in 1939 to the Good

Neighbor Get-Together show and heard
Sara say she was dedicating "Think
ing Tonight of My Blue Eyes" to him.
He turned to his mother and said, "I'm
going to go get Sara." His mother said,
"Well, Coy, I guess you better go."

�He traveled all the way to Del Rio, Tex
married her the next week. Sara

as, and

had found her lost love.

Musicians Were Listening
All Over the Country
was

It

the

musicians
tuning

in

mid-1930s

and

budding

remote communities

in to XERA and

were

soaking up the

music. Grandpa Jones in Ohio used to
put a crystal set in a big washtub to am
plify the sound. Everyone in the family
would hang his head over the metal tub
to listen to J. E. Mainer's Mountaineers
and Slim Rinehart.
Young Chet Atkins listened in Tennessee
and learned all the Carter Family songs.

Seven-year-old Johnny Cash fell
with

in love

Carter's

ten-year-old June
(Years later they got married in

voice.

fever.)
Doc Watson in Deep Gap, North Carolina,
sat in front of his radio hearing Smith's
Garage Band play "Beaumont Rag" on
a

the fiddle every night while he worked it
at home on the guitar. Doc heard the

out

Delmore Brothers play "Big River Blues,"
which he reworked into his signature fin
ger-picking song "Deep River Blues."
For the first time, the entire nation could
hear folk and country music. Its popular

ity began to spread to every corner of the
land. Bill Malone says in Country Music
USA, "In the dissemination of country

music

throughout the United States,
nothing was of more importance than the
powerful Mexican border stations. No
one can ever know the number of tradi
tional ballads that may have found their
way into some remote Midwestern area
solely through the means of Mexican

radio transmission, an oral process that

perpetuated the lives of these songs and
made it possible for them to be collected

by folklorists at
A

a

later date."

Six-Inch Life-Size Statue of Jesus

Early country music was the bait, but
product sales were the catch. All kinds
of things were sold over XERA beside
goat gland operations: electric bow ties,

hair dye, genuine simulated diamonds,
tomato plants, live baby chicks, "Certi
fied Radioactive Water," a six-inch "lifesize" statue of Jesus along with an auto

graphed photo and a wind-up John the
Baptist doll. It was the birth of modern

commercial radio.

Dr. Brinkley was making more than a
million dollars a year, while the average
doctor made $3,000.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Ashe
Ray
courtesy

Johnnie Boy, Minnie, and Doctor.
In the heyday in Del Rio, he had 50 sec
retaries to handle his mail, and an army

of assistant quacks. He and his business
partner Mrs. Brinkley built a mansion and
had Galapagos turtles, peacocks, and pen
guins wandering the grounds. There was
a pipe
organ with an organist hired away
from Grauman's Chinese Theater in Hol

lywood. The driveway

to their

was the widest paved road

in

mansion

Del Rio.

He had 12 Cadillacs that were color-coor
dinated with his home, all red one year, all
green the next. They even bought a Cadil
lac for their son, Johnnie Boy, who was still

adolescent. Johnnie Boy had anything he
wanted, even his own bodyguards. People
in Del Rio and around North Carolina re
membered Johnnie as "incredibly spoiled."
There were three gigantic yachts anchored
in Galveston (one was 172 feet long with
a crew of 36), several
airplanes, a 13-carat
diamond on His right hand and a 10-carat
an

on his left, each as big as a quarter.
Jeanette Carter once said that Doctor

in

"He came

with

down the stairs

in

a

white suit

monkey on his shoulder, its tail
wrapped around his neck. We didn't see
a

stuff like that in Poor Valley, Virginia."
The Brinkleys would spend part of the
summer sailing around the world on their
yacht or flying back to Western North Caro
lina to visit friends near the old homeplace.

They bought a second home near East La
Porte, North Carolina, so they could stay
for extended visits. Ray Ashe from Jackson

County remembers visiting the Brinkley at
their summer home. "Everybody around
there thought he was really something.
Once he drove up in a red Cadillac with
'Brinkley' embossed all around it. He was
always nice to us. You would have liked
him. He came to visit my grandmother,
whom he wrote to regularly. He said he
loved her like she was Iris own granny."
This was the high-water mark for the

Brinkleys. But in the late 1930s, Doc
tor made two drastic mistakes. He al
lowed Nazi sympathizers to broadcast
on XERA, which raised the hackles of

vited the Carter family to his mansion. On a
wall near the entrance was a large photo of
Doctor with a record-breaking 750-pound

he

fish, titled "Tuna Fish and Self."

him

the

American government; and worse,
decided to sue Dr. Fishbein for calling
a

quack in

a

magazine article.

�Holt

David

The Brinkleys' summer home near East La Porte, NC.

The End is Coming
In 1938 Dr. Morris Fishbein wrote an
article essentially calling Dr. Brinkley a

charlatan. Foolishly, Doctor started be
lieving his own publicity, and decided
to sue Fishbein for libel and $250,000 in
damages. The trial was to take place in
Del Rio. How could he lose on home turf?
But two things really seemed to trouble
the jury:

Brinkley's

admission

that

he

had been injecting people with colored
water instead of medicine, and the claim
in the advertisements that the goat gland

operation was

a

true graft which, under

oath, Doctor admitted it was not.
The jury found that there was no libel,
which translated that Brinkley could be
called a charlatan as Fishbein had charged.
In the past, Doctor had been able to
stop most damage suits by using threats,
Pinkerton detectives, stalling, or just
paying out of court. But by now he had
more than a million and a half dollars in

judgments against him.
Everything began to unravel as he was
besieged from every side. In 1941 Doctor
had several heart attacks.
Ironically, it was the last mailing of print
ed ads for the goat gland operation that
moved the Postal Service finally to charge
him with mail fraud, after 20 years. Doc
tor was scheduled to appear in the postal
fraud trial in the spring of 1942, but died

shortly before, at the age of 56.
Dr. John Brinkley left quite a legacy as
the most successful charlatan in Ameri

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

can history. He helped in the develop
ment of radio by giving regulators some
thing to regulate. He created the modern
radio format of commercials, talk, and
popular music. He revolutionized po

litical

campaigning by introducing air

planes, sound trucks, and radio.
Perhaps most importantly, his border
radio stations spread early country and
mountain music throughout the United
States, setting the stage for coma try music's
great popularity in the late '40s and early
'50s, and the folk music boom of the '60s.
Brinkley left a million-watt radio sta

a number of fine books that in
clude information on Dr. Brinkley:

There are

The

Roguish

can

North Carolina, area.

Most Dangerous
Pursued Him,

Who

by Pope Brock,

World of Dr.

Brinkley

Gerald Carson, Rienhart, 1960

across the country and opened the door
to grittier rock and roll. As Wolfman said,

David Holt is a Grammy Award-winning tra
ditional musician who lives in the Asheville,

Man

Crown Publishers, 2008

2002

dues to rhythm and blues."
Wolfman Jack talked a young David
Holt into buying an autographed pic
ture of Jesus and 100 live baby chicks
for $3.99, and introduced this young
boy to the sound of Elmore James and
Muddy Waters, who sang "I Just Want
to Make Love to You." But that is a
whole other story

the

and the Age of Flimflam,

tion dormant on the border of Mexico. It
was taken over in the early 1960s by Bob
Smith (AKA Wolfman Jack) who did the
same thing for black music that Brinkley
did for mountain music. Wolfman spread
the sound of black rhythm and blues all

"We pay our

America's

Charlatan:
Huckster,

Border

Radio by Gene Fowler and Bill

Crawford,

Will

by

You

University

of Texas

Press,

Miss Me When I'm Gone: The

Carter Family &amp; Their Legacy

Music

by Mark

in

Ameri

Zwonitzer with

Charles Hirshberg, Simon and Schus
ter,

2002

Country Music, USA by Bill Malone,
University of Texas Press, 1968
For this article I have interviewed Ray
and Ruth Ashe, Jeanette Carter, Doc Wat

son, Wade Mainer, and Lonnie Glosson.

�New, Used 6 Vintage Instruments

5-String 6 4-String Banjos
Vintage Gibson 6 Martin Guitars
Mandolins, Ukuleles. Harp-Guitars,
Resonator 6 Hawaiian Guitars

A A A A A A A AAA A AA A A A A A A A A A A A A

INTERMOUNTAIN

GUITAR

712 East

&amp;

100

BANJO

South

Salt Lake City. UT 84102
tel. 801.322.4682

fax 801.355.4023

guitarandbanjo@earthlink.net
www.guitarandbanjo.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

NOW THERE'S AN EASIER WAY TO TRACK DOWN

r

It's not always easy finding

those Old-Time Music releases independently

produced by devoted musicians. That's why The Old-Time Music Home PplM
opened an online CD store where you can get more of those hard-t6-find;J^P
and the musicians can sell their music without paying a hefty
recordings
commission. Isn't that the way the Old-Time Music community should work?

THE INDEPENDENT
OLD-TIME MUSIC STORE
AT WWW.OLDTIMEMUSIC.COM

I

�Vintage

Instruments
Since 1974

Specialists in Acoustic
Fretted Instruments
New &amp; Old
Experts in sales &amp;
appraisals of vintage
Martin and Gibson
Guitars &amp; Mandolins
New instruments by
C.F. Martin ฀National
Gold-Tone and others
See our web site for our
full inventory of fine

vintage guitars,
mandolins, banjos, ukes,
&amp; fiddles
We also carry a broad
range of accessories

straps, strings, tuners,
Calton cases, etc.
Fred Oster &amp; Catherine Jacobs
507 South Broad Street

Philadelphia, PA 19147

215-545-1100

www.vintage-instruments.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Reese
Bryan

State

Mississippi
Copyright
© 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.
House in Jackson.

�OLD, NEW, AND REAL:

THE CASE OF MISSISSIPPI'S SENATOR GEORGE CECIL MCLEOD
By Chris Goertzen
The following article is excerpted and condensed from Southern Fiddlers and Fiddle Contests,
forthcoming from the University Press of Mississippi.

opportunities; one local logger and fid

the

with him. Camp Shelby, southeast

twentieth century,

the

changes were gradual. The oldest fiddlers
active both in the middle of the twentieth
century and today have lived through
these transformations, sometimes help
ing change come about, at other times
resenting and resisting it. I will illustrate
how fiddlers' lives and activities have
changed in the last half-century through
a case
study of a fiddler who started fid
dling in an environment firmly set in the
past. He is George Cecil McLeod, a farm
er and former Mississippi state senator.
Three McLeod brothers migrated from
the Isle of Skye to North Carolina about
1800; then two of them relocated to Mis

dler brought tunes from Canada home
of

Hattiesburg, housed military profes
sionals and draftees from throughout
the nation; a violin repairman of Ger
man extraction trained there during

World War II; and the nearby Gulf
Coast has always been cosmopolitan.
McLeod's father didn't fiddle, but fid
dlers were far from hard to find. McLeod
recalls

that

"a

of

high percentage

the

folks, either their daddy, or their granddaddy, or their uncle, or their neighbor,
played the fiddle. In their younger days,

they would have gone visiting [to a fid
dler's home], or they knew that their
daddy had, or their parents had
very
few people hadn't been exposed to fid
dling." This echoes another broad factor
in the history of music in the rural South:
fiddling remained more central in musi

sissippi. George Cecil represents the fifth
generation of McLeods in the state. His
family background thus echoes several
broad trends in Southern demography
and in the history of American fiddling.
Many Scots immigrated to rural areas of
the Southern colonies and later Southern

cal life here longer than elsewhere in the
United States, for a mix of demographic
and financial reasons.

United States, and so their musical taste
strongly influenced the formation of
composite Southern musical taste. Their

the company of the two most skilled fid
dlers in the area, his uncle and especially

distinctive

and

rhythmically

complex

fiddling was especially apt for mixing
with blacks' performance practices over
the history of blackface minstrelsy in the
South. Second, many Southerners inter
ested in traditional music issued from a
broad trend in settlement in the South:

families of Southerners gradually spread
west across the South (very quickly in
the McLeods' case) and often have been
in the South for generations. They iden
tify themselves as Southerners more than
as members of any ethnic group.
McLeod was born in 1927, just outside
of Leakesville, in the pineywoods of
Southeast Mississippi. But any roman
tic equating of "rural" with "isolated"
would be hasty and simplistic, even
for the time when McLeod was a child.
Workers in lumber camps moved regu
larly from logged-out areas to newer

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

up on Saturday night to dance.
They'd clear the furniture out of one room
and the hall, and Uncle M. L. would play,
with some of the children accompanying
him, some on guitar, and some of the girls
would sometimes play piano [or] accor
dion. They danced in the bedroom and in

gather

the hall connecting."

Fiddlers back then typically started play
ing later in life than the best fiddlers of
today. By the time McLeod finally owned
a fiddle, his head was full of fiddle tunes.
He was in the tenth grade. His school
band director, a violinist, gave McLeod
lessons for about six months until the
director was drafted. When McLeod fin-

Young George Cecil regularly sought out

distant neighbor named Jode Denmark,
who was born in 1891 into a family in
which many of the men fiddled. I found
a

a common
pattern among older
fiddlers: they had more than One mentor A
close to home and knew fiddlers both J
within and outside of their family.
McLeod's main teacher, Den
mark, "had a little farm

this to be

3

maybe worked some turpentine
and logged wood some. He re
paired instruments a good bit."
Even before he made many treks
to hear Denmark play, McLeod
was regularly exposed to fiddling:
"Uncle M. L. Griffin, who married
my daddy's sister, they had eight
was.
children, all of them older than
They were all talented musically, and my
uncle played the fiddle. And that's where
the young folks up in Leakesville would
'

I

Goertzen

cally during

as both music and
practice changed dramati

fiddling

Chris

Although
as social

�ished high school, he attended Mississip
pi State University for a year, then went
into the Navy for sixteen months. He re
turned in the fall of 1946 and soon had a
semester of violin lessons from the head
of the music department at Mississippi
State College for Women, about twenty
miles east of Mississippi State University,
where he was enrolled. He summarizes
that he has "had a few violin lessons, but
not enough to hurt [my] fiddling."

McLeod played "Sugar Foot Rag" on his

first date with the woman he

would mar

"When I met her, had just learned it,
it was fresh on my mind. I heard that
tune one night [on the radio], when I was
out in the pickup. And it appealed to me.
And I got to humming it. The next morn
ing got up, and while Mama was cook
ing breakfast learned it. And it's always
been one that I liked to play." This sort
I

ry.

and

playing some. And then we had the first
bluegrass festival near Chatom [Alabama]
here in '71. So from that point on, I began
to hear fiddlers more."
Thus, the interval between decline and
revival of fiddling in this part of the Deep
South was remarkably brief, and not so
very long ago. Indeed, when Mr. McLeod
took up the fiddle again, some of the
same forums for performance were there
as earlier (though some of these have

gradually declined since). The use of
fiddling at political rallies was one such
forum: McLeod's opponents didn't spon

sor fiddle music, but he offered it himself,
with telling moments of hesitation:
Even when

the early
through
especially
'70s, I hadn't even thought about the ef

I

I

learning process, that is, inexact rep
lication in which a remembered outline
is fleshed out anew by individuals who
therefore had to command and exercise
considerable creative ability, was more
common then than now. In contrast, to
day's ubiquitous audio recorder allows
fiddlers to emulate one another with as
much precision as the learner's technical
of

running, you go through the newspaper
offices, radio stations, TV stations, and
the local printer to print up stuff to ad
vertise, to get people to remember you to
I'd played in all these
vote for you.
rural counties. I'd gone and played at
the

cakewalks,

knew

in Jackson County [on the coast]. Folks
will ridicule you if you do." [But] folks in
Jackson County was countiy folks [even
if they had moved to the city]. So I carried
7
my fiddle
got up, introduced myself,
and told them I wanted to play a little bit

time that fid
coincidentally
was
aside
in popular
dling
being pushed
consciousness. The biographical factor
was simple: the McLeods had entered

and just slid on into the tune. I didn't
play but just [a few moments] and there
was

the dairy business, a grueling occupation
leaving little time for recreation. The audi

lot].

got

in the

dairy

And I didn't play hard
business in '61
fiddle
from
the time I started dairy
ly any

ing until I got into the campaign [for state
wasn't in
senator] in '67. Consequently,
real good playing form then, but then af
I

I found out it worked
in politics, I got
chance to go to more functions and have
more reason to play some, I went back to

a

a

and

dozen couples
the

crowd

was

up

down there

in

out cards, and

Jackson
I

square

clapping

and keeping time for them before
And the next week
the tune.

I
I

very seldom came across

low that played the fiddle.
It

striking both that McLeod's

is

quit
was

County passing

somebody that hadn't heard of some

fel
con

stituents in rural Greene County thought
that the presumably more cosmopolitan
residents of a county on the coast would
look down on fiddle music, and that those
constituents were at least temporarily

wrong. These residents of Greene Coun
ty apparently were self-conscious about
their own enjoyment of a slice of culture

ter

that was

a

though

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

half

dancing,

ence for fiddling was shrinking anyway,

I

played the fiddle. [Before giving

I

speech, I'd] go and play the fiddle.
And the folks around here were saying;
"Now, don't go and play that thing down

the same

[a

meetings,
Everybody

a

was still part of local daily life during
McLeod's young adulthood in the early
1950s. He performed at square dances
and other functions all over the area. He
had less time to fiddle in the early 1960s,

played right smart

PTA

plays,

and dances, and at home.

McLeod's hearing a fiddle tune on the
radio in 1950 fit Southern trends more
than national
ones. Indeed, fiddling

owing to the inroads of rock music among
the young and a concerted effort by the
media to make public entertainment more
streamlined and thus profitable through
economies of scale. But McLeod returned
to fiddling. He described his performing
hiatus as follows: "Through the '50s, I

in

fect that the fiddle would have when I was
campaigning, because it was just some
But when you're
thing I liked to do.

ability permits.

at

'67 and

ran for office in

I

the '70s,

rural

explicitly old-fashioned by then,

it

had been right at the center of

entertainment when many of them

were children. That McLeod's disagree
ment with their prediction of urban dis
dain for fiddling was on target was ow
ing to his keener sense of demography;
however, the difference in taste that they
wrongly thought was in place around

certainly has materialized since.
can't imagine fiddling being thought
anything better than quaint at a politi
cal rally in Jackson County now. McLeod
still plays at rallies in Greene County oc
casionally, although he feels that the po
litical rally as an institution has declined
considerably. After all, we no longer need
to assemble to learn what candidates
think. But small traditional political ral
lies still occur in Greene County, and or
ganizers welcome McLeod's fiddling out
of respect for him.
I attended
one held June 13, 2003, on a
farm in the county. My impression on ar
riving was of pickup truck after pickup
1970

I

truck, and of powerful odors of barbe
cue. Local candidates spoke briefly, as
did the Republican gubernatorial candi
date in a whirlwind stop. He shook all

hands, praised George Cecil's fiddling,
gave a quick speech in which recollec
tions of hunting segued into references
to Greene County and then to promises
concerning tort reform and other themes
certain to resonate, and was gone. Had
he heard the

fiddling? Had anyone? The
was Republican stalwart and
former state senator McLeod who was
playing seemed the only reason fiddling
was even symbolically valuable.
McLeod's fiddling is more appreciated
these days at another annual political af
fair, the reunion of former state senators
in Jackson. In one room, most of the so
fact that

it

cializing and politicking goes on, and we
eventually eat a traditional catfish din
ner. In a neighboring smaller room, the
caterers lay out enormous chilled prawns
all

and oysters on the half shell (our tax dol
lars at work), and the musicians set up

shop. A few of the attending present and
former senators and members of their

families pay some degree of attention to
the music now and again, and most can
not avoid hearing it at some point, since
patronizing the restroom entails passing
within a few feet of us. But the end result
is not a concert for these politicians but
rather a contribution to a down-home at
mosphere. What's in it for the musicians?
paid nothing (apart from access
pricey snacks), and it's not all that
easy to hear one another through the roil
of hearty conversation. For us, the value
of the occasion is in the energy of the situWe're

to the

�ation and our own take on the symbolism

occasion: our music is a welcome
social lubricant among a crowd of people
who are really accomplishing something.
The something that they are doing while
at the party seems like
everyday schmooz
ing, but this chatter includes power bro
kers influencing one another on matters
of the

of

great consequence

to

our

time

in

the

In

the

state

of this

McLeod's running for office and serv
ing in the Senate during the 1970s led to
a modest but real amount of national ex
posure for fiim through a pair of perfor
mances on the Grand Ole Opry and also
to his

being part of Mississippi's delega
tion to the Festival of American Folklife.
He played at the Opry at the invitation of
Bill Monroe. His friendsJrip with Monroe
resulted from the fortuitous conjunction
of the arrival of bluegrass festivals in Mis
sissippi with the process of running for of
fice. When McLeod was arranging for ra
dio spots during his campaign, he had the

choose what music would
run behind his short broadcast speech
and found that his favorite tune available
at one station was by Monroe. "And that

opportunity

to

[of 1971] we had the first bluegrass
festival I'd ever gone to." After McLeod
got better acquainted with Monroe at the
series of festivals over a half-dozen years,
Monroe invited him to perform as his
guest at the Grand Ole Opry in 1979.
fall

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

up to Washington.
the featured state at

was

It

one they had, and each year

they'd feature a state.
They took up
about 150 Mississippians of various
arts and crafts

[including

a] chair maker

Greene County
7
got
go as a fiddler, mainly because I was
the Senate at the time, and they was

from up here
to

in

to

trying

funding-works.

in

cater

to

the

legislature

know how

you

to

get

that kind

of

don't know if it helped them for
in there I didn't control the
leg

I

me to be

islature

or anything like that. But they
had good intentions. And I enjoyed go
ing, so I'm not complaining about that.

capital,

audience hearing fiddling
because it was increasingly considered
part of American history.
tions

was

Festival of American Folklife.

the eighth

Jackson, his playing territory expanded
to fit that city: "I played in a number
of occasions up there. I carried the fid
dle with me, and every now and then,

there'd be something that came up. I've
played for the historical society, some
old ladies having some sort of a meet
ing. Or play for school young' uns, there
were just a number of things. I played
with the Jackson Symphony, at their
Brown Bag Concert." Such occasions for
performance point out that fiddling was
becoming a music for which much of its
audience was polarized by age, the old
and the very young, but with both sec

went

we

'74,

Mississippi

state. The

essence of the meeting is a heady combi
nation of nostalgia with very real power.
This particular music satisfies because the
crowd, although not uniformly elderly,
does center on men in their seventies who
remember when fiddle music was the dai
ly fare for political occasions.
We'll return now to McLeod's time as
a member of the Senate, the
early 1970s.
Since doing this job caused him to spend

considerable

An earlier trip that resulted from McLeod's
visibility as a fiddler and state senator was
:o the Festival of American Folklife:

But they carried

..as

a

a
fellow up therefrom
Meridian, Mississippi]

[near

Chunky

square dance caller. And

I

didn't

even know that they was carrying a fel
low up there as a square dance caller...

Coming back [from a concession stand, I
saw that] fellow on stage, and he was try
ing to get people lined up to square dance.
They had just skadoodles of people. I don't
know if anybody had

count.

a

It

was differ

ent things going on all over the mall, and a
crowd of folks had been there and listened to
our music. And [the caller] was trying [to

arrange

a

dance for

bunch of college kids
stage: He could see as

group including]

a

I
I

a

came around the

came around that

I

knew something about it. He immediately
called on me to lead [the dancers]
So we got out there. He was

figures. Of course
ing

to

calling

the kids [had] seen

the

danc

fiddle music, [but] they didn't know

anything but skipping. They'd skip from
here plumb over to that couch over yonder
per skip, and just absolutely mess a dance
up because of the long skip.

Everybody can

skip that far, you know. It's

of

a

a

dance step. But they saw

't

skip instead
it

done

in a

movie; I remember seeing the same movie.
And it was some Tin-Pan-Alley [director's]
idea of a way to put emphasis on
just hozv hillbilly it was

it, to

show

And Ralph Rinzler's wife [Kate] was in
he was put
charge of the stage up there
ting on a clinic square dancing, up at the
end of the mall. And she
had seen me
calling square dance when we was play
ing for ourselves, and she asked me would
go up there and call a square dance. There
wasn't anybody up there at that stage. So
I

Mickey [Davis,

a

violist who also fiddles]

got a guitar picker, and we walked up there
[and led a very successful dance].

Thus, at this national event, McLeod
found that the little that well-intended
younger urban visitors knew about
square dancing had not come from per
sonal experience. Instead, what they
knew about the main kind of dance asso
ciated with older-style fiddling had been
filtered through the media, and thus styl
ized to exaggerate rustic associations.
Of course, many Americans in the babyboom generation likely including much
of the festival audience
learned some

dancing in physical education
classes. I remember this well: a gym with
its characteristic palette of odors, mixed
attitudes on the parts of the participants,
and a scratchy variable-speed turntable
from which emanated bad renditions of
music seldom connected with the older
history of the dance, with fiddline.
McLeod still likes to teach square danc
ing and insists that it be done with as
much historical accuracy as possible.
True, this process entails his relinquish
ing his treasured role of fiddler to some
square

one else, and

it is not always easy to find
fiddler for this purpose. He does
not explain steps over the microphone
but teaches as he learned, from within
the square. He is the man in the head
couple and talks and maneuvers others
during the dance.

an apt

I witnessed
him teaching square danc
ing recently at the Two Rivers Bluegrass Festival (held in his hometown of
Leakesville), as one of the activities away
from the stage on an evening early in the

festivities. Among the participants were
a handful
of experienced dancers, avid
who
had learned fancy square
hobbyists
as
dancing
part of a club. This presented
its own problem: these dancers wished

"help" McLeod by taking over, by
teaching the modern fancy western-style
square dance.
What of other settings that called for
fiddlers or at least offered the sounds of
fiddling to the public in Greene County,
Mississippi, earlier in the century? Fid
dling on local radio ceased when rock
music arrived, then returned in a small
way with bluegrass, though that faded
too after a while. How about fiddle con
tests? McLeod played at them regularly
to

for fifty years, but their flavor continually
evolved, so his tune choices for contests

have changed
contest, held

in
in

1949, he played

response. In his first
Fruitdale, Alabama, in

"Pop Goes the Weasel"

holding his fiddle not just under his chin,
but also upside down, behind his back,
and

so forth.

That contest still retained

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

much of the feel of 1920s, but times were
changing. Later, McLeod did well in a
contest through a politically astute tune
choice: "In the playoff, I played a waltz,
and I played 'Carroll County Blues.' And
I was
in territory close to where 'Carroll
County Blues' supposedly emerged."
When McLeod, following his teacher's
advice, began using "Ragtime Annie" in
contests, he discovered that other tradi
tional Mississippi fiddlers found his ver
sion suspect, in part because a flourish
with which he opened the high strain
was deemed unusual but even more so
because of the inclusion of Jode Den
mark's third strain (one that McLeod
hadn't often heard elsewhere, because it
is found almost exclusively in Texas ver
sions). Yes, that strain does appear in the
1922 commercial recording by Texan Eck
Robertson, and that may well be why it
was in the version McLeod learned, that
record
of Jode Denmark. Robertson's
ings were sold all over the United States

during the 1920s and 1930s but that sub
sequently became much harder to find.
This efflorescence was during Denmark's
youth. Denmark's repertoire was eclec
tic, just as Eck Robertson's had been, and
iust as McLeod's would be.
Today, with a lower geographical density
of fiddlers and with fiddlers meeting and
hearing each other at contests or festivals
more often than in each other's homes,
more of a purist attitude has emerged,
one not very tolerant of heterogeneity of

repertoire or style, despite admiring the
eclectic repertoires of fiddlers of the past.
Contests, in order to be coherent, need to
be divided into categories, and these are
often defined by style. Thus, many con
tests in the Southeast place fiddlers in ei
ther the old-time category or that of bluegrass. Elsewhere in the country, a contest
may have old-time style separated out
from the array of newer solo fiddle styles
that are centered on Texas contest style.
Such segregations by style have benefi
cial effects. By protecting styles possess
ing less "ear candv" than the contestoriented styles, these separate categories
of

competition preserve variety

of style.

since these styles are of different
vintages and appeal to performers of dif
ferent ages in some parts of the country,
the separation allows for the exposure of
a broader sweep of the history of Ameri
can fiddling during contests. McLeod
could have easily won more at contests
by having become more of a modern oldAnd

if he had sought out
old-time style self-consciously and

time purist, that is,
an

�Goertzen
Chris
of
courtesy

Sen. McLeod playing at home accompanied

by the author, Chris Goertzen.

meticulously avoided any influences of
bluegrass or of Texas fiddling. But that
would have been true neither to the let
fiddle tradition
inherited in Leakesville, Mississippi.
And his own cumulative approach to
shaping a repertoire and style strikes me
neither labored
as an unusually careful
nor precious but genuinely nuanced
mix of respect for what he learned from
his principal teacher, Jode Denmark, with
how fiddling evolved in his own life af
ter his apprenticeship years. He reflects
on his music more than many fiddlers do
but does not obsess about any aspect of
symbol or sound. It's fun, it's history, it's
ter nor to the spirit of the

he

part of him, and it's

a

way

share this

to

whole package with family, friends, and
also with strangers, who thus are more

likely to become friends.
Would McLeod pass on tunes in the
same sort of intimate environments inwhich he learned them? The simple an
swer is no, but the reasons are complex.
The chance of keeping fiddling vital
in

the family

would

and

in

the

neighborhood

some continuity in
depend
several spheres, in how daily life in rural
areas does or does not encourage extend
ed families to stay reasonably intact and
to interact regularly, to what degree fid
dling can be heard on a regular basis out
side of the home, and whether a musical
child would see fiddling as a fun choice
for

a

on

hobby.

Of George Cecil's children,

lives

at

home and

a

a

daughter

son lives very near

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

McLeod's former home. Another
child lives in Mobile, Alabama, about
an hour away, several are in Atlanta,
one teaches at Delta State (about two
hours away), and a daughter has retired
with her air force husband in Hawaii.
Since Leakesville has neither the natu
ral resources nor felicitous location that
would encourage further growth, hav
ing more children in this large family
depart than stay isn't surprising and
in fact simply reflects national demo
graphic trends. But, unsurprising or not,

by in

this doesn't help in fostering any sorts
of oral tradition within such families. In

McLeod's kids took up the
fiddle. There were so many other kinds
of music around to enjoy as they grew
up (a much wider selection than in their

fact, none of

parents' childhoods), and fiddling sym
bolized patterns of life from which they
grew away. Will an apprentice surface
outside of the family but within the com
munity, someone who will visit George
Cecil the way he visited Jode Denmark?
This hasn't happened yet.
In a sample fortnight, from September
28 through October 12 of 2002, George
Cecil McLeod fiddled in quite a vari
ety of venues. His main guitar accom
panist for nearly thirty years has been

a retired postal worker who
lives in Wiggins, about an hour's drive
from Leakesville (they met at a bluegrass festival in the mid-1970s); how
ever, McLeod often invites others to join
in. At the annual McLeod family reunion

Lee Fulcher,

�Leakesville, he, Lee, and played in a
a church
fellowship hall while
well over one hundred family members
in

I

corner of

visited with each other and filled their
plates with home cooking. Some folks
listened and some didn't, but even those
who hadn't seemed to have been paying
attention later expressed sincere grati
tude; it was clear that symbol as well as
sound had mattered.
The Pine Belt's dulcimer club invited
him to fiddle a few numbers at their

meeting in Hattiesburg and
also to join in with their group numbers
when possible. ("We play in the key of
D," we were told at this low-pressure
jam.) On the way to that event, he and
weekly

Fulcher stopped off

county hos

at the

pital and played for the ward on which
Mrs. McLeod was recuperating from
hip surgery. He and Fulcher performed
one evening at a local restaurant, and

they also competed at the state fiddle
contest held during the state fair. Last,
we three would have played during
the opening evening of a local bluegrass festival, but back-to-back tropical
storms caused the festival to be can

celed. This was an especially busy time
for McLeod as fiddler, but the venues
were representative.
McLeod continues to do his best to
continue to represent his local fiddle
tradition and considers it both an honor
and a pleasure to do so. To what degree
is his case representative? It does seem
that most of the venues in which he
now plays welcome him partly because
he is a fiddler but more because they
enjoy his charisma and wish to honor
His personal his
tory illustrates broad shifts of fiddling
in American culture, first moving from
him as an individual.

normal

entertainment
viewed

area to being

in
as

a
a

very rural

fun illustra

tion of history, then to being the stable

linchpin of a fiddle-based subculture,
the fiddle contest environment.

Chris Goertzen teaches music history and
world music at the University of Southern
Mississippi. He is the author of Fiddling
for Norway: Revival and Identity, and
coeditor of the volume of the Garland En
cyclopedia of World Music about Eu
ropean music. His new book, Southern
Fiddlers and Fiddle Contests, will be
published this November by the University
Press of Mississippi.

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Section with Illegible Text

Old Time Music for the Holiday

Season

20041

12005

1

2006

I

2007

12008

Great old time gifts from the Field Recorders' Collective: CDs, DVDs or photographs. Below is just a sampling of our
CDs and DVDs, please come to visit www.fieldrecorder.com to hear sound samples and see all of our offerings. We
are now in our fifth year of producing quality and rare old time music!

order via US mail, send a check made payable to the Field Recorder's Collective to the address
below. $15 each CD, $20 each DVD PLUS $5 for US domestic priority mail. Please check our Web
site for additional discs and discounted sets. We accept Paypal and credit cards on our Web site.

To

Field Recorders' Collective,

124 Quaker Bridge Road, Croton, NY 10520

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

The Field

Recorders'

collective

�Reviews

ongoing documentation of Texas religious
and vernacular music he initiated. (Ray
Alden has put up a beautifully done web
site about Owens on fieldrecorder.com,
and there are additional related articles
there by Dan Foster.) Alas, however, the
original recording media and field notes

Texas Fiddle Bands:

The Bill Owens 1939 Recordings

did not survive, so we are mostly are left

with some speculation about the artists
on this disc, but we do have their music.

Marynell Young made an admirable at
tempt to determine name spellings and
tune titles, so huzzahs to her.
There is considerable historical signifi

Field Recorders' Collective FRC 409
J.

D.

A. (jack) Meyers, fiddle;

Vee

Tuller, guitar;

J.

Dillingham, banjo, vocal; Sam Welch (fiddle)

and Family; Ed Gillespie, fiddle; Colonel Ogden
and his son Jimmy; Jace Middlin (fiddle) and his
Alabama Boll Weevils

Hell Among the Yearlings
Arkansas
Durang's Hornpipe Rickett's
Soldier's
Hornpipe Eighth of January
Leather Britches
Irish
Joy /Little Fish
Washer Woman
Rustic Dance
Cattle
Traveler

Cane Break
Run Nigger Run
Billy in the Low Ground /Give the Fid
dler a Dram Heel and Toe Polka with the
Night Cap On Polka Schottische
Sally
Gooden
Patsy Mind the Baby /Cripple
Creek
The Bastard King of England
Cornhuskin' Gal
Listen to the Mocking
Bird
Rochester Schottische
Sally John
son San Antonio Rose
in the

remarkable collection is something
that veritably came out of nowhere. There
is a long saga involved with bringing
other of Bill Owens' field recordings that
This

urge you to read, at www.fieldrecorder.
com. In that narrative, Dan Foster (my
introduction to these old recordings of
I

fiddlers) describes his odyssey in
tracking down the Peter T. Bell recordings
initially, and then finding better-quality
copies. Marynell Young, Steve Green,
several others, and I were all involved at
various stages of these voyages of discov
ery. Marynell went on an alternate trail,
Texas

failing to find the original Bell disks, but
found this lovely treasure, something we
knew nothing about prior to her discov
ery. I hope at some point Marynell will
write down her part of the discovery
put on the FRC website. In short, she
found digital copies of the original discs

to

in the Cushing Collection at Texas A&amp;M
University, and made copies. These items,
contained on this CD, were recorded by
Bill Owens on an instantaneous disc re
corder that he modified in 1939, part of an

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

cance in this set, and the Bell set, as Dan
Foster discusses on the FRC site. Owens
captured some of the few audio record
ings of the older Texas fiddle music, precontest style and pre-swing. We do hear
on this CD that these two styles (now

dominant

in Texas)

made some inroads

among the group that Owens recorded,
but more about that later.
Bill

Owens

or

some of the musicians talk

and announce on some of the discs. The
set starts out with a recording session on
February 18, 1939, in or near Austin. The
as Marynell identified them,
"Uncle Jack" Meyers on fiddle,

musicians,
are

J.

A.

Vee Tuller on guitar, and

J.

D.

Dillingham

on banjo. We'll hear more about them lat
er, too. They have a very nice set of tunes

a solid
square dance band. Their
"Hell Among the Yearlings" is not the
common D tune usually associated with
that title, nor is it the tune that Ft. Worth

and are

denizen Moses Bonner recorded

for

Vic

Canebrake."
More than likely, they'd have been famil
iar with Bonner, who had been quite in
volved in fiddlers' associations in Texas.
It bears more resemblance to the "Paddy
tor in 1925, "Yearling's in the

on the Turnpike"
"The Route" group of
tunes that some call a "double tonic" be

dance music. Following these tracks is
one solo performance by Dillingham on
banjo and vocal, singing "Diamond Joe."
This is a reprise, of sorts. "Reprise?" you
ask? Yes sirs and ma'ams. This Dilling
ham fella recorded this tune for John A.
Lomax in Austin in December 1935, and
it is now housed in the American Folklife
Center in the Library of Congress (AFS
537-A). This is the source Bruce Molsky
used for his reworking of this tune. And
no, it is not the "Diamond Joe"that the
Cofer Brothers waxed in the 1920s, nor
the one that floated around the singersongwriter scene in the 1960s.
Ed Gillespie, fiddle and vocal, is next
up on this CD. We don't know, however,
who else was on this recording session.

His "Little Fish" evokes "Bright Sher
man Valley," with echoes of "Free Little
Bird." "Leather Britches" sounds to me
like there are two fiddles on it, and is
done rather slowly with a nice sortie
into the upper register. The "Irish Wash
er

Bonner's "Yearling's in the Canebrake,"

and is almost a missing link in the eti
ology of this tune that eventually be
came popular as "Cattle in the Cane" in
more modern times. "Run, Nigger, Run"

probably owes a lot to the John Carson
(1924) and Skillet Lickers (1927) rendi
tions. No doubt, however, that tune was
very widespread. Gillespie ends his set
with a nice, slow version of "Billy in the
Low Ground," again sounding like two
fiddles at work. Jace Middlin's group

cause the tonal center shifts from the Ichord to the VH-chord, something many
associate with classic Scots folk fiddling,
but Meyers' tune has a more minor qual

has

ity, or more

the

"modalish," if you will. They
take "Arkansas Traveler" at a moderate
pace and I do hear some nuances of the
Texas contest style, but it still would make
a great square dance piece. Meyers' "Du

rang's" is bouncy and jaunty, notey, and
with short bow strokes. His "Rickett's"
is a classic book version, almost like he
obtained it from Cole's 1000 Fiddle Tunes
(or its ancestor, Ryan's Mammoth Collec
tion). "Soldier's Joy" is kind of a "book"
version, with variations, and there is

nothing particularly noteworthy
"Eighth of January" except that

in

their

it is

solid

Woman," in 6/8 time, again sounds

like there are two fiddles. I don't know
if Gillespie called the next piece "Rustic
Dance" or if someone else put that title
on it. It is not the same melody usually
associated with that title (though the
story of that title could be an entire arti
cle in itself), but like that tune, it is in the
key of C and is an old-time schottische
or clog. Gillespie's rendition of "Cattle
in the Cane Break" is very evocative of

a

pleasant peppy sound on "Give

Fiddler a Dram" that sounds like
some cross-pollination of similar tunes
in the family, using what sounds like
fiddle, guitar, bass, and perhaps tenor
banjo, banjo, or mandolin. The next two
items are listed as "unknown" but the
fiddling sounds very familiar. "Wag
oner"

sounds

like it is surely in Ed
able
hands, with some ting
Gillespie's
es of Am Stuart and J. W. Day thrown
in. It sounds like two fiddles, again, on
"Pick the Devil's Eye Out" with one part
sounding like "Eighth of January," and
the obligatory pizzicato.

�Marynell told me the next performers'
names sounded like "Colonel Ogden and
son Jimmy/' and though it does not sound
like that to me, I can't tell you what it does
sound like. So they may remain a mys
tery. Whoever they may be, they hearken
back to the older styles of ranch and so

course, and I have my favorites among
modern Texas fiddlers, but I prefer the
older styles found on this CD (and also
surviving in West Texas among members
of the Lewis family; someone should re
cord and issue material from them, and
do some interviews). I am submitting

cial dancing, lots of couple and big-circle
formats and non-breakdowns, which is a

to the

subject that Dan Foster addresses in his

essays on the FRC website. The interest
ingly titled "Heel and Toe Polka with

"Jenny Lind
Polka." Check out Narmour and Smith's
"Heel and Toe Polka" (1929) for another
example of this piece. Ogden next plays
"Polka Schottische," which we hear to be
a version
of "Flop Eared Mule," which
the

Nightcap On"

appeared in print

is in fact

as "The

Detroit Schot

Howe's mid-nineteenth
century publication(s) Musician's Omni
bus, and has been found in many Euro

tische"

in Elias

pean folk musicians' repertoire as some
thing of their own. Next is a bit of a sur
prise, "Old Sally Gooden," in A and with
a wild guitar rhythm. Their final track, a
very nice one, is called "Patsy Mind the
Baby" and is an old-fashioned clog.
Sam Welch and Family (Leroy Bowman
on guitar

perhaps), recorded

in

Austin

in

March 1939, finish this set with a more
modern sound. "Cripple Creek" is longbowed, with some pizzicato. "Bastard
King" is quite the bawdy piece, sung by
solo voice and guitar. "Corn-

Mr. Welch,

Gal" is a fiddle /guitar piece
style of "Old Richmond," "Katy
There's a Bug on Me," which probably
knew life at one time as a schottische be

huskin'
in the

fore

becoming

a

breakdown.

It's

pretty

notey, and has the feeling to me of the
1930s "Hillbilly radio show fiddling"
sound. They follow that up with fiddle
and guitar on "Listen to the Mocking
Bird," with the requisite third-position

Next up is something
"Rochester
Schottische," and

meanderings.
called

schottische, it is not the mel
associated with this title.
The now-ubiquitous contest tune "Sally
while

it is a

ody usually

Johnson" makes its appearance here,
with modern chord backup and perhaps
tenor banjo. They end the set with the
Texas swing favorite and standard "San

Antonio Rose," very swingy.
So there

you have

it,

a

wide variety of

styles and sounds, showing how nonhomogenous Texas fiddling had been
at one time, before everyone seemed to
try to sound like whoever had won the

previous year

test. There are

at the

Crockett fiddle con

wonderful exceptions,

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

of

Old-Tune Herald a listing of Texas
fiddlers recorded prior to World War II
who were recorded for the Library of
You can

Congress.

read this list at www.

-ed.)

oldtimeherald.org.

Examples

of their

fiddling can be found at the Library of
Congress website, in the John A. and
Ruby T. Lomax site, http:/ /memory.loc.
gov ammem lohtml lohome.html.
In

listening

Dillingham,
reminded

to

J.

A.

Meyers, with J. D.
I was
strongly

on this CD,

Miers (sic) and J. D.
Dillingham's recordings for John Lomax,
in

the

of A.

J.

Austin area

in

1935 and

1936. In

deeper into some unpublished
research by Guthrie Meade, I found that
Gus listed this gent as Andrew J. Mears. I
then searched for Andrew J. Mears in the
Social Security Death Index, and found
Andrew J. Mears, born November 19,
1892, died August 1975 in Mansfield, Tar
rant County. Unless someone in that area
does a more thorough search and perhaps
can interview relatives, or does a newsdigging

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

paper search for fiddlers, we may never
if this is, in fact, the same person.
I did a similar search for J. D.
Dillingham
and found Jefferson D. Dillingham, born
November 25, 1898, died in Austin on

know

May

5,

1998.

I

found census information

Dillingham, born
who
moved
to Tarrant
Kansas,

on an older Jefferson D.
in 1867 in

County and appeared there in the 1930
census records. There also was a vague as
sociation with this elder Dillingham with
the legendary Texas outlaw Sam Bass, but
the entry I found was incomplete, so I
don't know the nature of the association.
One regret I have is that Bill Owens did
not record

J. D. Dillingham on his fiddle,
something that John Lomax had done, but

those discs are in pretty bad shape. Or

at

least the tape dubs are.
KERRY BLECH
To

Order: www.fieldrecorder.com

�several cuts of Tommy playing banjo
with Earnest East (only faintly heard) on
fiddle, with Mac Snow on guitar. There
is one track of Laurence Lowe (Charlie
Lowe's son) on fiddle with Fred Cocker
ham on banjo, and one cut from an old
home recording of Tommy and Charlie

Lowe.
If

of

you're already familiar with the music
these musicians and have their record

a must-have CD for an
invaluable glimpse into what it was like
to sit around playing music with these

ings, this is still

informal settings, or, as we like
you like old-time mu
sic and aren't familiar with these players,
or don't have their recordings, you gotta
have it. These musicians are the real thing
and these were real moments in time
guys

in

to call it, real life. If

ALICE GERRARD
To order:

www.fieldrecorder.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�But that misses

the point. These aren't
these are friends making

performances,
music together where, through good for
tune, there was a tape recorder running.
I'm glad we have these. Thanks to Andy
Cahan for recording them. As Ray Alden
says, "You have but to put this CD in
your player to unlock these treasures."
PETE PETERSON
To order:

www.fieldrecorder.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�The most interesting of the instrumen
are the banjo duets. "Waiting for

tal

Nancy" and "Bear's Leaving Town" (both
written by Curt in 1978) are exciting lis
tening. Two banjos back up Curt's rendi
tion of "Sweet Sunny South," a perfect

setting for Charlie Poole's wistful song.
The last track, a "Reuben's Train" esque
version of "Nine Hundred Miles," fea

tures both Curt and Bob singing, both
playing Curt's gourd banjos. This would
be a really stunning finish to the album
if it wasn't a whopping seven and a half

minutes long. The singing doesn't start
until five minutes or so into the track.
There's a saying I've seen on hats and
shirts: "Old-time music
better than

Tit

believe this track to be a per
example of that phenomenon. It must
have been fun to play; Curt mentions in
sounds."

I

fect

the liner notes that they played the tune
for 20 minutes, probably inducing the

tune

trance

that's such

a

great feature

of playing old-time tunes. Sometimes it
doesn't translate to listening, though.
The more familiar
tunes
"Seneca
Square Dance" and "Mississippi Saw
are played as banjo/hammered
dulcimer duets. These are less success
ful. The instruments are playing in the

yers"

same pitch range, for the most part, and

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

dulcimer's sustain gives a muddy
to the mix, covering the banjo's

the

feeling

quicker attack and decay.
Some songs on this CD will be familiar
to listeners. Others are less well known,
of greater antiquity, with interesting ar
rangements. I found a couple of things
distracting, though. Most of the vocals

way in front of the instruments, giv
ing an auditory picture of voices a few
inches from your ears while the instru
ments are several feet away. The vocal
harmonies, though precisely worked out
in terms of pitch, don't always match the
phrasing of the lead vocals.
are

Special mention needs to be made of
Rangers." I remember listening
to the New Lost City Ramblers' version;
the liner notes also cite Ian and Sylvia as
a source. I have seldom had such vivid
pictures in my mind from hearing a song
"Texas

as

I

had from listening to Bob and Curt's

arrangement, Curt freely echoing Bob's
meditative vocal phrases on the ham
mered dulcimer. This form of emotional
punctuation is common in Indian classi
cal and ghazal singing, which translates

song with an eerie effectiveness.
Among the less-well-known songs are
"A Long Time Ago," a humorous capstan
shanty with concertina accompaniment,
to this

"Ticklish

an

Reuben,"

early-twentieth-

century novelty "laughing" song, and "I
Only Want a Buddy (Not a Sweetheart),"
widely popular in the 1930s, recorded by
Bradley Kincaid and Bing Crosby, among
others.
The liner notes

a
delight. Schol
instru
information,
arly background
ment details, and general musings are
imparted with a light touch and a solid
sense of humor.

are

HILARY DIRLAM
To order:

Note

to

(650) 804-2049; or

www.cdbaby.com

Artists and Record Companies

Please send all material for review to
the OTH (PO Box 51812,

Durham, NC

27717). Do not send to individual

review

ers. What gets reviewed is determined at
the discretion of the OTH according to

space available, balance of old and new,
and compatibility with our mission. We
cannot review everything that comes in
nor guarantee that because we received
it we will review it. We do not return ma
terials to the sender. Thanks!

�rounded by a large wilderness area, home
to native plants and wildlife Northern
California, it lends its name to this string
band, based in Walnut Creek.
Carl Pagter, Harry Liebstrand, and Matt
Dudman have been active musicians and
organizers in the traditional music scene
for many years. (More details are avail

Grand Picnic
Mt. Diablo String Band

able on their CDBaby page.) Harry Lieb
strand started playing fiddle at age four,
learning from his father. Moreover, this is
band. Harry and Cin
a two-generation
and
son play fiddle and
dy's daughter

Harry Liedstrand, fiddle and vocals; Cindy LiedTerrell Liedstrand,
strand, guitar and vocals;
mandolin; Carl Pagter, banjo and vocals; Corbin
Pagter, mandolin and vocals; Matt Dudman,
bass; Parrin Liedstrand, fiddle

mandolin, and Corbin, Carl's son, plays
mandolin and sings.

Woodchuck/Old and Gray/
Ladies Quadrille/Pine Valley Waltz/Fire

ergy, precise rhythm that

Indian Ate

on the

a

Mountain /The Happy Tune /Will

the Roses Bloom (Where She Lies

Sleep

Billy Wilson /Crockett's Hon
eymoon/Goodbye, Girls, I'm Going to
Boston/Shamus O'Brien /Forked Deer/
Wild Goose Chase/
Taggart's Reel #3
Hobb Dye/Tater Patch /Grand Picnic/
ing) /Old

Jeff

Sturgeon

Mt.

Diablo

landscape

is
in

familiar feature of the
California's Bay Area. Sur
a

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Given the size of the group, and the fact
doesn't seem to play out
much, they have a surprisingly high-en
that the band

would enliven

dance or festival stage anywhere in the
US. The band's repertoire is drawn from
a

Appalachia, California (via
Mill Band, of which Harry

the

Sweets

is

former

a

member), with a couple of tunes from the
Midwest and New England thrown in for
good measure. All tunes and songs are
performed with authenticity and taste.
"Old and Grey," learned from Kenny
Hall, who got it from a Charlie Poole 78, is
sung by Harry with a hard-edged plain
tiveness reminiscent of the singing of Peter

Stampfels. Other California tunes include
"Ladies Quadrille," "Pine Valley Waltz,"
and "The Happy Tune," a suitably cheery
rag in C. "Will the Roses Bloom Where She
Lies Sleeping"

Scruggs)

is

(popularized by Flatt and

sung

as

a

father-son duet by

Carl (lead) and Corbin (tenor). "Crockett's

is a lovely tune originally
recorded in the 1920s by Crockett's Ken
tucky Mountaineers, who lived in Fowler,
California, from 1919 on, making this a
great choice for the CD.
With
The album is well recorded.
so many instruments and quite a few
switches of lead and backup vocals, it
might have suffered from a lack of clarity.
Everything is, however, bright and clear.
Cindy Liedstrand's guitar work deserves
special mention; she and Matt Dudman
(bass) provide a rock-solid rhythmic un

Honeymoon"

derpinning for the rest
The liner notes

are

of the band.

well done, citing

original sources whenever possible. Last
a stunning photo of
the Mt. Diablo range on the cover. This
is a well-crafted album, and if you want
to listen to some old-time music played
in the traditional family band style, I

but not least, there is

recommend this CD.

HILARY DIRLAM
To order:

www.cdbaby.com/cd/mtdiablosb

�The Horse Flies

Field Recorders' Collective 602

violin vocals; Jeff Claus: acoustic
guitar, banjo-uke, vocals; Richie Stearns: banjo,
vocals; John Hayward: bass; Taki Masuko: per
cussion; Peter Dodge: accordion, synth
Judy Hyman:

Ride

Old

Buck/Jimmy

Johnson/New

Monongahela/ Improvisations /Who
Throwed

Lye/Cotton

Eyed

Joe/Lost

Train Blues /Oh Death /I Live Where It's
Gray/ Thank You Frank /Jenny on the

Railroad /Human Fly /Candy Girl/Iko/
Breaking Up Christmas

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�in

1995),

fiddle band pow
fifth gear. The difference

which it's

a

ering along in
of the
is mainly about the "experience"
to learn
If
CD,
wanting
you're
guess.
one of Chirps' tunes, this CD is perfectly
set up for that delightful chore. Chirps
introduces each one, plucks his strings
for tuning, and sets to work, mostly on
1

fiddle but sometimes on another instru

There's no particular "build" to
listening to the whole disc as a piece
ment.

"con
outmoded
any
cept
that
demand
unless
your
you
just
ways,

but then the Internet has made the

somewhat

CD"

listener do
whole hour

it
a

your way by making the
single cut. Chirps' tunes, at

Some you'll
are totally
others
version
know some
of;
fresh unless you already know Chirps'
playing. For some reason was particu
any rate, are plumb choice.

I

larly happy to see "Citaco" among the
tunes. It's one I'd heard a long time back
at one of those campfires I was mention
ing, and I didn't remember it at all. Now
I've got it here and I've only got me to
blame for not learning it. Mama tried.
It's

CD.

ereat to hear this Renegades
There's not enough emphasis in oldreallv

time music

singing, partly or mainly
due to the kind of random fact that con
tests tend to highlight the instrumental
when it comes to the old-time category,
but also because a lot of good or even great
old-time pickers just don't seem to want
to sing. I don't understand this reticence.
on

Both Tommy Jarrell and Bob Dylan have
made it crystal clear that it's really okay to

sing, that you don't have to be Tammy or
Ella to do it, or even do it well. Maybe if

Tammy or Ella were actually in the room,
you might STFU. Otherwise, believe in
your voice; leam the words right, listen to
how it's done, then do it sing! Anyways,
the Renegades never had this problem of
reticence, and they didn't need a contest
This CD comes from its origi
situation.
nal 1993 DAT recording,

issued then

as

a

cassette, plus (some or all of, it's not clear)
their 1995

I

Need

to

Find CD.

As all four

members are songwriters, there's

a

lot of

original material on the disc, most of it still
in the style of that part of old-time music
that gets called "early country" or "classic
country" sometimes, particularly when it
has electric instruments or drums. James
Leva, who writes the notes on the cover,
I'd
calls the band "nascent Americana."
the
lack
of
about
twang
only quibble
here
just don't understand why there's
I

no steel, tele, or light drums, at least from
time to time, aside from it being just an ar

bitrary decision.

But I'm

speaking purely

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

musically obviously these folks come out
of the old-time world, where electric isn't
appreciated much, and where the tastes
hearken back to the pre-electric sounds of,
again, the Monroes, the Stanleys, the Cart
ers, the string bands.

I'm

in total

agree

ment with James that old-time as a living
genre encompasses must encompass
has to be happening now;
harder, more manual way
the past. And bands like
of "recording"
the Renegades are evidence that, indeed,

originality.
it's not

It

simply

a

really alive. Toucliing
CD offers great perfor
this
the other base,

old-time music

is

tire great old-time tunes:
from Burl Hammons, "High

mances of some of
"Big Scioti"

from Emmett Lundy,
Farewell"
Old Hen." If you
"Cluck
Winds,"
"Chilly
didn't hear tire Renegades live, or only sorta remember how good they were: voila.

landers

The Horse Flies live in another hemi
Some
sphere of the old-time planet.
another
from
even say they're entirely
planet. Not true, not at all. They began
as a band in 1981, up in the environs of
Ithaca, New York a veritable jungle of
the old-time, full of Highwoods and Hen
ries (and these days, Buffalo even). This
CD gives us five early cuts of their music,

recorded at home in 1984, two of them
pretty much damn good traditional fiddle
tune cuts
raucous, driving, with clean,
rhythmic fiddling and, from the first cut, a
very interesting, distinctive take on banjoplaying from Mr. Stearns. Then, with the
third cut, the CD shows us the evolution
of the Horse Flies into a string band that
admits, embraces, accepts the fact that its
members live in the '80s and '90s, can play
their instruments creatively as well as
with a grounding in sources, and have ac
tually listened (as all of us in fact have, to
some or other extent) to all sorts of music.
After the first five cuts the CD moves its
lens to 1988, where the band is captured
in festival concert and great form. By then
they've added a synth, and are doing not
only roaring old-time tunes (some twisted
cubist's face, to be sure
evidencing
appreciation both of musical theory
and, perhaps, of such deep questions as:
"Why, anyway, does a major scale domi
nate the fundamental character of a West
This evolution into a kind
ern melody?"
of modernity started early, with "Who
Throwed Lye," one of the at-home tracks
from '84. It blossoms and builds with cuts

like

a

an

like "Thank You Frank,"
val concert.

from the

festi

Meanwhile, they developed

vocal side (apart from the fiddle-tune
is just
"I Live Where It's Gray"
vocals)
a really neat piece; it's "old-time" because
a

Horse Flies are an old-time band. If
they weren't, the song would be just as in
teresting, and it might get more air in the
burgeoning world of, say, satellite radio.
across
By '88 the Flies are also reaching
the

genres

to

the zydeco

rhytlrms of "Iko."

Indeed, one of the very enjoyable tilings
about the Flies is their use and awareness
of genre rhythms. Not only zydeco, but
also reggae is represented.

And they re

turn, after sipping the various umbrellaadorned glasses on the musical table of
1988, to some smoky shine with a good
bead, ending with Tommy Jarrell's "Break
ing up Christmas," done their way.

This CD is a great listen, end to end. Ray
tells us in the notes and to my pleasure
that they've put out a new CD in '08 called
Until the Ocean. It has to be good. And it's

typical of Ray's generosity that he would
mention it it's not, after all, on the Field
Recorder label. That's Ray for you. Go
check out his whole site online. I'm sure
there's been new stuff added since I start

writing this piece this morning. After
all, it's already lunchtime. Like Mr. Jarrell
liked to sing: "Soon be time, soon be time,
soon be time, to sit and eat again."

ed

BILL HICKS
To Order:

www.fieldrecorder.com

�York City. The Chicken Chokers sound as
if they were in their twenties at the time

exuberance

show

typical of that
they play hell-for-leather
age group
breakdown tunes with technical aplomb.
they

as

I
particularly liked the fiddle-harmonica
combination in "Cacklin Hen and Rooster

Too," "Tempy," and "Texas Gals." Even bet
ter is a harmonica-banjo duet at the start
of "John

Dream." If I'd been at
I think
I'd have pre
bright harmonica future for Mark
Brown's

the tavern that night,

dicted a
Graham. "Cumberland Blues" (an instru
mental that is not the Grateful Dead song)
is a nice change from the breakdowns. It's

done
feel.

but
In

I

right speed and with excellent
have no idea where it came from,

at the
I

like

it a lot.

addition

to

exuberance, the Chokers

display some other youthful characteris
tics: sophomoricism in some of the words
to "Ruben" ("Ruben had a wreck/ Broke
his friggin' neck
"), and a tendency to
to
the
instruments rather
the
songs
pitch
a few in
stances of severely strained vocals. Tradi
tional singers usually retune their instru
ments rather than cause pain to either
their vocal chords or their listeners' ears.

than to the voices, resulting in

Some of the songs may be more familiar
under other titles: "Jordan" is Uncle Dave
Macon's "Jordan is a Hard Road to Travel,"
albeit with the peculiar imagery of both
putting on (rather than pulling off) one's
overcoat and rolling up one's sleeves.
is

"Tempy"

Bascom

mostly

Lunsford's

Wish I Was a Mole in the Ground."
"Months and Months" is Uncle Dave's "I
Don't Reckon It'll Happen Again."
I'll join the chorus of reviewers in lauding
the Field Recorders' Collective releases of
previously-unavailable non-studio old"I

hope they'll contin
must point out that
could be
information
the accompanying
the
The
back
of
jacket
greatly improved.
lists 5 musicians, while the cover photo
shows 6, none of whom are identified. Jim
Reidy is listed as playing only banjo uke,
time recordings, and
ue. At the same time,

but

a

5-string banjo

I

is

I

clearly being played

on several of the cuts. The one paragraph
of notes includes the statement, "Kevin

Wimmer abandoned violin for fiddle
",
yet Kevin is mentioned nowhere else, on
either the Chokers' or the FRC website.
I

can

understand that the expected sales

a booklet. But there
notes
available for re
sensible
should
cords by even urban bands. The CD jacket

do not justify printing
be

directs you to www.fieldrecorder.com, but
the notes given there for this recording are
limited to obscure reminiscences by band

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

members, including one (Stefan Senders)
who is not listed on the jacket, and exclud
ing one (Chad Crumm) who is. I'd want
some independent commentary similar
to that which accompanies a recording by
traditional artists, including something
about the sources of the music.
LYLE LOFGREN
To order:

www.fieldrecorder.com

�Home/Valse

A

Cathleen/L'Homme

Ca

jun Travaille 'Si Dur/Rieve de Soulard/
Johnnie Billy Goat/Valse a Pop/La Talle
des

Ronce/La Valse Minuit/Hee HawSpecial/ Creole Belles

Scott Playboy

Belles are a working band
women, plying their music and

Creole

The

have for their sources. Each tune is, I'd
estimate, eminently learnable, at least
for the intermediate fiddler or accordion
player, and particularly with the assis
tance of, say, the Amazing Slow Downer.
Possibly this is even true of the vocals,
at least if the student has some modi

their joy mostly around the Bay Area of
Northern California since 1995. For this,
their first recording, they have added

cum of French to ground him. (For me,
sadly, my abilities in French are limited
to "Une biere, Monsier," and, later, "Une
Thus, in my personal Ca
cafe por favor."

an

jun

of four

extremely

"special

guest, "Andrew

Southwest Louisiana native

Carriere,
whose father was the traditional Creole
musician Bebe Carriere. He fortuitously
a

California, and brings enormous
authenticity and energy to this record
ing. Not that such would be lacking oth
erwise; these four "belles" have listened
to their impeccable sources
well, and
have the chops to carry the concert, the
dance, or this recording project. None
theless, having Carriere on board adds a
lives

in

great deal, as is evidenced by the fact that
participates in one way or another on

he

10 of the 18

cuts, including great vocals

on all ten cuts and masterful

accordion

My guess is Carriere fre
in their live work as
well. It's just one of those things perhaps:
a guy in a band called the "Creole Belles"
just doesn't quite make sense.
Carriere is of course his own"source," a
transplanted son of Louisiana. The Belles
have learned well, and at close range.
Their sources include Canray Fontenot,

zydeco fiddling experience I have
my conversation to trading

restricted

rhythmic chops with the drummer.

It is

the better part of valor to refrain from at
tempting the Cajun "Aieeeeeee" without

some knowledge of la Fmngaise.)
If this group is doing a lot of gigs these
days I would expect them to be well into
their second pressing, and with good rea
son. You'd want to take a bit of the band
home after one of their concerts and/
This CD would definitely
or dances.
do the trick. At the same time, I would
say that their reverence to a small degree

dampens the pure insanity that inhab
Cajun/ zydeco bands. And

its the best

on six of them.

again, Carriere does much here to push

quently participates

the fun meter back into the red zone, as
do Delilah's impassioned vocal stylings,

the Ardoin family, Nathan Abshire, Will
[sic] Bolfa, Boozoo Chavis, and the in
comparable Dennis McGee. The singing

Lewis and Karpan has a country puri
would surely be as at home at the
Lacassine or Rayne, Frog Capital
of the Universe, as at a weekend night
of

ty that
gym in
at

Freight and Salvage.

The Cajun-style

first-rate throughout, includ
fiddling
brief
ing
forays into the arcane art of sec
onding since Heil also has duties on the
bass, and since the group clearly wanted
is

to do an

essentially "live" recording, the

"seconding" facet of Cajun music is nec
essarily limited to some extent. It isn't
fair to complain about physics, and if
there's a "Yankee stroke" hiding in Lew
is' right arm, as is hinted modestly in the
notes, I sure couldn't hear it.
One of the very nice things about this

CD is its clarity. No doubt a lot of this has
to do with the quality of the recording

good mics, good space, good engineer,
I'd guess
and of course good playing.
that

a

bit of the clarity

also reflects

the

genuine affection and respect the Belles

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

which

partner
a

happy

reminded my musical

and

life

Libby of the great Cleoma. It's
compromise for all concerned.

Let the bon tons roulette.
BILL HICKS

To Order:

www.creolebelles.com

�Courville and Ernest Fruge, you will love
cuts. "Chez Denouse," recorded
by Dennis McGee as "Two Step de Gran
Marais," is especially beautiful. "Brasse
le gombo vite" (a Doucet original) seems
to conjure up the Klezmer roots of Cajun
music. (Okay, so there aren't really any!)
The rest of the selections are solos, and
many of these are also quite wonderful.
these

On the truly funky "Two Step de Basile,"
Michael pulls out his whole bag of tricks

tribute to the early Cajun music heroes

in

Leo Soileau and Mayeuse Lafleur.
medley "Reels de Mamou" sounds

The

kind
of Bruce Molsky-ish, not surprising since
one of the tunes is a version of "Wagonner" from the playing of Wallace "Cheese"
Reed, who was a big fan of western swing

suspect, influenced by the music
Robertson and other early Texas
fiddlers. It's common practice for Cajun
musicians to rework a tune in a different
rhythm; it gives a new perspective to old
and,

I

of Eck

familiar tunes. Wade Fruge's signature
waltz, "Caillette," becomes "Wade's Twostep;" Austin Pitre's "Chere Joues Roses"
is played as a reel.
The only accordion
is
the
solo
"Amedee's
Accordion"
piece
de
on
which
Michael's
("Two Step
Elton"),
evokes
the
strong bassing perfectly
primi
tive and powerful sound of the old Amedee (Amede) Ardoin recordings. This is
the most rocking piece on the whole CD.
The production is spare. This CD was re
corded quickly without overdubbing, which
it a nice fresh
quality, definitely not
over-produced. The thick booklet includes
Andy Wallace's detailed bio, plus Michael's
notes to the songs, which are written in a
playful and conversational style.
Like all of Michael Doucet's music, this

gives

times self-indulgent but also thor
oughly enjoyable. Michael possesses both
CD is

at

impressive command of technique on
a
free-wheeling attitude;

an

the fiddle and

what keeps his music from being super
ficial is his unwavering passion for and
dedication to the old-time Cajun music
of earlier

generations.

the musicians who
of

He always credits

influenced him (many

whom he learned from first-hand) and,

like

Dewey Balfa before him, by doing

this he provides

map for

the seeker

with a road
the most obscure and

exploring
beautiful of Cajun music sounds. Funky
Buddhist persona notwithstanding, Mi
chael Doucet's connection with the deep
est roots of Cajun music is undeniable, as
is his

stature as the most important Cajun

fiddler of his generation.

SUZY ROTHFIELD THOMPSON
To order:

(888)365-5929, www.folkways.si.edu

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

convey a sense of continuity between
contemporary urban style and its roots.
Familiar names-- Lead Belly, Elizabeth
Cotten, Little Brother, Sonny Terry, Gary
Davis-- appear alongside less familiar
ones whose contributions are every bit
The Thrasher Wonders were
as worthy.

two-brother-one-sister trio who capably
emulated the Golden Gate Quartet on a
1945 performance of "Moses Smote the
a

The brothers later joined R&amp;B gi
Clyde McPhatter in the 1950s as mem

Water."
ant

bers of the Drifters.

Baptist pastor Brother
Willie Gresham sings and responds to his
Athens, Georgia, congregation in a spell

binding performance reminiscent of the
popular Rev. J. M. Gates records made in
nearby Atlanta more than 75 years ago.
Alvin Dockett and Blessed is a Washing
ton, DC, large mixed choir inspired by
the James Cleveland style that evolved in
and

the 1970s,

whose polished contem

porary style retains an abundance of pas

sionate singing and compelling rhythms.
There's a neat relic from the mid-1940s
that couples the voice of Rosetta Tharpe
influenced Ernestine Washington with a
New Orleans revival band led by cornetist
Bunk Johnson, whose music was featured
nightly at New York's fashionable Stuyve
Civil rights legend Fannie
a powerful singing voice;
leads other Greenwood, Mis

sant Casino.

Lou Hamer had
here

she

mixing old-time scripture
citations with contemporary (1963) Free
dom Movement sentiments. I'll resist the
temptation to cite other tracks, even when

sissippians,

they're as good as or better than those I've

singled out.
Much as I like it, I recommend the CD
primarily to those whose tastes encom

pass untrained voices in (usually) unso
phisticated settings. Even if you don't
think the description fit, give Classic Af
It
rican American Gospel a listen anyway.
features some good out-of-the-way mu
sic and you may well enjoy more of it
than you think.

Recording information in both CD book
lets is not consistent. Sometimes we're
told when and where a record was made,
but elsewhere we're only shown a record
number and date of a previous Folkways
release. Instead of artist photos there are
vintage generic snapshots of dancers,
pianos, night club and storefront scenes
in Classic Piano Blues, and assorted wor

singers, and preachers in the
Photos of actual performers
gospel
would have been nice to include too.
shipers,

set.

DICK SPOTTSWOOD
To order:

1-888-365-5929,

www.folkways.si.edu

�popular music in the world." He in
cludes at least two towering classics,
which is a gutty move in itself. "Dust

My Broom" is surely one of the top five
blues pieces ever, and this version from
Robert Johnson himself remains a killer
no matter how many times you hear
it.
Then there's "Another Man Done
Gone," a song recorded by John Lomax
in 1938 from the

singing

of Vera

Hall-

Scott tells us that this original Vera Hall

recording (and she learned it from her
mother, which takes it waaaaay back)
was played by the Library of Congress

commemorate the eightieth anniver
sary of the Emancipation Proclamation.
It still resonates of course. Other "cov
ers" (to use a word that doesn't fit so
well in this context) include Son House's
to

"Grinnin' in Your Face," and the J. S.
Lenoir/ Willie Dixon "Down in Missis
sippi." Giving a nod to more modern
song-crafting, Scott also includes Tom
Waits' "Little Trip to Heaven," which,
with its swingy changes and very tasty

organ playing by T-Bone, reminds us of
where the old blues ended up.
Of the original cuts, I think my favorite
is probably "I Should Get Over This." He
mixes a lyric which expresses acceptance
of loss with a neat dancey Gurian gui
tar sound, surely one of the underlying
reasons that his chosen musical sources
are those of much of the world: you can,
amazingly, dance to Bob Marley's "War
How is
(We Don't Need No Trouble)."
that even possible?
Here's the edge of
the knife:

From this window,

I

see it's just

a

All the kids out playing stick ball
And no one keeping score
Who could ask for more
the man said, I'm

As

game
in the rain

bleeding, and

I

never felt the cut.
On another of his original compositions,
Scott plays a gourd banjo in a tuning he
learned from Sherman Hammons: "a
tuning designed to make playing in the
West African minor pentatonic scale
the blues scale
easy." Thusly we brush
aside these genre-fied conceits the way
the Mexican bandits brush aside Bogey's
complaints: "Badges? We don't need no
stinking badges."
A final note on the context of these
songs

done

Frequently

Putting out

a record
time, like it or not.
in the land of "old-time" we

is in order.

is an act

in real

find artists who suggest they are actually
making music in the 1920s or '30s, or at
least sorta act that way. Sadly, this is of

course impossible.

The Triceratops is

ex

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

tinct now; all we have is the white tail.
Scott dedicates two of his own songs to,

respectively, the survivors and victims of
Katrina, and the survivors and victims
of 9/11. His cover art also refers to Ka
trina, featuring a remarkable photo by
John Rosenthal of a ruined New Orleans
church. As with everything else on the
CD, bringing these tragedies into focus is
done with taste and love. If your focus is
a tad wider than the
genre to which this
is
dedicated, you should enjoy
magazine
every cut on Thunder's Mouth.
BILL HICKS
To Order:

www.cattailmusic.com

�songs that Lydia sang, as well as the in
struments they played. Life was hard for
the family. Their relative poverty, Lydia's
father's struggles with alcohol and the
family's struggles with prejudice against
Mexicans and Tejanos, all took their toll.
Lydia never went to school. The fam
ily moved back and forth from Texas to
Mexico, struggling to earn a living as mi
grant laborers, and eventually decided
to try making a living playing music. In
1929 they went to San Antonio to audi
tion for Okeh Records
they were paid
$140 to record 20 songs.
One thing led to another and

eventu

ally,
Lydia's popularity grew, she and
the family were able to earn a small liv
ing with their music playing on the radio,
and in restaurants, tent shows, and other
venues. By the 1930s she was famous and
as

beloved

by her
"La

nickname

people, who gave her the
Alondra de la Frontera"

Meadowlark

("The

of the Border").

She

traveled and toured widely up until she
suffered a stroke in 1988. She was invited
to sing at Jimmy Carter's inauguration in
1977, and was the recipient

of both

the

National

Heritage Fellowship in 1982
and the National Medal of Arts in 1999.
This CD presents the music of a singer
singer of great passion and deep feeling

a

and love for her culture and her musical
heritage. Most of the songs on the CD

Lydia accompanied only by her
12-string guitar, although there are sev
eral with her sister and brother, and with
are

of

various conjuntos or bands featuring ac
cordion greats like Narciso Martinez.
The

CD

contains

a

36-page booklet

with information on the songs, a biogra
phy, some nice photographs, and song
words with translations. Altogether a
nice package.
I was fortunate
to have met Lydia Mendoza when we were both part of tradi
tional music tour on the West Coast. She
was

a

consummate

remember

professional and
her

about how

I

she

asking
managed to convey such emotion night
after night with certain songs that she
sang over and over. I'll always remember
what she said about how she placed her
self mentally in the song, becoming one
with the story and the emotion. Lydia
Mendoza was a singer's singer, and a

singer beloved by her audiences, espe
cially her Mexican American audiences.
This CD is a fine reflection of her art. I
highly recommend
especially to singers.

it

to

everyone, and
ALICE GERRARD

To

Order: www.arhoolie.com, (888) 274-6654

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Sing It Pretty: A Memoir
Bess Lomax Hawes

Lampell,
Hawes).

and

her

husband-to-be
the War

During

Butch

worked

she

government's Office of War In
formation, incorporating folk song into
propaganda broadcasts, activities which
for the

earned for her the 1946 attention of the
FBI's earliest efforts to smoke out "unAmerican" plots such as labor unions

whether everybody else knows them

or

not, and the appropriate

of

introduction

those items of intellectual power into the
public discourse has been the unswerv

ing thrust of my work, whatever form it
took, all my life." We will look long in
the halls of Washington before we find

another like her.

and

working-class song lore. In the 1950s
she relocated to California and began her

University of Illinois Press

The name Lomax will of course catch the

attention of OTH readers, quite deserv
edly in this case. Bess Lomax was born
in 1921, the daughter of John A. Lomax
and younger sister of Alan Lomax. Her
"memoir" (it is not intended to be an au
tobiography) recounts her 60-year pro

fessional career

as

performer, folklorist,

author, and administrator
vocate for the folk arts at the highest
teacher,

ernmental

levels.

/ad

gov

home-schooled

The

Bess began in the 1930's as a teenage as
sistant to her father and brother during

publication

of the classic book Our

Sing

ing Country, the first folk song collection
to be based on field recordings
rather

than written texts.

Having accompanied

her father into Texas prisons to transcribe

inmate performances, she followed him
to Washington,
DC, to work in the Li
brary of Congress archives:
And when

I

lis
spent hours ev

wasn't reading

I

was

life's work combining her passion for
folk song with her calling to educate, be
ginning as a community guitar teacher
and eventually attaining the tenure wars
of academe at UC after returning to col
lege to complete her MA. (Her surpris
ing thesis was on a song every American
knows and can sing but knows nothing
about: "Happy Birthday to You.")
By the 1960s and the "Folk Revival," her
love for what she calls "the difficulties
and splendors of trying to explain things
across cultural lines," her many articles
about and research into children's songs,

growing network of university
colleagues brought her to the attention
and her

Berkeley Folk Festival's planners.
festival work followed, and by
1976 Ralph Rinzler had lured her back
to Washington as an assistant director
of the bicentennial Festival of American
Folklife. She then moved to the National
Endowment for the Arts, serving under
of the

Other

presidents Ford, Carter, Reagan, and the
first Bush,

retiring

in

1992 and

receiving the National

Medal

in 1993
of

Arts

from President
den ceremony.

tening, for Alan and I
ery day playing back every single song
loudly, cataloging each one, transcrib
ing the words, and locating any avail
able field notes. Eventually the patience
of our scholarly research neighbors
was exhausted, and we were exiled to a

Clinton in a Rose Gar
Her account of life as a
bureaucrat
is clear-eyed: the
Washington
woman endured the blind alleys, cross
currents, and conflicts inevitable in any
huge bureaucracy, and took in stride the
eternal focus on funding. (Imagine try

small attic

ing to explain the concept of "folk arts"

at the

very top of the Library

of Congress with only the pigeons for
company. As we listened to hour after

hour of field recordings day after day,
the dust and the heat blew in as they
had perhaps on the singers
and the painted friezes and

themselves,

the gilded
decorative panels filtered the roaring ax-

chopping songs and the crashing shape
note hymns down through the ornate
and orderly library stacks below us.

In

evenings, string quartets woidd play
Schubert and Chopin in the groundthe

floor concert

hall,

but in

the attic

the

unsilenced and unquenchable voices of
southern working people sang on.
By the 1940s Bess was a performing

member of the Almanac Singers (Woody
Guthrie, Pete Seeger, Lee Hayes, Millard

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a
congressman while simultaneously
convincing him to fund your project with
the tax dollars of his constituents. Nasty

to

job, and we were fortunate
Bess Hawes to do it.)

Astonishingly modest
her accomplishments,

of

to

for

have had

a

Bess

person

Hawes

claims that "I am never, inside myself,
quite sure what I am being honored for. I
have singly produced no books, no films,
no songs; all my creative work has been
collaborative," a sentiment she supports
with warm portraits of colleagues such
as Rinzler and Bessie Jones.
Her book
concludes, "I have always had the un
shakable belief that every single human
being has some knowledge of impor
tant

elements

of

beauty and substance,

JON PANKAKE
To Order:

www.press.uillinois.edu,

(217) 333-0950

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

nations of the NBD, respectively. Tyler's
chapter, "The Rise of Rural Rhythm," is
the longest in the book and one of the
also the one that is likely to be
of most interest to old-time music fans.
Tyler discusses the origins of the NBD,
and puts it in context with the few pre
decessors it had in the realm of live oldtime music on radio. The first broadcast

best.

It is

of the
19,

National Barn Dance was on April

1924,

in

the second

week of opera

tions for station WLS. Beginning in 1933
listeners across the country could tune
in the Barn Dance on the NBC radio net

work. Like any good cultural phenom
enon, the NBD has its own origin myth;
i.e. that it began by accident when, faced
with a lack of programming for Saturday
night, station janitor Tommy Dandurand
magically produced a fiddle and went
on the air with a few tunes. Tyler pres
ents evidence, in the form of an advance
newspaper notice about the forthcoming
broadcast of the "first weekly national
barn dance over the radio," that the
show's inception was deliberate.
Tyler notes the variety of musical styles
represented on the NBD, and comments
that the mix of hillbilly and pop "never
to be

for either WLS

problem
appeared
or for much of its audience,"
at the

a

time the NBD began

"a

and that
rubric for

defining the difference between country
music and pop did not exist." Tyler, and
many of the other contributors, make a
distinction between "rural music" and
what we now call "country music" as a
genre: "In short, some rural musicians,
from all parts of the United States, have
been known to play music that is, accord
ing to current definitions, unquestion
ably not country music."
Tyler

provides

a

good discussion

of the

different types of musical acts that ap
peared on the NBD, and groups them as
"Fiddlers," "Folksong Artists," "Modern
Folksong Artists," "Western Song Art
He be
ists," and "Novelty Musicians."
moans the fact that although early NBD
artists recorded extensively, their work
has been poorly represented on reis
sues, and no recordings of broadcasts
He sums up
are known prior to 1939.
the situation somewhat wistfully: "The
National Barn Dance is not well remem
bered primarily because of the incom
pleteness of the sonic record"
Wayne W. Daniel picks up the histori
cal narrative in this essay, "Music of the
Postwar Era." Whereas the early years
of the NBD largely coincided with the
era

of

the

Great

Depression,

the

pro

when all
a period
American culture underwent rapid
As Daniel notes, the show
changes.
gram came of age in
of

"had

to

adapt

the fears,

to

a

demands,

society beset by

and sacrifices

of

a

world war, followed by a postwar boom
that brought a higher standard of living,
new consumer mass media technology,
altered life styles, changes in musical
tastes, and innovative entertainment
concepts." These were changing times
for country music
indeed, -for all genres
of American music. The number of radio
stations increased, and many continued
to program live music, but it was also the
era in which other media emerged that
would eventually bring about the virtual
death of live radio. Recordings grew in
importance, the world of network radio
was in decline, and television was in its
NBC dropped the show
ascendancy.
from its radio network in 1946.

A

tele

vised version of the NBD, the ABC Barn
Dance, was carried on the ABC television
network for thirty-nine weeks in 1949,
but it was not successful.
The program aired on WLS for the last
time on April 30, 1960, shortly after the

station was sold

to

American Broadcast

It was
ing-Paramount Theatres, Inc.
reincarnated on another Chicago radio
station as the WGN Barn Dance, where
He cites no one
it survived until 1969.
cause for the show's ultimate demise,
but notes that changing musical tastes

the rise of

rock-and-roll

in

particular

as one factor.

Chicago historian Lisa Krissoff Boehm's chapter, "Chicago as Forgotten
Country Music Mecca," places the Na
tional Barn Dance within the context of
She
the city from which it emanated.
sounds the familiar theme of neglect of
the NBD on the part of historians both
of country music and of the city of Chi
cago. She argues that the music of the

NBD represented

"a

Midwestern sound,

true to the city and the region" (p. 103),
but that the connection between the city
and the surrounding rural areas of the

region was rapidly disappearing.
The show's rustic image was also at
odds with other aspects of Chicago's
The city's large foreign-born
culture.
population, its rapidly growing African-

American community, and the popular
view of Chicago as the home of corrupt
politicians and gangsters, made

it an

un

likely setting for a barn dance, even a vir
tual one. Boehm makes the astute obser
vation that while blues had a strong base
in the city's culture, the rural, white mu-

�sical forms did not. A vibrant new style
blues grew and developed in Chicago,

of

while the white rural styles of the NBD
increasingly came to represent the music
of an older and aging generation.
Nos
talgia has its limits when it comes to sus
taining musical styles.
In this context it is perhaps also worth
noting the apparently total absence of
any Irish element from the NBD's mu
sical mix. This is the same Chicago in
which Capt. Francis O'Neill did his
landmark work collecting and promot
ing the music of the city's Irish immi
grants less than a quarter century before
the National Barn Dance went on the air.
That the city's Irish musical community
was not tapped for the NBD may well
be due in large part to the insular na
ture of this community. In the present

much is made of supposed connec
tions between Irish and country music,
yet it seems that no such connection was
made during the era in which the Na
tional Barn Dance flourished.
The remaining essays in the book in
era

clude:

"Early

Audiences"

Broadcasting and Radio

Susan Smulyan; "Race
and Rural Identity," by Michael Bertrand;
"Patriarchy and the Great Depression"
by

by Kristine McCusker;

"Cowboys

in

Chi

cago" by Don Cusic; and "The National
Folk Festival" by Michael Ann Williams.
Bertrand's and Williams' contributions
are the best.
Bertrand touches on key
issues such as the racial makeup of the

radio audience for the NBD, the role of

blackface minstrelsy in its programming,
and the positioning of country /rural
music in opposition to urban jazz. Wil
liams does an excellent job of contrasting
what she terms "two forms of theatrical
presentation of traditional culture," the
National Barn Dance and the National
Folk Festival. One was a purely commer
cial form of

entertainment, disseminated

via mass media, and the other was (and
still is) a more self-conscious cultural

program. She treats this theme at greater
length in her book, Staging Tradition: John
Lair

and Sarah

Gertrude

Knott, also

pub

lished by the University of Illinois Press.
The Hayloft Gang is an important book
about a chapter in the history of (mostly)
country music that has heretofore not re
ceived the attention that it deserves. While
not all chapters will be of prime interest to
all OTH readers, there is much here that

warrants attention from serious fans of the
history of old-time and country music.
PAUL
To Order:

www.press.uillinois.edu,

F.

WELLS

(217) 333-0950

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

or

three times in different chapters. Some

judicious editing could have made for
stronger, more condensed whole.

a

The photos are amazing: of Iry, his im
mediate and extended family including
ancestors and descendants, his many
musical colleagues, and the dog that is
heard on "Duralde Waltz." And some
truly strange ones: the back brace worn
in the late 1940s (Iry's back was broken in
a car accident when the friend who was
driving fell asleep at the wheel), Iry's
First

Communion card, and (my favor
worn ladderback

ite!) two

chairs upon

backsides
of Iry Lejeune, Amede Ardoin, Amede
Breaux, Angelais Lejeune, and others.
wondered if these were magic chairs;
which supposedly

rested

the

I

maybe
to

play

if

I

sat on one of them, I'd be able

as

beautifully

these

as

seminal

masters of the Cajun accordion?
The author, Ron Yule, is

a

bluegrass fid

dler who came to Cajun music relatively
self-published several other
books about bluegrass fiddling. He is not
an academic, and does not maintain the
conventional scholar's distance from his
subject. His writing style is in-depth and
extremely respectful, and often becomes
late. He has

quite emotional, mirroring the emotion
that was at the root of Iry Lejeune's mu

Among the many short chapters in
write-up on Iry's
accordion style is especially well written.

sic.

this book, Chris Miller's

The lyrics chapter is terrific; all 25 of Iry's
recorded songs are included, both in the
original French and with English transla
tions, and each page includes a photo of
the label of the record, well worth exam
ining closely. For example, I never knew
that "Love Bridge Waltz" was recorded
for the Opera

the hillbillies!"

record company: "hits of
The French lyrics have

been well transcribed with contractions
like 'tite and 'garde

literation

is

included.

provided.

No trans

For that, one

must

go to Ann Savoy's Cajun Music: A History

of a People and Raymond Francois' Oh Ye
Yaille. Comparing the transcriptions from

these

books

reveals

some

completely understandable

anomalies,
considering

1940s and '50s, when these
were
recorded, Cajun French was
songs
not really a written language at all. Ron
Yule's book was made at the instigation
of and with the encouragement of Ervin
Lejeune, one of Iry's sons and a great ac
cordion player in his own right (as was
his brother Eddie who died in early 2001,
way too young, only in his forties). Even
so, I found the "Who Is Iry Lejeune, Jr.?"
section to contain a little too much infor
mation. Wailin' the Blues Cajun Style isn't
meant to be a general introduction to Ca
jun music, but readers who don't expect
a narrative and who enjoy minutiae will
have a wonderful time with it, and for
those who are interested in learning Iry
Lejeune's song it should prove very help
ful. A must-have for those interested in
the postwar Cajun music scene, in Cajun
accordion music, and especially the mu
that in the

sic and life of Iry Lejeune.
SUZY ROTHFIELD THOMPSON
To

order: www.ronyule.com

�whether the square dances are keepers,
in which you don't change partners, or
mixers, in which you do. There are also
several big circle dances (my concept of a
"mixer") and Sicilian circles. Other than
line dances, that about covers the types
of group dances that I know of.
The book is enjoyable on many levels.
There's a lot of humor, including the titles
given to certain dances: "Metaphors Be with
You," "Dorna Loon," and "What the Hey!"
The illustrations, garnered mostly from
traditional books, are spare and appropriate,

including

a

depiction of

a

Hog-Eyed Man.

Most dances have footnotes telling how
they came to be written; they are amusing
and give the reader a feel for the person that
Brian is
an outgoing, good-humored, and

enthusiastic Alaska denizen who surrounds
himself with music and dance.
The dance community is fortunate that
Brian has chosen to share his dances and
stir them into the traditional pot.
I rec
ommend this book for contra and square
dance callers, dance enthusiasts, and for
just plain old fun.
TONI WILLIAMS
To order:

bdemar@alaska.net

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

�Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

a
Johnson. One
of
booth
Johnson,
snapshot
grainy photo
cigarette dangling from lips adorns the
cover of Crossroads, the rights to the im
age controlled in the name of Johnson's
heirs by LaVere, who also contributes the
book's foreword. Both the lowlights and
highlights of the McCormick /LaVere
rivalry seem fairly covered with credit
given where credit is due.
Crossroads is a handy guide to the Rob
ert Johnson saga. Graves touches on the
the possible film
salient talking points
bluesman
which
really sold his
snippet,
soul at the crossroads, the Hollywood
film, the US postage stamp, the correct
recording playback speed, the lost songs,

photographs

of Robert

moments struck
as
an account of
such
out
of
me as
sync,
1950s multi-track recording techniques
and brief mentions of Ozzie Osborne and
and the lost son! A few

Charlie Daniels. All-in-all, though, Cross
roads is a brisk, insightful read, a reliable
overview, especially for the blues neo
phyte or interested fan seeking to learn
more about the quintessentially Ameri
can/African American roots music phe

nomenon known

as

Robert Johnson.
JERRY

To order:

www.ipgbook.com

ZOLTEN

�strong role in the Sacred Harp tradition,
as well, and Elene Stovall of Birmingham,
Joyce Smith Walton of Pisgah, Alabama,
and Charlene Wallace and Carlene Grif
fin of Mt. Zion, Georgia, speak of their
involvement in the tradition, often travel
ing hundreds of miles in the course of a

weekend

for

singing.

The film

footage of the singing is very
powerful. Different members of the sing
ing groups take turns leading the groups
from "in the square," as the leadership
station is designated. No one appears to
be excluded from this song-leading role-adults, teenagers, and children of both

sexes are shown leading the singing.
Leaders mark time and direct the sing
ing in accordance with their own way of

keeping time and their confidence work
ing in that role. Many of the singers also
keep time while singing. Each song is
preceded by "pitchers" giving the sing
ers in each vocal part their starting notes.
It is pointed out that the "pitchers" do

not have perfect

pitch, but good rela

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

tive pitch, so that while a song may not
end up being sung in the key in which
it was written, the accommodation that
the pitchers have made in

selecting the

starting notes for each part may have
the effect of making the song easier to
sing than it would have been in its origi
nal key. Richard Delong of Whitesburg,
Georgia, one of the pitchers,

is

a

distinc

tive presence, keeping time with
and is unabashedly moved by the

a

fan,

sing

ing on several occasions. The singing is
quite loud and is meant to be done full-

without dynamics or special
consideration given to blending. One of
the singers points out that the singing is
"experiential" rather than performanceoriented, and in this respect I think it is
like a lot of old-time music. Many of the
singers speak to the incredible sensa
tion of being in the middle of the sound,
and I don't think it's an exaggeration to
describe the feeling that they get from
that as addictive. It is thrilling to see a
roomful of people just singing their guts

throated,

I think
the power of what they
doing, apart from the sheer volume,
comes from their belief. It's an exagger
ation to say there is no vocal blending,
too. It's just that the blend, because of

out, and
are

common practices in the
counterpoint, like avoidance
writing
of parallel fifths and octaves, has a more
open quality than is commonly found in
choral singing, and thus ends up with
and more ringing sound, al
a brighter
for

disregard

of

most Asian-sounding

at

times,

or

like

a

bee hive.

won't get into the history of Sacred
singing here. You can find the
movie and watch it to get more infor
mation and background on the subject.
came away from the film though, cer
I

Harp

I

tain that the Sacred Harp singing is a
vital and valuable part of the singers'
lives, and that if you or I ever want to
participate in the singing, we will be

warmly welcomed.

JOHN M. MILLER
To Order:

www.thirdday.com/awake

�S

MUSIC DISPATCH

*1

Section with Illegible Text

Section with Illegible Text

fimesra8s *siaes

BAN

O

Best of Bluegrass
Book/CD

00690636 $24.95

B

bTo^-TfTb

00695358

Parlor Guitar

Book/CD

I

Book or Book/CD

Section with Illegible Text

Section with Illegible Text

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

00699796

$7.95

"■

$14.95

$14.95

Ragtime Guitar
Book/CD

00699611

rols'fiaBHme
MANDOLIN

GUITAR,

00699529

Easy Songs for

$6.95
$14.95

L E

5-String Banjo
Book/CD

Mandolin

00695865
00695866

L&gt;

Bluegrass Guitar
Classics

5

i

Comtry

Bluegrass and Folk

Hal

Guitar Book/CD

Leonard Mandolin
Method Book/CD

00695355

00695102

Earl

$19.95

MOKE?

$12.95

Scruggs and the

5-String Banjo
Book or Book/CD

00695764
00695765

MUSIC

$19.95
$34.95

$14.95

The Ultimate Banjo

Songbook
Book/2 CDs

00699565

$24.95

DISPATCH

j
j

'

�AMERICA

KEEPING

OLD &amp; WEIRD

Smithsonian Folkways Recordings
FOLKWAYS.SI.EDU

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

Save 20% through

888-F0LKWAYS
2/28/09

on

CD

or

800 410-9815

Orders with Code HERALDFW08

�5-STRING
PRODUCTIONS
Section with Illegible Text

Cataloochee

Bowling Green

Carol Elizabeth Jones

Alice Gerrard

&amp;

Mike Seeger

Evening at WPAQ, 1984

An

Benton Flippen

&amp;

the

Smokey Valley Boys

and leaving life

dozen songs about living, loving,
in the Appalachian
mountains.

Extraordinary performances by
two iconic musicians. Includes
three tracks with the legendary

5SP08001

Tommy Jarrell.

Recapture a memorable night of
music with one of the South's most
powerful old time string bands.

5SP08003

5SP08004

A

More Great Releases:
From Mali to America SSPO6004

Cheick Hamala Diabate and Bob Carlin
Birdie sspo/oo/

Wayne &amp; Margaret Martin
and Craig Johnson
The Road To Agate Hill SSP06003

Alice Gerrard, Gail Gillespie,
&amp;

Sharon Sandomirsky

It's About Time SSP07003
John Hoffmann &amp; Mac Benford

Ernest

V.

Big Ears ssposm

Stoneman:

The Unsung Father of
Country Music
Ernest V. Stoneman
Ernest V. Stoneman, pioneering
composer and performer, defined
the formula of "three chords and
the truth" and became the first
rural singer/songwriter of the

Mark Simos &amp; Friends

Falls of Richmond

Paul Brown

intimate solo recording that
reveals Matt to be a compelling
multi-instrumentalist and singer

The Rest

5SP08002

&amp;

An

Yet to Come 5SP04004

Lone Prairie ssposoo
Matt Brown with Paul Brown

Beverly Smith
1

SSP07002

Matt Brown
On the Edge ssposoo4

The Cliffhangers

5SPH00I

Clifftop Notes Vol. 1 ssposoos
Mark Simos &amp; Friends

www.5-string.com

Copyright © 2021 ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved.

is

Double Decker String band

Old-Time Fiddle Lesson Vol.

20th century to record.

334 West Union Street, West Chester,

Red Clay Country 5SP06002

Matt Brown

Known for their Reputation

PA

19382

info@5-string.com

The Hoover Uprights

SSP05002

�</text>
                </elementText>
              </elementTextContainer>
            </element>
          </elementContainer>
        </elementSet>
      </elementSetContainer>
    </file>
  </fileContainer>
  <collection collectionId="65">
    <elementSetContainer>
      <elementSet elementSetId="1">
        <name>Dublin Core</name>
        <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
        <elementContainer>
          <element elementId="50">
            <name>Title</name>
            <description>A name given to the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12031">
                <text>Old-Time Herald</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
          <element elementId="41">
            <name>Description</name>
            <description>An account of the resource</description>
            <elementTextContainer>
              <elementText elementTextId="12032">
                <text>Presented in partnership with the nonprofit &lt;a href="https://www.wholesouth.org/" target="_blank" rel="noopener"&gt;Whole South Heritage Works&lt;/a&gt;, &lt;em&gt;The&amp;nbsp;Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;collection includes digital copies of every issue of&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald Magazine&lt;/em&gt;, 1987-2023.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Founded in 1987 by legendary musician Alice Gerrard,&amp;nbsp;&lt;em&gt;&lt;em&gt;The Old-Time Herald&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/em&gt;served for more than 35 years as a leading voice of the old-time music community worldwide&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;. Its&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span class="wixui-rich-text__text" style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt; 130-plus issues, all accessible here, contain a vast wealth of information that can’t be found elsewhere. &lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Issues include:&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent" data-testid="inline-content" class=""&gt;&#13;
&lt;div data-mesh-id="comp-mf5t0qstinlineContent-gridContainer" data-testid="mesh-container-content"&gt;&#13;
&lt;div id="comp-mf5sjgaq" class="ku3DBC zQ9jDz qvSjx3 Vq6kJx comp-mf5sjgaq wixui-rich-text" data-testid="richTextElement"&gt;&#13;
&lt;ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;deeply researched explorations into the history of old-time string-band music and related traditions&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;in-depth articles from respected historians, musicians, and writers&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;historic photographs, many of them previously unpublished&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;detailed discussion of the contemporary culture of old-time music and dance&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;field reports from regional scenes&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;interviews and oral histories&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;extensive album reviews, spotlighting both new releases and reissues of historic material&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;li&gt;remembrances of departed musicians, including local community players typically overlooked in the national press&lt;/li&gt;&#13;
&lt;/ul&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-family: -apple-system, BlinkMacSystemFont, 'Segoe UI', Roboto, Oxygen, Ubuntu, Cantarell, 'Open Sans', 'Helvetica Neue', sans-serif;"&gt;Also included are robust community discussions and long-running, often fiery controversies waged in readers' letters to the editor.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;Originally based in Galax, Virginia, the magazine was published for most of its run in Durham, North Carolina. Founding editor Alice Gerrard was succeeded in that position by Gail Gillespie, then by Sarah Bryan.&amp;nbsp;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;The Southern Music Research Center and Whole South Heritage Works are grateful to our community of donors, whose contributions made possible this significant digitization and archiving project — and to Alice Gerrard, who paved the way and made this whole thing possible.&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;em&gt;A logistical note: Click on any issue's title or thumbnail image to access that entire magazine. On some screens, the PDF reader may initially display only a portion of the page. To view the issue more easily, click the "Presentation Mode" icon in the toolbar above the issue — four small arrows pointing outward in all directions. Then you can use your finger or your computer's arrow keys to scroll through the pages. Happy exploring.&amp;nbsp;&lt;/em&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;&#13;
&lt;/div&gt;</text>
              </elementText>
            </elementTextContainer>
          </element>
        </elementContainer>
      </elementSet>
    </elementSetContainer>
  </collection>
  <elementSetContainer>
    <elementSet elementSetId="1">
      <name>Dublin Core</name>
      <description>The Dublin Core metadata element set is common to all Omeka records, including items, files, and collections. For more information see, http://dublincore.org/documents/dces/.</description>
      <elementContainer>
        <element elementId="50">
          <name>Title</name>
          <description>A name given to the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12102">
              <text>&lt;em&gt;Old-Time Herald&lt;/em&gt;, Volume 11, Number 7 (October-November 2008)</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="49">
          <name>Subject</name>
          <description>The topic of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12103">
              <text>Old-time music</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="41">
          <name>Description</name>
          <description>An account of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12104">
              <text>&lt;p&gt;&lt;i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Old-Time Herald&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/i&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;, Volume 11, Number 7 (October-November 2008)&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;Contents include:&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Goat Glands and String Bands: Dr. John Brinkley,” by David Holt&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Old, New, and Real: The Case of Mississippi’s Senator George Cecil McLeod,” by Chris Goertzen&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;&#13;
&lt;p&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Issues in Old-Time Music – Old-Time Herald Reviews,” by Alice Gerrard&amp;nbsp;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;br /&gt;&lt;/span&gt;&lt;span style="font-weight: 400;"&gt;“Final Notes” include obituaries for George Chudacoff; Boyd Wilbert “Hick” Edmonds; Clifford Hardesty; and Artie Traum.&lt;/span&gt;&lt;/p&gt;</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
        <element elementId="40">
          <name>Date</name>
          <description>A point or period of time associated with an event in the lifecycle of the resource</description>
          <elementTextContainer>
            <elementText elementTextId="12105">
              <text>2008</text>
            </elementText>
          </elementTextContainer>
        </element>
      </elementContainer>
    </elementSet>
  </elementSetContainer>
  <tagContainer>
    <tag tagId="1004">
      <name>2000s</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="1005">
      <name>2008</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5459">
      <name>Artie Traum</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5457">
      <name>Boyd Wilbert “Hick” Edmonds</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5455">
      <name>Chris Goertzen</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5458">
      <name>Clifford Hardesty</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5453">
      <name>David Holt</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5452">
      <name>Dr. John Brinkley</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5454">
      <name>George Cecil McLeod</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5456">
      <name>George Chudacoff</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="5413">
      <name>Old-Time Herald</name>
    </tag>
    <tag tagId="1417">
      <name>Old-Time Music</name>
    </tag>
  </tagContainer>
</item>
